
Loading summary
Casey
You have gifts. You have unique gifts that will be a particular blessing to the people you're called to serve. Now, in ways unique to you, I can be who God has made me to be, to be a benefit to others. When you lean into the gifts God has given you, you're better able to bless authentically and to be a benefit to others. Lean into the gifts that God has given you and watch what heaven can do through you. Hello, Casey.
Scott
Hello, Scott. Good to see you again.
Casey
We get to dive into some really interesting Kirtland revelations where the Saints were dealing with some perplexing questions.
Scott
Casey, and questions that still kind of resonate in the church today to varying degrees.
Casey
Should we dive in? This just comes like a day after section 45, which we talked about last week. And Joseph has received the laws of the church, right? He's received section 45 with the signs of the times. Now, the next few revelations here are going to address some unusual spiritual manifestations that had been happening among new converts in Kirtland. Those converts became particularly enamored with the gifts of the Spirit and instructions in the Book of Mormon about how to conduct themselves. There's no set, set way to like deal with this stuff in this early era. This is 1831. What's acceptable practice, what's not acceptable practice? What gifts of the Spirit are real and what gifts are not real? And you're going to drop us into the IMMED context. But the next several revelations, Casey, from section 46, 49 and 50 is the same stuff, right? Same issues. It's a young church in the midst of growing pains, trying to understand orthodoxy and orthopraxy. What is acceptable doctrine, what's acceptable practice? These revelations are going to be very helpful in regulating the church and helping us to avoid deception.
Scott
Yeah, the church is less than a year old at this point, and I think these are just kind of growing pains. And the church is really new, especially in Kirtland, where Joseph Smith has just arrived. So this is received in March and I think the missionaries have showed up there in October. And so we're talking about a whole group of converts that are just a couple months old in the faith. And Joseph Smith is navigating this. He's also dealing with questions that come when you grow from a really small family based organization into a larger ecclesiastical structure. So this is normal stuff and it's stuff that, you know, still pops up on the local level of the church on a fairly regular basis.
Casey
So drop us into section 46 and tell us what was immediately going on here that brought about this revelation. Casey.
Scott
Section 46, like you mentioned, is received the day after Section 45. And Section 45 is this grand exploration of the eschatological signs of the times. Section 46 is a little bit more down to earth. How do we run the church right now? John Whitmer, who was the church historian who we're going to talk about in this episode, said that the revelation came in response to a question that church members had about whether non believers should be allowed in their meetings. So this is what John Whitmer wrote to introduce this. In the beginning of the church, while yet in her infancy, the disciples used to exclude unbelievers, which caused some to marvel and converse about this matter because of the things which were written in the Book of Mormon. And it's likely that these early members are riffing off the Book of Moroni, which has a passage. This is Moroni chapter 6, verse 7, which reads, and they were strict to observe that there was no iniquity among them. And whoso was found to commit iniquity. And three witnesses of the church did condemn them before the elders if they repented not and confessed not, their names were blotted out and they were not numbered among the people of Christ. So are we supposed to let people that are in iniquity worship with us? And what does that mean exactly? Like, does iniquity mean they haven't made covenants, they're not a church member? At the same time, there's this pressure, sort of the other direction. So there had been a conflict of opinion among missionaries. Some had just returned to Kirtland from Cleveland. Cleveland, where they had a terrible experience. They were preaching when a deceiver came forward and knelt as if to pray, but then led an attack on them. And his cohorts blew out candles and threw ink stands and books at the speaker. Some missionaries, recognizing this, understandably wanted to restrict attendance at their meetings as a result of this abuse. So this isn't like them being really snobby. They do have a legitimate concern of should we allow non members to attend our meetings? But other members of the church oppose this idea because in another place in the Book of Mormon, this is 3rd Nephi, 1822, the Lord commands the church not to forbid any man from coming unto you when you shall meet together. So both positions seem justified and the Saints are kind of at an impasse. So John Whitmer writes, the Lord deemed to speak on this subject that his people might come to understanding and said that he had always given to his elders to conduct all meetings as they were led by the Spirit. The Lord knows what he said in 3 Nephi 18 and allowing everybody to worship with the Saints. However, it is the case that elders are directed to conduct the church by led by the Spirit, as it says in Moroni. So could there be times when there are exceptions to what the Book of Mormon says based on what the situation is and how the Spirit is leading the elders? That's kind of situation one. Section 46 is dealing with who should come to our meetings.
Casey
So generally allow people to come to church. But what about people who like, are disruptive like that? What should we do about that? And if we kick them out, would that violate 3rd Nephi 18 we still.
Scott
Sort of deal with this today, right? Like, what if someone is really disturbing? You know, our sign says visitors welcome. But what if somebody is like threatening? What if somebody's dangerous or something like that? How do we deal with those particular issues? That's issue one. It seems like issue two is that during this time there's some unusual spiritual manifestations happening in Kirtland. For instance, Joseph Smith writes a letter to his brother Hyrum only a few days before this revelation was given. And in the letter he writes, this morning, after being called out of my bed in the night to go a small distance, I went and had an awful struggle with Satan. But being armed with the power of God, he was cast out. Now, Joseph Smith may have been referring to a member of the Kirtland community who'd been affected by demonic possession, because he also added in the letter, and the woman is clothed in her right mind, and the Lord worketh wonders in this land. So there's all these unusual spiritual manifestations. Joseph Smith is able to manifest the gifts of the Spirit. In fact, that really kicks the church into high gear. And Kirtland is when he gets there and starts to exercise some of the spiritual gifts. But these are new converts, and helping them understand the gifts of the Spirit is going to be a challenge too. So that's another major focus of section 46 is what are the gifts of the Spirit and how do we exercise them and what's appropriate in exercising them?
Casey
And how can we tell which spirits are really from God and which are just people doing weird stuff? And how do we know that's the devil and not the spirit of God, etc. Etc. Right? Because people are going to. And we'll talk more about this with Section 50, but people are doing some wild stuff and they're doing it in the name of The Spirit of God has come upon me. Imagine being a brand new convert and not knowing what's what. Like so many of these people are.
Scott
Yeah, I mean, everybody's a new convert at this point, right? The Church is less than a year old in this area. Most people are converts of just a few months. So this is necessary guidance that the Lord's providing just about some basic things they need to understand.
Casey
As we'll see, there are nuggets in here that even the most seasoned member of the Church today can still gain tremendous value from. So into the content we go, the Lord opens verse one like this. Hearken, O ye people of my church, for verily I say unto you that these things were spoken unto you for your profit and learning. Verse 2. But notwithstanding those things which are written, it always has been given to the elders of my Church from the beginning and ever shall be to conduct all meetings as they are directed and guided by the Holy Spirit. What's he talking about here? Your context was really helpful here. It's hard to understand what he means here without that context. What had been written? Well, what had been written was at least in their minds at this time. 3rd Nephi 1822. You shall not forbid any man from coming unto you when you shall meet together. Jesus said, the Lord says, notwithstanding that which is written. That's true. That is in the text that I said that in. 3rd Nephi 18. That is true. But I want you, leaders of the church, and all of you in your individual lives to conduct all of your meetings as they are directed and guided by the Holy Spirit. Yes, there's a handbook of instructions you might say, right? Yes, there are things that are written. But if the Spirit guides you to diverge from that, trust the Spirit, just make sure it's actually the Spirit. For instance, he goes on in verse three. Nevertheless, you are commanded never to cast anyone out from your public meetings which are held before the world. Right, Public meetings. You're also commanded not to cast anyone who belongeth to the Church out of your sacrament meetings. That's a different kind of a meeting. Nevertheless, if any have trespassed, let him not partake of the Sacrament until he makes reconciliation. Okay, so don't cast any members out of your sacrament meetings. But also if they are in serious transgression, don't let them partake of the sacrament. Actually, that resonates with what Jesus had said back in third Nephi 18 as well, where he said to leaders, then behold, this is the commandment I give unto you, that you shall not suffer Anyone knowingly to partake of my flesh and blood unworthily when ye shall minister it. For whoso eateth and drinketh my flesh and blood unworthily eateth and drinketh damnation to his soul. You wouldn't want to take of the emblems of your repentance, the emblems of the Savior's atonement, his body and blood, and your commitment to follow his commandments. If you have not repented right, that would be in some ways a serious hypocrisy. And so make sure you've repented and then go for it. So the Lord is obviously tracking here with the third Nephi 18 line of reasoning. He says, and again I say unto you shall not cast out any of your sacrament meetings who are earnestly seeking the kingdom. I speak this concerning those who are not of the Church. Oh, okay. So can church members come to sacramenting? Yes. What if they're not worthy? They can still come, just don't particularly the sacrament. Okay, what about those who are not members of the church? Verse 5. They also can come if they are earnestly seeking the kingdom. There's a third kind of meeting they were holding during that time. We don't hold this meeting anymore. Verse 6 talks about confirmation meetings. If there be any that are not of the Church, that are earnestly seeking after the kingdom, don't cast them out of your confirmation meetings. Now, confirmation meeting is when those who had been baptized would get together in a separate meeting and get confirmed members of the church. Today we typically just do that on the same day if someone's baptized.
