History Extra Podcast Summary: "Power & Terror: A History of the Nuclear Age"

Host: Matt Elton
Guest: Frank Close, Professor Emeritus of Theoretical Physics at Exeter College, Oxford
Release Date: July 27, 2025

Introduction

In the episode titled "Power & Terror: A History of the Nuclear Age," Matt Elton engages in an illuminating conversation with esteemed physicist Frank Close. They traverse the intricate journey from the late 19th-century scientific discoveries to the profound and often terrifying impact of nuclear energy and weaponry during and after the Second World War. The discussion delves deep into the confluence of scientific innovation, personal narratives, and geopolitical forces that sculpted the nuclear age.

The Three Industrial Revolutions

Frank Close begins by elucidating the concept of three distinct industrial revolutions, a framework not widely appreciated:

1. First Industrial Revolution (Steam Power):
   "The first industrial revolution involved steam power." [01:38]

2. Second Industrial Revolution (Electromagnetic):
   Focused on electricity and magnetism, propelled by Michael Faraday's work, leading to the electrical revolution that powered innovations like the dynamo.

3. Third Industrial Revolution (Atomic/Nuclear):
   "The discovery... that atoms have a deep inner structure... that there's a vast amount of energy locked in there." [01:38]
   This revolution pivots on understanding atomic nuclei and harnessing their energy, laying the groundwork for both nuclear power and weapons.

Early Discoveries and the Birth of Atomic Theory

The late 19th and early 20th centuries were rife with pivotal discoveries:

• William Crookes and Cathode Rays:
  Investigations into electricity revealed "strange phenomena... glowing in the dark," initially mistaken for supernatural ectoplasm. [04:41]

• Wilhelm Röntgen and X-Rays:
  Accidentally discovered X-rays in 1895, a form of radiation capable of passing through matter, "casting shadows of broken bones." [04:41]

• Henri Becquerel and Radioactivity:
  In 1896, Becquerel discovered that uranium salts emit radiation spontaneously, "radiating energy for millions, even billions of years without changing." [03:17]
  This contradicted established thermodynamic principles, hinting at energy trapped within atoms.

Pioneering Scientists and Their Contributions

Frank Close highlights the monumental contributions of key figures:

• J.J. Thomson:
  "Discovered the electron... established that electrons are constituents of atoms." [10:03]
  Revealed that atoms are not indivisible, containing electrons that carry negative charges, necessitating a balancing positive charge within the nucleus.

• Ernest Rutherford:
  "Discovered protons... and later, neutrons." [13:40]
  Identified the atomic nucleus as a compact center of positive charge and mass, fundamentally altering the atomic model.

• Marie and Pierre Curie:
  Pioneered research in radioactivity, coining the term and expanding its understanding beyond uranium to other elements like polonium and radium.

The Discovery of Nuclear Fission

A pivotal breakthrough occurred in 1938:

• Otto Hahn and Fritz Strassmann:
  Bombarding uranium with neutrons led to the unexpected production of barium, an anomaly that they couldn't initially explain. [17:50]

• Lise Meitner and Otto Frisch:
  Escaping Nazi Germany, Meitner and her nephew Frisch interpreted Hahn and Strassmann's findings as nuclear fission.
  "The amount of energy that would be released was vast." [29:05]
  They realized that splitting the uranium nucleus releases enormous energy, a discovery that would pave the way for nuclear weapons.

Notable Insight:
Frank Close emphasizes,
"Only in 1938 finally getting to what's going on, namely the discovery of nuclear fission, which, if..." [28:56]

The Road to the Atomic Bomb

The realization that a chain reaction was possible led to the urgent development of nuclear weapons:

• Chain Reaction Concept:
  "One neutron comes in, splits the uranium, liberates two neutrons, which hit two more, and so on." [34:55]
  This theory suggested the potential for an exponentially increasing release of energy.

• Frisch and Peierls' Calculations:
  Determined that "the size of a grapefruit of uranium 235... would have an explosive power equivalent to a thousand tons of dynamite." [34:55]

• Tube Alloys Project:
  The UK’s secret initiative to develop atomic weapons, which later merged with the US-led Manhattan Project after the Blitz’s threat became apparent.

• The Manhattan Project and Trinity Test:
  "The moment when the atomic age probably really began." [44:52]
  The successful detonation of the first atomic bomb demonstrated the unprecedented power of nuclear weaponry.

Ethical Reflections and Historical Context

Frank Close reflects on the human and ethical dimensions:

• Young Scientists:
  "The average age of the scientists involved was about 25." [44:52]
  Many were young graduate students and postdocs, including future Nobel laureates.

• Motivations Driven by War:
  The dire circumstances of WWII galvanized scientists to develop weapons to prevent Nazi dominance.
  "Their goal was to get an atomic bomb before the Nazis did." [44:52]

• Frank Close's Concluding Thoughts:
  "The impetus of the war... was the biggest campus of brain power at Los Alamos." [46:30]
  He underscores how the necessity born from fear and imminent threats accelerated scientific advancements that might otherwise have taken longer, potentially favoring nuclear power over weaponry.

Key Quote:
"If it hadn't been for the fear of fascism, nuclear power rather than nuclear weapons would have led the way." [46:30]

Final Thoughts

Throughout the episode, Frank Close weaves a narrative that intertwines scientific discovery with the tumultuous socio-political landscape of the early 20th century. By highlighting both the technical milestones and the personal stories of the scientists involved, the discussion provides a comprehensive understanding of how the nuclear age was born out of a complex interplay of knowledge, necessity, and historical circumstance.

Recommended Further Reading:
Frank Close's book, "Destroyer of the Deep History of The Nuclear Age, 1895-1965," published by Alan Lane, offers an in-depth exploration of these themes.

Produced by: The team behind BBC History Magazine
Subscribe: HistoryExtra.com