21st Precinct and The Line-Up

Summary

Podcast Summary: Case Closed! (Old Time Radio) – Episode: 21st Precinct and The Line-Up

Release Date: May 7, 2025 Host/Author: RelicRadio.com Duration: Approximately 59 minutes

---

Introduction

In this riveting episode of Case Closed!, hosted by RelicRadio.com, listeners are transported back to the golden age of crime stories, featuring gripping tales of cops, robbers, and private investigators. The episode, titled "21st Precinct and The Line-Up," delves into two intertwined cases that showcase the relentless pursuit of justice by New York City's finest.

---

1. The 21st Precinct Case

Setting the Scene

The episode opens with Captain Frank Kennelly overseeing operations at the nerve center of the 21st Precinct. As described by Kennelly at [00:27], the precinct's muster room is "the nerve center," highlighting its pivotal role in coordinating police activities across a densely populated New York City neighborhood.

The Fire Call and Subsequent Events

On October 27th, 1954, amidst heavy rainfall, a two-alarm fire erupts on Second Avenue ([01:07]). Captain Kennelly and his team, including Lieutenant Gorman and Sergeant Waters, respond promptly despite the challenging weather conditions. After managing the fire incident, Kennelly attends a scheduled safety talk at Julia Richmond High School ([05:32]).

The Parazoni Conspiracy Unfolds

During his lunch break at Philip Parazoni’s tailor shop ([03:28]), Captain Kennelly interacts with Mrs. Rose Parazoni, who indirectly reveals her involvement in a suspicious transaction. Lieutenant Gorman and Kennelly later confront Mrs. Parazoni about a mysterious package containing substantial amounts of money and policy slips ([07:24]).

Notable Quote:

• Lieutenant Gorman ([07:33]): "Look, when somebody who's worked so hard... can you blame them too much if they see an opportunity to make some money?"

The Package in Grand Central

Mrs. Parazoni explains how she and a mysterious woman named Marion became involved in hiding a large sum of money left by a racketeer ([10:06]). They decide to store the package in a locker at Grand Central Station, with the plan to split the money later ([13:12]).

Quote:

• Captain Frank Kennelly ([22:00]): "It always does. What made you decide to come and see me?"

Police Intervention and Unveiling the Con

Captain Kennelly and his team, including Detective Louis DeLuca, orchestrate a sting operation at Grand Central Station. They prepare a dummy package identical to the original, complete with recorded serial numbers for evidence ([16:06]). As Marion arrives to retrieve the package, the police swiftly intervene, ensuring that the con artist is apprehended without mishap.

Quote:

• Captain Frank Kennelly ([55:22]): "This game ain't the dumbest in the world."

Resolution and Reflection

The episode emphasizes the ingenuity and persistence of the 21st Precinct officers in dismantling confidence schemes. Captain Kennelly reflects on the ease with which unsuspecting individuals fall victim to such cons, underscoring the intelligence required to protect the community.

Quote:

• Captain Frank Kennelly ([15:25]): "The gullibility of people is amazing."

---

2. The Line-Up and the Senile Slugging Case

Introduction to the Line-Up

Transitioning to the second part of the episode, listeners are introduced to a police lineup scenario handled by Sergeant Matt Grab and Lieutenant Ben Guthrie ([30:31]). This segment provides an authentic portrayal of the lineup process, emphasizing the importance of accurate identification in criminal investigations.

The Senile Slugging Incidents

The precinct is grappling with a series of violent assaults dubbed "slugging," targeting elderly individuals ([32:27]). Each incident features victims being overpowered and robbed, leaving minimal evidence for police to trace the culprits.

Notable Dialogue:

• Detective Louis DeLuca ([34:21]): "They're liable to kill somebody. They seem to be getting rougher."
• Lieutenant Ben Guthrie ([35:28]): "They make the change. Mrs. Parazoni is giving her the package."

The Identification Challenge

During the lineup, suspects such as William Bushman and Max Sloan are questioned, revealing the complexities of witness identification and the challenges posed by accomplices ([32:27]-[33:57]). The narrative highlights how limited descriptions and small stolen items (e.g., a gold watch) complicate the investigation.

The Discovery of Victims

Amid ongoing investigations, a serendipitous discovery by Phil Parazoni leads to another victim, Mrs. Rebecca Stokes, found severely injured ([37:19]). This discovery intensifies the precinct's efforts to apprehend the perpetrators.

Quote:

• Detective Louis DeLuca ([38:35]): "They've been fighting old ladies too long."

The Breakthrough

A breakthrough occurs when Phil identifies a stolen gold watch under surveillance. Lieutenant Ben Guthrie and Detective DeLuca connect the watch to a suspect named Carl Young through Mr. Wagner, a pawnshop owner ([48:32]-[51:23]). This connection leads to the arrest of Carl Young and his accomplice, effectively closing the case on the violent slugging spree.

Quote:

• Phillip Parazoni ([50:58]): "Look, I know the man that hawked that watch, but honestly, I didn't know he killed anybody."

Conclusion of the Line-Up

The segment concludes with the apprehension of the criminals, showcasing the efficiency and teamwork of the 21st Precinct officers. Sergeant Grab and Lieutenant Guthrie reinforce the importance of vigilance and community cooperation in solving such crimes.

---

Themes and Insights

1. Community Trust and Deception: Both cases emphasize how trust can be manipulated by con artists, exploiting community relationships to execute their schemes.

2. Police Ingenuity and Dedication: The 21st Precinct's strategic planning and relentless pursuit of criminals highlight the dedication of law enforcement in safeguarding public safety.

3. Psychology of Crime: The narratives explore the psychological aspects of crime, including gullibility, desperation, and the moral dilemmas faced by individuals entangled in illegal activities.

4. Importance of Accurate Identification: The lineup segment underscores the critical role of accurate witness identification in criminal justice, preventing wrongful accusations, and ensuring the right individuals are held accountable.

---

Notable Quotes

• Lieutenant Gorman ([07:33]): "When somebody who's worked so hard... can you blame them too much if they see an opportunity to make some money?"

• Captain Frank Kennelly ([15:25]): "The gullibility of people is amazing."

• Captain Frank Kennelly ([55:22]): "This game ain't the dumbest in the world."

• Detective Louis DeLuca ([38:35]): "They've been fighting old ladies too long."

• Phil Parazoni ([50:58]): "Look, I know the man that hawked that watch, but honestly, I didn't know he killed anybody."

---

Conclusion

This episode of Case Closed! masterfully intertwines two compelling narratives, showcasing the challenges and triumphs of police work in mid-20th century New York City. Through meticulously crafted dialogues and realistic scenarios, listeners gain deep insights into the complexities of criminal investigations and the unwavering commitment of the 21st Precinct officers. Whether unraveling a sophisticated con or tackling a series of violent crimes, the precinct's stories resonate with timeless themes of justice, trust, and community resilience.

