Loading summary
Transcript133 lines
- [00:01]
Matt Lewis
Hello, I'm Matt Lewis.
- [00:03]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
And I'm Dr. Eleanor Jaenega and we're.
- [00:05]
Matt Lewis
Just popping up here to tell you some insider info.
- [00:08]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
If you would like to listen to Gone Medieval ad free and get early access and bonus episodes, sign up to History Hit with the History Hit subscription.
- [00:16]
Matt Lewis
You can also watch hundreds of hours.
- [00:19]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Of original documentaries such as my new series on everyone's favorite conquerors, the Normans.
- [00:25]
Matt Lewis
Or my recent exploration of the castles that made Britain.
- [00:29]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
There's a new release to enjoy every week.
- [00:32]
Matt Lewis
Sign up now by visiting historyhit.com subscribe or find the link in the show notes for this episode.
- [00:50]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Strap in. You're in the race with F1TV Premium. See what the race director sees with custom multiview. Watch every jog jaw dropping moment in Live 4K UHD across up to 6 screens. Uninterrupted experience. Ultimate live immersion with F1TV Premium available on selected devices. Did you know 1 in 2 women wear the wrong foundation. Matching foundation is hard, but il maquillage makes it easy. Take the Power Match quiz to find a perfect match in seconds customized to your unique skin tone, undertone and coverage needs. Weight with 600,000 5 star reviews woke up like this is our best selling foundation for a reason. Available in 50 shades of weightless Natural coverage and with Try before youe Buy, you can try your full size at home for 14 days. Just pay shipping. Take the quiz@ilmaquillage.com Quiz that's I L M A K I A G E.com Quiz I know I'm not alone when I say adulting can be overwhelming. And what we all could use is a drink. That's where Apple and Eve Juice comes in. As the rulers of the juice box, the They've been making juice joyful for 50 years with refreshing juice blends bursting with bold flavor. One sip sends you right back to childhood. So when the grind dulls your shine, remember to kid yourself. Apple and Eve has delicious juices for at home and on the Go shop today. Hello, I'm Dr. Eleanor Jennica and welcome to Gone Medieval From History Hit, the podcast that delves into the greatest millennium in human history. We uncover the greatest mysteries, the gobsmacking details, and the latest groundbreaking research. From the Vikings to the Normans, from Kings to Popes to the Crusades, we delve into the rebellions, plots and murders that tell us who we really were and how we got here. This month on Gone Medieval, we're delving into the medieval equivalent of Family Feud, but directed by Quentin Tarantino, not least because the Royal Shakespeare Company are staging a brand new production of Christopher Marlowe's violent yet tender play, Edward II. In the last episode, we heard how Edward II's rule and his deposition represented a moment of crisis in England that would rip up the being King of England rule book. Edward's reign was defined by his controversial relationships, first with Piers Gaveston and later Hugh Despenser. Today we turn our attention to Edward II's Queen Isabella. Now, she had to put up with a lot from her husband, but she was no walkover. Oh, no. England in 1327 is a realm holding its breath. The she wolf of France, that is what you will call her. Queen Isabella is born of an illustrious lineage. Her forefathers are the kings of France and now is her brother. The Queen has been a steady supporter of her husband. What she has turned a blind eye to is between her and her confessor. But now he seems to have gone too far even for her. She sits in France with their son and sets out her demands for their return. Can a king decide between losing his queen and losing face? He can only keep one at most. Isabella has been at Edward's side since the year after he became king. He has lavished gifts on her, then taken them away. He has carried her from a fire, consuming their tent, so concerned for her that he emerged naked with her in his arms. And he has pushed her away so many times, each time harder and further to make space for his fawning favorites. Good queens are the merciful balance to the wrath and vengeance of their husband. How has Isabella become as much rage and force as any king? How have the calm waters of their marriage become poisoned and bubbling as they boil? In France, the Queen is joined by a rebel. Roger Mortimer shares her hatred of Despenser. Some say he shares her bed too. Others say they will come with an army. Many claim both are true. Mortimer's plan seems clear.
- [05:52]
Matt Lewis
Fair Isobel, now have we our desire. The proud corruptors of the light brained king have done their homage to the lofty gallows and he himself lies in captivity. In any case, take heed of childish fear, for now we hold an old wolf by the ears, that if he slip, will seize upon us both. Think therefore, madam, that imports as much to erect your son with all the speed we may, and that I be protector over him for our behalf will.
- [06:24]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Bear the greatest sway when as a king's name shall be under it. In all corners of England, people talk in hushed tones of what might happen next. Joining me to discuss one of my favorite medieval Queens is historian Catherine Warner, author of Isabella of the Rebel Queen Catherine. Welcome to Gone Medieval.
- [06:50]
Matt Lewis
Hi, Milena. Thanks so much for inviting me. So happy to be here.
- [06:53]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
I am so glad to have you here because I'm going to have you gossip about two of my favorite people, some of the best to ever do it. Who are Queen Isabella and Roger Mortimer, which is. It's one of the biggest and sexiest topics there is, I think. Really?
- [07:13]
Matt Lewis
Well, it's just. I mean, to me, like, the story has always been just so endlessly fascinating, I think, like, you know, the characters, the personalities involved, the whole drama, you know, the whole turbulence of this era. There's just so much going on, you know, so many fascinating things. It's just. Yeah, it's a wonderful period of history.
- [07:31]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Absolutely, absolutely. And I think that for me, Queen Isabella, I like to call her the she wolf. I know that that is supposed to. I know that's supposed to be derogatory, but I actually think it's brilliant. Right.
- [07:43]
Matt Lewis
She's.
- [07:43]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
She's one of these characters who is so interesting because she's a really complex woman. She's a really difficult woman, and she's a woman who just sort of does what she wants, which is almost unheard of in the medieval period.
- [07:59]
Matt Lewis
Yeah. So, of course, you know, Isabella is one of the most powerful women, I guess, of the English Middle Ages. And, you know, she was kind of. She was born to power recently, so she was the only surviving daughter of the king of France, Philip iv, who's often known to posterity as the Iron King. Isabella's mother was also a sovereign in her own right. She was the queen regnant of Navarre, which then was a small kingdom in the Pyrenees, mostly in Spain, but also partly in France. So Isabella was one of the most highly born queens of England that we've ever had in our history. The daughter of two sovereigns, she had three older brothers who all reigned in their turn as kings of France and Navarre. So she was born to power, she was born to influence. She had a very strong sense of her own royalty. I mean, in my opinion, an almost sacred sense of who she was, who she was born to be. And she was betrothed to the future Edward II of England when she was only about 3 years old. And so their betrothed was arranged at the end of the 1290s, basically, to end a war between England and France. You know, their fathers, Philip IV of France and Edward I of England, had been at war for a large part of the 1290s, and this being the Middle Ages, they were royal. Obviously, they had no real say in who they married. So they were basically, they were betrothed to end a war between two kingdoms. That's how it came about. So Isabella had known, basically since she was a toddler that it was her destiny to marry Edward II and to be the Queen of England and hopefully, and indeed, as it did turn, be the mother of the King of England after that. Yeah.
- [09:30]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
And she's really raised to do just that. Right. Not just be a queen. I mean, again, this is one of the most highly born queens there ever is. You know, France is massively powerful at the time, but she's really educated to be not just, you know, an ornament, but a ruler.
