Handsome Podcast: Pretty Little Episode #86
Date: April 10, 2026
Hosts: Tig Notaro, Mae Martin, (Fortune Feimster is absent in this episode)
Theme: Life transitions, embracing change, celebrating queer icons, and whimsical listener questions
Episode Overview
In this “Pretty Little” mini-episode of Handsome, Tig Notaro and Mae Martin (sitting in for Fortune Feimster) catch up on tumultuous life changes, reminisce about their journeys, and tackle playful listener questions. From award season wrap-ups, personal milestones, and shifting work priorities, to building a dream Lilith Fair and pondering cosmic “life stats,” the hosts bring their signature humor and heartfelt honesty.
Key Discussion Points and Insights
1. Catching Up: Life Changes and Celebrations
[02:58-09:48]
2. Listener Question: Dream Lilith Fair Lineup
[10:23-16:38]
Question from Katie Walker, Milwaukee:
If you were to make your own Lilith Fair festival today, what artist would you choose and why?
-
Mae’s Dream Lineup:
- Indigo Girls
- Tracy Chapman
- The Pretenders
- Edie Brickell
- Dolly Parton (“she said she’d do the whole thing!”)
- Brandi Carlile, Sara Bareilles
-
Tig’s Dream Lineup:
- Dixie Chicks (Natalie Maines)
- Brandi Carlile
- Alanis Morissette (“She’ll probably want me to come up on stage and sing with her.” (Tig, 12:35))
- Kelly Clarkson
- Janelle Monáe
- Dolly Parton (for select cities)
- Celine Dion, Barbra Streisand, Cher (jokingly, for a “diva’s Lilith Fair”)
-
Katie’s Picks:
- Miley Cyrus, Olivia Rodrigo, Joan Jett, Britney Spears, Spice Girls
-
Notable Quote:
“That’s Lilith unfair.” (Mae, joking about Beyoncé being too busy for their lineup, 13:10)
-
Nostalgia and Inclusion:
- Salt-N-Pepa as a “nostalgia effect” addition (Tig).
- Mae named her Star Trek character after Joan Jett (“Commander Jet Reno”).
3. Listener Question: “If You Could Have a Lifetime Activity Stat?”
[16:44-24:39]
Question from Mercy, Richmond, VA:
If you could know exactly how many times you’ve done any one activity, what would you want to know?
4. Memorable Moments & Quotes
Important Timestamps & Segments
| Timestamp | Segment/Topic |
|-------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------|
| 02:58 | Banter about age, milestone birthdays, and “peaking” |
| 03:07-05:45 | Mae’s big week — Oscar, Star Trek, birthday |
| 04:26 | “We’re doing this together” — team spirit |
| 07:04-09:48 | Tig on work-life balance and spring break plans |
| 10:23-16:38 | Dream Lilith Fair festival draft (Katie’s question) |
| 16:44-24:39 | “Life statistics” question (Mercy’s question) |
| 21:14-23:01 | How social media use has changed |
| 23:53 | Hosts reflect on shifting priorities / Hollywood scene |
Conclusion
The episode offers an honest, funny, and relatable exploration of moving through bittersweet life changes with optimism, alongside trademark Handsome goofiness and insightful listener Q&As. Fans get a peek into the next chapters for Mae and Tig, fantasy music festivals, and the quirky stats we’d all love (or hate) to know about ourselves. Proves that sometimes, the best episodes are “pretty little” ones.
Noteworthy Quotes
- Mae: “Turning 55 and feeling healthy and lucky that I am alive and thriving and hanging up my spacesuit and opening the door to other possibilities is exciting.” (05:45)
- Tig: “I definitely feel like I’m heading into a new chapter of my life and some of those old doors are closing soon…and I feel good.” (08:17)
- Mae: “The fun of not knowing, like, what is it? Because you can turn a corner today or a year from now and a whole different world opens up.” (09:55)
- Tig (on Alanis Morissette): “She’ll probably want me to come up on stage and sing with her.” (12:35)
- Mae: “That’s Lilith unfair.” (13:10)
For next time:
Submit your own questions to speakpipe.com/handsomepodcast and catch the upcoming live show at the Wiltern in LA!