Loading summary
Lizzie Logan
This is an I Heart Podcast Guaranteed
WebMD Host
Human this week on a special episode of WebMD's Health Discovered podcast, we're taking a closer look at a common form of lung cancer that accounts for 85% of all cases.
Lizzie Logan
When I first heard the words you have lung cancer, I was in shock.
WebMD Host
It's a diagnosis that changes everything. So what does it really mean to advocate for yourself when you when you're living with non small cell lung cancer? Listen to Health discovered on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
Public Ad Host
Support for the show comes from Public, the investing platform for those who take it seriously. On Public, you can build a multi asset portfolio of stocks, bonds, options, crypto and now generated assets which allow you to turn any idea into an investable index. With AI. It all starts with your prompt. From renewable energy companies with high free cash flow to semiconductor suppliers growing revenue over 20% over year, you can literally type any prompt and put the AI to work. It screens thousands of stocks, builds a one of a kind index, and lets you back test it against the S&P 500. Then you can invest in a few clicks. Generated assets are like ETFs with infinite possibilities, completely customizable and based on your thesis, not someone else's. Go to public.com podcast and earn an uncapped 1% bonus when you transfer your portfolio. That's public.com podcast paid for by Public
Public Legal Disclaimer
Investing Brokerage Services by Open to the Public Investing Inc. Member FINRA and SIPC Advisory Services by Public Advisors, llc. SEC Registered Advisor Generated Assets is an interactive analysis tool. Output is for informational purposes only and is not an investment recommendation or advice.
Public Ad Host
Complete disclosures available@public.com disclosures you're listening to
Redfin Ad Host
a podcast, so you're doing something else too. Like maybe scrolling home listings on Redfin, saving places you like without thinking you'll get them. Because that's what house hunting has become. But Redfin isn't built for endless browsing. It's built to help you find and own a home. Redfin agents close twice as many deals as other agents, which means when you find a place you love, you've got a real shot at getting it. Redfin helps turn saved listings into real addresses. Get started@redfin.com Own the Dream
Lowe's Ad Host
introducing Home Care Plus, a new subscription service from Lowe's that helps make life easier by giving members a hand with home maintenance. Let Lowe's tackle the tasks you keep meaning to do, like electric dryer, vent cleaning, replacing hard to reach light bulbs and more subscribe to Home Care plus for just $99 a year and consider your to do list. Done. Members get more at Lowe's. Available in select zip codes only. Cancel anytime. Non refundable fee. Product purchase required terms and service restrictions apply. Details@lowe's.com Terms subject to change.
Dana Schwartz
You are listening to Hoax, a production of iHeart podcasts, folks. It's a hoax outcome.
Lizzie Logan
No one ever seems to believe me
Dana Schwartz
when I swear I never was deceiving the last one. Welcome to Hoax, a podcast about the lies we wish were true and truths
Lizzie Logan
that sound like lies.
Dana Schwartz
I'm the ghost of Dana Schwartz and
Lizzie Logan
I'm the evil twin of Lizzie Logan.
Dana Schwartz
Welcome to the show. So, Lizzy, this is a rare time in this podcast where I am going to be talking about a hoax that I have covered on Noble Blood. My other podcast, self plagiarism. It's self plagiarism. I did go back to the same well of research, but the reason that I wanted to talk about it is because I feel like sometimes the format of Noble Blood 1 this is just a quintessential hoax and it is delightful. But also, I think the form of Noble Blood as like a scripted show with a one single narrative sometimes means I can't explore things in as wide reaching a way as I want to.
Lizzie Logan
It lacks a little Lizzie.
Dana Schwartz
I mean, that's actually what I was gonna say.
Lizzie Logan
I'm not on Noble Blood. Really.
Dana Schwartz
I was gonna say it doesn't have Lizzie's take. And you know, I would never. I don't really often pause Nobleblood episodes to be like, I always take the historical consensus, but I never pause and like, oh, this source says this and this source says that. And I mean, very rarely do I do that. So I am excited to talk a little bit about the broader historical context around a hoax called Princess Caribou.