For those eager to delve deeper into these enthralling tales and explore more episodes, visit RelicRadio.com to stream the full broadcast and other classic Old Time Radio shows available 24/7.

---

Note: All timestamps correspond to the provided transcript and serve to highlight significant moments and quotes within the episode.

Transcript

[Host]

Welcome back to case closed. One hour of Old Time Radio Crime every Wednesday at relicradio.com. our first story comes from 21st Precinct. We'll hear the mark from October 27th, 1954. After that, it's the lineup and the senile slugging case. That story aired September 12, 1951.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Way face preaching. Sergeant Waters. All right, get on over to Second Avenue. The third alarm on that fire just hit. Sergeant Tierney's on the job there. He'll put you to work on traffic. Yeah, that's right. You are in the muster room at the 21st Precinct. The nerve center. A call is coming through. You will follow the action taken pursuant to that call from this minute until the final report is written in the 124 room at the 21st Precinct. Okay, you're gone. Bring in when you get back on your post. Yeah, all right.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

21St Precinct. It's just lines on a map of the city of New York. Most of the 173,000 people wedged into the 9/10 of a square mile between Fifth Avenue and the east river wouldn't know if you asked them that they lived or worked in the 21st. Whether they know it or not, the security of their homes, their persons and their property is the job of the men of the 21st Precinct.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

The 21st. 160 patrolmen, 11 sergeants and four lieutenants, of whom I'm the boss. My name is Kennelly, Frank Kennelly. I'm captain in command of the 21st. I was working my day tour 8am to 6pm it was raining hard when I came on the job and the 63 men who would patrol the precinct on foot and in sector cars for the next eight hours turned out wearing rubber coats, boots and cap covers. At ten minutes after nine, Lieutenant Gorman, the desk officer, rang into my office and informed me of a two alarm fire in a lost building on second Avenue. By the time a car came by the station house to take me to the scene of the fire, the third alarm had hit. The teeming rain added to our difficulties and it had not stopped until about the time the fire was out. At 11:14, I returned to the station house to finish the paperwork and begin a required inspection of departmental equipment. My calendar showed that I was scheduled to give a talk on safety to the student body of Julia Richmond high school at 1:30pm so at noon I changed to civilian clothes and took my rain soaked uniform trousers under my arm. It was my intention to leave them to be pressed while I went for my meal. In A restaurant a few doors from the tailor shop on 3rd Avenue operated by Philip Parizoni. Hello, Ms. Barazoni. How are you?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

I'm fine.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

I'm Captain Kelly.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Bill.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Well, you don't have to bother him.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Bill.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Bill. Come here.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Mrs. Parazoni.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Hello, Captain.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Oh, Phil. How are you, Phil?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Rose, you. You better get to 211 and pick up the work.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Oh, all right.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Yeah. The night doorman's uniform and the elevator operator's uniform from the. From the sou.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

211.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Yes. 2 11.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

All right, I'll get you.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Yeah. Only press if they want him back by 5 o' clock. Huh?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Only press.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Wides in the piston.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Yeah.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

There. Sometimes they ruin more customers than they're worth. Yeah. Captain Perch.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

I got them soaked this morning. Phil, I'm giving a talk to some high school students at 1:30 this afternoon. I wondered if I could get them present.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Oh, sure.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

They're not too wet, are they? Oh, don't worry about it.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

I'll take care of it.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

I'm gonna have lunch down the block. Could I pick them up in about half an hour?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

I'll deliver them to the station house if you want.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

No, no, that's all right. I'll pick them up.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Okay.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Thanks a lot, Phil.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Oh, Captain.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Yeah?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Could I ask you something? Sure. What is it, Bill? Look, Captain.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Yeah?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

I'm sorry. How? Rose asked what happened.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

You two have a fight?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Yeah, I guess you could call it a fight. Anyway, I'm sorry.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Don't worry about it.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

I am worried about it. You shouldn't treat people like that. Customers, especially you.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Oh, it happens in the best of family.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Yeah. Best family.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

I left Phil Parazone's tailor shop and went a few doors down the street to a restaurant where I had my meal. When I returned for the uniform trousers a half hour later, Mrs. Parizoni was not in the shop. At 1:30pm I was introduced to the student body at Julia Richmond High School and I talked for 20 minutes on the subject of safety, especially safe driving. It was 2:10pm when I returned to the station house where in the muster room Lieutenant Gorman was desk officer. And Sergeant Waters was on telephone 6:40 a captain. Go ahead and take the call, sergeant.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Yes, sir.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

I have time to block it 21st. Preaching. Sergeant Waters, where were you born? The borough of Manhattan. When you go down to the Department of Health, 125 Word street, you can.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Get a copy of your birth certificate there.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

125 Worth Street. Where are you? On the east side. You take the Lexington Avenue Express downtown and change it 14ft for the locals.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Right.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

The worst seat is just upstairs there.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Okay. You're welcome.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Yes, Sergeant? Did you have something for me? Oh, yeah, Captain.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

What?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

You know that Phil Parazzoni from the tailor show? What about him?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Came in to see you.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Yeah, he and his wife. I asked him to wait in your office. Are they in there now?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Yes, sir.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

All right. When he puts Precinct, stock and waters. All right.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Where do you be?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Well, hello, Phil.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Oh, you know, my wife's. Rose.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Yeah, sure. Hello, Ms. Tarzani.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Hello.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Well, what can I do for you, Phil?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Well, he told me it wasn't the.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Right thing to do. He told me in so many words.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

I wouldn't listen to him. No, Rose, that's what he told me.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

It wasn't the right thing to do.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

What wasn't the right thing to do?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

It was all my fault. He didn't have anything to do with it.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Rose.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Let me talk to him. Would you wait outside, please?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

It's my fault.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Would you just stand outside and I'll get it straightened out. Is that all right with you, Captain?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Yeah, I guess so.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Yeah, go ahead. Fr. Let me get it straightened out.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yeah, all right. But it's my fault. Everything.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Yeah. Could I close the door, Captain?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

That's all right. I get it.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Is it all right to wait here?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Yeah, sure.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

That's all right. Well, what's the trouble, philosopher, Captain?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

When you came in the store to get your pants first, she asked. Well, that's why she acted so funny, because it was you. You see, she thought you came to arrest her. That's why she acted that way.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Arrest her for what?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

It's a long story. It's a very long story.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

