DTC Podcast Episode 507: How to Optimize Subscription Offers for Better Retention and Profit with Jordan Narducci

Release Date: May 12, 2025

In Episode 507 of the DTC Podcast, host Eric Dick welcomes Jordan Narducci, a seasoned expert in direct-to-consumer (DTC) ecommerce strategies, to delve deep into the art of optimizing subscription offers to enhance customer retention and profitability. This comprehensive discussion unpacks Jordan’s journey, actionable strategies for subscription optimization, retention techniques, and the tools that can amplify these efforts.

1. Guest Introduction: Jordan Narducci’s Journey

Timestamp: [02:41]

Jordan Narducci begins by sharing his professional trajectory, highlighting his significant role at Kellogg as the Director of Global Direct to Consumer E-Commerce. At Kellogg, he spearheaded the global DTC strategy for prominent brands like Pringles and Cheez-it, successfully launching new products within six months—a stark contrast to Kellogg’s typical 2-3 year product launch cycle.

Transitioning from a corporate giant to the dynamic startup environment, Jordan found his niche in the hyper-growth supplement sector with Momentous. Here, he leveraged his DTC expertise to overhaul subscription programs, boosting subscription opt-in rates from 20% to 50%. This transformation underscored the profound impact of focused subscription strategies on lifetime value (LTV).

Notable Quote:

“Subscribers are the best type of customers. We should be doing something differently here.” — Jordan Narducci [05:33]

2. The Importance of Subscription Programs in DTC Brands

Timestamp: [05:33]

Jordan emphasizes that subscribers typically exhibit 3-4 times greater LTV compared to non-subscribers. By optimizing subscription offers, brands can significantly enhance their retention rates and overall profitability. He underscores the compounding effect of increasing subscription opt-in rates, which directly translates to sustained revenue growth.

Notable Quote:

“If you can increase the opt-in rate for subscription, the lifetime value of a subscriber tends to be anywhere from three to four times greater than a non-subscriber.” — Jordan Narducci [05:33]

3. Strategies for Optimizing Subscription Offers

A. Offer Stacking and Evergreen Offers

Timestamp: [22:06]

One of the pivotal strategies Jordan discusses is offer stacking. By allowing customers to combine discounts—for instance, stacking a 15% first-order discount with a 15% subscription discount—brands can make subscription offers more enticing. This approach transformed Momentous’s offer from a simple 15% off to a compelling “get up to 28% off when you subscribe,” significantly boosting opt-in rates.

Additionally, implementing evergreen offers—such as “get 25% off your first subscription order and 10% off subsequent orders”—ensures that new visitors consistently encounter attractive subscription incentives, maintaining a steady stream of subscribers.

Notable Quote:

“You want to create an offer that feels like a Black Friday offer every single day.” — Jordan Narducci [22:06]

B. Psychological Design and Value-Added Perks

Timestamp: [17:21]

Jordan highlights the importance of the psychological aspects of subscription offers. Designing subscription prompts with appealing colors, visuals, and clearly articulated benefits can make the offers more attractive. Additionally, incorporating free gifts—such as shaker bottles, magnet reminders, or sample products—adds tangible value, encouraging customers to subscribe and fostering habitual use.

Notable Quote:

“All of these things are encouraging rituals. Glasses, shaker bottles, frothers—all of these things are freebies, but they are in line with what you're trying to encourage, which is these routines and reminders to keep taking.” — Jordan Narducci [18:01]

4. Retention Strategies and Churn Prevention

A. Leveraging Subscription Reminder Emails

Timestamp: [26:35]

Subscription reminder emails are often underutilized tools in retention strategies. Jordan advises crafting these emails not just as reminders but as opportunities to reinforce the value of the subscription. Personalized messages that highlight benefits, upcoming perks, or offer incentives to stay can significantly reduce churn rates.

Notable Quote:

“The subscription reminder email is the most underappreciated and underutilized email.” — Jordan Narducci [00:00]

B. Incentives to Pause Rather Than Cancel

Timestamp: [15:02]

Instead of pushing customers to outright cancel, offering options to pause subscriptions can retain valuable subscribers. Incentives such as discounts or the ability to pause for a month or two can mitigate churn without losing the customer entirely.

Notable Quote:

“If you give them an incentive to pause, like here, pause for two months, pause for a month, you can give these discounts because a lot of brands don’t give enough away to keep the customers.” — Jordan Narducci [15:08]

C. Analytics and Continuous Improvement

Timestamp: [29:40]

Jordan underscores the necessity of robust analytics to monitor the impact of subscription strategies. Partnering with analytics teams, like Saris Analytics, allows brands to track real-time retention dashboards, measure the effectiveness of changes, and iterate based on data-driven insights.

