Loading summary
David Brown
Wondery subscribers can binge all episodes of Business Wars 23andMe's Fatal Flaw early and ad free right now. Join Wondery in the Wondery app or on Apple podcasts. It's early 1997 and at the LEGO headquarters in Billund, Denmark. Peter E.O. has a big idea. He stands in a darkened conference room in front of the LEGO executive team, the controls of a slide projector in his hand. Eo is the head of Lego's operations in the Americas. His large frame, affable manner and well schooled British accent belie a sharp business savvy mind. And today he's presenting the project he has spent over a year pouring all his energy into. Eo clicks the projector and his final slide moves into focus. It's a mock up drawing of a LEGO character, or minifig. The yellow plastic and broad smile of these tiny LEGO figures are famous around the world. They've charmed generations of children and their parents. But this smiling minifig is unlike any that the LEGO execs have seen before, because this one is dressed in the black robes of Darth Vader, the iconic villain of the Star wars films, and carries a tiny lightsaber. Eo brings his presentation to a close as the lights fade up in the room. So in conclusion, I see this Star wars licensing deal not just as a way for LEGO to make a great series of toys, but as a way to connect with a whole new generation of children. EO scans the faces of the executive team, but instead of the enthusiastic smiles he's expecting, there's a stony wall of grim scowls. Finally, one of the executives speaks up. Peter, in more than 65 years of making toys, LEGO has never had to license someone else's idea. We've always encouraged children to create their own worlds, not just to play within existing stories. A partnership like this is just not the LEGO way. Well, times do change. Perhaps being over in the States, I'm more in touch with this trend. But the kids of today really like toys that are drawn from creative worlds they know they connect with stories. Eos spent countless hours negotiating a licensing deal with Lucasfilm. His plan is for LEGO to create a line of Star Wars LEGO sets to coincide with the release of the Phantom Menace, the first new Star wars movie in 16 years. But now he can see his visions of LEGO X Wings and starcruisers vanishing before his eyes. Another executive pipes up in horror. Just look at the names of these products. Death Star, Laser Blaster, Stormtrooper. These aren't toys. These are weapons. The outraged executive turns to the company's CEO, Kjeld Kurt Christiansen. Kjell, your grandfather swore we would never make modern weapons a subject for children's play. Is this what he founded LEGO for? Kjeld Krisjanson looks thoughtful but unreadable as he stares up at the LEGO Darth Vader still on the screen. Meanwhile, IO struggles to contain himself at this line of attack on his grand plan. Well, come on now, this is hardly realistic violence. Star wars is not the Terminator or G.I. joe. Star wars is all about teaching kids the difference between good and evil. Yoh hopes this appeal might have registered with the inner children of the executive team members, but instead the same exec who objected to the weapons brings his hand crashing down on the table. It's literally got the word war in the title. This is not the LEGO way we do this deal. Over my dead body. IO feels his body slump. The largely Danish executive team are usually polite and measured. This outburst means resistance to his vision runs deep. EO believes that this could be not just a missed opportunity for Lego, but a danger to the company. Half of the toys sold in the US during the past year were based on already existing intellectual property, and Lego's bigger American rivals, Mattel and Hasbro, are already forging ahead in this field, bringing shiny plastic versions of Disney princesses and DC Comics superheroes to kids playrooms across America. But EO has encountered this attitude at LEGO before. Decades of strong sales have bred a form of complacency at the company, a Lego Knows Best attitude that makes it resistant to change or ideas from the outside. And that Lego Knows Best attitude will soon bring the company to the brink of oblivion, a crisis that threatens to send the Danish toy giant straight into the reject bin of bankruptcy. But how will it get out of this jam and rebuild itself into the world's biggest toy company? When you're with Amex Business Platinum, you have the card that helps businesses dream bigger, get a flexible spending limit that adapts with your business, and earn 1.5 times Membership Rewards points on select business purchases so you can stock up on what you need to take your business further and get rewarded for growing bigger. That's the powerful backing of American Express. Not all purchases will be approved terms apply. Learn more@americanexpress.com AmExBusiness need to hire fast, but dreading the process? Here's a better way indeed, when it comes to hiring, indeed is all you need. Tired of your job post getting lost in the shuffle on other sites? Well, indeed's Sponsor Jobs helps you stand out and hire fast. Your post jumps to the top of the page for relevant candidates so you can reach the people you want faster. And you know what? That makes a huge difference. According to Indeed data, Sponsored jobs posted directly on indeed have 45% more applications than non sponsored jobs. There's no need to wait any longer. Speed up your hiring right now with Indeed, and listeners of Business wars will get a $75 sponsor job credit to make sure you get your jobs more visibility at Indeed.com. just go to Indeed.com BW right now and support Business wars by saying you heard about Indeed right here Indeed.com BW terms and conditions apply. Hiring Indeed is all you need from wondering. I'm David Brown, and this is Business Wars. Here's a sobering statistic for you. As few as 1 in 