Best Of: 50 Years Of SNL Musical Guests / Black History Through Blues

Summary

Fresh Air Weekend Summary: Best Of: 50 Years Of SNL Musical Guests / Black History Through Blues

Release Date: February 1, 2025

In this engrossing episode of Fresh Air Weekend, host Tonya Moseley explores two significant cultural touchstones: Amir Questlove Thompson’s documentary celebrating five decades of Saturday Night Live (SNL) musical performances and Harvard Professor Imani Perry’s insightful book, Black and Blues. Through in-depth conversations with Questlove, TV critic David Biancooli, and Imani Perry, the episode delves into the intersections of music, television, and black history, offering listeners a rich tapestry of stories, analyses, and reflections.

---

Celebrating 50 Years of SNL Music

Amir Questlove Thompson's Documentary

Amir Questlove Thompson, Grammy-winning musician and co-founder of the hip-hop band The Roots, introduces his new documentary, Ladies and Gentlemen, 50 Years of SNL Music. Questlove serves as both a musician and a music historian, meticulously charting the evolution of SNL’s musical landscape over half a century. He emphasizes the show's role in showcasing diverse musical talents and its impact on American culture.

Notable Insights and Anecdotes:

• Iconic Performances: Questlove reflects on memorable moments, such as the infamous "More Cowbell" sketch. At [05:21], he recounts, “...when Beyonce was very polite about it, but she was very hesitant. And when I say hesitant, I mean...but she was not having it.”
• Behind-the-Scenes Dynamics: The documentary features behind-the-scenes footage and anecdotes, revealing the spontaneous and often chaotic nature of live television. Questlove shares, “[...] it's the most fascinating part of SNL, like how it's able to happen every week without fail” ([08:40]).

David Biancooli’s Review: TV critic David Biancooli provides a thoughtful review of Questlove’s film alongside Morgan Neville’s four-part documentary series, SNL 50 Beyond Saturday Night. Biancooli praises the comprehensive and engaging portrayal of SNL’s musical history, noting at [05:56], “It's such a solid, well-selected overview that I can think of only one SNL music performance I really wish had been included.”

Key Discussions:

• Integration of Diverse Genres: The documentaries highlight how SNL has been a platform for various musical genres, including the emergence of hip-hop and its assimilation into mainstream culture.
• Risk and Innovation: Questlove discusses the inherent risks in live performances, sharing stories like Ashlee Simpson’s lip-sync mishap and Elvis Costello’s abrupt song stoppage ([22:23]).

---

Black History Through Blues with Imani Perry

Imani Perry’s Black and Blues

Imani Perry, a renowned scholar and professor at Harvard University, delves into her latest book, Black and Blues. Perry explores the multifaceted significance of the color blue in black life, intertwining historical, cultural, and musical narratives. From the indigo trade in West Africa to the soulful strains of blues music, Perry argues that blue symbolizes both resilience and melancholy in black identity.

Notable Quotes and Passages:

• Passage from Page 21: Perry reads a poignant excerpt, “[...] everybody loves blue. It is human as can be. But everybody doesn't love black. Many have hated it, and that is inhumane. If you don't already, I will make you love it with my blues song.” ([35:32]).

In-Depth Discussions:

• Blue in Music and Culture: Perry explains the duality of blue in both visual and musical contexts. At [39:45], she states, “The blue note... transforms it much in the way that there's something indispensable about the presence of black people in the United States in what it becomes.”
• Historical Contexts: She examines pivotal moments, such as Louis Armstrong’s 1951 recording of “What Did I Do to Be So Black and Blue” and Nina Simone’s “Little Girl Blue,” highlighting how these works encapsulate broader social and emotional struggles ([42:33] & [47:28]).
• Music as Expression and Healing: Perry discusses how blues music serves as a channel for expressing pain and fostering healing within the black community, bridging personal anguish with collective memory.

Analysis of Musical Elements:

• Blue Notes: Perry elaborates on the concept of blue notes in jazz, defining them as “the in between” notes that don’t conform strictly to the Western scale, thereby adding depth and emotion to the music ([39:45]).
• Cultural Resonance: She connects musical expressions to broader themes of identity and resistance, illustrating how black musicians have used blues to navigate and articulate their experiences ([46:24]).

Storytelling and Personal Reflections:

• Perry shares personal reflections on how blue has been a constant presence in her understanding of blackness, both as a color and a musical form. She emphasizes the importance of recognizing and celebrating the beauty and complexity embedded in black culture ([51:59]).

---

Conclusion

This episode of Fresh Air Weekend masterfully intertwines the celebration of SNL’s rich musical legacy with a profound exploration of black history through the lens of blues music. Through engaging conversations and heartfelt anecdotes, Amir Questlove Thompson and Imani Perry illuminate the enduring power of music as a reflection of cultural identity and societal change. TV critic David Biancooli’s insightful reviews further enhance the narrative, offering listeners a comprehensive understanding of how entertainment and history are deeply interconnected.

By highlighting both the creative triumphs and the behind-the-scenes challenges of live television and music production, the episode underscores the resilience and innovation that define these cultural institutions. Meanwhile, Imani Perry’s scholarly perspective invites listeners to contemplate the nuanced ways in which color and sound articulate the black experience, enriching the broader discourse on race and culture in America.

Whether you’re a longtime fan of SNL, a music enthusiast, or someone interested in the intersections of race and art, this episode of Fresh Air Weekend provides a thoughtful and enriching listen, capturing the essence of fifty years of musical evolution and the enduring legacy of the blues.

---

Produced by Teresa Madden. Executive Producer: Danny Miller. Managing Producer: Sam Brigger. Technical Director and Engineer: Audrey Bentham.

Transcript

[Evan Ross Katz]

This message is brought to you by the Official White Lotus Podcast from hbo. Join host Evan Ross Katz as he.

[David Biancooli]

Looks back at the first two seasons.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Of the show with Jennifer Coolidge, Murray.

[David Biancooli]

Bartlett, Megan Fahey and more.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Listen before the new season starts February 16th on Max.

[Tonya Moseley]

From WHYY in Philadelphia, this is FRESH AIR Weekend. I'm Tonya Moseley. Today, Amir Questlove Thompson. He's the co director of a new documentary about the music of Saturday Night Live over the last 50 years. It's called Ladies and Gentlemen, 50 Years of SNL Music. TV critic David Biancooley also reviews Questlove's film and a four part documentary series about SNL. We'll also hear from author and scholar Imani Perry. Her new book Black and Blues explores the significance of blue in black life, from the indigo trade to the birth of blues music.

[Evan Ross Katz]

What did I do to be so black and blue?

[Tonya Moseley]

That's coming up on FRESH AIR Weekend.

[Evan Ross Katz]

This message is brought to you by the Official White Lotus Podcast from hbo. Join host Evan Ross Katz as he looks back at the first two seasons of the show with Jennifer Coolidge, Murray.

[David Biancooli]

Bartlett, Megan Fahey and more.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Listen before the new season starts February 16th on Max.

[Terry Gross]

This message comes from Charles Schwab. When it comes to managing your wealth, Schwab gives you more choices like full service, wealth management and advice when you need it. You can also invest on your own and trade on thinkorswim. Visit schwab.com to learn more. This message comes from CarMax. Buying a car is a big decision, a decision you should feel absolutely confident about. And and when you shop with CarMax, you will because CarMax offers a 10 day money back guarantee so you can feel confident that you made the right choice for you. If you're not completely satisfied with your decision, simply bring it back within 10 days for a full refund. Always shop with confidence at CarMax, the way car buying should be. See CarMax.com for details. This message comes from Thuma. Create your oasis with Thuma, a modern design company that specializes in furniture and home goods by stripping away everything but the essential. Thuma makes elevated beds with premium materials and intentional details with clean lines, subtle curves and minimalist style. The Thuma bed collection is available in four signature finishes to match any design aesthetic. To get $100 towards your first bed purchase, go to Thuma Co NPR this.

[Tonya Moseley]

Is FRESH AIR WEEKEND. I'm Tanya Mosley. As part of Saturday Night Live's 50th anniversary celebration this year, there's a new documentary highlighting the musical guests and music comedy sketches that the show has featured over the decades. It's called ladies and gentlemen, 50 years of SNL music. It was co directed by our guest Grammy winning musician and Oscar winning documentary filmmaker Amir Questlove Thompson. He's the co founder and drummer of the hip hop band the Roots. It's the house band for the Tonight show with Jimmy Fallon. Before we get into Questlove's conversation, our TV critic David B. Cooley offers us his review of the film and a four part documentary series that's also part of the 50th anniversary celebration. Both the film and the series are now streaming on Peacock.

[Amir Questlove Thompson]

The two new Saturday Night Live documentaries come from filmmakers who bring their own interests and perspectives. NBC's Ladies and Gentlemen, 50 Years of SNL Music comes from Amir Questlove Thompson, who's both a musician and a music historian. And the four part SNL 50 beyond Saturday night, now streaming on Peacock, comes from Morgan Neville, who's as interested in the creative process as he is in letting people tell their own stories. Questlove, in his movie length study, mines the archive of a half century of musical performances as well as the emergence of hip hop and other genres into the show and the culture. Some classic performances are run full length, others are sampled in cleverly compiled montages and mashups. It's such a solid, well selected overview that I can think of only one SNL music performance I really wish had been included. Paul Simon, backed by Ladysmith Black Mambazo on their thrilling 1986 rendition of Diamonds on the Soles of Her Shoes. But Questlove covers a lot. Not only infamous appearances by Elvis Costello, Sinead O'Connor, Ashlee Simpson and Kanye, but even comedy sketches and videos built around music. The infamous D in a Box Christmas song with Justin Timberlake and SNL cast member Andy Samberg is deconstructed. So is another classic SNL musical moment featuring guest host Paul Rudd and musical guest Beyonce. Timberlake tells how that got on the air with Timberlake, Samberg and cast member Bobby Moynihan as her music video backup dancers. Partway through Timberlake's account, we hear the start of the actual single lady's sketch.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Andy texted me and he said, hey, are you in town? I said, yeah, I'm in the city.

[Amir Questlove Thompson]

He said, bobby Moynihan, he has this great idea for a sketch about you, me and him being Beyonce's background dancers for single ladies that never made the cut.

[Evan Ross Katz]

She's gonna be the musical guest this week. I was like, full, like, leotard. And he's like, yeah. And I was like, oh, this is too funny. Like, we have to do this.

[Amir Questlove Thompson]

She was very polite about it, but she was very hesitant. And when I say hesitant, I mean.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Like, she was not having it. Beyonce, oh, my gosh. I'm so psyched to do this new video with you.

[David Biancooli]

Me too.