What does she do?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Look, Captain, when somebody who's worked so hard for so many years works really struggles, can you blame them too much if they see an opportunity to make some money just like that, A big opportunity to make it.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Well, I can't blame them if it's legitimate.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Well, in this case, it's legitimate and it isn't. Well, it can't be both. Well, I mean, the money don't really belong to anybody. You better start at the beginning, Phil. Yeah. Well, it was yesterday morning. We were in the shop, but Rose was at the counter like when you came in today. And I was in the back at the pressing machine.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Yeah.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Well, the door opened and a customer came in. A woman. They're a very pretty young woman. Yeah, but she came in mad as a wet hen. Well, I heard her talking to Rose and I came up to see what the matter was. But she had on a nice wool suit. See, the front of the skirt was dirty and smart. I didn't blame her for being mad. Anyway, she said she was on the bus. She said two men got on, and the man who was sitting next to her saw the two men. Well, she thinks they were detectives. And they were after the man that was sitting next to her. Well, anyway, he jumped out of the seat and crawled all over and ruined the suit with his shoe and went out the back door of the bus and the two men ran out after. Well, anyway, after a minute, she looked down on the seat and there was a package, you see, A pretty big package. Must have belonged to the man that the policemen were chasing. She picked it up.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

And did the woman have the package when she came into the store?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Oh, yeah. Yeah, she had it, all right. It was right down on the corner there all the time. Only, anyway, I said I tried to fix up a skirt as best I could, and she went in the dressing room. Well, I was in the back there working on a skirt. And then the lady asked Rose to bring the package into the dressing room. She'd like to take a look at it while she was waiting. So? So Rose brought the package in and Rose said, you know how curiosity can get the best of ladies. Well, they sat there looking at it, and Rose was hoping that she would open it up. And finally the lady decided to open it up. What was in it? Well, I didn't know. I didn't find out until last night. Oh, didn't she? Well, she didn't say anything to me about it while we were in the store.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

I was busy back there.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

I didn't know what was going on in the dressing room. I see.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Your wife only told you what was in it.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Yeah. I never saw anything in there.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Well, what was in the package?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Money. Lots of money, Captain.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

How much?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Well, I don't know exactly. Rose said at least 3,000, I think.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Aren't they sure?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Well, Rose told me they didn't comment. They were so scared they didn't count it. Oh, the money. The money wasn't all that was in there. What else? Number slips. You know, slips from playing policy. Oh, yeah. Well, they figured out Rose and the lady that this fella on the bus was a racketeer, you see, and he was being chased by the cops. Yeah. Oh, you can ask Ross in.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Well, I think we ought to have this story from her, don't you? Yeah.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Yeah, I think we ought to.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Ms. Parizoni?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yes?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Would you come in?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Now, all Right.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Just have a seat.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yeah, you tell him so.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Well, not everything. Yes.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Sit down. Laughing I only got up to the.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Pot after you opened the package in the dressing room.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Oh, yes.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

I'd rather hear the story from you, Ms. Parizone, instead of what you told your husband.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yeah, sure.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Now, how much money was in there?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

We didn't count it. We stole that money and the policy slipped. We got scared.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

You and the lady?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yeah. We wrapped the package back up again.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

What was it? A stack of money?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yeah, a stack about this thick, about 2 or 3 inches that. Lots of money.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

And was the pile of money tied up?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yeah, with a rubber band. A couple of rubber bands.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

And what was on top?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

A twenty dollar bill.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

You see the bottom?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yeah, there was a ten, I think there's a ten dollar bill on the bottom.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

You never did take the rubber bands off?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

I didn't even touch it. She was holding it.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

And you decided to wrap it up quickly?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

She decided. She said the best thing to do would be to call the police. That'd be the best thing.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Why didn't you call the police?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Well, I. I came back with the skirt.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

You better let her tell it soon.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Oh, yeah, okay.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

All right.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Well, Phil came back to the dressing room with the skirt and she had the package all tied up again. I took her out front of where the telephone was and she walked over to it and she picked up the telephone. All of a sudden she hung up.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Where was Bill?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

I wasn't back there. I was working on some work at the pressing machine. I don't know. I didn't see any of it.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

No, that's right. He didn't see any of it.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Did she tell you her name?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Not then.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Well, did you ever find it out?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Well, later she said it would be best if I didn't know her full name. She said her first name was Marion.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Did she tell you why she didn't call the police?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yeah. Yeah, she told me that she was afraid to call the police. She said that she was afraid that they'd find out that she had 22 parking tickets on her car. Never went to court about any of them. She was afraid she'd be arrested and find a lot of money and things like that. She said maybe it'd be better if she left the package in the store and if I'd call the police.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Did you agree to that?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Well, I didn't care, but. And she said there wasn't any reason why we couldn't keep the money to ourselves. Better that we should have it than the criminal Wallace said the only thing was he was afraid that the man from the bus might have gotten away from the cops and might have remembered us.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

So what did you do?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Well, it was decided that we could leave it in one of those lockers in Grand Central Station. You know, one of the lockers right in the waiting room There you see a little locker with a key that you take out and put in a dime.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Yeah, I know.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Well, because he was scared, I took the package, went out of the store, and she followed me. I went over and took the subway and rode down to Grand Central. I put the package in the locker, and she said I could keep the key because I didn't know her full name or where to get in touch with her. But she sure knew me, and she was sure I was honest.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Is the package still in the locker?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yes, still in the locker.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

And you've got the key?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yeah, I got the key. I got it right here.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

See?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

How much cash did she ask you to put up?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Did you tell them she asked me to put up cash?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

No.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

No, I didn't tell them.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

How did you know she asked me to put up cash?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

I knew. How much was it?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Seven hundred and fifty dollars.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Have you given it to her yet?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

No, no, I'm supposed to meet her this afternoon.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

You're lucky, Ms. Parazoni.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

What do you mean, lucky? I'm worried to death, scared to death.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

You're lucky you not only didn't find $3,000 of someone else's money, you didn't lose 750 of your own.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

You are listening to 21st Precinct, a factual account of the way police work in the world's largest city. Now back to 21st Precinct and Captain Kennelly.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

I took Mr. And Mrs. Parazoni upstairs to the 21st Detective Squad and into the office of Lieutenant Matt King, the squad commander. Shim, Shamming, Bunko and pigeon dropping, as the small con games are called, are old stories and easily recognizable to police officers. But to the victim, they're most convincing. This is especially true because in many there is a blinding streak of larceny exceeded only by that in the con artist. These confidence rackets are invariably based upon the victim's desire to get something for nothing, something that belongs to somebody else.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

To the police officer.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

The gullibility of people is amazing. It's incredible how many in the city of New York fall victim to these same old small con games year in and year out. In this case, Lt. King and Detective Louis DeLuca questioned the intended victim very closely. As I listened, why should she give you the key? She were on a level. Why wouldn't she suspect you'd go to the locker and get the package for yourself?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Well, she told me that she trusted me because she knew where to get in touch with me. We were in business.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