Lizzie Logan
Okay, great. I think I've listened to this Nobleblood episode, but I think it was a long time ago.
Dana Schwartz
It was a long time ago.
Lizzie Logan
I have a vision of myself listening to it at the gym and it's been so long since I went to the gym that I'm like, it couldn't have been this year and it couldn't have been last year.
Dana Schwartz
It was in fact a very long time ago. Okay, so we're gonna start the story on April 3, Good Friday. Some people say it took place the Thursday before, but most of the story takes place Good Friday, 1817. Okay, so Frankenstein's about to be written. I think Bridgerton is probably happening around this time. Anatomy A love story. If you're thinking about costumes and what's happening in England at this time.
Lizzie Logan
And we're in England.
Dana Schwartz
We are in England. We're in Bristol, which is the far west of England, like almost Wales.
Lizzie Logan
Okay.
Dana Schwartz
And a woman arrives to the small town of Almondsbury, which is right outside Bristol. And she's wearing what are described as exotic clothes, which in this case just means like a black turban, a head covering, a black gown with like a muslin frill at the neck and a red and black shawl. To me, looking pretty cool outfit. Pictures of it. It kind of looks like a, like a stereo. Like a child dressing like a flamenco dancer.
Lizzie Logan
Oh, funny.
Dana Schwartz
Like not an accurate reflection of that, but it's like a girl like putting a scarf on and being like, I'm Spanish.
Lizzie Logan
Yes, okay.
Dana Schwartz
Like a child.
Lizzie Logan
It's very dramatic.
Dana Schwartz
Yes. And she has a bundle, and this is important. Carrying soap, just a few ha' pennies and a counterfeit sixpence. And that's all she has. And this young woman goes to the house of a cobbler first and talks to him and his wife, but she's not speaking English, just sort of an unintelligible language. And she mimes that she's hungry. They give her some food. And then she mimes like, oh, can I sleep here? And they're like, no. Yeah, no, no, no. And the cobbler's wife takes this woman to the overseer of the poor, who's a person who's in charge of what? It sounds like he's like the one who levies taxes on people and then manages those taxes to manage poor houses and distribute food, money and clothing. Feels like the overseer of the poor is exactly who should be overseeing this situation.
Lizzie Logan
That's who you call.
Dana Schwartz
And the overseer, though, also pawns her off on someone else. He goes to like the local magistrate, sort of the mayor equivalent of this town, Samuel Worrell and his American born wife Elizabeth, to like figure out this whole thing.
Lizzie Logan
Two questions. How old does this woman appear to be? And like what color is she?
Dana Schwartz
Young, pretty?
Lizzie Logan
Uh huh. You're asking like race, ethnicity, like just appearance wise. Because if she can't talk, then she can't really explain her ethnicity, but just like purely on the surface.
Dana Schwartz
So again, I mean, she could talk, but not in the 19th century. Our understanding of race is different than it is now. She has dark hair and dark eyes.
Lizzie Logan
Okay.
Dana Schwartz
She is in fact like a white person.
Lizzie Logan
Right.
Dana Schwartz
But that she's also sort of just like swarthy.
Lizzie Logan
Okay. So she doesn't seem English maybe.
Dana Schwartz
She maybe doesn't seem English. And again, she's not dressed like an English woman. She's speaking another language and she's a poor beggar woman. But this is also a case where I do feel like pretty privilege really does exist.
Lizzie Logan
Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Dana Schwartz
Where this isn't just like an old crone. This is like a very pretty young woman. And I think that makes a difference in the story. And so as you're listening to the story and how people are treating her, I think the fact that she is pretty makes a difference.
Lizzie Logan
Oh, totally.
Dana Schwartz
Which is just an unfortunate reality of the world then as it is now. I feel like fundamentally there was a big to do. I think the equivalent to this story is there was a big to do because there was a very handsome convict at one point. Do you remember this?
Lizzie Logan
Oh, like, yeah, the. The hot felon.
Dana Schwartz
The hot felon.
Lizzie Logan
And there's a whole account that's like, mug. Shouties. Yeah, like mugshot of, like, shouties.