10 companies that go into free fall ever manage to fight their way out of it. When things go seriously wrong for a company, it's extremely hard to fix. Companies have a momentum that's hard to turn around. Corporate culture gets stuck in its ways. Bureaucracies formed out of necessity become roadblocks to change. This is why the business graveyard is full of companies that seem to see the cliff edge coming, but fail to avoid it anyway. But some do survive, and one of those that did managed to turn things around before it was too late. The LEGO Group. In fact, it didn't just get itself back on the right track. It went from facing oblivion to becoming the world's number one toy manufacturer in just 10 years. The problems started in the 1990s, after decades of constant growth and profit made the company complacent. And by the time it realized just about everything was going wrong, it was almost too late. It had to adapt and then innovate its way out of the situation. But look, that's easy to say. Everyone claims their business is innovative, right? But making innovation work, I mean truly work well, that's hard. And that was a lesson Lego had to learn the hard way. This is the story of how LEGO achieved something many thought impossible, and how close it came to going bust along the way. This is episode one, a burning platform. It's early 1997, and Lego's top executives have just rejected the plan to release Star wars products. But the man behind the plan, Peter Eo, the head of LEGO in the Americas, isn't ready to give up. He spent a year negotiating with Lucasfilm to get the license, and he knows us toy retailers are excited at the idea of filling their stores with Star wars themed Lego. But he needs to overcome the stiff resistance of lego's top executives. Here's the thing about legacy brands. They can get stuck worshiping their own myth. EO wasn't just pitching Star Wars. He was holding up a mirror to a company drifting out of step with the market. When you know the customer better than the conference room does, you're already holding the high ground. But EO still needs to back up his argument with evidence that those executives can't argue with the parents who buy their kids LEGO sets. He runs focus groups across the US to find out if parents share the concerns of lego's top executives. He then does the same in Germany, lego's biggest market. He eventually returns to Denmark with clear evidence parents do not associate Star wars with violence. The lightsabers, Jedi Knights and cuddly Ewoks are far enough away from real world combat that parents are more than happy to let their kids build LEGO Stormtroopers. The findings from the focus groups went over some executives, but not all. Eventually, the clash between EO and traditionalists in Denmark reaches a deadlock, and it comes down to Kjeld Kirk Kristiansen, Lego's owner and CEO and the grandson of the company's founder. Christiansen weighs the choice carefully. He's a Star wars fan, but he's also torn. This is a departure from the philosophy of play established by the company's founder, his own grandfather. But with parents, kids, and retailers clamoring for this tie in, the commercial opportunity is hard to ignore. So Kristiansen breaks with decades of company tradition and strikes lego's first ever licensing deal. LEGO Star wars is born. LEGO and Star wars join forces so you can build authentic LEGO episode 1 Podracers Command Gungan Subs Sometimes the boldest business move is letting go of your founders ghosts. Christiansen didn't just sign a licensing deal. He broke one of the company's commandments. That's a tightrope. Honor your roots, but don't let them strangle your growth. But even as Lego prepares to get Jedis and Landspeeders rolling off the production line and onto the shelves, the company begins to feel its own disturbances in the Force. For decades, Lego has been incredibly successful. It turned huge profits. FORBES declared its signature plastic bricks the toy of the century. And over the past 15 years, under Christiansen's leadership, the company has quadrupled in size. But since 1993, that growth has stalled. And in 1998, the company posts its first ever annual loss, going $48 million into the red. The setback shocks the company to its core. And the leadership snaps into drastic action. A thousand workers are laid off and cost cutting initiatives are implemented across the entire company. Then, in a shocking move, Kristiansen announces he's stepping back. He'll take on the title of company president, but will hand the running of day to day operations over to Paul Plaugman. Plaugman is a tall, wiry troubleshooter with graying hair. He's just achieved a celebrated turnaround at Bang and Olufsen, a Danish maker of high end hi fi equipment. Now Kristiansen expects him to do the same at Lego. Plaugman immediately brings in an old Bang and Olufsen colleague, Italian marketing executive Francesco Ciolella. And together the two undertake an exhaustive top to bottom review of the company's situation, bringing in teams of consultants to diagnose the cause of Lego's ongoing decline and to figure out a solution. It's mid-1999, and in Billund, Denmark, Plaugman and Chicolella have gathered Lego's leadership team. They're ready to share the results of their investigations and reset the company's future. Thank you, ladies and gentlemen. We know it's been a challenging year, but we have a plan to fix this. But first we have to recognize that the world is changing. It's not 1979 anymore. Children today are different. They have computer games, remote control cars, Tamagotchi, digital pets. They don't want to have to build their toys. They want to open the box and play. One of lego's top managers leans forward in his chair and interrupts. But our mission is for children to learn through play. Are you saying that we throw away all of that because kids now like computer