C (35:15)
Well, Sesame street was brought to you by the letters A, B and C. I was sitting at my desk in London in June, July of 2010. I'd been back in London from China for about six or seven years and my old friends and colleagues were making hay and I was working on the IPO of the online grocer in the UK called Ocado. And we had a much more junior role than I'd been hoping for. We've been working, working on that mandate for two years. And then my coverage banker that covered the founders of Ocado went and left us to go and become the CFO of Ocado ahead of the ipo and then felt he couldn't over, over favor his former employer. Employer. Just as we were wading through that, you know, the IPO of Agricultural bank of China. ABC hit the tape. A 19.2 billion IPO versus my 200 million pound IPO in London. You know, they had a, a cornerstone tranche where corporate sovereign wealth funds, Hong Kong tycoons were cutting checks in aggregate for five and a half billion dollars worth of stock which was going to be locked up for one to two years. I mean it was, I thought oh my God, what's going on? This wasn't a one off. And you know there were, there were a whole sort of queue of billion dollar plus IPOs in Hong Kong China lining up for months and well, suffice to say four months later, you know, one of those, One of those IPOs was, you know, the, the IPO of the insurance giant AIA which was being sold down by AIG to pay off the, pay off the, the, the, the GFC loan from the Federal Reserve bank of New York. And anyway that was enough. My FOMO kicked in and I was back in Hong Kong allocating those very same AIA shares. Four months later at the end of October, I pivoted back to China. Anyway, I, I've been getting to, getting to the current day. I've been overweight China for almost two years now since it was a very, very unloved trade. And you know, I got hate mail for a note that I wrote in the summer of 24 where I said, you know, you're all long China anyway just most of you are long it at the wrong price because you know they were constantly beating, beating up their, constantly, constantly beating up their, their, their, their boards so that they could be even more long. Nvidia. You know where, where, where were Jensen's GPUs made? You know, you know they couldn't own China because Chinese equities because China was about to retake Taiwan. Yet they had some pretty concentrated Taiwan risk themselves. Anyway, fast forward. You know, by September you had Dave Tepper giving Joe Kernan a heart attack on Schoolbox by saying you should buy everything China. And then we have one of these classic western fried rice trades. I'll talk about those in a second. But fast forward to today. I do think that the worst of the trade war US China trade war news is behind us. Green light from top. What I mean like that the Chinese leadership want domestic equities to work as a unit of savings, as a real asset class, not a token of speculation. China has plenty of scope for targeted fiscal stimulus and that's the dirty secret of all markets. Fiscal drives, equity markets. There is plenty of cash in terms of household and corporate savings both on and offshore that can be put to work. The companies are cash rich and are being encouraged to buy back their own shares. You know, one of the, one of the big, and we're seeing an inflection in earnings now. One of the big sort of potential killers to Chinese equity bull runs of the past is that, you know, all of this new issuance comes out of the woodworks as soon as the market starts to trend up. I think the danger of that is very low. With anti involution policies, Chinese corporates are not being encouraged to, to, to, to, to, to invest that capital and that cash in, you know, excess manufacturing capacity now and then. Finally, you know, I'm a curly value value investor at heart and these, these assets are really a really cheap, so in terms of, in terms of positioning, you know, when Dave Tepper goes on, goes on, goes on CNBC and saying he's, he's, he's backing up the truck on Chinese assets, you get, you get the hot money flows, right? And every guy in a fleece vest in midtown Manhattan reaches for 30 Delta calls on Alibaba, right? Listen, I've got nothing, nothing wrong against Alibaba again. I worked on Alibaba's ADR IPO back in, back in 2014. It's a fantastic business. But the, you know, the core US listed ADRs are, you know, very dangerous vessels for getting whipsawed by hot money flows. And the way I've been gradually building my overweight position in China is to stick with my lbc, which is my lower beta China. So you know, a dirty little secret that, you know, one of the best performing assets anywhere in the world over the past 24, 24 months has been state owned Chinese banks as their, as their dividend yields have compressed from double digits to down closer to 5 and a half, 6%. Right? Utilities Telcos are another example of that. You know, quite funny. So a core holding for me in Bushy is Dvye, which is the iShares emerging market high dividend ETF. If you look at the attribution of returns which have been great over the past 12 months, almost a quarter of those has come from those Chinese banks. And you know, I know certain, certain sort of vocal owners of this ETF that are also in the China is uninvestable camp, I find that dissonance quite hard to piece together. The other thing I wanted to point out is that chart at the bottom there, that red line there is just the relative chart of the A shares. So the domestically listed A shares in China versus the offshore shares in the MSCI China, the FXI ETF which is the iShares Large Cap China ETF. Now we, in the midpoint of last year the A shares started to catch ground. And this is really consistent with what I'm talking about in terms of the encouragement of domestic investment in in equities. And you know this looks to me like the start of a, a real trend over, over, over, over the coming and provided you know, I mean I, I'm, I'm, I'm long both on and offshore Chinese equities. But I, I have a hunch that the, the onshore, the onshore names are going to be the ones that that outperform and also that will will outperform both on the up and the downside. Remember you know, when what, what's known as the national team get involved Chinese equities at times of dislocation it's the big A share names where, where that, where the buying comes and actually you know, financials are relative. Those big, those big financials are actually a relatively small percentage of the CSI 300 which is the index that the A shares, the the A share ETF tracks. So you know that's, that's, that's, that's kind of kind of where I am on China. Just another illustration of, of this Western fried rice. So this is Tencent versus Alibaba since the, you know, the October 2022 lows which is when you know I jump there was, which was, which was my first jump back into Chinese equities post Covid was to buy my old friend ten Cent. Now one of the reasons that you know, number reasons I like it. But if I, I think both are formidable companies. But if you look at Tencent which has its primary listing venue in Hong Kong, right. You know there's, there's an unsponsored ADR that people can trade in the US but it is, it's essentially it's an overseas stock. If you compare the drawdown profile between Tencent and Alibaba over the last three years, I mean the difference is stark. You know, the thing about, you know, think about trades as being able to stay in them and if you're regularly looking at sort of 30, 40% drawdowns, you know, that's an awful, there's an awful lot of stopping out or an awful lot of you know, round tripping pain. So you know, that's, that you know those drawdowns, you know, cost total returns over time, right? And since that, you know, since that, my entry point in, in October 22, you know, 10 cent 700 Hong Kong has outperformed the Alibaba ADR by about 60%. Actually, I went to see 10 cent in Shenzhen back in late October, a trip organized by our mutual friend Louis Garve. I have to say, you know, there's, it's very easy to, you know, even in my mind's eye, you know, it was, it's my largest single stock position and I go, you know, maybe I should be trimming it, you know, you know, you know, Wei Shin is, is, is, is, is a, is an amazing super app. They've cracked the, they've, they've cracked, crack the super app concept with WeChat. If you look at what they're doing in the cloud business, what they're looking in AI, you look at the Tencent meeting is their equivalent of Zoom and it's just sort of night and day better. They've got unicorns and decacorns sort of lurking in the corner of the broom cupboard everywhere. There's just so much, so much value. Sorry about, sorry about Barney. They're just, they're just feels very strong.