The Dynasty Nerds are reviewing the 2025 rookie class at the season's end. Hosts Garret Price and Andrew Mott break down how quarterbacks and running backs have performed, from disappointing debuts to breakout stars. With playoff positioning locked in and the regular season winding down, it's time to assess which rookies lived up to the hype and which ones left fantasy managers wanting more.

Listen to This Episode:

🎧 Apple Podcasts

🎙️ Spotify

▶️ YouTube

Cam Ward has been the biggest quarterback disappointment, averaging just 10.3 fantasy points per game for Tennessee. The hosts debate whether he'd even go in the first round of a 2025 redraft today, comparing his trajectory to Bryce Young's inconsistent path. With the Titans needing a new coach and multiple weapons, Ward's ceiling appears limited.

Meanwhile, Jaxson Dart has been the opposite story. Averaging 17.7 points per game despite losing his head coach and key offensive pieces, Dart has shown the ability to will his team to production. His rushing upside has been a superpower, and the hosts consider him a potential 1.01 or 1.02 in a Super Flex redraft.

Shedeur Sanders remains the ultimate roller coaster. After falling to the fifth round and sitting behind Dillon Gabriel, he's finally getting his shot in Cleveland. The hosts hope his final three games provide clarity, either elite or terrible, to avoid another muddy Browns offseason.

Ashton Jeanty remains the most talented back despite disappointing numbers behind Las Vegas's terrible offensive line. The hosts still believe he's the first running back off the board in a redraft, though the conversation has gotten closer.

Omarion Hampton has moved to the top of some rankings after showing he's built for the Chargers' offense. TreVeyon Henderson continues flashing elite big play ability in New England, averaging five yards per carry despite limited touches. Quinshon Judkins has been steady for Cleveland with nearly 800 rushing yards and seven touchdowns, though touchdown consistency remains an issue.

RJ Harvey, Cam Skattebo, and Woody Marks all face uncertain futures heading into an offseason loaded with veteran free agent running backs who could shake up depth charts across the league.

FastDraft: Download and deposit $10 using code NERDS on the FastDraft app and join your first draft to be eligible for a free one-year full bundle membership at Dynasty Nerds (new members only). FastDraft will match your deposit up to $50. Draft best ball teams in under 5 minutes!

Keywords: 2025 dynasty rookie class review, Jaxson Dart fantasy football, Cam Ward dynasty value, Ashton Jeanty rookie season, Omarion Hampton Chargers, TreVeyon Henderson Patriots, Quinshon Judkins Browns, Shedeur Sanders Cleveland, dynasty fantasy football rookies, 2025 NFL rookie review

00:00 Start

01:28 Cam Ward is Having a Terrible Season

06:35 Jaxson Dart is Looking Great

10:41 The Shedeur Sanders Roller Coaster Continues

16:45 Tyler Shough is on the Saints

21:24 Is Ashton Jeanty Still #1?

26:32 Omarion Hampton is Garret's #1 Rookie RB

28:54 TreVeyon Henderson is HERE!

31:43 Quinshon Judkins Looks Like a Bellcow

34:23 RJ Harvey is Gaining Momentum

39:09 Kaleb Johnson Makes Us Very Nervous

44:57 Cam Skattebo is Still a Legit Dynasty Asset

48:15 Bhayshul Tuten or Woody Marks?

51:48 Kyle Monangai Will be a Solid Fantasy RB

53:44 Jacory Croskey-Merrit's Dynasty Outlook

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices