Sam Adams Brews Rebellion in Boston Harbor

Summary

HISTORY This Week

Episode: Sam Adams Brews Rebellion in Boston Harbor

Release Date: December 15, 2025
Host: Sally Helm
Guest: Stacy Schiff (biographer, author of "The Revolutionary: Samuel Adams")

---

Episode Overview

This episode delves into the pivotal and carefully orchestrated Boston Tea Party of December 16, 1773, shining a spotlight on Samuel Adams, a founding father whose behind-the-scenes brilliance engineered protest and revolution, yet left behind little trace of his direct involvement. Biographer Stacy Schiff joins host Sally Helm to explore Adams’s life, his deep grievances with British authority, his mastery of propaganda and organization, and how his tactics during the Tea Party and beyond catalyzed the colonial push for independence—all while ensuring he remained shadowy and low-profile.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Setting the Scene: The Boston Tea Party

• Recap of Events (01:46–04:17)
  • The Tea Party was not a chaotic riot but a precisely planned act of protest.
  • Men, disguised as Native Americans, swiftly and silently dumped 342 chests of tea into Boston Harbor in opposition to the British tea tax.
  • Despite the secrecy, clear indications point to Samuel Adams’s leadership.
  • Notable Quote:
    • “Every account of the Boston Tea Party is in the passive voice. The tea simply seems to have sailed overboard of its own volition. That's really Adams at his best.”
      —Stacy Schiff, (04:17)

2. Who Was Samuel Adams?

• Adams’s Early Years and Origins of His Grievances (06:25–12:07)

  • Raised in affluent Boston, educated at Harvard, but not a prodigy like other founders.
  • Family’s financial ruin at the hands of British authorities (the Land Bank episode) left a lasting mark—feeding Adams’s resentment toward Parliament's overreach and arbitrary rule.
  • Schiff’s own journey: “I was...a little bit embarrassed to realize that he had a cameo in my book on Benjamin Franklin and I knew next to nothing about him...and I'm from Adams, Massachusetts, which is named for Samuel Adams.” (08:13)

• Finding His Voice: Prose and Purpose (08:36–14:12)

  • Adams’s writing was “fiery,” “rousing,” and became influential in uniting colonies and articulating colonial grievances.
    • “All men have a right to remain in a state of nature as long as they please...in case of intolerable oppression...to leave the society they belong to and enter into another.” —Samuel Adams, letter quoted (08:36)
  • Schiff notes Adams’s dual character: “In a way...he’s several people at once” (13:26) — genteel and charming in social life; sharp-elbowed and confrontational in politics.

3. America’s Tensions — Adams vs. Hutchinson

• Introducing Thomas Hutchinson (14:40–16:28)

  • Adams's opposite number: conservative, boring (to Schiff), loyal to the Crown.
  • Both from similar backgrounds, but divergent values and politics.

• British Rule and Colonial Resistance (18:45–21:08)

  • Britons saw themselves as “caring parents” to the colonies, but needed revenue.
  • Taxes—including the infamous Stamp Act—provoke wide resentment, pushing more colonists toward resistance.
  • Hutchinson himself sees the core problem: “Yes, it is. Taxation without representation. This is overreach on the part of the British administration.” (20:01)

4. Escalation: From Tax Protests to Rebellion

• Boston’s Occupation and Adams’s Rise as Propagandist (23:17–25:20)

  • British military occupation creates tension: “There's a soldier in Boston for every Boston family.” (23:28)
  • Adams starts a kind of “news service,” spreading lurid, possibly exaggerated stories of British soldier abuses to unite colonies and stir outrage.
    • “He is a master propagandist...he seems to be able to pull these ambient ideas out of the air and crystallize them.” (24:43)
    • “Colonists have as much power in Parliament as they did to choose the emperor of China, or...London knew about as much about them as they did about the moon.” (25:12)

• The Boston Massacre and Showdown (25:27–27:52)

  • The massacre galvanizes colonial fury. Adams confronts Hutchinson: “If the troops are not immediately evacuated, there will be blood in the streets and that Hutchinson should consider his own life to be in danger.” (27:09)
  • Hutchinson capitulates, removing all regiments. Adams scores a public victory.

5. Secret Organization & The Path to the Tea Party

• Committees of Correspondence: Revolutionary Network (28:07–29:17)
  • Adams’s quiet but vital work creating intercolonial communication networks under an innocuous name:
    • “It's like when you're a kid and you have a diary and you call it, you know, my book instead of my secret diary...” (28:39)
    • Impact: “He just wires the continent. It's like an electrical network that he's formed.” (29:11)

6. The Tea Tax and Adams’s Calculated Response

• The Tea Act and British Miscalculation (29:40–30:42)

  • Britain tries to undercut colonial smuggling by dumping cheap, taxed tea in Boston.
  • Adams—ever distrustful of “private virtue”—insists the tea must be kept from ever reaching the market to prevent colonial temptation and ensure unity.
    • Notable moment: Adams tells ship owner Francis Roach he faces a “howling political tempest” (31:10).
  • Governor Hutchinson refuses to let the tea ships leave; tension builds.

