Podcast Summary: Good Guys – Episode: Good Wives with Claudia Oshry and Paige O'Brien Peck

Release Date: May 1, 2025

In this engaging episode of the Good Guys podcast, hosts Josh Peck and Ben Soffer delve into various aspects of pregnancy, parenting, and personal anecdotes alongside their special guests, Claudia Autry and Paige O'Brien Peck. The conversation is rich with insights, humor, and heartfelt discussions, making it a valuable listen for expectant parents and fans alike.

1. Setting Up the Nursery and Baby Preparations (00:33 - 05:07)

Claudia Autry and Paige O'Brien Peck discuss their approaches to preparing for their new baby. Unlike many expectant parents who are inspired by elaborate TikTok nursery setups, Claudia emphasizes practicality and necessity.

Claudia Autry (01:40): “Have you just assembled? Yeah. And they also, like, they're just, like, the real necessities, the basics, like, nothing exciting or fun or, like, you know, designer.”

Claudia expresses her struggle with planning and feeling envious of more extravagant preparations seen online but remains committed to a functional setup.

Paige O'Brien (02:30): “I'm like, okay, the first couple of months. There's no rush actually, on getting a nursery done. It's just, like, nice to have.”

The hosts humorously acknowledge the challenges of organizing a nursery while balancing everyday life.

2. Pregnancy Health and Supplements (05:07 - 11:18)

A significant portion of the episode focuses on health during pregnancy, particularly the use of supplements. Ben and Claudia share their personal supplement routines, while Josh offers a playful critique.

Ben Soffer (08:00): “The way I love Dose, I've taken it every day for a week. I have the cleanest liver this side of the river...”

Claudia admits her increasing supplement intake and the challenges of managing her vitamin collection.

Claudia Autry (09:40): “How am I supposed to live like that? We are going to have a lot of new things coming in the home.”

Despite the clutter, both Claudia and Ben express enthusiasm for the benefits of their chosen supplements.

3. Managing Storage and Home Space (11:18 - 15:30)

Living in New York City versus a suburban home comes with its own set of storage challenges. Claudia and Ben contrast their experiences with space management, highlighting the differences between urban and suburban living.

Claudia Autry (11:13): “My sweeping is definitely heightened with the baby coming. But you haven't met me where I'm at.”

They discuss strategies for decluttering and organizing to accommodate the growing needs of their families.

4. Family and Sibling Relationships (15:30 - 22:56)

The conversation shifts to personal histories, focusing on being an only child and the dynamics of having siblings. Josh shares his feelings of loneliness growing up without siblings, while Claudia and Ben reflect on their own family structures.

Josh Peck (17:23): “It was deeply lonely, shattering.”

Claudia empathizes with those raising children with siblings, emphasizing the different experiences each family has.

5. Parenting Finances (22:56 - 35:58)

Claudia and Josh delve into the financial aspects of parenting, discussing the costs associated with raising children, from school donations to extracurricular activities.

Claudia Autry (21:59): “Max is in public school, but even his public school suggests a $3,000 donation a year for the school.”

They highlight the increasing expenses as children grow, providing a realistic view of the financial commitments involved in parenting.

6. Baby Naming Discussions (28:44 - 35:58)

A lighthearted segment where Claudia and Ben brainstorm potential names for their upcoming child. They consider names like "Gus" and "Gustav," debating the merits and pronunciations.

Ben Soffer (32:58): “What do you think of Gus Offer?”

The discussion underscores the significance of selecting a meaningful and purposeful name for their child.

7. Fun Pregnancy Facts and Health Tips (35:58 - 40:00)

Josh introduces a segment on interesting pregnancy facts, sparking discussions about fetal development and maternal health.

Josh Peck (34:38): “Did you know that babies can cry in the womb while they can't make any sound?”

Claudia and Paige share practical experiences related to these facts, such as dealing with uncomfortable sleeping positions and the benefits of acupuncture.

8. Social Media and Public Perception (40:00 - 63:36)

The hosts address their interactions on social media, particularly the reactions to their candid discussions about pregnancy and parenting.

Claudia Autry (45:08): “I stand with Katy Perry. That was kind of an inappropriate tweet on behalf of Wendy's like, account.”

They critique Wendy's response to Katy Perry's space trip and discuss the balance between humor and targeted hostility in brand interactions.

9. Personal Stories and Anecdotes (63:36 - 71:39)

Claudia and Ben share memorable moments from their personal lives, including experiences at summer camps and bachelor/bachelorette parties. These stories add a relatable and humorous touch to the episode.

Ben Soffer (54:03): “They almost died on my bachelor party. They're... they could have died.”

The hosts also discuss challenges like unexpected expenses during gatherings and the unpredictability of social events.

10. Moment of the Week: Gripes (64:15 - 65:55)

In the "Moment of the Week" segment, Paige shares her frustration with Josh's quirky fashion choices, leading to a playful exchange about outfit terminology.

Paige O'Brien (64:28): “What do you think of my top?”

The hosts laugh over the miscommunication, highlighting the everyday annoyances that come with shared lives.

11. Closing Remarks (71:00 - End)

As the episode wraps up, the hosts remind listeners to rate the podcast and share their thoughts. Claudia humorously addresses the constant questioning about her well-being during pregnancy, advocating for more genuine interactions.

Claudia Autry (68:19): “How am I doing? I'm tired, I'm sick, I'm sore, I'm exhausted...”

The episode concludes with a light-hearted exchange about nipples and breastfeeding, showcasing the hosts' ability to blend humor with honest conversations.

Notable Quotes

• Claudia Autry (01:40): “Have you just assembled? Yeah. And they also, like, they're just, like, the real necessities, the basics, like, nothing exciting or fun or, like, you know, designer.”

• Paige O'Brien (02:30): “I'm like, okay, the first couple of months. There's no rush actually, on getting a nursery done. It's just, like, nice to have.”

• Ben Soffer (08:00): “The way I love Dose, I've taken it every day for a week. I have the cleanest liver this side of the river...”

• Josh Peck (34:38): “Did you know that babies can cry in the womb while they can't make any sound?”

• Claudia Autry (45:08): “I stand with Katy Perry. That was kind of an inappropriate tweet on behalf of Wendy's like, account.”

Conclusion

This episode of the Good Guys podcast offers a blend of practical parenting advice, personal stories, and humorous exchanges. Claudia and Paige provide relatable insights into the challenges of pregnancy and parenting, while Josh and Ben add their unique perspectives and humor. Whether you're expecting a child, navigating family dynamics, or simply enjoying candid conversations, this episode delivers valuable content with warmth and wit.

For those interested in future episodes, tune in every Monday and Thursday to catch the latest discussions and stories from the Good Guys team.