- [09:49]
Matt Lewis
Yes. Unfortunately, we don't know a great deal about Isabella's upbringing. Oh, before she married Edward when she was 12, I mean, hardly anything, in fact. So we just have to interpret her later behavior as you say, Elena, that she wasn't content just to be, you know, the ornament, you know, just the queen who was in the background, you know, raising the children, but, you know, not wielding any power. She wanted to wield as much influences as she possibly could. And she did do that. And I think, like, she. One key point is that Edward II actually did allow her to do that. So we tend to hear a lot about, like, you know, their marriage, you know, was awful and they disliked each other, but actually they got on and an awful lot better than I think most people assume, you know, for many years. I mean, it all went hideously wrong in the end. I mean, you know, let's not skate over that fact. But, you know, just because a relationship goes wrong doesn't mean that it had always been awful. Even though Isabella was only 12 years old when she first arrived in England in 1308, there's evidence that she was already wielding, like, a certain measure of influence over Edward. So we find, you know, records in the chancery rolls of, like, you know, Edward, say, let's say, pardoning a criminal or, you know, let's saying yes to a land deal of some description, you know, like, because Isabella had asked him to. So she was mediating with Edward, you know, right from the start of her life in England and her marriage to him. And then this happened, you know, like, with great regularity throughout the first, what, 14, 13, 14 years of their marriage. And then it all went wrong in the early 1320s. But, yes, we do see Isabella, you know, practicing her role as a mediator, you know, with her husband, which was, I kind of expected of a queen at the time. And she did it very well and obviously with a certain degree of pleasure. And then also because Edward II's reign was so turbulent and thanks to his own errors, he basically stumbled from one crisis to the next. Then we also see another aspect of Isabella's power and influence that she was mediating, negotiating between her husband and the barons, basically becoming a kind of peacemaker as well.
- [11:45]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Yeah. And this is the sort of thing that we expect from a queen. Right. Part of your role, one way or another, is this very specific mediation. You're the one who steps in when your husband's gone too far, you know, or when there is a situation where the king needs to climb back from a mistake that he's made. But this is very crucial. He cannot admit he's wrong. Right. Well, then you're the queen. Then it's your job to go in and beg humbly for the right thing to be done. And then the king can say, oh, yes, darling, for you, I would do such a thing.
- [12:20]
Matt Lewis
Right, yes. And we see that as well, you know, with Isabella's daughter in law, Queen Philippa, who kind of persuaded Edward III publicly, you know, to save someone's lives on one particular occasion. And he probably already decided to save their lives and not execute them, but, you know. Yeah. Philippa gave him the ability to go back on that in public.
- [12:38]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Absolutely. I mean, and also, I think about Isabella, you know, I say, I go right into, oh, isn't she great? And isn't she strong and isn't she clever? Which, you know, obviously I'm leaning on those things, because I think she is. But she is also going to do a kind of traditional thing when she initially gets there, which is much is made of the fact that she is rather a fashion plate. Right. So she doesn't just show up to be the Queen of England, she shows up to be the Queen of England with 85 headdresses. Right.
- [13:09]
Matt Lewis
Yes. We're lucky to have an inventory of the list of things that she took with her to England on her marriage in 1308. And we can see that her father, Philip IV of France, was very keen for his daughter to look as magnificent as possible. So, yeah, she had 85 headdresses and numerous wonderful gowns and very expensive jewels, and she must have looked absolutely amazing. And, of course, there was this mentality at the time that royalty did have to look the part. So Isabella fulfilled that role perfectly. And, you know, we're also told by several chroniclers that, you know, physically, she was Beautiful, you know, like one Parisian chronicler calls her, you know, la belle des plus belle. The fairest of the fair, like, and the fairest woman you could find in France and England and the Holy Roman Empire. And we're also told by several chroniclers that Edward II was quite a magnificent looking man, and we know was very tall and physically powerful and handsome. So I think that, you know, whatever went wrong between them and especially went wrong with Edward II's behavior as a king, they did at least look the part.
- [14:06]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
But here's the thing, right, Is I bring up the looks and I bring up the fashion, and I bring up all these things, you know, obviously, because this is a part of what makes a queen a queen, right? It's a great form of propaganda when she shows up to say, look how regal I already am. I'm an ornamentation to your court. Let's not forget where I've come from, which is France. But also, there's a story that things begin to go a little bit wrong pretty much immediately at the wedding, and it is down to jewelry. Can you elucidate this?
- [14:44]
Matt Lewis
Yes, I. I do know what you're talking about, Eleanor. And this is a story about Isabella that was actually invented at the end of the 19th century and has no basis in any reality whatsoever. So Edward II had this male favorite, let's call him, who was presumably his lover. His name was Piers Gaveston. Edward had known him since they were teenagers. And as soon as he became. Literally as soon as he became king, he gave Gaveston the Earldom of Cornwall. And when Edward left England in early 1308 to go to France to marry Isabella, he left Piers Gaveston as regent of England, which was unheard of because Gaveston wasn't royal. So this created a massive scandal. Anyway, so Edward married Isabella in Boulogne, and then a little while later, they arrived in England, they sailed back to Dover, and Piers Gaveston, as regent of England, was one of the people who was waiting for them there, along with several of Edward's sisters or his cousins and other members of the English nobility. And we don't actually really know, particularly from the extant records that we have from the era, that anything actually went wrong at that time. So one London chronicler does say that Edward sent his wedding gifts, given to him by his father in law, Philip iv, to Gaveston in England, but it does say, specifically Edward's wedding gifts. It doesn't say Edward's and Isabella's wedding gifts. And some of the wedding gifts Edward received from his father in Law were war horses destriers. So, of course, there's no reason that Philip IV would have given war horses to his daughter, of all people. And the chronicler does just say that Edward sent the gifts to Gaveston. He doesn't actually say that Gaveston was meant to keep them or that was what Edward intended. I mean, that might be what Edward intended. I mean, he showed a massive amount of favoritism and affection to Gaveston. But then, on the other hand, they were his wedding gifts. I mean, if he wanted to give them to his best friend Oliver, you know, he could do what he wanted with them. And then, for some reason, in the 19th century, I don't know whether, you know, some writer, like, misread this chronicle because they somehow got this idea that Edward had given Isabella's own jewels and wedding gifts to Gaveston. And this has just been repeated endlessly in virtually every nonfiction book written about the pair. And it appears in numerous novels to the point that everybody who knows anything about Edward II and Isabella thinks that it's a fact. And, you know, and it just isn't. We often read scenes in novels, you know, where Piers Gaverton is, like, strutting in front of the desolate young queen wearing her own jewels. And it's absolute nonsense, really. And because Isabella was only 12 when she arrived in England, she was too young to be, you know, Edward's wife, in more than name only, until she got several years older and she didn't get pregnant for another four years. And there's really nothing to show, particularly that she actually disliked Gaveston. I mean, the statements that she did were actually written decades later. And, yeah, maybe she did dislike Gaveston. He does seem to have had the kind of personality that easily alienated people, in my view. I think a lot of later chroniclers kind of got mixed up between Piers gave and Edward II's much later and much more powerful favourite, Hugh Despenser the Younger, who Isabella most certainly did hate and loathe and detest and fear. And I think then people kind of either mix them up or they kind of just kind of, like, put Isabella's feelings for Dispenser, which are absolutely, I think, unarguable, and then put them back on Piers Gaveston and assumed that whatever she felt about Dispenser, she must have felt for Gaveston. But I don't really think that's actually true.
- [18:09]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Yeah, I would agree with you as well, because I think when Isabella gets to the throne, you know, it's not like she walks into a bed of Roses, obviously. But she seems to have managed to kind of balance things off with Gaveston and certainly with Edward himself as well. And it's quite. Well, she did, because Edward is in hot water almost immediately when they get home to England. You know, he is at odds with the barons. You know, he's not exactly a favorite in his own kingdom. How does Isabella help to mediate this position?
