Loading summary
Sydney
Foreign.
Kate
Hey, guys, welcome back to Kate and Ty. Break it down. I just want to say thank you for the continued support. Don't forget to like and subscribe to the show. Apple podcast, Spotify, you can join our Patreon team and we drop the full video of our episodes on there. So just huge thank you. We see all the love and support and today we are with Sydney. And Sydney, you are a birth mom, right?
Sydney
I am a birth mom.
Kate
Okay.
Sydney
And I have two children that I raise in my home as well.
Kate
Okay. Can you tell us a little bit about, like, your journey of becoming a birth mom, what you were going through and kind of how it all went?
Sydney
Yeah, that's a packed question.
Ty
Yeah, it is. It always is.
Sydney
Yeah. Yeah, let me scrap that up real quick in a package. I found out I was pregnant in college. I was finishing a degree in psychology. I had a long childhood of trauma and hurt, broken home. Found out that I didn't really know the person that I was having a kid with. It was not. Not no effort to get pregnant. It was accidental and whatnot. And then my dad sort of said that if I didn't place the child for adoption, that he just wouldn't have anything to do with me. And lots of stuff went into all of those moving factors, of course.
Ty
Were you living with your dad?
Sydney
No, actually, I rented a condo from him that he owned, but my mom passed away when I was young, and so I have always found myself really looking for my dad's approval. Summarizing, like, what led to adoption is loaded, for sure. It was all of the factors of not wanting to repeat trauma and everything that had happened to my mom. I think really what it was at the end of the day was fear that I wasn't enough. And I was believing the things that people were saying about me without knowing who I was. And when I was taking other people's word for what my capacity was as a mom or my success personally, what, whatever have you. It just led to adoption at the end of the day, which was not ideal, not what I wanted even very heavily cohortsed in a lot of ways to make that decision.
Kate
And who do you feel like? Yeah, yeah, like, who do you feel like was coercing you?
Sydney
My dad and my family, primarily. And then the agency was the next one.
Ty
Okay, so you did place through an agency?
Sydney
I did go through an agency, unfortunately.
Kate
Yeah.
Sydney
Well, live and learn.
Ty
Yeah. We've heard a lot of different stories of people use lawyers and sometimes. And a lot of people, some people don't use agencies But I. That's why my next question was like, so it's through an agency. Was it an agency that you found yourself or did your dad, like, help you?
Sydney
I found it.
Ty
Okay.
Sydney
Yeah. Yeah. I googled. I think at that point I was probably five or six months pregnant when I. I mean, I knew before, but I had not even entertained the idea. I actually was looking for ways to keep my. My daughter.
Kate
Yeah.
Sydney
I had gone to. I live in Weld County. I had gone to the Weld county courthouse, and I was trying to figure out how I could get full custody before she was born. Okay. So that I could fight for those rights. When I found out her biological dad's past, I just didn't feel comfortable co parenting with him. I really strongly believed that it would compromise her safety and well being. So I wanted to be certain that I could have full custody prior to her being born. Weld county doesn't do. And I bet this is true for a lot of counties, but I really haven't done a lot of homework on it. You cannot get full custody or custody agreements in general for a child until the child is here.
Ty
Right.
Sydney
And it's so silly because you can do an in vitro paternity test, but the percentage is just ever so slightly different on the accuracy of the in vitro test versus a blood test or mouse swab. And so for that reason, they won't even entertain a custody battle until child is here.
Kate
Wow. Even if he's not, like, safe.
Sydney
Correct.
Kate
Wow.
Sydney
I thought it was terrible.
Kate
Yeah. Right.
Sydney
When I found that out, though, that's why I decided to. Okay. I should at least have a family matched. I'm not. I don't want to agree. I don't want to consent to anything. I don't want to do paperwork. But I, I should just know these are the people that I want to raise my child. If I do.
Ty
You're saying find an adoptive family match like that. Okay, so you did that. That was like your first. Once you found that out the courts, you're like, all right, I need to find cause. So that means you already kind of made the decision a little bit in your head that I'm going to lean. You lean more towards adoption. Once you found that out from the core.
Sydney
As soon as Weld county told me that, that really was where my mindset shifted from, I want to do this. But at that point, your options are like, what? Move states and change your name and raise this kid on your own. Live on the run or adoption or. And they just don't tell you what your options are. You know, Weld county there or county's corporations, courthouse systems. You know, their job is to just tell you what they can or can't do. It's not to educate you about your options.
Kate
Right.
Sydney
And then the adoption industry has a narrative that they want to promote because there's profit in it.
Ty
Right.
Sydney
So they're not going to tell you about your other options either. So it's just a kid figuring it out.
Kate
So you went to the adoption agency and you just were at first just trying to find a family that you felt fit for you, right?
Sydney
Yes, they do. I don't know. Did you guys place through an agency?
Kate
Yes, we did.
Sydney
So for the agency that I was working with, they gave us books and it was like family portfolio.
Kate
Same.
Sydney
Yeah. So they came with like 12 of them. And I'm flipping through them and all of the verbiage says, we can't wait to welcome a baby into our family. We can't wait to raise our child. Bond with all of this verbiage. And all I'm seeing is my baby. Our baby, baby, baby. There was one book out of all 12, and it said, we cannot wait to welcome you and your child into our home.
Ty
Boom.
Sydney
If they're not interested, I don't want it. That's where I was at at that point. And I sat down with them. I really liked them, but I didn't have a clue what to ask.
Kate
Right, right.
Ty
You don't know. You don't know.
Sydney
And so it was a lot of like, what do you do for work? Where are you from? I don't. What's your favorite color? I'm not sure. They give you that or. We got a sheet of questions that was kind of like really pathetic. First date questions get to know you stuff and I. You ask what comes to mind and then you leave. And you may be thinking more and you have dialogue back and forth, but it's not sufficient.
Kate
No, it's not sufficient.
Ty
Did you notice that all the profile books are very similar? Yeah, that's one thing that we talk about now that we were adults. Like, looking back, it's like you look back and say they were all like the vacations, their house, their family, them spending time with children in the picture.
Kate
Yeah, with kids.
Ty
And it's interesting how it's like, wow, they're all like. They're so similar. And it's. It's like, it was just ironic that, like, wow, like, the one that you saw was like the one verbiage is what got you to Be like, all right, that's them. And I almost wish we would have, because I didn't really pay attention like that. I mean, we were obviously 16. You're a little older than we were.
Kate
But like you said, you don't really know what you're looking for. You're just reading all these things. And like you said, even when you meet them, you don't know what to ask. Or it's just kind of awkward and.
Ty
Like, well, and plus. But they're verbally and saying that, like, we. We can't wait to welcome you and your child. That sounds like they're leaning towards openness. It's what. You know what I mean? So that mean that's probably. Did you even know about openness versus closed or semi or anything like that before you met them?
Sydney
Yeah, at that point, they had kind of asked me what my hopes for adoption were. And every time that I would say something, they would tell me it was too much and like, what?
Kate
Give me an example.
Sydney
So I wanted to be very active in her life. I want to see her every month. I want to do phone calls. I want to get together on the weekends when it's available and not in an obsessive way. Like, I'm not saying we have to. To do this, but this is the type of relationship that I want. In my mind, it was comparable to co parenting in some ways, just with the removed legal authority of one half of the family here. And so I wanted our relationship to mirror what I understood adoption to be in concept.
Kate
Okay.
Sydney
And I've always been somebody that's very in. Tuned in general with words that people choose, body language. I just. I'm very intentional about what I put out and what I received.
Kate
Yeah.
Sydney
And for that reason, I was looking for little wording cues like that. But every time that I said, I want to see her at least once a month, like, that's the floor. Send me pictures. They were like, well, that's a lot. I don't think that we're going to get a whole ton of families that agree to that type of relationship.
Kate
So the agency told you, like, oh, that's a little.
Ty
It wasn't the family.
Sydney
No, it was the agency.
Kate
Did you ever ask the family that?
Sydney
I did.
Ty
Okay.
Sydney
Yeah. So they had. The agency had talked me backwards from a visit once. And it was. I mean, it goes back to that coercion thing that it's really just. I mean, and I'm sure to a degree it's them trying to set realistic expectations based on what they've seen, but it doesn't make it okay. And they talked me from a visit once a month and pictures and phone calls all the way down to four visits a year.
Ty
Okay.
Sydney
When I got the profile books, I said I wanted to meet with that family that I had chosen for the wording reasons in their profile and sat down with them. I liked them a lot. Found out that the adoptive mom, she is my daughter's adoptive mom now. Her and I have the same birthday. It seemed like there were just these little coincidences lining up that were kind of cool at the time. And I was, I think, looking for anything to be grateful for at that point.
Kate
Right.
Sydney
Well, when I left that initial meeting and weeks kind of keep going by and you're maybe texting back and forth, talking to the agency, but nothing's really happening now at this point. And I decided I cannot do less than six. Like, that really is my floor. I need to see her every other month at a minimum.
Kate
Good for you. Because what do they tell us? Also, that it's your. You are in the driver's seat of this decision. You. It can feel and look any way you want it to look. So good for you for saying that. And what did they say?
Sydney
They said, let us think about it. The age. I didn't tell the agency because they were the ones that had talked me backwards. So now that I'm talking with them, I'm like, I'm going to talk to you about this.
Ty
Oh, so you actually got the numbers of the adoptive. Oh, wow.
Sydney
Yeah. Did you guys.
