
Jill and Tom chat with Sean Tucker of Autotrader about buying a car in uncertain times.
Loading summary
Home Depot Announcer
Now is the time to shop for upgrades that transform your yard during Spring Backyard Days at the Home Depot. Turn an empty corner into a hangout with the Hampton Bay Brook Mill four piece patio set. Then brighten your garden with lilacs or begonias and help them thrive with vigro potting soil. It's the finishing touches that really bring your space together with low prices. Guaranteed. Shop Spring backyard days for seven days at the Home Depot, now through May 6. Exclusions apply. See homedivo.com Pricematch for details.
Dish Network Announcer
For 45 years, Dish has been connecting America with the best in family, TV, entertainment and advanced technology at an unbeatable value. And that commitment continues with our new 45th anniversary special offer. Get the lowest price in satellite TV starting as low as $89.99 a month. In a world of rising costs and hidden fees, DISH stays transparent, reliable and honest, just like our founders intended. Learn more by calling 888-add-D dish or visit dish.com terms and conditions apply.
Strayer University Announcer
At Strayer University, we help students like you go from Will I? To why not? For over 130 years, we've been innovating higher education to make it more affordable, accessible and attainable so you can reach your goals. Go from thinking, can I? To Yes, I Can and keep striving. Visit strayer.edu to learn more. Strayer University is to operate in Virginia by Chev and its many campuses, including at 2121 15th Street north in Arlington, Virginia.
Host
Whether you drive a car, need a car, or just occasionally bum a ride
Producer/Announcer
with friends, you've come to the right place.
Host
Join Jill and Tom as they break down everything that's going on in the auto world.
Producer/Announcer
New car reviews, shopping tips, driving green
Host
electric cars, classic cars, and plenty of great guests.
Producer/Announcer
This is the Consumer Guide Car Stuff Podcast.
Tom Appel
All right. This is the Consumer Guide Car Stuff Podcast. I am Tom Appel. Thank you for joining us today. When you have a moment, check us out@consumerguide.com you know the drill if you're looking for a car or truck. Great stuff there, including our 2026 Best Buy list. Also, just lots of other fun stuff. Industry news, other stuff. It's good. I just wrote a piece.
Jill Simonello
Jill, you wrote a piece?
Tom Appel
I wrote a piece, okay. About the the Jeep Station Wagon Maverick edition.
Jill Simonello
There's a whole lot of stuff going on with that name.
Tom Appel
There is. And the story here. Jeep used to build a thing that was based on stuff that it had sold during World War II.
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
Actually, it wasn't cheap. It was Willys at the time but they built this thing called the station wagon, and they started to sponsor the show Maverick, which is fabulous. James Garner, Jack Kelly, Great show. But this vehicle was a special edition based on that sponsorship. Okay, Very cool. I just wrote about that. That voice is Jill Simonello. She's a contributing editor here at Consumer Guide, North American Car, the OR juror and freelancer. How are you, Jill?
Jill Simonello
I am doing well.
Tom Appel
Remember we talked about that perfect day a week ago?
Jill Simonello
Yeah. What today is not that day.
Tom Appel
Last night. Wind gust. My wife and I live in a bungalow, and the entire upstairs is our bedroom. Basically, our bedroom has four outside walls. The sound of wind slapping the. The. The siding on our house was. I couldn't sleep. It was crazy.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
And it's cold.
Jill Simonello
It is cold. It is.
Tom Appel
And then there was snow.
Jill Simonello
Yeah. It can't decide if it wants to snow or if the sun wants to come out.
Tom Appel
We have a lot of listeners in Michigan right now. They're just flicking us off, like, because it was way worse in Wisconsin and Michigan. And up Nordic.
Jill Simonello
Yep. So I have to say, I was trying to get back to Chicago on Friday. I was in Detroit. I gave a keynote speech on Friday to the women of Stellantis, and it was pretty awesome. But trying to get back to Chicago, not so awesome. I was stuck in the airport for an extra, like, three hours because the wind was so egregious that things just couldn't, like, take off. There were ground stops both in Chicago and in Detroit. And then when I landed in Detroit, I posted in my stories. I took a picture of the departure board, and there was, like, maybe one flight on there to Frankfurt that was not delayed.
Tom Appel
Frankfurt?
Jill Simonello
Yeah. Every other flight was delayed.
Tom Appel
A lot of flights stop in Frankfurt. You could have just made a stop.
Jill Simonello
Yeah. Well, I think that's why that wasn't delayed, is because that's like the jumping off to all the other things. And they're like, if one flight gets out of here today, it's going to be that one.
Tom Appel
That's where they have those hot dogs.
Jill Simonello
I thought Chicago was where they had those hot dogs.
Tom Appel
No. Well, Frankfurt's tours anyway.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
Right now it's crummy outside.
Jill Simonello
It is. That was the point of all that.
Tom Appel
Here's the funny thing. I'm watching people shovel today. We got some snow. It's not gonna be melted in a day or two. It's going up to, like, 60.
Jill Simonello
Yeah. Like, I feel like by Friday or something, it's gonna be warm again. This is where everybody needs to start taking zinc because everybody's immune systems are gonna be like, what?
Tom Appel
I'm still a little sick, so I can't get sick again.
Jill Simonello
I'm finally famous. Last words. I'm finally out of the woods. I'm finally.
Tom Appel
Still coughing?
Jill Simonello
Yeah, not much. I mean, I still have a little bit of a cough, but other than that, I'm good.
Tom Appel
You ever had that thing happen where you're falling asleep, you're comfortable, everything's great, your pillow's your best friend, and you're just sort of drifting off and then you have to cough and you're like, seriously?
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
I'm gonna have to reset after that.
Jill Simonello
Yeah, yeah. Because it's not just one cough. It's like a big cough, and you gotta get it all out.
Tom Appel
And then you might sit up and get a drink of water, and then you're like, oh, well, that's 20 minutes I lost.
Jill Simonello
Exactly.
Tom Appel
Because I gotta start over. I have to reacquaint myself with my pillow.
Jill Simonello
Yes.
Tom Appel
Oh, man. Speaking of bad news.
Jill Simonello
So which bad news do you want to talk about?
Tom Appel
There's a lot more. There are more EVs disappearing.
Jill Simonello
Yeah. You and I may have the same bad news.
Tom Appel
Well, I've got two. Okay, I've got two pieces of bad news here. First is the Volvo EX30.
Jill Simonello
That was the bad news that I had.
Tom Appel
This was a vehicle with so much promise. It was a delightful vehicle. And it was going to be $35,000 when they were going to build it in China.
Jill Simonello
Yep.
Tom Appel
I didn't even write down the name of the city in China because there was no way I was going to be able to pronounce it. But they were going to build these in China, bring them in here for as little as $35,000. And they were quick and they were fun, and they were agile, and they made great use of space. These were great little cars. And these are the kind of cars that would have changed people's minds about EVs.
Jill Simonello
Yep, 100%.
Tom Appel
But that obviously went bad. China tariffs. Yeah. So they move production to Belgium, but if it's not one administration, it's another Biden. Of course, with 100% tariff on Chinese, EV is actually 102.5%. And then now the Trump administration with a 15% tariff on stuff from the EU. So they just couldn't make a run of it. No, it was a little small for what they were going to have to charge for it. So that's gone. Yeah. Great car.
Jill Simonello
It was. You know, and I recently just had the opportunity to drive it on snow up in Canada and was thoroughly, thoroughly impressed.
Tom Appel
They may still sell those in Canada.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
Actually, I don't know the nature of this discontinuation. They're not killing the car.
Jill Simonello
No.
Tom Appel
They're just not going to bring it.
Jill Simonello
They're just here killing it here and here.
Tom Appel
Might be just here in the US Canada and Mexico probably still going to get it. I don't know if Mexico was ever going to get it, but that's. That's it. So. All right, that's one piece of bad news. The other one's kind of a bigger deal because it was a sub brand and I never knew where this was going anyway.
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
And. And for reasons that I can't fully explain, I never followed the story that closely, but Honda was developing a line of electric vehicles, a sub brand called Zero. And there were two products that were coming imminently and one coming later. But one of them was the Honda Zero SUV and the Honda Zero saloon. Saloon being British for sedan. And these were really striking looking. To me, they look like something that might have been out of the movie 2001 A Space Odyssey. Because the concept cars were white.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
And simple and had that sort of plastic look to them. But really interesting cars. They were due this year. Ain't coming at all.