Scott
We're seeing a theme, right? He talks about public meetings which are probably, you know, like missionary open houses, public preaching, sacrament meetings, which we're all familiar with, Confirmation meetings. But the central theme here is don't cast them out. In other words, we're to be more.
Casey
Inclusive than exclusive with the qualifier make sure they're earnestly seeking the kingdom. He says. So like, the implicit message here is like, if they are rabble rousers throwing ink bottles at your head, or they're hecklers, or they're disturbers and annoyers of the meeting, then you don't need to allow them to stay. Right? Notwithstanding that which is written, you can make a judgment, call leaders of the church, as long as they're well behaved and earnestly seeking the kingdom, don't disrupt the meeting. But you're welcome to come and participate. Yeah. Now we transition in verse seven to the next issue about spiritual gifts. Here's where the Lord starts to get into that quote, but ye are commanded in all things to ask of God who giveth liberally and that which the Spirit testifies unto you. Even so, I would that ye should do in all holiness of heart again above all things, like trust in the spirit of God walking uprightly before me. The Lord says, considering the end of your salvation, doing all things with prayer and thanksgiving, that ye may not be seduced by evil spirits or doctrines of devils or the commandments of men. For some are of men and others of devils. That's really interesting. Those are two interesting categories, isn't it? Doctrines of devils and commandments of men. Some false ideas and false doctrines come just from human brains, right? That's important to think about that. Like misunderstandings or crossing of wires. Like that happens. And so discerning church leaders need to be able to have the spirit of God with them so they can discern that there's also such thing as doctrines that come from sources more diabolical. One extreme example in Alma 30, when Korihor finally starts to fess up, he says, all right, I confess. The stuff I'm teaching was given to me by an angel of light who I now recognize was the devil. But he taught me what to say. He told me that there is no God. He taught me the things I should say which are pleasing to the carnal mind. And so I taught them. And because I had so much success teaching them, I started to believe in myself. And so Korihor is an interesting example of someone who was teaching doctrines of the devil about no accountability, about no God, about things that are pleasing to the carnal mind. So the Lord's point here is verse 8, Wherefore, beware, lest ye are deceived, and that ye may not be deceived, there's a solution to this problem. Seek ye earnestly the best gifts, always remembering for what they are given. They are given to help us avoid deception. And he adds in verse nine, they are given for the benefit of those who love me and keep all my commandments and him that seeketh so to do. Casey, I'm so grateful for that last line, even if you're not nailing it and keeping all of God's commandments. If you're seeking, other gifts of the Spirit are also for you. Why? That all may be benefited. That seek or that ask of me. That ask. And not for a sign, just that they may consume it upon their lusts. We're not talking about sign seeking here. But if you're sincerely seeking God and you want to be led right and not deceived. The gifts of the spirit are here to help with that. And one of the first keys he gives us, one of the first ways to avoid deception. This is really subtle here in verse nine, but I think it's powerful. He says, remember that the gifts are meant to benefit people. So maybe that's your first question. If you saw something kind of weird, Is that really from God? Quick question you can ask based on verse nine is, was anybody benefited by that? Is that actually helping anybody? And if it's not actually helping, then that's one of the good ways. You can start to tell, okay, that might be either from someone's brain or it could be from the devil. Either way, but it's not of God.
Scott
Yeah. And let me point out another thing, which is the Lord isn't saying that you just automatically have these gifts. He says that you seek the gifts. Spiritual gifts aren't set in stone. You can seek to acquire new ones. And the question is, well, what gifts should I seek? I really love this quote from President George Q. Cannon. Here's what he said. If any of us are imperfect, it is our duty to pray for the gift that will make them perfect. Have I imperfections? I am full of them. What is my duty? To pray to God to give me the gifts that will correct these imperfections? If I am an angry man, it is my duty to pray for charity which suffereth long and is kind. No man ought to say, oh, I cannot help this. It is my nature. He is not justified in it. The reason that God has promised to give strength is to correct these things, to give gifts that will eradicate them. For this purpose, he gives these gifts and bestows them upon those who seek after them in order that they may be a perfect people upon the face of the earth, notwithstanding their many weaknesses. So if you need a guide to seeking your spiritual gifts and what you should ask for, President Cannon would say, start with your weaknesses. Sit down and have an earnest conversation with yourself about the areas that you struggle in, and then ask for gifts that you feel will help you overcome those weaknesses. And this is a prophet of God saying, I have a ton of weaknesses, and I'm seeking spiritual gifts to try and counter them. So that's a big part of the function of spiritual gifts, too, is to make us whole, to fill in the areas where we have obvious problems.
Casey
Does it help you draw closer to God? Does it help you be in a better position to be able to help others draw closer to God? And if you can, answer yes to those this is probably from God.
Scott
It is deeply personal, right? And it's not always for us to judge a person's spiritual gifts. There are things like patriarchal blessings, priesthood blessings, and guidance from loving church leaders that will help you understand the gifts. But it can be a personal journey and sometimes it can be difficult to appreciate and see that you actually do have a gift. So let's keep going. Verse 10 Again, verily I say unto you, I would that ye should always remember and always retain in your minds what those gifts are that are given unto the Church. For all have not every gift given unto them. There are many gifts, and to every man is given a gift by the Spirit of God, to some is given one and to some is given another, that all may be profited thereby. As we're walking through this, he points out that it's not just a question of filling in your deficiencies, it's a question of bringing you together with the body of Christ. That God isn't going to give all the spiritual gifts to one person because we need each other. And you shouldn't get jealous if someone has a spiritual gift that you don't, because you can reach out to them and access the gift through the them. We're all in this together.
Casey
I think that's beautiful. The gifts of the Spirit are meant to benefit you, yes. But if you think about them as other people's gifts are meant to benefit you and your gifts are meant to help others profit thereby, you start to see how the body of Christ is meant to be together. We're not doing this in isolation from other people. Right? We're not doing this in isolation from other members of the church. We're meant to benefit one another. In fact, I remember President Eyring, he just gave the best talk about this. It's called Gifts of the Spirit for Hard Times. Go look it up. September 2006 CES Fireside for Young Adults. He said this about our motive. If you want to receive the gifts of the Spirit, you have to want them for the right reasons. Your purpose must be the Lord's purpose. And to the degree your motives are selfish, you will find it difficult to receive those gifts of the Spirit that have been promised to you. I think we're seeing right here in section 46, the Lord is saying these gifts are for you to have so that you can be a benefit to other people and so that you can benefit from other people's gifts. Like this is the purpose.