She walked in off the street with a smudge on her suit. And that's sufficient reason for her to trust you with $3,000? Well, she told my wife she had to trust somebody.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

That's right. She couldn't go to the police. And it can have a 22 parking ticket.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

You've known these people a long time, haven't you, Captain? Yes, ever since I've been in the precinct many years. As far as I know, they're good, honest, hard working people.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

It was all my fault. After I told Phil, he said, why didn't I go to the police? I should have gone to the police. That's what he said.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Rose, please. Huh? If I meant for you to go to the police, I would have insisted.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Now, let's pick this up for a minute where we left off.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yeah. All right.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Yesterday, you and Ms. Marion took the package down to Grand Central and you got one of those dime lockers.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yes, that's right.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Then what did you do?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

We went to a. I don't know, a coffee bar, I guess you call it, in Grand Central. We stood there, we had a cup of coffee and she said, well, I. I guess nobody followed us. I guess the detectives arrested the man. I said, yes, I guess they did. So she thanked me a lot for helping her. And she started to say how much I should get for helping her. She mentioned something like 25% of what was in the package. Well, I would have been satisfied with 25%. But anyway, we settled on the fact that I could get a third. We were supposed to meet at Grand Central, right at this coffee bar exactly at noon today. We'd take the package someplace and open up and then split the money.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

How did she happen to give you the key?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Well, it was her own idea.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

It was very nice of her, wasn't it?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

I thought it was.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Then you parted company?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yes.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

What time did you get back at the store?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

It was about an hour after left.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Your husband asked you where you'd been?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Well, yeah.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Yeah, I asked her.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

She told me she had to go out with the lady to help her out.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

I asked her why she had to help out a trade like that.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

She said she just did. She had to, that's all.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

You accepted that answer?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Well, I couldn't do nothing except accept it. What else could I do?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

When did you tell him about the money?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Last night, after dinner. I just couldn't keep it in me anymore. I told him about the package and about everything that was in it and how we went to Grand Central, how we put it in the locker and how she was going to meet me there tomorrow and I was going to get one first.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Your husband told you to go to.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

The police, didn't he?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yes, he told me.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Yeah, I told her, but with no enthusiasm. With no enthusiasm whatsoever.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Well, at least you told me.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

And you were intending to meet her at Grand Central Station at noon today and open up the package?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yes, that's right.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Well, it was about noon that I came to your store. You were still there.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yes, I know I was there. I got a call from her on the telephone at 9:30 this morning.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

That's Marion.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yes, Marion. She said she was in awful trouble. She said she got home the night before, went to bed and when she woke up in the morning there was a policeman there. A policeman? Phone almost fell out of my hand. She said the policeman came to arrest her on account of the 22 traffic tickets that she didn't show up in court for. She said the policeman took her down to the magistrate's court and she was sitting there just waiting for her trial. So she said she couldn't meet me this noon, but that I ought to go down and put another dime in the locker at Grand Central Station. I told her I'd do that. She made me promise to be sure not to open the package because we'd have to count the money together. And I told her I wouldn't, but I just put the dime in.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Did you go down to Grand Central?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yeah. Yeah, I went down there and I went out of the store when the captain was in there. Do you remember that captain that I left?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Yes, I remember.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

I'm so nervous, I didn't know what to do. I thought you came to get me. That's what I saw. But when I found out you didn't, I. I went over and got the subway and went down to Grand Central and put another dime in the locker.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

You look inside to see if the package was still there?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yeah. Yeah, I opened up the locker. I looked inside to see it was still in there, the package.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Then you went back to the store?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yes.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

What time was that?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Must have been about a quarter to one that I got back.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

What time did you hear from Marion again?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

About 1:00 clock. He called.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

What'd she say this time?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Well, she told me she'd been up before the judge. She said the judge was very mad at her for ignoring the 22 tractor tickets. And he find her $750. $750. She had to have the money right away. She'd go to jail. You had to pay the fine by 4 o' clock that afternoon. She said she didn't know what she was going to do. The judge wouldn't let her leave the building, but he let her go out in the hall and use the pay telephone so she could call some friends if she didn't have it before o' clock that afternoon to go to jail.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

What'd you say to her?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Well, I told her. I told her she had all that money in Grand Central Station. I said she ought to be able to use that. But she said no, she didn't want to do that. She didn't want to take the chance on opening up the package. Not down there, because there are all kinds of cops around and everything. There's always all kinds of cops in the courthouse.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Did you have any suggestions, Dolphin?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yeah. I told her I could open it up and throw the policy slips away. I could go to the ladies room in Grand Central Station and throw them in the waste basket or something like that and just bring the money down. She said no, that wouldn't be any good because we'd have to count the money together and each take our share so there wouldn't be any suspicion on either side.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

That seemed fair, didn't it?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yeah, but I knew she was in such trouble she had to pay the $750 fine.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Did she have any suggestions?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Yes, she had a suggestion. She wanted to know if I had $750, if I could get it? And I said yes. I said, go to the savings account. And she said, please, please, wouldn't I do her a favor and draw out the money so she could pay the fine? And after she paid the fine, we'd go up to Grand Central and get the package and we'd split it right away and I'd get my $750 back and she'd give me half of the rest instead of only a third.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Did you agree to do that?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Finally? I told her, all right, I would. And I told her that I'd meet her with the $750.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Where was that?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

In the courthouse down on Center Street.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Where in the courthouse?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

On the second floor, right by the pay telephones there. She said that the judge had given her permission to go out and stand by the telephones to wait for calls and to make calls. But she had to be back inside the court and pay off the fine before o' clock.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

What time are you going to meet her?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

At a quarter to four.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Well, in order to be thankful that you decided to bring the whole thing to me, you'd have given her the $750 and never seen her again with the package.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

I had the key to the locker. The package is in there?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Yes. You'd have gotten back 30 of your $750. 20 on top and a 10 on the bottom.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Frank, it looked like money to me.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

It always does. What made you decide to come and see me?

