Loading summary
Sanjay Gupta
We all know the Internet has a lot to say, especially when it comes to medicine and health. But you know, as I've been on the Internet lately, it seems like supplements have become a particular fascination.
Sleep Number
Top 10 supplements you should be taking.
Dr. Peter Cohen
Supplements I love that you may not.
Interviewer
Know about and might want to try.
Dr. Peter Cohen
Starting off with Tian amino acids, they're.
Sanjay Gupta
Often touted as something close to miracle drugs.
Dr. Peter Cohen
Something else I take every single day is my Inositol.
Interviewer
This has done a incredible things for my hormone balance.
Dr. Peter Cohen
I also take B12 every single day. As well as clinical evidence that supplementing with something called methyl folate can be very, very effective at treating anxiety and even effective at treating depression.
Sanjay Gupta
But look, I'm sure you realize this. You gotta be careful and keep in mind just about everyone is trying to make a buck off of you every time you're going on the Internet and doing a Google search for any kind of health condition. So let's talk about supplements today. What can they do? What can't they do? What do we really know about supplements? How good is the data? And how can you even know for sure what you're actually buying? To be honest, the answer to that last question, you really kind of can't. And that's because of a 1994 law called the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act. DSHEA going to talk more about this in the podcast, but here's an explanation.
Interviewer
Of what it is from the Food.
Sanjay Gupta
And Drug Administration's YouTube channel.
FDA Representative
DSHEA defined dietary supplements as a category of foods. So they must comply with requirements that apply to food as well as the dietary supplement specific requirements. Unlike prescription drugs, FDA does not have the authority to approve dietary supplements or their labeling before products are introduced to the market.
Sanjay Gupta
So the law basically allowed manufacturers to sell untested pills and powders as long as they didn't claim the product would treat or cure a disease. Now, since it was passed, everything changed. Annual industry revenues grew from 4 billion to 70 billion. So today I'm going to ask supplement safety advocate Dr. Peter Cohen for some help help in navigating the risks and rewards of supplements. Dr. Cohen is an associate professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School and a general internist at Cambridge Health alliance, where he leads the supplement research program. I'm Dr. Sanjay Gupta, CNN's chief medical correspondent. This is chasing life.
Sleep Number
We all sleep, but no two sleepers are the same.
That's why sleep number smart beds are designed to adapt to you. With sleep number it's easy, and your side of the bed can be totally different from your partner's why Choose a Sleep Number Smart bed so you can.
Sleep just the way you like.
The only bed that lets you make each side firmer or softer whenever you like your Sleep Number setting and now save up to $800 on select sleep Number Smart Beds limited time exclusively at a Sleep Number store near you. See store or sleepnumber.com for details.
Indeed
This episode is brought to you by Indeed. When your computer breaks, you don't wait for it to magically start working again. You fix the problem. So why wait to hire the people your company desperately needs? Use Indeed's sponsored jobs to hire top talent fast. And even better, you only pay for results. There's no need to wait. Speed up your hiring with a $75 sponsored job credit@ Indeed.com podcast terms and conditions apply.
Interviewer
How did you get interested in the world of supplements?
Dr. Peter Cohen
So I first got interested because of my patients. So I'm a primary care doc and take care of patients outside of Boston here in Somerville. When I started out in practice, I wasn't really focused on supplements at all. In fact, I just thought they were expensive placebos really that people were using on their own and didn't really affect medical care. That really changed over the years because I started to see that my patients were getting harmed by these weight loss pills from Brazil. And when we took a closer dive, the harm was that patients would have panic attacks or end up in the hospital with damage to their kidneys. When we looked at the contents of the pills, I was struck by how how pharmaceutical drugs that had never been approved here in the States were ending up in these pills. And then my patients were taking them and experiencing harm. So it was that experience that led my interest into this area. What are patients doing on their own and how might that be harming them?
Interviewer
You're talking about pills in this case that were imported from another country, Brazil. In this case. Were you seeing the same stuff ultimately in pills that were purchased in the United States?