- [18:48]
Matt Lewis
I think what's important about Isabella is that, you know, her upbringing at the French court and, you know, so from the earliest beginnings of her childhood, she would have known exactly how to behave. She would have understood courtesy, courtly manners, exactly how to get on with people. So she would have been able to bring that to bear, you know, in Edward's very turbulent and difficult relations with his baron, and which she would easily have been able to smooth things over. And she seems like she did have that kind of personality, you know, when she wanted to. And of course, we have to bear in mind that although Isabella was of royal birth, her status in England was kind of was based on her relationship with Edward. If Edward's reputation went downhill and then so did Isabella. So it was in her own interest, really, to build Edward up and to make him as successful as, you know, she could possibly do, you know, obviously within the limitations of Edward's own personality and behavior, because he worked himself against himself all the time. So poor Isabella, stuck in this very difficult situation at only 12 years old. I mean, we've got to feel for the poor girl, don't we? I mean, she was a child and she's brought into this turbulent, difficult conflict. I mean, you know, within months of her arrival in England, Edward had almost managed to bring his kingdom to the brink of civil war. I mean, what do you do with that when you. When you're 12 years old?
- [20:03]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Yeah, I mean, it's kind of incredible. And, you know, I think she does a pretty good job of it because interestingly, she does seem to kind of say, all right, well, here's a. Here's a difficult playing field. I am casting in with the favorite. It's going to be me and Kaveston, and we are going to make this work. You know, we've got a mutual interest which is kind of keeping Edward happy. So here we go. We're going to go forward. I mean, and to the point that her uncle, Thomas of Lancaster, is like, yeah, she's on the wrong team here. She's in Gaveston, right?
- [20:40]
Matt Lewis
Yes, it does seem like that Thomas of Lancaster, who, you know, interestingly, was both Edward II's cousin and Isabella's uncle, because he was the younger half brother of her mother. Yes, he does seem to have thought that. That Isabella was much more on Edward's side than the baron's side. And Isabella's own behaviour does also seem to indicate that. So we're lucky that actually most of Isabella's household accounts during her very long life in England, half a century, don't survive anymore, unfortunately. But they do for a few months in 1311 and 1312, which is exactly the period, you know, when Gaveston was exiled from England for the third time. His wife was pregnant, who was Edward II's niece. Edward brought him back. Then the barons ended up killing Gatherston because they were so sick of the whole situation. So, fortunately, we don't have Isabella's letters that we sent, but we do have records that she sent letters. We have payments to messengers for taking her letters to her uncle Lancaster and to other barons, you know, to the Earl of Warwick, for example, you know, who were both enemies and friends of Edward ii. So she was obviously trying to deal with the situation and to help Edward out.
- [21:45]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Yeah, I mean, you know, she's in this terrible position because essentially by 1311, you know, surprise. This is when we get some more records of Isabella. By this point, we are essentially in open rebellion against the Crown. And Isabella doesn't just sit around. Isabella doesn't just say, oh, yes, well, this is kingly business. You know, she starts writing letters. You know, she's sending letters to her uncle, she's sending letters back to France, being like, hey, guys, remember your daughter, niece, sister. You know, I could use some help here. She is a very involved stateswoman.
- [22:21]
Matt Lewis
I think that's an important point, Helena, that, of course, Isabella always knew all her life that she was the Queen of England, but she was of France, and, you know, her father was the King of France. She had her brothers, you know, at this point, until her father died in 1314, her eldest brother was the King of Navarre. And she was always willing to use that connection to help Edward if she possibly could. And then to remind the English barons that, you know, her husband had France on his side as well. Because, you know, there's a lot of evidence, or at least I think there's a lot of evidence, that Edward II and Philip IV did not like each other personally, but also that Isabella, in the period between her marriage to Edward and her father's death in late 1314, she actually visited the French courts three times, and she negotiated and mediated with her father to help Edward as much as she Possibly could. So I think this kind of speaks to Isabella's astuteness and her political intelligence, her emotional intelligence, that she was very keen and very willing to use the powerful royal connection she had to France, you know, the most powerful country in Europe at the time, to help her husband. Absolutely, yeah.
- [23:26]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
You know, these trips back and forth, that's really saying something considering that in the middle of all of the civil war and the going back and forth to Paris, she also gives birth to Edward iii. It's a lot.
- [23:40]
Matt Lewis
There's an awful lot going on. And when you think that Isabella was still only 16 when she got pregnant with Edward III, she was still essentially almost a child, legally still a child. And then when her son was only a few months old, she and Edward, she went to France for a two month visit, which again, really helped to smooth things over with Philip Ivan. And we're lucky to have the testimony of a Parisian chronicler who wrote a rhyming chronicle talking about their visit. And we get this lovely snippet. Edward II one morning was late for a meeting with Philip IV because he and Isabella had overslept because they'd been having fun during the night. And I just love this because I think, you know, they were the young parents of the future King of England. They were in France, it was summer, Isabella was surrounded by her and all the courtiers she'd grown up with. And it just seems like at this point in their life, they were really happy. And Gaveson had been dead by then for a year. There was no other male favorite on the horizon. Isabella was the mother of the future king. I mean, everything was great. And you know, she was still only a teenager and yet, you know, she'd achieved so much.
- [24:50]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
I mean, but one of the things that she achieves in this period is one that I love to talk about because my girl is a drama monger. My girl manages to kick off a little something called the Tour d'enessel affair. And I'm wondering if we could just, just, just a light gossip very, very quickly about this.
- [25:12]
Matt Lewis
Okay. So as I mentioned, Isabella had three older brothers, Louis, Philip and Charles, who all in their turn would reign as kings of France and Navarre. So in March, April 1314, Isabella treks upon on one of her visits to the French court to help Edward ii. You know, she's negotiating on his behalf with her father. And while there, it seems that she finds out that the wives of two of her brothers, the eldest Louis and the youngest Charles, were having affairs with other men who were the gautier brothers. And of course, you know, this being the Middle Ages, royal men could, you know, go and you know, have affairs with whoever they wanted. That was fine. But you know, they were women, they were going to bear the future kings of France. So. So for them, of course it was strictly forbidden to have lovers in case they might foist a non royal child on the throne of France. This was a big thing. Some French chroniclers and some English chroniclers say that it was Isabella who uncovered this relationship that two of her three sisters in law were having with these much lower born knights who were brothers and that she told her father and this ended very badly for everyone in question. So the two knights were horribly executed very soon afterwards. And the two women there was Marguerite of Burgundy and her cousin Blanche of Burgundy. They were imprisoned in quite harsh conditions. Marguerite died, what, about 15 months later, I think. And Blanche stayed in prison for another 10, 11 years and then was finally released again after years of quite harsh incarceration. And this of course was a very big thing. I mean, the annulment of the marriage of Isabella's eldest brother Louis, you know, the future King of France. Oh yeah.
- [26:51]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
I mean it has knock on effects later in terms of who we believe can take over the front of throne, et cetera, et cetera. But you know, of course nobody knows that at the time. At the time it's just, you know.
- [27:01]
Matt Lewis
Le scandal, which is, yes, because Louis and his wife Margaretha Burgundy actually had a daughter who was just two years old at this time. So then of course there were questions over her legitimacy and whether she could succeed her father in the future as King of France. And Louis actually died when he was only in his 20s. So when he died in 1316, his, his second wife was, was pregnant. She gave birth to a son five months later who immediately became King of France. But unfortunately the baby boy died when he was only a few days old. And then there was this big debate, you know, who is the next ruler of France? You know, is it young, young Jeanne, you know, Louis, daughter by Marguerite, or is it Louis and Isabella's next brother Philip?
- [27:46]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
I mean, this is a really precarious point in time for everyone. You know, we are in the years now of the great famine, which is a. Granted, it's not something that necessarily affects royals so much because they can just take food from poor people. But it is certainly something that kind of gets pointed out as you are a bad ruler when you do this. And also it's one of those signs that medieval people kind of read into you Know, like, oh, things are going very certainly badly when suddenly we're all starving. Right. And perhaps this is some kind of vengeance from God. And meanwhile, things are not going great militarily for old Edward up in England. And this places Isabella in kind of a really awkward position. You know, she's had a second son now, so, you know, she's doing her job, which is ensuring royal secession is going to happen. But she is not particularly happy with what is going on with Edward. I think that would be fair to say. No?
