
After the collapse of a landmark deal, we hear from those in the industry.
Loading summary
Will Bain
This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the uk.
Tim Wilkins
I love ravioli. Since when do you speak Italian?
Unidentified SAP Concur spokesperson
Since we partnered with SAP Concur. Their integrated travel and expense platform and breakthrough solutions with AI gave me time back to dive into our financial future. We expand into Europe in 2027 so I'm getting ready.
Tim Wilkins
Well, you can predict the future.
Unidentified SAP Concur spokesperson
I can predict you'll like that message.
Tim Wilkins
What message? Oh, hey, we all got bonuses.
Unidentified SAP Concur spokesperson
You can save for college now.
Will Bain
I don't have kids.
Guardian Bikes/AM PM Advertiser
You don't say SAP Concur helps your business move forward faster. Learn more@concur.com.
James Helliwell
Why do businesses need a resilient supply chain?
Ryan Seacrest
Disruption is blindness. You cannot see what is happening in your value chain and you cannot surface data to address it.
James Helliwell
I'm Vijay Sharma, special host of Resilient Edge, a business vitality podcast paid and presented by Deloitte. Learn how geospatial intelligence and AI are transforming supply chain resilience. Available now where wherever you listen to podcasts.
Will Bain
Hello and welcome to Business Daily on the BBC World Service with me, Will Bain. Today, as world leaders are gathered for the COP30 climate summit in Brazil, we'll be zooming in on how to tackle emissions at the heart of global trade. Shipping ranks as a top 10 contributor to Greenhouse gas emissions, yet recent global goals to cap them fail to be agreed.
Diane Gilpin
We were hoping to have some clarity. To have the whole conversation torpedoed is deeply disappointing.
Will Bain
Concerns remain though about what those environmental targets might cost us.
James Helliwell
The increased cost in shipping goods, it would likely be path to the end consumer and cost of buying products in a store that have been shipped around the world.
Will Bain
So is there a way forward?
Vincent Clerc
You have to believe that there is a path. If you don't think that there is a path, then it's time to stop.
Will Bain
And do something else on business daily. Today then, we're going to be looking at why it seems so hard for the global shipping industry to get greener. The headquarters of the International Maritime Organisation on the south bank of London's River Thames are hard to miss. The rusted copper coloured bow of a ship protrudes from the front of the office building, jutting out towards the river as if ready to set sail. A memorial sculpture to seafarers around the world In October it greeted delegates from more than 100 countries heading into the building. Many of them, they thought to make history. Because the leaders were gathered to ratify a deal 10 years in the making which had been struck back in the spring and would, if agreed by them, see shipping become the first industry in the world with internationally mandated targets to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. From 2028, it read, shipowners would have to use increasingly cleaner fuels or face fines. But after days of talks, the historic agreement layeth not in tatters then, very much in the long grass.
Unidentified SAP Concur spokesperson
Now a plan to introduce a new carbon tax on global shipping looks like it's going to fail to get the backing it needs to come into force. The idea is to raise billions of dollars to fund the green technology, which would reduce emissions from an industry that's responsible for 2% of carbon emissions.
Will Bain
Saudi Arabia moved a motion to adjourn talks on how to implement the plans for a year. The motion passed by just eight votes.
Arsenio Dominguez
Throughout the negotiations and the discussions, several areas for clarifications were raised, which in the end led to the committee to agree to adjourn the meeting for a year.
Will Bain
That was Arsenio Dominguez, the Secretary General of the International Maritime Organization here on the World Service. That day, he explained more about why members had decided to delay the implementation for a year.
Arsenio Dominguez
Always been aware that these are actually big discussions for the organization. These are discussions that, as we have said, are decarbonization of shipping not happening just within the sector. We need all the sectors to play their part, and we are serious about protecting the environment and of course, providing a just and equitable transition. I do always work with a membership in order to find the consensus and to move the way forward. But during negotiation, it started to become clear that the membership needed more time.
