Send us Fan Mail

In May of 1922, a young Michigan farmer named Romie “Doc” Hodell was found hanging in a barn outside White Cloud. At first glance, it looked like suicide.

But his feet were touching the ground.

Within days, doctors ruled it murder. And what followed would become one of the strangest and most divisive criminal cases in Michigan history.

Three months earlier, Romie’s father had died suddenly after drinking coffee at the same farmhouse. His death had been ruled a stroke. But when his body was exhumed, state chemists claimed they found strychnine — enough, they said, to kill a dozen men.

Soon there were forged suicide notes. Allegations of jealousy. A violent fight the night before the barn death. A vigilante mob that tied ropes around suspects’ necks and threatened to lynch them. Confessions that were later recanted. Claims that police used ghostly theatrics inside the very barn where the body was found.

By the end of 1922, a 21-year-old woman named Meady Hodell was sentenced to life in prison. Her mother joined her. Her brother was convicted. Others were acquitted. Appeals followed. Retrials were ordered. And for decades, questions about forensic science, coercion, and small-town justice refused to disappear.

Was this a calculated poisoning and staged killing?
A family conspiracy?
Or a miscarriage of justice fueled by fear, rumor, and community pressure?

Meady Hodell would spend more than 26 years behind bars before her sentence was commuted.

This episode examines the evidence, the confessions, the toxicology, the mob justice, and the haunting uncertainty that still lingers in the sandy soil of Newaygo County.

Because sometimes the truth isn’t buried with the body.

Sometimes it never fully surfaces at all.

Support the show