[Terry Gross]

But, you know, there's this one thing.

[Amir Questlove Thompson]

I haven't met the other dancers.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Are we gonna have time to rehearse? Oh, look, don't worry about the other dancers, B town. I hand picked them myself. These guys are pros. These guys. I'm like, does she know how funny.

[Tonya Moseley]

This is gonna be?

[Evan Ross Katz]

Like, how beloved this whole moment will be?

[Amir Questlove Thompson]

So I said, bring me the leotard. So I put the leotard and the.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Heels and the hose on and everything.

[Amir Questlove Thompson]

And I put a robe on and I walked and I knocked on her door.

[Evan Ross Katz]

I walked in and I threw the robe down and I put my hands on my hips.

[Amir Questlove Thompson]

And she was like, no, you didn't. Morgan Neville's SNL documentary series is broken into four episodes, each one looking at a different aspect of the show and its history. The first one looks at the original audition tapes by many of the people who tried out for snl with those same people watching and reacting to their younger selves. Some scream, some cringe, some cry. Some, like Pete Davidson, laugh.

[David Biancooli]

I'm not good at sex, you know?

[Evan Ross Katz]

Cause I wasn't raised in a brothel.

[David Biancooli]

I'm 20.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Like, I don't. I'm not good at it. I don't understand why my girlfriend gets mad. She's like, that's it. I'm like, yeah. Like, what did you expect? Like, you know any good guitar players that have been playing guitar for a year?

[Amir Questlove Thompson]

Another episode spends a week observing how an installment of SNL is created by following the process from start to finish, mostly from the point of view of the writers. A third episode gets even more laser focused, spending an hour on a single sketch. And it's a brilliant choice coming from the midway point of the show's 50 year run. It's the sketch recording session featuring guest star Christopher Walken and cast members Will Ferrell, Jimmy Fallon, Chris Parnell, and others. You may know it better by the name most associated with it, More cowbell. It's a sketch Walken and Farrell elevated after the dress rehearsal by going all out in character. The sketch was set during the recording session for Blue Oyster cult's 1970s hit Don't Fear the Reaper. Farrell plays a very loud Cowbell. And Walken portrays the track's very enthusiastic music producer. Jimmy Fallon remembers Christopher Walken for air upped his game.

[Evan Ross Katz]

He was almost doing an impersonation of Christopher Walken. He was talking like no other human being would talk ever. All right, here we go.

[Tonya Moseley]

Fear Don't Fear the Reaper.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Take one, roll.

[Amir Questlove Thompson]

All right.

[Evan Ross Katz]

One, two, three, four.

[Amir Questlove Thompson]

Once the sketch began on the live show, Farrell, who had written it, knew they had connected big time with the studio audience.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Are you sure that was sounding okay? I'll be honest, fellas, it was sounding great. But I could have used a little more cowbell. As soon as he delivers that first.

[David Biancooli]

Line, I could use a little more cowbell. And that gets a huge. I'm like, oh, they're in, they're in. Oh, goody.

[Amir Questlove Thompson]

There's more coming in this new recounting we do not hear from Christopher Walken himself, which Dana Carvey says is writing character for him. Carvey even slips into character as Walken to make his point.

[Evan Ross Katz]

That keeps his cool factor here. Yeah, that he's not gonna. Not gonna go down memory lane. Let the work speak for itself.

[Amir Questlove Thompson]

The final episode of Neville's documentary series hones in on one seemingly random but ultimately seminal year. The 1985, 86 season. When executive producer Lorne Michaels, who had left the show after its first successful five year cycle with the original cast, was asked back by NBC executive Brandon Tartikoff. SNL was in free fall. And the common wisdom was that Lorne never would return to a sinking ship. But he did when Brandon was trying.

[Evan Ross Katz]

To get me to come back in 1985.

[Tonya Moseley]

Hello, I'm Brandon Tartikoff, president of NBC Entertainment.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Someone said, you know, you've already done Saturday Night Live. Somebody who wants to be you does Saturday Night Live. And I thought, oh, right. Well, I kind of enjoyed being me.

[Amir Questlove Thompson]

It's one of the few times in either documentary we hear from Michaels. Clearly he prefers to let the cast and crew and the shows speak for themselves, and they do. Tina Fey and Amy Poehler, among others, tell some really great stories. There may not be enough screen time given to some SNL veterans in their stories, from Bill Murray to Kate McKinnon and Sarah Sherman, but there are an awful lot of laughs and memories and music and insights and just the right amount of cowbell.

[Tonya Moseley]

David Biancooli is professor of Television studies at Rowan University in New Jersey. Both of the SNL specials are now streaming on Peac. Ladies and gentlemen, 50 years of SNL music was co directed by our first guest, Amir Questlove. Thompson. He's the co founder of the hip hop group the Roots, which is the house band for the Tonight show with Jimmy Fallon, who is a former SNL cast member. Questlove is a busy guy these days. He's also co produced a documentary about Sly Stone called Sly Lives, AKA the Burden of Black Genius, which will start streaming on Hulu on February 13th. His 2021 documentary Summer of Soul, about the 1969 Harlem Cultural Festival won an Oscar for best documentary. Terry interviewed Questlove about the Saturday Night Live documentary last week.

[Imani Perry]

Amir, welcome back to FRESH air. It's a pleasure to have you back on.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Thank you for having me.

[Imani Perry]

Were the Roots ever on snl?

