DTC Podcast - Bonus Episode Summary

How Hungryroot Scaled Meta Spend by 10x with Partnership Ads + Meta and adMixt on Cyber5 Success Strategies

Date: December 10, 2025

Main Theme

This episode dives into the changing landscape of DTC (direct-to-consumer) e-commerce marketing, focusing on strategies and success stories from Black Friday–Cyber Monday (“Cyber5”) 2025. The conversation centers on how Hungryroot massively scaled Meta (Facebook/Instagram) ad spend via partnership ads (collaborating with creators/influencers), best practices for campaign structure and creative diversification, and predictions for Q5 (the post-holiday “New Year” period) and 2026. Insights are shared across brand (Hungryroot), agency (adMixt), and platform (Meta) perspectives.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Cyber5 Recap: "Resilient" Consumers, Offers & Market Vibes

• General Sentiment: Despite economic concerns and negative news cycles, consumer spending was strong, with most brands exceeding forecasts (03:14 – 04:32).
• Success Factors: Brands that planned ahead, crafted bold compelling offers, and provided clear value propositions performed best.
• Shift in Shopping Patterns:
  • Sales started earlier, extending “Black Friday” deals across a broader time horizon, though Friday and Monday remained peak days.
  • “The Black Friday Cyber Monday bump is just smoothed out over a longer timeline over the month.” – Kevin, adMixt (06:20)

2. Creative Diversification & Partnership Ads

• What Works Now:
  • “Creative concept diversification” is critical—ads must have visibly different creative angles to capture new audiences (00:00, 07:20–07:56).
  • Partnership ads (using creators/influencers) have exploded, driving reach, scale, and performance like never before.
• Why Partnership Ads Succeed:
  • Enable brands to tap authentic voices across various niches, driving storytelling and trust.
  • “Creators allow us to tell those [diverse] stories…that’s been the magic behind it.” – Adam, Hungryroot (11:17)
  • They help solve many “jobs to be done,” e.g., dietary needs, meal planning, convenience (11:40–12:34).

Notable Quote

“It’s so much more compelling when that comes from the voice of somebody who actually is looking for that diet or has that nutrition restriction rather than me, you know, having to manufacture that in the story of a UGC ad.”
— Adam, Hungryroot (12:14)

Partnership Ad Selection:

• Success came from not over-focusing on micro vs. macro influencers. Trials across small, medium, and large creators showed that “all of them work,” but especially mid-sized creators with 40–60k followers (13:39).
• Leveraging partnership ads with Meta’s newer catalog ad integrations further boosts conversion by making the buying process frictionless (16:23–17:50).

3. Deal Structures & Creator Relationships

• Typical deals now start with a trial (flat fee), then evolve to multi-touch, longer-term, or revenue-sharing partnerships if successful.

• Influencers value repeat deals and amplified reach:

  “The average message has to be delivered three to four times from a creator/influencer for it to really actually drive incremental purchase intent.”
  — Adam, Hungryroot (20:50)

• Emphasize to creators that promoted partnership ads massively boost their own followings (21:33).

4. Nimbleness, Humor, and Creative Testing

• Brands must be prepared for scenario planning (“good, better, best”), ready to pivot offers, creatives, and adjust to inventory in real-time (25:49–27:01).
• Humor and unique storytelling (e.g., a houseboat-dweller getting groceries delivered by Hungryroot) consistently break through ad fatigue (24:22–25:18).

Notable Moment

“Our best performing performance ad this year was a creator who lived on a house boat in a lake…delivered this amazing piece of creative talking about…literally like a little motorboat, like carrying her Hungryroot box out to her houseboat…It worked because it broke through and delivered the message.”
— Adam, Hungryroot (24:22–25:25)

• New campaign strategies layer top/mid-funnel reach (often video/creator UGC) to build audience, then “close” during key sale days.

5. Q5 (Post-Holiday) Marketing: New Habits, No Deep Discounts Needed

• For Hungryroot, Q5 is their “Super Bowl,” as consumers look to make healthy changes post-holidays (27:20).

  • Sales volume surges immediately after Christmas (December 26th).
  • Focus shifts from deep discounts to highlighting product fundamentals and habit change support.
  • Scenarios, planning, and inventory preparedness are critical due to unpredictable demand spikes (28:29–29:32).

• Creative approach: Bank a wide array of segmented creator/story-driven ads and launch all at once to maximize incremental reach (29:46–30:43).