- [28:48]
Matt Lewis
Well, absolutely. I mean, Edward lost the Battle of Bannockburn in 1314 to Robert Bruce, the King of Scotland, arguably England's most famous and most humiliating military defeat in history, you might say. So, of course, that's really humiliating for poor Isabella that her husband loses this battle that absolutely nobody thought that he was going to lose. And in fact, Edward lost his seal, like his great seal, with which he signed and sealed documents on the battlefield of Bannockburn. And so for a few days, Isabella actually lent him her own seal so that English government business could continue. And then also we're told that she tended Edward's wounds, you know, after he came back, you know, shattered by this defeat, to the port of Berrycom Tweed. And whatever Isabella was feeling at that point, and she must have been thinking, like, oh, my God, how did this happen? And then she did look after her husband and then lent him her seal.
- [29:42]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
I just think that that's such an important little bit of courtly life. Right? You know, the fact that she's close enough by and she understands the workings to insert herself and say, okay, well, this is what needs to happen. Yes, we're in a bad position, but here's how we keep things ticking over. You don't get to just sit here and lick your wounds. We need to keep moving.
- [30:03]
Matt Lewis
We need to get on with things. Yes. And then, as you say, then the great famine starts. So essentially what happened was that it basically hardly ever stopped raining towards the end of 1314 and then through the whole of 1315 years throughout Northern Europe. So crops rotted away in the fields. What food there actually was. It was. It was very little. And it became massively expensive because of the demand. And something like 10% of the entire population of northern Europe died of starvation and malnutrition or the diseases associated with them. So this is a natural disaster that was not caused by Edward ii. But yes, of course it was. It was something that it didn't help, you know, like the general turbulence and problems of his reign. And as you Say it's like, you know, almost like whatever he did was almost seen as the wrong thing, you know, so he tried to fix prices of food so that people could afford to actually eat and, oh, no, that's wrong. Oh, no, you shouldn't do that. You should do so. You know, it just seemed like, you know, even the weather and everything was turning against Edward, and certainly we're still.
- [31:01]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Having major problems with Scotland. Right. And this becomes a personal problem for Isabella. Right. Not just one that is something at court that she is needing to deal with politically, but she becomes an actual target for the Scottish. Right.
- [31:19]
Matt Lewis
Yes. So that happened a few years later in 1322. So, you know, Edward's military record against Robert Bruce is just disastrous beyond the telling of it. And in 1322, he launched his last invasion of Scotland. It was an utter disaster. He came back to England with his army. He was in Yorkshire with his army. Isabella was there as well. Robert Bruce launched a counter invasion of England, defeated a royal force at the Battle of Byland, near Cirsk in Yorkshire. Edward had to gallop hard to Scarborough on the coast to avoid being captured. And then poor Isabella gets kind of caught up in all of this as well. And according to a couple of French chroniclers, actually kind of like came quite close to being captured by a Scottish force. And actually, now I think of it, this was the second time it happened. It happened in 1319 as well. I'd forgotten about that. I've got. So this was when Robert Bruce invaded England on another occasion, defeated an English force at the Battle of Myton, and then Isabella was also nearby. And then we're actually told that the male inhabitants of the city of York actually marched out to where Isabella was staying at a manor, you know, just to kind of look after and to take her back into a walled city where she would be safer. This is just an absolute sign of the slightly utter disaster of Edward II reign. Like, he couldn't defeat Robert Bruce. Edward came from a much more. A much larger, much richer and a more powerful kingdom, could not defeat Robert Bruce in any way whatsoever. But worse than that, he couldn't protect the north of England from Scottish raids, he couldn't protect his own subjects. And then, worst of all, perhaps he couldn't even protect his own wife, his own royal queen, you know, the sacred vessel who had borne his children.
- [33:00]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Yeah. This is an incredibly valuable target. Right. If you were the Scottish, because a. You know, getting a queen, that's like free reign in terms of asking for whatever you want in order to get the Queen back. But I think it also kind of shows that people are aware that Isabella is one of the real powers behind the throne. That's why she's there in the first place. You know, she hasn't been left back in London where it's safe. She's near the battle because she's involved. Right.
- [33:28]
Matt Lewis
This is so important, I think. Yes. And so revealing of the kind of person that Isabella was, that, yes, she could easily have stayed at one of the numerous royal castles and manors, you know, hundreds of miles away in or near London. But she wasn't that type of person, you know, so she went to the north with her husband, she accompanied him. She wanted to be there, you know, at the forefront of matters. And this did put her in danger, you know, on at least a couple of occasions, you know, thanks actually, to Edward's own incompetence. But we can see that, you know, cowardice was emphatically not in Isabella's makeup. She wasn't someone who wanted to cow away safely, even though no one would have bothered about that. That would have been absolutely fine. You know, she was the second most important person in the kingdom. Absolutely fine. If. And she was a woman, of course she wasn't going to fight. So it's absolutely fine if you just stay in the. In the Tower of London or whatever, of course. But. But she didn't.
- [34:33]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
I used to think buying foundation online was impossible. How am I supposed to find my shade when I can't even get it right in store? Then I discovered Il Maquillage. I took their AI powered quiz to find my custom match and wow. This foundation is literally my skin in a bottle. The undertone and coverage are spot on. It's so neutral and weightless, I can't.
- [34:51]
Matt Lewis
Even tell I'm wearing makeup.
- [34:52]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Plus, with Try before youe Buy, you can try your full size at home for 14 days. Take the PowerMatch Quiz now at ilmaquillage.com Quiz I L M A K I A G E.com Quiz at Lowe's, our.
- [35:06]
Matt Lewis
Members get more with the Mylo's rewards programs. You can shop member only deals for your home and business every week. Plus members earn points on eligible purchases. So what are you waiting for? Join for free Today Lowe's we help.
- [35:22]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
You save loyalty programs subject to terms and conditions.
- [35:25]
Matt Lewis
Details@lowes.com Terms subject to change.
- [35:28]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Free standard shipping not available in Alaska and Hawaii.
- [35:31]
Matt Lewis
Exclusions and more terms apply.
- [35:35]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
I know I'm not alone when I say adulting can be overwhelming. And what we all could Use is a drink. That's where Apple and Eve Juice comes in. As the rulers of the juice box, they've been making juice joyful for 50 years with refreshing juice blends bursting with bold flavor. One sip sends you right back to childhood. So when the grind dulls your shine, remember to kid yourself. Apple and Eve has delicious juices for at home and on the go shop today.
- [36:05]
Matt Lewis
So we've arrived in winter.
- [36:06]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
We're getting up in the dark, the.
- [36:08]
Matt Lewis
Commutes are stuffy, the person next to you is coughing.
- [36:12]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
I've got just the thing for you.
- [36:14]
Matt Lewis
An excellent escape. I'm Dan Snow, host of the Dan Snow's History Hit podcast, where I whisk.
- [36:20]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
You away into the greatest stories in history.
- [36:23]
Matt Lewis
Join me on the Inca trail in Peru, where I'll tell you the story of Machu Picchu.
- [36:28]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Or travel with me to the mighty Colosseum in Rome to find out just.
- [36:31]
Matt Lewis
What the gladiatorial games were really like. Follow Thomas Cochrane, the real master and commander, across the high seas. I take you round the world to where history happened. So check out Dan Snows Historyit for.
- [36:44]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
The best historical escapism this winter, wherever you get your podcasts. Yeah, and I just think that that says so much about her. But, you know, also, this is the point in time when I would say there's a real turning point in the marriage of Isabella and Edward, because, you know, up to this point, here she is, she's out of the battlefield, you know, we get people saying they're getting on quite well and then things become decidedly more rocky. What's going on in the kind of 1320s that really changes things?