Jill Simonello
No.
Tom Appel
No more Honda 0 and Honda's killing everything.
Jill Simonello
Yeah. I mean, top. On top of that, I've heard rumors that the Prelude is going away.
Tom Appel
Oh, the Prelude. The Prelude.
Jill Simonello
No, not prolonged Prologue.
Tom Appel
Yeah, that.
Jill Simonello
Too many plosive P's.
Tom Appel
That confusion is because the Prelude is a small gasoline powered car based on the Civic.
Jill Simonello
Yes.
Tom Appel
The Prologue is an electric car based on a General Motors design.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
Actually very similar to the Equinox or Blazer.
Jill Simonello
Yeah. I think it's based on the platform for the Blazer and. But the Prologue, I'm going to mess them up Now. Has Apple CarPlay, whereas the GM variants did not. But the rumor, and I don't think that this has been confirmed yet, but the rumor is that when it stops production, it will not enter another generation.
Tom Appel
Yeah. Yeah, that's it.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
I think the relationship with General Motors was going to be short term.
Jill Simonello
Yeah. Well, I mean, the Zero sub brand was supposed to take the place of the relationship with General Motors.
Tom Appel
So here's a question for you. And we have not talked much about this on the show. Afila. Afila is a Honda Sony joint venture to build premium electric vehicles. Were they going to build those here? I should know this. And I don't.
Jill Simonello
I don't know.
Tom Appel
But they were going to be premium electric vehicles for sale in the United States. I was going to be the primary market where they would sell them everywhere because. But the brand was a Fila and they were going to be very high tech. Sony was going to bring connectivity and whatnot and Honda was going to bring its obvious manufacturing and automotive design expertise to the project. I bet you that's dead.
Jill Simonello
Yeah, I don't know. I mean, and here's the thing. I've recently been hearing a lot about the used EV car market and how
Tom Appel
that for some reason that's being hyper covered right now.
Jill Simonello
Yeah, yeah. I mean, I feel like as a lot of vehicles are starting to come off lease, that there is a huge potential for somebody to dip into the EV market without having to pay like the high EV premiums. So, you know, I think in some way we might see a resurgence of electric vehicle registrations. It's just not going to be the new ones.
Tom Appel
Well, there's not going to be any premium for purchasing a used ev versus buying a new correct ev.
Jill Simonello
Right.
Tom Appel
And part of the reason is that in that resale value, that 15, I'm sorry, $7,500 tax credit was part of the price.
Jill Simonello
Right.
Tom Appel
And that's why used EVs seem cheaper perhaps than they might. But yeah, to your point, I've heard the same story three times now from three different outlets, but about a million cars, a million EVs are coming off lease in the next three years, which means there are people who got four year leases, which is very weird. But, but anyway, those are going to flood the market with quality, nearly new EVs that are probably going to be very affordable.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
So if you were going to dip your toe into this maybe as a second car or a car for the kids, you can buy one for 20, 25 grand. Do that. Yeah, why not?
Jill Simonello
Yeah. I mean, and these things are going to be high tech. They're going to have all the safety features that you want, you know, especially for a teen driver, you're going to have the cool things. Most of them, you know, except for the ones from General Motors will have Apple CarPlay and then.
Tom Appel
Yeah, but the youngsters can work around that.
Jill Simonello
Yeah. By touching their phone.
Tom Appel
Old people like you and I, we can't figure it out.
Jill Simonello
Yeah, again, by touching your phone. That's how you work around it. So I don't know, but I just, I think that there's lots of safety, lots of tech features, you know, nearly new, as you pointed out, because somebody who's driving an EV probably bought it as a commuter car. So they weren't going huge miles. Like, they probably didn't do the 12,000 miles a year that is the average.
Tom Appel
No, the mileage, actually, man, I don't remember what I read about the mileage, but I thought it was higher than you thought it would be for an ev. Because I would think what you just thought that the mileage would be pretty low. It's a second car. You don't take it on trips. But anyway. Yeah, so that's going to be weird. And that'll be interesting. Here's a story. I want you to just sort of raise your hand if I'm getting too political when I talk about this.
Jill Simonello
Okay. Nobody else is going to see it, but you will, and you'll change course.
Tom Appel
But there's no way to have this conversation without hand raising.
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
Without getting political. Texas. The Texas DMV is now requiring residents who purchase a car. Do you know the story?
Jill Simonello
I do.
Tom Appel
They're going to need more than just a driver's license.
Jill Simonello
They need a real ID to purchase, not to purchase.
Tom Appel
To register a new or used car.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
And this is. This is clearly politically motivated and it is aimed at preventing undocumented residents from
Jill Simonello
purchasing a car or registering a car.
Tom Appel
Registering a car. Well, but you can't do one without the other.
Jill Simonello
Correct. But I mean, you can purchase the car and then like, here's where the problem is gonna come in.
Tom Appel
You purchase the car and then move to Louisiana.
Jill Simonello
Well, no, but this is where the problem is gonna come in. Somebody bought a vehicle this year before whatever laws were enacted, and then they need to re register their vehicle.
Tom Appel
Here's the good news. It's only the first time registration.
Jill Simonello
Is it?
Tom Appel
Yes, Based on what I just read.
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
It's just the first time I've seen
Jill Simonello
it because everything I've heard was talking about the RE registry.
Tom Appel
That's more difficult. Also, I don't know how many people actually know this whole story, but if I'm right, it's not as horrible as it could be.
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
If you're right, it's tragic.
Jill Simonello
Okay. Tragic.
Tom Appel
Here's part of the problem. This started this month. So I don't know how dealers are reporting monthly sales since it's only been two weeks, but they are. Dealers are reporting a slowdown in sales. It's small, but it's interesting. And ultimately we'll see what states adopt this. Otherwise, maybe Texas is the only one. Maybe there's a couple other states down south that want to do this, but this may actually hurt. Sales somewhat nationally.
Jill Simonello
Well, and so the concern is this, like, it's not, yes, it's to prevent people who don't have proper identification from registering a vehicle. But the concern from dealers, as I understand it, is this, you know, say you just have a regular driver's license and this new law requires a real id and you haven't gone to get a real ID yet, but you have a driver's license. Well, in addition then to your driver's license, you're going to need a birth certificate or a passport or something like that. So you show up at the dealership with your id, which is perfectly legal tender here. And then the dealer's like, this isn't a real ID and maybe your real ID isn't due for four more years or you're not due to renew. And so now they're like, you need to go home and get your birth certificate or your passport to complete this. And they're concerned that in the act of you need this one more thing, that people will just walk away.
Tom Appel
Well, they will. There's a fact in the auto industry and when I sold cars, this was very, very real to me. If someone leaves, there's a 75% chance they're not coming back. And that's because they're going to find a better deal someplace else or they were embarrassed by being forced to find more ID and want to go someplace else. Whatever it is. Dealers are going to lose some people, but they may gain some people in the flip flop. But it's still a very awkward situation and it seems designed mostly to harass, frankly.
Jill Simonello
Now, okay, this is me raising my hand. I think that is a little bit of a political statement. And I mean, I understand the rationale for this. And by the way, everybody should go get their real id. You should just do that because it makes going through an airport so much easier.
Tom Appel
If you go through an airport fair,
Jill Simonello
you know, but you never know.
Tom Appel
Actually a surprisingly small population of Americans actually go through the airport on a regular basis.
Jill Simonello
But okay, so you have a relative who lives in Ohio and you live in California and you need to go to their funeral or something and last minute you're going to have to travel. It's so much easier if you just have that real ID in hand.
Tom Appel
You're right. People should have it. People don't. And they're not.
Jill Simonello
No, no, they don't. My husband doesn't have a real ID yet.
Tom Appel
I don't yet either. So I've been slow to move.
Jill Simonello
I got my real ID with my license Expired this year. I was like, let's just, let's just make that happen.
Tom Appel
Yeah. My license isn't up till 2028, so I probably need to do something before then.
Jill Simonello
I mean, you have a passport someplace. Is it valid?
Tom Appel
I don't know.
Jill Simonello
So you're. You're the problem.
Tom Appel
Yeah, I am the problem. All right, enough of that topic. We'll follow up on this if it turns out it does have some impact on sales in Texas.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
Because part of what can happen too is, is that people might just borrow cars, register them with a family member, something like that. So ultimately this may not have any impact at all.