Notable Quote:

“Having the foundation of analytics set up and then getting your subscription set up, that drives recurring revenue.” — Jordan Narducci [33:52]

5. Tools and Technologies for Subscription Management

A. Subscription Management Platforms

Timestamp: [31:23]

Jordan discusses various subscription management tools, emphasizing the importance of selecting a platform that aligns with a brand’s specific needs. Leading platforms include Recharge, Skio, Loopstay, and others, each offering unique features tailored to subscription management and churn prevention.

Notable Quote:

“The dominant player was Recharge, but there are new entrants like Skio, Loopstay that focus more on subscription management and churn prevention.” — Jordan Narducci [31:33]

B. Generative AI in Customer Support

Timestamp: [20:07]

Integrating Generative AI into customer support can revolutionize subscription management by automating responses to common inquiries, such as order tracking or subscription modifications. This automation frees up customer service teams to focus on more strategic tasks like customer education and upselling, ultimately driving additional revenue.

Notable Quote:

“You can eliminate like 80% of your tickets with these mundane tasks by getting Gen AI.” — Jordan Narducci [20:07]

6. Beyond Subscriptions: Paid Memberships for Non-Habitual Use Products

Timestamp: [33:52]

For industries where products aren’t consumed habitually, such as apparel or fragrance, Jordan introduces the concept of paid memberships. Unlike traditional subscriptions tied to specific products, paid memberships offer customers the flexibility to purchase any product while enjoying member-exclusive benefits like discounts and perks. This model fosters a recurring revenue stream by emphasizing brand loyalty.

Notable Quote:

“It’s like you’re subscribing to the brand versus subscribing to a product.” — Jordan Narducci [33:52]

Examples:

• Subscribify: Originating from a lingerie brand, this platform allows customers to pay a monthly fee to access discounts and perks across the entire product range.
• True Classics Tees & Meundies: Brands successfully implementing paid memberships by offering credits and exclusive benefits, enhancing customer retention and lifetime value.

7. Creating Irresistible Offers

Timestamp: [22:06]

Crafting offers that are too good to pass up can significantly drive subscription growth. Jordan advises aiming for discounts between 25% to 35%, balancing attractiveness with sustainability to avoid attracting deal hunters who may churn rapidly. By providing substantial initial discounts and maintaining moderate ongoing incentives, brands can maximize both subscription sign-ups and retention.

Notable Quote:

“Generally, I would say somewhere in the range of 25 to 35% is where you want to be. Anything above 35%, you start getting deal seekers and freebie hunters.” — Jordan Narducci [24:39]

8. Conclusion and Next Steps

As the conversation wraps up, Jordan shares insights into his consulting services, encouraging listeners to connect with him on LinkedIn for more information. He also highlights innovative tools like Bolt New, which leverages AI to streamline website creation—underscoring his commitment to integrating cutting-edge technology into DTC strategies.

Notable Quote:

“LinkedIn is probably the best way. Jordan Narducci. N A R D U C C.” — Jordan Narducci [38:30]

Key Takeaways

• Prioritize Subscriptions: Subscribers offer higher lifetime value and should be the focal point of retention strategies.
• Optimize Offers: Implement stacking and evergreen offers to make subscriptions more appealing.
• Enhance Retention: Use subscription reminder emails and offer incentives to pause rather than cancel.
• Leverage Technology: Utilize advanced subscription management platforms and generative AI to streamline processes and enhance customer experience.
• Explore Paid Memberships: For non-habitual products, consider paid memberships to foster brand loyalty and recurring revenue.
• Data-Driven Decisions: Continuously monitor and analyze subscription metrics to refine strategies and maximize profitability.

This episode serves as a treasure trove of insights for DTC brands aiming to refine their subscription models, enhance customer retention, and drive sustainable growth. Whether you're just starting with subscriptions or looking to optimize existing programs, Jordan Narducci’s expertise offers invaluable guidance to navigate the complexities of the DTC landscape.

For More Information:

• Connect with Jordan Narducci: LinkedIn Profile
• Explore Subscription Tools: Recharge, Skio, Loopstay, Subscribify
• Discover Website Building with AI: Bolt New

Subscribe to the DTC Podcast and join the community of disruptive DTC brands leveraging cutting-edge strategies to scale their businesses.