Episode Summary: Benny Had a Baby!!

In the "Benny Had a Baby!!" episode of the "Good Guys" podcast by Dear Media, hosts Josh Peck and Ben Soffer dive into the delightful chaos and heartfelt moments surrounding the arrival of Ben and Claudia's newborn son, Prince Ruby. Released on June 23, 2025, this episode offers listeners an intimate glimpse into the joys and challenges of new parenthood, all delivered with the duo's characteristic humor and candidness.

1. Announcement and Initial Joy

The episode kicks off with exuberant announcements as Ben and Josh share the fantastic news of Ben’s new baby boy. Their excitement is palpable, setting a warm and engaging tone for the conversation.

• Josh Peck: “Prince Ruby. I love him. We love him. Everybody loves him.” [00:32]

2. The Birth Experience

Ben recounts the intricacies and emotions surrounding Claudia's C-section. With the podcast episodes pre-recorded, Ben had the opportunity to focus entirely on supporting Claudia during the birth.

• Ben Soffer: “We pre-recorded for a month. And now, henceforth, go have your beautiful baby.” [02:10]

The hosts humorously describe unexpected moments in the hospital, including a mix-up with coffee orders that left Claudia frustrated.

• Ben Soffer: “I've never seen Claudia so angry. She was furious.” [05:02]

Claudia’s determination to manage pain with minimal narcotics highlights her strength and resilience.

• Ben Soffer: “I'm so proud of her because she made it through on Tylenol and Advil.” [16:44]

3. Post-Delivery Challenges

After Ruby's birth, the couple spent two days in a private hospital room, navigating the physical and emotional aftermath. They discuss the exhaustion of sleep deprivation and the struggle to manage new responsibilities.

• Ben Soffer: “She was laying down, she's asleep. No swaddle all of a sudden.” [50:11]

Ben shares a relatable gripe about the hospital staff’s reluctance to provide pain medication to spouses, emphasizing the lack of support during such a critical time.

• Ben Soffer: “They don’t treat the spouse. What are you nuts?” [52:22]

4. Parenting Roles and Sleep

Josh and Ben delve into their nighttime routines, highlighting the importance of teamwork in ensuring both parents get adequate rest. Ben handles diaper changes and feeding, while Josh focuses on supporting Claudia and managing other baby needs.

• Ben Soffer: “My role is I change every diaper. ... I'm telling you, he drinks 4 ounces just from sticking it on the right tit.” [29:08]

They discuss strategies for maximizing sleep, such as taking shifts and sharing responsibilities to cope with the demands of a newborn.

5. Baby Care Routines

The hosts explore their baby care routines, particularly around feeding and managing sleep patterns. They highlight the benefits of both breastfeeding and formula feeding, noting Ruby’s impressive growth and health.

• Josh Peck: “The baby doesn’t need to eat in the middle of the night after four months.” [33:59]

Ben shares his methods for soothing Ruby’s gas issues, emphasizing the effectiveness of techniques like the bicycle maneuver.

• Ben Soffer: “I tilt him back and I get a nice toot. Then I tilt him again and it's a nice toot.” [36:57]

6. Handling Gripes and Frustrations

In the “What Do You Nuts” segment, Ben vents about the hospital’s refusal to provide additional pain medication for spouses, labeling the policy as unreasonable and frustrating.

• Ben Soffer: “What are you nuts? You should treat the spouse. Give the spouse three Advil.” [51:19]

Josh echoes the frustration, sharing his own challenging moments in the hospital, highlighting the lack of support systems for partners.

7. Humor and Light-Hearted Moments

Throughout the episode, Josh and Ben infuse their conversation with humor, making light of the sleepless nights and the less glamorous aspects of baby care. They share amusing anecdotes about diaper mishaps and the joys of watching their son grow.

• Josh Peck: “He’s up 50%. He’s going to be so fat and gorgeous and delicious.” [20:31]

• Ben Soffer: “Kids are cute. Even when they’re gross. They’re cute.” [46:49]

8. Conclusion

The episode wraps up with reflections on the profound experience of becoming parents, underscored by gratitude and humor. Josh and Ben reaffirm their commitment to teamwork and supporting each other through the journey of raising their new son.

• Josh Peck: “But I love us, as much as one can.” [32:33]

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• Josh Peck: “Prince Ruby. I love him. We love him. Everybody loves him.” [00:32]

• Ben Soffer: “I'm just saying, how great are we that we prerecorded? No time off.” [02:10]

• Ben Soffer: “I'm proud of her because she made it through on Tylenol and Advil.” [16:44]

• Ben Soffer: “We don’t treat the spouse. What are you nuts?” [52:22]

• Josh Peck: “The baby doesn’t need to eat in the middle of the night after four months.” [33:59]

• Ben Soffer: “Kids are cute. Even when they’re gross. They’re cute.” [46:49]

This episode of "Good Guys" provides a heartfelt and humorous exploration of the early days of parenthood. Josh Peck and Ben Soffer's candid discussions offer both entertainment and relatable insights for anyone navigating the joys and challenges of welcoming a new baby into the family.