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Oh, that was Phil's idea.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

No, no, Rose. You decided that you.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

No, it's not true. It was his idea. See, he keeps the bank book in the drawer of the sewing machine. He was putting a new lining in a coat and he wouldn't get away from it. Finally, he stood up to get something. I got the bank book. He saw me. So he asked me what happened. I told him. He says, no, I can't go to the bank and get the money. But I told him I promised. He said, I don't care what you promise.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

But she decided to come here herself. She decided.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

He told me. So I decided.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

What do you think, Lieutenant? Think I ought to go down to.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Grand Central and pick up that baggage. What time is it now?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Quarter three.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

I think you ought to leave it there. At least until we're sure that this Marion is down at the courthouse. Just as liable to be standing in Grand Central watching that locker.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

She sees a police officer or.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Rose, go get the package. She's not going to show up at the courthouse. It stays there in the locker. Then she's sure the deal is on.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Is it on? What should I do?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

You don't have to Worry about that, Ms. Parasoli. You just do what we tell you. It was decided that Mrs. Parizoni would go ahead and complete the transaction with the con artist she knew only as Marion. A dummy package of money prepared in exactly the same manner as the package left in the locker in Grand Central was gotten ready. There was a twenty dollar bill on top and a ten on the bottom. In between was plain paper cut to size. The serial numbers of the two real bills were recorded for evidence. Detective Deluca was instructed to see that Mrs. Parazoni waited until the exact time of the appointment, entered the building and took the elevator to the second floor. Lieutenant King and I went into the lobby of the building and met two detectives of the 5th Squad. The four of us took the elevator to the second floor. It was hardly necessary to make ourselves inconspicuous in the corridor. The place, as always on court days, was jammed with police officers, defendants, witnesses, complainants, bail bondsmen and attorneys waiting for their cases to be called in the various courts. The two detectives from the 5th Squad were planted near the elevators. Lt. King and I walked to a place in the corridor close to the telephone booth. And there we waited. Captain, this is the first time I've heard of the Criminal Court building being part of a con game. It's impressive, Matt. You got to give her credit for that. That's impressive, all right. There's a woman waiting. Think that's her? He's pretty close to the description. Wait a minute. There's another one down there. Where? At the drinking fountain.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

How are you?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Lots of them, Captain. Well, I guess we'll just have to wait and see. Yes, sir. How's the time? He's due up here now. How about moving across there while we can see the elevator? Gas arm. The blue dress. Yeah, that could be hard, too. Now, let's see. Look, we better not both watch the elevators, man. No, I'll. I'll look this way. You just let me know what's going on, okay?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Okay.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

There's another one. That could be the gal. That description fits half the women in New York. Yep. There's Ms. Parazoni coming off the elevator. She's starting to look around.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Does she see us?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Not yet. Which way is she looking?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

This way.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Here she comes. She stopped. You think Marion showed? Yes, sir, she showed. Parazoni is walking over to her.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

The one in the blue dress.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

I better keep looking this way.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

He's greeted her.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

They're making the change. Mrs. Parazoni is giving her the package.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

She's got it. All right.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Let's go. Good looking. All right. You think that'll help her not go far? I don't know how much good will do from now on.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Now where will I wait for you?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

All right, we're police officers. I'll take that package.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

What?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

When you've got there, I'll have it.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Please.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Did you bring them?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Why'd you bring them?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Because you were cheating.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Give me the package.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

You are K your eyes out right ahead.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

You stand over there. Ms. Parazoni.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Kill him. I'm killing.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

I don't think so.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

No, I don't think so either, but let her believe it. But you do. Open up the package in Grand Central.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

No, it's still there. What made her ring in the nut? You picked the wrong mark.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Jesus.

[Phil Parazoni]

Christ.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Yeah, but you didn't count on one thing. She's got a streak of honesty. 21st preaching, Sergeant Waters? Yeah, that's right. Those are policemen working over there. What do you want to know for? Well, how. Does what they're doing concern you? Yeah. Yeah. Well, you'll just have to bear with us a while, mister. Getting her out is more important than your losing a little sleep. All right. Yeah, we'll be through there right away, as soon as possible. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. You're welcome. And so it goes. Around the clock through the week, every day, every year, a police precinct in the city of New York is a flesh and blood merry go round. Anyone can catch the brass ring, or the brass ring can catch anyone.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

21St Precinct, a factual account of the way the police work in the world's largest city is presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolman's Benevolent association, an organization of more than 20,000 members of the police department, City of New York. Everett Sloan in the role of Captain Kennelly. Ken lynch as Lieutenant King. Harold Stone as Sergeant Waters. Featured in tonight's cast were Briana Rayburn, Joan Allison, Larry Haynes and Bill Quinn. Written and directed by Stanley Nist. Produced for CBS Radio by John Ives. Art Hannah Steven.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Ladies and gentlemen, we take you now behind the scenes of a police headquarters in a great American city where under the cold, glaring lights will pass before us the innocent, the vagrant, the thief, the. The murderer. This is the lineup.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

There. Yeah.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Here's Mr. Wiggins.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

How do you feel, Mr. Wiggins? Oh, better. I feel a little better. Well, we can sit right here. You need some help? No. No, thank you.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

It's.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

It's all right.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

I'll see you later then.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah. Thank you, Sergeant. Nice fellow, Quine. Yeah. How many people do we have to look at? Oh, I think they're 28 or 29. We've had two other cases like yours in the past week. Picked up a couple of guys that might be possibilities, but we haven't been able to get positive.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

May I have your attention, please? You people out there on the other side of the wire in the audience room. May I have your attention, please? Thank you. My name is Grab. Sergeant Matt Grab. I'll explain the lineup to you. Each of the suspects you will see will be numbered. I'll call off a number, then they're in charge. If you have any questions or identifications, please remember the number assigned to the prisoner as I call his name at the end of each line. When I ask for questions or identifications, call out the number. If you're sure, or not too sure of the suspect, have him held. The officers who took your name will assist you. They're seated among you. Please be prompt with your questions or identifications. When the prisoners leave here, they are sent to the washroom and dressed back into their jail clothes. It makes it quite difficult to bring them back after they leave here. The questions I ask these suspects are merely to get a natural tone of voice. So do not pay too much attention to their answers, as they often lie. Bring on the line. Okay, move it over. Right on over to this side of the stage. Spread out and stand facing the audience. Hands to your sides and keep looking straight ahead. Now, when you answer the questions, talk up so the people out there can hear you. It's a long way to the back of the room, so keep your voices up. Okay, number one. William Bushman. Robbery. Take your hands out of your pockets. Where do you live, William?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

108Th in Lincoln.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Where are you from? Los Angeles. How long you been in this city? About seven months, I think. January is about seven months. Were you arrested with anybody, William? Yeah, a couple of guys. Well, what are their names?

[Phil Parazoni]

Joe.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Joe.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

I don't know his last name. Joe Lucas. Number 18. All right, who was the other boy? Call him Twitch. Herman Twitchell. Number 19. Any weapons, William?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

No.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

You have a car? No, he was walking.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

If he had a car, we wouldn't be here.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Okay, Number two. Max Sloan. Robbery. Where do you live, Max? In the east side. You have an address, haven't you? 411 Orchid South. Were you alone when you were arrested?