Scott
Let me follow up with a little quote here from Joseph Smith, too, because it does seem like this section of section 46 is kind of warning us about spiritual gifts. Joseph Smith teaches this. He says, we believe in the gift of the Holy Ghost being enjoyed now as much as it was in the apostles days. We believe that it is necessary to make and organize the priesthood, that no man can be called to fill any office in the ministry without it. We also believe in prophecy, in tongues, in visions and in revelations, in gifts and in healings, and that these things cannot be enjoyed without the gift of the Holy Ghost. But then he adds his own caution too. And this is something that resonates with me. He says, we believe in it in all its fullness and power and greatness and glory. But whilst we do this, we believe in it rationally, reasonably, consistently and scripturally and not according to the wild vagaries, foolish notions and traditions of men. So Joseph Smith is also placing some limits here and saying it's got to be rational, it's got to be reasonable, consistent, it's got to be scriptural. We come back to that idea that the scriptures are the great measuring rod for things that come from God. But if it's something that is wildly inconsistent with the Scriptures, it's probably not from God. That that's our measuring stick, basically. These verses also teach a really important principle which is that everyone in the church has a spiritual gift.
Casey
Yeah, I wanted to swing back to that in verse 11 where he says, for all have not every gift given unto them. For there are many gifts and to every man is given a gift by the Spirit of God. That means we have at least one. Why? Remember verse 12, so that you can benefit other people, so that all may be profited by your gift. You have a gift, at least one from God, that you can use to benefit other people. You may know what that is right now or you may not know what that is. I remember the prophet Joseph saying, sometimes you don't know your gifts until you're put into the position where that gift is useful. And then you have the gift and you can use it. And so, so some of you out there who are listening may not have yet fully discovered your gifts. Others of you know exactly what your gift is. At least one. I know a lot of you have many, but let's walk through some of these gifts. He starts to talk about them and just kind of think about you think about what gifts you've been given. And if you could use your gift to benefit people, then it's a pretty high likelihood that it's actually from God.
Scott
It's interesting where he starts the gifts too. Verse 13 is the first official gift, which reads to some, it is given by the Holy Ghost to know that Jesus Christ is the Son of God and that he was crucified for the sins of the world. Now, that might not seem like a very flashy gift. It's definitely not as spectacular as speaking in tongues or healing somebody. But the testimony of Jesus Christ is a spiritual gift. Joseph Smith said, we believe that no man can know that Jesus is the Christ, but by the Holy Ghost. You should note that the phrasing that he used here is not that a person may believe, but that a person may know by the power of the Holy Ghost that Jesus is the Christ.
Casey
I remember Elder Richard G. Scott once quoted that on an interview that Sherry Dew did with him. And then he said to some, it is given by the Holy Ghost to know that Jesus is the Son of God, that he was crucified for the sins of the world. And then he said, the word no in that verse means a lot to me and 14 of my brethren in the first presidency in quorum of the 12 apostles. He said, that word no is really significant. It's not a hope, it's not a dream, it's not a wish. It's absolute certain knowledge. Then he bore his witness and he said, I actually know that Jesus is the Son of God. It was like this really powerful, like, ending to his testimony. But he wanted to preface it by quoting verse 13 and say, I happen to be one of those who have this gift. Did it benefit anybody when he bore that testimony? Oh, man, it lit me up. In fact, it activated the next verse. And I think I have verse 14 if I don't want to boast here. But I think verse 14 is one of my gifts. Casey. To others, it is given to believe on their words that they also might have eternal life if they continue faithful. Casey. It doesn't seem like believing on the words of those who know is a secondary gift. Sometimes we like to put a premium on knowing, like to be able to say know with every fiber of my being. But verse 14 says it's okay if you don't know. That's a gift some have, but not everybody. To others, it's given to believe on the words of those who know. And guess what the reward is in verse 14 for those who just believe? He says, eternal life. That doesn't sound like a secondary gift. And I experience this often when apostles bear their witness. Go back and listen to President Eyring. I'll paraphrase it, but you can go back and get the exact wording. But he said that I know just as much as Joseph Smith knew when he saw God the Father and his Son, Jesus Christ in the sacred grove. I know just as much as the disciples on the way to Emmaus, on the road to Emmaus know that Jesus is the Christ. He said, I am a witness of the resurrection of Jesus. There's something in me, Casey. There's a light that goes on in my soul when someone who actually knows bears that witness. And I think that's verse 14, being activated within me. And does it benefit me? It does. It does a lot. And it helps me draw closer to God. And that's how I know it's actually from God. It's not weird. It's not. Doesn't feel edgy. It doesn't feel out there. It feels like crucial to salvation.
Scott
It's practical. Right. I love the phrase that he adds on here, too. If they continue faithful. I never pass up a chance to quote Joseph Merrill. I love him. Full disclosure, I wrote a biography of Joseph Merrill. He's an apostle nobody's ever heard of. But what I loved about the guy was he was a scientist, and science and faith overlapped to a large degree. But he was like, hey, if they continue faithful means basically there is a scientific process. In fact, he says, this faith is one of those spiritual gifts that I believe is based on. We learn from the teachings of the prophet Joseph that if we get any blessing from heaven, it's because we fulfill the conditions upon which that blessing is based. That is a truth that not only comes from the mouth of our prophet, it's a truth that's been established by scientific research. Every investigator in the field of material science knows that when he fulfills the conditions, he can predict the results. And if the conditions vary, then the results will vary. And when the conditions are completely fulfilled, the results will be realized completely. So faith is one of those gifts that we acquire that we may cultivate only if we fulfill the conditions upon which faith is based. I love this guy because he's basically saying, hey, scientific method works with faith too. We know that if you read your scriptures or pray, you will achieve certain results. That if you live a Christlike life, it's demonstrable. I've seen it in my own life over and over again and again. It's just that idea of it doesn't have to be flashy, it doesn't have to be huge, but it is a gift of the spirit.
Casey
It to believe and to Continue faithful. Don't just believe, but continue faithful. That's the laws upon which the blessing of eternal life is predicated.
Scott
Yeah, because I know a ton of people who still believe but don't continue faithful. Honestly, eventually that belief withers and dies. You have to continue to move, to grow, to nourish that belief, or it is going to eventually fade away. Let's go on to verse 15, which contains probably not one of the more well known, or let's say flashy gifts of the spirit. But verse 15, it is given by some, by the Holy Ghost to know the differences of administration, as it will be pleasing unto the Lord. So differences of administration.
Casey
Here's a commentary, an old commentary written by Hyrum M. Smith, son of Joseph F. Smith and John M. Schojal. It seems to also be connected to what Paul says in First Corinthians 12, which, by the way, if you're making a list, there are three places in Scripture that list the gifts of the Spirit, kind of like categorically. And you've got first place is first Corinthians 12, second place is Moroni 10, and the third place is right here in D&C. 46. And so to paraphrase their explanation, they say that the phrase differences of administration has a connection to a phrase that Paul used in his discussion of the different divisions or courses of service that the priests and Levites engaged in in temple service. There was these different today we'd probably call them priesthood offices in the temple where Levites and priests did different functions. And what they do is they kind of riff off that. And they say, I'm still paraphrasing because of this connection. They believe that the gift described here in verse 15 of Differences Administration pertains specifically to an understanding of how those ordained to the priesthood should be directed in their duties and responsibilities. That's interesting. And more recently, church leaders have taken notice of the accompanying phrase that goes on in the same verse where the Lord says he'll suit his mercy according to the conditions of the children of men only the Savior really understands perfectly the conditions in which the gifts are going to be needed to handle whatever personal challenges people are in. And so differences of administration may have something to do with discerning which gifts are needed to accomplish which good, to bring about which benefit, to profit which people. So at a pretty high level, the differences of administration would be the differences of the gifts of the Spirit that we need in a given moment to be benefited or to be a benefit to others. And the Lord is the one who dictates that right through the. Through the Spirit. So what would it mean then, Casey, for a person, for one of us, to have the gift of the differences of administration? Is this like a leadership position where there are people in your jurisdiction and you would be able to discern who has which gifts and would be suited for which roles or callings in the church, for instance, in order to benefit which people according to their needs at a given time. Now I'm thinking of, you know, calling a particular person to be young women's president because of the particular gift she has and because of the particular needs that a group of young women have that at this time, I can see a bishop discerning this, having the gifts of the differences of administration to discern which person would be fitting for which role at which time in order to bring about the Lord's purpose.
