Episode Overview

Title: Ep 579: How to Nail DTC Merchandising in Q1: From Scroll to Sale
Date: January 23, 2026
Host: DTC Newsletter and Podcast Team (primarily "Eric Dick" as Host/C)
Guests: Taylor ("A") and Aves ("B") from Pilothouse

Theme:
This episode dives deep into the modern art and science of digital merchandising for direct-to-consumer (DTC) brands, especially as they transition from Q4’s holiday focus into Q1. The discussion unpacks how to bring the rich, tactile experience of in-store shopping into the digital funnel—transforming scrolls into sales through creative strategy, information architecture, and human-driven brand resonance.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Modern Consumer Journey & Digital Merchandising

• Consumers are comparing brands more than ever:
  “Consumers visit three to four different websites or brands before making a purchase for something that they're in the market for... They're fighting for cognitive awareness from the consumer. So you have to show up in a way that drives the appeal and that ultimate action.”
  — Taylor (A) [00:00]
• Digital is not like the retail shelf:
  Unlike retail, your direct competitors are not beside you, but you’re always up against the next tab or swipe. Winning attention means showing up creatively and contextually.

2. Translating Brick-and-Mortar Tactics to Digital Funnels

• Adapting the in-person experience:
  “In stores, you watch people pick up, feel, compare. Online, you don’t get that. So, you have to make the experience interesting and educational—showing up with strong USPs and creative content.”
  — Aves [04:20]
• Funnel congruency:
  Be mindful of where the user is in their journey and tailor messaging to their mindset and context.

3. Creative Execution: Identity, Emotional Truth & Social Context

• Move beyond direct comparison:
  “A competitor is not necessarily that other sheets brand, but whatever else is going on in the feed—memes, viral songs… It’s about recontextualizing merchandising in the world of scrolling.”
  — Aves [08:47]
• Content should resonate with emotional truths:
  Taylor shares advice to anchor messaging in "emotional truth":
  “You want to use storytelling to connect with them in a way that aligns to what we would call their emotional truth... That really strikes a chord with someone you can tap into at scale.”
  — Taylor [11:41]
• Example – Coffee Brand Landing Page:
  “I wrote the copy, I did not mention the product until the very end. It was all about the sensation of drinking good coffee… The product wasn’t even clear until you got to the bottom of the page... That was our top performing page and drove a ton of single session conversions.”
  — Aves [13:36]

4. Info Architecture & Conversion Flow

• Hierarchy of information matters:
  Guide users through emotional engagement, address objections, provide social proof, and facilitate clear choice—all organized logically down the page.
  “It’s about making the linear journey reflect the story: connect, socialize proof, solve a problem, allow choice. Not everything should be problem/solution.”
  — Taylor [11:41]
• Highlighting value and longevity:
  Subtle cues like a “lifetime guarantee” can signal reliability and belong to value-driven merchandising.
  “The subtle impact that like, a lifetime guarantee highlighted on a PDP does… makes me think, ‘Oh, that’s a real product…’”
  — Taylor [17:33]

5. Algorithmic & Data Considerations

• Algorithm event-based optimization:
  Ad performance must be tuned with an eye to where in the funnel the user is, understanding Meta/Andromeda shifts.
  “There’s always the temptation to turn off ads that look like they’re not performing, but if you look deeper, maybe they have lower CPM and higher CTR. That can mean they’re serving at an awareness level… Interpreting that kind of data is becoming more and more important.”
  — Taylor [18:59]

6. Practical Spot Checks for Brands

Creative/Brand Strategy

• Persona depth is crucial:
  “If you don’t know who your target personas are, that’s step one… After that, if you don’t have documentation on where those people spend their time, who trendsetters are, and what content style they engage with, you can’t merchandise for them.”
  — Aves [20:33]

Data & Funnel Analysis

• Check your funnel at every level:
  “Looking at how your top-, middle-, and bottom-of-funnel are all functioning using segment breakdowns in Meta, UTM filters in Shopify or GA... Cross-reference against competitors to see where you can beat the competition.”
  — Taylor [22:22]

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On digital competition:
  “A competitor is not necessarily another brand, but also what’s happening in the feed—memes, viral songs, everything...” — Aves [08:47]
• On emotional truth:
  “You want to use storytelling to connect with them in a way that aligns to what we would call their emotional truth.” — Taylor [11:41]
• On skipping product features for resonance:
  “There was not a single mention of the product until the very end of the page... It was our top performing page and drove conversions.” — Aves [13:36]
• On value & trust cues:
  “A lifetime guarantee on a PDP... makes me think, oh, that’s a real product.” — Taylor [17:33]
• On finding the edge between value and identity:
  “That intersection of value and identity—I think is just such a huge lever for brands to be focusing on this year.” — Taylor [17:33]

Segment Timestamps

• [00:00] – Setting the stage: The modern customer journey
• [04:01] – Transitioning from Q4 to Q1; creative resets
• [06:25] – Funnel congruency & customer context in merchandising
• [08:22] – Beyond product competitors; merchandising in the feed
• [11:41] – Info architecture: building the emotional journey online
• [13:36] – Coffee brand landing page case study
• [17:33] – Value, identity, and trust signals
• [18:59] – Data deep-dives, funnel analysis, and Meta’s evolving algorithm
• [20:33] – Quick spot checks for creative & data health

Takeaways for DTC Brands

• Get granular with personas & their digital habits.
• Build landing and product pages that tell a resonant, emotionally-driven story before selling.
• Understand your role on the feed—your competition is everything else, not just peer brands.
• Track every step in your funnel, tailoring content and design for where your customer actually is in their decision process.
• Lean on subtle value signals: lifetime guarantees, quality cues.
• Don’t turn off “underperforming” ads too quickly—they may be fueling awareness.
• Regularly audit creative against where actual personas and competitors are living online.

If you want more step-by-step insights, subscribe to the DTC Newsletter at directtoconsumer.co.