Jill Simonello
Right.
Tom Appel
It's just going to. Basically it's just some force people to jump through additional hoops.
Jill Simonello
Yeah. It's just something for us to talk about.
Tom Appel
It seemed than that overly political about. I didn't get overly political. Lord knows I didn't. I just finished my review, it's not published yet. Of the 2026 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid Limited. I want to make one point about this. You and I have driven a number of $60,000 non luxury SUVs. Non luxury brand SUVs. They've all been fine. But they're $60,000.
Jill Simonello
Correct.
Tom Appel
This fully loaded, top of the line Sonata in Hybrid trim.40. And you can do one for less. I'm just saying there is an answer to the affordability issue and it's to
Jill Simonello
buy less car, it's to not get an suv.
Tom Appel
Yeah. Seriously, step down from an suv. Consider a car again. You can get a Civic, a Corolla, a K4 Kia, K4, the K4 hatchback.
Jill Simonello
Phenomenal.
Tom Appel
These are nice vehicles. They cost less.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
You do not need to finance a vehicle for seven years. That's more car than you need. But people do that. And going way back, I don't know if you remember. Keep America Rolling. It was a General Motors program that was launched right after 9, 11. And basically it was. We are financing your car for I think five years. So just free financing, five years. And it worked. General Motors sold a lot of vehicles afterwards. Here's what happened. Nobody, nobody bought a cheaper car. They, they all stepped up to more expensive cars because this was cheaper. Like, like this helped them save money. And that's the way we work here. Like, we get as much as we can get because we want all the things and, and we like all the things. We do like all the things, but we may not need all the things. And so part of the affordability issue I think is, is homegrown. I think people are Buying more car than they need to. The other part is that cars are damn expensive and interest rates are pretty high.
Jill Simonello
Yeah, but.
Tom Appel
But anyway. But anyway. Was that political?
Jill Simonello
Ish.
Tom Appel
Ish. Okay, more social commentary.
Jill Simonello
Yes.
Tom Appel
You. Yes, you, Jill.
Jill Simonello
Yes.
Tom Appel
Just drove the Audi Q3.
Jill Simonello
Yes.
Tom Appel
Which is redesigned for 20, 26.
Jill Simonello
Yes.
Tom Appel
Okay, tell. So tell us what that is because I think people think the Q3 is compact.
Jill Simonello
It is.
Tom Appel
It's smaller than compact because it's kind of subcompact. Q5 is kind of considered compact on the Q7. Really? Considered mid size.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
All these things play a number lower than like they do at BMW or Mercedes.
Jill Simonello
Right. Well, I mean, so I mean if you're looking at BMW, like the competitive vehicle would be the X1. Yes, so I wrote that down. You wrote that down. So, you know, next gen vehicle they've made in addition to styling changes which happens when you have a next gen vehicle, they did a lot of tech upgrades which I thought was interesting for their entry into the SUV line for them. And so they are launching the new user interface for their Audi MMI multimedia interface with larger icons and a different design. You know, they have quicker processing speeds. They launched and this is going to be a little bit controversial. I just posted a TikTok on this and I haven't had the chance to look at the comments yet, but they have a new gear selector and it's controversial. Yes, because it's interesting. So Audi's gear selector used to be on the console and they now have this unit that goes over the steering wheel and it's kind of like a single unit.
Tom Appel
And then Jill is gesturing with her hands.
Jill Simonello
Yes.
Tom Appel
Okay, go ahead.
Jill Simonello
Yeah, well, I'm like hoping that it will help me describe it because it's really hard to describe. It almost looks like, you know, way back in the day, like I've only seen pictures of this, but like a yoke that they used to put on an ox that was going to be pulling like things. It's kind of, it's shaped like that. At any rate, I'm not up to date on yokes. Okay, you're not up to date on yokes. Got it. Okay. So at any rate, it's this thing that goes over the steering column and has two wands out to the side and on the right side is going to be your gear shift and it's not. You don't move the wand itself. There's like a little square on the end of the wand that is actually the gear selector.
Tom Appel
Well, that sounds like Hyundai, Kia, ev
Jill Simonello
no, that's a twister that you twist. This is an up or down square, like a disc almost. And then on the other side you have your turn indicator, which is a similar like, disc that's coming off of the wand that you don't obviously turn. You flip. And you would think that this is horrible, but it actually works really well in practice.
Tom Appel
Do you end up using your thumb?
Jill Simonello
No, I think I've used my finger. And you don't need to take your hand.
Tom Appel
I guess if it was thumb, I'd be inboard a little bit.
Jill Simonello
Yeah, you don't really need to take your hand off to select it.
Tom Appel
My thumb's on the wrong side, so I might use my thumb.
Jill Simonello
You might. You might. Your hand is kind of reversed. But at any rate, so I just want to rest assured everybody that like the gear selector, even though it looks a little bit weird, is not. Once you get behind the wheel and you use it, it works really.
Tom Appel
Not to cut you off.
Jill Simonello
Yep.
Tom Appel
But I am.
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
Everyone's going with new gear selectors now. Like the Hyundai Kia does it. It's actually really great. And that's a little twisty thing that comes off of the stock. But I think the Silverado and the Sierra, the new big pickups, are going to a column twister. Little thing.
Jill Simonello
Yeah, well, they had like the push button thing on.
Tom Appel
The part of the reason is everyone wants the console space for other stuff.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
And you know what drove that? Phone chargers. Yeah, phone chargers take up a lot of space. So everything has to migrate somewhere.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
Because you have a limited amount of real estate. But anyway, I cut you off.
Jill Simonello
Yeah, but no, I mean, I just wanted to say outside of that, I think there's a huge improvement in interior materials. Like I. The last time I drove an Audi Q3, I just remember thinking it was really not nice. Really, it wasn't worth the money. That it was just kind of like plasticky and really didn't feel good to me. But driving this 20, 26 model and they've gone to a single trim and you just add like tech packages, driver convenience packages, that kind of stuff to it. Really high end, really well done materials.
Tom Appel
Did Audi bitch about the tariffs?
Jill Simonello
No.
Tom Appel
Okay. Because they have in the press.
Jill Simonello
Yeah. No, they did not.
Tom Appel
Part of the reason that this is a single trim level with just a couple of packages is to simplify the lineup because they tended to sell fewer because they had to raise the price. And indeed, for a subcompact crossover, I have the price here someplace.
Jill Simonello
I want to say the base Price is right around $45,000 at destination. And then if you go all in with all the packaging, you're still, you're only looking at $52,000. So that I want to say is less than if you add all the things to the X1 or, you know, the Mercedes version.
Tom Appel
Here's the thing about the BMW X1. I'm mumbling already. The X1 is a delight to drive. I just wanted to throw that out there. I haven't driven a Q1 in a long time, but I always liked Audis.
Jill Simonello
The Q3 is now a delight to drive. I mean, it's always been delightful. It certainly has more of a firm, sporty ride to it. But I, I thought it was delightful in terms of ride and handling. I thought it was delightful in terms of the overall design. I thought it was delightful in terms of the interior materials, the user experience. I liked pretty much everything about it. I mean, there's always a couple of little quirky things that it's just like, why wouldn't you put latches in the cargo area to drop your rear seats down?
Tom Appel
Can't tell you.
Jill Simonello
They didn't.
Tom Appel
Don't know. Yeah, we were out of time. But real quick. Two liter turbo. It's Audi's famous tfsi. It's a nice engine. Seven speed, dual clutch. Is that smooth?
Jill Simonello
It is.
Tom Appel
Volkswagen Audi dual clutches are either really good or really nasty or terrible.
Jill Simonello
Yes.
Tom Appel
And the one that they stuck in the. Was it the Taos or the Tiguan?
Jill Simonello
I think it was the Taos.
Tom Appel
Brutal.
Jill Simonello
It was miserable.
Tom Appel
Yeah. All right. They reduced the number of trim levels. The car is built in Gior Hungary.
Jill Simonello
Yeah. And more horsepower this year too, I think 27 more horsepower.
Tom Appel
Oh, my.
Jill Simonello
So it's like the same engine? Ish. But completely reworked.
Tom Appel
All right.
Jill Simonello
Yeah. I want to say it was like 255 horsepower and maybe 273 pound feet of torque.
Tom Appel
And when does this bad boy go on sale?
Jill Simonello
I think it's already on sale.