Kate
We had theirs.
Ty
They got a specific.
Kate
It was like a specific phone, but to talk to us through.
Ty
Yeah, actually, well, it was. And it also. It was like they didn't. Their responses were, like, few and far. We would wait days and, like, they weren't. And then the responses were very. Not like, just like fluid. It was very, like, rehearsed. It seemed rehearsed. You know what I mean?
Kate
But you were actually able to tell them, like, hey, this is what I need. Okay.
Sydney
And they did agree to the six visits a year when we would sit down and talk because we had other meetings after that. I would just tell him, hey, guys, I would love to get coffee with you or dinner. I've thought of some other questions I'd just love to chat through. And it looked like they had promised me the sun and moon and stars and that this was going to be a flourishing relationship. We had shared faith, to my knowledge.
Ty
What do you mean? To share to your knowledge? What do you mean?
Sydney
So the agency that I placed through was an alleged Christian agency.
Ty
Okay.
Sydney
And I'm a believer. I don't necessarily think that that denomination though, was the principle for me. It was the core values that are rooted in my faith.
Kate
Right.
Sydney
That was what it really was for me. Well, Nightlight Adoption Agency is just a Christian adoption agency. And so I didn't think about all of the denominations of Christianity. Some of these are really brutally legalistic. I found out that that is exactly what I had signed up for with this adoptive family.
Ty
Okay. So what would that. Because there's so many Christianity as Presbyterian.
Sydney
The Calvinism, They're Baptist.
Ty
Don't quote me on that.
Sydney
I think they're Baptists. Again, nothing against Baptist in general. Right. But they had gone to a Catholic college and they had done mission trips in the past. All of these really great things and theory. But it's really common that when there is a religious superiority, there is a gap between just loving people and what religious law says, quote, unquote. I put that lightly. But it ended in them not even wanting a relationship with me, which I'll get into. How that kind of spiraled too, because of the fact that I had my child, I wasn't married. I had my other daughter not long after. And so it was like, well, this is added trauma. We want nothing to do with you. All of these. Bizarre 180. Yeah.
Ty
Okay.
Kate
So leading up to her birth, you were meeting them for coffee and just having conversations and that sort of thing?
Sydney
Yes.
Kate
So did they live in your state?
Sydney
They did at the time.
Kate
Oh, at the time they did.
Sydney
Our openness agreement was outlined pretty simply because we wanted to make it broad enough that we were going to be realistic. Right.
Kate
Yeah.
Sydney
So we ended on six in person visits per year, videos or pictures and. Or uploaded to a shared Shutterfly account once a month. Nothing crazy. Doesn't matter when you do it. Just.
Ty
Yeah.
Sydney
Photos.
Kate
Any pictures.
Sydney
Keep me posted. Yeah. Just in the moment, out of the moment, whatever you think of it. That they would let me know if something major medically happened or something along those lines. If she breaks an arm or is in the hospital, just keep me posted so that I can send a teddy bear in flowers and make sure everything's good.
Kate
Right.
Sydney
And then at the bottom it was a more vague description of like the hopes that we had for our relationship where it said my daughter's adoptive parents had agreed to include me in family activities and sporting events and barbecues and let's do fun things together and take family photos.
Ty
That's great.
Kate
Like it looks and sounds Beautiful.
Sydney
It does. And so I was sold on this vision that I had been pitched, for.
Kate
Lack of a better word, same.
Sydney
Yeah, it stinks. But.
Ty
Yeah, but your openness was way. I mean, I would love to have that on paper at least, but wow.
Sydney
Did you guys even have an open disagreement on paper or.
Kate
Yes, we did. So I think with ours, when we first, you know, we were probably three months pregnant when we were deciding, like, adoption is our thing. And you know, in that moment it was. I don't know if I could see her. It might be too hard. I still want to see pictures of her. But Facebook, like, yeah, so like, semi open, like, I think it might be too hard. I don't want her to be live in the same state because what if I'm wondering, is that her in the grocery store or whatever? And you know, we were always told like, you know, your openness can change at any moment. This can look and feel however you want it to feel. I was told, like, if you change your mind, it's all written in pencil so we can grab the big eraser, we can erase it, and we can start over. And so, you know, I was very much on like, semi open until the day she was born and the day she was born. And I held her in my arms. I said, oh, no, no, no, no, no. I said, I want to know where she's at. I want to see her. I want to get pictures and letters, I want to send her presents, I want to write her letters. I want to be able to FaceTime and call. And after holding her, I was like, there's no way in hell. I want to know all about this child. Like, I love her. I want to see her grow up and be a part of her life. And so we changed our openness agreement to face to face visits once a year for 18 years, ongoing, like pictures, pictures, letters, text messages, communication. And that's kind of where ours was. And for a few years, we were having face to face visits for every year. And then they adopted a son and the birth mom is also in Michigan. And like, once that happened, it kind of moved. Like face to face visits every other year.
Ty
After the five year mark, we noticed a big shift.
Kate
Yeah.
Sydney
What is it with the five year?
Ty
I don't. I have no idea. I'm not sure.
Sydney
Some voodoo associated.
Ty
I don't know. I don't know what's happening because I think it goes back to our, you know, our first draft of the openness before she was born. It did say, you know, for the first five Years. We'll get specific pictures and stuff and like, and I don't. And then, then obviously years down the line, we found out that 95 of open adoptions closed within five years. And so. I didn't know that. We didn't know that.
Sydney
Me neither.
Ty
No, they don't tell you those things.
Sydney
You should have to sign a disclosure that says that like you have, you've been told this information.
Ty
Yeah, because I think they say, well, you knew. It's like we, you can't really tell me. I knew. Because you clouded the language in such a way that especially at 16 years old, I'm trusting all the adults that what's on this paper is what's on the paper.
Kate
Well, because I'm looking at 45 year old adults looking at me and I'm like, why would they lie to me?
Sydney
And who am I to question their credibility where I'm at in this situation.
Ty
Especially they're the agency, they're the professionals. I never did adoption.
Kate
And the adoptive parents themselves telling me these things, of course I'm going to believe you. I'm literally giving you my child. Yeah, like, of course I'm going to believe you. You.
Ty
So that goes into the whole, I think our, our version of like open adoption is like, if it's not legally enforceable, then what else is the paperwork besides a coercive tactic to get this to, to get the baby, to make.
Kate
The birth parents feel secure in a moment.
Sydney
And why do they not tell birth parents that you can have outside legal representation and that the state supersedes the agency? Because most states have legally enforceable contracts between individuals. So even if open disagreements are not legally binding, that doesn't matter. I'm getting the state involved.
Ty
Correct. But they don't, they don't, they don't tell you that.
Sydney
No. God, that would hurt their profit.
Kate
Yeah.
Ty
And I think that's what it comes down to is that that's why, you know, it's important to talk about. Because even the word industry really offends people. Like, they're like, it's not like. So you can't even say adoption industry. People get really like freaked out about it and it's like, well, I think that's a first step though. You have to acknowledge that it's an industry. You have to acknowledge that people are making money in this industry and that it's very unique to America and that no other countries operates adoption like this. And so I think that's the first step to maybe like opening minds a little bit to like you know, I think. I think it comes down to, like, you, we need to ask questions, and you shouldn't be offended that I'm asking you to ask the question. Like, you know what I mean? Like, you should be wanting to learn more about this. And I feel like. I think it comes down to, like, you know, like you said, if we had legal representation, if they were to allow that to happen, I think open adoptions would look a lot different, you know, because, I mean, I know certain states are legally enforceable, but a lot of them, they're not.
Sydney
No ones that.
Kate
A lot of the times it fails. But so after.
Sydney
After your.
Kate
Your child was born and you obviously went through with the adoption, how did your guys's relationship look in the. Right off. In the beginning.
Sydney
In the beginning, it was tough for the same reason that you articulated that you wanted semi open prior to having your daughter. It's. It's. That is a empty pit of grief that I don't think you can even articulate with words unless you've experienced it. So when I see you, like, I know that we have that shared trauma, that shared loss, and that feeling of leaving the hospital or leaving your baby that day that no one else can understand except someone who has truly been through it.
Kate
Yeah.
Sydney
And it took a while for me to want those communications, so they were very generous at first, and they sent me a picture, sometimes multiple pictures every day right out of the gate, because it was so hard. I woke up the next morning, my first night back home, and I remember turning to my daughter's dad now and saying, I have to get her back. Like, how do we undo this? This is. I cannot do it the day afterwards.
Kate
Because it's so painful. And so you're just full of sorrow. It's uncontrol. It's the craziest felt.
Sydney
Me, too.
Ty
Yeah. The postpartum hormones, everything going on, on top of it. It's like. It's insane. Did you.
Sydney
Did you.
Kate
So what you do?
Sydney
Yeah.
Kate
Did you. So you look at him, you say that he.
Sydney
This was a huge, pivotal moment. I have not. I'm not with him, but I have nothing but phenomenal things to say about this man. He said there are four other little hearts on the line now. Like, we can't. We're not going to do that. And what he meant was, my daughter's adoptive parents have four biological girls of their own. Biological, biological. I did that intentionally.
Ty
Interesting. Okay.
Sydney
All right. Yeah. I'll tell you about that when we get to the book piece of it. But.
Kate
But Off Rip. I don't agree with what he said.
Sydney
Do you now?
Ty
Okay, you don't now?
