Handsome Podcast - "Pretty Little Episode #35" Summary

Release Date: April 18, 2025

Hosts:

• Mae Martin
• Tig Notaro
• Fortune Feimster

Episode Overview

In Episode #35, titled "Pretty Little Episode," the Handsome hosts delve into personal anecdotes, heartfelt discussions, and unexpected moments of connection. The episode features engaging conversations about favorite love stories, nostalgic scents, and an unforgettable listener proposal that leaves both Mae and Tig pleasantly stunned.

1. Opening Banter and Daily Habits ([00:43] - [07:58])

The episode kicks off with Mae Martin and Tig Notaro sharing light-hearted dialogues about their daily routines and personal preferences.

• Apples and Nutrition:

  • Mae Martin discusses her apple consumption, mentioning her gym plans:
    "[01:05] Mae Martin: Yeah, I'm having. I had an apple. I'm gonna go to the gym after this."
  • Tig Notaro emphasizes his commitment to eating an apple a day, sharing his struggle with mealy apples:
    "[02:18] Tig Notaro: I can. If it's even slightly off. I mean, it's the mealy kind of apples, I really. I cannot do."

• Splashing Out:

  • The hosts explore the meaning of "splash out," with Mae seeking clarification and Tig humorously imagining grand gestures:
    "[05:34] Mae Martin: You have to splash out in life. You gotta treat yourself."
    "[05:44] Mae Martin: I have never heard that. That sounds maybe like a British thing. Really."

• Upcoming Events and Responsibilities:

  • Tig shares his busy schedule, including notarizing documents and preparing for the GLAAD Awards:
    "[06:43] Mae Martin: Whoa. So you have to go authorize that."
    "[07:38] Mae Martin: Oh, what's the award show?"
    "[07:40] Tig Notaro: It's not going to line up with when this comes out, but Stephanie and I were nominated for the movie. Am I okay at the GLAAD Awards?"

2. Listener Question: Favorite Love Stories ([10:23] - [17:20])

Carla from Columbus, Ohio, poses a heartfelt question: "What is your favorite love story either fictional or in real life?"

• Mae Martin's Response:

  • Mae expresses her admiration for Mae and Tig’s own love story, highlighting her deep connection after watching Tig's documentary:
    "[10:45] Mae Martin: Because. And because I'd watched your documentary before even meeting you guys, I just was very invested."

• Tig Notaro's Response:

  • Tig shares his admiration for the real-life love story of Jimmy and Rosalynn Carter, marveling at their 77-year marriage and unwavering dedication:
    "[11:01] Tig Notaro: I would say the love story that I love is Jimmy and Rosalynn Carter."
    "[12:04] Tig Notaro: And I just. I'm so envious of 77 years. I mean, these people, they both live to be, like, a hundred years old. That's so appealing to me."

• Mae's Additional Insights:

  • Mae mentions the Paul Newman and Joanne Woodward documentary, appreciating their enduring relationship despite ups and downs:
    "[12:38] Mae Martin: I watched the Paul Newman, Joanne Woodward documentary. That was pretty beautiful."

• Fictional Love Stories:

  • The hosts discuss the challenges of fictional love stories, referencing Buffy and Angel and Sid and Nancy:
    "[14:02] Mae Martin: Buffy is a vampire slayer, and angel is a vampire who has been cursed with a soul..."
    "[15:17] Tig Notaro: Yeah. Wow. And that's good. You like? That's your story that."

• Carla's Beautiful Proposal:

  • Carla shares her own love story, describing how she and her partner Molly reconnected after many years and plans to propose:
    "[10:42] Carla: ...We sat two seats away from each other in homeroom for all of high school and then took many, many years to find each other again at 45. So, Molly, when you hear, let me know if you would do me the honor of spending the rest of your life with me."
  • Mae and Tig react with enthusiasm and excitement:
    "[16:27] Tig Notaro: I can't wait for their wedding."
    "[16:49] Mae Martin: Yeah. I'll go."

3. Listener Question: Nostalgic Scents ([17:20] - [21:09])

Melody from Oklahoma City asks: "What is a smell that will transport you back to a time in your childhood or teenage years?"

• Tig Notaro's Response:

  • Tig nostalgically recalls the scent of Coppertone sunscreen lotion, evoking memories of Mississippi:
    "[17:39] Mae Martin: Really? What is it?"
    "[17:40] Tig Notaro: Coppertone sunscreen lotion."

• Mae Martin's Response:

  • Mae reminisces about her grandma's kitchen, highlighting the smell of cold sausages and baking peanut butter cookies:
    "[18:05] Mae Martin: The first thing that came to mind was my grandma in her kitchen, it smelled like sausages... the smell of peanut butter cookies baking and then cinnamon hearts."

• Melody's Response:

  • Melody reflects on the combined scents of fresh coffee grounds and cigarettes, tying them to family vacations and cherished moments:
    "[20:04] Melody: ...the combination of coffee and cigarette smoke reminds me of being a kid and watching my grandma and my aunt and my mom sit around and drink coffee and just talk about our plans for the day."

4. Heartwarming Conclusion and Future Plans ([21:09] - [22:58])

The episode winds down with Mae and Tig expressing their excitement over Carla’s upcoming proposal and potential wedding.

• Celebratory Hopes:

  • Mae encourages Tig to possibly officiate Carla and Molly's wedding, showcasing the supportive community:
    "[21:50] Tig Notaro: It really is. I'm sure. Molly and Carla. Or is it Carla and Molly?"
    "[22:02] Mae Martin: Same. I'll go."

• Call to Action:

  • The hosts invite listeners to submit their questions and proposals via Speakpipe, promoting community engagement:
    "[22:00] Tig Notaro: For other listeners, submit your questions and proposals to speakpipe.com/handsomepod that is speakpipe.com/handsomepod and please come and see us."

• Final Remarks:

  • Mae and Tig wrap up with information about upcoming shows and ways to stay connected:
    "[22:46] Tig Notaro: Yeah, let's grow this handsome community and check out tignotaro.com for all local and international shows. And until next time, keep it pretty."

Notable Quotes

• Mae Martin on Apples:
  "[02:18] Mae Martin: I'm having. I had an apple. I'm gonna go to the gym after this."

• Tig Notaro on Love Stories:
  "[12:04] Tig Notaro: And I just. I'm so envious of 77 years. I mean, these people, they both live to be, like, a hundred years old."

• Carla's Proposal:
  "[10:42] Carla: ...when you hear, let me know if you would do me the honor of spending the rest of your life with me."

• Mae on Nostalgic Scents:
  "[18:22] Mae Martin: ...the smell of peanut butter cookies baking and then cinnamon hearts."

Conclusion

"Pretty Little Episode #35" of the Handsome Podcast offers listeners a blend of humor, heartfelt storytelling, and meaningful connections. From discussing favorite love stories to sharing nostalgic memories tied to specific scents, Mae, Tig, and Fortune create an engaging and relatable atmosphere. The highlight of the episode is undoubtedly Carla’s heartfelt proposal, showcasing the podcast's ability to foster genuine community interactions. Whether you're a long-time listener or new to the Handsome community, this episode promises warmth, laughter, and moments that resonate deeply.

Stay Connected:

• Submit Questions & Proposals: speakpipe.com/handsomepod
• Follow Tig Notaro: tignotaro.com
• Social Media: Follow @handsomepod on your favorite platforms

Produced by: Thomas Willett
Contact: us@handsomepodmail.com

This summary aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the "Pretty Little Episode #35" without including advertisements and non-relevant sections, ensuring that newcomers can grasp the episode's essence seamlessly.