Second Date Update: The Best Listener Ever

Brooke and Jeffrey, iHeartPodcasts — March 20, 2026

Episode Overview

In this episode of “Second Date Update,” the team welcomes back a familiar caller, James, who’d previously struck out on the show after being told he was a poor listener. Determined to improve, James returns, convinced he’s grown his skills and eager for another chance—this time, with a new woman named Audrey. The show explores James’ efforts at self-improvement, recaps the date in question, and brings Audrey on the line to uncover the real reason for her post-date radio silence.
Theme: Can listening classes and mock dates really change a dater’s fate—or are some social missteps hard to overcome, no matter how well-intentioned?

Main Discussion & Insights

James’ Redemption Story (03:10–06:39)

• James Reintroduces Himself:
  • Host Brooke introduces James, noting his previous appearance and infamous faux pas: interrupting a woman’s story about her dog’s death.
  • Brooke: “Last time he was on, James got turned down by a woman who said he’s not a great listener…” [04:37]
• Self-Improvement Journey:
  • James claims to have addressed all his personal flaws, mainly by taking free listening classes on YouTube ([05:30–05:43]).
  • He even took his sister-in-law (his brother’s wife) on mock dates for practice:
    • “She gave me, like, a solid B minus, which is actually pretty good because I don’t think she even likes me.” — James [06:19]
  • The hosts (Brooke, Jeffrey, Alexis) express cautious optimism at James’ efforts.

The Date with Audrey: Recap & Mishaps (06:40–10:15)

• James’ Approach:
  • James describes meeting Audrey, a high school teacher, after connecting via dating apps. He insists he was attentive, actively asked questions, and even took notes after the date.
• Ice Breaker Gone Awry:
  • As a joke, James sits with a different woman at a nearby table and loudly acts as if she’s his date, meant in jest. Audrey laughs it off, but hosts debate the move (“At least one of you laughed, even if it’s you.” — Brooke [08:20]).
  • Another attempted joke: James quips about “dining and dashing,” which unsettles Audrey before he reassures her and pays the bill.
• Host Analysis:
  • Hosts speculate whether mismatched senses of humor or James’ delivery may have set the wrong tone, but agree his efforts are genuine if possibly over-the-top.

The Mystery of No Callback (10:16–12:21)

• Lingering Questions:
  • Despite improved listening, James has not heard from Audrey since their date.
  • “At no point did you interrupt her when she was telling a story about her grandparents dying, right? … No, this time I listened to all her death stories all the way through.” — Brooke & James [09:55–10:01]
• Possible Explanations:
  • The hosts wonder if James’ enthusiasm or “self-improvement mindset” overshadowed natural chemistry.

Audrey Joins & Reveals Her Perspective (12:22–16:25)

• Audrey’s First Reaction:
  • Audrey finds James funny and cute but describes him as “a little too fast for me.” [13:16]
• The Property Proposal:
  • She retells her account of complaining about homeowner problems. James immediately proposes they “buy a property together,” highlighting his handiness and offering a joint real estate venture… on the first date.
    • “The first sentence inside of his mouth was, ‘Well, why, why don’t we just buy a property together?’” — Audrey [14:08]
    • Hosts react with mock horror and humor; Audrey insists this was off-putting, even if well-intentioned or joking.
• James Clarifies:
  • He says he “wasn’t joking” about moving in—he actually thought he could help, though he backpedals on timing (“far in the future, like a month or two from now”). [16:07]
  • Audrey: “That’s a lot. No, that’s a lot to handle… I appreciate it. You’re really nice. But if I need a handyman, I’ll just call somebody. I don’t need them to move in with me.” [16:16]
• Awkward Explanations & Oversharing:
  • James tries to justify his intentions with anecdotes about mock dates with his brother’s wife and his “listening classes,” confusing Audrey. The hosts rush to clarify.

Closing Conversation & Second Date Offer (16:26–20:49)

• Continued Honesty & Openness:
  • Audrey admits his honesty is actually refreshing amid the usual dating scene:
    • “Most guys are not admitting their flaws and faults. So in a way, I like that you overshare and you’re honest about who you are.” [19:22]
  • She even concedes, “You are funny. Like, the dine and dash thing kind of got me by surprise.” [19:46]
  • James, ever literal, eagerly notes this down: “Hey, did you guys hear that? She thinks I’m funny. Hold on, let me write that down.” [19:54]
• Second Date Agreement:
  • Audrey sets clear conditions: “We’re not buying a property together, and we’re not going on vacation.” [20:11]
  • James (half-joking/half-real) negotiates, wanting to leave the door open for vacations — eventually agrees.
  • Final plan: casual pizza date, no property, no travel.
  • “Let’s keep it casual. But I’m definitely willing to go out with you again.” — Audrey [20:43]

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “Did I say brand new twice? My brain is glitchy.” — Jeffrey [03:29]
• “No, this time I listened to all her death stories all the way through.” — James [10:01]
• “I started off the date with, like, a little humor… I sat down at the table next to her with a different woman.” — James [07:46]
• “We should just do it… I’m a two bath, three bed kind of guy.” — James, reported by Audrey [14:08]
• “You should not have said that to me, even if you were thinking it… talking about moving in when we don’t even know each other.” — Audrey [16:49]
• “I’m just writing this down. I’m trying to learn. God, his self-improvement journey.” — James [16:58]
• “Mock date. Right. And so she could critique me so that all the stupid things I do, she could be like, hey, you’re an idiot… just to be a better dater.” — James [17:53]
• “Most guys are not admitting their flaws and faults. So in a way, I like that you overshare and you’re honest about who you are…” — Audrey [19:22]

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 03:10 — James returns; redemption arc set up
• 04:37 — Recap of James’ original “bad date” story
• 05:30 — James discusses YouTube “listening” classes
• 06:00 — Mock date with brother’s wife
• 07:00–08:20 — James recounts ice breaker and humor attempts (fake first greeting, dine and dash joke)
• 10:01 — “No, this time I listened to all her death stories…”
• 12:22 — Audrey joins the call
• 13:16 — Audrey’s reason: James moves “too fast”
• 14:08 — Audrey reveals the “let’s buy a house together” comment
• 16:07–16:16 — Audrey’s firm pushback on James’ seriousness
• 17:53 — James explains “mock date” confusion
• 19:22 — Audrey acknowledges James’ honesty and flaws
• 20:11 — Second date conditions: no house, no vacation
• 20:43 — Audrey agrees to a second, casual pizza date

Episode Takeaway

Despite a checkered history on the show, James’ self-improvement efforts (and, paradoxically, his awkward honesty) win Audrey’s cautious agreement for a second date. Sometimes, too much self-help and a rush for progress can create their own barriers—but when paired with humility, sincerity, and genuine effort, even a tentative “no” can become a promising “yes.”

For more Second Date Updates:
Find Brooke and Jeffrey at iHeartRadio, Spotify, or Apple Podcasts.