Dr. Peter Cohen
Right. So I actually thought this was just a problem of weight loss pills from Brazil, but it was within the community here in Boston and we were publishing and working on getting the word out about it, going to local churches, talking to the community. It was at that time that I got a call from the fda, and the FDA told me, you know, Peter, what you're seeing in Boston with these imported weight loss pills from Brazil is a pattern that we're seeing across the country in weight loss dietary supplements.
Interviewer
Let me just back up for one second and ask for some definitions, some basics Here, the word supplement typically means to add, you know, whatever it may be. Is there an accepted definition of supplement when it comes to the medical world?
Dr. Peter Cohen
So what we're talking about here are things called dietary supplements, and it doesn't really have any meaning beyond the legal term. So basically, when the law was passed that regulates supplements, the law was passed in 1994 that defined this term, dietary supplement. It's really a legal term defined by Congress.
Interviewer
The law in 1994, Dshea, I think you're talking about, first of all, what is that law? And I think the perception often is that there is not a lot of regulation, regulation around supplements. So what, what is the regulation?
Dr. Peter Cohen
So supplements fall under DSHEA, this 1994 law.
Interviewer
What does that stand for again?
Dr. Peter Cohen
Dietary Dietary Supplement Health and Education act of 1994. And DSHEA is the. The current framework that all dietary supplements are sold in. Now, that law in 1994 was initially being designed to better regulate vitamins and minerals. What unfortunately happened, unfortunately, in my opinion, was that that same structure was expanded to include botanicals, all nature of botanicals, many different types of extracts, like, let's say a cow, thyroid extract, live microorganisms like both bacteria and yeast that are sold as probiotics, protein powders, amino acids. All this was lumped together under that same framework that was being created to regulate vitamins and minerals. And all of them were called dietary supplements or dietary ingredients.
Interviewer
If you think about a prescription medicine, I think people are pretty confident that it's gone through these clinical trials of safety and efficacy and things like that. What about with dietary supplements? What can the public reasonably expect if they say that this supplement has been regulated?
Dr. Peter Cohen
Yeah, I think we have a false impression of what regulation means. So the regulations really kick in after the fact. The FDA is in the position of looking for problems out in the marketplace after supplements are being sold and then working to try to identify the products, which is incredibly difficult because they don't have a effective system to detect harms and then to try to remove those dangerous products. So while those regulations exist for practical purposes, it's companies selling us whatever they choose to declare and identify as a dietary supplement. They have rules about certain manufacturing rules. The plant needs to be sterile, for example. But it's not like FDA inspector checks. The plant, ensures it's sterile before supplements are sold on the marketplace. So everything's retrospective after these products are already on the marketplace.
Interviewer
So someone can come up with a supplement, start to sell it to the public. I mean, person could go to a store, pay with a credit card, buy something like this. And unless, as you're saying, it's found to cause some sort of harm or. Or if the manufacturing facility is found to not be abiding by good manufacturing practices, in retrospect, a lot of people could take it before it might be potentially withdrawn from the market.
Dr. Peter Cohen
Correct?
Interviewer
That sounds like a pretty scary system.
Dr. Peter Cohen
It's a system that emphasizes access and minimizes the assurances of safety, or at least leaves safety in the manufacturer's court.
Interviewer
Let me ask you, just as a person who's very focused on his health, and I know you are as well, how many people do you think, or what percentage of the population do you think need supplements?
Dr. Peter Cohen
My thinking is that, and this is how I practice in my primary care practice, is that unless a person has trouble, a disease that either inhibits absorption of ingredients in the intestines or is likely to do so in the future, those are patients who I do think need multivitamins and other vitamins. My clinical experience is that regardless of how people are eating, as long as people are not on a highly restrictive diet, that they are going to get sufficient vitamins and minerals. So even if they're eating mainly manufactured processed foods or they're growing everything in their own garden because of supplement supplementation, I'm not seeing serious vitamin deficiencies in my practice. So I'm not recommending that patients take multivitamins routinely.