Scott
You and I both have probably had those moments where you're looking for a person to fulfill a position in the church, and all of a sudden it just becomes clear this might be an underappreciated gift in the church, but it is one of the most frequently manifested gifts in the church. It's not flashy, but it is so vital because those callings do make a huge difference in the lives of all those involved.
Casey
So that would be one expression of this gift. I'm sure there's many others, maybe. We see this also, for instance, when missionaries are called by revelation by apostles to a specific mission with a specific mission president at a specific time. Is that because the missionary has some things to learn? No doubt. But is it also because the missionary might have particular gifts matched to the needs of that particular mission also? No doubt.
Scott
All right, let's keep going. Verse 16. And again, it is given by the Holy Ghost to some to know the diversities of operations, whether they be of God, and that the manifestations of the Spirit may be given to every man to profit with them all. So this one, or the phrase diversity of operations shows up in the Bible in 1 Corinthians 12:5. And so this is one of those ones we can look at and say, well, there are alternate translations, like in Greek. The phrase has been translated in a different version of the Bible. In the new King James Version 2 difference of ministries, or in the NIV, it's different kinds of service. So it seems like in the larger context, Paul's sermon that he's giving here is about the body of Christ. And the Lord appears to be speaking through Paul to know that there's different kinds of service. Within the church, and that one of the spiritual gifts is to recognize the value of each type of service. The apostle Paul, for instance, says, there are many members yet, but one body. And the eye cannot say to the hand, I have no need of thee, Nor the head to the feet, I have no need of you. It's not where you serve, it's how. And it's a spiritual gift to appreciate the value of each one of those callings. Sometimes we have people that will say things like, I'm just a ministering brother, or I'm just a primary teacher. But understanding the value of those callings is a gift from the Spirit. And this is a feature of the church too. I love this statement from Dallin H. Oaks. He said, at this conference, we have seen the release of some faithful brothers, and we have sustained the callings of others in this rotation so familiar in the church. We do not step down when we're released, and we do not step up when we are called. There is no up or down in the service of the Lord. There's only forward and backward. And that depends on how we accept and act upon our releasings and colleagues.
Casey
So what's the difference between this gift diversity of operations and the previous gift we just talked about, which is the differences of administration? Like, they seem to both be about putting people in positions where they can flourish and be a prophet to others. That's how verse 16 ends. It says that the manifestations of the spirit may be given to every man to profit with all meaning, to profit other peoples with your gifts and to be benefited by their gifts. So putting people in a position to bless, how is that different than differences of administration?
Scott
Well, I would say they're Venn diagrams that overlap to a large degree. But there is a difference between knowing where someone is supposed to serve and understanding that where you're serving is important. There are a lot of church members that still sort of unconsciously place this ranking of positions like, oh, she got called to be the relief society president, therefore she is the most righteous woman in the word. And he got called to be the bishop, therefore he's the most righteous person in the world. When in reality, I haven't found that to be true. And the truth is, I've served in a number of callings in the church. Sometimes understanding the importance of your calling is a spiritual gift. You're doing something, it's important. It doesn't reflect on your personal righteousness or the ability or skill that you have. What you're doing is you're serving in the kingdom, that's a spiritual gift. I think that's the difference between the to. We don't really measure righteousness or blessedness according to the office held, only to the dedication you show in carrying out the service that the Lord asks of you.
Casey
And I would want to stress too that you are not to fulfill that calling the same way that the person before you fulfilled that calling. You have gifts, you have unique gifts that will be a particular blessing to the people you're called to serve now in ways unique to you. When you are placed in a position of, of being able to bless duly, as Elder J. Reuben Clark said, duly officially in the church, obviously you can use your gifts to bless whoever you want, whenever you want. But when you're duly placed in the church, in the body of Christ, you don't have to do it like the person before you did it. Your skill set, your gifts, your blessings from God are unique. The grace you've been given is the grace you've been given and you are to use that to benefit others. Like, I wish we could all just, just believe that deep in our bones and feel like a freedom that I can be who God has made me to be in this calling, to be a benefit to others as a missionary. Like, use your gifts to bless with the gifts you've got. When you lean into the gifts God has given you in the callings that you're in and the positions that you occupy, you're better able to bless authentically and to be a benefit to others rather than trying to pretend to be like the person who was in there before or acting like that missionary that you really admire and you kind of want to do it like them or that really charismatic teacher that you saw. Like, I want to do it that way. It's like, stop. Yes, learn from other people for sure. But lean into the gifts that God has given you and watch what heaven can do through you.
Scott
Yeah, comparison is the thief of joy, right? When we start comparing our colleagues with other people in the church, it becomes a bad thing that can sour our service.
Casey
Alright, so let's continue then. Verse 17. And again, verily I say unto you to some is given by the spirit of God the word of wisdom. That does not mean what we think it means. Let's keep going here. To another is given the word of knowledge that all may be taught to be wise and to have knowledge. Okay, Notice the pairings that are happening here. So in the previous two verses, there was the gift of diversity of operations and the gift of the differences of Administration very complementary. Similar gifts. Just before that were the two gifts of. Of knowing that Jesus is the Christ and believing on the words of those who know that Jesus is the Christ. Notice the pairing here. Now we're getting our third pair. The gift of wisdom and the gifts of knowledge. Like you said, there's a Venn diagram here. There's some overlap between wisdom and knowledge here. And of course, the phrase word of wisdom is eventually going to be associated with the law of health that the Lord will give to the church in section 89. But this section 89 doesn't exist yet. We're just. We're still here in section 46. Word of wisdom means something a little different. These are two separ. Gifts, but related knowledge and wisdom. For instance, Stephen L. Richards, counselor in the First Presidency, he defined wisdom as the beneficent application of knowledge indecision. I think of wisdom not in the abstract, but as functional. Life is largely made up of choices and determinations. And I can think of no wisdom that does not contemplate the good of mankind and society. I do not believe that wisdom can be exercised in living without a sound fundamental knowledge of truth about life and living. So knowledge is a key component of wisdom. I think he's saying here. But wisdom is proper application. He goes on, the fundamental knowledge which the Church brings you will bring understanding. Your testimony, your spirit and your service will direct the application of your knowledge. And that, he says, is wisdom.
Scott
So wisdom is knowledge properly applied is what I'm taking from President Richards statement there, which, you know what, you and I work in fields with some very, very smart people, and it is such a blessing to work with people that are dedicated to learning. But I know some people that have a lot of knowledge but not a lot of wisdom. And I find myself in that category sometimes too, where I've got a lot of books. You can see my shelf behind me. And I know a lot of facts, but I don't always know the practical ways to use them. On the other hand, I know some people who do not have a lot of knowledge but possess real wisdom that can come by experience or they can just be a gift of the Spirit. There are some people that are just so wise in certain ways of knowing how to help people and knowing how to get a person what they need. And I admire them greatly. I think I'm getting better, but I would feel comfortable saying I have the gift of knowledge, but I haven't always demonstrated the gift of wisdom, if that makes sense.