6. Campaign Structure: Testing, Automation, and Nuance

• There’s no “one size fits all” for campaign structure or testing. Structures differ by type of brand, SKU count, and vertical (31:51–33:27).
• Increasingly, advanced AI-driven automation and account simplification are recommended:
  • “The AI has gotten so much better than any one person’s ability to arbitrage…the best outcomes come from automation.” – Jake, Meta (33:32)
• Interest targeting still delivers incremental value at mid/top funnel (34:17).

Notable Quote

“Interest targeting still works. We do it because it works…It helps us grow mid and top of funnel when done correctly.”
— Kevin, adMixt (34:17)

7. The Return of Brand Marketing, Measurement & Strategy

• The pendulum is swinging back to brand marketing and rigorous measurement (via tools like Northbeam, TripleWhale).
• Being a solid “brand marketer” and strategist is now crucial—performance alone isn’t enough (37:35–38:01).
• Companies are investing more in organic content and combining insights from paid and organic to drive performance (35:00).

Notable Quote

“It’s cool to be a brand marketer again... People who understand strategy, segmentation, messaging, compelling storytelling—they’re needed on a team now in a way that they’ve never been.”
— Adam, Hungryroot (38:01)

8. AI, Incrementality & Looking Ahead to 2026

• AI is simplifying and turbocharging both performance and brand marketing. The focus: “getting the right content in front of the right consumer at the right time” (38:28).
• Advanced measurement of incrementality and mid/top funnel efforts is critical to maximize new customer acquisition and ROI (38:28–41:35).
• Even within platforms like Meta, specialized mid/top-funnel creative and targeting structures are essential—the “throw spaghetti at the wall” approach isn’t enough anymore (37:00–38:01).

Memorable Quotes & Timestamps

• Creative Diversity & Partnership Ads:
  “Ads really need to look distinct in order to drive performance and find new audiences...where we saw that was through partnership ads using creators.” – Jake, Meta (00:00, 07:20)

• Creator Value:
  “It makes so much more sense when that comes from the voice of somebody who actually is looking for that diet or has that nutrition restriction.” – Adam, Hungryroot (12:14)

• Deal Structures:
  “We don’t do one and dones because we find that actually repetition matters quite a bit here…The average message has to be delivered three to four times from a creator/influencer for it to really actually drive the level of incremental purchase intent.” – Adam (20:50)

• Planning and Nimbleness:
  “Having this notion of good, better, best, like three different scenario plans going in so that you know which actions to take when something happens is really important.” – Jake, Meta (25:49)

• Brand Marketing Resurgence:
  “It’s cool to be a brand marketer again…people who understand strategy, segmentation, messaging, compelling storytelling—they’re needed on a team now in a way that they've never been.” – Adam, Hungryroot (38:01)

Important Segment Timestamps

• Creative strategy and partnership ads intro: 00:00–01:00, 07:20–09:37
• Panel Intros (Meta, adMixt, Hungryroot): 01:22–03:14
• Cyber5 Results & Consumer Behavior: 03:25–06:20
• Offer and Promotional Trends: 07:56–10:12
• Hungryroot on Partnership Ads at Scale: 10:12–14:24
• How Partnership Ads Work (Meta POV): 14:39–15:42
• Meta’s Catalog Ads + Partnership Ads: 16:23–17:50
• Nimble Creative Testing & Unique Content: 22:09–25:25
• Deal/Creator Structures: 19:19–21:58
• Q5 (“post-holiday”) Marketing: 27:01–30:43
• Campaign Structure & Automation Discussion: 31:23–34:10
• Hot Takes & Strategy for 2026: 34:10–41:35

Conclusions & Takeaways

• Partnership ads (creator/influencer collaborations amplified with paid spend) are powering the next phase of DTC growth.
• Creative and offer diversity—tailored to specific audience “jobs to be done”—delivers incremental new reach and conversion, especially when paired with advanced automation.
• Nimbleness, scenario planning, and authenticity (including humor) are vital for both sales event periods and post-holiday spikes.
• Old-school brand marketing, nuanced campaign structure, and robust measurement are back in vogue as AI and platform tools mature.
• 2026 and beyond: AI, incrementality measurement, and avatar-based creative strategy will define DTC winners—along with a resurgent emphasis on creative and brand storytelling.

Hosts and Guests:

• Eric Dick (Host, DTC Podcast)
• Jake (Meta, Head of Industry)
• Kevin Simonson (adMixt)
• Adam Weber (Hungryroot, CMO)

For weekly DTC marketing tactics and insights, subscribe to the DTC newsletter at directtoconsumer.co.