Kate
Yeah. Like, I was like, I don't agree with that. Because I think in your heart and soul, you were like, I can't do this. This is very hard. And I feel like he should have just me. Devil's advocate. I feel like he should have said, okay, we will do whatever we need to do.
Sydney
Right? Right. And now that I've been through what I've been through and the promises have unraveled, that's where I fall, too. With the promises that they had said they were going to maintain at that time because of the love that I had for her children, the love that she had for mine at that point, it was for what? To get her back. Because I still would have to go through the custody battle. And so he knew, even though his words were, there are four other hearts on the line, he knew that even if we get her back now, we're facing a whole other set of complications and compromising our daughter's emotional stability. My daughter. We call. I apologize. We call him. He was there through the whole pregnancy. He's not her biological dad. Now we're risking this custody thing, compromising her emotional stability in the environment that she's in and compromising those other little ones that just got their sister home. From what they've been told and what they're experiencing. I don't feel the same way about it now, but at the time, it would have been selfish for me in a lot of ways. Maybe not in a bad way, but.
Kate
I was gonna say I don't think it would be selfish.
Sydney
And when I say that, I say it in the same way that you can be. You can have a good sense of pride, like, take pride in the things that you do. You can be selfish and caring for yourself. And that's not inherently a bad thing.
Kate
Right.
Sydney
I just think the nature of that decision would have been selfish. Selfish. Regardless of if we deem that a good or bad.
Ty
Regardless if you had the right to do it, because you did have the right to do it. Yeah, it was a revocation, period.
Sydney
Yes. But they don't.
Ty
They don't real straight.
Sydney
They're like, you have 72 hours, but you actually have until the adoption is final.
Kate
Yes.
Sydney
So, yeah. Just another thing that's weird there, but it was. It was great for that. I mean, the pictures and whatnot. It was really hard to see her. I would ball for hours after visitation. I mean, just hours. Sick to my stomach. Couldn't Eat, Couldn't sleep. You want your baby back.
Ty
Well, I think what. What. What I'm hearing from you is it's a little. I think it's a little different from our experience because I don't think we didn't wake up the next day kind of like having that immediate like, oh, my gosh, I want her back. I think we were trying to kind of like, almost brainwash ourselves that we did the right thing and it's okay. And I think our souls knew. Our souls kind of felt that we knew that of course we're always gonna want her, but, like, you know, do you look back at it now and just. I mean, it has to be hard not to have regrets, because you're looking back at now, you know, all these years down the line. It's like you could have honored yourself in that moment. You could have said, you know, yeah, I want her back. And then you. You did have 72 hours. So it's like, that's got to be. I. I think it's. It's got to be. I think it's harder for birth moms.
Kate
In your position as birth moms. We have lots of what ifs all the time.
Ty
Yeah.
Kate
You try not to live in them because they'll drive you crazy, but I think we all do. Like, what if I would have done this differently or that differently? Like, I feel like that a lot, and I try not to sit in that.
Ty
Right. But do you equate your. Your. Your saying, oh, I want her back? Do you equate that to. In, like, I. At that moment, you're like, I don't. Like, I don't want to do this anymore. This. This decision is not something I want anymore. That's how you felt. So when did that feeling go away is my question. Right.
Sydney
And I don't know if it ever does, but it definitely got worse when all of the promises started to unravel. I don't regret adoption. I regret not knowing what questions to ask that would have matched me with the family that met the needs of what my hopes for a relationship with my daughter were.
Ty
Would be.
Sydney
And that's what people miss. When you and I have said publicly I would have chosen a different family.
Ty
And they get mad.
Sydney
Mad. I have had people blow up my DMs with videos of you. My own things. And it's like, well, you need to talk to. Like, we need to hear your thoughts on this. Like, all right, let's lay it out.
Kate
Talk about it.
Sydney
But it is. It's really hard because I Don't. With all of the circumstances of the relationship with my daughter's biological dad, I still think that I would have chosen adoption. I've always been somebody that puts others needs above my own. I don't think that that would have changed. But I would have known that what I was asking for was not too much. It wasn't unreasonable. It was fair.
Ty
Very fair.
Sydney
And if anything, it was a reflection of how much I loved her and how much I wanted to raise her.
Kate
Yeah.
Sydney
And I just didn't know what to ask. And they're great people and they love my daughter. And I can say all of that and have almost no respect for the way that they've handled this relationship.
Ty
Be true at the same time.
Sydney
Yeah.
Ty
Yeah.
Kate
Because how long did it go on? Like, was everything really good for a really long time? Like you were seeing her multiple times, all that? Like, when did it start dwindling or them not keeping their promises at three years old?
Sydney
They told me in the month of her birthday that they were moving out of the country. So we went from six in person visits a year to we're leaving the country and we're gonna have to continue this relationship via FaceTime.
Ty
What.
Sydney
And from that day forward, every visit that I had with them thereafter was them chipping away at one more piece of what we had agreed to. I started to have to beg for the pictures. And can you upload this? How are you guys doing? When can we schedule a call? When's our next visit? Yada yada. Yeah.
Ty
And you're probably doing it very cautiously. Cause you don't want to. I think as a birth parent, people don't get. We have to be very like, we have nothing.
Sydney
We walk on eggshells after being the punching bag for our whole child's life.
Kate
And what was the reasoning that they wanted to move out of the country?
Sydney
The whole Baptist thing that I mentioned about comes full circle. I think that they. My understanding is that they went on a missions trip to start a new church in another country. And so I think that they think that they're doing it for the right reasons. What I do not, and I probably will never understand, is how you can preach the gospel to people while not living it in your own life for your own kids.
Kate
Yeah.
Sydney
Will never make sense to me.
Kate
Is there any contact now between you and them?
Sydney
So In February of 2024 last year, my birthday, her birthday as well. I guess she pulled me aside after I FaceTimed with my daughter and her and her husband said, we have to go from Six video calls a year to four video calls a year. Just because we have so much demand and so many things going on, we not going to have the time to just allocate this to you anymore. I'm really sorry. Like, we'll reevaluate. That is where I drew a hard line. I. I was like, respectfully sorry. Like, sorry, not sorry. You guys have taken away everything that we've agreed to. I'm now doing video calls instead of in person. And now you're telling me that you don't have 30 minutes twice a year to do a video call so that I can know that my child that I loved enough to entrust you with is okay? And I'm not even going to have this conversation with you if I'm being honest. Like, we can't talk about this. And so I. I just said, guys, respectfully, I know that time isn't the issue. I want to hear you out. I believe that there's something else going on. I'm not an expert. You're not an expert. Can we get the agency to mediate a call? And the agency has always, at least on paper and over the phone, said, you know, we'll always mediate these conversations and help with communication, conflict resolution, yada, yada. So we did. We scheduled a call and I. This is what I don't. Going back to. The birth parents have to tread lightly. I really hate that. I hate.
Kate
Oh, yeah, same. I do not like it.
Sydney
I don't understand why we make all of the sacrifices that we make, lose all legal authority, and still have to be the ones that are cautious with our words at the end of it. That hurts me. There's no reason, like, why do. Why do you have to have an ego as adoptive parents when I've given you everything?
Ty
I'm proving you that ego German, for me, it's love. So please, drop your own and drop your weapon.
Sydney
Like I. Come on. Yes.
Kate
And like Tyler and I, we always say, like, you know, the adoptee and the birth parents lose everything. The adoptive parents, they don't lose shit. They gain everything. So why is it so hard to let me be involved in this child's life that I love so much?
Ty
And also hold up to your end of the agreement. So at this point, they already went out of the country?
Sydney
Yeah. So they.
Ty
Now you're having these.
Kate
So they're still out of the country and everything?
Sydney
Yeah, they're in France right now. And, you know, it bothers me too, because when they were moving to France, that's not Just like an overnight thing, you know, just like, hey, pack your bag, sell everything. So they were actually in the States for another, like, year and a half almost. And they still didn't accommodate in person during that time. And it was like, guys, we could take advantage of this 18 months that we have until you're gone.
Kate
So you weren't seeing her face to face?
Sydney
No.
Kate
What about before they left?
Sydney
Before they left, we did, yes. We were doing in person visitation as agreed upon per the openness agreement for three years. It was at that three year mark when it started to go away. And I want to say it would have been like three and a half years is when it switched to the video calls officially. And then it was four years or four and a half years when it switched to. Now we need to do the four video call thing instead of the six video call thing.
Kate
But you got to see her in person before they left for France.
Sydney
Before they left for. No, no, no. Not while they were in. No. Yeah, they took that away when they moved out.
Kate
So there was no, like, face to face goodbye. It's like ceiling.
Ty
Wow.
Sydney
It was.
Ty
And they knew they were going on.
Kate
Horrible.
Ty
That is.
Sydney
They knew. Yeah, they knew. They told me in person that day. So that kind of was my goodbye in a lot of ways. And the only other time that I saw her before she left the country was when they had a wedding back home that they were attending. And so they did. They were gracious enough to allow me to write to see her. And we went to the aquarium or something like that.
Kate
That's heartbreaking. Like, heartbreaking.
Sydney
It is.
Ty
And. And so. And they left the country for one reason, which was to start a new church, which is to proselytize to whoever is living there whatever their goal is for the mission.
Sydney
Right.
Ty
And so religion played a huge part in your openness agreement being destroyed, which is very ironic, isn't it? Through a Christian Aid. You know what I'm saying? It's like, how is this happening?
