Detailed Summary of "Battle of Winchelsea with Dan Jones" Episode of Gone Medieval

Podcast Information:

• Title: Gone Medieval
• Host/Author: History Hit
• Episode: Battle of Winchelsea with Dan Jones
• Release Date: August 1, 2025

Introduction

In this engaging episode of Gone Medieval, hosts Matt Lewis and Dr. Eleanor Jaenega delve into the intricacies of medieval naval warfare with special guest Dan Jones, the acclaimed author of the historical fiction trilogy centered around the Hundred Years War. The episode focuses on the Battle of Winchelsea in 1350, a pivotal yet often overlooked naval confrontation between English and Castilian forces.

Overview of Dan Jones' Trilogy and "Lionhearts"

Dan Jones provides an insightful overview of his trilogy, culminating in "Lionhearts", the third installment that explores a critical moment in the Hundred Years War.

• "Essex Dogs" covers the Battle of Crécy (1346).
• "Wolves of Winter" chronicles the Siege of Calais (1346-1347).
• "Lionhearts" picks up in 1348, aboard a fleet approaching Bordeaux amidst the looming threat of the Black Death.

Dan Jones explains how "Lionhearts" intertwines the turmoil of war with the devastating impact of the plague, offering a nuanced portrayal of the era.

Dan Jones [02:35]: "It's part of a 10-year project. It's been incredibly good fun... seeing these campaigns and battles from the eyes of ordinary people."

The Black Death's Influence on the Narrative

The conversation shifts to the Black Death and its significant role in shaping the events of "Lionhearts". Dan discusses the challenges and opportunities of integrating such a catastrophic event into his narrative.

• Impact on Alliances: The plague disrupts Edward III's plans to forge an alliance with Castile through the marriage of Princess Joan, leading to Castilian support for the French.
• Character Development: Characters like Love Day face profound personal and societal upheavals, adding depth to their portrayals.

Dan Jones [04:20]: "The Black Death as a spanner in the works is going to win the prize for 2025's understatement of the year."

Dan emphasizes the importance of portraying varied human responses to the plague, reflecting both denial and acceptance, thereby enriching the story's emotional landscape.

Setting the Stage for the Battle of Winchelsea

Dan elaborates on the geopolitical tensions leading up to the Battle of Winchelsea. With the failed Anglo-Castilian alliance, Castilian fleets begin aggressively targeting English ports, threatening commerce and security.

• Castilian Naval Dominance: Castilian ships, larger and better-armed, pose a significant threat to English maritime operations.
• English Naval Limitations: Unlike later centuries, England's navy in the mid-14th century relies on merchant ships pressed into service, lacking the sophistication and size of Castilian vessels.

Dan Jones [28:24]: "The Castilian ships... towered over our ships like castles over cottages."

The Battle of Winchelsea: Events and Tactics

The heart of the episode centers on the dramatic portrayal of the battle itself, as depicted in "Lionhearts".

• Edward III’s Strategy: Faced with superior enemy ships, Edward III devises a bold plan to directly engage the Castilians, despite the English fleet's disadvantages.
• Drunken Revelry: A moment of levity occurs when Edward III and his men, indulging in revelry, disguise their tensions, leading to a spontaneous and risky naval assault.
• Climactic Combat: The ensuing battle is fierce and bloody, with longbowmen playing a crucial role in turning the tide in favor of the English despite heavy losses on both sides.

Dan Jones [35:14]: "It's much more like a land battle."

The battle, also known as the Battle of the Spanish in the Sea, underscores the brutality and chaos of medieval naval warfare, blending historical accuracy with fictional dramatization.

Historical Sources and Fictional Liberties

Dan discusses the challenges of balancing historical accuracy with creative storytelling, especially given the limited detailed sources on the Battle of Winchelsea compared to other battles like Crécy.

• Chronicle Accounts: Primary sources from chroniclers like Jean Froissart provide vivid descriptions but lack comprehensive detail.
• Creative Freedom: The scarcity of detailed records allows Dan to infuse the narrative with imaginative elements, enhancing character arcs and battle sequences.

Dan Jones [23:05]: "Writing fiction, everything's flipped on its head. The big story is all background; the little story is what matters to the characters."

Legacy of the Battle of Winchelsea

While the Battle of Winchelsea may not be as famous as other conflicts in the Hundred Years War, Dan highlights its significance in the broader scope of English naval history and Edward III's military reputation.

• Strategic Importance: The battle reinforces Edward III's dominance both on land and sea during a critical phase of the war.
• Naval Development: It marks a stepping stone in the evolution of English naval power, laying groundwork for future maritime endeavors.

Dan Jones [42:31]: "It's a landmark along the way... but with writing fiction, that doesn't really matter."

Despite its limited immediate impact, the battle contributes to the sustained nature of the Hundred Years War and the enduring legacy of English military prowess.

Future Projects and Conclusion

Concluding the episode, Dan shares insights into his forthcoming non-fiction work, "The Castle," which explores the evolution and mythology of castles from the Bronze Age to the modern era. This project reflects his ongoing passion for medieval history and its broader cultural implications.

Dan Jones [46:27]: "I'm writing a non-fiction book about castles... going to see them."

Matt and Eleanor thank Dan for his contributions and encourage listeners to explore his trilogy, especially "Lionhearts," to experience the gripping tales of the Essex Dogs amidst historical upheavals.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Dan Jones [04:29]: "The Black Death presents certain opportunities... to have some fun."
• Dan Jones [28:24]: "The Castilian ships... towered over our ships like castles over cottages."
• Dan Jones [35:14]: "It's much more like a land battle."
• Dan Jones [42:31]: "It's a landmark along the way... but with writing fiction, that doesn't really matter."

Final Thoughts

This episode of Gone Medieval offers a compelling blend of historical analysis and engaging storytelling, providing listeners with a deeper understanding of medieval naval warfare and its portrayal in historical fiction. Dan Jones' expertise and imaginative narrative bring the Battle of Winchelsea to life, highlighting both its historical context and its significance within his literary work.

For more episodes and historical explorations, subscribe to Gone Medieval on Spotify or your preferred podcast platform. Dive deeper into the Middle Ages with History Hit’s extensive library of award-winning podcasts and original documentaries.