Interviewer
So just to be clear, what are some of the conditions you're talking about where someone may not be absorbing as well?
Dr. Peter Cohen
Well, a very common thing would be if someone's had stomach surgery, like gastric bypass surgery, part of the stomach is removed, and in that situation, they're not able to absorb all the vitamins when.
Interviewer
They'Re eating things like gluten sensitivities as well. Would stuff like that fall into that category?
Dr. Peter Cohen
Absolutely. If you have untreated celiac disease or untreated gluten sensitivity, what that's going to do is jam up the mechanism there in the stomach to absorb the vitamins. But once it's treated, if someone is avoiding gluten and their celiac disease is well controlled, it's certainly reasonable to continue a multivitamin, but it might not be necessary.
Interviewer
Got it. But what about the safety issue again, though? Are multivitamins generally considered safe then? Or do you sort of lump them together with some of your same concerns about supplements overall?
Dr. Peter Cohen
No, I consider multivitamins to be safe. There have been very unusual cases. There was a case years ago in which people were being harmed by multivitamins. And it turned out that one of the heavy metals was very high levels because of a very serious manufacturing problem. Like very high levels, like a thousand times what it should have been.
Interviewer
Wow.
Dr. Peter Cohen
And patients, hair was falling out, people were getting very sick, visiting the doctors, you know, we're talking about like very small number of products over decades. The great majority of multivitamins are safe and the clinical trials have demonstrated that they won't harm you. So that's why I don't clump them with the categories. What I would I term high risk dietary supplements, which are more likely to.
Interviewer
Be risky to help weight loss supplements, some of the herbals, things like that. You'd put in the higher risk category.
Dr. Peter Cohen
You got it. Some of the sports supplements and some of the sexual enhancement supplements as well.
Interviewer
You made this comment to me last time we spoke again that even if you had a sort of standard American diet, and we're talking about maybe eating fast food from time to time, cereals, things like that, the way that food is fortified, maybe not like this all over the world, but at least in the United States, that for the vast majority of people, again, unless they've had some sort of intestinal surgery or something like that, they. They're probably not going to need supplements. I remember you saying that and it really stuck out to me. Like even bread is fortified. You may say, look, I'm not eating a salad every day, but I am eating a standard American diet. So for the most part, while that may not be the healthiest in terms of supplementation, I shouldn't necessarily need anything.
Dr. Peter Cohen
That's precisely the reason why I don't think the majority of adults need multivitamins. Because if you're cooking everything from lots of fruits and vegetables in your own kitchen, or you're buying those breads, milk, cereals that are available everywhere, you're going to be getting the vitamins you need. Unless you have very restricted diet or one of those health conditions we were talking about earlier.
Interviewer
You've been at this for a long time. Do you take supplements?
Dr. Peter Cohen
I don't, but if my doctor recommended I should, I would start and your.
Interviewer
Doctor would recommend because they would look at Peter's lifestyle and say, hey, you're probably not getting enough of X, Y.
Dr. Peter Cohen
Or Z. Oh, right. Let's say I was diagnosed with a condition that was interfering with my absorption and my doc recommended I should take a multivitamin. I certainly would take one.
Interviewer
So if you sort of extend that argument, if you look at something like vitamin D, for example, people who may have gotten their vitamin D levels checked, found to be deficient. They're asked then to take supplementation. And then you hear varying doses, 1000mg, 2000mg, 4000mg. How good is the data then if you're trying to figure out dosing or whether to take something at all?