[Evan Ross Katz]

You know, it's weird. I've been on SNL in every configuration except for the one that I want to be on, which is actual music guest. Like, I've been a punchline on Weekend Update. I've been part of a Timothee Chalamet sketch. I've been mentioning monologues. I've been in like a Lonely island sketch. But I guess one could say that my dream, one of the main reasons why I was excited to be on the tonight show, like 16 years ago when we first got offered the position, I was like, great. This puts me within like one degree of the brass ring, which is, you know, doing snl. So, you know, kind of funny how I'm a part of that ecosystem almost in every way. But the one way I want to be, which is like musical guests one day. But, you know, the Roots are working on their 17th album right now. So, you know, I'm still hanging onto my dream.

[Imani Perry]

Good. So do you think that the Saturday Night Live band, particularly in the Paul Schaeffer era, though I don't know what era you started watching.

[Evan Ross Katz]

I assume it was Paul Schaefer, the very beginning. So my Saturday Night Live obsession really starts with, you know, the epicenter of my entire music world is Soul Train. And it just so happens that, you know, for most of America, especially with Soul Train in its prime, you know, everyone has a Saturday afternoon 12pm cleaning the house, watching Soul Train experience. But in Philadelphia, kind of weird. My Soul Train experience was always at one in the morning. And so I had parents that were very forward thinking, very cool. And of course, I'd have to be in bed at like 8:30pm so whenever, like the Love Boat theme starts, it's like, gotta go to bed. Not with that deep voice, but yeah, basically gotta go to bed. And the agreement was that be in bed at 8:30 and then at 12:30 midnight, we will wake you up. And by 12:30, Weekend Update is over for SNL. And then their music guest does two songs. And so I would go downstairs, turn on the tv, watch the two songs from snl, whoever the music guest was. And then Soul Train comes on at 1 in the morning and then I'm in bed at 2am and up for church at 7:30 in the morning. That's pretty much like my Life from like 5 until maybe 11. Then Soul Train started coming on like in the afternoon. But I never stopped watching snl. So I was there from the very, very beginning. It was nothing like it. I know that's the cliche that you're gonna hear a lot about this 50th anniversary, but there was truly nothing like it on television.

[Tonya Moseley]

Amir Questlove Thompson speaking with Terry Gross. His new documentary, ladies and gentlemen, 50 years of SNL Music, is now streaming on Peacock. We'll hear more of their conversation after a short break. I'm Tanya Moseley, and this is FRESH AIR WEEKEND.

[Terry Gross]

This message comes from BetterHelp Online Therapy. Relationships of all kinds are complicated, and they tend to come with a lot of tough questions. From questions about co workers to family to romantic partners, therapy can be your safe space to talk about challenges you face in any of life's relationships. BetterHelp offers therapy 100% online, and sign up takes only a few minutes. Visit betterhelp.com NPR to get 10% off your first month. That's betterhelp.com NPR this message comes from PEMCO Mutual Insurance Company. You know that moment when things take an unexpected turn and you get that sudden sinking feeling that maybe it could have been avoided? Pemco Insurance wants to help you avoid that feeling by sharing prevention tips that empower you to prevent some of life's preventable pitfalls. Because Pemco's commitment to their customers goes beyond the moment of acclaim, it's about being with their customers every day. [e-mail] Prevention this message comes from Carvana.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Finance your next car the convenient way, with customizable, transparent terms, all online, make your budget work for you and swap hassle for convenience with Carvana.

[Imani Perry]

One of the questions that you ask both cast members and people behind the scenes at SNL is can you humor the SNL theme? So I want to play the attempts to hum the theme and then talk.

[Tonya Moseley]

To you about it.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Yes. Okay.

[Imani Perry]

I can't hum the theme either.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Hey, no one can.

[Imani Perry]

I immediately went to the actual theme and I want to before we hear it. I want to challenge our listeners to just pause and think for a second if they can hum the theme. Now let's play the theme. You know what I realized listening back, which I hadn't ever really thought of before?

[Evan Ross Katz]

What?

[Imani Perry]

There isn't a melody. I mean, it's like you're coming in in the middle of an improvisation.

[Evan Ross Katz]

It's the most iconic, nondescript theme song. And kind of in my. That was my first realization back when I would pretty much any Saturday, that the Roots aren't touring and they're taping. I'm in the audience watching. And that to me is one of the most humorous things ever. Like, wow. Like, you know it. You know it when you hear it. You know that's snl. But no one can. It's a feeling. It's. It's almost like it's the last theme that offers a feeling but not any evidence of it. I don't know, it's like trying to put water in your pocket or something like that. Like it's abundant, but it's not. It's whatever you want it to be.

[Imani Perry]

Having gone through 50 years of musical guests, what's one of the performances that had a big impact on you when you were a kid and had to be in bed at 8:30, but you managed to watch Saturday Night Live?

[Evan Ross Katz]

I will say that, you know, the first five years was pretty much, you know, SNL. The role of SNL was. That was our YouTube, that was our viral video. For me, that was the one place where I could watch at the time, I think my all time favorite artist was Bill Withers. You know, there really just wasn't a show in which you can see actual musicians playing. I mean, you could watch American Bandstand or Soul Train where they might be lip syncing occasionally. On Soul Train they play live, but, you know, back then it was slim pickings either. Friday night you watched Midnight Special. Sometimes rock concert would come on like Sunday nights. But basically SNL was just. It was a rare moment in which you got to catch really cool bands. So even like Devo coming on, like I was 8 years old when they did a. The Jocko Homo song. Are we not Men we are Divo. And like me and my cousins, minds were blown, you know, so practically any group that came on in the first five to six years, I was an instant fan of.