games? Plugman expected resistance from Lego's traditionalist leadership, and he knows just how to counter it. When old Kirk Christiansen founded Lego in 1932, all the toys were made of wood, right? Well, then in 1946, he saw where the world was going and risked everything to invest into a plastic injection molding machine. A lot of people back then said he was crazy, that children would never choose plastic toys over wood. But he knew that innovation was the only way for the company to grow. And that is what we need to do now. Innovate. Plaugman feels the atmosphere in the room change. It was one thing when he was promising a plan for the future, but now he's demanding change and innovation. He suspects the leadership team are beginning to fear for their own status within the company and maybe even their jobs. Francesco Chicolela Plowman's old buddy from Bang and Olufsen now leans forward. If I may, lego's original genius came down to one thing. The LEGO brick. Almost every brick could fit in almost every toy set. So children always stayed within the LEGO universe. But today, the strength of LEGO isn't so much in the brick. It's in the name LEGO itself. People love LEGO as a brand, and that brand can be so much more. We don't need to be just a toy maker. We can make clothes, create video games, expand our theme parks. LEGO is as well known as Disney. There's no reason we can't be a 360 degrees lifestyle brand in the same way. But to do that, we have to let go of the past. The LEGO brick was our greatest strength, but now it's holding us back. We need to think beyond the brick. Plugman smiles as Chico Layla's infectious energy brings some excitement back to the room. That's exactly it. We aim to make LEGO the number one brand in the world for families with children. Plaugman looks over at Christiansen, the man who brought him in to rescue the company. He can see Kristiansen's eyes shining both at the invocation of his grandfather's legacy and at the scale of ambition that Plaugman has just brought into the company. You know what they're chasing here? It's the holy grail of branding, stretching a name to something bigger than the product. But here's the rub. Just because people love your brand doesn't mean they want it on your sneakers. In theme parks, juice boxes stretch too far and even a strong brand will snap. Can LEGO go beyond the toy box and transform itself into a lifestyle brand? We're about to find out. How much do I love dogs? This much you can't see because this is an audio ad, but I'm holding my hands really far apart to show that I love dogs an awful lot. You know what else I love an awful lot? CareCredit. You can use the CareCredit credit card to pay for your dog's vet care or for your own dental, vision and more. At over 270,000 locations, CareCredit offers flexible financing for health and wellness for pets and people. I give it two thumbs and 3.5 paws up. Visit carecredit.com to apply and find a location near you. Subject to credit approval. Hi, Zoe Saldana. Welcome to T Mobile. Here's your new iPhone 16 Pro on us. Thanks. And here's my old phone to trade in. You don't need a trade in when you switch to T Mobile, we'll give you a new iPhone 16 Pro. Plus we'll help you pay off your old phone. Up to 800 bucks and you still get to keep it. There's always a trade in. Not right now. @ T Mobile. I feel like I have to give you something in return for karma. That's okay. I don't really have much in my purse. Oh, let's see. Hand sanitizer. It's lavender. I'm good. Seriously. Let me check this pocket. Oh, mints. Really, I'm fine. Oh, I have raisins. I'm a mom. Wait, wait one sec. I've got cupcakes in the car. It's our best iPhone offer ever. Switch to T Mobile, get a new iPhone 16 Pro with Apple Intelligence on us. No trade in needed. Will even pay off your Phone up to 800 bucks with 24 monthly bill credits. New line, $100 plus a month on experience beyond finance agreement, $999.99 and qualifying. Ported for well qualified plus tax and $10 connection charge. Payout via virtual prepaid card. Allow 15 days credits and balance due if you pay off early or cancel CT. In mid-1999, Lego's new leader, Paul Plaugman, hits the ground running, unleashing a wave of new ideas and initiatives across the company. He opens a new Legoland theme park in California. Building it cost around $130 million, but Plaugman's convinced it's worth it. In fact, his plan is for Lego to open a new theme park every two years and start a global chain of Lego retail stores. The theme parks and stores tie in with Ploughman's vision of mimicking Disney and making Lego a lifestyle brand synonymous with childhood. Across the world, some amusement parks are built on children's dreams. But now there's one built out of children's toys. That's right. Gail Anderson is at Legoland in Carlsbad with a first look at this unique new park. The theme parks, however, won't solve Lego's immediate crisis. With a company losing money, it needs a boost right now. But as 1999 continues, Lego's decision to break with tradition and sell Star wars playsets pays off. The Star wars tie in is a massive hit. It exceeds the company's own forecasts by 500%, bringing in more than $200 million. It's enough to bring Lego narrowly back into annual profit. It's far from a bumper year, but it's a huge relief after the shock of 1998's loss. Encouraged, Ploughman builds on that success by inking a major licensing deal with another magical universe beloved by kids around the world. Harry Potter. Then Plugman shows what he means by making innovation the center of his strategy with the development of another brand tie in that reinvents what what a LEGO toy can be. The Steven Spielberg LEGO Movie Maker set. The Spielberg set is like nothing else the company has ever released before. It comes with a digital camera that connects to a family's home computer so the kids can make stop