Casuals with Katie Nolan: Episode Summary Episode Title: Derek Carr, the NBA Playoffs, and Golden Corral with Giannis | with Carl Tart
Release Date: May 13, 2025
Host: Katie Nolan
Guest: Carl Tart

1. Introduction and Raphael Devers Controversy

The episode kicks off with Katie Nolan addressing the ongoing debate surrounding Raphael Devers of the Boston Red Sox. Devers, initially signed as a starting third baseman, faced backlash when the team requested him to transition to a Designated Hitter (DH) role, leading to fan unrest.

Katie Nolan (02:15):
"Raphael Devers named American League Player of the Week this week... his batting average was .476."

Carl Tart (05:30):
"In sports, we say the team is more important than the individual, and Devers is exemplifying that by performing exceptionally well as a DH."

Katie emphasizes the team's reliance on Devers and questions the long-term implications of forcing players into unfamiliar positions, highlighting the delicate balance between individual preferences and team dynamics.

2. Guest Introduction: Carl Tart

Katie warmly welcomes Carl Tart, a comedian, actor, and writer affiliated with SNL and Upright Citizens Brigade, who brings his unique perspective to the discussion.

Katie Nolan (10:15):
"We're joined today by Carl Tart, a comedian and actor, known for his work on SNL and Upright Citizens Brigade."

Carl Tart (10:17):
"Thanks for having me, Katie. Excited to dive into some sports talk!"

3. NBA Playoffs and Conspiracy Theories

The conversation delves into the NBA playoffs, focusing on Carl's perspectives as a Clippers fan and his critical views on Luka Doncic's potential move to the Lakers. They discuss the recent NBA draft lottery, highlighting the Dallas Mavericks securing the first overall pick with a mere 1.8% probability.

Carl Tart (14:00):
"The Mavericks getting the first pick... it shouldn't have happened. I'm critical of Luka Doncic, and now he's potentially moving to the Lakers?"

Katie Nolan (17:28):
"The Mavericks have the first pick again, one of the longest shots to win the draft lottery. It's to discourage tanking, but it feels precarious."

Carl speculates on a conspiracy involving the lottery and predicts Shaed Gilgis Alexander winning the MVP award, suggesting the league might favor certain players for narrative purposes.

Carl Tart (23:25):
"I think Shaed Alexander will win MVP as a compromise to Jokic, who's been statistically better this season."

4. Giannis Antetokounmpo and the Clippers

Giannis Antetokounmpo's situation is a hot topic, with Carl proposing a humorous pitch to transfer Giannis to the Clippers, highlighting numerous Golden Corral locations in LA as an incentive.

Carl Tart (39:04):
"Giannis, the LA Clippers – they have a Golden Corral in Victorville. Let's hop into my Jeep and make it happen!"

Katie Nolan (41:22):
"Giannis is exploring his future, but Carl's pitch is certainly... unique!"

The duo discusses Giannis' impact and potential moves, blending humor with genuine sports analysis.

5. NFL Spotlight: Derek Carr's Retirement

Shifting to the NFL, Katie announces Derek Carr's retirement after an 11-season career with the New Orleans Saints, citing a shoulder injury that led to his decision.

Katie Nolan (44:54):
"New Orleans Saints quarterback Derek Carr has announced his retirement following a labral tear and degenerative rotator cuff issues."

Carl Tart (47:31):
"He’s made $195.7 million in his career. I’m glad we can take him off the books, minus the $10 million cap hit."

They discuss the Saints' future prospects, including potential quarterbacks like Tyler Schuck and Arch Manning, and express skepticism about the team's direction.

Carl Tart (46:12):
"With Arch Manning entering the draft, I think we might win too many games next year but still miss the playoffs."

6. Other Sports Highlights

The podcast touches on various other sports events:

• Hockey:
  Unnamed Sports Commentator (64:06):
  "The Panthers vs. Maple Leafs series is heating up, tied at two each."

• Cricket (IPL):
  ** Katie Nolan (65:04):**
  "The IPL is resuming on May 17 after a suspension due to India-Pakistan tensions."

• Formula One:
  Unnamed Sports Commentator (66:42):
  "The Emilia Romana Grand Prix is set for May 18, featuring Oscar Piastri leading the standings."

7. Personal Anecdotes and Pop Culture

Katie and Carl share personal stories and humorous takes on various topics:

• Writing Night and Podcast Life:
  Carl Tart (27:17):
  "Writing night evolved from staying late in the office to now doing it remotely, though it's still a communal effort."

• Pop Culture References:
  Katie Nolan (29:04):
  "Cardi B and Stefan Diggs were seen together at Madison Square Garden—what a pairing!"

• Cruises and Buffets:
  Carl Tart (38:35):
  "My mom loves cruises for the restaurants and casinos, but I prefer flying to destinations."

8. Concluding Thoughts and Upcoming Content

As the episode wraps up, Katie and Carl discuss their various podcast projects, including Hollywood Handbook, Flagrant Ones, and upcoming series like a Sopranos watch-along. They also highlight upcoming sports events and encourage listeners to engage with their content.

Carl Tart (61:13):
"Check out our other podcasts like Hollywood Handbook and stay tuned for our new Sopranos watch-along series."

Katie Nolan (70:00):
"Don't forget to email us at casuals@kadenalgmail.com and follow us on IG and TikTok at CasualsThePodcast. See you next Thursday!"

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Katie Nolan (02:15):
  "Raphael Devers named American League Player of the Week this week... his batting average was .476."

• Carl Tart (05:30):
  "In sports, we say the team is more important than the individual, and Devers is exemplifying that by performing exceptionally well as a DH."

• Carl Tart (14:00):
  "The Mavericks getting the first pick... it shouldn't have happened. I'm critical of Luka Doncic, and now he's potentially moving to the Lakers?"

• Carl Tart (23:25):
  "I think Shaed Alexander will win MVP as a compromise to Jokic, who's been statistically better this season."

• Katie Nolan (44:54):
  "New Orleans Saints quarterback Derek Carr has announced his retirement following a labral tear and degenerative rotator cuff issues."

• Carl Tart (47:31):
  "He’s made $195.7 million in his career. I’m glad we can take him off the books, minus the $10 million cap hit."

This episode of Casuals with Katie Nolan masterfully blends in-depth sports analysis with light-hearted banter, offering listeners a comprehensive overview of current sports events, personal insights from guest Carl Tart, and a touch of pop culture. Whether you're a casual fan or a sports enthusiast, this episode provides engaging content that keeps you informed and entertained.