Will Bain
Different countries, it turned out, had a range of concerns. Saudi Arabia and other countries whose economies rely heavily on oil revenues, for example, like the uae, Venezuela, Oman and Bahrain, were all concerned about what the deal might do to oil prices. But by far the strongest condemnation came from the United States, with President Trump taking to truth social on the eve of the talks to denounce the plans as a green scam that would increase prices of goods being shipped for consumers. And he threatened tariffs on countries that signed up. Thomas Kazakos, the Secretary General of the International Chamber of Shipping, the body that represents 80% of the world's fleet, said he was disappointed member states had not been able to agree a way forward and warned the industry needed clarity to be able to make the investments needed to decarbonize the maritime sector. And that's the central issue here. Shipping is big business. Every day, tens of thousands of massive vessels crisscross the world's oceans, bringing us the goods we want or need. It's an industry worth more than US$14 trillion each year, moving 80% of global trade. But that movement of goods comes at a cost to the environment. And the international shipping industry is responsible, as we heard, for between 2 and 3% of global greenhouse gas emissions. The rules may be delayed then, but for many within the industry, they know the issue still persists. It's about how you get there. It was something we spoke to the chief executive of one of the world's biggest shipping firms, Maersk, about. Vincent Cl joined us from their headquarters in the Danish capital, Copenhagen.
Vincent Clerc
There is three ways to go to actually solve the problem of energy transition. One is to rely on a high willingness to pay from the end consumer for green solutions. It is not there to the extent that it would be necessary at this stage. The second is to have a regulatory framework that would level the playing field and provide the incentive to invest in green. That's what we thought we had with the IMO until very recently, and we found out that actually we didn't. And then the third one is actually to continue to work on the technology to reduce or erase the green premium so that this can go without the regulatory framework and without the willingness to pay. I think for sure what the IMO decision has meant is the regulatory framework is pushed a bit further in, in the future.
Will Bain
I was going to say, does it not slow down part three, though as well? Because there isn't that incentive to do that spending when you've got other places where some of that investment might also be needed.
Vincent Clerc
So clearly that's one of the risks. It is that it will delay the scaling of the technologies we've been talking about. The opportunity is that it will foster more innovation because a lot of capital now would go towards finding either different processes or different ways of producing or different fuels or completely new solution that will not rely on a green premium to be effective. And there are different things that are being worked on that could have a lot of potential. We're looking at electrification of shipping. We're looking at different solutions that actually might be able to scale without relying on a regulatory framework. And if the consequences of the IMO decisions is that we get to a new and better solution, then I think it's going to be a win for a delay. That's what we have to work through right now.
Will Bain
So it's, it's about the pacing of that change as well, to sort of keep people on board, keep consumers on board with it too. Not feeling that they're paying a premium for it.
Vincent Clerc
Yeah, I think it's really important to remember the complexity of this and that there's going to be ups and there's going to be downs, but we have to keep people engaged. We have to keep also capital flowing towards investing in potential new solutions. There's going to be a big industry to build when we find those solutions. And I think there is still a lot of hope that we can make this in time.
Will Bain
You're an optimist still, and Maersk is still as committed as you were to this.
Vincent Clerc
You have to believe that there is a path. If you don't think that there is a path, then it's time to stop and do something else. I do believe there is a path. I believe if I look at how much technology has evolved in the last five years and just assume that this will continue for the next few years, then I think we're going to have some significant breakthrough. The framework at the IMO has been delayed, but there is still a lot of momentum from a lot of countries to get something done on the regulatory front. I think also this is getting more and more important for a lot of citizens around in the world because the effect of climate change are being felt more and more. So, you know, maybe we will not get to an easy, IMO pure solution on time, but we'll get through a combination of different things. But I do believe that there is a path and I do believe that we can look at the future with a lot of optimism still.
Will Bain
Vincent Clerk, the chief executive of the shipping firm Maersk, speaking to us from Copenhagen. You're listening to Business Daily on the BBC World Service with me, Will Bain.
Guardian Bikes/AM PM Advertiser
Every story begins somewhere for your child. It could begin with a Guardian bike, built right here in the usa, engineered for safety and designed for confidence. Kids of all ages are learning to ride in just one day. No tears, no frustration. It's why Guardian is America's favorite kids bike. And the New York Times and Wirecutters top pick three years in a row. This holiday season, give the gift that's safer, smarter and built to last. Visit guardianbikes.com to save up to 40% on all bikes, plus a free accessory bundle worth over $100.