• The Night of the Tea Party (32:06–33:43)

  • 6,000 Bostonians meet; Adams gives a signal that “nothing more can be done to save the country.” The disguised men slip out for the harbor.
    • “There does seem to be this almost jeering at the British. You know, you think we're a bunch of savages. We're going to show you.” (32:28)
  • Importantly, Adams remains at the meetinghouse, creating a public alibi.
    • “If he didn’t mastermind the thing, he was at least complicit in the masterminding.” (34:37)
    • “It is, in fact...a perfect crime in the sense that there is no perpetrator.” (34:37)
  • Aftermath: No chaos; quiet celebration.

7. Impact and Legacy

• Boston’s ‘Martyrdom’ and The Road to Revolution (35:13–35:40)

  • Parliament retaliates by closing Boston’s port—galvanizing colonial solidarity, thanks to the “electrical grid” Adams already established.
    • “After the Tea Party, the current just begins to run so much more quickly from north to south.” (35:34)
  • Events accelerate: The First Continental Congress, then war.

• Why Adams Was Forgotten (36:09–37:38)

  • Adams intentionally erased his tracks: destroyed correspondence, rejected vanity.
    • “His entire methodology is based on the no fingerprints school. So he really does need to remove himself from the scene.” (36:09)
    • John Adams wrote of watching cousin Samuel burn his papers.
    • Paul Revere’s famous ride was to warn Samuel Adams and John Hancock, the most wanted men in Massachusetts, of their impending arrest. (37:08–37:38)

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Leadership & Secrecy:

  • “Every account of the Boston Tea Party is in the passive voice. The T simply seems to have sailed overboard of its own volition. That's really Adams at his best.”
    — Stacy Schiff, (04:17)

• On Propaganda & Influence:

  • “He is a master propagandist...He seems to be able to pull these ambient ideas out of the air and crystallize them.”
    — Stacy Schiff, (24:43)

• On the Principle vs. the Perpetrators:

  • “If he didn’t mastermind the thing, he was at least complicit in the masterminding...A perfect crime in the sense that there is no perpetrator. So it is very Adams-like in the sense that the principles rise above the perpetrators.”
    — Stacy Schiff, (34:37)

• On Discretion and Historical Amnesia:

  • “His entire methodology is based on the no fingerprints school. So he really does need to remove himself from the scene.”
    — Stacy Schiff, (36:09)
  • “Paul Revere...is riding to warn John Hancock and Samuel Adams that as the two most wanted men in Massachusetts, they are about to be arrested for treason.”
    — Stacy Schiff, (37:08)

---

Timestamps & Segment Guide

• 01:46–04:17: Dramatic retelling of the Boston Tea Party; role of Samuel Adams in orchestrating secrecy.
• 06:25–14:12: Adams's background, family grievances, and development as a revolutionary thinker and writer.
• 14:40–16:28: Introduction to Thomas Hutchinson; Adams's adversary.
• 18:45–21:08: British colonial policy, taxation without representation, and early resistance.
• 23:17–25:20: British occupation; Adams’s use of propaganda in uniting colonies.
• 25:27–27:52: The Boston Massacre; Adams’s confrontation with Hutchinson and the evacuation of British troops.
• 28:07–29:17: Formation and importance of Committees of Correspondence.
• 29:40–30:42: The Tea Act and why cheap tea was a colonial crisis.
• 32:06–33:43: The night of the Boston Tea Party; Adams’s indirect role.
• 34:15–35:40: Fallout: British reprisal, colonial unity, and revolutionary momentum.
• 36:09–37:38: Why Samuel Adams is a “forgotten founder”; destruction of evidence and deliberate modesty.

---

Summary

This episode artfully pulls Samuel Adams out of the historical shadows and presents him as a master strategist, propagandist, and organizer—whose fingerprints are everywhere and nowhere at the dawn of American independence. With insights from historian Stacy Schiff and evocative storytelling, listeners learn how grievances, careful networking, and clandestine genius created explosive consequences in Boston, ultimately pulling a reluctant continent into open revolution. Adams’s deliberate anonymity ensured his plans succeeded—and guaranteed his own later obscurity as one of America's foundational figures.

Transcript

[Sally Helm]

Hello History this Week listeners. It's Sally here. As we are heading to the end of the year, I just wanted to thank you all for sticking with us these last five years. We really do love bringing these stories to you every week and we cannot wait to keep it going in 2026. If you like what you have been hearing, you can always support our work by subscribing to History this Week. Plus exclusively on Apple Podcasts. You can also get email notifications and bonus content by signing [e-mail] and of course you can follow us on Instagram or Facebook. Thank you so much for listening. We could not make this show without you.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Hey, Ryan Reynolds here wishing you a very happy half off holiday because right now Mint Mobile is offering you the gift of 50% off unlimited. To be clear, that's half half price, not half the service. Mint is still premium unlimited wireless for a great price. So that means a half day.

[Natural Cycles Advertiser]

Yeah.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Give it a [e-mail] Switch upfront payment.

[Stacy Schiff]

Of $45 for 3 month plan equivalent to 15 per month required new customer offer for first 3 months only. Speed slow hatch 35 gigabytes of networks busy taxes and fees extra.

[Blue Apron Advertiser]

See mintmobile.com why does every recipe I try need 18 ingredients, including a jar of something paste I'll never use again but will sit in my fridge for nine months? I just want dinner and then in the oven fast. That's why I love Blue Apron's new one Pan, Assemble and Bake meals. They send you fresh ingredients that are already chopped. All you do is put it all together and bake. That's it. No chopping, no weird leftovers. Just delicious, easy to make meals. Get 20% off your first two orders with code APRON20. Terms and conditions apply. Visit blueapron.com terms for more.