Dana Schwartz
I think fundamentally, if you see an unhoused person or a convict, a felon who is very conventionally attractive, something in you is like, well, that person shouldn't be there. They should be doing Pilates.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah.
Dana Schwartz
Oh, yeah.
Lizzie Logan
I mean, Jim Gaffigan has a whole bit about how actors are way too good looking to be believable as, like, in certain roles where he talks about, like, Halle Berry in Monsters Ball, he's like, she played that poverty stricken woman the whole time. I was like, why doesn't she just become a model? She could be the next Halle Berry.
Dana Schwartz
So basically, they bring her to this magistrate to figure out what her deal is. And she acts pretty unusually. She sleeps only on the floor of the room, even though there's a bed. And then when they bring her to, like, a local inn called the bowl, their botanical prints are very popular around this time. Like on the wall, and she sees a botanical print of a pineapple and says nanas, which is. Nanas is a word for pineapple in Indonesian, but also a lot of other different languages. And. And people are like, oh, she knows what the exotic fruit pineapple is. And then they show her pictures of China, and she gets, like, very animated and excited, even though they don't know what language she's speaking. So they're like, okay, maybe this woman came from Asia again, Samuel Worrell is the magistrate of this town, but he doesn't want to be associated with a counterfeiter because they had found a counterfeit coin in her purse. And he's like, I don't wanna get in trouble for this. I'm gonna have this woman be tried for vagrancy in Bristol because he thinks she's just a vagrant.
Lizzie Logan
I don't wanna get in trouble for being around this person who did this crime.
Dana Schwartz
Yeah.
Lizzie Logan
For such, like, my job.
Dana Schwartz
Well, you should turn her into the authorities. All right. I will also say different sources sometimes characterize Samuel Worrell very ungenerously. Like, people are like, he's a drunk and a cruel man. And I take those with a grain of salt because a lot of contemporary sources just don't comment on his personality. And I think if you are embellishing this story, you want to, like, add a little spice to the side characters. And you're like, oh, well, he sent her to be tried for vagrancy. What a cruel man. Presumably a drunkard. So you might see anyone researching this story might see things like that. I just am like, I don't know. He didn't want to get involved with this strange woman acting in a weird way. But she is briefly imprisoned, and it's while she's in Bristol that she meets a Portuguese sailor. And sometimes in some sources, he's named Manuel Ennis, but I've also seen Manuel Eneso, and he says that he actually understands the language that she's speaking, and he's able to translate and says that according to this woman, her name is Princess Caribou. She's from the island of Javasu in the Indian Ocean, right off of Sumatra. She was kidnapped from her homeland by pirates, managed to escape by jumping overboard, and that's how she ended up in Bristol. And from this translation of the Portuguese Sailor, we learn that she's the daughter of a Chinese person of rank and a Malay woman, which is a indigenous tribe to this group, like an indigenous ethnic group in what we now call the Indonesian islands. Javasu, again, located off the coast of Sumatra. But I'm gonna do a brief spoiler for people who maybe are like, I don't know where Javasu is. That's not a real place. Yeah.
Lizzie Logan
It doesn't sound real.
Dana Schwartz
Well, it sounds kind of like Java.
Lizzie Logan
Yes.
Dana Schwartz
And Sumatra. But you're like, okay, sort of put them together, but it's not real. But what's happening right now in England is the exotic is very exciting. Yeah. And so this woman is let out of prison, and the Worrells, drunk and cruel or not, take her back to their house. And this is where, like, two months of the best summer we ever had started. So she is staying with the Worrells in this small town, and it is
Lizzie Logan
just like, do they keep this Portuguese guy around to continue translating?
Dana Schwartz
No.
Lizzie Logan
At this point, because it seems like he's really key to this whole thing.
Dana Schwartz
By this point, she's able to communicate enough.
Lizzie Logan
Okay.
Dana Schwartz
And I think part of, like, her childlike inability to articulate things is part of her, I'm going to say air quotes charm. Okay. I also, again, want to be like, she's very pretty. She has this sort of childlike approach to things, and I think that's why people get very excited about her.
