Gone Medieval: King John – Worst Medieval Monarch?

Episode Title: King John: Worst Medieval Monarch?
Release Date: January 10, 2025
Host: Matt Lewis
Guests: Dr. Eleanor Jaenega

Introduction to King John

In this episode of Gone Medieval, host Matt Lewis delves into the controversial reign of King John of England, exploring whether he truly deserves the title of the "Worst Medieval Monarch." Joined by Dr. Eleanor Jaenega, the discussion unpacks John's reputation, his early promise, subsequent failures, and the lasting impact of his rule on English history.

Background and Early Life

Matt Lewis opens the conversation by providing essential background on King John. Dr. Eleanor Jaenega explains:

"John is the youngest son of King Henry II, famous for the murder of Beckett, and his highly intelligent wife, Eleanor of Aquitaine. He was often called John Lackland because his father provided him only the lordship of Ireland, a position he despised."
[03:28]

John grew up overshadowed by his elder brothers, Richard the Lionheart and Henry the Young King, eventually rebelling against both his father and brother alike. This pattern of rebellion laid the groundwork for his later reputation.

John’s Early Reign: A Promising Start

Initially, John's reign showed signs of promise. Dr. Jaenega highlights:

"The chronicler Ralph of Coggeshall writes about 1201-1202 with full praise of John, particularly for the peace with France through the Treaty of Le Goulet. This peace alleviated the financial strain caused by Richard’s costly wars."
[13:39]

Additionally, John's reconciliation with the Cistercian order earned him commendation:

"Coggeshall describes John as a king whose 'shoulder is touched by the hand of God,' reflecting his genuine efforts to mend relations with the Church."
[16:30]

These early years painted a picture of a capable and conciliatory monarch, suggesting a positive trajectory for his reign.

The Downfall: Rebellion and Loss of Normandy

However, John’s reign quickly deteriorated due to significant failures and personal flaws. A pivotal moment was his capture and subsequent murder of Arthur of Brittany:

"John managed to capture Arthur at Mirabeau, and most contemporaries believed John had murdered him in a drunken rage, an act considered outside the chivalric norms of the age."
[17:10]

This event, coupled with the loss of Normandy to Philip Augustus in 1204, marked a turning point:

"Philip Augustus took Gisors by treachery, undermining John's ability to defend Normandy. This loss was a humiliating blow and a critical failure in John's military leadership."
[06:55]

The combined effect of these actions severely damaged John's reputation and power base.

Conflict with the Church and the Road to Magna Carta

John’s tumultuous relationship with the Church further exacerbated his standing. The appointment of Stephen Langton as Archbishop of Canterbury without John's consent led to significant conflict:

"John responded by placing England under an interdict and ultimately facing excommunication, demonstrating his unwillingness to compromise with ecclesiastical authority."
[24:09]

This ecclesiastical rift set the stage for the baronial rebellion and the eventual signing of Magna Carta.

Magna Carta: Concessions and Consequences

Faced with widespread rebellion and external threats, John was compelled to agree to Magna Carta in 1215. Dr. Jaenega explains:

"John signed Magna Carta from a position of strategic concession, hoping the rebel barons would not enforce its terms. He cleverly omitted the names of the 25 security barons, rendering the enforcement clause ineffective initially."
[38:13]

Despite John's intentions, the barons enforced the charter rigorously, leading to further conflict and undermining John's authority.

Foreign Policy and the Battle of Bouvines

John’s efforts to reclaim lost territories culminated in the disastrous Battle of Bouvines in 1214:

"John orchestrated a massive invasion with a formidable alliance and substantial financial resources. However, the campaign ended in a decisive defeat, highlighting his strategic miscalculations and further weakening his position."
[28:06]

This defeat not only solidified Philip Augustus's dominance but also intensified domestic unrest, setting the stage for John's declining rule.

Underlying Factors: Angevin Governance and Personal Flaws

The episode emphasizes that John’s failures cannot be solely attributed to his personal shortcomings. Dr. Jaenega discusses:

"By 1199, resentment towards the Angevins' financial exactions was already brewing in England. Under John, these grievances intensified, tripling revenue demands and fostering widespread dissent."
[31:02]

John's unpredictable and often cruel behavior further alienated nobles and the Church, making rebellion more likely.

John’s Death and Its Aftermath

King John’s death in 1216, following a reign marked by loss and conflict, had significant immediate impacts:

"His death preserved the dynasty, allowing his nine-year-old son, Henry III, to ascend the throne. This transition led to the continued enforcement and adaptation of Magna Carta, shaping English governance for generations."
[42:42]

John's demise removed a volatile figure, but his legacy lived on through the enduring principles established by Magna Carta.

Conclusion: A Complex Legacy

Matt Lewis wraps up the episode by reflecting on John's multifaceted legacy:

"John was a highly intelligent and strategic ruler who made both commendable and catastrophic decisions. His ability to negotiate and build alliances contrasted sharply with his unpredictable and brutal tactics, leaving historians to debate his true place in history."
[46:50]

Dr. Jaenega concurs, noting:

"John’s reign was a blend of effective policies and personal failings. While he demonstrated significant political acumen, his cruelty and unreliability ultimately overshadowed his accomplishments, justifying his reputation as one of medieval England’s most infamous monarchs."
[47:21]

Notable Quotes:

• "John might well have thought that I'm merely doing what my elder brothers have done. Why should I attain this reputation for treachery?"
  – Dr. Eleanor Jaenega [04:29]

• "John behaves completely correctly in those circumstances... he's going to be one of those kings going up happily being received by angels into heaven."
  – Dr. Eleanor Jaenega [16:39]

• "John Gillingham famously said on one occasion that John is a shit. And that's certainly how he was regarded by a lot of the great nobles."
  – Dr. Eleanor Jaenega [35:47]

Final Thoughts

King John's reign exemplifies the complexities of medieval monarchy, where personal traits and political decisions intertwine to shape historical legacies. This episode of Gone Medieval offers a nuanced examination of John’s rule, challenging listeners to reconsider preconceived notions about one of England’s most notorious kings.

Subscribe: To delve deeper into the Middle Ages, subscribe to Gone Medieval on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Visit History Hit for ad-free episodes and exclusive content.