Dr. Peter Cohen
Yeah, I think that's a good point. I think that's something that's evolving and it's something that's not. There hasn't been much attention to study that. A recent example of this is really with iron supplementation. So when I was in medical school, if someone was deficient in iron, we would recommend they take an iron supplement in the morning, an iron supplement at night, do that indefinitely until their iron stores came back up. More recently, a few years ago, there was a small study, but one that strongly suggested that that was actually all that iron was actually interfering with absorption iron. So it would be better to take iron one day, not to take it the next day, and then to take it the other day. So just take one pill every other day. And that's become more the standard of care recently of routinely repleting iron deficiencies, actually greatly decreasing the amount of iron we give. That's an example of. And that study is just. That's not based on a tremendous amount of data. And that just goes to show us how little this area is researched and how much more we do need research in this area to better understand what would be the best approach to repleting vitamin levels at different levels, but also with people with different conditions, they might require different regimens and different dosages, and that's not well studied.
Interviewer
Yeah. It does seem like the manufacturers, as you were sort of alluding to, they would prefer you take more of their product, obviously. And if the data is not required from a regulatory standpoint, will we ever have that data? I mean, who's going to fund those sorts of trials if the data is not required and people actually would prefer to sell as much of their product in the first place as possible.
Dr. Peter Cohen
Right. I think you're getting at a core concern I have with the current regulatory framework that really inhibits us moving forward. It's that there is no incentive for manufacturers to conduct carefully done clinical trials. One thing we haven't talked about yet is that one other part of the law is that supplements can claim to have health effects.
Interviewer
Yes.
Dr. Peter Cohen
Without it being proven in humans.
Interviewer
Yeah.
Dr. Peter Cohen
Since you can do that without doing a clinical trial, what's the incentive to investing all that money Millions of dollars to do a clinical trial. The only potential outcome is negative, because if you're right, you were already advertising it as it was beneficial to your health and all you did was prove that your claim is correct. But more likely, it turns out, doesn't really work like you had hoped it did, and all that money is wasted and then you've got a problem. But the good news, I guess, is that you can still keep on selling if it does work, even when the studies come out negative.
Interviewer
But that seems like a huge problem, though, because you do hear these outlandish claims. And I think people who are well intentioned, you know, I think there's part of what has driven the use of supplementation, which seemed to increase even more so during the pandemic as people wanted to take greater control of their health, is that they read a claim that this is going to cure your back pain, it's going to help you live longer, it's going to whatever. And they believe it, understandably. And yet there's no accountability for those claims. And even when it comes to harm, it's only after the fact. So not only may it not work, could potentially harm you. And you have just bought this product with your credit card from a legitimate looking store. Again, that seems problematic, especially when you're doing it in pursuit of good health.
Dr. Peter Cohen
I absolutely agree. And one of the problems with supplements compared to traditional foods is that when we buy traditional food, we're using all our senses to try to determine if we should put this into our body. So when we buy broccoli, if it's yellow, if it's mushy, if it's getting soft and smells bad, we're like, you know, yes, it's broccoli, but no thank you. And the thing about supplements is they're in those capsules, usually they're closed off, right? There's no smell. And unfortunately, given the regulatory framework that we have here in the States, we can't be assured of the quality of that powder. And we also can't be assured of those health benefits that are written on the bottle.
Sanjay Gupta
We're going to take a quick break here, but when we come back, we're going to take a look at some popular supplements that could be sitting in your cabinet right now.
Sleep Number
This podcast is supported by Sleep Number.
We all sleep, but for each of.
Us, our sleep is unique. Sleep Number Smart beds are made to adapt to your changing needs from day to day. Using the science of your sleep, they effortlessly adjust to optimize your comfort. So whether you need softer or firmer, cooler or warmer, you can enjoy your.
Best sleep because it's just right for you.
Plus, with our Climate series, smart beds that cool up to 20 times faster than a leading competitor and optional dual temp layers, you'll stay perfectly cool even when summer doesn't. Whether you're looking to change your bed's firmness whenever you like, or treat your partner to custom settings on their side of the bed or Sleep Number Smart Bed tracks the evolution and improvement of your sleep, giving you personalized insights designed to make each night's rest even better. Why choose a Sleep Number Smart bed so you can sleep just the way you like. The only bed that lets you make each side firmer or softer whenever you like your sleep number setting and now save up to $800 on select sleep Number Smart Beds limited time exclusively at a Sleep number store near you.seestore or sleepnumber.com for details.
