Deep Cover: Season 6, Episode 3 - "The Confidante"

Release Date: May 19, 2025
Hosts: Jake Halpern and Jess McHugh

Introduction

In the gripping third episode of Season 6 of Deep Cover, titled "The Confidante," Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Jake Halpern and investigative expert Jess McHugh delve deeper into the enigmatic life of Sarah Kavanaugh. This episode unravels the complex web of deception spun by Sarah, exploring her relationships, the extent of her lies, and the profound impact on those around her.

Meeting the Confidante: Sam

The episode opens with Jake and Jess recounting their road trip to Rhode Island, where they aimed to meet individuals closest to Sarah—those who might hold pieces of the truth about her double life. One pivotal figure is Sam, Sarah's long-time physical therapist, who becomes a central confidante in uncovering Sarah's fabrications.

Notable Quote:
Sam: "She was really kind. She definitely knew me and she knew, I think, what I wanted to talk about type thing, if that makes sense." (17:35)

Sarah and Sam's relationship had evolved from a professional one to a deep emotional bond. Their interactions were suffused with shared vulnerabilities, creating a strong sense of trust and intimacy.

Insight:
Sarah's ability to forge deep emotional connections played a crucial role in her deception. By presenting herself as a compassionate and empathetic social worker, she gained the unwavering trust of those around her, particularly Sam.

The Web of Lies: Sarah's Deceptions Unveiled

Sarah's facade as a decorated Marine and cancer survivor begins to crumble as inconsistencies emerge. Through interviews and firsthand accounts, Jake and Jess reveal that Sarah fabricated her military service, family background, and even her medical condition.

Notable Quote:
Jake Halpern: "This was not it. This woman sounded more like a high school guidance counselor or the type of person you'd hope would be taking care of your grandma at the senior citizen home." (06:12)

Sarah's elaborate stories about her service in Iraq, her heroic acts, and her battle with cancer were entirely fictional. Her supposed siblings, including the tragic death of her twin brother Joel, were products of her imagination designed to elicit sympathy and admiration.

Notable Quote:
Nicole (Sarah's wife): "She literally stole money. And I said to her, I go, you're going to go to jail, Sarah. And she's like, you think." (47:45)

Confrontation and Collapse

The turning point in the episode occurs in January 2022 when rumors about Sarah's fraudulent claims reach her closest confidantes. Sam, initially in disbelief due to years of trust and evidence supporting Sarah's stories, grapples with the possibility of betrayal.

Notable Quote:
Nicole: "I literally turned around and I was going to my work. I turned around and I went right to her house... like, asking her, is this real? Is this real? Is this real? Is this real?" (44:37)

The revelation is devastating. Sarah confesses to never having served in the military, never having battled cancer, and fabricating her entire family history. This confession not only shatters the trust of her closest friends but also exposes the depth of her deception.

Insight:
Sarah's ability to maintain her lies for years illustrates the intricate psychological manipulation involved in long-term deceit. Her strategic manipulation of emotions and trust networks enabled her to sustain a double life without immediate detection.

Impact on the Victims

The fallout from Sarah's deception is profound and multifaceted. Both Sam and Justin, another key figure who was financially and emotionally invested in Sarah's fabricated stories, find themselves navigating the betrayal and its repercussions.

Notable Quote:
Justin: "We veterans look out for each other, and I'm not gonna sit here and let a fellow... what I thought at the time was a fellow veteran die from lack of treatment when I know there's an alternative if I can help it." (40:09)

Justin, a fellow veteran diagnosed with lung cancer, had trusted Sarah implicitly, even financially supporting her medical treatments. Sarah's deceit not only exploited his vulnerability but also endangered his trust in his support network.

Notable Quote:
Sam: "When she kept telling me that she couldn't afford it... I said, look, I don't want you to die." (40:59)

Sam's role as both a caregiver and confidante underscores the emotional and financial toll of Sarah's lies. The betrayal extends beyond personal relationships, affecting the very support systems meant to aid veterans.

The Aftermath and Reflection

In the aftermath of the confrontation, the episode delves into the lingering psychological impact on the victims. Sam grapples with fragmented memories and lingering doubts about the fabricated aspects of her relationship with Sarah, such as the existence of Sarah's family members.

Notable Quote:
Nicole: "I'm still coping with it. I don't want to be upset now. Memories will come up, and I'll be like, oh, did that really happen? And I think probably not." (46:32)

This internal conflict highlights the insidious nature of prolonged deceit, where victims struggle to reconcile their memories with the revelations of truth, leading to ongoing emotional distress.

Justin's Journey and Revelation

Parallel to Sam's story, Justin's personal narrative provides a compelling backdrop to the broader impact of Sarah's deceit. His battle with cancer and subsequent relationship with Sarah, built on mutual understanding and perceived shared hardship, exemplifies the depth of Sarah's manipulative reach.

Notable Quote:
Justin: "No one really was in my shoes except her. At least that's what I thought." (38:38)

Justin's unwavering support for Sarah, even in the face of financial strain, underscores the vulnerability exploited by Sarah. The eventual revelation forces him to confront not only the loss of faith in Sarah but also the broader implications for his trust in fellow veterans.

Conclusion: The Thin Line Between Empathy and Manipulation

"The Confidante" serves as a poignant exploration of how trust and empathy can be weaponized in the hands of a skilled deceiver. Sarah Kavanaugh's ability to manipulate those closest to her underscores the fragility of trust and the profound consequences of betrayal.

Notable Quote:
Jake Halpern: "What if that very person takes your most personal struggles and uses them to their advantage, sees them as an opportunity? Then the line between empathy and manipulation is thinner than we'd care to admit." (12:09)

This episode not only unpacks the specifics of Sarah's deception but also invites listeners to reflect on the broader themes of trust, vulnerability, and the complexities of human relationships in the face of betrayal.

Looking Forward

As Deep Cover continues to uncover the layers of Sarah Kavanaugh's double life, listeners are left anticipating the next episodes, which promise to further explore the ramifications of her deceit and the journey of healing for those she wronged.

Credits:
Produced by Amy Gaines, McQuaid, and Tali Emlen
Additional Production Support by Sonia Gerwitt
Edited by Karen Shakurji
Executive Producer: Jacob Smith
Original Scoring by Luis Guerra
Show Art by Sean Carney
Fact-Checking by Annika Robbins
Special Thanks to Sarah Nix, Izzy Carter, Daphne Chen, Jake Flanagan, and Greta Cohn
Executive Producer: Vicki Merrick

Hosts' Note:
Jess McHugh is currently researching a book on female con artists.

For ad-free episodes, early access, bonus content, and more, subscribe to Pushkin+ via Apple Podcasts or visit pushkin.fm/plus.