[Phil Parazoni]

I was with the guy was sticking up.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Was anybody arrested with you?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

No.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

I was full of your job.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

We weren't sticking up each other.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Any weapons, Max? You think he was giving me his wallet because I was pointing my thumb at him? You want to be funny? We've got all night, Max. You can just stand there and be funny all night? All right, I'm sorry. Were there any weapons?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah, 32.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Well, nickel plated, Blue steel. What?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Blue steel.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Not counting the rust. You have a car?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

No.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Okay, number three. Stanley Mines.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Robbery?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

No, no, none of those men.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Where do you live, Stan?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

I don't recognize any of those.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Come on. You'll have to speak up, Stanley. I said I don't live here. I'm from out of town. Where out of town?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Wilme. Wilmington, Kentucky.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Can you people hear him back there?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

No.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

All right, now, look, I told you boys, you're going to have to talk up. I don't want to have to Repeat the question. So, come on, talk up all the way to the back of the room. Now, where are you from, Stan? Wilmington, Kentucky. Where have you been staying? Here.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Only one place. One place Here.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Flop house. What flop house? Oh, just a flop house. I don't remember. Who remembers a flop house?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Hi.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Hi, Mr. Wiggins. Didn't spot anybody, huh?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

No. Two guys jumped and did it so quick.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Oh, this is the third slugging in a week. Somebody better come up with a halfway decent description.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Those guys aren't stupid. Follow a pretty routine MO Dark spots. Pick an old guy like Wiggins jumping before he knows what's happening. Beat him unconscious and unroll him. How much chance has he got for a decent description?

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

They're liable to kill somebody. They seem to be getting rougher.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah. Here's a list of Wiggins valuables. See that all the pawn shops are covered. Okay. Other two victims didn't have much. These guys might want to hunk. Wiggins had a gold watch and an old stick pin. Watch had his name and an inscription. I might try to get rid of it.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

We're in car 13J tonight, huh?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah. These boys move around, but they seem to stay pretty much to the east side. We'll have the usual cars and five auxiliaries. Waldo's putting about a dozen plain clothesmen on the streets.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Funny if one of our boys got rolled.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

They're not old enough. These guys pick them old so they won't give much trouble. Nice guys.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Yeah, swell.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

87415 at 105 North Lincoln.

[Phil Parazoni]

You got 89 of 5?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Let's pull into Rogers and get a hamburger, huh?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Okay.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

63A905 at 1769 East Brighton. See the man.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Order me a hamburger and coffee, will you, Ben?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Sure.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

73 of 480.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Be right back.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Okay. License five two, young seven six. No, I don't need a menu. Two hamburgers and two coffees.

[Ms. Lillian Dunn]

Two hamburgers and two Coffees. Everything on the burgers?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yep.

[Ms. Lillian Dunn]

Thank you.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Attention all units in Area H, a 245 slugging at 87 West Bullock. All units in area.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Miss, pull those hamburgers.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

What's up?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Slugging about a block away.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

You know someone? Someday I'm going to.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

There it is.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Oh, crime's already here.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Over here is a woman. Pretty bad.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Good.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Gosh, I've done everything I can.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Oh, here comes the ambulance.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

This is the fellow that found her. Mr. Hall?

[Phil Parazoni]

Yeah.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

This is Lieutenant Guthrie. Tell him about it.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

No. Yes. You know.

[Phil Parazoni]

Well, I was walking by over on the sidewalk and tossed a cigarette over Here and saw her about. Then I spotted this officer in his car and I yelled, hi, doc.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Now they're slugging, huh?

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Yep.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

She's not dead, but she's close.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Get that blanket over her, boys. All right, doc. Looks like a bad fracture.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Really a bad one. Lost a lot of blood.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah. You think she'll make it?

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

I don't know. Keep that end up there.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Pretty old.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Lost a lot of blood. You coming down, Lieutenant?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah, we'll be down.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

She didn't have anything on her. No identifications. They got everything.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Hey, you just found a lying here, Hall.

[Phil Parazoni]

Yes, sir, that's right. I threw my cigarette over here. Wouldn't have even seen her if I hadn't thrown my cigarette.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

They probably waited behind this hedge, grabbed her when she passed, slugged her and dragged her into the lot.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

That's a good spot for it.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Good and dark.

[Phil Parazoni]

Gee, it was a terrible thing. Still can't quite believe it. What are you going to do about it?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

What do you think?

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Hello, Lieutenant.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Now, that.245 slugging that came in about a half hour ago. Who's got her, the old lady?

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Yeah, she's in surgery now. Dr. Gordon.

[Phil Parazoni]

It's the fourth one this week, isn't it?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

You mind if I look at your newspaper, Murph?

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

No, no, no.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Go ahead. Coffee shop's closed, isn't it? Yeah. Well, you want some coffee? I could use some.

[Phil Parazoni]

Want me to run down the kitchen?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

No, no, no, forget it. It's no trouble. No, no, thanks, Murphy. We'll get some across the street later. All right.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Hey, Ben, the tennis finals are next weekend.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Wanna go on duty?

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Well, they'll be playing the rest of this week.

[Phil Parazoni]

Yeah, I'd like to see that.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Maureen Connelly.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

That's a pretty girl.

[Phil Parazoni]

The picture's in the last section there sometimes.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah? Yeah.

[Phil Parazoni]

In the sports section.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Yeah, right there.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Pretty girl, huh? Yeah.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Huh? Ben?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah. Want to go? Yeah.

[Phil Parazoni]

Here comes Dr. Gordon.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Doctor.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

I'm Guthrie, Doctor. 16 precinct. Oh, how are you? This is Sergeant Graham. Hello. Well, how's the old lady? She died. Wasn't much we could do. She was pretty well gone when she came in.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Come on.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Walk down with me while I get.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Out of this gown. I'm sure. See you later, Mark.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Yeah. Take it easy, Mark.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

So long.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Have you got an identification yet? No, not yet. Fingerprints will help. Did just about everything. Bad fracture.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Really bad one.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

When they're that bad, they don't stand much of a chance. She regained consciousness at any time? No. By the looks of the wound, whoever hit Her? Hit her with something pretty heavy.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Blackjack?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Oh, something like a pipe, maybe. Really?

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Let her have it.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Well, that's the way these boys have been working. Had three others. Not this ban.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Cigarette?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

No, thanks. Sergeant?

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

No, thanks.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Hard to believe anybody would beat up an old woman to hit her that hard. Just doesn't make sense. No, I guess it does. These other victims have much money on them? Added all together, about $24.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Hi, Ben.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Morning, Matt. Anything new?