[Imani Perry]

One of the things that you highlight in the SNL documentary is the role of SNL in the world of hip hop and tell the story of how Deborah Harry basically broke Hip hop on snl.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Okay, so Saturday Night Live is the first time that America and the world will get to see what hip hop culture is. The very first rap performance on TV is when Deborah Harry hosts the show in 1981 and brings on a Sugar Hill act called the Funky Four, plus one more. And she took a liking to this group, even though there were other popular groups at the time, like there was Grandmaster Flash and the Furious 5 and the sugar Hill Gangster, both were like platinum hits and really music and culture changing songs at the time. But she took a liking to this group because it was similar to Blondie, a band that had a woman in the lead of it. And so she took a liking to them. And for me, that's such an SNL move where those first 10 years, they weren't about, well, who's the most popular person to bring ratings in. It was always like the cool factor. Like, okay, okay, who's the most popular person now? Who's the person under that person that we could give a boost to? And that's like a prime example of how cool, how SNL always had their finger in the pulse of, you know, who's next. And you know, as a result, come 20 years later, a lot of those first time acts, you know, your early hip hop groups, like, you know, them getting Run DMC before Run DMC was Run dmc, or them getting Prince before Prince was Prince or the Talking Heads or Diva, whoever, like a lot of those risks that they took in the first 10 to 15 years, those guys will wind up being like the household names and the fiber of the mainstream once SNL becomes the mainstream instead of the underground. But yeah, with Deborah Harry using her power to bring attention to a culture that no one knew about, like, that is a prime moment of the SNL effect and how it builds American entertainment culture.

[Imani Perry]

Some of my favorite parts of the movie are the stories about things that have gone wrong, followed by clips of showing what went wrong and how it really shocked everybody behind the scenes. And one of those stories is Elvis Costello. So, you know, he does one song during dress rehearsal that I guess he and Lorne Michaels had agreed on, right? And then he stops it after a few bars. Let's hear what happens.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Here's Elvis Costello in the dress rehearsal. We did a song that was on my first album, but I thought it sounded a little too slow. It was a medium tempo song and I didn't think it was exciting enough. And I realized this show is live, we can do anything we want. Calling Mr. O. R. I.P. and I'm sorry, ladies and gentlemen, there's.

[David Biancooli]

No reason to do this song here.

[Imani Perry]

When he stopped, the hubub in the studio was like, oh, my God.

[Terry Gross]

Oh, my God, what's going to happen?

[Evan Ross Katz]

You can Hear it. Radio. Radio 1, 2. With the Elvis thing, I was sitting with Dan Aykroyd on Home Base. You're just watching him. I go, oh, I think we're being hijacked. How I Shooting in the shining the light not dialed songs bring the tears to my eyes. All of this stuff, it builds up in legend in the retelling. But I didn't come out there to give a political lecture. You know? Know, I came out to kind of shake it up. As we finished the song, the initial reaction in the moment was, I think we better get out of here. Somewhere in it, somebody said in anger, you'll never work on American television again. But the idea I was banned from television is nonsense.

[Imani Perry]

That's such a great story. I love it. And I think he made a good choice. I love both songs, but I do think he made the right choice.

[Evan Ross Katz]

He made the absolute right choice. And, you know, that's the thing about SNL is there's a risk factor involved. And usually it starts with no. Like, Eddie Murphy talks about, I did not want to do Hot Tub with James Brown. Justin Timberlake goes on and on about trying to convince Beyonce to do the Single lady sketch. Like, everything starts at no. And it's like, wow, you almost talked yourself out of history. And I'm trying to get people in the mind state that oftentimes we get in our own heads about why something won't work. And sometimes you just gotta take a risk. And you never know. This might be part of the American fiber, the history of it, but also, I know people have so many questions about what happens on a live show if something goes wrong. Like, for me, one of my favorite clips is the Ashlee Simpson moment, where you hear the directors freaking out because they don't know what to do. Should I go to a commercial? What do I do?

[Imani Perry]

Just describe what happened.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Well, you know, Ashlee Simpson had a sore throat and was a little iffy about her singing, so she opted to lip sync instead. And her drummer, who's controlling all the music, accidentally plays the wrong song for the second song.

[Imani Perry]

He, in fact, plays the song that we already heard as the first song.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Right, exactly.

[Imani Perry]

Everyone in the audience knows this is wrong, and there's no way of covering that up.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Well, yeah, I mean, they could have just patiently just stopped the song and started all over again as if nothing happened. But um, you know, she infamously does a weird dance and runs off stage, kind of humiliated. And they go to a commercial. It just so happens that Oz Rodriguez, my co director of this documentary, said that, you know, they, they also have the audio recording of the production room. Like what was happening at the time. And for me, it was so hilarious to hear the, the producers and the directors inside of the control room. It sounds to me it sounds like a bunch of teenagers that stole their parents car in San Francisco. And then the car is like the brakes just give out in a San Francisco hill going down 100 miles per hour. Like, what do we do? Oh no. Oh no. You know, so I love showing like not how the sausage is made, but you know, you get to see what's under the trunk. And that to me is the most fascinating part of snl, like how it's able to happen every week without fail.