- [37:32]
Matt Lewis
I suppose, I suppose, yeah. Firstly, it would be like these two occasions in 1319 and 1322, when, you know, Edward's incompetence almost led to Isabella being captured by Scottish forces. But the main thing was actually that Edward began a relationship with a new male favourite called Hugh Despentor, the younger Lord of Glamorgan. Now, he had been married to Edward's eldest niece since all the way back in 1306. But Edward had never liked or trusted Despenser before. Despenser was always on the baron side, so the barons, assuming that he was one of them and was loyal to them, appointed him as Edward II's Chamberlain in 1318. So the Chamberlain was the man who controlled access to the king. So it was a powerful position. And once Edward and Hugh Despenser began spending time together, we have no way of knowing exactly what happened. But over the next few months, Edward became absolutely besotted with Dispenser and to the point where he started doing absolutely everything that Hugh wanted him to do. Piling him with money, for example, you know, doing loads of favors for him. Basically, anything that Hugh wanted, he got. Until by 1321, he was virtually Edward's co ruler, even though he had never been appointed to that position. And as has happened with Piers Gaveston in 1311, almost exactly a decade earlier, the English barons got really sick of this and they exiled to Spencer, who became a pirate in the English Channel, as you do. And again, like, Isabella kind of like, played a role in this. We're told by several chroniclers that she actually went on her knees in front of Edward and begged him to exile Hugh Despenser, basically, because if he didn't, England was just going to collapse into civil war. So, you know, and again, I think at this point, you know, Isabella actually kind of saved the day because, you know, Edward was never going to exile Dispenser unless, you know, she kind of, you know, asked him to. And with the Queen on her knees in front of him, Edward actually did exile Dispenser. And then. So for a while, everything seemed to be okay until it all went horribly wrong. Edward brought Dispenser back again. And there's also evidence during this period in 1321 that, again, Isabella is doing what she can for Edward. So she had recently born their fourth child, Joan of the Tower, a future queen of Scotland. And then Isabella claimed that she was going on pilgrimage to Canterbury from London. But she. When she went back from Canterbury to London, she passed via Leeds Castle. And it seems like she was doing this deliberately because the road from the normal way from Canterbury back to London would not have gone past Leeds Castle. But Leeds Castle was owned by a lord called Badlesmere, who was one of Edward's chief baronial enemies. And Lord Badlesmere wasn't present, but his wife was, and he refused Isabella entry. So then Isabella then contacted her husband to say, look, you know, Lady Baldlesmere has insulted me, I'm the Queen, I can stay wherever I want in the kingdom. Please do something about it. So Edward then besieged Leeds Castle, successfully killed some of the garrison, and then this gave him a way in to then, like, go after the rest of the barons and to defeat them. So at this point, it seems to me that Isabella was very much acting on her husband's behalf, like, she must have known what was going on when she actually went to Leeds Castle, you know, to demand entry.
- [40:47]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Yeah, I mean, absolutely. To me, I think it's difficult to read this as anything other than a mutual understanding, but unfortunately, Edward doesn't really do what Isabella wants when he then has a pretty successful campaign against the barons. You know, here is Edward and Hugh Despenser, you know, kind of ruling then in England. And Isabel is not particularly happy with their crackdown against the barons. Right. This is where it gets really, really rocky.
- [41:20]
Matt Lewis
Well, things really start to go wrong both for, you know, both in. For Edward as a king and also in Edward and Isabella's relationship. Because, Ed, Edward was very brutal towards the defeated barons, the contrarians, he took to calling them. He executed about 20 or 22 of them, you know, which was, you know, they were English noblemen. So this was quite shocking at the time. And then the other thing that he did, which I think really began to ruin Edward and Isabella's relationship, was that Edward recalled Hugh Despenser back to England from his piracy in the English Channel and brought him back to court and made him his chamberlain again and made him his main sidekick, essentially. And the problem was that Despenser was an English nobleman. He was a real insider. He was related to most of the English nobility and he was a very ruthless individual who wanted political power. He wanted to be rich. I mean, he writes this. I've read his own letters, you know, I've translated them. You know, he actually, he actually says at one point, you know, to one of his followers, do such and such so that I will be rich. I was like, okay. So, I mean, you know, he was quite honest about his ambitions, but one of his ambitions was to be, yes, Edward's main co ruler and then Isabella was his main rival for this position. So starting in, say roughly March 1322, when dispenser came back to England from his exile and his piracy, he started to do everything he could to sideline Isabella. And he succeeded possibly beyond, you know, his wildest dreams. Because beginning in 1322, like Isabella, who had always been like so influential with Edward and appears so often in all the docum have, she suddenly disappears from all of them. It's like she died. It's like she's just suddenly not there anymore. She died or retired to a convent. And somehow Despenser had been very successful in persuading Edward that Isabella was, was not his loyal queen, his supportive and loving wife as she had always been. She was his enemy. She was French, she was an outsider. And so in 1324, Edward actually went to war against his brother in law. So Isabella's third and last brother, Charles iv, It's conflict between the two kingdoms. And at the height of this war, in September 1324, Edward actually confiscated all of Isabella's lands in England, which was absolutely appalling, and treated her, his own loving wife, the mother of his children, as though she was nothing but an enemy alien, as though she's, oh, no, like, you have nothing to do with me anymore. You're just French. You're, you know, you're your brother's sister. You're not my wife, you're French. That's it. I'm not interested. And she was absolutely devastated and extremely angry, certainly with Edward, also with Hugh Despenser, who had somehow persuaded Edward into treating his wife as his enemy. Essentially, after all the years of love and support and affection and care Isabella had given her husband, she was suddenly treated as though she didn't even exist anymore in Edward's life.
- [44:17]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
I think this is such an important point because people tend to focus on what comes after this, but they don't engage with what an incredible insult this is. You know, here is a woman who was absolutely integral to keeping the kingdom together. She was intimately involved in all these parts of court life. She's trying her hardest to do the right thing by this guy the whole time. And then to suddenly have your lands confiscated and just be told, well, no, I'm afraid you're French riff raff and you need to get out of here. It also runs contrary to the entire point of royal marriage at the time.
- [44:56]
Matt Lewis
Absolutely.
- [44:56]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Which is that, yes, I mean, you do come from these places and the idea is that there's going to be some connection, but you then are supposed to be mediating exchange. Not that you are always going to side with your family, you're going to intervene with your family to get good things for your own kingdom. Right.
- [45:13]
Matt Lewis
I think it's impossible to overstate just how much of an insult Edward offered to Isabella by doing this to her as a queen and, you know, to his royal wife and also to their personal life. He was basically, you know, just almost like, you know, just. He froze her out of his life completely. So, I mean, it just seems from the records that I've seen of Edwards and Edwards accounts that, you know, they did exchange letters and presents sometimes. But, you know, what kind of presence? I don't really know. Or what kind of letters? I don't really know. And Isabella obviously kind of just at one point, she just. She was so upset, distraught, angry. She actually declared that she was going on pilgrimage, or that's possibly just an excuse that actually Edward came up with, because she just left court, she had actually literally walked out on him, which, again, is unheard of. I mean, you know, you don't walk out on the king, you know, so Edward had to come up with an excuse. But there's no evidence at all that Isabella actually ever did go on pilgrimage. He just said she just angrily just, like, took herself off somewhere where Edward wasn't and stayed away from him for a long time. And it does seem, at least superficially, that they kind of reconciled slightly, a little bit, at least kind of in public by exchanging the occasional letter and gift. But something had gone horribly, horribly wrong in their marriage, and Isabella was distraught. And a lot of people have always thought that this is when she started hating Edward. And I think, you know, maybe she did, you know, and I can't get into her head. I don't know. I think she was terribly angry with him, but I think she was also devastated that, you know, her marriage had essentially collapsed, her role as Edward's consort and his queen and his royal wife had collapsed, and she was just being treated as though she was nothing. And I'm sure she was terribly angry with Edward, but most of all, she was angry with Hugh Despenser, who she absolutely hated. And I think eventually she realized that if Hugh Dispenser harmed her in some way, that actually Edward had reached the point in his obsession with Dispenser that he wouldn't actually prevent Dispenser from harming his own royal wife.