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

No, just routine stuff.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Well, let's grab some coffee then.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Okay.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Oh, I was just looking for you, Ben.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Huh? Bart sent us over.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Fingerprints on that old lady.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

You got an identification? Yeah.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

We ran a check through, and this is what we came up with. Woman's name is Stokes.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Mrs. Rebecca Stokes.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Lives at 5:18 North Oak with her daughter. Asher went over to get the daughter. We'll need a positive identification to. Asher's taking her right down to the morgue. Thought maybe you'd like to talk to her first.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah. Yeah, I would. Let's go.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Her daughter's name is Lillian Dunn.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

She was married. Husband killed in the war. Morning, Lieutenant. This is Ms. Dunn. This is Lt. Guthrie and Sgt. Gret. How do you do, Ms. Dunn? Hello. Hello. We certainly wish we could eliminate all this, Ms. Dunn, but it's necessary.

[Ms. Lillian Dunn]

I don't think I can go through with it. I don't think I can do it.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Well, it's really necessary. She has to be identified by a relative.

[Ms. Lillian Dunn]

I just don't think I can.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Well, it's your mother.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

We're sure of that. Sooner or later, you'll have to. Well, sooner or later, you'll want to see her.

[Ms. Lillian Dunn]

But not in here. Please, not in here.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

We have to keep her here until we get a positive identification. Do you have any other family in Nevada?

[Ms. Lillian Dunn]

An aunt and a cousin.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Well, if they could get down here.

[Ms. Lillian Dunn]

They haven't seen mom in years.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Your mother's the fourth victim in a week. We've got to stop these men. We'll need some information.

[Ms. Lillian Dunn]

All right.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Where was your mother going last night?

[Ms. Lillian Dunn]

I guess she was coming home. She went to a movie, early one. I guess she was coming home.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

She have a purse with her? Any valuables?

[Ms. Lillian Dunn]

Yes, she had a purse.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Can you remember some of the things she carried in her purse?

[Ms. Lillian Dunn]

Yes, I guess I can. It wasn't much. Not much money.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Anything to identify her?

[Ms. Lillian Dunn]

Some cards and things.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

She have any jewelry? Any rings or a watch?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yes.

[Ms. Lillian Dunn]

She had a wedding ring and an engagement ring. They weren't worth much. I'm sorry.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Don't be. I think Ms. Dunn, better go on home. Asher, get a description of the two rings and take home. Show them too.

[Ms. Lillian Dunn]

No, I'll do it. It's best to get it over with. I'll have to do it sooner or later.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Well, look, maybe we can get some close.

[Ms. Lillian Dunn]

No, I want to. It's all right.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Okay.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Now look, Ms. Dunn, if you don't want.

[Ms. Lillian Dunn]

Go ahead.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

All right, Charlie.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

How many times a day do you say? I heard it on the radio. CBS Radio's famed news department, with its nationwide staff, its worldwide network of correspondence, its eight wire services, keeps you up to date and informed throughout the day and night. The CBS radio newsroom is on duty 24 hours a day for the latest news. Keep in touch with CBS Radio News.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

You sure?

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Deal him.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

King.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Lovely. What do you think?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

No, can't use it.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

No?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

No, huh? Jen?

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Look, Quine, do me a favor, will you?

[Phil Parazoni]

Drop dead.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Well, you couldn't discard the three. Picked one up?

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

No.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

You owe me 30 cents.

[Phil Parazoni]

Kibbitz yet?

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Oh, Waldo's got eight auxiliaries tonight. Ben, you and Matt are in 13J again.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

How about the police? Women?

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

He's got five of them. They'll be in the area from 10 till 2. One car within a block of them at all times.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Okay. Well, I got half an hour. You want some dinner?

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Yeah, I'm getting hungry.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Okay. Wait a minute.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Have what?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

This guy.

[Phil Parazoni]

Oh, it had to be the jack.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah, put him on.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

It couldn't have been any one of the nine other cards.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah, hello, Mr. Wiggins. Yeah, yeah, I remember. You didn't work. 897 South Wilton. Okay. Yeah, yeah, we'll meet you there in about 10 minutes. Right. That was Mr. Wiggins. He spotted his watch in a pawn shop. The watch the hold up men took after they slugged him.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

There's Mr. Wiggins.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Hello, Lieutenant. Hello. Where's the watch? Right over here in the window there. The gold one. It's open. See the inscription? Okay, let's go in. Yes, Police. Yes, they want to see a watch you've got in your window.

[Phil Parazoni]

Sure, sure. Which one?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

It's that one. The. The gold one?

[Phil Parazoni]

Sure. This one?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

That it, Mr. Wiggins? Yes, yes, that's it. See the inscription? To Dave Love Alice, my wife. She gave it to me.

[Phil Parazoni]

Hot.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah. Remember when you got it?

[Phil Parazoni]

I. I got a ticket. Yeah, yeah.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

John Jones, 671 Barrington. John Jones, That's a good name. You remember what the man looked like?

[Phil Parazoni]

The man who walked the watch?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

No.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

You remember when he.

[Phil Parazoni]

Arctic? No.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Well, didn't you date the Ticket?

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

How long have you had it?

[Phil Parazoni]

A week, maybe. What's so important about the watch?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

It belongs to this gentleman, not to the man who hawked it.

[Phil Parazoni]

Okay, take it. Ain't worth much.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Why? It's solid gold.

[Phil Parazoni]

Solid gold? I got dozens now.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

What's your name?

[Phil Parazoni]

Wagner. George Wagner. Look, I don't know nothing about it. This guy came in, he hogged it, that's all.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Look, Mr. Wagner, it's very important that we get a description of this man.

[Phil Parazoni]

He stole it, huh?

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Yeah, and he's got a friend. We want them both for murder.

[Phil Parazoni]

Murder?

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

That's right.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

You think you might know him if he came in again?

[Phil Parazoni]

I don't know. I don't know. Maybe I don't remember.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

You get one of these lists?

[Phil Parazoni]

Lists?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah, one of these. List of stolen articles, like that watch.

[Phil Parazoni]

Oh, sure, sure, sure, I got one.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

None of these other things in your store?

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

No, no, no.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

You sure?

[Phil Parazoni]

Sure, I'm sure.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

You didn't know about the watch. You better check.

[Phil Parazoni]

Look, I know I ain't got none of them.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

You didn't report the watch. You better check.

[Phil Parazoni]

All right. If I find something, I'll call you. We'll wait while I check the whole inventory.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Just the tickets on the last week and a half.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Okay, we'll take a look at them too.

[Phil Parazoni]

Yeah, sure.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Okay.

[Phil Parazoni]

Look, officer.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah?

[Phil Parazoni]

I know the man that hawked that watch, but honest, I didn't know he killed anybody. I didn't know it.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

What's his name?

