History Extra Podcast Summary: "A Nazi in Chile: Did an SS Commander Work for Pinochet?"
Release Date: April 3, 2025
Host: Rob Attar
Guest: Philippe Sands, Author and Lawyer
Introduction
In this compelling episode of the History Extra Podcast, hosted by Rob Attar and featuring renowned author and lawyer Philippe Sands, listeners are taken on a gripping journey that interweaves the tumultuous histories of Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet and Walter Ralph, a notorious SS commander implicated in the Holocaust. The episode delves deep into the intersection of law, mass murder, and international politics, uncovering a narrative that spans continents and decades.
Pinochet's Arrest in London
The episode opens with a discussion on the seismic event of Augusto Pinochet's arrest in London in 1998. Philippe Sands recounts the dramatic moment:
“...he had been arrested for murder and crimes against humanity and genocide... it was the first time that a former head of state had been arrested on international crimes.”
— Philippe Sands [01:14]
Sands emphasizes the unprecedented nature of this arrest, especially in the context of the newly adopted Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court.
Geographical and Political Context
Rob Attar prompts Sands to explain why Pinochet was arrested in London rather than his home country, Santiago. Sands provides a detailed background:
“In September 1973, Augusto Pinochet seized power in Chile and ruled for 17 years, committing numerous human rights violations... The principle of universal jurisdiction allowed courts in any country to exercise jurisdiction over these international crimes.”
— Philippe Sands [02:04]
He further elaborates on the role of Spanish Judge Baltazar Garzon, who issued the arrest warrant while Pinochet was in London for medical treatment.
Philippe Sands' Personal Involvement
Sands shares his personal connection to the case and the moral dilemma he faced:
“...my wife said, will you do it? ... she said, okay, well, you can do it if you want to do it, but if you do it, I will divorce you.”
— Philippe Sands [05:05]
Adhering to the cab rank principle, Sands initially agreed to represent Pinochet but ultimately declined after a public stance against immunity, citing his wife's concerns rooted in their shared family history with Spanish Civil War refugees.
Legal Proceedings and Immune Debate
The conversation shifts to the legal intricacies surrounding Pinochet's immunity as a former head of state. Sands describes the groundbreaking nature of the case:
“...there was no precedent, there was no example of it having come up before.”
— Philippe Sands [09:49]
He highlights the House of Lords' deliberations and the eventual decision that Pinochet was not entitled to immunity, a historic judgment that set a significant legal precedent.
Walter Ralph: From SS Commander to Chilean Canery Manager
The narrative takes a darker turn as Sands introduces Walter Ralph, linking his past as an SS commander to his post-war life in Chile:
“Walter Ralph operated mobile gas vans used in Nazi-occupied Europe to eliminate groups of up to 50 people... He fled to Chile, where he became the manager of a king crab cannery.”
— Philippe Sands [19:33]
Sands details Ralph's attempted extradition to West Germany, thwarted by Chile's statute of limitations, resulting in Ralph's impunity.
Exploring 38 Laundress Street and Repression in Chile
Central to the episode is the exploration of 38 Laundress Street, the former Socialist Party headquarters turned torture center under Pinochet's regime:
“...it was a torture center. It was a place of mass murder. It was a place of industrial scale paedophilia.”
— Philippe Sands [28:54]
Sands recounts his harrowing visit to Colonia Dignidad, a site of horrific abuses, and its transformation into a modern holiday resort, highlighting the lingering trauma and lack of closure surrounding these dark chapters.
The Quest for Truth and Justice
Sands explains his relentless pursuit to uncover any connections between Ralph and Pinochet:
“There were too many people who said to me, I saw him or I heard him... I needed to get to the heart of those claims.”
— Philippe Sands [33:03]
His investigations reveal unsettling truths about the interplay between former Nazis and Chile's oppressive regime, emphasizing the challenges of achieving justice decades after the crimes.
Immunity vs. Impunity: Legal and Moral Implications
A significant portion of the discussion centers on the concepts of immunity and impunity:
“Immunity connotes a sort of freedom from being subjected to prosecution, and impunity connotes a total absence of justice.”
— Philippe Sands [40:04]
Sands draws parallels between the Pinochet case and contemporary legal issues, such as the U.S. Supreme Court's stance on presidential immunity, underscoring the ongoing relevance of these legal debates.
Notable Quotes and Insights
-
Philippe Sands on Legal Precedents:
“...this was going to set a precedent at a time when the world was changing and when the rules of law were changing.”
— Philippe Sands [12:06] -
On the Complexity of Pinochet's Supporters:
“Pinochet continued to have many supporters in Chile, and he had supporters in Britain and in Spain... it was very complex and very difficult.”
— Philippe Sands [10:42] -
On Trusting Instincts in Investigation:
“...if you really sense there's something there, you've just got to keep going.”
— Philippe Sands [33:16]
Conclusion
This episode of the History Extra Podcast masterfully intertwines personal narratives with historical events, shedding light on the intricate web of international law, human rights abuses, and the quest for justice. Philippe Sands' in-depth exploration of Augusto Pinochet's arrest and Walter Ralph's evasion of justice serves as a poignant reminder of the complexities inherent in prosecuting international crimes and the enduring struggle against impunity.
Listeners are left to ponder the fine line between immunity and impunity, and the moral responsibilities of nations and individuals in the face of historical atrocities.
For more insightful historical discussions and stories, subscribe to History Extra and explore their extensive library of podcasts and resources.