[Stacy Schiff]

The History Channel Original Podcast.

[Sally Helm]

History this week December 16, 1773 Sally I'm Sally Helm. The men had just a few hours notice. It'll happen tonight. Gather your disguises, gather your resolve. Wait for the signal to strike. Three British ships are anchored in Boston harbor, unable to unload their store of tea because the American colonists have been protesting a tariff on that tea, negotiating to keep the British from importing more of it. As of today, those negotiations have failed. Nothing to do now, the colonists think, but throw that tea into the harbor. Sounds disorderly, even chaotic, but it all unfolds with great precision and secrecy. On this night, December 16th, there's a big gathering at Boston's Old South Meeting House. American Colonial leaders talking about this tariff business. And at the appointed moment, a group of men rise from their pews in the meeting house. They slip into the streets, walking together towards Griffin's Wharf. They've disguised themselves as Native Americans with headdresses and tomahawks. When they arrive at the harbor, they move swiftly, take over the ships, jump down into the holds, attach ropes to chests of tea, then hoist those chests onto the decks where they use their tomahawks to chop them open and then dump the tea into the water. One of the participants will recall years later, we were merry in an undertone at the idea of making so large a cup of tea for the fishes. But we used not more words than absolutely necessary. I never worked harder in my life. When it's over, the men scatter without revealing their identities. It's all so well planned that it's clear they must have been acting under some kind of leadership. We don't know for sure who made this happen, but we have an idea. A patriot in his 50s named Samuel Adams. Because the secrecy itself, the precise coordination, biographer Stacy Schiff says that has Samuel Adams written all over it.

[Stacy Schiff]

Every account of the Boston Tea Party is in the passive voice. The T simply seems to have sailed overboard of its own volition. That's really Adams at his best.

[Sally Helm]

Today, a forgotten founding father lays the groundwork for revolution. How did a major American rebel manage to maintain such a low profile, which carries on to this day? And how did the Boston Tea Party help tip the colonies towards war?

[Ryan Reynolds]

Hey, Ryan Reynolds here wishing you a very happy half off holiday because right now Mint Mobile is offering you the gift of 50% off unlimited.

[Stacy Schiff]

To.

[Ryan Reynolds]

To be clear, that's half price, not half the service. Mint is still premium unlimited wireless for a great price. So that means a half day. Yeah, give it a [e-mail] Switch upfront.

[Stacy Schiff]

Payment of $45 for three month plan equivalent to $15 per month required new customer offer for first three months only.

[Sally Helm]

Speed slow.

[Stacy Schiff]

135 gigabytes of network fizzy. Taxes and fees extra.

[Von Miller]

See mint mobile.com what's up world is Von Miller, Super Bowl MVP, chicken farmer and now host of Free Range. This is a show where I go off the field and off the script. We're talking what's hot in music, film, trending news and everything blowing up your feed. If you love football, you'll feel at home. But if you're here for the vibes, the Internet deep dives, the conversation. This is your podcast. Join me every Wednesday. Follow and listen to Free Range with me, Vaughn Miller everywhere you get your podcast.

[Lemonade Pet Insurance Advertiser]

If you're an experienced pet owner, you already know that having a pet is 25% belly rubs, 25% yelling drop it. And 50% groaning at the bill from every pet visit. Which is why Lemonade Pet Insurance is tailor made for your pet and can save you up to 90% on vet bills. It can help cover checkups, emergencies, diagnostics, basically all the stuff that makes your bank account get nervous. Claims are filed super easily through the Lemonade app and half get settled instantly. Get a'@lemonade.com pet and they'll help cover the vet bill for whatever your pet swallowed after you yelled drop it.

[Sally Helm]

It's 1732, 41 years before the Tea Party Boston, Massachusetts is an orderly city of nearly 15,000 people, a very pleasant place to be. Samuel Adams is growing up there with his family. They live in a nice home with an orchard and an observatory and views of the harbor. At this time, there are no shouted threats in the air, no sounds of weapons discharging and bodies hitting the cobblestones. There's none of that. Yet. The only cries in the air come from seagulls. Visiting Englishmen remark on the quality of the food, on the spare sublimity of the architecture, on the overall air of sophistication. To the British, all this is surprising.

[Stacy Schiff]

I think probably the best assessment is that of a British officer who says that everything about it is lovely. He just wished the people would be more so.

[Sally Helm]

That's Stacey Schiff. Her biography of Samuel Adams describes the Boston of his youth and the tensions between the colonists and the British that were even then pushing their way toward the surface.

[Stacy Schiff]

It's growing pains, really. No one who's ever studied adolescence or lived with an adolescent would fail to recognize these symptoms.

[Sally Helm]

But Adams boyhood is seemingly calm. His parents are raising him to one day live the quiet life of an educated elite. Before we say any more about Adams, this forgotten founding father, let's get a few things straight. Samuel Adams is not John Adams, the second president of the United States. That is Samuel's second cousin. Samuel Adams is, however, the namesake of the popular modern beer, Schiff says. That is in fact how his name has come down to most people until recently. Even she who's studied this period couldn't have told you much about him.