[Imani Perry]

Let's hear some of what happened behind the scenes.

[David Biancooli]

Uh oh, on a Monday.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Spy rock, rock song, wrong song.

[David Biancooli]

They should play it.

[Evan Ross Katz]

And it was just like, you know those old movies of two locomotives hitting each other full bore.

[David Biancooli]

What are we doing?

[Evan Ross Katz]

I don't know.

[Terry Gross]

She should sing.

[Evan Ross Katz]

People were running in and out of the studio and it just seemed like the show came to a screeching halt.

[Imani Perry]

And the rumors were after that. I think there were two rumors after that if I remember correctly. One was that, oh, she really can't sing. So not because of a sore throat, but because she's not capable of singing live and therefore they had to have her lip sync. And the other rumor was, oh, there's probably lots of acts that are really lip syncing.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Well, you know, the thing is, you know, we went through this like 10 years before with Milli Vanilli. You know, the kind of. This is what I call, this is what I call the post thriller effect of 1982, where suddenly your music video became the most important way to sell the song. And you know, it came to the point where if you're in concert, fans expect whatever you did on your video, you would have to surpass it. And you know, because Michael Jackson's introducing this whole idea of like, not only do you have to sing the song, but you have to sell the song, dance the song, act the song. For most people it's hard to. It's hard enough just to sing it, but also to sing and perform or dance or whatever you have to do. Since the 80s, there have been options on how to sell the song without you giving up your voice or whatever. And so, I mean, kind of the lip singing aspect has been a thing since the early 80s, but for me as a musician, that's just a fact of life. But for a lot of people, there's a smoke and mirror aspect to it. And I guess with that Ashlee Simpson performance, most of America found out that half their favorites kind of do that. Like, it's just the standard, really. I don't want to pop any more balloons than I have to, but it's just, again, like, from the artists that I talk to, it's like they might get in their heads that, you know, if I move too much and I'm out of breath, then I won't be able to hit the notes like I normally do. And, you know, I think people, again, the Thriller effect is. It must be perfect. And I'm kind of from the school of warts and all. Like, I love seeing the warts. I love seeing the pimples, the mistakes. Like, to me, that's the human touch. And I think people need to trust that more. You know, things don't have to be. Instagram filter perfect 24 7.

[Imani Perry]

So I assume that what they're lip syncing to is a live performance. That's not the record.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Um, there's some people. You know what, there's a few artists that are smart enough that will maybe do eight specific takes of a particular performance so that you're under the impression that they are, you know, what's up, Detroit?

[David Biancooli]

How y'all doing?

[Evan Ross Katz]

You know, like, they'll go that far. Like, I know artists that will do like 10 or 20 versions of a song to sort of customize or not get caught out there. But I think just in the name of presenting a perfect package, that's what people go through.

[Imani Perry]

You're talking about in concert right now, right?

[Evan Ross Katz]

Yeah, in concert or most, you know, I'm on television. I'll say that 90% of. You know, it's very rare for a person to just go 100% live. Like, I'll say that on the Tonight Show, 85 to 90% of what you see is a perfected delivery. Like, in their minds, it's like, I must sell this song to sell my album. And so they don't want to leave risk or to chance any, you know, any flub that would make you say, nope, that note was flat. So I'm not supporting that group. So, yeah, that's kind of where we are now in entertainment.

[Imani Perry]

Well, you solve one mystery for me, which is how do singers manage to sing when they're doing this elaborate workout with their choreography, when you're going to be out of breath.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Exactly. So pretty much it's just part of the chorus. Like it's, it's always been that way. But when I go to snl, yeah, I'm entertained by what I see. But I'm not sitting in the audience just to watch Saturday Night Live. Like for me, the best part of the show is what happens in the commercials, like watching the teamster guys and the crew guys at furious pace in two minutes build an entire set while the artists are quick changing in the back and, well, they make it in 2 minutes flat. To me, that's the best part of the show, watching the choreography of a well oiled machine.

[Imani Perry]

Amir, it's been so great to talk with you. Thank you for being such a regular guest on our show. It's really, it's a joy.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Thank you.

[Tonya Moseley]

Amir Questlove Thompson's new film, Ladies and Gentlemen, 50 Years of SNL Music is part of SNL's 50th anniversary celebration. It's streaming on Peacock. He spoke with Terry Gross. Coming up, Harvard Professor Imani Perry talks about her latest book, Black and How a Color Tells the Story of My People. I'm Tanya Moseley and this is FRESH AIR weekend.

[Terry Gross]

This message comes from Grainger. As a maintenance specialist for a historic high rise, you know that vintage charm historically needs constant attention, which is why when it's time to upgrade turn of the century mechanicals, they turn to Grainger. With easy access to a million plus products and the scale to deliver when and where you need them, the right tools and supplies are never far away. So you can keep that vintage building running like new. Call click granger.com or just stop by Granger for the ones who get it done. This message comes from Warby Parker. If you wear glasses, you know how hard it is to find the perfect pair. But step into a Warby Parker store and you'll see it doesn't have to be. Find a Warby Parker store near [e-mail] retail. This message comes from Bombas. Socks, underwear and T shirts are the top three requested clothing items by people experiencing homelessness. Bombas makes all three and donates one item for every item purchased. Go to bombus.com NPR and use code NPR for 20% off.