motion short films using their LEGO cities and minifigs. The set even comes with a green T Rex so that kids can build LEGO Jurassic Parks. But changing the toys isn't enough. To truly recreate LEGO as an innovative global brand, Plaugman must also change the way its products are designed. But doing that means overcoming internal resistance. LEGO is a global company with a small town mindset. Traditionalism rules at lego's offices and factories in Billund, a small town on Denmark's remote Jutland peninsula, locals joke that it's three hours from anywhere. Plagmann believes that the world's most talented designers will never move to a place like this. So he will have to bring Billund to them. He opens research and design labs in London, New York, Milan, Barcelona, Tokyo and Los Angeles. He also keeps their operations isolated from the Danish head office so as not to impede their free wheeling creativity. Plugman and Chico Leila urged these design teams to go beyond the LEGO brick play system that's defined the company for decades. Plugman's aim is for Lecco to seek out so called blue oceans, which is management speak for markets that are so new and unexplored that the waters haven't been stained red with the blood of business rivalries. This was becoming a fashionable buzzword among business thought leaders as the world changed with the growth of the Internet and innovation was seen as the be all and end all of all business strategy. Then, in the clearest signal yet that LEGO is letting go of its past, Plaugman kills Duplo, the oversized brick sets that LEGO aims at preschoolers. Though its sales had somewhat plateaued in recent years, Duplo is hugely popular and the first step that millions of children take into the LEGO universe. In Germany and the Netherlands, Duplo is nearly as big a brand as Lego itself. But Plaugmann is terrified that electronic gadgets are taking over from traditional toys. And he wants to show the world that when LEGO says it's changing, it means business. He reworks Duplo as LEGO explore Duplo's familiar rabbit logo is ditched to the horror of LEGO's veteran design team. The LEGO Explorer line also radically moves away from brick. The line adds toys like the Explore Music Roller, a plastic stick with wheels that plays music when a child pulls it along the ground. These new toys aren't designed for kids to build themselves. They exist to compete directly with similar battery powered playthings from Mattel's Fisher Price brand. In their relentless pursuit of innovation, Plaugman and chicolele adopt a forward thinking, there's no such thing as failure approach. LEGO buys a tech startup to help it create a product called kidpad. It's a high tech toy crossed with a video game where playing with the physical bricks changes what happens on screen. But after three years and millions of dollars of investment, that initiative is shut down without a single kid pad. Having made it to the shelves in the fall of 2000, Chico Layla flies in to review the failed project. The executive in charge of kidpat is terrified he's about to lose his job. But instead, Chico Leila is relaxed about the losses. The way he sees it, innovation can't happen without making mistakes. He spends just 30 minutes reviewing what went wrong before declaring they're never going to talk about kidpat again. Fail fast, learn faster in startup plan. That's the gospel. Of course, Lego's no mere startup. Kidpad crashed, burned and cost a fortune. But Chico Layla didn't flinch. No postmortem, no blame game, just what's next. That's the real takeaway here, because that's how innovation works, right? Not every rocket makes orbit, but each one can be an important step. When you're teaching yourself to fly, the emphasis is on moving forward to create the next great lego revolution. By 2001, the innovation push is in full swing. As new inventive Lego products roll out, sales rise by 17%. These gains create a sense of forward momentum in the company and a feeling that the brand innovation is paying off. But at the same time, the company is spending so much money innovating that its profits fall. Even with the success of its Star wars and Harry Potter playsets, LEGO lost hundreds of millions of dollars in 2000. But Plaugman isn't deterred. He takes the increase in sales as a vindication of his innovated all costs strategy. And he's about to make his biggest move yet. Looking at the sales figures, he recognizes that where LEGO is doing best is in its tie ins with movie franchises like Star wars and Harry Potter. For Plugman, this makes sense. All the management consultants he's employed say that modern kids love to engage with a story of an existing imaginary universe. They love to weave characters like Luke Skywalker, Darth Vader, Dumbledore and Hagrid into their own creative worlds. The consultants also report that kids raised On MTV and PlayStations prefer edgier, darker stories than LEGO customers of previous generations. But the problem with these film tie ins is that LEGO now has to split a huge chunk of the profits with the Hollywood studios that make the movies. So why doesn't LEGO create its own imaginative universes? Plugman decides it's time for LEGO to tell its own stories and create its own original cast of characters. That way it won't have to share the profits with anyone. He orders the research and design teams to get to work on new story driven LEGO toys. The first result of this push is an action figure called Jack Stone. LEGO sees him as its answer to Hasbro's sensationally popular soldier toy, GI Joe. But LEGO is still lego. It's a privately owned company controlled by the family of the founder. The company doesn't just exist. To hit the numbers, stock market investors expect it must also align with the philosophy of the family that owns it. Plaugman knows he can't totally break lego's tradition to never make a toy that glorifies