Casey
You totally have the gift of knowledge. You can remember facts and you remember context, and you remember the proper, like, like positioning of those facts in relationship to others really, really well. And the way I know it's of God is because you use your gift to benefit other people, Casey. Like, I am a beneficiary of your gifts of knowledge. And I also think you have wisdom. So they do go together. They're not exactly the same. You'd want both. You want to seek both to be a benefit to others. And certainly a teacher would be one who would want to seek both the gifts of knowledge and the gifts of wisdom in order to benefit those. Those who will be under your teachings. Right. Will receive your teachings and back at.
Scott
You like, I see the same things present in you. And it's great to have a partner that can kind of balance out my weaknesses and my strengths.
Casey
Okay, here we. Here we come to our next pair. Do you want to take us into the next pair? Notice there's two that go together again. Here they go.
Scott
19, 20. Okay. And again. To some, it is given to have faith to be healed. And to others, it is given to have faith. Faith to heal. And this is where I think we're getting into the flashier gifts of the spirit. This is a gift that I have seen demonstrated in the church in the latter days. In fact, let me give you one striking example. So near the time this revelation was received, Joseph Smith exercised the gift of healing. There's a woman named Elsa Johnson. She lives in Hiram, Ohio. She's going to figure big into the story as we go through the doctrine Covenants. This is when they first meet Joseph Smith, right? They hear rumors of this gold Bible and this prophet, and they come to Kirtland, where Joseph Smith is staying. And the reason why they came was because Elsa had an arm that wasn't very functional. She had rheumatism, really bad. Now, Philo dibble, who was present when the Johnsons meet with Joseph, this is what he records. He said Elsa went to Joseph and requested him to heal her. Joseph asked if she believed the Lord and was able to make him an instrument in healing her. So the gift to have faith, to be healed. She said she believed the Lord was able to heal her arm. Joseph put her off till the next morning. When he met her at brother Noel K. Whitney's house, there were eight persons present. One a Methodist preacher and one a doctor. Joseph took her by the hand, prayed in silence a moment, pronounced her arm whole in the name of Jesus Christ, and turned and left the room. The preacher asked her if her arm was whole. And she straightened it out and replied it is as good as the other. Joseph upon hearing this, said it is as good as the other and as liable to accident as the other. So Joseph Smith basically saying it's healed, but you know, you don't get a warranty. Okay, so take care of that thing if you get it. And this incident leads to the Johnson family joining the church, which leads to Joseph and Emma staying at their home. Their home is a church historic site today that you can go visit. It's where Section 76 was revealed. Unfortunately, it's where Joseph Smith was attacked by a mob. Also, it is also the place, place where the conference is held to make the decision to create a new book of scripture that will eventually become the Doctrine and Covenants. Two of John and Elsa's sons, Luke and Lyman Johnson also are original members of the Quorum of the twelve Apostles. So she shows faith to be healed, he shows faith to heal. It's a two way street right there.
Casey
Notice the pairs in section 46. They're not all pairs. Not all the gifts mentioned here are going to come in pairs. But so far they have. All of them have been coming in pairs and related gifts. Right? That, that kind of mutually reinforce each other. An example of one that does not have a pair is in verse 21. And again to some is given the working of miracles. This kind of broadens it and just says miracles. The prophet Moroni in the Book of Mormon when he, he chastises those that think that the day of miracles has, has passed. He says, quote, oh all ye that have imagined up unto yourselves a God who can do no miracles. I would ask of you, have all these things passed of which I've spoken? Has the income? Behold, I say unto you, nay. And so God has not ceased to be a God of miracles. Scriptures show unapologetically that God is a God of miracles. Now he's not flashy, doesn't do them every day. There have been some big ones in scripture, but it's not like he's showing off all the time. The ministry of his son Jesus Christ was, was a high concentration period of miracles. During his ministry. It seems like during the season of restoration there was another high concentration of miracles. The first being, I would say the translation of the Book of Mormon was the first miracle. Others happened at this time. There may be some, a couple dramatic ones that were happening during this time. For instance, a member named Levi Curtis. He recalled a conversation with William D. Huntington where William described a time that Joseph Smith actually exercised the Power to raise the dead. Levi is hearing this directly from the person. Person who died, William Huntington. Okay, so William said that he'd become deathly ill while living in Joseph Smith's home in Nauvoo. I'll quote directly from Levi's account here. Quote he said he had been sick some weeks and kept getting weaker until he became so helpless he could not move. Finally, he got so low he could not speak, but had perfect consciousness of all that was passing in the room. He saw friends come to the bedside and look at him a moment and commence weeping and then turn away. He further stated that he presently felt easy in observing his situation. He found that he was in the upper part of the room near the ceiling, and he could look down and see the body he had occupied lying on the bed with weeping friends. About this time, he saw Joseph Smith and two other brethren come into the room. Joseph turned to his wife Emma and asked her to get him a dish of clean water. This she did, and the prophet, with the two brethren accompanying him, washed their hands and carefully wiped them. Then they stepped to the bed and laid their hands upon the head of his body. Body, which at that time looked loathsome to him, William said. And as the three stretched out their hands to place them upon the head, he by some means became aware that he must go back into that body. And he started doing so. The process of getting in he could not remember, he said. But when Joseph said Amen, he heard and could see and could fill with his body. The feeling for a moment was most excruciating. He he said, as though his body was pierced in every part with some sharp instruments. As soon as the brethren had taken their hands from his head, he raised up in bed, sitting erect, and in another moment turned his legs off to bed. At this juncture, Joseph asked him if he had not better be careful, for he is very weak. He replied, I never felt better in my life, almost immediately adding, I want my pants.
Scott
I love this.
Casey
Every looker on was ready to weep for joy, William said. Every hand was anxious to supply the wants of a man who a few moments before was dead. Really and truly dead, he said. Joseph listened to the conversation and in his turn remarked that they had just witnessed as great a miracle as Jesus did while on the earth they had seen the dead brought to life. Close quote this is not the only story of raising the dead. I've heard many of them don't get documented very well, but some do. For fun, go listen to Matthew Cowley's BYU speeches. Talk Called Miracles. And you'll hear a ton of cool stories there, some of them about raising the dead. Another one President Oaks gave in general conference years ago called Miracles. Maybe I think it's just called Miracles. He outlines some miracles that he personally has witnessed and others that he's heard from reliable sources.
Scott
Miracles require eyes to see, too, right? Like some people will look and see a coincidence or see a serendipitous arrangement of circumstances. But for those that have eyes to see, we can see miracles happening around us all the time. Do we recognize them for what they really are? It seems like the Book of Mormon especially warns us that the great epidemic of the last days will be people not seeing miracles, people standing up and saying, God doesn't do miracles anymore. The day of miracles has passed. And so if we have to err, I'm okay with someone saying, hey, I found five bucks on the road, it was a miracle, because I don't know what their circumstances are. Maybe they needed that five bucks to buy their medication or something like that. Joseph Smith said, I've never heard of a man being damned for believing too much, but they have been damned for unbelief. All right, let's keep going. Verse 22, very short. And to others, it is given to prophesy. This is another one of the flashier miracles. I guess we'd say that you can prophesy or foretell things past, present, and future. That's how the Book of Mormon kind of defines it.
