Business Wars: Disney Under Siege | Peltz Strikes Back | Episode 2 Summary
Host: David Brown | Release Date: December 18, 2024 | Source: Wondery
Introduction and Context
In the riveting second episode of Business Wars titled "Disney Under Siege | Peltz Strikes Back," Wondery delves deep into the high-stakes battle unfolding within the Walt Disney Company. The episode chronicles the relentless efforts of activist investor Nelson Peltz and his investment fund, Trian Partners, as they challenge Disney's leadership and strategic direction. Hosted by David Brown, the episode provides an inside look into corporate maneuvering, shareholder dynamics, and the intense proxy fight that captivates Wall Street and Disney enthusiasts alike.
Bob Iger's Leadership and Disney's Struggles
The episode opens in July 2023 at the exclusive Sun Valley Conference in Idaho, where Disney CEO Bob Iger seeks to reassure Wall Street amidst mounting concerns over the company's performance. Eight months into his return as CEO, Iger faces a 16% decline in Disney's stock price over the past year, signaling investor unease.
Notable Quote:
Bob Iger [02:25]: "They may not be core to Disney. Yes."
Iger acknowledges the erosion of Disney's traditional linear TV business, attributing its decline to disruptive streaming platforms. Despite his efforts to steer Disney towards a successful turnaround, skepticism persists both among investors and within the company's own TV operations, leading to fears of potential asset sales or layoffs.
Nelson Peltz's Proxy Fight Begins
Nelson Peltz, co-founder of Trian Partners and a major Disney shareholder, re-enters the fray after initially halting his proxy contest five months prior. With Disney's stock continuing to falter, Peltz intensifies his campaign to secure a board seat, arguing that enhanced accountability and fresh expertise are imperative for Disney's resurgence.
Notable Quote:
Nelson Peltz [04:55]: "The progress toward a successor CEO is glacial streaming. Still unprofitable in the stock price."
Peltz's fund, now holding approximately 33 million Disney shares worth over $3 billion, positions himself as a critical voice capable of revitalizing Disney's strategy. His nomination includes Jay Rasulo, Disney's former Chief Financial Officer, whose insider knowledge bolsters Trian's bid.
Campaign Strategies and Shareholder Dynamics
As the proxy fight escalates, both Disney and Trian employ multifaceted strategies to win over shareholders. Disney fortifies its position by revising bylaws to limit outside nominations and launching a robust communication campaign featuring beloved characters and endorsements from industry legends like George Lucas. Concurrently, Peltz leverages high-profile alliances, including support from billionaire Elon Musk, to amplify his message and appeal to retail investors.
Notable Quote:
Nelson Peltz [15:45]: "I invest in companies that are good companies, but are just sort of missing the mark a little bit."
The battle extends beyond boardroom negotiations to grassroots efforts, with targeted direct mail, emails, and phone calls aimed at persuading retail investors. Both factions vie for the pivotal votes of major index funds—BlackRock, State Street, and Vanguard—which control 16% of Disney's stock and hold the power to sway the election's outcome.
The Annual Shareholder Meeting and Resolution
On April 3, 2024, the culmination of months of strategizing and campaigning materializes at Disney's annual shareholder meeting. Despite Peltz's confident appeals and strategic endorsements, the result heavily favors Disney's slate of nominees. The decisive support from major index funds and institutional investors like Neuberger Berman ensures the incumbent board's victory, with Peltz and his nominees falling well short of the required votes.
Notable Quote:
Horatio Gutierrez [20:30]: "We are pleased to announce that the full Disney slate has been selected by a substantial margin."
The outcome not only thwarts Peltz's immediate ambitions but also reinforces Disney's control over its strategic direction. Subsequently, Trian Partners divests from Disney, realizing substantial profits despite the proxy loss, while Disney celebrates the reaffirmation of its leadership and strategic plans.
Aftermath and Future Implications
In the wake of the proxy battle, Disney experiences a resurgence marked by blockbuster successes like Deadpool and Wolverine and a profitable shift in its streaming operations. Bob Iger remains at the helm, with James Gorman appointed as the new chairman tasked with CEO succession planning. Meanwhile, Nelson Peltz retreats from the spotlight, though he hints at a potential return should Disney falter again.
Notable Quote:
Bob Iger [Final]: "We have a clear path forward, and with the support of our shareholders, we are poised for sustained growth."
The episode concludes by reflecting on the intense clash between corporate governance and activist investment, highlighting the delicate balance CEOs must maintain to satisfy both creative ambitions and shareholder expectations.
Conclusion
"Disney Under Siege | Peltz Strikes Back" masterfully captures the intricate dynamics of corporate power struggles, the influence of activist investors, and the relentless pursuit of shareholder approval. Through meticulous storytelling and insightful commentary, David Brown and Business Wars provide listeners with a comprehensive understanding of how high-stakes battles shape the destiny of iconic businesses like Disney.
Credits and Additional Information
Business Wars is produced by a dedicated team including Tristan Donovan of Yellow Ant, Marina Watson, Karen Lowe, Dave Schilling, Emily Frost, Grant Rutter, Ryan Potesta, Emmanuel Chimaciero, Gabrielle Jolais, Desi Blaylock, Callum Plews, Jenny Lauer Beckman, and Marshall Louie. The episode features dramatizations based on thorough historical research, ensuring an engaging and accurate portrayal of events.
To listen to more episodes like this, join Wondery+ in the Wondery App or on Apple Podcasts.
Notable Quotes with Attribution and Timestamps
- Bob Iger [02:25]: "They may not be core to Disney. Yes."
- Nelson Peltz [04:55]: "The progress toward a successor CEO is glacial streaming. Still unprofitable in the stock price."
- Nelson Peltz [15:45]: "I invest in companies that are good companies, but are just sort of missing the mark a little bit."
- Horatio Gutierrez [20:30]: "We are pleased to announce that the full Disney slate has been selected by a substantial margin."
- Bob Iger [Final]: "We have a clear path forward, and with the support of our shareholders, we are poised for sustained growth."
Note: This summary excludes advertisements, intros, outros, and non-content sections as per instructions.