Fire Escape Cast #94 (Game of the Year) Summary
Release Date: November 18, 2024
In Episode #94 of Fire Escape Cast, hosts Dan Ryckert, Mary Kish, and Mike Mahardy convene to honor the standout video games of the year across various customized categories. The episode is punctuated by their characteristic banter, strategic discussions, and occasional interruptions from co-host Jake, ultimately culminating in the announcement of each category's winner.
1. Most Dewey Game of the Year
Nominees:
- Echo Point Nova
- Astrobot
- Children of the Sun
- House Flipper
- Mini Shoot Adventures
- Super Monkey Ball Banana Rumble
- UFO 50
- Pepper Grinder
- Wild Bastards
Discussion: The hosts deliberated on games that emphasized action and gameplay mechanics over narrative depth. Dan highlighted the superficial story elements in some nominees, favoring titles that allow players to "just do shit" without extensive dialogue.
Winner: Animal Well
Notable Quote:
- Jake: "Fire Escape's most dewy game of the year is Animal Well, congrats." ([23:10])
2. Most Talky Game of the Year
Nominees:
- The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom
- Metaphor: Refantazio
- Pucky Squire
- Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth
- Persona 3 Reloaded
- Halibut
Discussion: The conversation focused on games with an abundance of dialogue that might detract from the gaming experience. The hosts debated the balance between storytelling and gameplay, questioning whether excessive talking enhances or hinders player engagement.
Winner: Persona 3 Reloaded
Notable Quote:
- Mary: "I just wanna reiterate that I think all three of these would be excellent winners for different reasons." ([25:21])
3. Coziest Game of the Year
Nominees:
- House Flipper
- Fields of Mystria
- Ette Tavern Manager Simulator
- Neva
- Astrobot
- Plucky Squire
- Little Kitty Big City
Discussion: The hosts examined games that offer a comforting and relaxing experience, perfect for unwinding. They assessed titles based on their ability to provide a serene environment and stress-free gameplay.
Winner: Little Kitty Big City
Notable Quote:
- Mary: "There's nothing wrong with it. It's pure. It's like paint." ([49:21])
4. Best Mechanic
Nominees:
- Memories in Prince of Persia
- Hoverboard in Echo Point Nova
- Frisbee in Animal Well
- Possessing People in Slitterhead
- Strike in Balatro
Discussion: This category spotlighted innovative and engaging gameplay mechanics. The hosts debated which mechanics best enhance player interaction and enjoyment.
Winner: Frisbee in Animal Well
Notable Quote:
- Mary: "It deserves to stay. It is a brilliant mechanic." ([53:48])
5. Best Remake/Remaster
Nominees:
- Silent Hill 2 Remake
- Dead Rising Deluxe Remaster
- Red Dead Redemption PC
- Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door Remaster
- The Last of Us Part 2 Remaster
- Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth
Discussion: The conversation centered on remakes and remasters that successfully rejuvenated classic titles. The hosts evaluated how well these updates preserved the spirit of the original while introducing modern enhancements.
Winner: Silent Hill 2 Remake
Notable Quote:
- Jake: "Silent Hill 2 remake a little too long. They cut like three hours from that game." ([327:46])
6. Most Fun to Play with Friends
Nominees:
- Lethal Company
- Helldivers 2
- Echo Point Nova
- Core Keeper
- Content Warning
- Outlast Trials
- Call of Duty: Black Ops 6
- Jackbox Survey Scramble
- Children of the Sun
- Mario Party Jamboree
- Astrobot Speedruns
Discussion: Focusing on multiplayer experiences, the hosts discussed games that shine when played in groups, emphasizing teamwork, competition, and shared enjoyment.
Winner: Helldivers 2
Notable Quote:
- Mary: "Helldivers should win." ([347:16])
7. Most Fucked Fucker
Nominees:
- The Cat Ghost in Animal Well
- Mimic Bile
- Titans in Helldivers 2
- Paul Phoenix in Tekken 8
- Nightwing in Palworld
Discussion: This uniquely titled category highlighted antagonistic or particularly challenging characters in games. The hosts debated which characters epitomized the term humorously or as true adversaries.
Winner: Metaphor: Refantazio
Notable Quote:
- Jake: "Fire Escape's worst title of the year is Metaphor: Refantazio." ([341:20])
8. Best Game to Look At
Nominees:
- Harold Halibut
- Black Myth: Wukong
- Astrobot
- Shadow of Erdtree
- Neva
Discussion: Aesthetics and visual design took center stage as the hosts evaluated games based on their artistic merit, graphical fidelity, and overall visual appeal.
Winner: Neva
Notable Quote:
- Mary: "It really is a marvel to look at. I think it's perfect." ([282:25])
9. Most Funny Game
Nominees:
- Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
- Alan Wake 2: Night Springs and Lake House DLCs
- Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth
- Rise of the Ronin
- Suicide Squad
- Kill the Justice League
Discussion: Exploring humor in gaming, the hosts discussed titles that successfully incorporated comedic elements, enhancing the entertainment value.
Winner: Thank Goodness You're Here
Notable Quote:
- Mary: "I really like showing it off to people... It's the funniest game I've ever played." ([292:25])
10. Most Fucked Fucker
(Note: This appears to be a duplication in categories. Assuming it's meant to be a different category or repetition.)
11. Best Game We Played That Didn't Come Out This Year
Nominees:
- Hollow Knight
- Case of the Golden Idol
- Diablo 4
- Warhammer
- The Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker HD
- The Out Foxes
Discussion: Highlighting outstanding games from previous years, the hosts recognized titles that left a lasting impression despite not being recent releases.
Winner: Hollow Knight
Notable Quote:
- Jake: "Fire Escape's best game we played that didn't come out this year is Hollow Knight." ([347:53])
12. Most Fucked Fucker
(Note: Another repetition. It seems the transcript loops or has overlapping categories.)
Final Thoughts
Throughout the episode, the hosts passionately defended their nominations, engaging in lively debates and playful conflicts. The culmination of their discussions celebrated both innovative mechanics and visually stunning titles, while also honoring games that excelled in humor and multiplayer experiences.
Notable Episode Highlights:
- Dan's Advocacy: Dan passionately defended Metaphor: Refantazio and Animal Well, emphasizing their unique contributions to gaming mechanics and storytelling.
- Mary's Champions: Mary championed Little Kitty Big City for its cozy gameplay and Crow Country for revitalizing the survival horror genre.
- Mike's Favorites: Mike lauded Helldivers 2 for its intense multiplayer dynamics and Diablo 4 for its engaging mechanics, despite some pacing issues.
The episode not only celebrated the best games of the year but also showcased the camaraderie and spirited discussions that Fire Escape Cast is renowned for.
Support Fire Escape Cast at fireescapecast.com