Casey
It's also, I think, important to point out that prophesying is not just about telling the future. That's kind of where my mind goes to. It's like, oh, someone told the future and it came to pass. That's prophecy. But Scripture also defines it in a really interesting way. Like In Revelation, chapter 19, verse 10, it says that the testimony of Jesus is the spirit of prophecy. If you can say that Jesus is the Christ, Jesus is our redeemer, that Jesus will come again, I guess that's about the future, isn't it, that Jesus is our Lord. There is something about that, that if you really have that conviction in your soul, that's a spiritual gift. And sometimes that's called the gift of prophecy. That seems to be related back to verse 13. To know that Jesus is the Christ. Okay, verse 23. And to others is given the gift of discerning of spirits. Now, this seems to be a reference to the ability to discern whether or not a spiritual manifestation has actually come from God or from another source. Spiritual manifestations were abundant among the saints in Kirtland, but not all manifestations came from God. The prophet addressed this question actually in this revelation and again in another revelation that we're going to talk about next week, D&C50. So stay tuned for kind of part two to this answer. But Joseph, he said that if you want to know if it's from God or not, you should try the spirits. He called it. Test the spirit to see if it came from God or from Satan. He said, we may look for angels, angels, but we are to try the spirits and to prove them. Test them. It's often the case that men make a mistake in regard to these things. God has so ordained that when he has communicated, no vision to be taken, but what you shall see by the seeing of the eye or what you hear by the hearing of the ear, when you see a vision, pray for the interpretation. If you get. Not this, shut it up.
Scott
This is going to turn into a huge theme in the Doctrine and Covenants. Right. Where Joseph Smith is very, very concerned. And a lot of later sections like section 129 and 130 deal with this idea that it's possible for us to be deceived. Discerning spirits is being able to know when something genuinely comes from God and when it doesn't. Because people take advantage of individuals of faith. They try to play on their senses. They try to manipulate them by presenting themselves as messengers from God. And the gift of discernment allows us to look at people and say, no, I know that you're not a messenger from God. Now there's more mechanical things that are presented in places like section 129 and section 130. But this is the beginning of just saying, hey, not everybody that claims to come in the name of God is coming in the name of God. And being able to discern who is and who isn't is a genuine spiritual gift that everybody needs to seek to acquire that it feels like the Lord felt was a really big deal.
Casey
There are some times when the discerning of spirits is a gift that we need it and we don't have it. It's nice to have friends, friends, family members, church leaders who do have it that can help us to see clearly when we're in the midst of potentially being deceived by somebody.
Scott
Yeah, and you said something really wise there, which is, not everyone possesses this gift. But if there's doubt, it's a good idea to go to somebody else. Like councils, I really think are blessed with the gift of discerning of Spirits to know if something's good and comes from God or if it's not good. And there's been a couple times when meeting in council with other people is really kind of saved me from making a bad decision. So the next part talks about one of the most controversial gifts of the Spirit. It reads verse 24. And again, it is given to some to speak with tongues. And another it is given to the interpretation of tongues. Now, we should point out the gift of speaking in tongues was really common in the early church and manifested abundantly among the saints in Kirtland. The type that we always think of is speaking in an unknown tongue, which definitely happened among the early saints. It's called glossisalia. And part of the problem is we don't see this manifestation in the church very much today. But in the early church, it seemed like it was all the time. There's more examples than I can think of. Like Brigham Young speaks in tongues. Karl G. Maeser speaks in tongues. And it seems like speaking in an unknown tongue is not common in the church today. But the reason why I don't want to put speaking in tongues in a box, because it can be learning and understanding languages. Wouldn't you say the gift of speaking in tongues and interpreting tongues is active among missionaries. I mean, you learned a different language on your mission. Did you feel the gift of tongues when that happened?
Casey
Yeah. In fact, when I was set apart by my stake president, he actually said these words. His hands were on my head, setting me apart as a missionary, and he said, I now bless you with the gift of tongues. He said that phrase. And I remember I opened my eyes, it was so dramatic. I was like, whoa. He just said that. Then I closed them again. But a fancy term for this one is xenoglasia, spelled with an xeno, know glacia, which is preaching the gospel in a foreign tongue, which is, I think, less dramatic than glasilea. Speaking just spontaneously, it's more common, less dramatic, whereas glossolalia is more dramatic, less common. The question as to whether or not it's really from God is again, that the litmus test is anybody benefited by it. Because if somebody stands up and just starts jabbering in some unknown tongue, and there's not anyone who has the gift of interpretation of tongues, then you have to ask yourself, why would God give the gift of speaking in tongues to somebody when there was no companion gift of interpreting it there in the congregation? That would be God. Just sowing confusion. Are missionaries who are learning languages quickly and going out and preaching the gospel in those languages, are they benefiting anybody by that gift? Unquestionably, yeah, for sure. And so that's, I think, a good test.
Scott
I gotta point out that this was the gift that Paul, for instance, hones in on. And in 1 Corinthians 13, which is the chapter after his lift of the gifts of the Spirit actually says, it doesn't really matter that much, like it's a tinkling cymbal in sounding brass if you don't have charity. And modern prophets have warned against this, too. So here's Joseph F. Smith. He said, there is perhaps no gift of the spirit more easily imitated by the devil than the gift of tongues. Where two men or women exercise the gift of tongues by the inspiration of the Spirit of God, there are a dozen, perhaps, who do it by the inspiration of the devil. So far as I am concerned, if the Lord will give me ability to teach the people in my native tongue or in their own language to the understanding of those who hear me, that will be sufficient gift of tongues to me. Yet if the Lord gives you the gift of tongues, do not despise it and do not reject it. So it seems like he is saying, too, that this manifestation does need to have a purpose, like you pointed out. And Joseph S. Smith served a mission in Hawaii, became fluent in the Hawaiian language. But he's saying there's got to be a reason for it. Another person, this is Joseph Smith. Joseph Smith, a junior. Be not so curious about tongues. Do not speak in tongues, except there be an interpreter present. The ultimate design of tongues is to speak to foreigners. And if persons are very anxious to display their intelligence, let them speak to such in their own tongues. The gifts of God are all useful in their place, but when they are applied to that which God does not intend, they prove an injury, a snare and a curse. Curse instead of a blessing. So this is the trickiest of the gifts of the Spirit, because speaking in an unknown tongue, for example, is very flashy and can cause people to say, oh, that person's feeling the spirit. How come I'm not having the same kind of manifestations? But two prophets have warned and basically said, no, it's got to be with purpose. And if it's not happening with a purpose, if it's just happening for the cause to kind of make you look amazing, it can be a snare and can prove an injury. Those are the words of Joseph Smith, 2nd Nephi 32.
Casey
He opens up the possibility that this might not just be speaking in an unknown tongue, right in second, Nephi32, he talks about speaking with the tongue of angels. Where he says this, he says, once you receive the Holy Ghost, I'm quoting from verse two. You can speak with the tongue of angels. And now how can you speak with the tongue of angels, save it were by the Holy Ghost? And then he drops this insight. Angels speak by the power of the Holy Ghost. Wherefore they speak the words of Christ. Let's let that sink in for a second. Could another application, like you said, we don't want to box this gift in, but could another application of the gift of tongues and speaking with the tongue of angels by the power of the Holy Ghost be when you speak the words of Christ, when you speak in English on your mission in Florida, Casey, did you have this gift of tongues, right? Being able to speak in English, English, the words of Christ by the power of the Holy Ghost? Nephi calls that also speaking. He doesn't say in tongues. He calls it speaking with the tongue of angels. So maybe another food for thought on that. I'm not sure section 46 is really talking about that or not, but throw that into the mix of speaking in tongues.
Scott
So that is kind of the complete list. The next verse says, all these gifts come from God for the benefit of the children of God. God, and then adds, and unto the bishop of the church, and unto such as God shall appoint and ordain to watch over the church and be elders unto the church, are to have it given unto them to discern those gifts, lest there should be any among you professing and yet be not of God. And so he kind of wraps it up by saying, these gifts are given to the members of the church. But there is a gift of discernment given to presiding officers in the church. So at the time the revelation is given, there's really only one bishop. It's Edward Partridge, who's just been called a few sections earlier. But the system that we eventually develop of presiding church officers, and this might include stake presidents, bishops, relief Society presidents and others that God appoints and ordains. That's the wording here, to watch over the church is gradually revealed. The principle here is that presiding officers in the church are given the power to discern if a gift comes from God.