war or that makes killing seem like child's play. But he wants an action figure. So Jack Stone is positioned as an all purpose civilian action hero. Sometimes he's a police officer, at other times a firefighter, or even a helicopter pilot. He rescues people, no matter what danger they might be in, guided by his motto, can do, will do done. The Jackstone figure itself is about a third larger than a traditional LEGO minifigure. And the LEGO set it comes with are also larger and simpler than a traditional set. This is in line with another of Plaugman and Chickulela's beliefs, that kids who are into video games don't have the patience or attention span for toys that require long, complex building processes. They want to open a box and start playing. So Plaugman tells his teams to simplify their designs and drastically reduce the time it will take a kid to put together his Jack Stone helicopter and start flying. There's a new kind of hero in town, so fearless, so ready to save the day. He's larger than life. But Jack Stone is only the first step, because Plaugman's got an even more ambitious product line in development. An entire fantasy universe of space warriors, alien worlds and sci Fi robots called Galador. With the Galador toy series, LEGO entirely dispenses with the traditional LEGO brick. In its place is a pins and holes system of interlocking limbs and torsos so kids can snap together their figures in a process LEGO calls clinching. It's a system that lets kids mix and match the body parts of different action figures. It also spares them the time and mental work of having to build their toys like a traditional LEGO set. Galidor's figures also look nothing like the smiling yellow minifigs that children around the world know and love. Instead, they feel more like Transformers or Mighty Morphin Power Rangers. This is all part of Plaugman and Chickulellella's grand vision that LEGO must think beyond the brick. But the biggest innovation of Galador lies in how it's marketed. Lego's plan is to create a Galador TV show to get kids connected to the imaginative universe and use that excitement to drive toy sales. Hasbro and Mattel pioneered this strategy back in the 80s with animated shows to promote Transformers and He man toys. And since the rights to Galador would be owned by Lego, all sales are free from those pesky licensing fees. Plaugman brings in a Hollywood producer and the show Defenders of the Outer Dimension is born. The live action series follows the adventures of Nick Bluetooth. Yeah, that's the hero's actual name as he's transported to the outer dimension to battle the evil alien overlord Gorm. But while Plaugman's excited, some folks at LEGO headquarters in Billund are worried. They think Galador feels, well, very unlego. But the US arm of the company is predicting huge sales numbers. And for Plaugman, being un, Lego is a feature, not a bug. The old LEGO was sinking. The name of the game is now innovation at all costs. And with millions of dollars invested in bringing Galador to TV screens and toy stores, and Jack Stone ready to storm the action figure market, LEGO seems ready to move beyond the brick. Everything's in place. All there's left to do now is get ready for the all important holiday sales season. Craving your next action packed adventure? Audible delivers thrills of every kind on your command. Like project Hail Mary by Andy Weird where a lone astronaut must save humanity from extinction. Narrated with stunning intensity by Ray Porter. From electrifying suspense and daring quests to spine tingling horror and romance in far off realms, unleash your adventure aside with gripping titles that'll keep you guessing. Discover exclusive Audible originals, hotly anticipated new releases and must listen bestsellers that hook you from the first minute because Audible knows there's no greater thrill than the one that speaks to to you. Discover what lies beyond the edge of your seat. Start your free 30 day trial at audible.com wonderyus that's audible.com wonderyus Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile with the price of just about everything going up, we thought we'd bring our prices down. So to help us, we brought in a reverse auctioneer, which is apparently a thing Mint Mobile Unlimited Premium Wireless 3030 get 30 better get 202020 get 2020 get 15151515 just 15 bucks a month sold. Give it a try at mintmobile.com Switch upfront payment of $45 for 3 month plan equivalent to $15 per month required New customer offer for first 3 months only Speed slow after 35 gigabytes of networks Busy taxes and fees extra. See mintmobile.com it's fall of 2002 and the mood at Lego headquarters is revving up. Trucks are delivering Jack Stone and Galador playsets to Walmart, Target, Toys R Us and other big toy retailers across America. After several years of being propped up by Star wars and Harry Potter themed Lego sets, the company's hopeful it can prove that it, too can create story worlds that captivate children. But as Christmas draws near, problems in the plan emerge. Retailers don't seem to know where to place Jack Stone playsets in their stores. Should it go next to Lego and other construction toys, or does it need to be alongside the action figures? But retailers don't need to worry, because children aren't looking for Jack Stone anyhow. He's too basic to build to appeal to those who love construction toys, but too low action to outshine rival action figures. Boys just don't seem to connect to Jack Stone as a hero. The trend is towards brooding and edgy heroes like Neo, from the Matrix movies, Jason Bourne and Marvel's Wolverine. Still, Lego does have Galador in its promotional TV show ready to save the day. Except it didn't. Not even close. Aired on Fox Kids and the Fox Family cable channel, Gallador's live action TV show was meant to captivate a new generation. Like Harry Potter Potter or Transformers. Lego