- [47:19]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Well, and I mean, I think this is a huge misstep, both on Edward's part and Dispenser's part, because this is not the type of girly who takes this lying down. You know, you can't just completely sideline her, take her kids away and say, yeah, guess what? You're an enemy of the state. Oh, by the by, you don't have any lands, any money or any way of supporting yourself. This is the sister of the king of France. Right. It's not like she has nowhere to go in this situation.
- [47:45]
Matt Lewis
I think, yeah, both Edward and Dispenser really underestimated Isabella and her anger with both of them, and I think they were both politically quite, quite foolish, and I can kind of understand Edward doing that. But Dispenser normally was more intelligent than that, so it seems a real misstep on his part. So I think perhaps Gaveston, years earlier, okay, who admittedly was dealing with a much younger Isabella, but I think perhaps he tried to take her more on side and say, look, you have your role. You know, you're the queen, you're royal, I'm just his friend, lover, whatever. You know, we both have our roles in Edward's life, but I will never try to take over your role. But Dispenser did all of that. It was like, you know, he wanted to be Edward's own consort. And there is evidence that this is how he thought of himself and how Chronicler actually thought of him. So you start seeing, like, records of, like, you know, Edward and Hugh's household, like, they had a joint household, like they were a married couple. So Hugh had kind of taken everything from Isabella, and she wasn't the kind of person who was going to just put up with this insult, obviously. And so, yes, Edward was at war with Isabella's brother, Charles IV of France. It was going badly. And so Edward came up, or possibly it was the Pope actually, who came up with the bright idea and Edward accepted it, that Isabella could be sent to Paris to negotiate a peace settlement. You know, being the wife of one and the sister of the other. So in March 1325, Isabella went back to her homeland. And that is absolutely the key moment.
- [49:08]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Yeah, Right. Because here we have, you know, Charles has been like, well, oh, we're at war. Guess what? You don't have any of your French possessions anymore, which seems smart. That's probably what I would do. And Isabella is now down at court with her brother, you know, like, oh, hey. Oh, I'm so French, look. Yeah, here I am at the French court and people who don't love what Edward is doing in England start showing up. Right. So suddenly we have a big flocking of the nobility from England who are also arriving at court in France.
- [49:45]
Matt Lewis
Yes. So back in 1322, Edward had defeated the baronial faction who rebelled against him, who we call the contrarians. 20 or so were executed, many of them were in prison, some of them fled abroad. And one of the contrarians was Roger Mortimer, Lord of Wigmore. So he had been imprisoned in the Tower of London for 18 months, but escaped, made his way over to the continent, and he was the highest ranking of the English rebels, or contrarians, on the continent. So therefore he became their leader. So he and the other contrarians then actually went to the French court and offered their services to Charles IV and then to Isabella.
- [50:23]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Yeah, well, and, you know, speaking of services that are offered to Isabella, it seems like around this time Isabella and Mortimer start seeing each other romantically. I mean, this is her kind of guy can break out of the Tower of London, can you know, get together a bunch of forces. He is kind of diplomatically minded and he is here. And she, for all intents and purposes, is a free agent. She's been told that she's replaced, you know, like she's no longer the consort of the king. So what's a girl to do?
- [50:55]
Matt Lewis
Well, I think actually that the evidence that where Isabella and Mortimer were sexually and romantically involved is a lot less than most people actually think it is. I mean, they might have been. I'm not saying that they definitely weren't, but I just think the evidence is a heck of a lot less than, I mean, than most people think. I mean, it's certainly not the case that we know that they fell into bed together at the French court in 1325 or that they fell passionately in love. I mean, you know, yes, maybe they did, but I think at this stage, you know, Roger Mortimer was a very useful political and military ally to Isabella, as indeed were the other barons, you know, including one of Edward II's own half brothers, who had a French mother and was Isabella's cousin. So it wasn't just Roger. He was just the leader of the baronial, the English baronial faction at the French court. Though, of course, there is evidence that, that he and Isabella did become very close over the next few years. And he was essentially her co ruler in the early years of the reign of her son, Edward iii. Picture this. You're halfway through a DIY car fix, tools scattered everywhere, and boom, you realise you're missing a part. It's okay because, you know, whatever it is, it's on ebay. They've got everything. Brakes, headlights, cold air intakes, whatever you need. And it's guaranteed to fit. Which means no more crossing your fingers and hoping you ordered the right thing. All the parts you need at prices you'll love. Guaranteed to fit every time. Ebay Things people love.
- [52:41]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
I used to think buying foundation online was impossible. How am I supposed to find my shade when I can't even get it right in store? Then I discovered Il Maquillage. I took their AI powered quiz to find my custom match and wow. This foundation is literally my skin in a bottle. The undertone and coverage are spot on. It's so neutral and weightless, I can't.
- [52:59]
Matt Lewis
Even tell I'm wearing makeup.
- [53:00]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Plus, with Try before youe Buy, you can try your full size at home for 14 days. Take the Power Match Quiz now at ilmaquillage.com Quiz I L M A K I A G E.com Quiz yeah. And so Here we hatch a plan, right? Here we are in the French court. We've got rather a lot of disaffected lords, we've got the King of France very mad at his sister's treatment. And, you know, there is a heir apparent. So here is what happens with a woman scorned, right? A very clever, well connected woman with an army can apparently just take the fight back to England.
- [53:56]
Matt Lewis
Well, Edward II's biggest mistake was actually to send his son to the French court, his son, the future Edward iii. So Edward II was the Duke of Aquitaine. You know, he inherited the Duchy of Aquitaine in the southwest of France from his father and his great great grandmother, Eleanor of Aquitaine. So he owed homage and fealty to his overlord, the King of France, for this territory. But of course, Edward didn't want to leave England. England was in absolute chaos and mayhem. Everything was going horribly wrong for Edward at this point. So he didn't really know what to do. Like he had to pay homage to Charles IV or the Duchy of Akron or he would lose it, which he couldn't allow to happen. So the only other alternative was to make his and Isabella's son, Edward of Windsor, who was not quite 13 years old at this point, he made him Duke of Aquitaine instead and sent him to the French court to pay homage to Charles IV. So this was in September 1325, and this really was a key moment because Isabella, by herself and even the baronial rebels she had with her, the French court, could pretty much be ignored. I mean, I think it was embarrassing for Edward that his wife is just, you know, like, openly defying him in Paris. But it's not really that bad. There's not all that much that she can do by herself. But having the future King of England in her custody, this was actually a really key point. And this is actually what enabled Isabella and her allies to actually to raise an army. So they went to the county of Hainault in modern day Belgium, arranged Edward of Windsor's marriage to one of the Count of Hainault's daughters in exchange for ships and mercenaries.
- [55:31]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
You know, that's a pretty good, pretty good wedding gift, you know, and also fundamentally, hey, no, they're very rich. You know, this is a great, it's a very nice little match too, for a future King of England. So, hey, that's great.
- [55:43]
Matt Lewis
And absolutely.
- [55:43]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
And here they go, they've got a fleet, they've got an army, and they go back to an England which is not unhappy to see the Queen back. I, I think that that would Be fair to say.