[Stacy Schiff]

At a certain point. I was, I think, a little bit embarrassed to realize that he had a cameo in my book on Benjamin Franklin and I knew next to nothing about him. And that was particularly galling Because I'm from Adams, Massachusetts, which is named for Samuel Adams.

[Sally Helm]

So Schiff did a deep research dive to uncover who Adams was. And the first thing that struck her was his fiery prose lines.

[Spot Pet Insurance CEO]

Like all men have a right to remain in a state of nature as long as they please, and in case of intolerable oppression, civil or religious, to leave the society they belong to and enter into another.

[Stacy Schiff]

And the more I read around, the letters are very rousing stuff. There are lots of anthems to American liberty. They're extremely interesting, and I kind of just fell hook, line and sinker.

[Sally Helm]

It's clear to Schiff that in the years leading up to the American Revolution, Samuel Adams is right at the center of things.

[Stacy Schiff]

He helps to unite the colonies over those years, and he is utterly instrumental in articulating American grievances and in basically making himself extremely unloved by crown officers in Massachusetts, Massachusetts and throughout the colonies. He is pretty much at the forefront of things until the Revolution and then falls off the radar as he remains very much to this day.

[Sally Helm]

But strikingly, that rebellious Adams doesn't emerge until middle age. He doesn't make agitation his career until he's in his 40s. The conflict between Britain and its American colonies galvanizes him, focuses his energies and his mind, partly because he believes in the principle of liberty. But that's only part of his motivation.

[Spot Pet Insurance CEO]

He also writes, the colonists have been branded with the odious name of traitors and rebels only for complaining of their grievances.

[Sally Helm]

That's the other part. Samuel Adams has grievances, and they likely go way back to the time in 1740 when Adams was 18 and the British, appointed governor of Massachusetts, mucked with his family's financial affairs. Back then, the British are keeping a tight hold on trade with the colonies. They want to make sure that more gold and silver flow into royal coffers than come out of them. That leaves the colonies low on cash. So Adams father and other prominent men come up with a plan. They want to turn something that they have in large amounts, land, into something that they cash.

[Stacy Schiff]

So a group of men get together, including Samuel Adams father, and they found something called the Land bank, which in simplest terms is just a bank where notes are secured by their land holdings.

[Sally Helm]

Adams father is a believer. He pours his fortune into the project and the Land bank takes off. It works well. It's popular with colonists, but upsetting to a powerful group of merchants. Those merchants have political sway.

[Stacy Schiff]

And so the governor of Massachusetts writes to Parliament, asks them to shut down the Land bank, which they do. And in the process of shutting down this venture, they basically bankrupt Samuel Adams's father because he had invested so heavily in the bank.

[Sally Helm]

The young Samuel Adams sees that his father is ruined.

[Stacy Schiff]

So you have this unusual situation where you have an organic colonial effort that is utterly squashed out of the blue by this bolt from London.

[Sally Helm]

Remember Samuel Adams's picturesque family home, the one with the orchards? The British authorities move to seize it. Samuel will fight them off for years, but he still has to sell parts of the family estate to pay the bills.

[Stacy Schiff]

And, you know, you could see how that could potentially bring someone around to the ideas that they're being dealt with arbitrarily and that there seems to be parliamentary overreach.

[Sally Helm]

Resentment festers in Addams and in the colonies at large. They're both struggling to find their role in the world. It takes Addams a while. For much of his young adulthood, he's just knocking around, not sure what to do with himself.

[Stacy Schiff]

The astonishing thing is that he never manages a career period, which in early America, early New England in particular, was just absolutely singular.

[Sally Helm]

For perspective, think of some of the other Founding fathers. They glimmered with ability from the very start. Washington with his leadership skills and physical courage. Franklin with his entrepreneurial savvy. Madison, philosophical genius. And now consider Samuel Adams, a guy who graduated from Harvard, yes, but who, Schiff says, spent years cycling through jobs that didn't add up to much. He fails at accounting, then becomes a clerk helping vendors at crowded markets. After that, he's a tax collector, not a very good one. He can't muster much enthusiasm for collecting money for the British crown. Painted portraits usually show him later in life, and he looks average. His plain coat, his serious expression, even his hair length are pretty typical of the styles of the day. But Schiff points out that Samuel Adams wasn't just one thing.

[Stacy Schiff]

In a way, that is very true. I think of many of us, he's several people at once. So from John Adams descriptions in particular, you get a sense of an immensely affable, decorous, somewhat formal man who's very charming and very easygoing, who entertains in great simplicity at his home, but who.

[Sally Helm]

Was just a genteel individual, the model son of an upper class Boston family. But other sources paint a different Adams.

[Stacy Schiff]

You get the sense that he's sharp, elbowed and brawling, and he's extremely eager to mix it up and doesn't ever hesitate really to kind of upset the apple cart. He's equally at ease on the elite of Boston as he is in the streets of Boston.

[Sally Helm]

In 1748, Samuel Adams launches a newspaper with friends. It's called the Independent Advertiser. And this is when he begins to find his calling. He writes editorials lashing out at the British and articulating an early version of America's democratic ideals.

[Spot Pet Insurance CEO]

There is nothing so fretting and vexatious, nothing so justly terrible to tyrants as a free press.