Sydney
It doesn't translate. One doesn't equal the other.
Ty
Yeah, yeah.
Sydney
No, it doesn't make sense.
Ty
It doesn't make any sense. And I almost. Did the agency ever say anything? Like when you told them, hey, they're moving out of the country. Did the agency ever try to, like, mediate more and say, hey, guys, like, you made an agreement with these people?
Sydney
They said, my hands are tied.
Ty
Wow. So now your hands are tied.
Sydney
Yeah, right.
Kate
Now they are.
Sydney
Right.
Kate
You know what I'm saying?
Sydney
Yeah. Now you can't help.
Ty
So, yeah, that's so that's. That's. That is like. Yeah, because I. That. I mean, I can't imagine, like, a whole nother country, because even if you. Even if they're saying that they're gonna let you see her, it's like, well, it's never gonna be six times, you know?
Kate
And it's never gonna be the same. It's through a device, even. It's not like I can't even touch her, hug her, hold her, like.
Ty
And when did you have your. When did you have your next child after her?
Sydney
My daughter and her are a year and four months apart.
Ty
Okay, so you already had. By the time she left to the country, you already had another.
Sydney
I did. And so my daughter had a relationship with her sister, and now I'm eating the consequences of that, too, that nobody talks about.
Kate
Yeah, I was gonna say, like, one of the things, because, like, for me, when I was going through the adoption process and placed her and all that, like, never once did I logically even think to myself, like, how will this affect my future children? I never thought about it.
Sydney
Not on your radar?
Kate
No. Right. But it does. And it does so deeply, and it affects my children all the time. All the time. Nova more so because she's older, but. And I remember just talking to Ty a lot, like, wow, I. Why didn't I ever think of this? Like, why didn't I think the effect it would have on my future children?
Sydney
I know.
Ty
And I think people don't understand, like, oh, well, that's not their sister, and you need to just let it go.
Kate
And I'm like, as what they know that is their sister.
Sydney
You can call that thing you want if you tell it to my kid. I will.
Ty
I will.
Sydney
Like, I will. Absolutely. We're going to the parking lot, literally. Pack a lunch. I will. I'm not messing around when it comes to that. My daughter's in occupational therapy because of the loss of her sister. And because she's four, she doesn't really understand what adoption is. So you have to explain it in these age appropriate terms. Right. And so for that reason, she doesn't understand that this was my. Her sister. My daughter was not taken from her. But in my moments of weakness. And I deeply regret this, but I have broken down in tears in my home. Not to her, obviously, but. And it's. They stole my baby. And so now my daughter has heard me say that her sister has been taken, and she has this notion in the back of her little baby brain that the same thing can happen to her. And I have to walk her through. Come hell or high water, kid, nobody's taking you. Like, you are stuck with me, like it or not. And also just work through the emotional effects that it's had on her in regards to, like, why don't we see my sister anymore? I don't understand. She talks to other people about it. I have a sister, I just don't get to see her. She lives with a different mom and dad. And then people are looking at me like, yeah, right, hell is going on.
Kate
Right.
Ty
The same thing. Our kid will like, you know, when they're younger, they kind of spew the whole story to people, random people. And you're like, they give you that look of like, what is going on?
Kate
And you'd be like complete strangers.
Sydney
Right?
Ty
Yeah, right.
Sydney
Like, I'm Sydney. It's nice to meet you.
Ty
Yeah. Well, I think it's one that we, I think that we, that we have in common that like you said, people don't talk about is that adoption affects everybody, even the, the siblings. And I think it's interesting because we had a guest yesterday talk about how she's an adoptee and so she had children. So we consider our children second generation adoptees. And I'm like, what about second generation? Like relinquished children? Because that is what it's. It's like my child's affected by it regardless. If you think we're bad parents because we talked about it in front of them and they know about it, but it's like that's a reality that they're living with. And it's like, how do you even explain to a kid such a complex thing that makes them feel okay about it? And it's like almost impossible to do. It's incredibly hard.
Kate
Like I was always just try to explain it as at their age level, like, right. You know, in the beginning. And Nova knew when she started asking questions, it was like, I didn't have a car, I was still in school, I couldn't buy diapers. And then, you know, with her little four year old brain, she was like, oh, okay, that makes sense. You didn't have. And I was like, yeah. And then, you know, as she's gotten older, her questions have evolved and so my answers have evolved. But yeah, it's still. It's hard.
Sydney
Very much so. It's a really tricky thing to navigate. I'm also adopted, but I'm not from. Not in the context that we're talking about. My mom took her life to a drug addiction when I was 13 and so I was adopted later on by my stepmom and my dad was adopted by his stepdad. His dad left when he was little. My mom's dad passed away when she was little. She was adopted by her stepdad, so on and so forth. And so there's a lot of intricacies that go into it in general and it is really, really difficult to explain in a way that they can. But when we make that sacrifice, I think that we believe that it's just us that is affected because that's where the focus is. And you don't think about the long term implications of having to not only be strong for yourself when you're already the punching bag in this relationship, but then carry that burden for other people that you love. Yeah, it's hard for their whole life.
Ty
Yeah, the whole life. Yeah.
Sydney
When the agency mediated that call regarding the open disagreement, I came in very, very vulnerable and I told them I was calling their bluff on the lack of time thing and that I wanted to grow as a person, that I was willing to lay on the sword and if I was doing something that they didn't approve of or that they didn't like, I wanted that feedback. I wanted the opportunity to be able to ask for forgiveness and to learn and grow from that for the sake of my relationship with them, ergo, the well being of my daughter. And so we go through this whole conversation and I am quiet like, so what is it?
Kate
Right, right.
Sydney
They're like, not nothing. Like, we're just, we're really busy. We've got xyz, we've got other kids.
Kate
I love how that's always their excuse that we're super busy.
Sydney
And they were like, we'll add you to our newsletter with this missions thing, so on and so forth. The news literally was like, I'm sorry, what? What?
Ty
I mean, a newsletter, but you can't talk to you for 20 minutes.
Sydney
And I didn't say anything when they said that, but my face had to have just like ought to been like, yeah, I'm sorry, what? What? What are you talking about? No, it was bizarre for sure. But they ended that call with like, you know, let us think about it. We also did an educational thing. So in co parenting, right, There is almost no scenario unless the parents fighting for custody or in discussion of custody, I suppose, is a drug addict, danger to themselves, homeless, whatever it is. In situations that are not that. Almost all states at this point will encourage 50, 50 for the sense of identity that this child needs from both of their parents and the crucial roles that both parents Play in the child's life.
Kate
Yeah.
Sydney
So we explained this to them, right? I have a background in psychology, but I didn't want them to hear it from me because they won't.
Ty
Right.
Sydney
So I get the social workers involved and the psychiatrist that works for their agency. Please explain to these people how it could be detrimental to my daughter, especially at this age, because she doesn't understand even the gap in between frequency. What if we did more calls, but much shorter? You can just call me when you're on the road. Just let me tell her that I love her and ask what you're doing for the day. Click, hang up. Like, that's it. It can be random. I'll answer the phone. I don't care what time it is. But even that is in support of a more healthy sense of self for my child at this point. So I will do whatever it takes. This isn't about me. This is about coming back to what we agreed to and figuring out what is best for her right now.
Kate
Right. Because it's nothing to do with them either.
Sydney
No, it isn't. So, yeah. So let's talk about it. Tell me what you think. So they hear all of this conversation and all of these, Take all these notes, whatever. They go ghost for two months. They say, we'll get back to you. Yeah, two months. I still didn't have a call with them. So her birthday rolls around, and I guess it was a month and a half, but anyways, her birthday rolls around and they text me like a couple days before, hey, can we call you between X and Y time so you can talk to her? Yes, get on the call, have my little powwow with her, wish her happy birthday, send her gifts overseas, whatnot. And then they send me an email, I think it was a couple days later, saying, hey, we want to revisit the conversation that we had. I'm like, yes. Like, finally.
Ty
Yeah, right.
Sydney
We haven't missed any visits yet. Like, let's get it back on the calendar. Let's. And they. They got the call scheduled with the agency, get on a video call, and I.
Ty
So the agency's mediating this whole thing?
Sydney
Yes. Yeah. The same way that they did with, you know, my approach to them. Mother's intuition, maybe just a pit of nausea in my stomach. Like, I don't know how I knew or even what I thought I knew at that point, but something was wrong and I knew it. And when we got on that call, they were cold. Her adoptive dad was crying and her adoptive mom was pissed. And I, for What? Yeah.
Kate
Why?
Sydney
For what reason? And they have a letter that they've written and they start by saying, we're gonna read you this letter. We're unlikely to entertain questions after we read this. Oh, really?
Ty
Oh, wow. Okay.
Sydney
We're unwilling to entertain questions after. We likely will not facilitate or participate in any other mediated calls with or through the agency after this. This is sort of like our final decision. And really this is just a formality. We told you that we would get back to you. And so here is our explanation of where we're at. And you know, that will be it. And so I'm recording the call, but my camera's off and I'm just listening. And she starts by saying that I have proven to be a danger and manipulative, using their words against them in the context of the openness agreement in order to propagate my own agenda to have a relationship with my daughter. She said, you have weaponized our words against us. As a result of this and a variety of other factors that demonstrate dangerous and toxic behavior, we are null and voiding our open disagreement and reinstating full control. You will be allowed to talk to her around her birthday and around Christmas. If you contact us anytime outside of these designated periods or make initial contact, meaning not in response to contact that we have initiated, we will deem that as a further threat and we will pursue legal action.