[Phil Parazoni]

Young. Carl Young. He's hacked things before. He's been in a couple of times. I know him from the neighborhood. I didn't.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

His name's Carl.

[Phil Parazoni]

Yeah. Cardio.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

The name in this watch is Dave.

[Phil Parazoni]

Well, he said it belonged to his brother.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

You know his brother?

[Phil Parazoni]

No, but I know him. He seemed like an honest guy.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Where does he live?

[Phil Parazoni]

In the neighborhood. I bowl. He's in the bowling alley a lot. I bowled with him last Friday.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Look, honestly, does he hang around with another guy?

[Phil Parazoni]

I seen him with another guy sometimes. Big guy.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

You better come on down to the station, Mr. Wagner.

[Phil Parazoni]

The station? Why?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

I'm afraid you're in a little trouble.

[Phil Parazoni]

Yeah, I know him.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Carl Young.

[Phil Parazoni]

Oh, yes.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

He hangs out in here a lot.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

You know where he lives? No.

[Phil Parazoni]

What's he done?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Does he pal around with anybody?

[Phil Parazoni]

Well, yeah. He's with one guy quite a bit. He's a fell named.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Let me see now.

[Phil Parazoni]

What the heck was that? Kind of a quiet guy, a big guy. Kind of. John and Joe gone. I'm sorry, I can't Remember Joe? Joe, I think.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Okay, we'll stick around. You let us know if Carl Young or Joe comes in with him.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Sure.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Klein says he's got a dozen men checking the neighborhood. Ben, there are four cars in the block. Nobody does anything unless you give the word.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Okay? Well, if they both come in, we'll take them.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

One of them.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

We'll tail him. Okay.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

That's 3:30.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah. See that guy down there? Second alley.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Yeah. What about him?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

He's bowled six strikes.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Okay.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Oh, fair. 150 so far.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

You need a few strikes, friend.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

All right.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Try to pick up that split.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah, I will.

[Phil Parazoni]

Lieutenant.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah, what is it?

[Phil Parazoni]

That fella just came in there.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Which one?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

That big one there.

[Phil Parazoni]

I said to him, I said, hello, Joe.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

And he said, hello, his name must be Joe. Where is he?

[Phil Parazoni]

He's upstairs, the pool hall.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Come on, point him on.

[Phil Parazoni]

Yeah, up here.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

It's right up this way.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Wait a minute.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Wait a minute.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Hello, Joe.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Yeah.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

How are you? That's him. Yeah. Come on, man.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

He's out in the street.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Hold it. He's getting into a car. All right, come on.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

There he goes.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

All right, stay with him. 13J, Code 2. Suspect proceeding east on Fountain, license number 80. Roger, 1135.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Attaching. All units, Code 2. Suspect traveling east on Fountain, license number 8O. Roger, 1135.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

He's swinging left.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

13J, suspect turning north on Lincoln.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

All units in area B, code 2. Suspect proceeding north on Lincoln.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Now, don't get too close.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

He's stopping now.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Pull up.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

13J. Suspect at 3000 block Lincoln.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

He's getting out then.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

All right, let's go.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Going into that building?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah. Hold it. We'll wait a little rest. The boys get here, there's Quine. Now he's in the building. Quine, you better take it around back in the alley. Right.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

And there's Asher.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Quine's taking the back. Asher, we'll go in. You wait here for the rest. Spread them out. Right, Lieutenant. All right, let's go, man.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Okay, how do we do it?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Let me find out what apartment he went in. Clear out the building and take him.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Wait a minute.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Mailboxes.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Oh, yeah.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Lipski, Buscher, Whiting, C. Young, 208.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Well, if they're in the room, we can just clear out the rooms on both sides. Forget the rest of the building. I'll take 206.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

I'll take 210.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

204, 206. Okay? Yeah, sure, sure.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

So what I tell you, Carl?

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

I tell you, I know what I'm talking about. This game ain't the dumbest in the world.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Matt.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah?

[Phil Parazoni]

That was Carl Young with the big boy.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Come on. It's better that way. We'll take him on the straight.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

They're climbing into a car.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Hold it, Young.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Watch it. Ben.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Asher, over that way.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Get them between us. Give it up, Young. Watch it.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

You break it for the alley. Young's down.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Take this one, Asher.

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Yeah.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

That Qu's. Tackle him. You all right, Quin?

[Lieutenant Gorman]

Yeah.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Yeah.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Big boy wasn't as tough as he looked.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Ah, he's been fighting old ladies too long.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

The lineup, where before you pass the innocent, the vagrant, the thief, the murderer. Listen, next Wednesday when we again bring you the lineup, May I have your attention, please?

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

You people out there on the other side of the wire in the audience room. May I have your attention? Thank you. My name is grb. Sergeant Matt grb. I'll explain the lineup to you. Each of the suspects you will see will be numbered. I'll call off and number their name in charge. If you have any questions or identifications, please remember the number assigned to the.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

Prisoner as I call his name. At the end of his line, you may ask questions.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

The lineup, starring Bill Johnstone as Lt. Ben Guthrie and Wally Mayer as Sgt. Matt Grab, is written by Blake Edwards with music by Eddie Dunsteady. Featured in tonight's cast were high effer back, Ray Hartman, Bob Sweeney, Howard McNear, Peter Leeds, Virginia Gregg, Sydney Miller and Bill Boucher. The lineup is produced and directed by Jaime Del.

[Lieutenant Ben Guthrie]

Foreign.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

The top fights of the nation come to you on CBS radio just a little later tonight. Get the gang together and sit in on the Jimmy McAllister Baby Ortiz Lightweight battle from Baltimore. The broadcast will be heard on most of these same CBS radio stations. Who are you pulling for? And just as a reminder of where to find the ringside, cbs.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

Cbs.

[Captain Frank Kennelly]

The star's address.

[Detective Louis DeLuca]

The star's address. Where you always hear the best at cbs. Cbs, the Stars address. The Stars address.

[Mrs. Rose Parazoni]

Cbs. Cbs.

[Sergeant Matt Grab]

Stay tuned for yours truly, Johnny Dollar, which follows immediately over most of these same stat, Dan Coverly speaking. And remember, mystery fans can't miss when it's the FBI in peace and war. Thursdays on the CBS radio network.

[Host]

That's case closed for this week. There's more from 21st Precinct, the lineup, this podcast and all of the Relic Radio shows at Relic Radio. Our shoutcast stream is there as well, with even more old time radio streaming 24 hours a day, seven days a week. If you'd like to help support this and all of that visit, donate. Relicradio.com or click on one of the links on the website. Your support makes all of this happen. Thanks to those who have helped out. Thanks for joining me this week. I'll be back next Wednesday with another hour of Case Closed.