This podcast is supported by Wonderful Pistachios. Whether you're running between meetings, dropping off the kids or listening to a podcast, Wonderful Pistachios is the perfect healthy snack for when hunger strikes. Each 1 ounce serving of Wonderful Pistachios contains 6 grams of protein, giving you over 10% of your daily value. It's one of the highest protein nuts out there. The fact that Wonderful Pistachios is a complete protein, providing you with all nine essential amino acids is why these little green wonders pack such a protein punch and that satisfying crack of opening each shell? That's like snack meditation. You can also do Wonderful Pistachios no shells for that grab and go ease. Wonderful Pistachios come in a variety of flavors and sizes, perfect for enjoying with family and friends or taking them with you on the go. When you're looking for a protein pick me up or a late night tasty treat, get snacking on Wonderful pistachios. Visit wonderful pistachios.com to learn more.
Dell
This podcast is supported by Dell Introducing the new Dell AI PC powered by the Intel Core Ultra processor. It's not just an AI computer, it's a computer built for AI. That means it's built to help do your busy work for you so you can fast forward through editing images, designing presentations, generating code, debugging code, running lots of apps without lag, creating live translations and captions, summarizing meeting notes, extending battery life, enhancing security, finding that file you were looking for, managing your schedule, meeting your deadlines, responding to Jim's long emails, leaving all the time in the world for more you time and for the things you actually want to do. No offense, Jim. Get A new Dell AI PC starting at 7.49.99@dell.com AI PC how those ahead? Stay ahead.
Interviewer
So it is a little bit buyer beware or a lot buyer beware when it comes to these things. I did a deep dive on a few supplements because I was very interested in the use of certain supplements for pain specifically. So, for example, the four that I came up with for pain, potentially CoQ10, which helps seemingly with mitochondrial function, which can help with the sort of pain that one might develop after intense workouts or even with statins. Sometimes if you're taking a cholesterol lowering medication, it can cause these muscle aches. There seem to be pretty good data to me, at least on the use of CoQ10 for that. Is that something you've heard of?
Dr. Peter Cohen
I've definitely heard of it. My take is that it's. The totality of the evidence does not suggest that's the case to me. So I don't recommend to my patients. But it's a great example of what we're talking about, which is that an educated consumer should be able to take CoQ10 if they wish to, to try to treat pain after working out or when they're taking their cholesterol medication. I think that that makes perfect sense just because my assessment of it is that I'm not convinced that it works. I don't think that should limit consumers and my patients from trying it if they'd like to.
Interviewer
Fair. I think that's a really sensible approach. I think as physicians, we probably have some obligation to make sure patients aren't harming themselves. But beyond that, who am I to say that, look, that didn't work for you, even if they say it did. But again, getting to this point, and I think you've said this already, Peter, but the totality of evidence for many of these things is just not going to be great. And to take it a step further, it may never be great because there's no requirement for that evidence to be great. If you're looking for great evidence to do or not do something when it comes to supplements, you may not find it.
Dr. Peter Cohen
I agree. And I also agree that the placebo effect is something that we should take very seriously. If someone is taking something that's safe and it's helping them function better, be more relaxed, have less pain, regardless if we can understand it biomedically or not, I definitely think that should be encouraged.
Interviewer
The four that I was talking about, I'm just going to name them you don't have to, because again, I don't think there's going to be great evidence behind these. But there was better evidence in my estimation than there was around a lot of other things, specifically with regard to pain. So COQ10, as I mentioned, magnesium, which I thought was really interesting. Magnesium I saw for lower back pain, which I thought had decent evidence behind it. Turmeric was another one. And then willow bark, which probably should be no surprise because it has some of the same active ingredients as aspirin, salicylic acid. So those were the four. But again, I think this is such an important point. If you're looking for great evidence behind any of these things, you're probably not going to find it and you may never find it unless the regulatory framework changes and that evidence starts to become required. Yeah.