Tom Appel
It's on sale. There you go. All right, we're going to take a break. When we come back, we're going to talk to Sean Tucker of Autotrader about buying cars during economic uncertainty. Like right now.
Jill Simonello
Like now.
Tom Appel
Yeah. We'll be right back.
Host
Questions or comments?
Producer/Announcer
Drop us a line at question carstuff@consumerguide.com
Host
that's carstuffconsumerguide.com what would you do if
Producer/Announcer
your online store converted 36% more shoppers? You could take 36% more vacation another pina colada.
Jill Simonello
Yes, please.
Producer/Announcer
Open a new retail location with 36% more square feet.
Tom Appel
Fantastic.
Producer/Announcer
Hire 36% more help.
Tom Appel
You're hired and you're hired.
Producer/Announcer
Shopify has the world's best converting checkout up to 36% better than other e commerce platforms. What you do with those extra sales is up to you. Switch to Shopify today@shopify.com listen and get a $1 trial. Shopify.com listen it's time to refresh your
Home Depot Announcer
yard during Spring Backyard Days at the Home Depot. Get low prices guaranteed on propane grills starting at $179 like the next grill 3 burner gas grill. Or get $50 off a select Weber stick Spirit grill. And bring big flavor to your backyard. Then set the scene with Hampton Bay string lights that bring it all together. Shop Spring backyard days for seven days at the Home Depot. Now through May 6th. Exquisite. Apply seehomedepot.com Pricematch for details.
Dish Network Announcer
For 45 years, Dish has been connecting America with the best in family, TV, entertainment and advanced technology at an unbeatable value. And that commitment continues with our new 45th anniversary special offer. Get the lowest price in satellite TV starting as low as $89.99 a month. In a world of rising costs and hidden fees, Dish stays transparent, reliable and honest, just like our founders intended. Learn more by calling 888-add-D dish or visit dish.com terms and conditions apply.
Capella University Announcer
There's a fire inside you you can't ignore. Stand still. Not a chance. You're a lifelong learner who's come this way far. Now we are here to help you keep going further. Capella University. What can't you do? Visit capella.edu to learn more.
Host
Welcome back to the Car Stuff Podcast.
Tom Appel
And we're back. This is the consumer guide Car Stuff Podcast. I'm Tom Shi is Jill in our slightly political show.
Jill Simonello
Yes. And this is a moment where I literally wanted video during the break. Coming into this segment, there was like some zzz zippy music and Tom was actually dancing.
Tom Appel
How do you know? Talkstone got new zippy boppy hipster music.
Jill Simonello
Yeah, a little zippy bumper there.
Tom Appel
Yeah, I'm too old for that music.
Jill Simonello
I don't know. You were. You were popping your head.
Tom Appel
Yeah, I got into the groove.
Jill Simonello
And you know what? Even though you're old, you've got social media, right? How'd you like that transition?
Tom Appel
I have several social media. Yeah. Real quick. You could just check me out. Car guy Tom on Twitter X or Blue sky or if you want to just Follow my completely non automotive stuff
Jill Simonello
about pictures of cars on TV shows.
Tom Appel
Yes. I guess that's automotive kinda. Also pictures of people on TV shows.
Jill Simonello
Yes.
Tom Appel
Like if Ave Vigoda showed up on the Night Stalker, I might get a picture of that.
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
You have an Avagoda T shirt.
Jill Simonello
I do.
Tom Appel
That you've never worn a second time.
Jill Simonello
I probably will not.
Tom Appel
I spent hard earned money on that T shirt. You should wear it or camp in was over. It was big.
Jill Simonello
It was, it was like husband sized.
Tom Appel
One of the things that we often talk about doing that we never do is talk about car buying tips.
Jill Simonello
Yes.
Tom Appel
And these are certainly strange times, so it'd be a good time to talk about car.
Jill Simonello
Yes.
Tom Appel
About. No. Luckily for us on the phone is Sean Tucker. He is the managing editor at Autotrader. Sean, how are you?
Sean Tucker
Pretty good, Tom and Jill, good to be with you. How are you?
Tom Appel
I think we're well.
Jill Simonello
I'm very well other than the freaky cold weather outside.
Tom Appel
Where are you at, sir?
Sean Tucker
I'm in Washington D.C. so all I've got outside right now is thunderstorms and a possible tornado.
Tom Appel
Oh. Oh, okay. Well, that's, that's fine then. Tell us a little bit about what you do at Autotrader.
Sean Tucker
I'm the managing editor of both the Autotrader and the Kelley Blue Book brand. So I lead a team of, you know, video and written experts who talk about cars all day.
Tom Appel
That would make you, I think, the perfect person for the conversation we're about to have. But before this conversation, we invited you on to talk a little bit about smart car buying tips during economic uncertainty. That certainly describes the world we live in now. And we do know that, that most pundits out there are suggesting that auto sales are going to fall slightly this year.
Sean Tucker
It does seem likely.
Tom Appel
Yeah. Yeah. What's your take on that?
Sean Tucker
You know, even before we were dealing with high gas prices into war, there was just enough economic uncertainty going on that I think we are somewhat likely to see a drop this year. But on top of that, you have to add in that cars have grown far more reliable than they used to be. The average car on American roads is almost 13 years old now. So people just don't car shop as much as they used to.
Tom Appel
Part of the problem, which isn't a problem at all, is that cars actually last longer than they used to.
Jill Simonello
Right.
Tom Appel
So I think consumers are served well by improved reliability. But on the other hand, things change very quickly and they might feel left out of the game. But buying cars has gotten to be Kind of a strange process. It's, it's no longer as difficult. One of the things I learned just shopping for a car with my daughter is that the old, the old battle with the dealer seems to have subsided a little bit. But that doesn't change the fact that prices are extremely high. And I've heard some numbers lately about how upside down the average shopper is.
Sean Tucker
Yeah. And those prices, I. There's a certain element of consumer choice playing into that. The average buyer February paid $49,353, which sounds like an extraordinarily high number. But if we take full size trucks out of that, it's more than $10,000 lower. That was pushed up quite a bit by the fact that the average full size truck is selling for $66,157. And as you know, most of those have options in the low $40,000 range. That's just consumer choice.
Tom Appel
66,000. Well, that's a, that's a wonderful point. And Jill and I were just talking about that, that people are in fact choosing to buy these cars as expensive as they are. And I made the point that I had just Test driven the 2026 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid Limited. And then that vehicle came to almost exactly $40,000. And it would serve most families very, very well for 20 grand less, 10 grand less than something else that they might buy. And one of the things we've also noticed that crossovers, mid sized crossovers have gotten phenomenally expensive.
Sean Tucker
Phenomenally expensive and very, very big. Not to jump the gun into where I think you're going next, but as your experience with that and that hybrid might have taught you, one of the things we're seeing is that, that cars have grown so much larger than they used to be that the average buyer would probably be quite satisfied with a compact SUV now. And they're not necessarily aware of that. They're still going for mid size models that are as large as the large SUVs of a decade ago.
Tom Appel
I do remember a story, and this is completely off topic. Jill is used to me doing this,
Jill Simonello
and so I apologize in advance, but
Tom Appel
I remember a story maybe 15, 20 years ago, but I bet you this is still true, is that people who were shopping for an Accord would go to buy an Accord and leave with a crv. And the number was fantastically high. It was like half the time or something like that. And I think that a lot of shoppers are finding that crossovers, for whatever reason, the magic is there that holds more stuff. You can get all wheel Drive. And the seating position is. Is more. Is preferable in traffic because every other vehicle is a crossover now.
Sean Tucker
Right?
Jill Simonello
Right.
Sean Tucker
We're kind of in a constant height war where if you want to see over the guy in front of you, you need a taller car than him. And I don't know when that ends.
Tom Appel
We do. So what do you recommend consumers do now? Is this a good time to buy a car?
Sean Tucker
This is a relatively good time to buy a car, as strange as that may sound.
Tom Appel
It does sound strange
Sean Tucker
because those prices are high, as I said. But that's partly a matter of concern, consumer choice. There are a lot of reasonably affordable compact crossovers, compact sedans that will meet the needs of most families. And I think with sales likely to fall a bit this year, the buyer is going to be in more demand.
Tom Appel
So are we looking at any shifts during the year? Jill had noted earlier a story about the fact that EVs. Used EVs are about to. The availability is about to increase because a bunch of leases are coming in. But. But what are we waiting for this year that might affect the market? Is there any big event? Are we waiting for a big fall in interest rates that may not happen, or what is the outlook?