Lizzie Logan
There's a great YouTube video that, as far as I know, this YouTube video is what coined the term, but it's a term that people use now to describe this character trope in movies, mostly sci fi. Born sexy Yesterday.
Dana Schwartz
Born sexy. That's exactly what she is.
Lizzie Logan
Where it's like Leeloo in the Fifth
Dana Schwartz
Element or a little bit Madison in Splash. Yeah.
Lizzie Logan
Or Bella in Poor Things, where it's usually a woman who has the body of a hot woman and the brain of a child, not for creepy reasons, but for, like, sci fi reasons.
Dana Schwartz
Yeah.
Lizzie Logan
And so she's very helpless, and she's also very sexy for some reason.
Dana Schwartz
My brain also goes to, like, mermaid things. So I'm going to like, you know the woman in Splash or, like, in Aquamarine. Yes, that girl where it's just like, I'm just so helpless and silly and naive with my strange customs. Yeah.
Lizzie Logan
Like, how do this work?
Dana Schwartz
Yeah, it's othering a foreigner, but it's not racist.
Lizzie Logan
If she's a mermaid, it's infantilizing a grown woman so that you can still want to fuck her. And also, she has no agency.
Dana Schwartz
That is exactly what's happening with this woman. So a ton of visitors are coming through Allmansbury because they're all so excited to see her. The Worrells are very excited that they have a royal visitor. And Samuel Worrell is actually starting a private bank at this time. And he feels like the publicity and sort of the esteem of having a royal guest is, like, bolstering his local business.
Lizzie Logan
Surely the answer to this question will be no, but does anyone have the idea of, like, oh, we should probably get her home?
Dana Schwartz
No.
Lizzie Logan
Okay.
Dana Schwartz
She's in England now. How wonderful.
Lizzie Logan
She's a princess where she's from. Why does she want to live with these fucking people?
Dana Schwartz
Maybe because she's having a freaking blast.
Lizzie Logan
She's a princess.
Dana Schwartz
I know.
Public Ad Host
Support for the show comes from public, the investing platform for those who take it Seriously On Public you can build a multi asset portfolio of stocks, bonds, options, crypto and now generated assets which allow you to turn any idea into an investable index with AI. It all starts with your prompt. From renewable energy companies with high free cash flow to semiconductor suppliers growing revenue over 20% year over year, you can literally type any prompt and put the AI to work. It screens thousands of stocks, builds a one of a kind index and lets you back test it against the S&P 500. Then you can invest in a few clicks. Generated assets are like ETFs with infinite possibilities, complete, completely customizable and based on your thesis, not someone else's. Go to public.com podcast and earn an uncapped 1% bonus when you transfer your portfolio. That's public.com podcast paid for by Public
Public Legal Disclaimer
Investing Brokerage Services by Open to the Public Investing Inc. Member FINRA and SIPC Advisory Services by Public Advisors llc. SEC Registered Advisor Generated Assets is an interactive analysis tool. Output is for informational purposes only and is not an investment recommendation or advice.
Public Ad Host
Complete disclosures available@public.com disclosures are you really
Autotrader Ad Host 1
buying a car online on autotrader right now?
Autotrader Ad Host 2
Really? I can get super specific with dealer listings and see cars based on my budget.
Autotrader Ad Host 1
You can really have it delivered or pick it up. I think kid is walking up the slide.
Autotrader Ad Host 2
Really Auto trader? Buy your car online. Really?
Homeserve Ad Host
Owning a home is full of surprises. Some wonderful, some not so much. And when something breaks, it can feel like the whole day unravels. That's why Homeserve exists for as little as $4.99 a month. You'll always have someone to call a trusted professional ready to help, bringing peace of mind to four and a half million homeowners nationwide. For plans starting at just $4.99 a month, go to homeserve.com that's homeserve.com not available everywhere. Most plans range between 499 to $11.99 a month. Your first year terms apply on covered repairs.
Amazon Ad Host
Amazon presents one versus baby drunk on milk and power. This bundle of sheer chaos only comes with three settings. Crying, pooping and crying while pooping. But Juan shopped on Amazon and saved on pacifiers, diaper cream and a colossal B coffee beans. Hear that baby Juan just rocked you to sleep. Save the everyday with Amazon.