[Sally Helm]

Adams's writing brings him notice, a lot of it. And soon his objections to British rule will focus in on one Thomas Hutchinson. Hutchinson will become Adams nemesis. He's the kind of high born gentleman who has his London tailor send him rust colored coats and lace. He's elected to the Massachusetts House of Representatives by the age of 26, then rises to become the lieutenant governor of Massachusetts. He works for the British, but he was born in Boston.

[Stacy Schiff]

He is a very decent, very sober, very modest, very diligent man. Unlike Adams, he was making a fortune even while he was still at Harvard.

[Sally Helm]

What would Hutchinson have been like to be in a room with?

[Stacy Schiff]

This may be unfair of me. I think he would be terribly boring. And I'm perhaps basing that on his history of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, which is not exactly an exciting book.

[Sally Helm]

Hutchinson wrote that book with an eye towards comprehensiveness. It has a passage about a group of settlers debating at length whether to build their cottages on this side of the river or the other side of the river. Hutchinson is as boring a writer as Adams is fiery. But in other ways the men are similar, starting with their upbringing.

[Stacy Schiff]

Entirely the same world, entirely the same education.

[Sally Helm]

And now, like Adams, Hutchinson is a man of strong conviction.

[Stacy Schiff]

Duty was immensely important to him. He would say that he lay awake for nights on end in the colonies, hoping that he had properly done his duty to the king.

[Sally Helm]

But on questions of politics, the two men are diametrically opposed.

[Stacy Schiff]

They have utterly distinct views of how colonial life should be regulated.

[Sally Helm]

Samuel Adams and Thomas Hutchinson are on a collision, as are the American colonies and Great Britain.

[Natural Cycles Advertiser]

Meet Natural Cycles, the only FDA cleared and CE marked birth control app that's built around your body. The Natural Cycles app pinpoints your fertile days by tracking shifts in your temperature so you can plan or prevent pregnancy naturally. It's easy to use. Simply take your temperature in the morning with our free Bluetooth thermometer included with our annual plan, or sync with your Oura ring or apple watch. The app analyzes your data and tells you daily whether it's a fertile or non fertile day. Natural cycles is 93% effective with typical use and 98% effective with perfect use. But beyond effective birth control, the app helps you understand your body and cycle better than ever. And unlike some period tracking apps, Natural Cycles provides an advanced data protection program to keep your information private and secure. Ready to go hormone free? Sign up for the Natural Cycles annual plan and get a free Bluetooth thermometer plus 15% off your subscription with the code [e-mail] Holiday PSA from DSW this.

[Lemonade Pet Insurance Advertiser]

Is your reminder that shoes are a gift.

[Spot Pet Insurance CEO]

Literally.

[Lemonade Pet Insurance Advertiser]

So unwrap something good, like boots that inspire your next big adventure, or cozy slippers that give you an excuse to stay in or sneak that feel like pure joy. Because shoes aren't just shoes, they're exactly what you wanted. Let us surprise you so you can surprise them. Find shoes that get you and everyone on your list at prices that get your budget at DSW stores or dsw.com.

[Sally Helm]

Own a small biz and need a reliable way to reach new customers?

[Ryan Reynolds]

Try TikTok for business.

[Spot Pet Insurance CEO]

We've generated over 100,000 leads, which has converted into over 40,000 sales for our pet insurance policy. I am the CEO of Spot Pet Insurance. TikTok's smart plus AI powered automation takes the guesswork out of targeting, bidding and optimizing creative. If I can advertise on TikTok, you can too.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Drive more leads and scale your business today. With TikTok for business, head over to.

[Spot Pet Insurance CEO]

Get started.TikTok.com TikTok ads.

[Sally Helm]

In the 1760s, British authorities were saying to themselves how lucky the Americans are to be ruled by us. We're like their caring parent. We send our troops to protect their borders, to keep them safe from Indians and French invaders. But you know, that costs money. And so, dear little colonists, you'll need to give us more of that more money. Stacy Schiff explains.

[Stacy Schiff]

So essentially in the 1760s, Great Britain looks to the colonies. They seem to be prospering beyond anyone's wildest imaginings. And yet the amount of money it's costing to administer the colonies is proportionately great, and the revenue is proportionately small.

[Sally Helm]

So the British do what they've done before. They raise taxes and prepare to endure some colonial grumbling. But this time, they get more than they bargained for. The tax they've levied is actually raising revenue for the Crown, not just covering costs. That's new. And the colonists get angry.

[Stacy Schiff]

Resistance begins to travel sort of up and down the East Coast. Everyone comes around to this idea that, wait a minute, we are not complicit in our own taxation. Therefore Isn't this an arbitrary decision?

[Sally Helm]

Taxation without representation. Does that start to be said around this time?

[Stacy Schiff]

Absolutely. And Hutchinson himself will say, yes, it is. Taxation without representation. This is overreach on the part of the British administration.

[Sally Helm]

Hutchinson, who lies awake at night thinking about how he can serve the Crown, even he thinks it's too much. But still he keeps doing his job, looking after British interests. Meanwhile, the colonists around him can't stop talking about this latest tax and how it might be just the beginning. Samuel Adams, at this point, is helping to foment opposition to these taxes.

[Spot Pet Insurance CEO]

He writes, if our trade be taxed, why not our lands or produce, in short, everything we possess?

