Fat Mascara Podcast Summary
Episode: Ep. 569: Pat McGrath 2.0, What Greenpoint Smells Like & The Week’s Beauty News
Release Date: March 12, 2025
Hosts: Jennifer Sullivan & Jessica Matlin

Introduction and Overview

In Episode 569 of Fat Mascara, hosts Jennifer Sullivan and Jessica "Jess" Matlin dive deep into a variety of beauty-related topics, blending personal experiences with industry news and listener interactions. The episode emphasizes a balance between candid discussions and upbeat energy, ensuring listeners are both entertained and informed.

Personal Beauty Journeys: Jess’s Fraxel Treatment ([05:20] - [08:18])

Jess opens up about her recent Fraxel laser treatment, sharing the physical and emotional journey of undergoing such a procedure.

• Jess: “Fraxel is not a joke... it’s blasting off layers of your skin and it’s not comfortable.” ([05:25])

She recounts the challenges post-treatment, including discomfort and the importance of proper skincare:

• Jess: “Do not slug. Moisturize twice a day. Use a gentle cleanser and sunscreen.” ([06:09])

Jennifer adds value by discussing the meticulous research they undertake to respond to listener inquiries about unavailable products, highlighting their commitment to thoroughness.

Cultural Moments: Meghan Markle’s New Show ([08:13] - [12:16])

The hosts pivot to discussing Meghan Markle’s latest television appearance, reminiscing about guest Daniel Martin’s participation in the podcast’s first episode.

• Jess: “Watching Daniel with this face that I would have the same face of, what the hell is going on... so funny.” ([09:35])

Jennifer shares a humorous personal anecdote about her husband inadvertently reading Prada’s accompanying booklet, sparking a conversation about intentional typos and brand messaging.

Product Spotlights and Recommendations ([12:40] - [43:55])

Sunscreen Focus: Blue Lizard ([12:40] - [14:43])

Jennifer and Jess discuss their favorite sunscreens, emphasizing the importance of protection and suitability for sensitive skin.

• Jennifer: “One of our favorites is, of course, Blue Lizard Pediatrician trusted dermatologist tested... free from potentially irritating parabens, phthalates, fragrances.” ([13:08])

• Jess: “I love them for my child because I love a spray. Easy to get her, but they dry clear.” ([13:36])

Skin Supplements: Rituals Hyacine ([13:43] - [15:09])

Jennifer introduces Rituals’ Hyacine skin supplements, highlighting their clinical benefits and sustainable practices.

• Jennifer: “In a clinical study, Ritual Hyacine led to a 2.9 times increase in skin smoothness within 90 days compared to placebo.” ([13:43])

Lush’s Activism and Partnership ([21:44] - [23:37])

Jess shines a spotlight on Lush’s partnership with Change the Ref, an organization advocating for gun control through art.

• Jess: “They are partnering with an organization called Change the Ref... founder Manuel and Patricia Oliver are the parents of Joaquin Guac Oliver, one of the 17 children killed at Parkland.” ([22:00])

Major Beauty News

Pat McGrath Joins Louis Vuitton ([24:03] - [28:31])

The episode highlights the groundbreaking collaboration between makeup legend Pat McGrath and luxury fashion house Louis Vuitton.

• Jen: “Pat McGrath, creative director of Louis Vuitton... I’m confused because I feel like Pat McGrath Labs is like...” ([24:15])

Jess reflects on Pat McGrath’s journey from establishing her own successful brand to taking on a role with Louis Vuitton, pondering the implications for both brands.

• Jess: “She came out with her own brand... now she’s ready for another challenge.” ([25:15])

Jennifer discusses the commercialization aspect, questioning whether Pat McGrath can maintain her artistic integrity within a high-fashion framework.

• Jen: “I think it's becoming bigger than her. And it's very commercial now... Maybe at Louis, she can do something amazing.” ([27:39])

Bond No. 9’s Greenpoint Fragrance ([28:31] - [34:03])

The hosts delve into Bond No. 9’s latest fragrance, "Greenpoint," exploring its inspiration and sensory profile.

• Jess: “It makes me smile because Greenpoint is... my brother lived in Greenpoint... median rent now is $5100 for a one-bedroom.” ([28:41])

Jennifer connects the fragrance to the historical and cultural backdrop of Greenpoint, Brooklyn, discussing its evocative scent notes like juicy pear and fresh cardamom.

• Jen: “When I think of what Greenpoint would smell like, I think of it as a former industrial neighborhood...” ([32:28])

Listener Interaction: Raising a Wand ([36:29] - [43:55])

The segment encourages listener participation through product recommendations and beauty questions, fostering a community-driven atmosphere.

Eyeliner Recommendations

Jennifer and Jess share listener-submitted favorite brown eyeliners, highlighting products like Hourglass Mechanical Gel Eyeliner and EM Cosmetics Brush Tip Illustrated Eyeliner.

• Ines: “Sephora’s Wink It Felt Tip Eyeliner in Cup of Joe... Black Magic Cocoa Edit Liquid Eyeliner.” ([38:14])

Body Wash Praise

Jess praises "Chance of Sunny" body wash, emphasizing its suitability for sensitive skin and value.

• Jess: “It's got nothing in it that's gonna bother your skin... $14 for a sizable body wash.” ([41:13])

Facial Razor Appreciation

Jennifer showcases the Tweezerman Stainless Steel Facial Razor, lauding its durable design and effectiveness.

• Jen: “I love this because it’s so slim... it's much more expensive than it is when it's only like $15.” ([43:54])

Conclusion and Calls to Action ([43:53] - [49:37])

The hosts wrap up by reiterating the importance of listener feedback and encouraging reviews on platforms like Spotify and Apple Podcasts. They also promote their partnership with MasterClass, offering listeners a discount on annual memberships.

• Jennifer: “It's your reviews and feedback that help us make the podcast even better. Head over to iTunes to rate and review us...” ([48:43])

Notable Quotes

• Jess on Fraxel: “Fraxel is not a joke... it’s blasting off layers of your skin and it’s not comfortable.” ([05:25])

• Jennifer on Prada’s Branding: “Pat McGrath Labs is like... if you've built up a brand, it's under identity.” ([24:36])

• Jess on Lush’s Activism: “I spent like, 15 minutes last night just on their Instagram...” ([22:00])

• Jen on Greenpoint Scent: “When I think of what Greenpoint would smell like, I think of it as a former industrial neighborhood.” ([32:28])

Final Thoughts

Episode 569 of Fat Mascara masterfully intertwines personal anecdotes with insightful industry commentary, offering listeners a comprehensive look into the multifaceted world of beauty culture. From high-profile collaborations to everyday product recommendations, Jennifer Sullivan and Jess Matlin ensure that their audience remains both entertained and well-informed.

Become a Member: Support the podcast and gain access to exclusive content by becoming a member here.

Follow Fat Mascara:
Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.