Dana Schwartz
So there's all these anecdotes because a few I'm not to jump ahead but newspapers get word of her and we'll write all these anecdotes. So a lot of our sources for These unusual things. She does come from newspapers, but according to one source, this gentleman who had visited Malay in recent years brought out a souvenir sword and caribou. The princess gets very excited and recognizes it as belonging to her country. And they even say she tries to grab at it. But quote from Prudence, it was denied her, which is very boring, sexy yesterday. It's like, well, she can't have a knife. And then she. But she placed the dagger to her right side, where, according to this gentleman who had visited Malay, the Malay people wore it, which, quote, confirmed to this gentleman that she perfectly understood the custom, though not the language of that country, because she is not speaking Malay.
Lizzie Logan
Okay.
Dana Schwartz
She is, in fact, not speaking any language that anyone really recognizes. There's sort of a local expert, like A polymath named Dr. Wilkinson, who shows her this book, Edmund Fry's Pantographia, which has. Is like a manual of different languages. And she picks hers, and which he identifies as one called Re Jeng, which is, I believe, spoken in Sumatra. And this doctor also identifies that she has strange markings on her head, scars that could only have come, he says, from Eastern medicine, practices some sort of barbaric surgery.
Lizzie Logan
Wow. So she. She's from, like, all over.
Dana Schwartz
Yeah, she has some strange scars on her head. And we're like, we don't know what that is. They send samples of her language to Oxford to be like, do you know what this is? And they're like, no. So no one quite. I mean, this Dr. Wilkinson identified what he thought the language was, but no one quite knows what she's saying, even though some of the words she's using are specific to Indonesian languages.
Lizzie Logan
Did you, in middle school read the island of the Blue Dolphins?
Dana Schwartz
Yes. I love that book.
Lizzie Logan
It's like the real version of this.
Dana Schwartz
Real version of island of the Blue Dolphins.
Lizzie Logan
Well, no, the island of the Blue Dolphins is based on a real lady.
Dana Schwartz
What? A woman's whole family left her behind on an island.
Lizzie Logan
I think they all, like, died or something. And then she was like, the. If I'm remembering fourth grade correctly, she, like, got separated from her family or whatever and became, like, the last person in the world who spoke her language.
Dana Schwartz
Okay. I did not realize island of the Blue Dolphin was inspired by a real story.
Lizzie Logan
Can we very quickly check if I'm right?
Dana Schwartz
Yes, yes. The lone woman of San Nicolas island left alone for 18 years. Wow.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah.
Dana Schwartz
Yeah. This woman crazy. Again, no one. It's hard to get to the place that she came from. No one really understands the language, but they're having just a fun summer with her.
Lizzie Logan
Okay, great.
Dana Schwartz
She's doing. She swims naked.
Autotrader Ad Host 2
Hot.
Dana Schwartz
Hot. She practices archery and is apparently very good at it.
Lizzie Logan
Okay, badass. Badass.
Dana Schwartz
Cooks a chicken curry, performs a war dance with a gong, and prays on the roof to a God that she calls Allah tala, which is also a name for a God in a bunch of a few other languages.
Lizzie Logan
Allah is most Muslim, but Allah Tala specifically.
Dana Schwartz
Yeah. She also declines to drink alcohol. She brings one or both of her hands to her forehead to greet people. She bathed more often than was the custom and wore a shawl while praying. They also just put her in exotic clothing and have her portrait painted and throw a ball for her in her honor. In Beth.
Lizzie Logan
She's kind of like E.T.