Ty
Pursue legal action. That is so like, wow. I. And so there was no other reasonings beyond any of that.
Sydney
When that was it, when I was at the, when I was at the hospital, the day that we were leaving the hospital, I had a social worker on my right and my daughter's adoptive mom on my left. And at this point I hadn't decided for adoption yet. And so I knew that that was the more responsible of the choices for her well being. But it wasn't what I wanted. That was not my desire. And I had. It was last night. They were there, but they were not in the room when I delivered and they were not staying in my room. They had their own space and they came into me before. Came into my room before they went to bed. And they said, we're going to let you have the night to be with her and, and make this decision.
Ty
We're going to let me. Which is very interesting. Like you said, verbiage, the language crucial. Yeah, it is.
Sydney
Because people don't pick up on those little things until after you've been through it either.
Kate
No, you don't. Yeah, you definitely don't.
Ty
Well, honestly, my, my Feeling is though, is that like, like I don't think adoptive parents should even be at the hospital in my opinion. Right.
Kate
I think me looking back on it, like I had three days. You have her whole life.
Ty
Like, like we, you know, I think all, all birth mothers deserve to take that time to be just with them and the baby and adoptive parents, you have the rest of the life. So if the adoption goes through, then, you know, let this birth mother have her time. I don't think your presence really doesn't do anything for the child. And that's what I think. If we remain child centered, the adoptive parents being at the hospital does not do anything for the baby. So at that moment, so you need to just like I don't agree with them being at the hospital, I think it creates a different pressure on birth parents.
Kate
Well then also just that letter, like that had to throw you for a loop. Like, what do you mean? I'm dangerous and toxic.
Ty
Yeah. So I mean, they didn't explain any further. What.
Sydney
Well, so the words that they were referring to, I remember very distinctly. They'll always. I mean, I have nightmares about this now, but at the hospital we did a couple things leading up to creating the foundation for what we thought was going to be a really great relationship. One of those things was we took maternity photos together. I also got my own maternity photos. This was me and my daughter's journey. And I was making these decisions and having these promises made to us, not me. And so I did all of these little things so that she could see the effort that I put in from the day that I found out I was pregnant. One of the other things that we did was when she was born, we did placement photos. Also my idea, we had the adoptive parents come into the hospital and I gave birth alone because I went through the journey alone. But we took, we've got pictures of us, like with all of our hands on her, for example, and pictures of me and her adoptive mom together, holding her, looking at her in the nursery bassinet and all of these things that were supposed to be really, really special.
Kate
Yeah.
Sydney
On the last day, I had a social worker on my left, or I'm sorry, my right. It's time to sign paperwork. And I had my daughter's adoptive mom on my left, left. But it was just the three of us in the room and well, she.
Ty
Was there with you when you signed the paper.
Sydney
She was there when I signed papers. And I'm bawling. I mean, like, you can't, I really just can't explain It. You can't explain it, so I'm not even gonna try. I was a wreck. And the social worker goes through. This is the one that's terminating your parental rights. Gives me a brief nutshell of how that works in logistics. And I'm holding the pen, can't even see the words that I'm signing because I'm crying so hard. And I look over to my daughter's adoptive mom and I said, do you promise you'll never take her from me? And she was crying, and she said it would be ungodly to do so. And to this day, I have quoted her words to her because that has not been the execution of her actions. I'm sorry.
Kate
Rightfully fucking so.
Sydney
You should. That's what I'm saying. I'm not saying it to weaponize these against you.
Kate
Right. This is what you told me and the promises that you told me. She knows what she told you in.
Sydney
Those moments, and it pisses her off because she met her match. I will not quit.
Kate
Yeah.
Sydney
I will never quit. There's not. What do I have to lose?
Kate
That's what we.
Ty
Yeah, we say that, like, at this point, like, we literally have nothing to lose. You've done.
Sydney
You've taken it.
Ty
You've taken it all.
Sydney
Like, you have my heart.
Ty
Yeah.
Kate
Yeah.
Sydney
There is nothing else that you can do to me. So I will fight until my dying breath.
Ty
Yeah. And I think that's one thing that they underestimate, birth parents. That's specifically. Even birth mothers alone are like, we. Once that's done, it's. You've exhausted all. In any of the eggshell, any of the power you believe you have, it's done now because you went back on your promises, and now we're. What are we supposed to do as birth parents? I think a lot of us just.
Kate
Expect us to just, like, roll, get.
Ty
Over it, move on, wait till she's 18. And I've had thousands. And I didn't even realize this until this year, I've had thousands of adoptees write me and say, don't wait until she's 18. Because I turned 18, looked for my bio parents, and they're dead. And so some of the bio parents died months before they turned 18. Like, they. They missed by months. Just like a few days by a few days. And I'm like. Like, I couldn't imagine being adoptee.
Sydney
Oh, my gosh.
Ty
And going to search. And so people like, wait, no. Time isn't guaranteed to us.
Sydney
No.
Ty
And that child is more important than. Than your insecurities adopt a parent or whatever your reasons for not having this contact. And. And those are for adoptees who didn't have an openness agreement at all.
Kate
We've had adoptee souls, too. Don't stop fighting. Keep reaching out. Because obviously, when our children get older, I don't want her to look and say, like, my parents told you to stop. So you just bent over and listen, like, I want my child to see. Like, I will. I continued fighting. I continued trying. I continued all of the things. And it was them putting the wall.
Sydney
Yes.
Ty
And at the end of the day, they do have to answer for that because the.
Sydney
Exactly.
Ty
Adoptee is going to grow up.
Sydney
Yeah.
Ty
They're going to ask the hard questions.
Sydney
So I started the day that. My first day back home from the hospital. That day, I created an email address for her where I could send her letters and poems. I also document everything that I send to her. So if I send her a birthday gift or whatever it is, I take a picture of it, I attach it to the email, and I send it to her for this reason.
Ty
We should do that. I know, it's.
Sydney
Yeah, it's. I do it for my kids now, too, you know, like, then they've got an email address when they're older. And I'm not going to risk losing all of these things that I put together for you, so.
Kate
Right.
Sydney
It's just kind of multifunctional, I suppose. But, yeah, it's. It just became something that as soon as I was a threat to her position in my daughter's life, I became the enemy. And that is a place that I am comfortable being.
Ty
Me, too.
Sydney
I don't care. You know what I mean? It's. And it's not. Again, it's not an ego thing.
Ty
It's not. I think people get confused because they think that. Oh, you're.
Sydney
Oh, for sure.
Ty
But it's. But it's literally out of a desperation of. Through love that I am in this position. And if you want me to put the hat on as being the enemy, that's. I mean, that's. That's. You're doing it, not me.
Sydney
Well, that's our job as parents, too.
Ty
Thank you.
Sydney
And that's the thing that people miss, is that they make it, like, heal your trauma. This is. This is you. I'm sorry, what? Yeah, I just. It doesn't. That doesn't compute. And also, I can't make it make sense. The dots connect. Right.
Kate
And also, just because I placed this child in my eyes, she will always be my child. Always. And I will do anything for my children.
Sydney
And I haven't met a single adoptee unless their natural parents have been a real toxic figure that have said otherwise. In some cases it's even adoptees that did have a toxic natural. Like that's still my mom, that's still my dad at the end of the day. I mean they gave me the opportunity for life. So I've run into maybe one adoptee, maybe that has said I don't classify them as having anything to do with me or where I'm at. Which honestly I think is also unhealed trauma. Because I just think that's just not true.
Kate
Right, right.
Sydney
Yeah. So it all boiled down to the whole concept of being willing to ask the right questions. And that's what kicked off the journey of the book. Because when they told me that I could no longer contact them or use their words against them.
Kate
So they said like after this meeting you cannot contact us ever again.
Sydney
Yes, that they. I can only legal, they said legal action.
Ty
That's, that's a big.
Sydney
Yeah.
Ty
I mean legal action about. Against what? Harassment. Like what would.
Sydney
I'm sure that it would be something of that nature which in my, in.
Ty
My opinion there's any adoptive parents listening. Like if you're willing to legally go after a birth mom that is not going to look very good for you when that adoptee gets older. Because what would that look. Could you imagine being adopted child and like wow, you actually legally attacked my like because for wanting relationship. That is really not, it's not child centered at all. It's. It's that if anything that's ego driven from the adoptive parent like to legally actually and put anyone through a legal process like that is just, it's, it's cruel. It's cruel.
Sydney
It's cruel even when it's in a co parenting situation. I mean legal battles are not fun regardless of if you're in this triangle of adoption or if it's just happening between individuals. It's hard, it's draining, it's not easy for the kid, it's not easy on the individual. So why would you add to that fire? Why would you fuel it? It just doesn't make sense to me. You made a comment about how my daughter's adoptive dad was crying.
Ty
Yeah, like I feel like what I've noticed a lot in just talking to adoptees and just everything like adoptive parents. The mom is very the ringleader and the dad is usually very passive and.
Kate
That soft hearted and it's, it's.
Ty
I'm like it's interesting that then you saying what you said, it's like, it's kind of. This dynamic is interesting because they're all very similar, I feel like.
