Dinner’s on Me with Jesse Tyler Ferguson
Episode: Side Dish: More Shoshana Bean (April 30, 2026)
Guest: Shoshana Bean
Location: Miriam's, Upper West Side, NYC
Episode Overview
In this "Side Dish" episode, Jesse Tyler Ferguson enjoys a candid and lively brunch conversation with Broadway star Shoshana Bean at Miriam’s on Manhattan’s Upper West Side. The episode dives into Shoshana’s early days hustling in the theater world, her experience stepping into the iconic role of Elphaba in Wicked, the emotional complexities of being a theatrical “replacement,” and her current excitement—and anxieties—about starring in the new Broadway musical Lost Boys. The conversation over Turkish eggs and borekas weaves through stories of perseverance, identity, vulnerability, and the unglamorous side of Broadway dreams.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
Stepping into Elphaba in Wicked
[02:45–09:37]
-
Reluctance and Sports Metaphors:
Shoshana reflects on not wanting her Broadway breakthrough moment to be all about her, referencing sports metaphors to describe her role as a “runner” rather than the “hitter” when first covering Elphaba.
- “It was almost like in baseball… I’m just the runner. Like, she’s the hitter.” (Shoshana, 02:45)
-
Embracing Leadership:
She credits earlier experiences in Hairspray, watching Harvey Fierstein and Marissa Jaret Winokur, for showing her how to lead a show:
- “I observed, I absorbed. I knew what to do.” (Shoshana, 04:30)
-
Feeling Like a Replacement:
Shoshana addresses imposter syndrome—knowing she wasn’t the producer’s first choice and struggling to own her power in the role. She describes how letting go of that pressure unexpectedly set her free on stage.
- “Something very interesting happens when you no longer give a fuck. You sort of liberate yourself to be your fullest self.” (Shoshana, 06:19)
-
Earning Her Place:
A pivotal moment occurred when, during a rare performance as Elphaba, producer Marc Platt saw her and realized, “What the fuck are we doing? We have her right here.” Within days, she got the offer.
- “Mark Platt was in the house that night and apparently he called the team and was like, what the fuck are we doing? We have her right here.” (Shoshana, 07:02)
-
Challenges of Being a Replacement:
Months into her run, director Joe Mantello returned and challenged her performance, pushing her to stop mimicking her predecessor and fully inhabit the character. It was then Shoshana started truly making Elphaba her own.
- “What I didn’t want to say was, like, I'm just sort of barfing up my version of what I saw.” (Shoshana, 08:03)
- “I think I just have to really just let this be mine now.” (Shoshana, 08:51)
-
Humor About Imposter Syndrome:
Jesse lightens the mood with playful banter:
- “I wake up every day saying, I am the new Alphabet.” (Jesse, 09:10)
The Magic and Anxiety of Opening a New Broadway Show (Lost Boys)
[13:08–18:29]
-
Generational Gaps and Backstage Memories:
Shoshana shares an anecdote about a young co-star, Benjamin Kjak, innocently asking if she ever met Judy Garland, drawing laughter about age and Broadway lore.
- “Did you ever meet her?” (Benjamin Kjak, [13:32])
- “How old do you think I am?” (Shoshana, [13:36])
-
Specialness and Timeliness:
Shoshana recounts a castmate's observation that everyone will see themselves in the characters, emphasizing the show’s themes of belonging, otherness, and found family.
- “It is about belonging and finding your people… anyone who’s been othered… will find that and feel that.” (Shoshana, 14:14)
-
Broadway Tech Humor:
She amusingly describes how Lost Boys is using a repurposed “Elphaba jib” (stage lift) originally from the Korean production of Wicked:
- “He's actually on… an actual Elphaba jib that has been reconstructed, but we got it from, like, the Korean production of Wicked.” (Shoshana, 15:22)
-
Pre-Show Jitters & Sacredness of Previews:
With Lost Boys about to open, Shoshana and Jesse discuss the mixture of excitement and nausea as they prepare for an audience. Shoshana confides in the unique sacredness of rehearsals before the floodgates of public feedback open:
- “It’s never had an audience, a mounting of a production anywhere… Our team has done this really interesting job of just keeping a lid on everything… So it really is… still untouched.” (Shoshana, 16:45–17:09)
- “This moment is still ours… It’s never gonna happen again.” (Shoshana, 17:39)
-
Reflections on the Theatrical Rollercoaster:
The conversation recognizes the recurring, paradoxical feelings performers experience: terror and exhilaration, especially right before a new show meets its first audience.
- “I was saying this to them... I know when something feels special. This is special. You’re not crazy. Don’t miss a single second of this.” (Shoshana, 17:51)
Day Jobs, Hustle, and Early New York Theater Life
[21:51–26:16]
-
Resisting the Musical Theater Mold:
Shoshana tells Jesse about her determination to be different at University of Cincinnati, digging for obscure, soulful songs that no one else would perform.