Ryan Seacrest
Hey, it's Ryan Seacrest for Albertsons and Safeway. Flu season is here and our pharmacies have you covered with a free flu shot with most insurance plans. Plus it's cough and cold. And now through December 2nd, stock up on all the season's essentials and get ready for relief with discounts on items like Mucinex, Cold and Flu, Kickstart, Mucinex, Fast Max Products Vicks, Daquil and Nyquil Combo Pack. Alka Self, also Airborne and afrin offers end December 2nd. Restrictions apply and offers may vary by location. Visit Albertsons or Safeway.com for more details.
Will Bain
And today, with the COP30 climate summit ongoing in Brazil, we're looking at why it's proving so difficult for the shipping industry to work out how to get greener. So what comes next? How do those in the sector see the decision, or lack thereof, made at that IMO meeting? And is there a way to try and please everyone and move forward? We gathered a panel of industry leaders to try and work some of that out.
Diane Gilpin
Hello, I'm Diane Gilpin. I'm the founder and CEO of Smart Green Shipping.
Tim Wilkins
Tim Wilkins, Managing Director for Intertanko, the association of Independent Tanker Owners.
James Helliwell
Hello. James Helliwell, Commercial Director for decarbonisation at VGroup. We're a ship management organisation.
Will Bain
Diane, why don't you field this? Was it disappointing, the outcome?
Diane Gilpin
Yeah, absolutely, it was a disappointment. We were hoping to have some clarity that would stimulate the acceleration of our technology of all sorts of different wind assist fuel reduction technology, but to have the whole conversation torpedoed is deeply disappointing.
Will Bain
James Hallowell of V Group, was it the same? Was it a shock?
James Helliwell
It really was a shock. This is a journey that the maritime industry's been on for certainly the last three or four years, and we were hopeful, really hopeful, that this vote would have been positive and that we'd continue on that pathway to decarbonise the maritime industry.
Will Bain
And, Tim, what about for your members at Intertanko? Was it as simple as the threat of potential tariffs from the US side was just completely what shook this up, or were there other concerns already that had mounted up and that was just simply sort of a final straw that nudged people over the top, do you think?
Tim Wilkins
I think there was a set of contributing factors. The high politics at play was obviously the tipping point. But if you really listen closely to what happened at MEPC 83, which was the meeting before, there was already concerns that had been put on the table at that meeting. And I think if you read between the lines, you'd have said, oh, there's still a little bit of uncertainty. And that uncertainty simply grew.
Will Bain
And so was that around exactly what you were talking about? Okay, all well and good. We've got a framework if people don't go on this journey. A stick, if you like. What are the carrots? Where are the transitions? Where are the pathways, as you put it?
Tim Wilkins
Yeah, I think you're absolutely right.
Will Bain
I think There are a lot of.
Tim Wilkins
Question marks over the funding side of things, where that fund was going to be used, how it was going to be managed, and basically who's going to take advantage over that. So that was one aspect that was still thrown into question. Certainly from an industry perspective, there were those questioning the realism of the objectives that have been set.
Will Bain
James, just a quick thought on that. Was that a concern for you?
James Helliwell
I mean, more of a concern for us was really what it meant for the seafarers and the crew we have on board in terms of which fuel do you train them on? There's still a lot of uncertainty about the safety of those fuels and what that means operationally. I think on the cost side, the real cost, the increased cost in shipping goods, it would likely be pat to the end consumer and cost of buying products in a store that have been shipped around the world. In the shipping industry, it's always going to passed to that end user.
Will Bain
And to be clear, that was President Trump's argument, right, wasn't it?
James Helliwell
It was, yep. Yep.
Will Bain
And so how do you see that being overcome?
James Helliwell
I mean, I think that's one of the arguments that's been put forward for delaying this for 12 months, that the IMO still need to work out the finer details of how the fund is going to be gathered, how the money that is generated from the fund is then going to be used to help the industry to decarbonize. So that there's obviously a lot of tension around that financing side. But at the same time, one of our frustrations is it takes longer to decarbonize the we're on this pathway to 2050, and any further year that we're delayed makes it harder and harder for shipping companies to achieve those goals.