Sydney
And I really think that's related to the maternal component. I like would be curious to hear your thoughts about this too. Because men don't carry the children that we race. So it's easier for men to be. And this isn't a negative thing, just on a biological level, it's easier to bond with a child because you never carried them to begin with. So there's nothing to be defensive over. Like regardless of this child is my flesh and blood or I'm raising it as my flesh and blood, it doesn't affect the love that I have for this child. But for mothers, especially ones that have carried and bonded with the children before, it does become this territorial claim and need to stake ownership on. You cannot own a person.
Ty
Right.
Sydney
And I hate that about adoption because that's what it becomes is this level of ownership thing. And if you can put your ego aside and do what's truly best for your child, then there is no need to tighten the reins on how much love this child can have in their life.
Kate
Right.
Ty
Love doesn't run out. No, it's infinite. So I mean, yeah, it's one of those things where it's like. I just feel like it's interesting to. Because a lot, like a lot of adoptive dads, I noticed that they're just very passive. And I wonder if that's because like you said, the maternal part of it, it's like, is that like, you know, like territorial? Is it like primal? It's interesting even the biology aspect of it because you're saying that she had biological children. So this was her only adopted child.
Sydney
Correct.
Ty
And did they ever tell you why they were adopting?
Sydney
They said that they felt called to adoption by, I believe their faith.
Ty
Their faith. And I want to bring that up because I think I have also talking to thousands of adoptees and all this situation that it's a lot of. It's very heavily faith based. Like there's a lot of. Even the highest donors on these non profits are Catholic, social, all these. You know what I mean? And it's interesting how like that kind of part. No one talks about that part. But I think it's important because they. That religious influence will affect policy. Yes, inevitably. Right. I mean, so. And you're talking about there's, there's policy changes that are. You're, you've said you pass how many out of four okay.
Sydney
Out of nine, what do you think.
Kate
Birth parents can do to help change adoption or adoptive parents or. Yeah. Or to change things to make it more maybe even legally binding for the adoptive parents.
Ty
More ethical.
Sydney
Yeah. In general. Right. That really is what it boils down to is just the ethics of it. Yeah. I think that there's a lot of things that we can do and that need to be done. And choosing the order that you go in in terms of which mountain are we going to tackle first is crucial for multiple reasons. One of those reasons is if I can get you to agree with me on a fundamental level about some of the basic stuff, then I have a foundation to have established trust and rapport with you to get you to understand these bigger things more. So one of the first things that needs to happen and has been passed is that adoption will be taught in all public education systems in the state of Idaho. Right now it's just parenting, protection, abortion.
Ty
You mean sex ed or kind of like family. Okay.
Sydney
Yeah. Yeah. If we can just agree that people should be educated about what adoption is versus the foster care system, for example.
Kate
Yeah.
Sydney
Then we have a foundation for people that can at least have more knowledge than they had before, regardless of what they end up doing. The next thing that needs to happen is mediators need to be removed. This is a commission paid position. You've heard of this?
Ty
Well, I've heard of the commission based in that. I don't.
Kate
And that we believe there needs to be mediators.
Sydney
Yeah.
Ty
No, no, no. Meteors take them out because you're commodifying children already and there shouldn't be any money.
Kate
My mind was going to. Is like as far as like having like the birth parents.
Ty
Yeah.
Kate
Like outside legal.
Ty
Yeah.
Sydney
Right, right. I was both. Yes, yes. And two different types of mediators. Mediators are that commission paid role that really does just match expectant parents that are considering adoption with families. For every child that is adopted there are 40 helpful families waiting. We have a supply and demand issue.
Ty
Huge problem.
Sydney
And that's why it's so expensive to adopt. And it's also why we run into people that are just uneducated about the process is because there's no margin in explaining this to you. You might change your mind.
Ty
Yeah, yeah.
Sydney
So that has been a huge thing. And then giving birth mothers the knowledge that they can have outside legal representation would be a game changer.
Ty
Huge.
Kate
That should be legal.
Sydney
I think requires conflict of interest to begin.
Kate
It is.
Sydney
It's already illegal. If somebody decided to crack down on it, somebody would get their ass sued.
Ty
Yes.
Sydney
It's just that they were paying for it. Our legal team will make sure that you have representation. So now I've changed that talk track to say our legal representation is going to do the paperwork for you to. Our legal representation is going to represent you. Wrong.
Ty
Wrong.
Sydney
Yes, exactly.
Ty
It's.
Sydney
Or the adoptive parents attorney, like will legally also a conflict of interest. Scrap it.
Ty
Yeah.
Kate
So that's one thing that I regret is that I wish an adult in my life would have said how, hell no, you're not reading it. We're getting you somebody to read these things to you.
Sydney
Yes.
Kate
And explain it to you that way you understand it. That is not affiliated with the adoption agency whatsoever.
Ty
Yeah.
Sydney
Every birth mother needs to understand that. I am pretty certain in all 50 states, written agreements between individuals are legally binding. State supersedes agency.
Ty
Right.
Sydney
So if you have outside legal representation that is not affiliated with the agency that you place through in any regard and you have a contract with individuals, I don't care what the agency says. That's a legally binding document.
Kate
Right, Right.
Sydney
And I would have paid whatever it costs to make this an enforceable agreement. I would not have placed her with these people if I knew that the relationship with my daughter would be compromised because it's detrimental to her sense of identity. It doesn't. I don't care about me. If I cared about me, she'd be with me.
Kate
We say that all the time. I'm like us, them. What does she want? What does she need?
Sydney
We say that all the time. All the time. It's. Yeah, I think that's a good place to start. There's. I mean, there's nine that we post. But the outside legal representation got come down on like, hard. I crushed it because of the money.
Ty
Well, but what was it. What was your defense to that?
Sydney
They were just saying that if we give that. You're going to hate this.
Ty
I want to hear it though, because I think it's important for everyone to hear it. Legal representation, you have to know the.
Sydney
Opposing side so that you can fight it.
Ty
Right.
Sydney
So they're saying that by giving birth parents access to outside legal representation, it becomes a threat, whether it's a predominant threat or a passive threat to the adoptive family. In other words, you cannot control what birth parents do with their life if they become a threat, Are they home? All the stereotypes that we already know that we have, being in the corner of the triangle that we're in, you can't control those things about us. We are unpredictable. We're Dangerous. We are toxic. And for that reason, how dare you allow legal representation for these people that also love.
Ty
That could potentially be a.
Sydney
See so much.
Ty
It doesn't make any sense because they're going off of the premise that you're potentially could be a threat. Well, guess what? Adoptive parents could also become drug addicts, lose their job. They could abuse our children. They could abuse our children. So it's like that, that arguments.
Sydney
No, horrible argument.
Ty
Yeah, that's a horrible argument. I almost feel like that says everything that you're literally gonna like. That's because even, even, even with foster care, for instance. I know it's very different, but I'm saying there. That's why we have CPs and DHS because when they deem a parent who has. Because whatever, they're not dangerous. So we'll have supervised visits. That's when the. It's a whole different ball game that you're worried about birth parents potentially becoming a threat. Right. It's.
Kate
Well, and also I feel like if they're, you know, if they're, they're contracts, I feel like there can be certain things in the contracts and say yes, if you become.
Sydney
Yeah, like easy. That is easy.
Kate
Right, Right. That's what I mean. You could put different clauses in there as, you know, if they become addicted to drugs or they are showing up unannounced all the time or whatever. Like.
Ty
Yeah, you know, so that's, that's, that's horrible argument.
Sydney
So it made me go back to the drawing board because it. This, it just goes back to if you haven't been through it, you don't know. Right. And this applies even to the people that work for these agencies. These people haven't, I mean lots of them haven't been adopted or placed or any of those things. And so you're just talking out of your ass. Literally.
Kate
Right.
Sydney
And I wrote a book called Courageous Considerations. And it is the. Technically, it's a pre placement journaling workbook that breaks down into three segments, category by category. Every question that you don't have to ask, but you should think about and consider if it's relevant to what you're looking for in adoption so that you can have these open dialogues prior to actually signing papers. And if we had that precedence beforehand, all of these legal things that we were just talking about, it wouldn't even matter because I have a relationship with the person that's raising my child now. We have set up what we want. Now both of us feel comfortable entering into a legal agreement that's binding by the state, separate from the agency.
Kate
Right, right.
Sydney
But you have to know what to ask. And if you don't, then of course you're going to say no to outside legal representation because you are afraid of what you don't know.
Kate
Right. And also, I feel like if I would have. If, say I met a family that I really loved and I said, I want to go about it this way. And if they were like, no, no, no, no, no. I said I would have been like, well, it's not a good fit. Yeah, Next one.
Sydney
Next.
Kate
You know what I mean? Until I.
Sydney
2 million couples.
Kate
Right, right.
Sydney
Thank you. Next.
Kate
It's not a good fit then.
Sydney
No, no. But don't compromise what you want for your relationship with your child because you're trying to fit into the outline of something that somebody else has made.
Kate
Yeah.
Sydney
The book is written in a way that I really encourage people to ask the questions objectively because I think that there is a viable threat there of using this tool and saying, when you're interviewing adoptive families, you know, I'm really looking for an openness, openness agreement. I definitely want open adoption. I'm thinking that I want to be involved every other month. Like, what does this look like to you? I just laid out my cards for you. And if I am in line or being interviewed against 40 other families. What do you do in a job interview?
Ty
Right.
Sydney
You sell yourself. It doesn't matter if it's true or not. I don't care who you are. Most people have lied on a resume. And we're not about talking, talking about a job.
Kate
Right, Right.