Sean Tucker
It's very hard to predict the interest rate situation right now. But the one thing that I have my eye on in the short term is the price of gas. We just got the numbers in this morning that demand for this is used car shopping. But demand for used SUVs dropped off quite a bit in February, and The war started February 28th. So with gas prices rising, it may be that there's far less demand for those used SUVs, and those prices may be going to come down.
Tom Appel
Wow. If you can actually make use of a used suv, then you actually need it. This might be the time to buy one of those.
Sean Tucker
Right.
Tom Appel
All right, I got it. I got a question for you, if you don't mind. I have a theory, and I think that the mark. I think that the media is kind of overblowing something. We keep hearing about the fact that hybrids are incredibly phenomenally popular right now. Everyone wants a hybrid. But my suggestion to you, and please tell me I'm wrong if I am, is that hybrids aren't that popular. It's that people aren't really choosing hybrids. They're just looking at vehicles that happen to be available as hybrids. And at Toyota, it's almost hard to not buy a Toyota. A hybrid.
Sean Tucker
Now, I was going to say, I think you're onto something. I don't have A lot of data to back it up. But I would note that in the Toyota example, they're just slowly becoming a hybrid company.
Tom Appel
Yeah.
Sean Tucker
If you go in to replace your Camry, you're buying a Camry hybrid because there is nothing else anymore. Anymore. That's also true of the Rav 4 all of a sudden. So some of their volume models, they're no longer available in anything that isn't hybrid. And I'm sure that's pumping the numbers up.
Tom Appel
And I think the Sienna and the Crown too. Hybrid only. And didn't you suggest the Sequoia?
Jill Simonello
Yeah, I can't remember if the Sequoia is hybrid only or not.
Tom Appel
I mean, that's not a huge volume thing, but still.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
All right, so we talked about this. If you're a consumer right now, what do you suggest that they do if they're, if they're thinking about buying a new car or used car?
Sean Tucker
So a couple of tips that are really evergreen, tips that make sense in all markets, but certainly in this one, my number one piece of advice to friends is buy the car you need 50 weeks a year. I see so many people say, you know, I need three rows of seating because mom and dad visit during the holidays. Well, that means you need three rows of seating during the holidays, save $15,000, buy a two row car and rent one when they show up.
Jill Simonello
Yes, It's a creepy 100%. That's, you know.
Sean Tucker
The second thing I recommend though is pay close attention to inventory. You're not going to get inventory numbers out of your local dealership, but we publish the inventory numbers by brand and car. Pricing is supply and demand and in some cases the supply is really out of whack with demand. I'm just looking here at the end of February and Lexus and Toyota. So there's an old industry rule of thumb that they aim to have about 75 days worth of cars for sale on the lot. Yeah, Lexus and Toyota right now are sitting at 38 and 41. You're not going to get a deal at Lexus and Toyota. Ford and Hyundai are at 121. They are willing to negotiate.
Tom Appel
So they've got a bunch of stuff. Where do you, where can people find your inventory numbers?
Sean Tucker
That one's available on Cox Automotive. We also publish it monthly in an article on Kelley Blue Book. Yeah,
Jill Simonello
so question for you, like, say I'm getting ready to. I know I need a new car and I'm getting ready to go and look, but I don't know if I want a new car or a used car, Would you. Do you have any, like, pros and cons of buying new versus used or buying used versus new? Like when, when should I buy new and when should I buy used?
Sean Tucker
So your grandfather's and your father's old advice of letting somebody else pay the depreciation still apply?
Jill Simonello
Right.
Sean Tucker
The reality is the market's kind of bifurcating to where there are no cars. There are no new cars left under $20,000 at all. We believe that the last one probably rolled off the lot about two months ago. There are very few under $25,000.
Tom Appel
What was that?
Sean Tucker
So the last one was likely a Nissan Versa S. Since Mitsubishi canceled the Mirage and Nissan canceled the Versa, there's nothing new for sale under $20,000 at all. Under 25 is relatively rare. So if that's your budget, you're shopping used.
Jill Simonello
So do you think it's purely a budgetary consideration or. I mean, like, I know my husband and I, we needed a new car in 24 hours and I was like, I asked my husband, I was like, how much do you want to spend? He's like $10,000. And I'm like, good luck with that. I will say we managed to find a 2017 Volkswagen Jetta for 12. So we were close. But yeah, those unicorns are very rare and don't exist.
Sean Tucker
It's primarily a budget consideration. But there's also the question of how long you're going to operate it and how long the warranty will be. If you are like me and you drive a car until it absolutely will not drive anymore, then there are good reasons to consider some new cars with very long warranties because that will save you a lot of money in year nine. And I'm still driving a car in year nine. That's not necessarily true of everyone though.
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
My wife is driving a 10 year old Subaru. So I appreciate the getting the most for your money. Which we did buy new, right? We did buy it new, but. But yeah, ultimately we're holding on to it. And she started working from home.
Jill Simonello
No hurt, right?
Tom Appel
Tell us about Cox then, because Cox is one of those things that I don't think people fully appreciate because there are so many branches and divisions of what they do. And they serve, they serve dealerships, they serve manufacturers and they serve the consumer. It's a big company.
Sean Tucker
Yeah, absolutely. We've got a, you know, a company that provides the software that operates a lot of dealerships. That's where we get some of this data. The way that I can tell you the inventory, you know, partly because we have the software that controls the inventory.
Tom Appel
You actually generate that information. Interesting.
Sean Tucker
Cox also runs Mannheim, which is the largest source of auctions. So quite a few of the used cars pass through our hands and increasingly over the last few years we're getting into battery recycling and.
Tom Appel
Interesting.
Sean Tucker
My world is. Is Kelly Blue Book an autotrader?
Tom Appel
Tell me about Manheim for just one moment. And the batteries. Jill and I had an opportunity to visit Mannheim a long time ago now.
Jill Simonello
Yeah. It's been a hot pre covered. Yeah.
Tom Appel
But we visited an auction on the south side of Chicago and the volume of vehicles that go through that. Crazy. I don't think people know. I don't think people know how many Mannheim vehicles they've owned or how many vehicles go through that process. But when we were there, there was already talk of of making dealers aware of the battery condition of EVs. Is that something that's happened?
Sean Tucker
Yes. In fact, when you look at a listing for an EV on Auto Trader these days, you will find a battery health score. O surely we've actually tested that physical battery that you're considering buying and can tell you how much life is left in it.
Tom Appel
So that's handy. And people might be shopping for EVs now. So if you're looking for an EV, if you go to. Is that Autotrader and Kelly.
Sean Tucker
No, those are on Auto Trader.
Tom Appel
Just Auto Trader. Okay. You can get the battery health indication. So that's cool. Generally are those. Are you finding that the batteries are in fact holding up nicely?
Sean Tucker
Yes, I think there was a lot of fear a few years back battery replacement would be a significant expense. And the reality is it's something we rarely ever see. So it hasn't proven to be a significant problem for the industry. Most of these batteries are in pretty good shape and right now I think Jill got into as we were beginning. There are just so many 3 year old EVs about to be rolling off lease that will be available used that used. EVs are a fantastic value this year.
Tom Appel
What is your recommendation for someone who's considering an ev? What should they think about before they commit to going electric?
Sean Tucker
You need to think about your lifestyle and how you're going to use the car. There's a common misunderstanding in that people tend to look at the infrastructure around them and say, you know, does my town have enough charging? And the reality is there's a mental shift you have to make in that you don't have a gas station at home, but you do refill your Battery at home. It's a different way of driving that you're going to refill when you get there instead of stopping in the middle. So you don't necessarily need the local infrastructure to be up to spec if you have access to home charging. However, I do caution people, the one situation in which I'm a little reluctant to get an EV is if you do a lot of road trips.
Tom Appel
Okay.
Sean Tucker
Structure, particularly here on the East Coast, YM has caught up to the point that a road trip on an ordinary day is not difficult, but a road trip on a day when everyone is driving can be quite difficult. So, you know, it's the day before Thanksgiving and you need to drive to grandma's house. A lot of those chargers that. That the charging route planning app is telling you to use are likely going to have lines.
Jill Simonello
Yeah. And I think this all feeds into something that you said a little bit earlier, is that you should buy the car that is going to work for you 50 weeks of the year.