- [55:56]
Matt Lewis
Absolutely. So Isabella's in and Roger Mortimer's invasion force arrived in England in September 1326. And at this stage, Edward II's support just collapses. And I don't think he realized just how massively unpopular he was at this stage. So, like Edward's two half brothers joined Isabella, so did Thomas of Lancaster's brother and Henry of Lancaster, who is Isabella's uncle. He was like one of the most powerful barons in the country. You know, everyone just kind of flocked to Isabella. Edward ended up having to. And Despenser ended up having to flee to Wales, pursued by Isabella and her army. And soon the King of England was little more than a fugitive in his own kingdom. And Isabella had brought this about within a matter of weeks. All it took really was, it was just, I suppose the Queen and her son providing a focus of opposition to Edward and his support just collapsed at that point.
- [56:48]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
You know, that is one way to tell that you are not a popular king. Right. You know, when your wife is in pursuit of you across the country and everyone's like, yeah, fair play seems legit to me.
- [57:00]
Matt Lewis
I just wonder what the heck was going on in Edward's head.
- [57:03]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
You know, not anything smart, right. Because they catch up with him, they capture him, they capture Dispenser and this is where their story comes to an end.
- [57:17]
Matt Lewis
Yes. So Despenser was executed two months to the day after Isabella arrived in England. That's how what a little period of time it took to capture and execute her biggest enemy. And then just two months after that, in January 1327, Edward II was forced to abdicate his throne to his and Isabella's 14 year old son, Edward III. And so because he was underage, Isabella essentially ruled England for the next few years.
- [57:43]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Yeah, and she does a pretty okay job of this. I mean, you know, considering you think.
- [57:51]
Matt Lewis
We could quibble that one.
- [57:52]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
But yeah, I'm just, I'm a partisan, I suppose, but you know, it's, and this is the thing, I think that she kind of then misplays her own hand. Right? Because I think people were quite happy to see somebody who was slightly sensible come back along with, with the future king. Right. You know, this gives you a very easy way to hand off power, but I'm not sure that people were really ready for a, a queen who was really like, no, I'm 100, here's my great seal, I'm ready to rule. This is what's going down. Also, hey, there's Roger Mortimer. Don't worry about it, you Know, don't. Do not worry about how this guy, maybe my boyfriend, question mark, is also ruling. Right. I. I don't. I think that's a pretty big ask.
- [58:39]
Matt Lewis
Yes. I mean, I don't think it would be possible to overstate just how popular Isabella was when she returned in late 1326 and got rid of Hugh Despenser and forced her husband to abdicate. I mean, just like the wave of joy that overtook the whole country at this point was just massive. But the problem was that there was a Regency Council was officially appointed to rule for Edward iii and Isabella wasn't on it. And I would think, well, she probably should have been. But unfortunately, in England, unlike some other European countries in the Middle Ages, you know, like Queensland generally didn't rule for their underage sons, not officially, which is wrong and bad and awful, but unfortunately, that's what happened. So Isabella and, you know, with Mortimer at her side, we can probably fairly assume kind of just basically just, yeah, ignored the Regency Council and just kind of, you know, just ruled anyway. And I think a lot of people struggled with that. And there were, I think, a good four rebellions against her in the period of her rule for her son from. From January 1327 to October 1330. So, yeah, and that's.
- [59:43]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
That's rather a lot that I. And I do think that one of the things that kind of, she didn't necessarily grapple with is that whilst people were happy to see Edward go, they were also used to rebelling at this point in time. You know, yeah, they wanted to get rid of the king, but it's not like they weren't used to it at this point in time.
- [60:09]
Matt Lewis
Yes, absolutely. Completely used to rebelling against their rulers.
- [60:13]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
I mean, so here she is, she's the regent. And I mean, I think the other thing is that she is using the opportunity as regent to definitely enrich herself.
- [60:24]
Matt Lewis
And I think this is actually one point which fascinates me that, you know, she'd been. She'd seen up close what Edward II was like with his male favorites and enriching them, enriching himself, forcing people into rebellion. And then it just seems to me that she and Roger Mortimer kind of did pretty much the same thing themselves. So Roger Mortimer made himself Earl of March, which is essentially making himself Earl of all the English Welsh borderlands. I mean, that's a pretty massive territory, that's an unprecedented title and he makes himself massively wealthy. And I just think, what were they thinking? I mean, this actually almost makes the story more interesting to me than if they'd been successful. Because it just seems to me that they were just repeating the same mistakes of Edward and Dispenser, perhaps even without. Not without entirely realizing it. So then the barons and then everyone else, and we thought, oh, gosh, you know, we used to have the King and his ruthless, greedy, avaricious favorite, and now we've got the Queen and her ruthless, greedy, avaricious favorite. You know, what's the benefit here?
- [61:25]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
But I think also, she's a little unfairly maligned by the kingdom, because one of the big things that she does that I think actually quite smart is she affiances her daughter off to the Scottish. You know, there are these huge problems with the Scottish wars, and Isabella says, okay, yeah, I know how to solve this. It's how I solved, you know, the problems for England and France, in theory, you know, or here is Joan of the Tower. She will marry David Bruce, and this is going to be fine. And people really don't like this move.
- [61:59]
Matt Lewis
I mean, from our perspective, I think, you know, hundreds of years later, you think, yes, what a clever idea. Of course, England and Scotland shouldn't be at war. What is the point of this? It's just killing lots of people. It's destroying lands on both sides of the border. England is never going to conquer Scotland. What is the point of it? So it just seems like, yes, the marriage of Joan of the Tower and the future David ii, David Bruce of Scotland, it just seems like it was a really sensible idea, but people at the time hated it because, you know, they liked being a wood scuff.
- [62:31]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
It's such a strange thing. It's like, oh, yeah, no, I love it, actually, Please, please, let's mess the borderlands up.
- [62:37]
Matt Lewis
It's like, get a clue. Discover pacifism. It's great. But unfortunately, so unfortunately, I would have to say that one of the actions that Isabella took, that from our perspective, was great, it's sensible, and the obvious thing actually lost her answer. An awful lot of popularity.
- [62:53]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
And that's when things kind of start to go downhill. Right. You know, we are almost at a state of civil war by that time. We're kind of like closing out 1328. No.
- [63:05]
Matt Lewis
Yes, it's 1320. Yeah. Closing out 1328. There's. There's a big rebellion which is kind of led by the English barons who had been promised land in Scotland or thought they had a right to land in Scotland when England conquered Scotland. And. And then Isabella's own uncle, Henry of Lancaster, also joined this rebellion against us. So you know, it. It had got pretty about by this point.
- [63:26]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Yeah. And, you know, here we have, you know, Lancaster rising up, you know, not necessarily successfully.
- [63:36]
Matt Lewis
We can.
- [63:36]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
We can say that, you know, and. And Isabella does some cool things like, you know, show up wearing armor to battles. Huge fan of that. I'm a huge fan of girlies in armor. Fantastic. But these things never go away. There's just this kind of bubbling resentment towards Isabella and certainly Mortimer at this point in time.
- [63:55]
Matt Lewis
I would say, yes, absolutely. I mean, we're told by one chronicler that even one of Mortimer's own sons started calling him the King of Folly by early 1330, that they basically lost almost all of their support from, you know, everyone who had been so enthusiastic about them. So, you know, they'd lost Isabella's uncle, they'd lost Isabella's cousins, Edward II's half brothers. You know, they'd lost most of the important people of the country. And then Mortimer kind of set a seal on this unpopularity by kind of like judicially murdering essentially the Earl of Kent, who was one of Edward II's half brothers. And I think that was also a key point and certainly in Edward III's own attitude towards them. So, you know, because Edward III turns 17 in late 1329, he's rapidly reaching manhood. He and his wife, Queen Philippa, had a son who was born in June 1330. You know, made Isabella a grandmother in her 30s. Lovely. And I think as soon as Edward III saw that his mother had judicially murdered his own uncle, he had a son, he'd secured his throne, he saw, okay, now it's time to do something about it. So in October 1330. Yeah, he took his moment. Yeah. So the court was staying in Nottingham Castle in October 1313, and Edward III, who is still only 17, he wasn't even quite 18 yet. He launched a coup against Isabella and Mortimer. He used a secret tunnel cutter through the rocks into Nottingham Castle and marched into the room where Isabella and Mortimer were having a meeting with their last remaining allies, including the Bishop of Lincoln, and, yes, arrested Roger Mortimer and several of his few remaining supporters. Supposedly, the Bishop of Lincoln tried to escape down a latrine at this point.
