Episode Summary: DTC Podcast Ep 476 - How to Leverage Google PMAX for Demand Capture and Growth | AKNF

Release Date: January 24, 2025
Host: Eric Dick
Guest: Dougie from Pilothouse's Google Team
Podcast: DTC Podcast by DTC Newsletter and Podcast

Introduction to Performance Max (PMAX) and the October Update

In Episode 476, Eric Dick welcomes Dougie to discuss Google's Performance Max (PMAX) campaigns, focusing particularly on a significant update rolled out in October 2024. This update alters how PMAX interacts with Shopping campaigns, impacting campaign prioritization and structure.

Key Points:

• PMAX is Google's automated campaign type designed to operate across multiple Google channels, including YouTube, Display, and Search.
• Initially, PMAX had a "black box" approach, where PMAX campaigns would always take precedence over Shopping campaigns for identical products.
• The October update shifts prioritization from PMAX always taking precedence to a more nuanced ad rank-based system.

Notable Quote:

Dougie [02:16]: "We're pretty excited they snuck that little update in end of October right before the promo periods like Black Friday, Cyber Monday."

Impacts on Campaign Structure

The October update allows advertisers more flexibility in structuring their campaigns by no longer having PMAX automatically overshadow Shopping campaigns. This change facilitates a hybrid approach, enabling the simultaneous use of both PMAX and Shopping campaigns to target different segments of the audience.

Key Points:

• Previously, PMAX campaigns would automatically prioritize over Shopping campaigns for the same product.
• With the update, prioritization is now based on ad rank, considering factors like bids, budgets, and ad optimization.
• This opens opportunities for hybrid campaign structures, where approximately 90% of Pilothouse's clients now use both PMAX and Shopping campaigns concurrently.

Notable Quote:

Dougie [03:35]: "With this update that came towards the end of October... it really opens up the door to have more hybrid structures."

Targeting New vs. Returning Customers

Dougie elaborates on how the revised PMAX allows for more strategic targeting of different customer segments. By leveraging separate Shopping and PMAX campaigns, advertisers can distinguish between warmer, brand-aware traffic and colder, high-intent traffic.

Key Points:

• PMAX is geared towards capturing warmer traffic, often those who have interacted with the brand before.
• Shopping campaigns can now target less brand-aware, yet high-intent shoppers effectively.
• This segmentation enhances demand capture by aligning campaign types with customer intent levels.

Notable Quote:

Dougie [07:37]: "So they're not necessarily within PMAX like two different campaigns... we can use Shopping to target more of those prospecting type, less brand consideration type users as well."

Differentiating New Customers and Returning Customers

A critical aspect of effective PMAX utilization is distinguishing between new and returning customers. Dougie emphasizes the importance of providing accurate first-party data to Google to enable PMAX to serve the appropriate audience segments.

Key Points:

• PMAX relies on first-party data to identify and differentiate new customers from returning ones.
• Accurate audience lists, managed through integrations like Klaviyo or direct imports from Shopify, are essential for PMAX optimization.
• Without proper data, PMAX may inaccurately attribute conversions, undermining campaign effectiveness.

Notable Quote:

Dougie [10:46]: "Generally it relies on your ability to input that accurate first-party data."

PMAX Performance: Initial Success vs. Long-Term Outcomes

The discussion shifts to the performance trajectory of PMAX campaigns. Dougie highlights that while PMAX can deliver strong initial results by capturing easy conversions, maintaining long-term performance requires strategic optimization and segmentation.

Key Points:

• Initial campaign launches should be minimally interacted with to allow PMAX to optimize based on provided audience signals and product targeting.
• Over time, campaigns benefit from feed management and segmentation strategies, adjusting budgets and targeting for optimal performance.
• Future enhancements, such as A/B testing capabilities for creative elements within PMAX, are anticipated to provide additional optimization levers.

Notable Quote:

Dougie [12:20]: "We are trying to leave our Campaigns without too much interaction for those first couple weeks."

Attribution Challenges and Solutions

Accurate attribution remains a significant challenge with PMAX due to its holistic approach, which can lead to double-counting or misattribution of conversions. Dougie outlines Pilothouse's strategies to mitigate these issues.

Key Points:

• Platform attribution models, including Google's data-driven attribution, often see conversions through their ecosystem, potentially ignoring external factors like organic or influencer-driven traffic.
• Pilothouse leverages GA4, Northbeam, and Triple Whale to triangulate data and ensure more accurate attribution across multiple touchpoints.
• The agency emphasizes not relying solely on platform attribution but integrating third-party tools to validate and refine conversion data.

Notable Quote:

Dougie [15:01]: "We are often checking back in with GA4 to get a better sense of the customer journey."

Brief Discussion on Google Ads Security

In a brief tangential discussion, Eric brings up a recent issue regarding criminal activities targeting Google Ads accounts. Dougie acknowledges the concern but notes that he hasn't encountered such incidents within his agency.

Key Points:

• A reported scam involves fraudulent ads mimicking Google Ads to steal user information.
• Dougie advises vigilance and encourages stakeholders to stay informed about such security threats.

Notable Quote:

Dougie [18:45]: "Oh, I'll have to send me that link. I haven't... but maybe we'll have to keep a keen eye out."

Wrap-Up and Future Topics

The episode concludes with light-hearted banter about hockey, a nod to future podcast topics like demand capture on YouTube ads, and an invitation for listeners to connect with Pilothouse for their Google advertising needs.

Key Points:

• Dougie mentions upcoming opportunities to experiment with YouTube and other Google platform features.
• The team at Pilothouse remains committed to evolving their strategies in response to platform changes and client needs.
• Listeners are encouraged to subscribe to the DTC newsletter and explore Pilothouse's services for further insights.

Notable Quote:

Eric Dick [19:47]: "I'm excited maybe in a future episode to talk a little bit about demand capture on YouTube ads."

Conclusion

Episode 476 of the DTC Podcast provides a comprehensive exploration of Google's Performance Max campaigns, particularly focusing on the significant October 2024 update. By leveraging a hybrid campaign structure and ensuring accurate data input, advertisers can enhance their demand capture strategies and better differentiate between new and returning customers. Additionally, the discussion on attribution underscores the importance of integrating multiple analytics tools to maintain campaign integrity. The episode offers valuable insights for DTC brands looking to optimize their Google advertising efforts amidst evolving platform dynamics.

For more detailed insights and step-by-step tactical guidance, subscribe to the DTC newsletter at directtoconsumer.co and stay tuned for upcoming episodes of the DTC Podcast.