Dr. Peter Cohen
One thing we haven't talked about yet is that there's no manufacturing standards for how something's prepared. So let's say willow bark has been used for hundreds of years for pain in a traditional medicine practice. And in that practice, though, there would be a specific way to prepare the bark before it's consumed by humans. So it wouldn't just be like willy nilly. There's going to be a very specific process. How is the bark treated first? Is it dried? What's that liquid that's used? Is it water or is it a different solvent? Do you drink as a tea? Do you then boil it down or somehow isolate it or distill it? And all of this would be standardized in traditional medicine practice, allowing for willow bark to be effective for the reason that it's being used. So it's important for consumers to understand that buying commercial willow bark dietary supplements in the United States, there's no requirement that any standard practice here is used. The only requirement is that a manufacturer make up the steps that they use. They write it down like the recipe and they keep it in their factory. And they do that same thing every time. They do every batch. So it's. There is a perfect example of how I believe our regulatory framework doesn't allow us to channel the potential benefits of the botanicals because we've lost all the standardization that's required to make high quality botanicals.
Interviewer
If I was a very well intentioned supplement, I wanted to put out really good supplements because I felt like they could be helpful. Like, how would I convince someone like you that this is a good supplement?
Dr. Peter Cohen
Yeah. Well, fortunately we do have a workaround and how it generally works today is there's a few companies that the manufacturer that you could hire to do a deep dive into your practice. So two examples that I'm big fans of usp, US Pharmacopoeia and nsf. NSF I've collaborated with on many research.
Interviewer
Studies and National Science Foundation.
Dr. Peter Cohen
No, it's just NSF International. You probably have many things at home from your dishwasher to pipes in your house.
Interviewer
Got it.
Dr. Peter Cohen
They're tested by nsf. They run an excellent dietary supplement testing program. And both those groups do deep dives into the quality of manufacturing. So a manufacturer would pay one of those two groups, for example, and they would take a look. They look at the manufacturing, they look at the original ingredients that are coming in and that at the end of the line when consumers are going in to purchase this online or in a store, that the label accurately represents what's in the product. So if a company is spending that kind of money to ask an external group like NSF or USP to analyze every step of the process, that's what would make me comfortable that what's on the label is in the product. However, with a few caveats. One is that manufacturing process. This isn't assuring that it's made in a traditional way. It's just saying it's made in the way that the company thinks it's being made. And the other thing is those claims, if you say something's good for gut health or will boost your immunity, those claims are not assessed by these companies. The companies are just looking at is the powder in the bottle the same as what's on the label? That's a very good start. But obviously we need more accurate information about the claims and ideally the manufacturing process. So how do I go about finding the brand of willow bark extract that is going to be accurately labeled? Here's my tips. Number one is go to one of those two companies or nonprofits websites and they on their website will list the all the supplements that they have certified.
Interviewer
That's good to know.
Dr. Peter Cohen
So you, you find their dietary supplement certification section and you look up willow bark. Are there any willow bark supplements that have been certified by either of those two? Then you go purchase that individual brand. Other tips? Sometimes, unfortunately you might be looking for an ingredient that hasn't been certified. So the next best thing I would recommend if you can't find something that is certified by one of those two firms or other. There are some other high quality programs, particularly in the sports supplement field. But if you can't find something, then my recommendation would be to purchase supplements only with one ingredient on the label and that makes no health claims. If you want to try willow bark extract and you can't find any that are NSF or usp, I'd recommend going to a retailer you trust and purchasing something that just lists willow bark extract on a label and does not say anything about pain or anything else. And try that.
Interviewer
Yeah, that makes sense. A retailer you trust with Amazon. I mean, would you find reputable products on Amazon?
