Podcast Summary: Handsome Episode – "What Meal Handsome Would Be"

Podcast Information:

• Title: Handsome
• Hosts: Tig Notaro, Fortune Feimster, Mae Martin
• Description: "Handsome" is a comedic podcast where Tig, Fortune, and Mae tackle diverse questions from friends each week, sharing stories and humor along the way.
• Episode: Caleb Hearon asks what meal Handsome would be
• Release Date: June 3, 2025

1. Welcome and Casual Banter ([01:46] - [04:39])

The episode kicks off with the trio reuniting after Fortune Feimster's time in Atlanta filming a movie. They engage in light-hearted conversation about Fortune wearing a cozy hoodie provided by her performance in Roanoke, sparking jokes about the local lesbian community's reaction to her scheduling conflicts with Melissa Etheridge.

Notable Quote:

• Fortune Feimster ([03:05]): "I think I might have told May, but I happen to schedule my show on the same night as Melissa Etheridge. And, yeah, they were not happy that I divided the community."

2. Sharing Personal Experiences ([04:39] - [07:00])

The hosts delve into personal anecdotes, including Tig Notaro’s encounters before her shows and Mae Martin’s spontaneous knock-knock jokes. They humorously discuss the origins of their jokes and the nature of widely circulated "dad jokes" that lack clear attribution.

Notable Quote:

• Mae Martin ([05:54]): "In 1999, Joan Murray fell 14,500ft when her parachute didn't open during a skydive. God, guys. She landed on a pile of red ants..."

3. Discussion on Survival Stories and Myth Busting ([07:00] - [14:35])

The conversation shifts to bizarre survival stories, such as Joan Murray’s miraculous survival due to ant bites and other questionable rescues involving animals. Mae shares her skepticism about the authenticity of these tales, highlighting how viral stories on social media often blend fact with fiction.

Notable Quotes:

• Mae Martin ([10:10]): "In 1999, Joan Murray fell 14,500ft when her parachute didn't open during a skydive... The jolt saved her life."
• Tig Notaro ([12:40]): "I've never heard that. Nor have I heard the person being bitten by ants coming back to life."

4. Introduction to Caleb Hearon and His Question ([28:43] - [29:07])

Caleb Hearon, a comedian and podcast host, is introduced as the question asker for the episode. His question prompts the hosts to think creatively about their culinary alter egos.

Notable Quote:

• Mae Martin ([28:45]): "Caleb Heron is asking today's question. If you were to be any meal, what meal would you be and why?"

5. Hosts’ Responses to "What Meal Would You Be?" ([29:07] - [44:27])

Each host shares their unique take on the meal they embody:

• Mae Martin ([30:21] - [33:23]): Identifies with corn-based dishes, envisioning herself as "street corn named Desire." She relates corn’s versatility and bright energy to her personality layers.

  Notable Quote:

  • Mae Martin ([30:28]): "I'm gonna go with street corn named Desire."

• Fortune Feimster ([32:05] - [42:07]): Describes herself as a "progressive dinner," reflecting her multifaceted personality that evolves through different stages—appetizers, main course, and dessert—symbolizing connection and growth.

  Notable Quote:

  • Fortune Feimster ([40:10]): "I would love to be a progressive dinner."

• Tig Notaro ([33:27] - [44:27]): Chooses to be the "Last Supper," emphasizing the significance of meaningful gatherings and being central to conversations and relationships.

  Notable Quote:

  • Tig Notaro ([33:27]): "I think I would be the Last Supper."

6. Light-Hearted Interactions and Jokes ([44:27] - [55:56])

The hosts continue their playful banter, discussing their favorite meals, sharing knock-knock jokes, and reflecting on personal experiences with trivia and game shows like "Who Wants to Be a Millionaire?" Fortune reminisces about her challenging experience on "Celebrity Jeopardy," highlighting the pressures of live competition.

Notable Quote:

• Fortune Feimster ([56:28]): "I played celebrity Jeopardy. And it was one of the most nerve-wracking experiences of my life."

7. Concluding Remarks and Future Plans ([55:27] - [60:19])

As the episode wraps up, the hosts promote their upcoming projects and tours. Mae announces her music tour, Fortune shares her upcoming comedy shows, and Tig discusses the documentary "Come See Me in the Good Light" screening at the Tribeca Film Festival. They encourage listeners to stay connected through their websites and social media.

Notable Quote:

• Mae Martin ([58:15]): "I'm going on tour doing some music. June 10th I'm in San Francisco..."

8. Final Jokes and Farewell ([58:07] - [61:19])

In their final moments, the hosts attempt to exchange knock-knock jokes but humorously fail to nail them, reinforcing their playful dynamic. They sign off by reminding listeners about their contact information and social media handles.

Notable Quote:

• Fortune Feimster ([60:19]): "What a podcast."

Key Takeaways:

• Creativity in Responses: Each host’s unique perspective on the question showcases their individuality and humor.
• Dynamic Interaction: The chemistry between Tig, Fortune, and Mae is palpable, characterized by playful teasing and supportive camaraderie.
• Personal Storytelling: The episode blends personal anecdotes with broader discussions, making it relatable and engaging.
• Humor and Authenticity: Despite tackling whimsical questions, the hosts maintain an authentic and humorous approach, ensuring the content remains entertaining.

This episode of "Handsome" offers a delightful mix of humor, personal stories, and creative thinking, making it an enjoyable listen for both regular fans and newcomers alike.