Every Outfit Podcast Episode Summary

Title: Every Outfit
Episode: 227: On And Just Like That: Under the Table (Feat. Brock Collier & Marisa Meltzer)
Release Date: June 28, 2025

Hosts: Chelsea Fairless and Lauren Garrone
Guests: Brock Collier and Marisa Meltzer

Introduction

In Episode 227 of the Every Outfit podcast, titled "On And Just Like That: Under the Table", hosts Chelsea Fairless and Lauren Garrone delve deep into the fifth episode of the popular series "And Just Like That". Although Lauren remains on maternity leave, Chelsea expertly guides listeners through the intricate plotlines, later joined by special guests Brock Collier and Marisa Meltzer for an insightful discussion.

Episode Recap: "Under the Table"

[01:16] Chelsea kicks off the episode by recapping the latest developments in "And Just Like That". The focal point of this episode centers around Carrie Bradshaw grappling with newfound challenges in her upscale Gramercy Park townhouse. The introduction of a contentious downstairs neighbor, Duncan Reeves, a revered biographer, sets the stage for escalating tensions.

Carrie vs. The Neighbor

[03:48] A memorable sequence showcases Carrie’s array of extravagant shoes, symbolizing her struggle to maintain elegance amidst chaos. Brock humorously remarks, “Is Carrie wearing all of these crazy shoes?” highlighting the juxtaposition of fashion and frustration.

[04:09] The conflict intensifies when the neighbor confronts Carrie about her incessant heel-wearing, culminating in a dramatic scene where he threatens her with a meat cleaver. Lauren quips, “[...] I think she’s just being a lot more passively aggressive.”

Introduction of Duncan Reeves

[07:36] Brock introduces Duncan Reeves as a pivotal character—“He did indeed. His name is Duncan Reeves. He's basically Hot Walter Isaacson,” implying his significant role within the story. The dynamic between Carrie and Duncan hints at a potential romantic subplot, albeit fraught with complications given their living arrangements.

[10:01] Carrie’s attempt to foster peace by gifting Duncan an assortment of neighborhood delicacies backfires, showcasing her passive-aggressive nature. Brock muses, “That's what Carrie does. She gets pissed off. She storms out.”

Miranda and Carrie as Roommates

[15:00] The conversation shifts to the cohabitation woes between Miranda and Carrie. Both hosts express disappointment over the lack of harmony, lamenting missed opportunities for genuine connection. “We couldn’t have one fun thing happen while they were roommates,” Chelsea notes poignantly.

[22:21] A standout moment occurs when Carrie unexpectedly encounters a naked Miranda in the hallway, a scene Chelsea finds both hilarious and perplexing: “I still have no idea why Carrie is so shocked to see her friend's naked body.”

Seema’s Struggles and Charlotte’s Turmoil

[32:05] The discussion moves to Seema’s subplot—her challenges in securing a bank loan for her real estate agency. Lauren critiques the inconsistency with Seema’s previously successful portrayal: “Why can’t Seema just be cool?”

[34:02] Charlotte’s storyline takes a serious turn as Harry is diagnosed with prostate cancer. The hosts reflect on the emotional depth this brings to the series, though Brock questions the realism of Charlotte keeping Harry’s diagnosis a secret: “Which is unreasonable in my opinion.”

Glamping with Lily and the Wexleys

[35:19] The episode wrapped up with a glamping trip to Governor’s Island involving Lily and the Wexleys. The hosts find the portrayal disjointed and irrelevant, yearning for more substantive interactions: “We need better plot progression. It’s just a random assortment of stuff.”

Guest Insights: Brock Collier & Marisa Meltzer

Brock Collier and Marisa Meltzer join the conversation to provide their perspectives on the show's current trajectory.

Character Analysis and Plot Critique

[40:37] Brock and Marisa express frustration with the stagnant character development and lack of meaningful plot progression. Marisa comments, “It's so boring. They need more dramatic stuff or hilarious cringe moments.”

[42:41] The discussion turns to the show’s handling of aging and character evolution. Marisa laments, “Is it possible to change so much [...] personality transplant bordering on a lobotomy?”

[51:33] Chelsea shares her experience writing a profile on Sada Ramirez (Che Diaz), detailing the backlash and personal challenges: “The post was furious. And then something happened later that evening, like, oh, you know what it was.”

[57:00] The conversation explores the podcast’s own dynamic, with playful banter about identifying with characters and personal anecdotes reinforcing their critiques of the show’s direction.

Fashion and Cultural Commentary

[70:03] The guests shift towards discussing contemporary fashion, specifically Jonathan Anderson’s first Dior collection. Both express mild disappointment, with Marisa saying, “It felt safe. It felt marketable, but not that exciting.”

[78:12] They segue into a critique of Glossier’s evolving brand identity, emphasizing the disconnect between original brand ethos and current marketing strategies: “It just looks ransacked at Sephora too.”

Notable Quotes

• Chelsea Fairless [03:07]: "So this is fully her novel."
• Lauren Garrone [08:04]: "It's like having a secret weapon against spam."
• Brock Collier [22:21]: "Carrie's so shocked to see her friend's naked body."
• Lauren Garrone [40:00]: "This is what I was most invested in in this episode."
• Marisa Meltzer [51:33]: "Is is possible to change so much in however many years we're supposed to have elapsed."

Conclusion

The Every Outfit podcast episode 227 offers a thorough and engaging analysis of "And Just Like That: Under the Table", supplemented by insightful commentary from Brock Collier and Marisa Meltzer. The hosts navigate through complex character dynamics, plot inconsistencies, and cultural critiques, all while maintaining a lively and relatable discourse. Listeners are left with a clear picture of the episode’s strengths and shortcomings, along with anticipations for future developments in the series.

For more in-depth discussions and exclusive content, listeners are encouraged to join the podcast’s Patreon community.

Join the Conversation:
Stay updated with Every Outfit by subscribing on your favorite podcast platform and following their Instagram account. For exclusive content and deeper discussions, consider supporting them on Patreon.