Casey
And verses 28 through 32 basically is an instruction to a church leader of how to seek those gifts. Gifts to discern that. We don't necessarily need to read all the verses. We're starting to wax along here, but go check out verses 28, 32 on how to do that?
Scott
Basically, yes. Leaders are given discernment in order to understand what gifts come from God and what gifts don't. Boyd K. Packer, for instance, said there is a power of discernment granted unto such as God shall appoint to watch over his church. To discern means to see. To see clearly what is ahead and yet find members slow to respond or resistant to counsel or even rejecting the witness of the apostles and prophecies prophets brings deep sorrow. Nevertheless, the responsibility of leading this church must rest upon us until you shall appoint others to succeed you.
Casey
Alright, let's talk about controversies in section 46. Casey, here's one that tends to come up a question about this section. Can those not of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints Saints have spiritual gifts? Do they have spiritual gifts? If so, is there any difference between the spiritual gifts given to non members of this church and those who are in the church?
Scott
Yes to the first question. I think people that aren't members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints can manifest spiritual gifts just because there are so many examples coming to mind. Off the top of my head, Karl G. Maeser has the gift of speaking and interpreting in tongues. The first time he meets with the mission missionaries, he's speaking German, they're speaking English. They have a perfectly fluent conversation with each other. And he was not a member of the church.
Casey
I'm thinking of Joseph Smith translating the Book of Mormon. He translated the whole thing without being a member of this church. There was no church.
Scott
That's a big one, right? But in my own individual life, I saw people when I was a missionary and in my church service since, demonstrate the gifts of the Spirit. Spirit before they were baptized and given the gift of the Holy Ghost. So there's no doubt in my mind. Yeah. That people from other churches, from other religions can access the gifts of the Spirit.
Casey
If the testimony of Jesus is the Spirit of prophecy. I have seen countless people outside of our church who have a testimony that Jesus really is the Christ. So I've heard Some quote verse 10 as saying that these gifts are unique to the church. Where he says again, verily I say unto you, I would that ye should always, always remember and always retain in your minds what those gifts are that are given unto the church. So I've heard some people interpret verse 10 as to say, see, these gifts are only for members of the church. But you and I believe something that Nephi calls in First Nephi 14 the Church of the Lamb of God. Where if you look at that, that's bigger than just the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. But it's all those who believe in God are trying to follow him according to their best understanding. And in verse 14 of chapter 14, Nephi sees the Spirit of God being poured out upon them and strengthening them, arming them with righteousness and the power of God. And we've had prophets as recently, I think, as President Oaks, who said that those of the church of the Lamb of God, that's. That's bigger than just the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. And so for me, that's how I reconcile it. Casey is. I think that, yes, they are meant for the church. Verse 10 is saying, but it's not just the church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints saints. It's that bigger church that Jesus was referring to. In doctrine and covenants 10 we talked about where he says, those who repent and come unto me, those are my church. We're all about wanting to baptize all mankind eventually, right? This is going to culminate in Nauvoo when we get baptisms for the dead. We're not saying that we don't believe there is a center place where you do need to receive the ordinances and eventually gain that legal administration to make you an heir of the kingdom of God. But what the scriptures seem to bear out is that when you believe in Christ and have faith in God and try to come unto him and repent, like narrowing these gifts to those who have been baptized in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints might be too narrow of an interpretation based on what other scripture says and based on, I think what we can observe with wonderful people who repent come unto God the best they know how. And it's almost like the Spirit can't hold back. It's almost like when people. People show the fruits of faith and repentance and coming to God, like, it's almost like heaven, just like rewards that, you know, and the fruits of the Spirit, of gentleness and meekness and patience and goodness and kindness, like all of that just like starts to flow almost immediately. And then they start being a benefit to those around them in cool ways. And I think that's all leading up to, you know, becoming part of God's official kingdom on earth. But I think the gifts of the Spirit come early or. Casey, is that okay? Is that heretical or what do you think about that?
Scott
There's a difference between receiving the gifts of the Spirit, which I believe any child of God can do, and receiving the gift of the Holy Ghost, which means you've made a sacred covenant with God is different. But God works among all people. He's no respecter of persons. But I do believe the promises made in the covenants to the believers in God, those that are baptized and confirmed by authority, do bring special power blessings. Another controversy is this the complete list of the gifts of the Spirit. You noted that there's another list given by Paul in 1 Corinthians 12:13. And Moroni gives a list that is very similar to section 46 in the last chapter of the Book of Mormon. The question is, is this the complete list? There are several church leaders that seem to say, no, it's not. Bruce R. McConkie said, Spiritual gifts are endless in number and infinite in variety. Those listed in the Revealed Word are simply illustrations of the boundless outpouring of divine grace God gives those who love and serve him. So he would say, now this is to get you going, but they're illustrations, but they're not the complete list, and a complete list doesn't exist. Another apostle, this was Marvin J. Ashton, said, take it at random. Let me mention a few gifts that are not always evident or noteworthy, but that are very important. Important among these may be your gifts. Gifts not so evident, but nevertheless real and valuable. He said, let's take a moment to review some of the less conspicuous gifts. The gift of asking, the gift of listening. The gift of hearing and using the still, small voice. The gift of avoiding contention. The gift of being agreeable. The gift of avoiding vain repetition. The gift of seeking that which is righteous. The gift of not passing judgment. The gift of looking to God for guidance. The gift of being being a disciple. The gift of caring for others. The gift of being able to ponder. The gift of offering prayer, the gift of bearing a mighty testimony, and the gift of receiving the Holy Ghost. I'm with Elder Ashton, and I think Elder Ashton would have said, and that's not the complete list either. I'm just adding in a few things that don't seem to be evident in those three scriptural passages but that he personally had witnessed. And some of those I've witnessed, too. And if you're sitting there thinking, I don't have anything that's in section 46 or Moroni 10 or First Corinthians 12:13, don't despair. You have a gift. It might not be one that's been named in the scriptures, but you do have a gift. And you have the right to cultivate new gifts, too.
Casey
And one of the ways to kind of just cut through the noise of like, ah. Which gift is. My gift is just to, I think again ask the fundamental question that Section 46 is offering, which is, do you have any gifts that can benefit other people? People? Do you have any gifts that you notice, help and profit people and help them draw closer to God or help them receive comfort or help in any way? Like if you, if you've got that, that seems to be a gift from God. Right. That's how you can discern that it's really from him. It's not from the devil. It's not just the made up man one. It's one that actually helps people come closer to God. All right, let's go then to the consequences of section 46.
Scott
One consequence. Visitors welcome. On every Latter Day Saint Chapel, there is a sign that says visitors welcome. We got that settled and I think we're even more open than a lot of other churches. Like a lot of other churches don't practice open communion, Meaning you can come to the church, but you don't participate in the ordinances. In our church, there's been a little controversy on this, but it seems like someone shows up, they want to take the sacrament. Great.
Casey
Yeah. In fact, President Nelson actually highlighted that very point when he said, quote, because we invite all to come unto Christ, friends and neighbors are always welcome but not expected to take the sacrament. I don't think that's very well understood in the church right now, Casey. I think some would say that if you're baptized, you can take the sacrament. If you're not baptized, then please don't. Right. Children can because they haven't been baptized yet, but they're not accountable. Accountable. President Nelson is saying here, it's okay. Our friends and neighbors are always welcome but not expected to take the sacrament. He said, however, it is not forbidden. They choose for themselves. We hope that newcomers among us will always be made to feel wanted and comfortable. Little children, as sinless beneficiaries of the Lord's atonement, he says, may partake of the sacrament as they prepare for covenants that they will make later in life. That is called open communion. You can come and partake of the sacrament with us if you're sincerely seeking the kingdom of God. Come. This section also provides this framework that there is such thing as doctrines of devils and commandments of men and true gifts of God. So how do we discern those? I think one of the greatest benefits of Section 46 is to teach us that these gifts are given. Like verse 26 said to that all may profit thereby. So if it doesn't profit, then it's not from God. It might be from man, it might be from the devil. I don't always know how to distinguish between the two, but I do know if it doesn't help anybody, if it doesn't edify anybody, if it doesn't benefit anybody, then it's not a gift from God, and that's how you can discern it. That's a really cool takeaway from section 46. Such a clear way to distinguish divine versus not. Casey. We have been going for over an hour with just section 46. And so we're going to call that this part one of this week. So stay tuned for part two, section 4748. We'll just do that in a separate video so that, you know, you can do this broken up and it's not so long. Is that okay?