[Sally Helm]

Sure enough, in 1765, the British Levy a tax on paper, the Stamp Act. By law, all paper in the colonies now requires a special stamp.

[Stacy Schiff]

It would apply to almost anything. A deed to your home, your legal documents, playing cards, your Harvard diploma. Pretty much any piece of paper you could name would require a stamp, and.

[Sally Helm]

All that stamped stuff would be taxed. This does not go down well in Boston.

[Stacy Schiff]

There's a lot of street theater around this, which, I mean, I think we all heard about in grade school in a vaguely amusing way, but was really threatening.

[Sally Helm]

Like a mob makes an effigy of a Boston tax collector and hangs it from a tree. Adams is writing about all of this.

[Stacy Schiff]

This. He doesn't seem to be complicit in the violence. He does what any smart member of the opposition should do at this point, which is that he downplays it tremendously.

[Sally Helm]

In August of 1765, two weeks after that effigy swings from a tree, Thomas Hutchinson sits down to dinner in his elegant home, a dinner he will not finish. Word comes to him that a mob has formed. It's attacking nearby houses and heading in his direction. Hutchinson flees with his children. Good thing for him, because the mob destroys his home. They chop down the door with axes, put holes in the walls, demolish the furniture, make off with his valuables. The next day, Hutchinson shows up at his job as a chief justice. He's a pathetic sight. His judicial garb was stolen during the raid, so he's in his normal clothes, and he rails against the mob, whoever they were. So what does Samuel Adams think of all this? After all, he too lost parts of his family estate back when the British moved to seize it. It's conceivable that he might be sympathetic, but Stacy Schiff says, not really. To Adams, the blame for the anger of the colonists lies squarely with the British. If Thomas Hutchinson has felt the wrath of his fellow Bostonians. Too bad.

[Stacy Schiff]

Hutchinson will make demand after demand to be reimbursed, obviously, for the damage to his home. And Adams seems to stand in the way of that reimbursement on principle. So, you know, there does seem to be something between Adams and Hutchinson even as early as this point, in terms.

[Sally Helm]

Of, like, a personal beef.

[Stacy Schiff]

Yeah, there's clearly something going on between the two men there which we can't document.

[Sally Helm]

One thing we can document is that on September 30, 1768, the British turn up the heat. Royal Navy ships sail into Boston Harbor.

[Stacy Schiff]

It's very tense. I mean, there's a soldier in Boston for every Boston family.

[Sally Helm]

This amounts to a military takeover of Boston with no end in sight.

[Stacy Schiff]

There's a great deal, obviously, of dissatisfaction with the fact that the town has been occupied by these men who are obviously, you know, not necessarily churchgoing children, loving friends to meet in the street. So it's a little bit gnarly.

[Sally Helm]

Adams pours his version of the gnarliness into vivid dispatches for the Boston Gazette, and he also expands his reach.

[Stacy Schiff]

It's at that point that he and his colleagues start a sort of news service.

[Sally Helm]

Adams's accounts of the conflict in Boston become regular reading far and wide.

[Stacy Schiff]

These kind of lurid, sensationalist items about various assaults on women, various guns in the chest and knives in the throat, all of these brutal encounters between the soldiers and the population. And those accounts are sent out of Boston to New York and Philadelphia, so that the other colonies hear about poor, martyred Boston and then only later printed in Boston, by which time no one's really sure if it ever really happened in the first place. So it's a kind of genius fake news operation.

[Sally Helm]

Is he especially skilled at that, or is he just especially prolific?

[Stacy Schiff]

I would say he is a master propagandist, yes, in the sense that he seems to be able to pull these ambient ideas out of the air and crystallize them. He's by no means the only person who's opposing British policy at this point, but he seems to be able to pin it to the page very colorfully and very artfully.

[Sally Helm]

In his dispatches, Adams hammers home the fact that the colonists have essentially no such say in their governance.

[Stacy Schiff]

They. The colonists have as much power in Parliament as they did to choose the emperor of China, or, you know, London knew about as much about them as they did about the moon.

[Sally Helm]

Thomas Hutchinson is reading these stories, too.

[Stacy Schiff]

And he fears that these are just paving the way, essentially, to something like.

[Sally Helm]

The Boston massacre on March 5, 1770. He's proven right. The moon shines down on a blanket of snow as a lone British sentry stands guard outside the customs house. A crowd surrounds him. Insults begin to fly. A redcoat captain, hearing the commotion, calls for reinforcements. The troops post up around the sentry and raise their bayonets, the blades glinting in the light. The crowd advances. The detachment of soldiers then let loose with a volley of bullets. Men fall. Their blood stains the snow.

[Stacy Schiff]

This all happens very quickly. Nobody's really sure who instigated what, but it's massive chaos.

[Sally Helm]

In the immediate wake, bells ring out, a makeshift signal to rally the local militia. By now, hundreds of people are out.

[Stacy Schiff]

On the streets, so the town has gone quite wild.

[Sally Helm]

Thomas Hutchinson comes on the scene and does his best to remember, restore order.

[Stacy Schiff]

Hutchinson has tried to calm everyone. He's essentially said, go home. I've got this. Justice will be served, you know, Let us please find out precisely what happened.