Dr. Peter Cohen
Absolutely. But do I trust Amazon to have vetted the products so that I know that every product on Amazon is reputable? Absolutely not. Amazon has tried to put into place some safety factors, but my understanding from multiple different studies, including our own from my colleagues, some of which you bought on Amazon, is that for reasons that we don't know exactly for why that program is not really working that well, it is possible that it's because those certifications that are required are very easy maybe to find online and fabricate.
Interviewer
So you, you're not a supplement taker. Have you ever, I mean, ever tried it? Or have you ever been curious about trying some. Or melatonin? My kids take melatonin, for example, or ashwagandha. That's another one that's gotten a lot of steam lately.
Dr. Peter Cohen
Everything I know about the manufacturing concerns me, so I can't be assured of what I'm getting. I think I would be more supplement curious and experimentational if I had a sense that I could get precisely the same formulation that's been studied in trials that are beneficial. And outside of vitamins and minerals, I don't have that assurance.
Interviewer
Peter, I always learn a lot from you. I really appreciate it. It's a complicated field and again, I have a lot of sympathy for the folks who are probably listening to a podcast like this because I think most people are genuinely in pursuit of good health. So hopefully this helps people navigate through that. Thanks for your time.
Dr. Peter Cohen
Great to be here.
Sanjay Gupta
That was my conversation with Dr. Peter Cohen. Thanks so much for listening. Chasing Life is a production of CNN Audio. Our podcast is produced by Aaron Mathewson, Jennifer Lai, Grace Walker, Lori Galleretta, Jesse Remedios, Sofia Sanchez, Kira Daring and Madeleine Thompson. Andrea Kane is our medical writer. Our senior producer is Dan Bloom. Amanda Seeley is our showrunner, Dan Dijulla is our technical director. And the executive producer of CNN Audio is Steve Lichtai, with support from Jamis Andrest, John Dionora, Alex Maniserie, Robert Mathers, Lainey Steinhardt, Nicole Pessarou and Lisa Namorow. Special thanks to Ben Tinker and Nadia Kanang of CNN Health and Wendy Brundage.
Sleep Number
We all sleep, but no two sleepers are the same.
That's why Sleep Number Smart beds are designed to adapt to you. With Sleep Number it's easy, and your side of the bed can be totally different from your partner's. Why choose a Sleep Number Smart bed so you can sleep just the way you like. The only bed that lets you make each side firmer or softer whenever you like your Sleep Number setting. And now save up to $800 on select sleep Number Smart Beds limited time exclusively at a Sleep Number store near you. See store or sleepnumber.com for details.
CNN
Live Aid brought together the world's biggest musicians for one important cause. Now, 40 years later, a new CNN original series explores how it came Live Aid When Rock and Roll Took on the world. Sunday at 9 on CNN.
Episode: Did you take your vitamins today? Maybe you don’t have to
Host: Dr. Sanjay Gupta
Guest: Dr. Peter Cohen, Associate Professor of Medicine at Harvard Medical School
Release Date: July 11, 2025
Dr. Sanjay Gupta opens the episode by highlighting the rampant popularity of dietary supplements on the Internet. He notes the surge in interest and sales, prompting a deeper examination of their true benefits and risks.
Dr. Sanjay Gupta [00:01]: "We all know the Internet has a lot to say, especially when it comes to medicine and health. But you know, as I've been on the Internet lately, it seems like supplements have become a particular fascination."
The conversation quickly shifts to specific supplements that have gained traction, including amino acids, inositol, B12, and methyl folate. Dr. Peter Cohen shares his personal regimen, emphasizing supplements he believes in based on clinical evidence.
Dr. Peter Cohen [00:24]: "I also take B12 every single day. As well as clinical evidence that supplementing with something called methyl folate can be very, very effective at treating anxiety and even effective at treating depression."
Dr. Gupta delves into the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act (DSHEA) of 1994, explaining its pivotal role in shaping the supplement industry. He underscores the lack of pre-market approval by the FDA, allowing manufacturers significant leeway in selling supplements.
