Pete Rose, Peak Joes, Loomsters, and Kelce Joke Theft | with Joe List

Tue Mar 04 2025

Hello! It's the podcast that will never turn heel in Toronto. Today, Katie breaks down why bad people love to defend disgraced baseballer Pete Rose, then comedian Joe List [12:47] joins to the show to involuntarily discuss his favorite lists, and talk about his dip into sports news when Travis Kelce stole his joke verbatim before the Super Bowl, the curse of the Dallas Mavericks and what happens when franchises act like they hate their fans, Paul George's podcasting hiatus and the dangers of listening to your partner's podcast, John Cena's attack on Cody Rhodes at the WWE event on Saturday, baseball players lying about their height, the 2025 Oscars, and Joe's surprise that we've never heard the heroic tales of his Little League career. See Joe List Live - https://punchup.live/joe-list/tickets

Summary

Casuals with Katie Nolan: Episode Summary Episode Title: Pete Rose, Peak Joes, Loomsters, and Kelce Joke Theft | with Joe List
Release Date: March 4, 2025

Introduction
In this engaging episode of Casuals with Katie Nolan, host Katie Nolan welcomes comedian Joe List as her guest. Known for his sharp wit and prolific content creation, Joe brings a blend of humor and insightful commentary to the conversation. The episode delves into a mix of sports controversies, personal anecdotes, and the challenges of content creation in the digital age.

1. Pete Rose Pardon and Donald Trump's Involvement
The episode kicks off with a heated discussion about Pete Rose, the all-time hits leader in Major League Baseball, and recent headlines suggesting Donald Trump plans to pardon the late Rose. Katie provides a comprehensive background on Rose's illustrious yet controversial career, highlighting his record-breaking achievements and subsequent bans due to gambling allegations and tax evasion.

Notable Quote:
Katie Nolan [04:05]: "Pete Rose was banned from baseball for life due to gambling allegations, and now Donald Trump is looking to pardon him posthumously, which doesn’t make sense legally."

Joe concurs, dissecting Trump's motivations and the implications of such a pardon, emphasizing the irrelevance of pardoning someone who has already passed away.

Notable Quote:
Joe List [05:45]: "A pardon is meant to relieve responsibility for something current, not legacy issues like Pete Rose's case."

2. Joke Theft Incident and Social Media Reactions
The conversation shifts to the modern challenges comedians face with joke theft, particularly on social media platforms. Joe recounts an incident where Travis Kelce, a prominent NFL player, uncreditedly used one of his comedy bits on his podcast, leading to frustration over the lack of proper attribution.

Notable Quote:
Joe List [24:33]: "Stealing jokes is so frustrating. I’m a big Chiefs defender, but when someone takes my material without credit, it’s just outrageous."

Katie adds her perspective on how content creators navigate the digital landscape, often having to safeguard their original material against unauthorized use.

3. Sports Insights: Dallas Mavericks and NBA News
Katie and Joe analyze the tumultuous season of the Dallas Mavericks, focusing on major player trades and significant setbacks that have impacted the team's standing. They critique the rising ticket prices and the apparent disconnect between team ownership and fan loyalty.

Notable Quote:
Katie Nolan [32:10]: "The Mavericks have fallen to 10th place in the Western Conference after trading Luka Doncic, and their ticket prices have surged by up to 20%, showing a blatant disregard for their fanbase."

Joe agrees, expressing sympathy for Dallas fans and highlighting the broader issue of sports franchises prioritizing profits over community support.

4. Personal Stories and Comedy Bits
Joe shares personal stories, including his experiences as a new father and the humorous challenges it brings. The duo engages in playful banter about Joe's parenting mishaps and his foray into various comedy projects, including his web series portraying the Ultimate Warrior.

Notable Quote:
Joe List [58:10]: "I have dirty pants and I'm wearing ladies’ underwear. It’s inappropriate, but my baby gets stuff on my clothes, so what?"

Katie complements Joe's storytelling with observations about balancing personal life and public persona, enhancing the relatability of the episode.

5. Listener Story: Soccer Match Referee Incident
A listener-submitted story narrates an unusual event where a referee was bitten by a young player during a soccer match in Germany, leading to the postponement of the game. Katie and Joe humorously dissect the incident, drawing parallels to Joe's own experiences as a parent dealing with teething toddlers.

Notable Quote:
Katie Nolan [44:13]: "A referee was bitten in the left testicle by a child player, causing him to buckle over in pain and postpone the match. It’s both bizarre and painful."

Joe adds his comedic twist, relating it to his own encounters with his son's teething.

6. Listener Submissions and Top Lists
Throughout the episode, Katie engages Joe in creating "Top Four" lists based on various prompts, such as athletes named Joe, best TV shows, and biblical plagues. These segments showcase Joe's quick-thinking humor and creative approach to list-making.

Notable Quote:
Joe List [55:40]: "My top four things to hear from a doctor: 1. Get out of here. 2. Do you cheat on your wife? 3. Keep doing what you’re doing. 4. I’ve never seen anyone so healthy."

7. Oscars Discussion and Listener Defense
The discussion briefly touches on the Oscars, where Katie mentions a listener named Andrea who passionately defends Ariana Grande. This segment highlights the dynamic interplay between the hosts and their audience, emphasizing community engagement.

Notable Quote:
Andrea [78:31]: "I will never say a bad thing about Ariana Grande. She’s faultless because of her music like 'POV' and 'Sweetener.'"

8. Sports Technology and Rule Changes
Katie brings up advancements in sports technology, such as the upcoming implementation of automated strike zones in baseball and the introduction of appeal systems in basketball. Joe expresses enthusiasm for these changes, advocating for their potential to enhance fairness in the games.

Notable Quote:
Joe List [61:42]: "I am actually for the robo strike. It’s outrageous how easy it is to make mistakes, and this could really help."

Conclusion
The episode wraps up with heartfelt thanks to Joe List for his participation and comedic contributions. Katie highlights upcoming sports events and encourages listeners to engage with the podcast community. The hosts reaffirm their commitment to delivering relatable and entertaining sports discussions without the typical clichés associated with traditional sports media.

Closing Quote:
Katie Nolan [73:06]: "Thank you for listening to episode 13 of Casuals. We love you, and we'll see you next Thursday."

Key Takeaways:

The complexities surrounding Pete Rose's legacy and potential posthumous pardon.
The frustrations comedians face with joke theft in the digital era.
The struggles and disappointments of Dallas Mavericks fans amid team mismanagement.
Personal anecdotes that humanize the hosts and foster listener connection.
The evolving landscape of sports technology aiming to bring greater fairness to the games.

This episode of Casuals with Katie Nolan seamlessly blends humor with critical sports analysis, offering listeners both laughs and thoughtful insights into the world of sports fandom.