Will Bain
Yeah, Diane, that seems like the sort of almost unsolvable bit, but right now, I think someone said this, didn't they, off the back of the meetings? Diesel is just by far and away the cheapest way to do this. How do you shift that?
Diane Gilpin
I think reality comes in all sorts of forms, doesn't it? And the reality of the climate emergency is in our face every single day. And the reality of delay means that the costs will increase. I mean, we're already seeing extremely high costs for insurers for extreme events. But the reality is also that the industry has to now operate in a more complex environment. It becomes more and more complicated to be a ship owner. So kicking the can down the road, I think will make things much, much more expensive.
Will Bain
And it means people dealing with this, thinking about it Time, productivity, all that kind of stuff as well. And just pure business terms. Terms.
Diane Gilpin
Yeah, absolutely. Any business doesn't need to be in shipping, wants a clear regulatory framework in which to operate. I have not, in the 15 or so years I've been working in shipping, met anybody who has said, I would like to accelerate the climate change impact. So there's a lot of very, very good people working in this industry and everybody is committed to doing something or certainly most people.
Will Bain
Well, Tim just. Tim, just pick up on that appetite from members.
Tim Wilkins
Yeah, I would like to actually, because I think there's a great misconception out there that the industry has been sitting around waiting for this decision. In fact, looking at the IMO data, it really does showcase the trajectory of the industry and driving down its emissions and becoming more efficient. The paper basically says after four years of collecting this data, the industry has reduced its net emissions by 29% compared to 2008 in 2023. Now if we look at the target for 2030, then we are getting closer and closer to that 30%, striving for 40% net emission reduction. I think it's a very positive point to launch from and say, well, the industry hasn't been sitting around twiddling its thumbs waiting for something to happen because it makes good business sense, because it makes good ethical sense, will continue to drive down their emissions.
Will Bain
Well, that brings us neatly, doesn't it, to what is being done and the pace at which is happening at Diane, because that's very much your field, isn't it? Wind assisted propulsion is the term. Explain to people what you guys do practically how it works.
Diane Gilpin
We're developing wing sails which are effectively digitally enabled wind powered devices. So if you think of a sail, but it's made out of aluminium, wind is available, it's abundant. The point that we want to be able to discuss is that there's a lot of energy in the world, wind built global trade systems. So we're not suggesting that you go back to a kind of clipper ship from the 1850s, but you know, wind power is powering grids. We know that we can harness that in 21st century ways using lightweight long life technology. And it's easy to retrofit and it's being put onto ships. It is being put onto ships on a fairly piecemeal basis. I mean there are something like between 60 and 100,000 ships in the world, depending on who you ask. I think it's about scale and it's about acceleration.
Will Bain
But to up that pace, then there's not going to be this nudge in terms of rules and regulations to do that. So what is going to incentivize it and what is going to allow companies like you to grow to make your product cheaper? All that kind of stuff as what. What is kind of in the way at the moment, do you think?
Diane Gilpin
Yeah, I think the incentive is around building coalitions of the willing. The framework doesn't change people's belief that we have to decarbonize. It doesn't change the 2030 goal that the IMO set. It doesn't change the 2050 goal. It just makes it more difficult.
Will Bain
James, what's your sense around the pace of change and upping it?
James Helliwell
I think more regional regulation is still going to help drive and accelerate the pace of change, even with some uncertainty.
Will Bain
But it's the other wild card to that, that President Trump is out there saying tariffs for this kind of stuff that we actually, we want you to roll back those things as well, those regional things. We think those things are bad for business. We think those things are bad for American consumers too. And if you do them well, we'll factor them into our tariff negotiations.
James Helliwell
I think all of this uncertainty when we talk about international tariffs and how polit policy or may or may not develop is all of this will increase the cost of conventional fuels. All of this uncertainty is going to have an impact on fuel price. And so one thing we talk to a lot of our clients is focus on energy efficiency first. You can still reduce your emissions by 10, 20% just by trying to consume less amount of the fuel that we have today. So with all of that uncertainty, why not focus on Geofficial?
Will Bain
And that can make good business sense in its own right too.
James Helliwell
Exactly. It makes a very strong business case. Some of the wind technologies like Diane's company provides the air lubrication systems, propeller devices, all sorts of technologies that are on the market can help a ship owner to save money today.