Scott
Yep. We had too much to chew on here and that's okay. This is going to be part one, and in part two we'll pick it up with section 47 and 48 SA.
Church History Matters Podcast Summary
Episode 120 - D&C 46 CFM - Seeking & Discerning Gifts of the Spirit - E20 May 12-18
Release Date: May 8, 2025
Host/Author: Scripture Central
In Episode 120 of the Church History Matters podcast, hosts Scott and Casey delve into Doctrine and Covenants Section 46, exploring the discernment and seeking of spiritual gifts within the Latter-day Saint Church. This episode provides a comprehensive analysis of how early church members in Kirtland navigated the challenges of spiritual manifestations and established guidelines to ensure doctrinal purity and effective church administration.
The episode begins by setting the stage in early 1831 Kirtland, Ohio, a pivotal time when the Latter-day Saint Church was less than a year old. New converts were grappling with the influx of spiritual experiences and gifts of the Spirit. Scott and Casey emphasize that these early revelations from Joseph Smith were responses to both internal spiritual manifestations and external challenges, such as conflicts among missionaries.
Casey [00:00]:
"You have gifts. You have unique gifts that will be a particular blessing to the people you're called to serve... Lean into the gifts that God has given you and watch what heaven can do through you."
A significant portion of the discussion centers on the tension between inclusivity and exclusivity in church meetings. John Whitmer highlights the early church's struggle with whether non-believers should attend their gatherings.
Scott [02:34]:
"Section 46 is dealing with who should come to our meetings."
Casey and Scott explore the balance between welcoming earnest seekers and managing disruptive individuals, referencing both Moroni 6:7 and 3 Nephi 18:22 to illustrate the scriptural foundation for inclusion.
Casey [05:24]:
"Generously allow people to come to church, but manage disruptions appropriately without violating scriptural directives."
The hosts delve into the nature of spiritual gifts, emphasizing their purpose to benefit others and avoid deception. They discuss how gifts are meant to complement one another within the church body.
Scott [14:09]:
"The Lord isn't saying that you just automatically have these gifts. He says that you seek the gifts."
Casey reinforces that spiritual gifts are tools to draw closer to God and assist others, highlighting their communal benefit.
Casey [15:36]:
"Does it help you draw closer to God? Does it help you be in a better position to help others draw closer to God? If you can, answer yes to those, this is probably from God."
Scott and Casey discuss the fundamental gift of knowing and bearing testimony of Jesus Christ. They reference Elder Richard G. Scott's interpretation, emphasizing the certainty and personal impact of this testimony.
Casey [20:03]:
"The gift of knowing that Jesus is the Son of God... It felt like crucial to salvation."
The episode recounts historical accounts, such as Elsa Johnson's healing in Hiram, Ohio, illustrating the practical application of faith-based healing.
Scott [37:12]:
"To believe that Jesus is the Son of God and to have the faith to continue faithful."
These gifts involve discerning appropriate roles and services within the church, ensuring that each member's unique abilities are utilized effectively.
Casey [25:02]:
"Differences of administration pertains to understanding how those ordained to the priesthood should be directed in their duties."
Scott and Casey differentiate between wisdom and knowledge, drawing from Elder Stephen L. Richards' definitions to explain their interconnected roles in spiritual leadership.
Scott [35:20]:
"Wisdom is knowledge properly applied... It's a blessing to work with people dedicated to learning."
The discussion highlights that God continues to perform miracles, countering the notion that the age of miracles has ended. Historical anecdotes, such as Levi Curtis's near-death experience, are shared to illustrate ongoing miraculous events.
Casey [36:20]:
"Miracles require eyes to see. If you have that, we can see miracles happening around us all the time."
Prophecy is explored beyond predicting the future, encompassing bearing testimony of Christ's divinity and role as Redeemer.
Casey [44:40]:
"Prophecy is not just about telling the future... it's about affirming the divinity and mission of Jesus Christ."
A critical gift discussed is the ability to discern whether spiritual manifestations are divine or deceptive, essential for maintaining doctrinal integrity.
Scott [46:25]:
"Discerning spirits is being able to know when something genuinely comes from God and when it doesn't."
The controversial gift of speaking in tongues is examined, with historical context provided about its prevalence in early church history versus its rarity today. The necessity of purposeful use and interpretation is emphasized to prevent confusion and misuse.
Casey [53:18]:
"If it's not happening with a purpose... it can be a snare and can prove an injury."
Scott and Casey address whether individuals outside the Church can possess spiritual gifts, citing examples like Karl G. Maeser and Joseph Smith's translation of the Book of Mormon without formal church affiliation.
Casey [55:28]:
"Gifts of the Spirit can be accessed by all who believe in God and seek Him sincerely."
The podcast discusses varying interpretations among church leaders regarding whether Section 46 provides an exhaustive list of spiritual gifts. They cite Bruce R. McConkie and Marvin J. Ashton, who affirm that spiritual gifts are numerous and not limited to those listed scripturally.
Casey [55:28]:
"If you don't have anything listed in scriptures, don't despair. You have a gift."
Inclusivity in Meetings:
Embracing the principle of "visitors welcome" while maintaining order and doctrinal purity in church gatherings.
Discernment Practices:
Encouraging leaders to utilize their gift of discernment to evaluate spiritual manifestations and ensure they align with divine teachings.
Encouraging Gift Seeking:
Motivating members to seek spiritual gifts to both benefit themselves and uplift others, fostering a cohesive and supportive church community.
Casey [62:28]:
"Our friends and neighbors are always welcome but not expected to take the sacrament... seek to make newcomers feel wanted and comfortable."
Episode 120 of Church History Matters provides an insightful exploration of Doctrine and Covenants Section 46, emphasizing the importance of seeking and discerning spiritual gifts within the church. Scott and Casey effectively bridge historical context with contemporary application, offering listeners a nuanced understanding of how early church revelations continue to guide modern church practices. The episode underscores the communal purpose of spiritual gifts, advocating for their thoughtful and purpose-driven use to enhance both individual and collective spiritual journeys.
Notable Quotes:
Casey [00:00]:
"Lean into the gifts that God has given you and watch what heaven can do through you."
Scott [02:34]:
"Section 46 is dealing with who should come to our meetings."
Casey [05:24]:
"Generously allow people to come to church, but manage disruptions appropriately without violating scriptural directives."
Scott [14:09]:
"The Lord isn't saying that you just automatically have these gifts. He says that you seek the gifts."
Casey [15:36]:
"Does it help you draw closer to God? Does it help you be in a better position to help others draw closer to God? If you can, answer yes to those, this is probably from God."
Scott [35:20]:
"Wisdom is knowledge properly applied... It's a blessing to work with people dedicated to learning."
Scott [46:25]:
"Discerning spirits is being able to know when something genuinely comes from God and when it doesn't."
Casey [55:28]:
"Gifts of the Spirit can be accessed by all who believe in God and seek Him sincerely."
For a deeper dive into Section 46 and to continue the discussion on Sections 47 and 48, stay tuned for Part Two of this episode.