[Sally Helm]

But a lot of colonists aren't satisfied with that. They don't want to wait. Instead, they decide to confront Thomas Hutchinson. And the man they choose to do it is Samuel Adams. He goes to address Hutchinson at a meeting of the governor's council, while his fellow colonists wait nearby at a town hall meeting of their own. The British officials on the council are in a room ringed by painted portraits of their forefathers. Adams stands before them. He addresses Hutchinson directly.

[Stacy Schiff]

So John Adams leaves us this depiction of Samuel Adams essentially reading in the riot act, telling him that if the troops are not immediately evacuated, there will be blood in the streets and that Hutchinson should consider his own life to be in danger.

[Sally Helm]

Hutchinson understands the threat, but makes a counteroffer.

[Stacy Schiff]

At first, Hutchinson will agree to remove one regiment.

[Sally Helm]

Adams brings the offer back to the colonists at the town hall meeting. Soon enough, he leaves that meeting to tell Hutchinson, if you have the power to remove one regiment, you have the power to remove them all.

[Stacy Schiff]

Adams, who doesn't normally gloat, will admit that he saw Hutchinson's knees tremble and that he enjoyed the sight.

[Sally Helm]

Hutchinson and the governor's council give in.

[Stacy Schiff]

So it's this sort of monumental showdown of the people demanding something and in a funny way, outmaneuvering the authorities.

[Sally Helm]

Adams has scored a victory, and he can sense that tensions will only continue to rise. The colonists need to be ready. So in the years after the massacre, he begins an effort to connect Boston with the rest of Massachusetts and eventually with other parts of the colonies. He forms these groups that aim to share information and hone revolutionary ideals. The groups have a pretty boring name. They're called the Committees of Correspondence.

[Stacy Schiff]

I think he picked that name to be as inoffensive sounding as possible. So nobody would. So nobody would sort of say, wait, these are revolutionary. These are proto terrorist committees. I mean, it's like when you're a kid and you have a diary and you call it, you know, my book instead of my secret diary, so that nobody's going to think it's interesting. It's the same kind of. Same kind of thinking. He tried to make it sound just utterly anodyne. And they do.

[Spot Pet Insurance CEO]

Totally.

[Sally Helm]

It works. I mean, but, but, but what you're saying is that what he's doing is actually really important. He's laying this secretive foundation for the revolution that is going to come eventually. Yeah.

[Stacy Schiff]

What he essentially does with those committees is he just wires the continent. It's like an electrical network that he's formed.

[Sally Helm]

That network is ready for the next British provocation. And in 1773, that provocation arrives. It has to do with tea. The Crown decides to let the British East India Company flood the colonial market with their tea. And, oh, by the way, that new supply of tea will be taxed.

[Stacy Schiff]

So it's a very explosive act, which no one in London, or very few people in London seem to realize at the outset, is going to be explosive. From their vantage point, this act will lower the price of tea. The Americans will be thrilled.

[Sally Helm]

Increasing the supply of tea in the colonies will make it cheaper all around. The British are like that added tax will be nothing but a minor inconvenience. The Americans feel differently.

[Stacy Schiff]

When the tea arrives in Boston harbor, a clock starts ticking. Adams and his colleagues essentially band together and start holding a series of meetings as to how they are going to meet this crisis. And the way that Adams articulates it is as follows. He doesn't trust, as he puts it, the private virtue of his fellow citizens to not drink the tea. So he prefers to trust their public virtue. In rejecting the tea, he means, it's.

[Sally Helm]

Going to be too tempting if this tea is actually on the market. We could boycott it once it gets into the city, but. But instead, let's just not let it into the city. We're worried people will be a little bit too tempted by this cheap tea.

[Stacy Schiff]

Exactly. As soon as that tea is unloaded, people are going to be buying and drinking it.

[Sally Helm]

So the colonists tell the ship's owner, Francis Roach, turn around and bring your tea back to England. But it's not so simple. Roach says he's legally bound to unload the tea. Before departing, Samuel Adams reminds Roach of a loophole in the law. It allows him to sail back home if his ship is battered by a deadly storm.

[Stacy Schiff]

He says to Roach, if you're faced with a tempest, you can turn around. And you, sir, are facing a howling political tempest. So why would that not apply to you?

[Sally Helm]

And so, as the deadline to unload his tea approaches, Roach rides his horse through the pouring rain to the country estate of the new governor of Massachusetts. Thomas Hutchinson. The ship's owner, stands before the governor, mud splattered, soaking wet, begging for permission to turn his ship around.

[Stacy Schiff]

Hutchinson stands firm. He refuses to issue a pass.

[Sally Helm]

Hutchinson says, roach, unload your tea. Roach rides back to Boston, arriving just past sundown on December 16, 1773. He tromps into the Old south meeting house and delivers the bad news to a crowd of 6,000 people, a crowd that includes Samuel Adams.

[Stacy Schiff]

Samuel Adams, shortly after hearing the report, says that it is clear that nothing more can be done to save the country. And very shortly thereafter, a portion of the room begins to melt very silently away.

[Sally Helm]

And then these men move together toward the harbor, disguised in their Native American garb.

[Stacy Schiff]

There does seem to be this almost jeering at the British. You know, you think we're a bunch of savages. We're going to show you. American Indians had already established themselves as avatars of independence. Let us show you what that means here.