Sydney
We're talking about the life and well being of my child. And I need to know who you are and what you're about.
Kate
Yeah, absolutely.
Sydney
What's one of the questions that you wish you would have known that you should, like if you could rewind the tape. And this is the question that I wish I would have asked.
Kate
The question I wish I would have asked.
Ty
I think it comes down to if they could close this without me, even without having any say. And I think us being 16, I mean, that's like. I think we deserve a little extra explanation because we were kids, Right. And so that would be the one thing, is that can they take this away from me? Which is exactly what you asked before you signed. And so, I mean, that would be mine.
Sydney
And they still boldface lied to me. And that's where it gets tricky is that, you know, people say things and it doesn't mean that they're untrue necessarily. It just means that they were true in that moment. And that's why that character evaluation and that value and alignments is so crucial. And it's why I ask some of the questions that I do that have nothing to do with adoption. Tell me about a time in your life that you've had to remove somebody from your life. What did that look like and how did you go about it?
Kate
I had to remove my mother from my life and remove her for like a year. And I went about it by. I basically just told her, like, I can't be around you when you're drinking. I had to create boundaries and say, like. Because she was also very degrading towards me and would say really mean things and it was taking away from my peace. And I was like, absolutely. I don't know. Just one day I was like, I am not tolerating this anymore and I will not tolerate it.
Sydney
Well, good for you.
Kate
Yeah. And I took a break from her for like a year. And the only reason why our relationship. And honestly, my life was peaceful and it was fine without my mom. Like, I had to grieve that or whatever, but. And honestly, the only reason why it ever opened up again was because of my children and Nova crying to me, saying she misses her grandma. And. And so now it's opened up slowly, but it's. I've done things in the way where I keep my boundaries. My mom knows my boundaries. She is so far respecting those boundaries. And I keep it very much, like whatever makes me feel safe and comfortable. And so she'll come to my house every once in a while to see the kids, or my kids will go over there for a few hours and then I'll pick them up, but they don't spend the night there.
Sydney
Right.
Kate
So it's all about like just healthy boundaries to protect myself and even opening.
Ty
Up, protecting yourself while also being child centered. Because it's about the kids. Nova wants to see your. You know, so.
Sydney
And you just told me everything that I need to know about your conflict resolution strategies in that question that I asked you. If I had asked that to an adoptive couple, I would have an accurate depiction of how they will elect to evolve inevitable conflict. At any point in our relationship, you withdraw when you need space to heal and to figure things out. You also put others needs above your own because at the end of the day, it came back to the child for you. When you came back, you had more clarity and you knew how to draw boundaries and establish effective communication in order to make sure that this doesn't happen again. Now I know what I need to know about you and who. Who are. I mean, just things that, again, you wouldn't think of because I'm just like, where are you raising my kid? How much do you make? Do you have the financial means to raise my kid? What are your qualifications? Do you know cpr? Like, I don't know. I don't have anything for you. But it's those types of questions that are in this book that if you ask them in that objective way. I didn't tell you why I want to know. I just am listening for key words that can indicate to me who you are as a parent person. And now I know if we align enough on a value system, faith system, family system, that this is going to be good long term for both of us. And if it's not, I can quickly check it off the list and move on.
Ty
Yeah, I think we don't get, I don't think birth parents. You don't get that kind of thorough process, though.
Kate
You know, it's very, it seems very fast and rushed and, and once you.
Ty
Find a family, that's it. It's like. No, it's, it's. And then it's up to us to ask these, like.
Sydney
Right.
Ty
It just, it just add one more.
Sydney
Thing to the plate.
Ty
Yeah.
Kate
Yeah.
Ty
But I also feel like it's important because we're talking about, you know, open adoption. And, you know, open adoption was only created for one reason. It was because no one was adopting babies.
Kate
No one was getting any babies.
Sydney
So how do we get these women.
Ty
Back in to do this adoption? Well, we'll craft this nice little bow around it and say, oh, now we have openness. Now it's, it's. You can still be involved. And it's like we use the word open adoption and it's so nuanced and it's so, like there's a. It's so broad and it, it's not narrowed down enough to even try to like.
Sydney
No.
Ty
Hone in on it, litigate or whatever you want to. You know, it's. It's like, it's so in, in a way, it's like from my opinion now as an adult, I'm like, open adoption is literally, in my opinion, a manipulating tactic. And I don't know how to get. I'm not.
Sydney
It's a sales tactic.
Ty
It is a sal.
Sydney
I. I own an exterior home remodeling business. I do sales for a living. When I look 2020 on what HAP. What was said to me during this process. I'm Like I teach my top closers that. Wow, it's. It's disgusting. I mean, it is disgusting. The tactics that I see these people that are supposed to be creating families making decisions in love for the child, the verbiage that surrounds these decisions and the coercion tactics.
Kate
And it feels very inhumane and like wrong.
Ty
It's unethical. And when you have manipulation involved, it's unethical. When you have coercive tactics, it's unethical. I mean there's nothing we can't get around it. So how do we. The whole system needs to go down and rebuild. Absolutely ruin. Get rid of all the foundations.
Kate
You thought they should have birth moms and adoptees running the system, you know, literally. Yeah.
Sydney
You know what's ironic about. I actually thank you for saying that. So the gal that founded the non profit that I work with that's changing these laws is an adoptive mom.
Kate
Wow.
Sydney
Isn't that incredible?
Ty
We need more of that.
Sydney
We need literally clone her, put her in a cage, study her. She's a unicorn of a woman. She raised her daughter. She adopted her daughter. She raised her, I believe, as a single mom. Don't quote me on that. But I believe she raised her as a single mom. Her daughter's adopted. Her adopted daughter's name is also Sydney, ironically. And she just has a heart for. For reformation in this area. She just sees that this is not. It's not ethical.
Ty
Yes. I've actually had adoptive mom write me recently and she said that she was looking to adoption. She went to the agency and then they were talking about openness and stuff like that. And then the agent, the agency actually pulled the doctor parents aside and said, you don't have to. You can. This is all just nothing. You don't have to agree to any of this. And the adoptive mom left and she wrote a review pretty much. And then now she fights because she's like, this is. And she wanted baby so bad. And she's like. But once that agent told me that I don't have to agree to. I don't have to do anything.
Kate
You want to do this, but you.
Ty
Don'T really have to. She's like, I knew in my. My conscience, my soul. So her desire to be a parent was like pushed to the. And then she was like, ethics come morality. And I'm like, where are you? Like, we need.
Sydney
Seriously, we need more.
Ty
Where are those that have to par parents? Because I think it's an important thing to realize that they also get kind of like, I mean I think adoptive parents also get kind of like, bamboozled a little bit because they're like, oh, it's, it's. It's gonna be fine. And then they get. They don't talk about, did you get trauma therapy? Have you dealt with the fact you can't have kids? Have you, you know, just. Are we interviewing? Are we like, you know what I mean, to make sure it's right.
Sydney
I also think, too, to just, like, I mean, devil's advocate, but in a. In a healthy way. I suppose I could understand being an adoptive family and feeling a lot of pressure in these conversations, especially as people like us start to speak up about the actual secrets that go into this and, like, pull back the curtain and expose these things. Now there's a lot of pressure on me because I've seen and witnessed real people with real lives that really love their kids go through hell. So this book, it needs to be structured in a conversation. And I say that in there, but it's not an interview in the sense that I'm just going to sergeant drill you with these questions. I just want to get to know you. Adoption is the marriage of two families, and we are united in love of this child. That's how it should be. And so if we just, like, lower the guard, set the precedence, like, we sit down, we've just met, it's already awkward. Right. We know that that whole engagement, that whole interaction is just so bizarre, but if it can just really be, you know, I've got this book and I've highlighted some of the questions that are relevant to me, but I want you to reciprocate these questions. I want you to ask anything that you want to know about me. Because the same way that I need to know if it's a good fit for me, you need to know if it's a good fit for you. And it kind of takes away from that just feeling of pressure and trying to please when you are openly creating the space for them to dialogue with you about the same things.
Ty
Yeah, because I also feel like with that pressure that they have, they also have a responsibility with that pressure. And honestly, they are the only ones, in my opinion, in the whole triad that has the most responsibility. You have a moral obligation to make sure that that adoptee is well rounded, educated, connected to whatever they and fulfilled all their needs. And so I feel like, yeah, you have pressure, and it's a responsibility. Are you ready for this? Are you even meant to be an adoptive parent? Because if you are questioning any of these things, you should Reconsider adoption or you need to.
Kate
Or you need to go work on yourself.
Ty
Yeah. Go back your stuff out, figure it out.
Sydney
Then, you know, then come.
Ty
Yeah, because I feel like. I almost feel like it should be required that these adoptive parents go through, like, you know, like, almost a separate from agency wise, like, let's get a total separate psych evaluation. How are. Where are you at with your trauma? How do you. You know what I mean? Like, just certain things. And I. I think we'd have a lot less adoptive parents going back on their word if they are properly vetted or.
Kate
Oh, for sure.
Sydney
We would have less open disagreements, crumble in general if we had the ability to set the precedents effectively.
Ty
Yeah, right.
Sydney
Yeah.
Ty
So I feel like, you know, it's a whole. The whole system needs to just.
Kate
So when is the last time that you've, like, spoken to or saw your daughter?
Sydney
Christmas of last year. They called me two weeks before Christmas and I got to talk to her for a brief moment in time. And then before that it was July and.
