Podcast Title: Good Guys
Episode: Gone Catfishin' with Nev Schulman
Release Date: June 30, 2025
Host/Authors: Josh Peck & Ben Soffer
Description: Hosted by actor & writer Josh Peck and entrepreneur & social media icon Ben Soffer, "Good Guys" dives into a variety of topics every Monday and Thursday, blending humor with insightful discussions.

Episode Overview

In the episode "Gone Catfishin' with Nev Schulman," hosts Josh Peck and Ben Soffer engage in an in-depth conversation with Nev Schulman, best known for his role in the documentary series Catfish. The discussion spans Nev's personal journey, his experiences as a father, insights into online relationships, and the evolving landscape of digital interactions.

Guest Introduction and Personal Background

Josh Peck kicks off the episode by introducing Nev Schulman, highlighting his prominence from the Catfish series. Nev shares anecdotes about his name change from Yaniv to Nev, reflecting on how introductions often catch him off guard:

[02:17] Nev Schulman: "Once in a while I'll be out somewhere and someone will introduce me or say hello, and they'll say, 'This is Yaniv,' like we went to high school together. But high school changed that to Neve."

Josh and Ben playfully discuss their own name origins, establishing a lighthearted tone for the conversation.

Life in New York and Cultural Insights

The trio delves into Nev's life in New York City, particularly his residence in Williamsburg. Nev provides a candid look into the Orthodox Jewish community's practices, including the use of sirens to signal the onset of Shabbat:

[05:06] Nev Schulman: "Every Friday, half an hour before sunset, it sounds like we're being bombed... it reminds me, which is nice. It is Shabbat."

Ben humorously quips about the perceived role of Jews in spreading measles within the community, to which Nev responds by addressing the anti-vaccination stance in certain Orthodox circles.

Fatherhood and Parenting Experiences

A significant portion of the episode centers on fatherhood. Nev shares his transition into being a parent, discussing the challenges and emotional journey:

[08:38] Nev Schulman: "Having had three kids, like the first six to nine months, you don't really know what to do. Your job is really just to take care of your wife and get her whatever she needs."

Josh reflects on his own experiences, emphasizing the importance of shared responsibilities in parenting:

[09:03] Josh Peck: "If you're down to clown in my style, we're good to go. With a baby, they have to be right."

Ben adds his perspective, highlighting the difficulties of soothing a baby and the deep connections (or lack thereof) initially felt toward his child.

Discussion on the WNBA and Caitlin Clark

The conversation shifts to sports, specifically addressing the treatment of WNBA star Caitlin Clark. The hosts express concern over the bullying she faces:

[15:38] Josh Peck: "Caitlin Clark is getting bullied. And I'm not okay with it."

Nev provides context, comparing the attention Clark receives to that of male athletes like LeBron James, suggesting that her success attracts undue negativity:

[18:03] Nev Schulman: "The WNBA is turning into the WWE whenever she's on the court or beating the shit out of."

Ben further elaborates on the dynamics within the league, attributing the mistreatment to jealousy over her prowess and endorsements.

Catfishing Segment with Nev Schulman

Nev delves into the origins and evolution of the term "catfish," sharing personal insights from his documentary work:

[20:44] Nev Schulman: "The origin of the term catfish comes from the documentary Catfish, which was about me..."

He recounts the story behind the documentary's title, emphasizing the unpredictable and sometimes deceptive nature of online relationships.

The hosts and Nev discuss various catfishing scenarios, highlighting both malicious intent and genuine connections that become complicated by deception.

Listener Stories and Advice

Josh introduces listener-submitted stories about catfishing, prompting Nev to offer expert advice on navigating and recognizing deceit in online relationships. They discuss the emotional complexities involved and the importance of maintaining safety and trust.

"What Are You Nuts?" Segment

In this light-hearted segment, Josh, Ben, and Nev share their pet peeves and humorous frustrations:

• Ben talks about the dangers of tourists misusing electric bikes in New York City, leading to accidents due to lack of experience.

• Josh recounts an awkward encounter where young fans overzealously greeted him at an airport, making him uncomfortable:

  [52:13] Josh Peck: "I was like, are you nuts? I looked at the guy, I said, that sign is too big."

• Nev expresses irritation over harsh lighting choices in homes, emphasizing the impact of lighting on personal comfort:

  [53:31] Nev Schulman: "If you walk into your house and you have a fluorescent bulb, it makes me immediately hate you."

Closing Remarks and Future Projects

As the episode nears its end, Nev shares his upcoming endeavors, including training for a triathlon with a friend who is blind. The hosts express their support and discuss potential sponsorships, demonstrating their commitment to Nev's causes.

Key Takeaways

• Authenticity in Relationships: Nev emphasizes the importance of genuine connections and the complexities introduced by online interactions.

• Parenting Challenges: Navigating fatherhood requires patience, support, and understanding the evolving dynamics within a family.

• Sports and Gender Dynamics: The treatment of female athletes like Caitlin Clark in professional sports reflects broader societal issues related to gender and success.

• Safety in the Digital Age: Recognizing and addressing deceptive online behaviors is crucial for maintaining personal safety and emotional well-being.

Notable Quotes

• Nev Schulman on Parenting:

  [08:38] Nev Schulman: "Sometimes it takes time to feel a connection with your child. Don't feel weird if it doesn't happen instantly."

• Josh Peck on Online Relationships:

  [31:01] Josh Peck: "If someone denies face timing you more than once, they're probably lying."

• Nev Schulman on Catfishing:

  [20:44] Nev Schulman: "We were so moved by that [sailors' story] that we called the documentary Catfish, just to highlight his beautiful description of her."

Conclusion

"Gone Catfishin' with Nev Schulman" offers listeners a blend of heartfelt discussions, personal anecdotes, and critical insights into modern relationships and societal issues. Through Nev's expertise and the hosts' engaging dialogue, the episode provides valuable perspectives on navigating the complexities of today's digital and personal landscapes.