Economist Podcasts: "Finally, a deal: the fragile peace in Gaza"
Date: October 9, 2025
Podcast: The Intelligence (The Economist)
Host: Rosie Blore, Jason Palmer
Featured Guest: Greg Karlstrom (Middle East correspondent)
Episode Overview
This episode marks a historic moment for the Middle East: a peace agreement between the Israeli government and Hamas after two years of intense conflict in Gaza. The hosts and Middle East correspondent Greg Karlstrom break down what the deal means, how it was reached—crediting a significant role to Donald Trump—and what the future may hold for governance in Gaza. The conversation also unpacks the challenges that may arise now that an initial ceasefire is in sight but long-term issues remain unresolved.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
1. Breakthrough Peace Agreement Announced
Timestamp: 02:04 – 03:35
-
Celebrations erupted in Gaza and Israel as both sides reached a peace plan, including singing, dancing, and hope for an end to hostilities.
-
The agreement comes two years and two days after the October 7, 2023 massacre that initiated the latest escalation.
Quote:
"This is the first time in two years that we have what looks like it could be a durable agreement to end the war in Gaza."
— Greg Karlstrom (03:16) -
The deal's details: Hamas has 72 hours post-signing to return 48 hostages. Of those, 20 are believed alive; Donald Trump predicts releases may stretch until Monday, and some bodies may not be recoverable.
-
In exchange, Israel will release 1,950 Palestinian prisoners, some held without charge.
Quote:
"Once the hostage deal is done, the Israeli army will pull back… It will continue to occupy more than half of Gaza, but will pull back from the big cities and allow a large influx of humanitarian aid."
— Greg Karlstrom (04:36)
2. Reactions from Both Sides
Timestamp: 04:58 – 05:55
- Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu hailed it as a "great day for Israel," shifting political narrative to portray the ceasefire as a victory after months of resistance.
- Hamas responded positively, publicly thanking Donald Trump and Arab mediators, though signaling concerns regarding the withdrawal, potential disarmament, and their future political role.
3. Donald Trump's Role & International Pressure
Timestamp: 05:55 – 07:02
-
Trump is credited with pushing through the agreement, leveraging significant American and international pressure.
-
The deal was only possible because the U.S. and Arab partners applied pressure to both sides—Netanyahu for Israel, and Arab states/Turkey for Hamas.
Quote:
"It's a demonstration that when an American president is serious about trying to end this war, he actually can end it."
— Greg Karlstrom (06:05)Quote:
"Arab states and Turkey… made it very clear to Hamas that this was the group’s last chance to reach a ceasefire."
— Greg Karlstrom (06:45)
4. Uncertain Future: Governance in Gaza
Timestamp: 07:02 – 08:25
-
The "Trump Plan" proposes a Board of Peace to govern post-war Gaza, chaired by Trump and including figures like Tony Blair. Palestinian partners are yet unnamed.
-
The Palestinian Authority seeks a role; Israel is resistant; Hamas insists on continued involvement despite the agreement ranging against it—a major flashpoint for the future.
Quote:
"One of the areas where this agreement could run into problems is Hamas insisting on playing a role in Gaza when the agreement says quite clearly that it should not."
— Greg Karlstrom (08:09)
5. Phases & Potential Pitfalls
Timestamp: 08:25 – 10:07
-
Though the Trump plan is officially presented as a single, comprehensive package, both parties have effectively split it into a phased approach—first focusing on the ceasefire and hostages, leaving questions of governance and disarmament for later.
-
These postponed issues (Hamas role, Israeli withdrawal, disarmament, recognition of Palestinian statehood) are deeply interconnected and contentious.
Quote:
"You have this circle of problems that you have to deal with and everything is interlocking. So maintaining this ceasefire is going to take a lot of sustained attention from Donald Trump."
— Greg Karlstrom (09:22) -
Sustaining peace will require continued American engagement and regional cooperation.
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
-
On the end of war’s devastation:
"Gaza has been left in ruins. Israel has lost allies and friends around the world. Finally, all that seems to be coming to an end."
— Greg Karlstrom (03:16) -
On the danger of unresolved issues:
"Once we get past the optimism of these first few days, I think a much more difficult reality might set in."
— Greg Karlstrom (09:55)
Timestamps for Key Segments
- 02:04: News of the peace deal and public reactions
- 03:16: Background on two years of conflict and destruction
- 03:46 – 04:58: Details of the hostage-prisoner exchange and military withdrawal
- 05:02: Public statements from Israel and Hamas on the agreement
- 05:55: Trump's involvement and international mediation
- 07:02 – 08:25: Postwar Gaza governance and complications
- 08:33: The phased nature of the agreement and unsolved challenges
Tone & Style
The tone is sober but cautiously optimistic regarding the breakthrough peace deal. The discussion blends relief at progress with realism about the challenges ahead. Greg Karlstrom's analysis is concise and clear, with critical insights into the political dynamics and unresolved issues.
Summary Table
| Segment | Main Points | Notable Quote & Time | |-------------------|---------------------------------------------------------------------|-------------------------------| | Peace Deal | Ceasefire, celebrations, hostages-for-prisoners exchange, partial pullback | "Durable agreement to end the war in Gaza." – Greg Karlstrom (03:16) | | Reactions | Israeli and Hamas positive statements, caveats remain | "Great day for Israel." – Netanyahu (05:02 summarized) | | Trump's Role | U.S. push crucial; Arab states pressured Hamas | "American president… actually can end it." – Greg (06:05) | | Gaza Governance | Board of Peace, role of PA/Hamas disputed, risk of breakdowns | "Hamas insists on playing a role…" – Greg (08:09) | | Phases & Pitfalls | Ceasefire/hostages now; governance/disarmament delayed | "Circle of problems… interlocking." – Greg (09:22) |
For listeners and readers, this episode delivers a detailed analysis of a turning point in the Gaza conflict—explaining the contents of the deal, who brokered it, and why, while warning that the peace remains fragile and much work remains.