Business Wars: The Unraveling of Boeing | Jedi Mind Tricks | Episode 3 Summary
Hosted by David Brown, Business Wars delves into the high-stakes conflicts between major companies shaping our world. In episode three of "The Unraveling of Boeing," titled "Jedi Mind Tricks," Wondery explores the tumultuous journey of Boeing as it grapples with fierce competition, internal challenges, and catastrophic failures.
1. The Intensifying Rivalry: Boeing vs. Airbus
January 2012, Seattle, Washington:
Boeing's research facility buzzes with activity as aerodynamicists test the 737 Max, an updated version of Boeing's bestselling 737 model. Facing pressure from Airbus, whose A320neo boasts modern, fuel-efficient engines and is gaining substantial airline orders, Boeing aims to reclaim its market dominance.
Quote:
David Brown [00:00]: “Boeing uses this high-tech tunnel to test how its plane designs might perform under different conditions.”
2. Launching the 737 Max: Strategic Moves and Innovations
Boeing responds to Airbus's advancements by developing the 737 Max, incorporating larger, more fuel-efficient engines. To maintain minimal training requirements for pilots, Boeing introduces the Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System (MCAS), a software designed to stabilize the aircraft's flight characteristics despite the aerodynamic changes from the new engines.
Quote:
Boeing Chief Technical Pilot Mark Forkner [29:47]: “MCAS is now active down to Mach 0.2. It's running rampant in the sim on me, so I basically lied to the regulators unknowingly.”
3. Navigating Regulatory Waters: FAA and Global Standards
Boeing's aggressive push to minimize pilot training costs leads to contentious negotiations with the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). Forkner faces immense pressure to convince the FAA to accept Level B training—a brief computer-based course—rather than comprehensive flight simulator training. The FAA, wary after grounding the 787 Dreamliner due to battery issues, demands stringent scrutiny, signaling potential additional training requirements that could jeopardize the 737 Max's market appeal.
Quote:
Forkner [29:47]: “MCAS doesn't fix the handling problems at lower flight speeds, and particularly when the plane's approaching a stall.”
4. Internal Struggles and Cost-Cutting Measures
Amidst mounting pressure from Airbus, Boeing initiates drastic cost-cutting measures to compete on price and maintain profit margins. Ray Connor, Boeing's Vice President of Product Strategy, announces that Boeing is "losing the air war," highlighting Airbus's dominance in the single-aisle market with 60% of A320 orders in 2015. This revelation sends shockwaves through Boeing's engineering teams, culminating in a company-wide push to streamline operations and increase 737 Max production.
Quote:
Ray Connor [REFERENCE TO TRANSCRIPT]: “Airbus is beating us time after time... Boeing must compete with Airbus on price.”
5. Success Amidst Struggles: The 737 Max Takes Flight
Despite regulatory and internal hurdles, the 737 Max achieves significant sales milestones. The aircraft becomes the fastest-selling model in Boeing's history, securing nearly 3,700 orders from 87 airlines by late 2015. Malindo Air's maiden flight in 2017 symbolizes this success, as Boeing anticipates earning over $40 billion from the Max.
Quote:
David Brown [29:47]: “The Max is already the fastest selling aircraft in Boeing's history.”
6. The Cracks Begin to Show: Lion Air Flight 610
October 29, 2018, Jakarta, Indonesia:
Tragedy strikes when Lion Air Flight 610 crashes shortly after takeoff, killing all 189 on board. Investigations point to a malfunctioning angle of attack sensor feeding erroneous data to MCAS, causing the system to relentlessly push the plane's nose downward. This incident marks the beginning of Boeing's unraveling, exposing critical flaws in the 737 Max's design and Boeing's regulatory oversights.
Quote:
Pilot [Nov 2018]: “The Lion Air guys didn't even know the damn system was on the airplane, nor did anybody else.”
7. Fallout and Accountability: Boeing Under Fire
In the aftermath of the crash, Boeing faces intense scrutiny from airlines and pilots. American Airlines pilots confront Boeing executives, demanding transparency about MCAS—a system they were unaware of due to its exclusion from pilot manuals and training. The frustration boils over as pilots emphasize the critical role they play in flight safety, highlighting how Boeing's omissions directly contributed to the disaster.
Quote:
Infuriated Pilot [Nov 2018]: “The Lion Air guys didn't even know the damn system was on the airplane, nor did anybody else.”
8. The Path Forward: Crisis Management and Rebuilding Trust
As regulators worldwide begin grounding the 737 Max, Boeing's reputation is in tatters. The company scrambles to address safety concerns, while its newly appointed CEO, Dave Calhoun, works tirelessly to steer Boeing out of crisis. The episode sets the stage for the ensuing battles Boeing must face to restore its standing in the aviation industry.
Quote:
David Brown [End of Episode]: “The momentum behind the Max is now unstoppable, and few are paying attention to MCAS, the software program lurking deep within the aircraft that's about to turn deadly.”
Conclusion
Episode three of "The Unraveling of Boeing" masterfully chronicles Boeing's descent from market-leading dominance to a perilous crisis precipitated by internal missteps and aggressive competition from Airbus. Through detailed narrative and poignant quotes, David Brown captures the high-pressure environment within Boeing, the strategic gambits against Airbus, and the tragic consequences of compromised safety standards. "Jedi Mind Tricks" serves as a cautionary tale of how corporate ambition and regulatory complacency can culminate in disaster, reshaping an industry giant's legacy.
For those seeking an in-depth understanding of Boeing's challenges and the broader implications for the aviation industry, this episode of Business Wars is an essential listen.
Recommended Further Listening:
- Boeing vs. Airbus by John Newhouse
- Flying Blind by Peter Robison
Explore more Business Wars episodes on the Wondery App or your preferred podcast platform.