Will Bain
Tim, interesting hearing the sort of language you use. You really believe that this will come back? Because I think a lot of people, perhaps cynics, I think that's it. It's in the long grass now and it's not coming back. And it's just convenient that there's a date in the future this will never be returned.
Tim Wilkins
You know, absolutely, it has to come back. The question, I guess the key question is shape and form this comes back rather than will it come back? And that's something we need to work on.
Will Bain
And at the pace it goes at Diane as well.
Diane Gilpin
Yeah. And I think the more that the addiction to fuel can be decoupled, the more resilient the industry can be and the more robust it can be in the face of this kind of regulatory uncertainty.
Will Bain
Diane Gilpin, the chief executive and founder of Smart Green Shipping, there you also heard from James Hallowell, commercial director for decarbonization at the V Group, and from Tim Wilkins, managing director of Intertanko, the International association of Independent Tanker Owners. That's just about it from us today. The producer was David Kann. And remember, do subscribe to our podcast to never miss an episode. Just search for BBC Business Daily.
Guardian Bikes/AM PM Advertiser
Dude, this new bacon, egg and chicken biscuit from AM pm. Total winner, winner, chicken breakfast.
Will Bain
Chicken breakfast. Come on. I think you mean chick dinner, bro.
Guardian Bikes/AM PM Advertiser
Nah, brother. Crispy bacon, fluffy eggs, juicy chicken, and a buttery biscuit. That's the perfect breakfast.
Will Bain
All right, let me try it.
James Helliwell
Okay.
Will Bain
Yeah, totally. Winner, winner, chicken breakfast. I'm gonna have to keep this right here.
Guardian Bikes/AM PM Advertiser
Make sure every breakfast is a winner with the delicious new bacon, egg and chicken biscuit from AM PM AM PM Too much good stuff.
Podcast Summary
Episode: Can global shipping go green?
Date: November 17, 2025
Host: Will Bain
This episode explores the immense challenge of decarbonizing the global shipping industry, a key player in international trade and a significant contributor to greenhouse gas emissions. While world leaders gather at the COP30 climate summit in Brazil, the shipping sector stands at a crossroads after a hard-fought international emissions deal failed to be ratified. Through interviews with industry leaders and experts, the podcast investigates why agreement remains elusive, the obstacles facing shipping’s green transition, and possible pathways forward.
Panelists:
| Timestamp | Segment & Highlight | |-----------|---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------| | 01:09 | Setting the episode’s main focus: shipping’s contribution to global emissions | | 03:23 | The adjournment of emissions deal at the IMO, Saudi Arabia’s motion | | 04:24 | Breakdown of political and economic opposition (including US stance) | | 06:03 | Vincent Clerc’s three paths to decarbonization | | 08:08 | Maersk CEO on optimism and continued commitment | | 10:29 | Introduction of industry panel | | 10:50 | Diane Gilpin laments the lack of clarity, disappointment in stalling progress | | 11:43 | Concerns about increased shipping cost for consumers (James Helliwell) | | 12:38 | Helliwell: Concerns for crew training, safety, and operational impact | | 13:55 | Gilpin: Delay will only raise long-term costs due to the climate crisis | | 15:00 | Wilkins: Industry has already cut 29% of emissions since 2008 | | 15:57 | Gilpin explains practical wind-assisted propulsion technology | | 17:26 | Regional regulation’s potential (Helliwell) | | 18:49 | Wilkins: The efforts to green shipping “have to come back” | | 19:01 | Gilpin: Reducing dependence on fuel strengthens industry resilience |
The episode carries a balanced but urgent tone, juxtaposing cautious optimism with the frustration of delayed action. Speakers highlight both technical and political complexity, stressing a pragmatic blend of regulatory support, technological innovation, and industry self-motivation.
The episode underscores the global shipping industry’s critical junction — with delays on an international emissions deal leaving the sector in regulatory limbo even as climate change effects intensify. Industry leaders believe solutions are within reach but require clarity, investment, and multi-sector cooperation. Despite the setback, ongoing innovation and regional measures keep hope alive for shipping’s green transition.
For those seeking an intelligent take on the state of play in global shipping’s decarbonization journey, this episode offers sobering reality balanced with practical perspectives and optimism for what’s ahead.