Tom Appel
I wrote that down. Just say what you're going to say.
Jill Simonello
If you are only going to be taking a road trip once or twice a year, one, do you have a gas car to back it up and you could take that car instead? Or, you know, two, I mean, the route planners these days are so good. That will tell you, like, where the chargers are and, like, tell you if they're open as you're arriving. And so, you know, I think a lot of times people will buy a pickup truck because they're gonna haul something once a year or they're going to put plywood in the back of their car or mulch in the back of their bed once a year. And it's just like. Like buy the car for 50 weeks, not 52.
Sean Tucker
Right. You can always rent for the other two. It's so much.
Tom Appel
Do you remember either of you, when. When BMW launched the i3. It was the i3. And one of the things. This was a pioneering electric vehicle, and it was fun to drive. It was a crazy car. People might remember. Small car with weird doors. But one of the things that they were going to put together for owners was a plan by which they could rent a BMW for a couple of weeks a year. Yes, that was part of that.
Sean Tucker
I remember that Nissan did something similar with the Leaf for a few years, where I bought a new Leaf and you had the right to check out some other Nissan for. I think it was up to two weeks a year.
Tom Appel
I have a business idea for Autotrader. This is a great idea. You can have it. I'm not going to make you sign anything, but you had suggested that what you have now if you have an electric car is a gas station at home. What you need is the AutoTrader gas station kit, which you put in your garage and is filled with Funyuns and Slim Jims. Right.
Jill Simonello
Self refilling.
Tom Appel
Yeah. Maybe Gatorade. Yeah. Someone comes by once a month and tops you off.
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
All right. Just an idea. Just an idea. You don't have to. You don't have to tell me now.
Jill Simonello
I think that's enough.
Sean Tucker
I'll pitch it to the CEO. My hopes are not high.
Jill Simonello
Yeah, I'm sure the CEO is listening to this and he'll be like, yes, that's a great idea.
Tom Appel
Oh, man. Sean. How can people find out more about AutoTrader? Go to autotrader.com Sean, thank you so much for your time today. We really appreciate it.
Sean Tucker
Thanks, guys. I really enjoyed this.
Tom Appel
All right, that was Sean Tucker with AutoTrader. We're going to take a break and when we come back.
Jill Simonello
Quiz time.
Tom Appel
Quiz time.
Host
Questions or comments?
Producer/Announcer
Drop us a line@car stuffonsumerguide.com that's car
Host
stuff at Consumer Guide.
Producer/Announcer
What would you do if your online store converted 36% more shoppers? You could take 36% more vacation.
Tom Appel
Another pina colada.
Jill Simonello
Yes, please.
Producer/Announcer
Open a new retail location with 36% more square feet.
Tom Appel
Fantastic.
Producer/Announcer
Hire 36% more help.
Tom Appel
You're hired and you're hired.
Producer/Announcer
Shopify has the world's best converting checkout up to 36% better than other e commerce platforms. What you do with those extra sales is up to you. Switch to Shopify today@shopify.com listen and get a $1 trial. Shopify.com listen now is the time to
Home Depot Announcer
shop for upgrades that transform your yard during Spring Backyard Days at the Home Depot. Turn an empty corner into a hangout with the Hampton Bay Brook Mill four piece patio scent. Then brighten your garden with lilacs or begonias and help them thrive with big row potting soil. It's the finished touches that really bring your space together with low prices. Guaranteed. Shop Spring backyard days for seven days at the Home Depot. Now through May 6th. Exquisite supplies at home depot.com pricematch for details.
Dish Network Announcer
For 45 years, Dish has been connecting America with the best in family, TV, entertainment and advanced technology at an unbeatable value. And that commitment continues with our new 45th anniversary special offer. Get the lowest price in satellite TV starting as low as $89.99 a month. In a world of rising costs and hidden fees, Dish stays transparent, reliable, and honest, just like our founders intended. Learn more by calling 888-add-D dish or visit dish.com terms and conditions apply.
Capella University Announcer
You've never been one to settle, stand down or stand still. You're a lifelong learner, energized by excellence. There's a fire inside you you can't ignore. You've got competition to outrun, momentum to build on, and your own high standards to meet. Stop now. Not a chance. At Capella University, we help you catch what you're chasing, because you've always had the drive. Now go earn the degree. Capella University. What can't you do? Visit capella.edu to learn more.
Host
Welcome back to the Car Stuff podcast.
Tom Appel
And we're back. This is the consumer guide Car Stuff Podcast. I am Tom. She is Jill. This is episode 318. Is there any Feng Shui there?
Jill Simonello
Well, 18 is a lucky number in the Jewish faith.
Tom Appel
I knew that.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
I don't know why I knew that, but I knew that.
Jill Simonello
My. My accent is going to be horrible, but I think it's high.
Tom Appel
Isn't there a name for. For a Hebrew. Hebrew numerologist?
Jill Simonello
I don't know.
Tom Appel
There's. There's some. There's something to that, which I don't think is very steeped deeply in the actual Judaic faith. I think it's something kind of ancillary and weird.
Jill Simonello
I just know that all of my Jewish friends, whenever they donate money to whatever charity I'm raising money for, it's usually in multiples of 18.
Tom Appel
Really?
Jill Simonello
Yep.
Tom Appel
Really? That's crazy. All right, social media.
Jill Simonello
Yes, I'm on it.
Tom Appel
All right.
Jill Simonello
I'm on TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn threads, Blue Sky, YouTube, all the things you can find me at. Jill Simonello. Or, you know, Blue sky does that. Weird. Like, Jill Simonello. Bs Ky. Whatever. So. But Jill Simonello, and I use the hashtag Karta Jour. So if you can't find me with my name, which is, you know, kind of hard to spell, you can usually find me by cartesur.
Tom Appel
Speaking of things Jewish. Okay, tomorrow.
Jill Simonello
Yes.
Tom Appel
I have to go drive past my old office, which takes me to Skokie, Illinois.
Jill Simonello
Yep.
Tom Appel
I don't. People outside of Illinois might know this, not know this, but lots and lots of Jewish people in Skokie, Illinois.
Jill Simonello
There are.
Tom Appel
And because of that, Kaufman's Deli.
Jill Simonello
I was gonna say really good delis.
Tom Appel
I'm going to Kaufman's Deli tomorrow.
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
I need Egg salad. I need challah. I need coleslaw and dill pickles.
Jill Simonello
Oh, oh, okay.
Tom Appel
So they sell them in two barrels. One is like new and old. And it's basically how long they've been.
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
They've been decanting.
Jill Simonello
Decanting.
Tom Appel
That's the wrong word.
Jill Simonello
Fermenting.
Tom Appel
All right. Did you get through the social media?
Jill Simonello
I did.
Tom Appel
I wasn't paying attention.
Jill Simonello
I feel like I was pretty time efficient there.
Tom Appel
You were, you were. And we actually have enough time today. I have some really good news about the quiz today. The bonus question is an extension of last week's bonus question.
Jill Simonello
Great.
Tom Appel
So I think you'll enjoy that. We talked about the Nancy Drew mysteries last week.
Jill Simonello
Yes.
Tom Appel
So we're going to expand on that this week. People are going to do that. But the quiz. Oh, 318 was a BMW.
Jill Simonello
Got it.
Tom Appel
And it was one of the early BMWs. When people talk about yuppies buying BMWs in, in the 80s, the 318.
Jill Simonello
Got it.
Tom Appel
And later the 320. 325. 328, but got it. Yeah.
Jill Simonello
I'm taking a bite of my. I'm an orange cranberry scone right now.
Tom Appel
You have issues with the donuts again?
Jill Simonello
Well, I mean, I'm never gonna do the German chocolate thing. And then, wow, I know that's racist. I'm not gonna do. I'm not gonna do that. And then you had this scone looking thing that's covered. It's like, you know, it's not horrible. It's not horrible. So I took a bite of that cranberry and orange with like some white chocolate in it.
Tom Appel
That's not a review you want of a donut. It's not horrible. But then, you know how many women said that after a first date with me?
Jill Simonello
La la la la la. I'm raising my hand again. That's too political. And then the other, the other, the other donut is magically delicious.
Tom Appel
That is possibly the most cynically cheap thing a donut shop can do for St. Patrick's Day, which is literally to pour lucky charms on a donut.
Jill Simonello
Yeah. They put icing on top and then just dipped it in lucky charms.
Tom Appel
Here's the thing about it.