[Tonya Moseley]

You know, sometimes there are ideas that make you reconsider the way you look at the world around you. My guest today, scholar Imani Perry does that with her new book Black and How A Color tells the story of my people. Perry weaves the gravitational pull of blue in black life, both literally and metaphorically, in sound and in color, from the creation of dyed indigo cloths in West Africa that were traded for human life in the 16th century to the American art form of blues music and sartorial choices. Coretta Scott King wore blue on her wedding day. Fannie Lou Hamer wore a blue dress to testify before Congress. These examples could be seen as mere coincidences, but in this book, Perry weaves a compelling argument for why they are not. Imani Perry is the Henry A. Morse Jr. And Elizabeth W. Morse professor of Studies of Women, Gender and Sexuality and of African and African American Studies at Harvard University. She's also the author of several books and has published numerous articles on law, cultural studies, and African American studies, including Looking for Lorraine, which is a biography of the playwright Lorraine Hansberry, and Breathe A Letter to My Sons. Imani Perry, welcome back to fresh air and thank you so much for this fascinating book.

[David Biancooli]

Oh, thank you for having me.

[Tonya Moseley]

Can I have you read a passage, page 21, last paragraph.

[David Biancooli]

The truth is this black as such began ennobly through conquering eyes. Writing that makes me wince because I hold my black tightly, proudly. Even honesty requires a great deal of discomfort. But here's the truth. We didn't start out black, nor did we choose it first. Black was a hard earned love. But through it all, the blue blues, the certainty of the brilliant sky, deep water and melancholy have never left us. I can attest you might be thinking by now that this blue thing I'm talking about is mere device, a literary trick to move through historic events. And if blue weren't a conjure color, that might have been true. But for real, the blue in black is nothing less than truth before trope. Everybody loves blue. It is human as can be. But everybody doesn't love black. Many have hated it, and that is inhumane. If you don't already, I will make you love it with my blues song.

[Tonya Moseley]

Thank you so much for that, Imani. I also want to say that this book is. I know you don't think of yourself as a poet, but it's very lyrical. It's really poetry.

[David Biancooli]

Thank you.

[Tonya Moseley]

How did meditating on the color blue help you come to a deeper understanding about the use of the word black to articulate what we are?

[David Biancooli]

So, I mean, I have a sort of roundabout answer to that question. It's a beautiful question and it may have more than anything to do with the blues. So it's the genre of music that is sort of the foundation of African American music, certainly, and the foundation of American music generally. And it is, as I say, sort of a sound of the world's favorite color. Meaning that it captures both the joy and the melancholy, you know, having the blues when you have the blues. Rather, playing the blues can act as a means of kind of curing the blues. You know, it has this movement through the spectrum of emotions, this deeply human sensibility to it. And so there was something about the universality of the color blue and the power of the sound of the blues. The way the sound of my people coming out of the Deep south, coming out of a history of enslavement, coming out of having this identity cast upon them and making something beautiful, creating beauty at the very site of wound. There was something about the way in which those two senses of blue coincided so profoundly that actually, for me, became a pathway to thinking about blackness and in some ways, the absolute tragedy of the failure to recognize its beauty. And so, you know, the book is a journey through that. A journey through both the anguish. But of course. Which you have to acknowledge, but of course, this remarkable beauty that actually has a resonance with everything, even when they deny it. So, you know, that. I guess that's the simplest way I can think about saying how. Yeah. How that connection emerged for me.

[Tonya Moseley]

I want to talk a little bit about music. It's kind of the easiest way to get even deeper into this book and this thought. You know, I think the term blue note is so embedded in our understanding as something that relates to jazz music. If you're not a musician, maybe you just. But not really. At least, I didn't know what it meant really, until I was reading your book, and I understood it to mean the in between.

[David Biancooli]

Yeah.

[Tonya Moseley]

I was just really curious how this definition of the in between also allows you to deepen your understanding of how black people's creation of the art form of jazz itself came to be.

[David Biancooli]

It's the in between. It's the slurred note is that which isn't recognized on the Western scale. And, of course, it is recognized. You know, increasingly, musicians have been talking about a blues scale. And there are other scales in which what we refer to as blue notes in this context are understood just as notes. And that's actually just a wonderful example, because the blue note, or the addition of the blue note to the sound of American music transforms it much in the way that there's something indispensable about the presence of black people in the United States in what it becomes. And at the same time, it is its own thing. And also it has connections to these other genres of music. And it's a beautiful example for me of actually the combination of African Americans being American, becoming a people in the context the United States and also having these connections that are like arteries to the rest of the black world. And so, you know, there are references in the book to Haitian history and Brazilian history and history of the Congo and all of these very deep connections that are present. And so the blue note really is like that. And it is something that you are attuned to, you can hear. It operates intuitively, I think, for listeners of American music. And in some ways that is the whole globe. Because American music has journeyed everywhere. Right. Even if you don't have its formal definition or even if you can't describe it. And there's something to that as well in this story. There is a presence and a power that isn't necessarily fully articulated that comes through this particular history. So, you know, the music really does. It's not even just. It's not just metaphorical. It functions as a kind of representation or an example of the fact of being black, and particularly being black American.

[Tonya Moseley]

I want to play an early reference that you write about. It's Louis Armstrong's 1951 recording of what Did I Do to be so black and blue? Let's listen to a little.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Cold empty.

[Tonya Moseley]

Bed.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Springs on his lips Feel like old men wished I was dead what did I do the beast soul black and blue Even the mouse ran from my house they laugh at you and scorn you too what did I do to be so blind it blue I white inside but that don't help my case Cause I can hide this what is in my face for spa does but this va does my silly ass how would it end?