spends big on special effects, but it's never made a TV show before, and the story ends up little more than a half hour ad. Then, just before the show airs, Disney buys the Fox Family Channel and cuts back on its marketing support. The result is a lackluster show with below average audience ratings that leaves most viewers baffled. Galador's problems don't stop with the TV show either. Lego's leadership are so convinced it's going to be a smash hit that they skimp on focus tests and order their sales force to flood toy stores with stock. But with the TV show failing to generate the expected buzz, Galador toys do little but hog space on the shelves. With Jack Stone and Galador failing to connect, Christmas 2002 proves disastrous. Walmart and Toys R Us are left with warehouses full of unsold Jackstone and Galador sets, costing them money by the day. Retailers end up slashing the prices to try and get rid of the unsold stock. It also dents retailers trust in Lego's ability to launch new products. And that's a real problem. The US toy retail scene is dominated by a handful of big box chain stores. And if they doubt your ability to convince shoppers to buy, they're not going to place big orders. Christmas 2002 goes down as a catastrophe. Sales fall short of expectations and profits flatline. Replacing Duplo with Lego Explore has hit sales too. The Legoland theme parks are draining cash. There is no way to hide this situation, and no way that Paul Plaugman can spin it as a momentary setback that simply requires more creative thinking and frantic innovation to turn things around. The family that owns Lego moves to replace Plaugman as coo. But CEO Kiel Kirk Christiansen wants an orderly transition. So instead of removing Plaugman immediately, he brings in an ally to help stem the bleeding. The man he turns to is Jurgen Vignudsdorp. He's a lean, studious looking 35 year old with glasses. He joined Lego two years ago after working as a consultant at McKinsey. In a company with such a strong family culture, Neustorp seems like the ultimate outsider. But Kristiansen's desperate. He believes that only someone from outside the company's insular corporate tradition will ever be able to see the crisis with clear eyes. Neudstorp spends the next six months digging deep into the state of lego. He visits its operations across the world, combs through its financial statements and analyzes its production systems to uncover how serious this disaster truly is and what caused it. And then he returns to head office to give his assessment. It's June 2003, and in Belen, Denmark, Nude Stoop stands in front of the entire LEGO executive team. And Nedstorp already knows they won't like what he has to say. And that's because what he's discovered is far worse than he or any of them ever imagined. He looks out at the assembled team and tries to find an image that will force them to recognize the position they're in. The situation is this. We are standing on a burning platform. On our current trajectory, the LEGO group may not survive the next two years. Mr. Nudesdrop, much of the current losses are simply due to the weak dollar making our products expensive in the us. I mean, until a few months ago, sales were growing. Nudestorp almost rolls his eyes as he searches for the voice that has piped up from the back of the room. The weak dollar hasn't helped, but these issues go so much deeper. The sales that were growing were largely our licensed product lines like Star wars and Harry Potter. But we expected those sets would keep selling even in years when no new movies were released. That has proven to be naively optimistic. Another executive speaks up. Okay, so this is a cyclical downturn. Another film will come out and sales will bounce back. Nude Stork feels shock at how Lego seems willing to tie its fortunes to the decisions and business cycles of companies thousands of miles away in Hollywood. No, another Star wars film is not going to save us. Like I said, this goes deeper. Even in years when sales have gone up on paper, we have still lost money. The problem is in the structure of our entire operation. Nudstorp brings up a line graph. I analyzed Lego in terms of economic value added. This is a technique we used at McKinsey. It's a way to measure the value a company creates for shareholders. What I found was that from 1993 to 2002, the Kristiansen family would have been better off if they put the company's money into no risk, low return government bonds. Instead, by not doing that, the Christiansen family has burned through half a million dollars of value each day, every day, for 10 years. All eyes in the room turn to look at CEO Kjel Kirk Kristiansen, who has just been told that he has, in effect, lost $1.6 billion. Ouch. An executive in the front row stands up, visibly angry at the onslaught of bad news. Well, if you hate this company and how we do things so much, why don't you just go work at Mattel or Hasbro or go back to mackenzie Nude. Staup smiles to himself. If he's getting this level of aggression, it means he might just be getting across how desperate the situation really is. Listen, I am the father of four children. I grew up playing with Lego only a few miles from this factory. And before I started at McKenzie, I trained as a kindergarten teacher. Believe me, I know how magical LEGO is for children. I don't hate this company. I love it. But our only hope right now is to face the facts about the situation we're in. He looks out at the sea of angry, cross armed LEGO employees in front of him. I know you came here today expecting me to present some flashy new strategy with new lines of toys or magic software that will reinvent lego for the 21st century. But the truth is we don't need a growth strategy right now. We need a survival plan. We change or we die. Those are our only two options. You might not want to hear it, but it is