Jill Simonello
And put some like, shamrock sprinkles on there.
Tom Appel
And it looks good.
Jill Simonello
It is all yours.
Tom Appel
It looks good. Well, no. Well, producer Randy picks before I do. That's a rule.
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
All right. And that's fine because I love German chocolate.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
All right. It's quiz time.
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
Do you remember when we Had a lot of time.
Jill Simonello
We still have a lot of time.
Tom Appel
Not really.
Jill Simonello
I'm looking at your watch upside down. We've got like 10 minutes. Plenty of time.
Tom Appel
All right. Are you ready?
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
Consumer guide, Car stuff. Podcast power quiz. 318. $100,000. Question mark. Okay, I forgot the. No, it's not $100,000. It's 100,000 units. I'm going to give you a car. You have to tell me if they sold more than a hundred thousand of those bad boys in 2025. Are you ready? The Hyundai Elantra. Hyundai's likable compact car. Good looking and one of those cars that you can buy instead of a crossover.
Jill Simonello
That is true. I'm gonna say no,
Tom Appel
actually. Yes, by a lot. 148,200. Wow. Secretly a hot seller.
Jill Simonello
Wow.
Tom Appel
That's a good car. It deserves it.
Jill Simonello
It is. It is a good car.
Tom Appel
All right. You have no points. BMW x5. BMW's very nice mid sized crossover.
Jill Simonello
I'm gonna say yes.
Tom Appel
No.
Jill Simonello
Oh, gosh.
Tom Appel
76. 246.
Jill Simonello
I'm off to a bang up start.
Tom Appel
But that's an awful lot of these things because they probably. The average retail price is about 80 grand on those.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
All right. You have no points.
Jill Simonello
I'm in trouble.
Tom Appel
Here's one. The Jeep Compass. No, that is Jeep's compact crossover and really the only affordable crossover in their lineup at the moment. Yeah, we have the Cherokee coming. You and I are going to go see the Cherokee next week.
Jill Simonello
We are. I'm in town.
Tom Appel
They're bringing it to the local journalists here in Chicago. We're going to get a walk around. We're not going to drive it. No, but we get to see it.
Jill Simonello
We get to see it also.
Tom Appel
We probably get like free pasta
Jill Simonello
there. There will be some form of free lunch involved.
Tom Appel
Yeah.
Jill Simonello
I'm thinking it's probably going to be like sandwiches.
Tom Appel
Journalists just, just come together over free food.
Jill Simonello
I know.
Producer/Announcer
Free food.
Tom Appel
We're all journalists. We haven't seen for nine years will be there because. Free food.
Jill Simonello
Free food.
Tom Appel
All right. What did you say about the compass? Yes. Yeah. 101,997. That surprised me. Of the ones on here. I didn't know the Compass was selling that well, so. But it does have a very nice interior now. And it's pretty quick. All right. You need to, you need to win out. You need to clean up here.
Jill Simonello
I know. I, I'm, I'm. Signs point to know the Magic 8 Ball is saying this is not my week.
Tom Appel
All right. The Subaru Cross truck. My wife owns a Crosstrek, the most affordable Subaru crossover.
Jill Simonello
I really like the Subaru Crosstrek. I just don't think.
Tom Appel
When do you think Subaru will kill the impression?
Jill Simonello
Soon.
Tom Appel
Yeah. All right. Sorry I cut you off again, Kim.
Jill Simonello
Like soon. I just. I don't know. I don't know there's a volume like that much of a volume seller. Let's see if I can go for 0 for 6. I'm gonna say no.
Tom Appel
Yes. By a lot. 191,724. They move a lot of those bad boys. Subaru may have a bunch of different models, but it is the Crosstrek, it is the Outback, and it is the Forester that do all their volume. And those are all great vehicles.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
All right. You can't win anymore, but you can try to save face. The Honda Passport.
Jill Simonello
There is no face to be saved. Yes.
Tom Appel
No. This is a model. This is a model in a slump because it used to be one of the best selling good size crossovers. Just 55, 231 last year. So I don't know what the deal is there.
Jill Simonello
That's hard.
Tom Appel
But everyone's been. I mean, you know what part of the problem is the Koreans. I mean, they have two vehicles in, in the mid sized category. Both of them. Right. You've got Palisade and Tucson and then Telluride. And what is the Sorrento? Sorrento. Thank you. It's kind of a one, two punch bunch. And they're all good vehicles. And there's hybrids there now.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
In all of them.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
Alrighty, bonus question. Are you ready?
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
We talked about Nancy Drew. Today we're going to talk about the Hardy Boys. Hardy Boys. The Hardy Boys novels go back to 1927.
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
They wrapped up the original season in Series in 2005, but there's been a bunch of subsequent things that have come out. So there's still plenty of Hardy Boys to be had. I'm going to give you four book titles. You have to to tell me which one is real.
Jill Simonello
Real. Okay.
Tom Appel
Are you ready?
Jill Simonello
Ready.
Tom Appel
All righty. The Case of the Shapely Librarian. The Tuna that Would Not Swim. The Empty Q Tip Box. Or the Tower Treasure.
Jill Simonello
And I'm assuming the last two are the case of because you didn't put the case of in front of that.
Tom Appel
Strangely, strangely, the Hardy Boys aren't named that as consistently as the Nancy Drews.
Jill Simonello
Interesting.
Tom Appel
It's the case of or the clue of for almost all of the Nancy Drews. Not the case with the Hardy Boys.
Jill Simonello
I wouldn't know if you're telling me a bald faced lie because what I
Tom Appel
just said is true in the context of the quiz. I would not lie about the question.
Jill Simonello
Yeah, you would.
Tom Appel
No, I wouldn't. Okay, so the case of the Shapely Librarian.
Jill Simonello
I'm gonna say no.
Tom Appel
The Tuna that would not Swim, the Empty Q Tip box or the Tower Treasure.
Jill Simonello
And I have to tell you which one is real.
Tom Appel
Yep,
Jill Simonello
I'm gonna say the Tower Treasure.
Tom Appel
It is. Yep. You got a point. As a kid I would totally have read the Shapely Librarian.
Jill Simonello
No joke.
Tom Appel
Sadly, these weren't illustrated. Actually. I think there was like a line drawing in the middle someplace.
Jill Simonello
You don't know what shape the librarian was though. It could have been a square.
Tom Appel
Well, shapely suggests a certain positivity.
Jill Simonello
Does it?
Tom Appel
Yeah. Yeah. I don't know that I would describe a librarian as shapely if I didn't mean it, you know, as a compliment.
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
Mercedes Benz is bringing out a van. Did you see this?
Jill Simonello
I did not.
Tom Appel
Yep. Why didn't I write down the name of it? I believe it's the. I believe it's the Vel. Anyway, it's an electric van. It's coming in a couple of years.
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
It's going to be a premium thing, going to be used for maybe hotels, they are going to make a passenger version of it. So you could buy it as the America's most expensive minivan. Do you remember the Mercedes Benz R Class?
Jill Simonello
Yes.
Tom Appel
That was a really interesting vehicle because it was a crossover ish with sliding rear doors. It did. Did it have sliding doors? It did, yeah. And they advertise this as having the room of an S class up front, the room of the midsize E class in the second row and the room of the compact C class in the third row. And sure enough, I could get into the third row pretty easy and be comfortable back there. Even me.
Jill Simonello
That was like 20 years ago.
Tom Appel
It was a while ago. 15 years ago. But they're giving it another shot. No one understood what the R class was. It didn't sell well. They did do an AMG version of it, which I thought was the coolest thing in the world. But another shot, they're going to go with this. This van. It's going to be electric only.
Jill Simonello
Okay.
Tom Appel
All right.
Jill Simonello
So a piece of news we did not discuss at the beginning. It just jogged my memory when we were talking about SUVs.
Tom Appel
I can't talk about news that isn't in my notes.
Jill Simonello
Too bad.
Tom Appel
So four minutes of silence.
Jill Simonello
Okay. Four minutes of silence. The Hyundai Palisade recalled this week.
Tom Appel
Talk about that. Yeah, I'm sorry, I really should have covered that first.
Jill Simonello
Yeah, no, like I completely spaced. And then when you mentioned it, I was like, we just, we should probably mention that recall. So essentially it is being recalled because the second row seats are, they're power operated and they don't stop even if somebody is in it. And it resulted in the death of a child.