Dana Schwartz
yeah, but they're all having a great time being like, what is she gonna do next? So this doctor, Dr. Wilkinson, who examined her head and examined her language, published her findings. There's a Telegraph article written about her. This is, you know, June at this point, one of the Worrell servants, allegedly, who's a Greek man, doesn't think she's legit and he decides to test her. And in the middle of the night, he walks around and shouts fire to see if she would react because that would prove that she knew English. But she didn't. This story, over the course of about eight weeks, gains in popularity. I think I understand why, which is kind of. I don't want to get ahead of myself. But the reason people are so interested in this story I think is kind of the main fascination here. But this story becomes so well known that this woman named Mrs. Neal, who runs a boarding house in Bristol, hears about it and sees a photograph. Not a photograph, sees a drawing of this young woman in the newspaper and she recognizes the picture of her published in the Bristol Journal and goes to inform the worlds that, oh, this girl that you're calling Princess Caribou. I know her. She's a former servant and her name is Mary Wilcox. And when she lived in the boarding house that I ran, she just like, would sometimes wear a turban and do a made up language for fun.
Lizzie Logan
I'm obsessed with her. I love her so much. This is incredible. I love how much she has committed to the bit.
Dana Schwartz
She. It's. She's really the patron saint of committing to the bit.
Lizzie Logan
I mean, this is like Nathan Fielder wishes, like, this is jury duty, but uno reversed.
Dana Schwartz
This is just her turning everyone else into the jury duty guy.
Lizzie Logan
She's just pranking. I mean, the greatest character actress of Our time.
Dana Schwartz
I do. I want to point out. And we'll get to this a little later. She is exploiting and othering people of different races. Yeah. To be like a slight buzzkill here. She's not just doing like a quirky character, but she is the queen of committing to the bed.
Lizzie Logan
I'm gonna not give her a pass for being of her time, but I'm gonna contextualize her as being of all of the things that people are doing in the pre Civil War world. I realize this is in England.
Dana Schwartz
Yeah.
Lizzie Logan
This to me, does not rank among the atrocities.
Dana Schwartz
Oh, not the. Not the atrocities to people of color. And I also want to point out, I don't think the problem is as much with her as it is everyone around her.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah. If they didn't want to believe in racist stereotypes, there would have been no stereotypes for her to exploit.
Dana Schwartz
That is it. It's everyone around her delighted that she is indulging exactly the racist stereotype that they want to enjoy.
Lizzie Logan
What a grifter.
Dana Schwartz
Yeah. So who is Mary Wilcox? She was born in 1791 or 92 in Devonshire. Her father was a cobbler. We don't know anything about her mother.
Lizzie Logan
Is that why she went to a cobbler house?
Dana Schwartz
Oh.
Lizzie Logan
Because she was like, I know how to get around a cobbler house.
Dana Schwartz
Maybe I never even put that together. Maybe. See, this is what you need.
Lizzie Logan
These things are not coming up on Noble Blood.
Dana Schwartz
Her dad apparently said that when she was young, she suffered from rheumatic fever, which affected her mentally after that. So we don't. We don't even know what's going on up there.
Lizzie Logan
She's a little kooky.
Dana Schwartz
She's a little kooky. She left home at 19, came to London, and she got very sick and went to a poor house hospital and received an improperly done cupping operation on her head. And that was what gave her the scars, which I find very funny. It's like people being like, oh, only a primitive eastern country could have possibly done this to her. And it's like, no, this happened in London because she was a poor person at the hospital. It's people not realizing the barbaric practices are what they're doing in their own communities.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah.
Dana Schwartz
She worked as a nursemaid for a family in Clapham, and apparently the children really liked her. She was very imaginative with stories.
Lizzie Logan
Sounds like it.
Dana Schwartz
Then she got very interested in their Jewish neighbors. She just, like, loved their language and their prayers. I mean, we love an ally. We love someone being interested in the community.
Lizzie Logan
What is not an anti Semite. Like a pro Semite.
Dana Schwartz
Pro Semite. She gets fired from her job for attending a Jewish wedding. I know.
Lizzie Logan
That is insane.
Dana Schwartz
I know. It's. I like, I love an ally, but I also. There's, like, the bit of balance here where she was, like, maybe a little too interested in their prayer and language, where I do feel a little like, have you read that Judge Judy Interview with RuPaul?
Lizzie Logan
Oh, yes. Yes.
Dana Schwartz
Where it's like, incorporating Judaism into your personality is maybe something you don't need. Yeah.