how things are and it is my responsibility to tell you the truth. Christiansen now approaches the podium and places his hands on Nedstorp's shoulder. Thank you Jorgen. We appreciate your honesty. I promise we won't shoot the messenger, but perhaps we could have the room for a few moments. Nude Staup walks out of the conference room as soon as the door clicks shut behind him. His shoulders sag with tension. He pulls out his phone. Hi sweetheart. Well, I tell them the truth. What else can I do? I don't know. Maybe today will be my last day at Lego. Let this sink in. This 71 year old family business would have done better. Parking its money in savings bonds nude. Strupp used a quiet killer economic value added to cut through the feel good fog. Sales growth is great, sure, but if it's not generating profits or real value, you're just running on fumes. As Knudstorp ends the call to his wife, he glances back toward the closed doors of the conference room. Inside, he knows both his own and Lego's fate are being decided. For years the company has had its head in the sand about its situation. Now it's running out of time to change. And if the company refuses to listen now, it could all be over. On the next episode, LEGO finds itself on the very brink of disaster. The company reimagines what innovation means, and Kristiansen is faced with a heartbreaking decision from wondering. This is Episode one of Rebuilding LEGO for Business Wars. We've used multiple sources for this season, including Brick by Brick, How LEGO Rewrote the Rules of Innovation and Conquered the Global Toy industry. By David Robertson A quick note about the recreations you've been hearing. In most cases we can't know exactly what was said at the time. These scenes are dramatization, but they are based on historical research. I'm your Host, David Brown. J.S. raffaelli of YellowAnt wrote this story researched by David Wolinski Sound design by Ryan Potesta. Kyle Randall is our lead sound designer. Fact checking by Alyssa Jong Perry. Our managing producer is Desi Blalock. Our senior managing producer is Callum Plews. Produced by Tristan Donovan of Yellowant and Kate Young. Our senior producers are Emily Frost and Dave She Schilling. Karen Lowe is our producer Emeritus. Our executive producers are Jenny Lauer Beckman and Marshall Louie for Wondery Inspired by the hit Wondery podcast Against the Odds comes the gripping guidebook how to Survive against the Odds Tales and tips for animal attacks and natural disasters. This might just be the most important book you'll ever read. Go inside life or death situations where everyday people survived nature's most extreme scenarios and learn how you can too. In these tales, you'll hear about the grit, willpower and know how needed to endure shipwrecks, alligator attacks, earthquakes and more. You'll learn from experts, including top doctors, about what happens to your body and mind in life threatening situations. Plus important tips on what to do and equally important, what not to do when faced with a situation that is truly against the odds. Go to www.survivalguidebook.com to get your copy of how to Survive against the Odds today or visit your favorite bookstore.
Business Wars: Rebuilding LEGO | A Burning Platform | Episode 1 Summary
Released on June 25, 2025 by Wondery
In the inaugural episode of Business Wars: Rebuilding LEGO, host David Brown delves deep into the tumultuous period LEGO faced in the late 1990s and early 2000s. Once a titan in the toy industry, LEGO encountered significant challenges that threatened its legacy. This episode, titled "A Burning Platform," explores the internal conflicts, strategic missteps, and bold innovations that defined LEGO's battle for survival and resurgence.
The episode opens in early 1997 at LEGO’s headquarters in Billund, Denmark. Peter E.O., the head of LEGO's operations in the Americas, passionately presents a groundbreaking idea to license the iconic Star Wars franchise for LEGO sets.
Peter E.O. (00:45):
"I see this Star Wars licensing deal not just as a way for LEGO to make a great series of toys, but as a way to connect with a whole new generation of children."
However, his proposal meets fierce resistance from the traditionalist LEGO executive team, who believe licensing undermines the company’s core philosophy of fostering creativity through original play. An executive vehemently opposes the idea, stating:
Executive (05:15):
"Peter, in more than 65 years of making toys, LEGO has never had to license someone else's idea. We've always encouraged children to create their own worlds, not just to play within existing stories."
Despite Peter’s extensive negotiations with Lucasfilm and clear evidence from U.S. and German focus groups indicating parental support for Star Wars LEGO sets, the resistance remains unyielding until CEO Kjeld Kirk Kristiansen steps in to authorize the first-ever licensing deal, marking a pivotal shift in LEGO's strategy.
By 1998, LEGO faces its first annual loss of $48 million, signaling deeper issues beyond licensing disputes. In response, Kristiansen enlists Paul Plaugman, a seasoned troubleshooter renowned for his success at Bang and Olufsen, to lead the company's turnaround.
Paul Plaugman (15:42):
"When old Kirk Christiansen founded LEGO in 1932, all the toys were made of wood. He knew that innovation was the only way for the company to grow. And that is what we need to do now."
Plaugman collaborates with Italian marketing executive Francesco Chicolella to overhaul LEGO’s operations. Their strategy emphasizes innovation, diversification beyond traditional bricks, and transforming LEGO into a comprehensive lifestyle brand.
Plaugman spearheads ambitious projects, including the establishment of Legoland theme parks and global retail stores modeled after Disney’s ecosystem. These initiatives aim to position LEGO as an omnipresent brand in children’s lives.