Tom Appel
Yeah. That is tragic. And we're so used to these things working.
Jill Simonello
Yes.
Tom Appel
That it is stunning and awful when they don't work. That this actually happened because there are so many things now on cars. Like if you stuck your hand in a window as it was rolling up, it would just bounce back.
Jill Simonello
Unless it's a Tesla.
Tom Appel
And I don't know how many times I've actually bumped my head on the, the rear hatch of a crossover or minivan and it just bounces off.
Jill Simonello
I've, I've had some that haven't, like, because I'm short and so what I'll try to do is pull it down so that I can reset the height and then it just keeps going and I'm like, no, no, no. And I'm like trying like Atlas Shrugged as I'm trying to like hold the thing up so that I can set it. So I've had some, I've had some missteps.
Tom Appel
It used to be in General Motors. It used to be a little bit knob in the door pocket on the driver's side that you could adjust the
Jill Simonello
height to like half, three quarters. Yeah.
Tom Appel
But this recall, this is two vehicles. Right. So it's the, the Palisade and the Telluride.
Jill Simonello
No, because the Telluride. I think it's the new Palisade.
Tom Appel
Just the new Palisade because the new
Jill Simonello
Telluride isn't out yet. 2027. I don't think it's. So I, if, if it would apply to the Telluride. I've only heard it applied.
Tom Appel
Okay.
Jill Simonello
It would. Well, it would be the 2027 model, which, I mean is on sale, but I, I don't think that. Actually, you know what? I don't think the Tellur. I haven't driven the Telluride. I don't think it has power operated seats.
Tom Appel
You're right. So it's not on sale yet. So not an issue. But yeah, a child was hurt, killed.
Jill Simonello
Yes.
Tom Appel
So this is brutal.
Jill Simonello
So if you own a new Palisade, be sure to, to look up that recall information, please.
Tom Appel
Get that done immediately. I don't think they have a fix yet.
Jill Simonello
No. I don't know.
Tom Appel
The way these things work, it's really interesting. We're made aware of the recall as soon as they decided to recall. But then there's a period of time, sometimes it seems very long, a month, six weeks before people get notifications. But they have to find a fix. They know there's a problem and they have to let people know about it right away. But it can be a while before they develop a fix. And if it's a software fix like that. Right. You go to your dealer and have it fix. Or if you have OTA updates, if your car accepts those, it just happens in your driveway automatically. But yeah, this one's a big deal.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
So. All right, what else you got going on?
Jill Simonello
You know, just something cool that I'm going to be doing later this week that I'm not sure I can talk about yet. So yeah, I. Lots of cool things on tap.
Tom Appel
And does that involve fruit juice, electrolysis donuts?
Jill Simonello
Cars. It involves cars.
Tom Appel
Oh, okay. It's a car thing.
Jill Simonello
It's a car thing.
Tom Appel
Guess what I got delivered today.
Jill Simonello
What did you get today?
Tom Appel
The Lexus LS500 Sport. Okay, this is the end of the line. It's actually a 2025 model. But the Lexus LS the single most important Lexus ever built. It's no longer very important because Lexus has moved on. But back when they were sitting there scaring the crap out of the Germans back in 1989, this car mattered.
Jill Simonello
Right.
Tom Appel
It came in 15 grand cheaper than the Mercedes Benz S class, with more power, possibly better build quality. I think that, I don't think people question anymore, but it was absolutely a game changer. Mercedes Benz products are cheaper now because of Lexus.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
So this car is going away. I've got one of the last ones. It's really a pretty cool car. But people do not want large luxury sedans. They do not ever for any reason. They just don't buy them.
Jill Simonello
But as we discussed at the beginning, maybe that's your better cost alternative for an suv. I don't know.
Tom Appel
I don't, I don't.
Jill Simonello
Not the large luxury sedan.
Tom Appel
The $95,000 sedan might not be your best option.
Jill Simonello
I don't know.
Tom Appel
Also Lexus still sells the es. Yes, the front drive Camry based vehicle. It is so roomy and so refined and so quiet.
Jill Simonello
Well, and I've started to see some 60 grand content coming out from the new ES that's going to be launched and I'm hearing Electric.
Tom Appel
Interesting. I was not 100% convinced there would be a new ES.
Jill Simonello
Yeah.
Tom Appel
But anyway, we are out of time.
Jill Simonello
Yeah. So more on that next week.
Tom Appel
All right. Big thanks to Sean Tucker of Autotrader. Thank you, Jill. Thank you to producer Randy and the good folks here at talkzone. Let's talk more about cars again next week. Next week.
Producer/Announcer
Remember to check us out@consumerguide.com the car
Host
stuff podcast is produced by J Turn Media.
Producer/Announcer
To advertise on the show, please drop us a line at car stuff@consumerguide.com.
Home Depot Announcer
It's time to refresh your yard during Spring Backyard Days at the Home Depot. Get low prices guaranteed on propane grills starting at $179 like the next three burner gas grill. Or get $50 off a select Weber Spirit Grill and bring big flavor to your backyard. Then set the scene with Hampton Bay string lights that bring it all together. Shop Spring backyard days for seven days at the Home Depot now through May 6th. Exclusions applies to home depot.com pricematch for details.
Dish Network Announcer
For 45 years, Dish has been connecting America with the best in family, tv, entertainment and advanced technology at an unbeatable value. And that commitment continues with our new 45th anniversary special offer. Get the lowest price in satellite TV starting as low as $89.99 a month. In a world of rising costs and hidden fees, DISH stays transparent, reliable and honest, just like our founders intended. Learn more by calling 888-add-D dish or visit dish.com terms and conditions apply.
Capella University Announcer
You've never been one to settle, stand down or stand still. You're a lifelong learner, energized by excellence. There's a fire inside you you can't ignore. You've got competition to outrun, momentum to build on, and your own high standards to meet. Stop now. Not a chance. At Capella University, we help you catch what you're chasing because you've always had the drive. Now go earn the degree. Capella University. What can't you do? Visit capella.edu to learn.
Ryan Reynolds (Mint Mobile Announcer)
Learn more Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. I don't know if you knew this, but anyone can get the same Premium Wireless for 15amonth plan that I've been enjoying. It's not just for celebrities. So do like I did and have one of your assistant's assistants switch you to Mint Mobile today. I'm told it's super easy to do@mintmobile.com
Producer/Announcer
Switch upfront payment of $45 for 3 month plan equivalent to 15 per month Required intro rate first 3 months only,
Jill Simonello
then full price plan options available, taxes
Producer/Announcer
and fees, extra fee, full terms@mintmobile.com if
Host
you like the show, please take a
Tom Appel
moment to rate, review and subscribe.
Dish Network Announcer
It really does help the show to grow.
Tom Appel
Thank you for listening.
Episode: Honda Drops 2 Models, Audi Q3 Review, Buying a Car in Uncertain Times
Hosts: Tom Appel & Jill Ciminillo (Consumer Guide Automotive)
Guest: Sean Tucker, Managing Editor at Autotrader
Release Date: March 16, 2026
This episode dives into notable shake-ups in the automotive world, including Honda’s withdrawal of two key models and discontinuation rumors, and a review of the redesigned 2026 Audi Q3. The hosts dissect affordability issues in today’s car market, with strategies for buyers navigating economic uncertainty, and welcome industry expert Sean Tucker to share practical car shopping advice. The show balances auto industry news with in-depth analysis on buying new versus used, the reality of EVs in the marketplace, and memorable commentary on quirky features and trends.
(Bad News in the Industry – 05:40)
(EV Market Trends – 09:42)
(Regulatory Trends – 12:10)
(Affordability Analysis – 16:54)
(Vehicle Review – 18:57)
(27:16 – 30:05)
(30:10–34:09)
(32:51–34:09)
(33:43–34:09)
(34:15–35:18)
(35:27–36:36)
(36:45–38:34)
(39:03–41:05)
(41:12–42:19)
The hosts blend expert insight with a conversational, witty, and occasionally irreverent banter. They balance news and analysis with humor, personal anecdotes (from travel mishaps to donut critiques), and prioritize actionable guidance over hype or sensationalism.
The episode delivers a timely, lively look at how shifting economics, global trade policies, tech innovations, and consumer habits are reshaping the automotive landscape. Whether you’re car shopping now or just nerding out on cars and industry drama, Tom, Jill, and guest Sean Tucker provide the pragmatic—and often entertaining—insider’s view.