[Tonya Moseley]

That was Louis Armstrong's 1951. What did I do to be so black and blue? It was really fun to go down memory lane and listen to these old pieces. I'll say. But what did you learn about how Armstrong really turned this song, which was several decades old by the time he sang it, into really a direct commentary for the time.

[David Biancooli]

Yeah. So the original version of the song actually took place in a black musical and it was sung by a dark skinned black woman who was actually talking about colorism in the black community and the kind of preference for lighter skinned women. And the transition is. Is. It's beautiful. But what Armstrong does is it's this example of the sort of multi layered references that exist in both black and blues. So There's. And it's a song that bridges blues and jazz as well. So it has this blues phrasing and sensibility, but then with the horns and the scatting, you hear the kind of growing complexity of jazz. And we have black and blue in the sense of being bruised, and you have blues in the sense of melancholy, and of course, the general sense of sort of the blues that exist along with blackness. And in Armstrong's personal life, you have this struggle around being a person who is actually sent into the world as an advocate of the United States in the context of the burgeoning Cold War and as a kind of figure that is supposed to be an example of the glory of the United States. And yet, as was often the case, and we saw this in the context of World War I and World War II, even as black people served the nation valiantly, they were subject to deep inequality at home. And so the song actually is able to encapsulate all of those dimensions with these rather simple sentences, lyrics that are not directly about all of that, but absolutely are about all of that. So you get the sense of innuendo, of multi layered discourses. It's just so elegant and beautiful and profound.

[Tonya Moseley]

You also reference Nina Simone. You talk about her first album, which was in 1957. There is this song called Little Girl Blue. I also want to play that. Let's hear a little bit.

[Evan Ross Katz]

There.

[David Biancooli]

And count your fingers.

[Amir Questlove Thompson]

What can you do?

[Evan Ross Katz]

Oh, girl, you through?

[Amir Questlove Thompson]

Sit there.

[Evan Ross Katz]

Count your little fingers Unhappy little girl Blue Sit there.

[Tonya Moseley]

That was Nina Simone singing Little Girl Blue. And Imani, as you write about, there was just a lot going on with this album. There's a lot of delays with the recording label. It kind of set her on the path, really, her career path, decisions from that point on. What did you learn about Simone and the recording of this song that made you want to explore it for the book?

[David Biancooli]

I'll just say, you know, I grew up on Nina Simone. My mother loved Nina Simone. And so I been listening to her literally for my entire 52 years of life. And, you know, we talk a great deal in some ways about the late Nina Simone in the world of sort of popular culture. Nina Simone as a woman who was both a musical genius and also a person who put politics in their music, and also a person who struggled with her mental and emotional health efforts after so many tragedies. And so I wanted to look at the beginning. I wanted to attend to early Nina Simone, a person who had already experienced extraordinary disappointment. She was a trained classical pianist. She'd been denied admission to the Curtis Institute. She was certain that that denial was because of her race. And so she became this musician who was blending torch songs, show tunes, jazz as a performer, and then elements of the classical music. But she also was really struggling with emotionally with the desire to have been a classical musician and the ways in which she was excluded from that. And so there's something about in thinking and talking about this first album, I wanted to gesture to the complex emotions associated with her putting this work together and also its incredible beauty. It's yet again one of these sites where you see, you know, the process of creating beauty at the sight of wound. It happens over and over and over again in black culture and life. And I was able to do it through the story of a really cherished musician for me personally. But I think the world I'd like.

[Tonya Moseley]

To end our conversation on a passage of your book that I feel is so rooted in the present moment. It's page 228, the last paragraph. It starts with an admission, an admission.

[David Biancooli]

I am very much an American, and that is an uneasy title for me. I have a culture and an identity tied to this land. I am, without apology, who and what I am. The unease is about the relationship between my citizenship and the rest of the world. My blackness is a conduit, but my Americanness is so often a betrayal of that connection with others. I know the classic response is coming from some people want to come here from all over the world. The American dream is universal. I think that dream is of a castle of security that exists inside the palace gates. I come from inside the territory, but outside the gates. So I know better. But I have one take. There are many others. We are no monolith. This is my blues.

[Tonya Moseley]

Imani Perry, as always, thank you so much for this thought provoking conversation.

[David Biancooli]

Thank you.

[Tonya Moseley]

Imani Perry's new book is Black and How a Color Tells the Story of My People. FRESH AIR WEEKEND is produced by Teresa Madden. FRESH air's executive producer is Danny Miller. Sam Brigger is our managing producer. Our technical director and engineer is Audrey Bentham. A special thank you to Jose Yanes and Connor Anderson from WDE for additional engineering help with Terry Gross. I'm Tanya Moseley.

[Terry Gross]

This message comes from Warby Parker. What makes a great pair of glasses at Warby Parker? It's all the invisible extras without the extra cost, like free adjustments for life. Find your [e-mail] or visit one of their hundreds of stores around the country. This message comes from Bombas Their socks are super plush, designed to support your arches and support people in need. One purchase equals one donated to those experiencing homelessness. Go to bombus.com NPR and use code NPR for 20% off your first order. This message comes from Mint Mobile. Mint Mobile took what's wrong with wireless and made it right. They offer premium wireless plans for less and all plans include high speed data, unlimited talk and text, and nationwide coverage. See for [e-mail] Switch.