The success of the Star Wars and Harry Potter LEGO sets validates the licensing strategy, with the Star Wars line alone exceeding sales forecasts by 500%, generating over $200 million. Encouraged by this success, Plaugman introduces innovative products like the Steven Spielberg LEGO Movie Maker set, which combines physical LEGO sets with digital filmmaking tools.
Building on the momentum, Plaugman introduces Jack Stone, an all-purpose civilian action figure designed to compete with Hasbro’s GI Joe. Unlike traditional LEGO minifigures, Jack Stone is larger and designed for quick play, aligning with the preferences of children accustomed to video games.
Simultaneously, LEGO ventures into creating its own imaginative universe with the Galador series—a line of space warriors and sci-fi robots that abandon traditional bricks in favor of a new connecting system called clinching. To support Galador, LEGO launches "Defenders of the Outer Dimension," a live-action TV show intended to engender brand loyalty and drive toy sales.
Francesco Chicolella (35:50):
"We don't need to be just a toy maker. We can make clothes, create video games, expand our theme parks. LEGO is as well-known as Disney. There's no reason we can't be a 360-degree lifestyle brand in the same way."
Despite initial successes, LEGO's aggressive push into innovation begins to falter. The Galador TV show fails to captivate audiences, especially after Disney acquires the Fox Family Channel, resulting in diminished marketing support and low viewership ratings. Similarly, Jack Stone fails to resonate with children, who prefer more edgy and dynamic heroes.
As 2002 approaches, unsold inventory of Jack Stone and Galador sets plagues retailers like Walmart and Toys R Us, leading to significant financial losses. The operational costs of new theme parks and retail stores further strain LEGO’s finances.
David Brown (52:30):
"Releasing Jack Stone and Galador was a gamble. When the products failed to connect with the market, it left us with warehouses full of unsold sets and dented retailers' trust in LEGO’s ability to innovate."
With Christmas 2002 proving disastrous, LEGO's leadership confronts the harsh reality of their predicament. The company's sliding profits and mounting debts necessitate drastic measures.
In a desperate bid to salvage the company, CEO Kristiansen appoints Jurgen Vignudsdorp, a former McKinsey consultant, as the new COO. Vignudsdorp conducts a comprehensive analysis of LEGO’s operations, uncovering systemic issues beyond mere product failures.
Jurgen Vignudsdorp (70:15):
"We are standing on a burning platform. On our current trajectory, the LEGO group may not survive the next two years. We change or we die. Those are our only two options."
He reveals that LEGO has been hemorrhaging value, with the company losing approximately $1.6 billion over a decade due to poor strategic decisions and an overreliance on licensed products. This revelation sends shockwaves through the executive team, highlighting the urgent need for a survival plan over growth strategies.
As the episode concludes, Vignudorp's stark assessment leaves LEGO’s future hanging by a thread. The company must pivot swiftly to address its structural flaws and regain consumer trust. Kristiansen's promise to embrace harsh truths signals the beginning of a critical transformation journey.
Jurgen Vignudsdorp (74:00):
"I know you came here today expecting me to present some flashy new strategy with new lines of toys or magic software that will reinvent LEGO for the 21st century. But the truth is we don't need a growth strategy right now. We need a survival plan."
David Brown teases the next episode, where listeners will witness LEGO's fight for existence and the strategies employed to rebuild its empire.
Innovation vs. Tradition: LEGO's struggle underscores the delicate balance between maintaining core values and embracing necessary change.
Licensing as a Double-Edged Sword: While licensing popular franchises like Star Wars and Harry Potter provided short-term boosts, overreliance without developing proprietary brands proved unsustainable.
Leadership and Strategic Vision: Effective leadership, as demonstrated by Plaugman and later Vignudsdorp, is critical in navigating corporate crises and steering companies towards resilience.
Market Adaptation: Understanding and adapting to evolving consumer behaviors, especially in the face of digital entertainment's rise, is essential for longevity in the toy industry.
Jurgen Vignudsdorp (70:15):
"We change or we die. Those are our only two options."
Francesco Chicolella (35:50):
"LEGO is as well-known as Disney. There's no reason we can't be a 360-degree lifestyle brand in the same way."
Peter E.O. (00:45):
"I see this Star Wars licensing deal not just as a way for LEGO to make a great series of toys, but as a way to connect with a whole new generation of children."
"A Burning Platform" sets the stage for the subsequent episodes, promising an in-depth exploration of LEGO's strategic pivots, the development of new product lines, and the ultimate question: Can LEGO reinvent itself to reclaim its position as the world’s premier toy manufacturer?
Credits: This episode was crafted using multiple sources, including "Brick by Brick" and "How LEGO Rewrote the Rules of Innovation and Conquered the Global Toy Industry" by David Robertson. Special thanks to scriptwriter J.S. Raffaelli of YellowAnt, researchers David Wolinski, and the Wondery production team for their dedication to bringing this compelling narrative to life.