[Sally Helm]

Another benefit. No one can tell who they are, but we know one person who isn't among them. Samuel Adams. He stays behind with John Hancock and other rebel leaders.

[Stacy Schiff]

Hancock and Adams very conspicuously remain behind at the Old south and missed the most fateful moments in American history and missed the dumping of the tea into the harbor.

[Sally Helm]

He and the others couldn't hear the sounds from the harbor, Schiff says, But some British officers later described what those sounds were like.

[Stacy Schiff]

They could hear the splintering of the chests. There obviously would have been the noise of the rigging being maneuvered throughout this. They could hear cheers.

[Sally Helm]

The protest takes two hours, and it goes off without a hitch.

[Stacy Schiff]

Rise. Adams will say, the whole thing was conducted with decency, unanimity, and spirit. And we know that everyone at the end of this just goes home extremely quietly, that there's no commotion in the streets afterwards.

[Sally Helm]

There isn't any commotion, but there is some quiet celebration.

[Stacy Schiff]

We hear from Thomas Hutchinson afterwards that Adams was never in greater glory than he is at this moment. So the implication is that there's a certain amount of gloating about what's happening.

[Sally Helm]

And yet Adams, this Well known agitator, this man who has spoken of the virtue of rejecting British tea. You can't easily pin this on him. After all, he was in the Old South Meeting House at the time. He clearly wasn't one of the men splitting crates open with a tomahawk.

[Stacy Schiff]

I mean, it's one of the rare moments where we know precisely where he is and, and he's there for very much, clearly for a reason.

[Sally Helm]

That reason essentially an alibi. Still, pretty much everyone knows that Adams was involved. Some of the men who witnessed all this later give testimony in London and they name Adams as the chief conspirator.

[Stacy Schiff]

So there's a fairly good indication that if he didn't mastermind the thing, he was at least complicit in the masterminding of is in fact, if you think about it, a perfect crime in the sense that there is no perpetrator. So it is very Adams like in the sense that the principles rise above the perpetrators.

[Sally Helm]

The principle of independence, which in the wake of the Tea Party, takes off in a major way. Parliament reacts to the tea protest with a series of drastic punishments. They start by closing Boston's port and demanding that its citizens pay for the ruined tea.

[Stacy Schiff]

And because of the machinery that Samuel Adams has already set in motion through the committees of correspondence, the other colonies will react to what is truly now Boston's martyrdom with enormous sympathy.

[Sally Helm]

Those committees that had formed a kind of revolutionary electrical grid for the colonies, they are ready for this moment.

[Stacy Schiff]

After the Tea Party, the current just begins to run so much more quickly from north to south.

[Sally Helm]

After that, things happen fast. Anger over the punishment in Boston leads to the first Continental Congress. And before too long, the colonists desire for independence has broken out into a full blown war. During that war, Samuel Adams keeps a low profile. A low profile that still persists. Why is he a forgotten character in the first place? Who made that happen?

[Stacy Schiff]

I think he's to some degree complicit in his own disappearance. Adams is not vain. He's very modest. Obviously he's operating in the background. His entire methodology is based on the no fingerprints school. So he really does need to remove himself from the scene. There's an amazing moment in John Adams's writings in which he describes cousin Samuel at the Continental Congress, feeding his papers to the fire. And Samuel Adams. I know, this just like breaks the biographer's heart.

[Sally Helm]

Yeah, he must have been like, no.

[Stacy Schiff]

I had trouble writing that scene. Exactly. And Samuel explains to John that he needs to preserve the anonymity of his colleagues, that he doesn't want anyone to be compromised. They're fomenting revolution. Obviously, the whole point is you can't leave a paper trail. So to some extent, he does pretty much erase the record after him.

[Sally Helm]

I forget that they would have wanted to cover their tracks because I feel like we all spend so much time, like reading the tracks that they did leave, you know, but you're right, it would have been dangerous to leave those letters lying around.

[Stacy Schiff]

And I think that was one of the other things that so thrilled me about the story was we precise that we forget the peril that these men are in at that moment. We all know that Paul Revere gets on his horse on April 18, 1775. But where is he riding? And suddenly it dawned on me he's riding to warn John Hancock and Samuel Adams that as the two most wanted men in Massachusetts, they are about to be arrested for treason. Wow. And I think we tend to think, oh, Paul Revere, he just rode off to war in the countryside. I think we forget the destination at the other end.

[Sally Helm]

Which was Samuel Adams.

[Stacy Schiff]

Which was Samuel Adams. Exactly. Foreign.

[Sally Helm]

Thanks for listening to History this week. For moments throughout history that are also worth watching, check your local TV listings to find out what's on the History Channel today. If you want to get in touch, please shoot us an email at our email address, historythisweekhistory.com or you can leave us a voicemail. 212-351-0412. Special thanks to our guest, Stacy Schiff, author of the revolutionary Samuel Adams. This episode was produced by Corinne Wallace. It was sound designed by Dan Rosado and story edited by Jim o'. Grady. Our senior producer is Ben Dickstein. History this week is also produced by Julia Press and me, Sally Helm. Our associate producer is Emma Fredericks. Our supervising producer is McKamey Lin, and our executive producer is Jesse Katie. Don't forget to subscribe, rate and review History this week, wherever you get your podcasts and see you next week.