Felonious Florida: The Altidor Massacre | Episode 2: Secrets

Release Date: May 6, 2025

Introduction to the Altidor Massacre

On a tranquil spring day in 1997, the serene community of Miramar, Florida, was shattered by a horrific quadruple homicide. The victims—three generations of the Altidore family—were found brutally murdered in their family home. Detective Ron Peluso spearheaded the investigation, meticulously gathering evidence that initially pointed to George L. Altidore, the sole surviving family member. However, George maintained a solid alibi, leaving the case unresolved for nearly three decades.

The Altidore Family: Roots and Reverence

The Altidore family's story begins in the remote Haitian village of Tamonde, a community where Teresia La Verne, the matriarch, was a beloved figure. Teresia, along with her husband Ferdinand, raised five children on their 100-acre farm, contributing significantly to their village's prosperity and well-being.

Teresia's Legacy:

"She was high respected in the town. She was the sweetest thing ever. She is one of the smartest ones, too, and I will consider her as a leader because she always has things for you to do, delegate."
— Alberta Altidore [12:02]

Teresia's nieces and nephews described her as selfless and nurturing, often referring to her affectionately as "Matant Tilly."

Marie Altidore: A Multifaceted Persona

Marie Altidore, Teresia's daughter, was a bright and reserved individual. Her academic prowess and linguistic talents—fluent in French, Spanish, Creole, and English—set her apart. Despite her achievements, Marie remained humble, consistently attributing her success to her faith.

Marie’s Humble Nature:

"She was about her studies, having a future, and living her best life."
— Fabiola [18:34]

Her transition to the United States marked a significant shift as she pursued higher education and career opportunities in Miami, quickly establishing herself within the community.

A Sudden Engagement: George and Marie's Marriage

In a surprising turn of events, Marie reconnected with George Altidore, a childhood acquaintance from a nearby village. Their relationship blossomed swiftly, culminating in a lavish wedding on February 12, 1994, at Casa de Alabanza Baptist Church in Miami.

Concerns Among Family:

"I knew there was something wrong. I knew they were not in love, I could tell."
— Fabiola [22:32]

Family members noted an undercurrent of unease during the ceremony. Marie’s subdued demeanor and the choice of a Baptist church, diverging from the family's Catholic roots, raised eyebrows and fostered suspicions.

Marie’s Uncharacteristic Behavior:

"Mommy, she was so jovial. She's always smiling. That part was missing in her face the day of the wedding."
— Alberta Altidore [27:41]

Signs of Distress: A Growing Shadow Over Happiness

Despite outward appearances of success and expansion—Marie’s career advancement, George’s professional growth, and the arrival of their daughter Sabrina—nuances of sorrow persisted within Marie. Her withdrawal from social interactions and increased paranoia hinted at underlying issues.

Marie’s Paranoia:

"We had several calls at her house where she was very paranoid and worried about things."
— Detective Ron Peluso [35:21]

An incident during Teresia’s visit highlighted Marie’s escalating mistrust. A neighbor seeking assistance with a letter was met with suspicion, leading to a police involvement that further strained Marie’s relationships.

George Altidore: The Survivor’s Enigma

Following the massacre, George Altidore presented himself as the devastated widower. His comprehensive alibi—supported by multiple witnesses from his workplace—initially cleared him of suspicion. However, Detective Peluso's instincts suggested otherwise.

George’s Statement:

"He has no enemies, he does not owe anyone any large sums of money, and he knew of no reason why anyone would kill his family."
— Detective Ron Peluso [37:44]

Peluso, however, harbored doubts about George's account, perceiving a discrepancy between his public persona and potential hidden truths.

Detective’s Doubts:

"Believe me, you don't know what happens behind closed doors. And that was this particular case. This guy with a Jekyll and a Hyde behind closed doors was a completely different person."
— Detective Ron Peluso [38:38]

Detective Peluso’s Investigation: Unearthing Secrets

Detective Peluso's methodical approach delved deep into the family's history, uncovering layers of complexity and potential motives. The investigation explored Marie's guarded nature and her unspoken struggles, which might have contributed to the tragic events.

Alberta’s Insights:

"I saw a sadness in her face too. Even though I don't know exactly what was going on. She did not share that with us, unfortunately."
— Alberta Altidore [33:40]

Peluso’s exploration revealed inconsistencies in George’s narratives and subtle hints towards possible internal family conflicts or external pressures.

Clues and Conundrums: The Path to Truth

Despite George’s seemingly strong alibi, various elements—Marie’s paranoia, the family's observations of George’s distant behavior, and the lack of clear motive—complicated the case. Detective Peluso remained steadfast in his pursuit of the truth, convinced that George was concealing critical information.

Detective’s Determination:

"The more questions Paluso asked, the deeper he dug into the Altidores, the more convinced he became that George was holding back."
— David Shutes [39:11]

This persistent investigation set the stage for uncovering long-buried secrets that could explain the unfathomable violence that erupted in the Altidore household.

Conclusion and Cliffhanger

As Detective Peluso continued to piece together the fragmented narrative of the Altidor Massacre, the lingering question remained: What hidden truths within the Altidore family led to such unimaginable violence? With George as the primary suspect but holding a seemingly unshakable alibi, the mystery deepened, promising further revelations in the subsequent episodes of Felonious Florida.

Stay tuned for the next episode of Felonious Florida, where Detective Peluso continues his relentless quest to uncover the truth behind the Altidor Massacre.

Notable Quotes:

• "She was high respected in the town. She was the sweetest thing ever."
  — Alberta Altidore [12:02]

• "She was outside crying. I've never seen a bride who cries like that on their wedding day."
  — Fabiola [28:12]

• "A lot of that was show, I think. Like a lot of people would tell me he's a hard working man. He works for the family. He loves his family. He wouldn't do anything wrong."
  — Detective Ron Peluso [38:38]

For more information and to follow the investigation, visit Felonious Florida and follow us on social media.