- “I just wanted to be different. So I dug so deep to find things that no one was doing… to just not be like anybody else.” (Shoshana, 22:51)
-
Breaking Out with Godspell and Life Off-Broadway:
Jesse brings up Shoshana’s unforgettable solo in Godspell, marveling at the rawness and energy she brought to her role.
- “You must have felt like you were bursting out of the gate. Like a bull bursting into the pen.” (Jesse, 23:18)
Shoshana reminisces about the production’s barebones origins—performed in an office building behind a Victoria’s Secret, with dressing rooms made from borrowed meeting spaces and file cabinets:
- “We would walk by. File cabinet stick, baby.” (Shoshana, 24:47)
-
Day Jobs Meeting Broadway Legends:
To pay the bills, Shoshana worked the front desk at Equinox gym:
- “I worked the front desk… That’s where I, like, met Mark Kudish. Fell in love with Mark Kudis… Mandy [Patinkin] worked out there…” (Shoshana, 25:07–25:28)
Jesse compares this to Justin Makita’s experience at Equinox West Hollywood, where Queen Latifah was a regular.
-
Life Changes, Or Not:
The narrative humorously tracks her move from the fifth floor of an office building (Godspell’s first home) to the York Theatre—“the basement of a church”—with “up” in career actually meaning “down” in real estate.
- “So by moving up, I meant down.” (Shoshana, 26:18)
Personal Stories & Theater Family
[26:36–29:37]
-
Family Talk and The Joy of Children:
Shoshana asks about Jesse’s husband and kids. Jesse comically recounts his son Beckett waking him up at 4:30am, excited for the day:
- “How could I possibly go back to bed when I’m so excited about the day?” (Beckett, 26:46)
-
Performer FOMO:
Reflections on the “fear of missing out” that accompanies both parenthood and performing:
- “Now I’m like, please put me to sleep. Please can I miss out?” (Shoshana, 27:33)
- “We do still… We’re not dead yet. Not dead inside.” (Shoshana, 27:43)
-
Rush of the First Audience:
Jesse and Shoshana bond over the “insane rush of energy” from performing for that first crowd, admitting to pre-show anxiety.
- “That first time in front of an audience, it's gonna be like that for a minute with this show.” (Jesse, 28:20)
-
New Show Magic:
Shoshana talks about how Lost Boys has had no out-of-town tryout, making the upcoming Broadway opening even more nerve-wracking and magical.
- “I realized, like, it never got an out of town tryout… I haven't done anything like that.” (Shoshana, 28:28)
- “This show feels a lot like Hairspray in that way. Just like a magical curation, an alchemy of people.” (Shoshana, 29:09)
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
-
“Something very interesting happens when you no longer give a fuck. You sort of liberate yourself to be your fullest self.”
— Shoshana Bean [06:19]
-
“He’s actually on… an actual Elphaba jib… from, like, the Korean production of Wicked.”
— Shoshana Bean [15:22]
-
“It's about belonging and finding your people and finding your family and finding your community… Anyone who’s been othered… will find that and feel that.”
— Shoshana Bean [14:14]
-
“That first time in front of an audience, it's gonna be like that for a minute with this show.”
— Jesse Tyler Ferguson [28:20]
Timestamps for Key Segments
- 02:45 – Shoshana on stepping into Wicked, sports metaphors, and leadership
- 06:19 – Letting go, finding freedom on stage
- 07:02 – Marc Platt recognizes Shoshana’s talent; offer extended
- 08:03 – Coping with being “just a replacement”
- 13:08 – Humorous generational moment: “Did you ever meet Judy Garland?”
- 14:14 – Universal themes of Lost Boys
- 15:22 – Technical details: Re-purposed Elphaba "jib" on Broadway
- 16:45 – The sacredness of preview rehearsals
- 21:51 – Finding musical theater “pockets” and resisting the norm
- 23:18 – Explosive debut in Godspell, offbeat NYC theater spaces
- 25:07 – Day jobs: Checking in Mandy Patinkin, Broadway legends at Equinox
- 26:36 – Parenthood, FOMO, and pre-show excitement
- 28:28 – Unique jitters for Lost Boys’ Broadway world premiere
- 29:09 – Comparing Lost Boys to the alchemy of Hairspray’s cast
Tone & Energy
The episode radiates warmth, self-deprecating humor, candid honesty, and a palpable sense of excitement—mixed with a performer’s perpetual anxiety—about theater, family, and being true to oneself. Jesse’s gentle banter keeps things playful, while Shoshana brings emotional depth and a rare window into both the pressure and joy of a Broadway life.
For Listeners New and Old
This episode offers a revealing backstage glimpse into Broadway stardom, with honest highs, relatable insecurities, unforgettable anecdotes, and inspiring reflections. Whether you’re a lifelong theater fan or just discovering Shoshana Bean, it’s a feel-good, full-hearted window into the real lives behind the curtain.