- [65:35]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
I love that. Yeah. That's basically the end for the Isabella and Mortimer alliance and indeed, Isabella's reign as regent.
- [65:48]
Matt Lewis
Yes. So Roger Mortimer was imprisoned and then he was executed at Tyburn, near London. A few weeks later, Isabella was forcibly retired to house arrest for a while, no longer wielded power, but she lived for another 28 years. So you Know, she had quite a long life and, you know, there's kind of quite a lot of evidence that, you know, as the years passed, Edward III perhaps grew more forgiving. He and his wife would visit her, their children, especially when their children got older. So she kind of takes on this role of, like, the much more conventional Dowager Queen who's traveling all around her massive estate, you know, shelling out loads of money on clothes and minstrels and jewels, you know, like, like she'd always done as she had the right to do, you know, by the standards of the time. Yeah.
- [66:32]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
You know, I'm afraid that I don't feel too badly for her. I've been to Castle Rising, you know, it doesn't seem so bad to me, hanging out in a series of castles and spending rather a lot of money on musicians. And by all accounts, she's living a very fashionable lifestyle. She's going hunting a lot, she's hanging out. And yeah, she does kind of have this quite nice relationship with her son and his family. Eventually, you know, he's kind of like, ah, yeah, well, who, who hasn't attempted to enrich themselves? And, you know, I think it's just a really interesting story, you know, because it does a lot to put our assumptions about how women behave in the Middle Ages on their head. Right. And at the same time, though, we also can use this as a test case to see exactly how far a woman can get, you know, what is it that you can do within this power structure if you're willing to surprise people. But then this is also where the breaks come on, Right?
- [67:37]
Matt Lewis
Yes. Unfortunately, you know, I, I, there's an awful lot that, you know, we could say about, about women wielding power in the, in the Middle Ages and how much they were allowed to wield and, you know, and all the criticism that they perhaps received that probably men wouldn't have in exactly that, that same position. So I think Isabella's story is fascinating for what it reveals about what, what women in power were able to do. But then, yeah, eventually the brakes come off and it just, yes, unfortunately, all went downhill.
- [68:06]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Yeah. I think one really interesting thing too, that we see, even at her death, she has this long, pretty nice retirement. And then she does the ordinary queen retirement retirement, which is, she's like, I'm a nun now, which is a really great way to kind of make sure that you get into heaven right. After doing things and executing people. Right. So she becomes a poor Clare, which is the sort of woman's equivalent of the Franciscans, and she, she Dies and is buried at a Franciscan church. And she's buried with her husband's heart.
- [68:40]
Matt Lewis
Yes, we think so. So she was definitely buried with the clothes she was wearing during her wedding to Edward. Not necessarily in the clothes, I hasten to add. I mean, this is 50 years later, but her wedding clothes were definitely buried in the coffin with her. And there's a rather later tradition that she was also buried with Edward II's heart, but that's not totally certain. But I like to think that that's true. And I should point out at this stage that separate heart burial was entirely normal in royal burials of the 13th and 14th centuries. So this isn't macabre or, you know, Isabella like having, oh, I murdered my husband and, you know, this is the trophy, his heart or anything like that. It was, you know, entirely unexceptional to do. But I think, you know, it kind of, yeah, maybe speaks volumes about how Isabella felt about, you know, her marriage and her husband at the end of her life. And, you know, we don't really know, but it just, you know, their story is a complex and a rather fascinating one.
- [69:39]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
You know, frankly, I could talk about Isabella for years, but we have to leave it somewhere.
- [69:46]
Matt Lewis
Somewhere.
- [69:47]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
I think that. But this is not a bad place to leave it because it is messy. It is difficult to decipher exactly what was going on here and why people made the decisions that they did. But it's still a very human story as well. And I think that's what I love about Isabella, is that she's an incredibly clever person in a weird situation who really does her best. But she's got foibles. You know, she seems like a really. She's a kind of fully fleshed character, even though we don't get to know that much from her, from her own.
- [70:20]
Matt Lewis
Mouth, I think the word messy is just about right. You know, yes, she was a human being. She had some wonderful traits. She was a wonderful, amazing person in many ways. But of course, yes, she had negative qualities as well. Like all of us, she was just a complex, real person who did some great things, some very intelligent things, and Frankie's, you know, some less praiseworthy things as well. But, you know, I mean, that's the same for so many others.
- [70:44]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Look, let women be complex, too. We stan a messy queen. We absolutely love all of this. But, Katherine, thank you so much for coming on to talk to me about Isabella. It's been such a treat.
- [70:57]
Matt Lewis
Thank you so much, Ellen. I've really enjoyed it.
- [71:01]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
The fate of all races up to meet them. The King has chosen between his wife and his favorite. All of England recoils. Hugh Despenser is emboldened by Edward's choice. His boot presses down on all the harder. In France, the Queen plots her vengeance. Edward has raised the sword of Damocles above his own head and now awaits the fall. Mortimer is the steel gauntlet about the clenched fist of the Queen. If they land a blow, it could leave Edward with a bloodied nose. And what of the rest of us? England stands on the edge of a precipice. Stepping in might mean war, bloodshed, and upheaval. Resisting the fall might lead to them too. Who is right and who is wrong is becoming less important. The real question is, who will survive? Next time, Matt Lewis will consider the swift and ruthless rise of Roger Mortimer as the de facto ruler of England. He wielded power through Isabella, but how did his ambition ultimately lead to his downfall? Thank you once again to Catherine for joining me. And thank you for listening to Gone Medieval from History Hit. Remember, you can enjoy unlimited access to award winning original TV documentaries, including my recent series Meet the Normans, and ad free podcasts by signing up@historyhit.com subscription. You can follow Gone Medieval on Spotify, where you can leave us comments and suggestions or wherever you get your podcasts. And tell all your friends and family that you've gone medieval. Until next time, Acast powers the World's best podcasts. Here's a show that we recommend.
- [73:28]
Matt Lewis
I'm Kristen.
- [73:29]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
And I'm Jen from the I Mom so Hard podcast. We don't want to brag, but yes, we are moms. We're average moms. Below average sometimes. But we're not just moms.
- [73:38]
Matt Lewis
And we're not just supermodels either.
- [73:40]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
We're not just pieces of meat. That's right. We're not even close. We are comedians and we're also best friends. We're also best selling authors and television writers.
- [73:48]
Matt Lewis
We created a viral web series with.
- [73:50]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Over 300 million views. WhatsApp. Who? Who's bragging? And we were in our swimsuits. Again, not supermodels. We're also podcasters. Are we podcasting right now?
- [73:59]
Matt Lewis
Not right now, but we have been.
- [74:01]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Bringing laughs every Tuesday to women and moms everywhere. And one dude who's a sophomore in college. His name's Greg Whatever. He messaged us and made me feel cool.
- [74:08]
Matt Lewis
So nice. Amazing. Please listen to the Am mom so Hard podcast on Acast.
- [74:12]
Dr. Eleanor Janega
Woo.
- [74:14]
Matt Lewis
Acast helps creators launch, grow and monetize their podcasts everywhere. Acast.com.