Dr. Sanjay Gupta [01:25]: "Unlike prescription drugs, FDA does not have the authority to approve dietary supplements or their labeling before products are introduced to the market."
Dr. Cohen expands on the implications of DSHEA, highlighting how it has transformed the market, with annual revenues soaring from $4 billion to $70 billion.
Dr. Sanjay Gupta [01:46]: "Everything changed. Annual industry revenues grew from 4 billion to 70 billion."
The duo discusses the inherent risks in the current regulatory environment. Dr. Cohen categorizes supplements into low-risk (e.g., multivitamins) and high-risk categories (e.g., weight loss pills, sports supplements).
Dr. Peter Cohen [05:44]: "That's what we're talking about here are things called dietary supplements, and it doesn't really have any meaning beyond the legal term."
They discuss real-world scenarios where supplements have caused harm, such as weight loss pills imported from Brazil leading to panic attacks and kidney damage.
Dr. Peter Cohen [04:45]: "I started to see that my patients were getting harmed by these weight loss pills from Brazil."
A pivotal part of the discussion revolves around whether the average person requires supplements. Dr. Cohen asserts that most individuals with a standard diet do not need multivitamins, as fortification in common foods generally suffices.
Dr. Peter Cohen [09:46]: "My clinical experience is that regardless of how people are eating, as long as people are not on a highly restrictive diet, that they are going to get sufficient vitamins and minerals."
He emphasizes that supplements should be considered primarily for those with specific absorption issues or dietary restrictions.
The conversation turns to the paucity of robust clinical data supporting many supplements. Dr. Cohen expresses skepticism about the efficacy claims made by manufacturers, using CoQ10 as an example for pain management.
Dr. Peter Cohen [23:18]: "The totality of the evidence does not suggest that's the case to me. So I don't recommend to my patients."
He highlights the challenges in conducting necessary research due to the lack of regulatory requirements compelling manufacturers to fund large-scale trials.
Dr. Peter Cohen [16:38]: "There's no incentive for manufacturers to conduct carefully done clinical trials."
To assist consumers, Dr. Cohen provides practical advice on selecting reputable supplements. He recommends seeking certifications from organizations like US Pharmacopeia (USP) and NSF International, which verify the quality and accurate labeling of supplements.
Dr. Peter Cohen [27:31]: "If a company is spending that kind of money to ask an external group like NSF or USP to analyze every step of the process, that's what would make me comfortable that what's on the label is in the product."
He cautions against relying solely on retailers like Amazon for trustworthy supplements, noting potential quality control issues.
Dr. Peter Cohen [31:01]: "My understanding from multiple different studies... it's possible that... it's not really working that well."
The interviewer shares a personal investigation into supplements for pain relief, mentioning CoQ10, magnesium, turmeric, and willow bark. Dr. Cohen remains cautious, reiterating the limited evidence supporting their efficacy.
Dr. Peter Cohen [25:51]: "There is a perfect example of how I believe our regulatory framework doesn't allow us to channel the potential benefits of the botanicals."
Despite his reservations, he acknowledges the potential placebo effect and supports consumer choice when supplements are safe.
Dr. Peter Cohen [24:35]: "If someone is taking something that's safe and it's helping them... I definitely think that should be encouraged."
Concluding the episode, Dr. Cohen underscores the necessity for enhanced regulation and more comprehensive research to truly understand the benefits and risks of dietary supplements. He advocates for informed consumer choices, emphasizing the importance of verified quality and accurate labeling.
Dr. Peter Cohen [32:20]: "I think I would be more supplement curious and experimental if I had a sense that I could get precisely the same formulation that's been studied in trials that are beneficial."
Dr. Gupta wraps up by expressing gratitude for the insightful discussion, aiming to empower listeners in their pursuit of health.
This episode of Chasing Life offers a critical examination of the dietary supplement industry, shedding light on the complexities of regulation, safety, and efficacy. Listeners are encouraged to approach supplements with informed caution, prioritizing verified quality and evidence-based benefits.