Kate
Is there any more for the future, you just are left in the dark.
Sydney
On the limb, really.
Ty
So do you reach out or do they reach out to you?
Sydney
I can't.
Ty
Right. So they. They have. They say you can call us for Christmas.
Sydney
Yeah, they'll text me and like, does this day. This day work? Here are the time frames sort of thing.
Ty
And so.
Kate
And they're telling you that you cannot reach out to ask.
Sydney
Can't ask anything. Can I just got to take their word for it that she's.
Ty
Because they're going to legally go after you if you do.
Sydney
Yeah, that's what they've said. I don't think that they will. Here's the thing. There's a reason that I do this. Now, if you don't want me to talk to you directly, the whole world's gonna hear it.
Ty
Well, people will, as you know. They'll come after you because we. We've experienced and I don't give back.
Kate
And I don't give a word.
Sydney
Sitting here.
Kate
That means people are talking about it.
Ty
Yeah, I mean, like I said, me and Karen, like, we'll wear the hats if we have to be the brunt of this.
Sydney
Should we just all get, like, bad guys?
Ty
Yes.
Sydney
Just like. Yeah, we'll just start a club. Yeah.
Kate
We love our kids so much that we're shitty, you know?
Sydney
Okay. That's a long acronym, but we're gonna figure it out. We'll work on that. But it's. That's. It's just gonna be that and we're just gonna wear them everywhere that we go.
Ty
I feel like, you know, we are the ones that just get. I mean, we've never experienced what we've experienced after talking about it. So I mean it's. I think it's important for us to do it, but I want to honor the bravery that it takes for birth parents to do what we're doing. Even having these discussions is difficult and it's hard.
Kate
And so what is the name of your book again? And where can people find it?
Sydney
Courageous Considerations. It's available on seven, seven different online stores. So Amazon's probably the easiest for most people, I guess to get to get that. And then the name of the nonprofit is called Unplanned. Good.
Kate
Okay.
Ty
Okay.
Sydney
Yeah.
Ty
I would love to get connected any way possible, especially with the policy stuff like.
Kate
Yes.
Sydney
Yeah.
Ty
Because that's the only way any of this works. It's going to work, right? I mean, the only way that we.
Kate
Make changes and then also where can people find you?
Sydney
I have a. I'm available on social media. I created a software application for smartphones and it is a productivity goal training app that uses AI to help people accomplish their goals, heal from trauma, work through things that they're working through. It's very intricate. Intricate. But there's a link to the website and I. Social media is still probably where I respond the most because I, of all of the things that I do, own two businesses, book author, raise kids. I will always stop what I'm doing for a mom that needs help. And I had somebody reach out to me. I think she's in New Jersey. Don't quote me on that though. And she found me through one of the Facebook pages like she had just seen one of my videos and it was like anti adoption was the name of the page or something.
Ty
Oh, wow.
Sydney
But she's pregnant and she's trying to get all of the information and she's a middle aged woman. It wasn't a planned pregnancy. And long story short, she's like, I don't even know where to begin, like what to ask. And I literally sent her the unedited manuscript. I was, it's not even. I was like, it's not even out yet. But like, this is what it's for and I'm not gonna hold back on you just because it's not ready. Like, because I haven't dotted the I's and crossed the T's, you know, so Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, CoachSydney, Curtin, C U R T I n. And then I've got. Yeah. My email on the website and stuff like that, so.
Ty
Great.
Sydney
Wow.
Kate
Yeah. Thank you so much for just coming on here and sharing everything. I love hearing about what you're doing to try to make a difference. And I just. I just really, really hope that somewhere in the future they can wake up and just see that you being involved in her life isn't a negative thing. And I'm sorry.
Sydney
Yeah, I'm sorry too. But for what it's worth, I am really grateful that of all of the people that have been through this, that somebody like you and somebody like me were dealt that hand, because I don't know if there are many people strong enough to handle it.
Ty
I agree.
Sydney
Yeah, I just like, not only feel your heart and that, but if not us, then who. Yeah, who's gonna fix it? Right, for our babies? You know what I mean? There's not many people cut from this cloth that can bear that burden. And if it takes the rest of my life, but I can save one person from what they didn't know, it's gonna be worth it. Absolutely.
Kate
I totally agree.
Ty
We agree.
Sydney
It's such a God thing to run into you guys for real. Like.
Ty
Well, I saw your video 1. I saw one of your videos on Tik Tok and that's when I was like, I mean, I literally hashtag adoption on there. And then you. You're mentioning how I think it was a video of you holding your daughter.
Kate
And saying, that's the one that got me. I didn't even know that's how the first time I ever saw you was that video of you and I. It hit me so hard, cuz I'm like, yeah, yeah. You look at my kids and tell.
Ty
Yeah, look at Nova and tell her.
Sydney
Yeah, right.
Ty
All your.
Sydney
The one that we originally connected on, he probably told you about it too. That one was very shortly after, was the one where I said, and it was either right before or right after your video got posted, saying that I would have chosen different parents. Yes. And it was your friend from Texas that knows you guys. Somehow, some way, she reached out to me and she was like, do you know Tyler and Kate? And I was like, no. She was like, you have to talk to these guys. And she tagged you in the video. And that's when we got in communication. But like, everything happens for. For a reason. And I. Rather than being upset about the things that I can't control, I'm just ready to do something about it. Yep.
Ty
Moving forward. That's all we can do.
Sydney
Yeah.
Kate
Well, thanks for coming today and just so much sharing everything.
Sydney
Thank you.
Ty
Yeah. This summer, Pluto TV is exploding with thousands of free movies. Summer of cinema is here. Feed. Feel the explosive action all summer long with movies like Gladiator, Mission Impossible, Beverly Hills Cop, Good Burger and Transformers. Dark of the Moon. Bring the action with you and stream for free from all your favorite devices. Pluto TV stream now pay never.
Podcast Summary: Cate & Ty Break It Down
Episode: Promises vs Reality: Sydney's Open Agreement Journey
Release Date: June 4, 2025
Hosts: Catelynn (Kate) and Tyler (Ty) Baltierra
Guest: Sydney, a birth mother raising her two biological children while navigating open adoption
In this deeply emotional episode of Cate & Ty Break It Down, hosts Catelynn (Kate) and Tyler (Ty) Baltierra engage in a heartfelt conversation with Sydney, a birth mother who chose to place her child for adoption. Sydney shares her personal journey, the challenges she faced with the adoption process, and the profound impact it has had on her and her family. The discussion delves into the complexities of open adoption agreements, the emotional turmoil of relinquishing parental rights, and the systemic issues within the adoption industry.
Sydney opens up about her unexpected pregnancy during her college years while pursuing a degree in psychology. She describes a tumultuous upbringing marked by trauma and loss, which significantly influenced her decision-making process.
Sydney discusses the immense pressure from her family, particularly her father, who conditioned his support on her decision to place her child for adoption. This pressure stemmed from her desire to avoid repeating the trauma she experienced in her own fractured family.
Determined to ensure her child's safety and well-being, Sydney sought full custody before the child's birth. However, she encountered systemic obstacles, such as the inability to obtain full custody until after the child was born.
Frustrated by these limitations, Sydney decided to proceed with adoption through an agency she found independently, seeking a family that aligned with her hopes for an open relationship with her child.
Sydney shares her experience with the adoption agency, highlighting the superficial nature of adoptive families' profiles and the agency's discouragement of her desired level of openness.
Despite initial optimism, Sydney found that the agency minimized her requests for regular communication and visits, pushing her to agree to less frequent contact than she desired.
After three years of maintaining the agreed-upon six in-person visits annually, the adoptive family began to retract their commitments, citing increased demands and plans to move abroad. This gradual reduction in communication left Sydney feeling abandoned and disrespected.
The adoptive parents' move to France further complicated the relationship, enforcing strict limitations on any future contact and effectively nullifying the open agreement.
Sydney expresses profound sorrow over the unraveling of promises made by the adoptive parents, highlighting the emotional toll on both her and her children. She regrets not being equipped with the right questions during the placement process to ensure a more secure and fulfilling relationship post-adoption.
Sydney also discusses the ripple effects of her decision on her other child, who suffers from the loss of her sister, emphasizing the often-overlooked impact of adoption on siblings.
A significant portion of the conversation focuses on the shortcomings of the adoption system, particularly the lack of transparency, insufficient legal protections for birth parents, and the profit-driven nature of adoption agencies. Sydney advocates for comprehensive policy changes to protect birth parents' rights and ensure ethical practices within the adoption industry.
Sydney introduces her book, "Courageous Considerations," a pre-placement journaling workbook designed to help birth parents ask the right questions and establish clear, enforceable open adoption agreements.
The episode concludes with Sydney emphasizing the importance of advocacy and systemic reform to protect the interests and emotional well-being of birth parents and their children. She provides information about her book and nonprofit organization, Unplanned, aimed at supporting unplanned pregnancies and fostering more ethical adoption practices.
Resources Mentioned:
This episode of Cate & Ty Break It Down offers a raw and unfiltered look into the realities of open adoption from a birth mother's perspective. Sydney's story underscores the need for more robust support systems, better education for birth parents, and ethical reforms within the adoption industry to ensure that the promises made during the adoption process are honored and that the well-being of the child remains paramount.
For those interested in learning more or seeking support, Sydney's book "Courageous Considerations" and her nonprofit organization Unplanned provide valuable resources and tools to navigate the complexities of adoption.