Lizzie Logan
But, like, attending a wedding to me
Dana Schwartz
is like, the wedding is great.
Lizzie Logan
Like, that's fun. Like, go celebrate.
Dana Schwartz
Go celebrate. She shouldn't have gotten fired. No justice for Mary Wilcox. Yeah, but she did. This is also one of the most iconic details about her that I love. She gets admitted to a Magdalene hospital for fallen women, which is, like, where us sex workers would go, because, quote, she admired the uniform of brown dresses and straw hats for the inmates. So she sees that these women, these fallen women in a Magdalene hospital are wearing brown dresses and straw hats, and she's like, I like that. And so she gets in.
Lizzie Logan
That's like the opposite of Maria von Trapp being like, I love what's going on with the nuns. I'll become a nun. She's like, I love what's going on with the sex workers. I'll hang out with the sex worker.
Dana Schwartz
She gets kicked out when it's discovered that she's not actually a sex worker. And then we get pieces of her backstory from here, where we're just kind of assuming and putting pieces together. We know she hops around, possibly goes to France, where she learns some French. She becomes pregnant, gives birth in secret. At first she says the father was a bricklayer from Essex. Later she'll say it was a Frenchman she met in a bookshop. The child passes away very tragically. And this is when Mary hits the road with a group of Romani people. And this is kind of important because there's a lot of their language and culture that she'll sort of imitate in her own little way. She'll take the seeds and then have fun with it. Yeah. She becomes a beggar in Bristol because she got fired for going to a Jewish wedding. What she's supposed to do. And this is kind of where the seeds of the caribou trick are born, because she notices in Bristol there are girls who are from Brittany who are like ethnic Bretons, and that's like a Celtic ethnic group. And she notices that the Breton girls make more money because they're begging in their traditional Breton clothing. And she's like, hmm, okay. Whether it's, like, because you're getting attention or you look more unique or something about it. Mary puts on a turban and pretends to be French as a beggar. But then they take her to the French consul, and she doesn't actually speak all that well, and so she pretends to be Spanish. And then at the French consul, they're like, oh, we have a cook who's Spanish. Hold on one second. And then she's like, wait, wait, wait, wait. No, no, no. Just kidding. And I think this is probably the point where she realizes that if she's going to fake an ethnicity, she needs one that no one can call her on. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So then that's, I think, how the Princess Caribou situation began. We can kind of assume that the Portuguese guy was in on.
Lizzie Logan
Sounds like she. Maybe not from the beginning, but maybe
Dana Schwartz
she, like, met him and was like,
Lizzie Logan
wasn't what to tell people.
Dana Schwartz
Yeah, okay. I mean, we don't have any information on that. We don't know what their relationship was, but it kind of reading between the lines, I'm like, I assume she was just like, go along with this. Let's have fun. And again, pretty young girl. So I think more people were willing to go along with it.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah. So is that how it ended, was when this woman, like, outed her after seeing her in the paper?
Dana Schwartz
Well, so once she sort of outed. And again, I think this woman also outed her in a very polite way. It doesn't seem like it was a real, like, cancel culture way. She was just like, oh, by the
Lizzie Logan
way, I know her.
Dana Schwartz
She used to talk gibberish. Yeah. The language was sort of. Now they realize it's a combination of gibberish and Romani words. And technically, because this is right after the Napoleonic War and impostering was an actual crime under British law, but I mean, because they're scared of spies during the war, so, like, you're not allowed to be an imposter. Okay. So what she's doing is against the law, but she isn't punished, which is, like, kind of cool. And what really happens, the person.
Lizzie Logan
Too pretty.
Dana Schwartz
Too pretty. But really, it was just like, well, this was all in good fun. And who everyone makes fun of is sort of the Bristol elites for believing that they were hosting a princess.
Lizzie Logan
Oh, yes.
Dana Schwartz
Like, look at these stupid rich people in Bristol who were so amused and, like, patting themselves on the back for having a royal guest.
Lizzie Logan
It's like when you see roundups of really, really drunk people who thought they met celebrities.
Dana Schwartz
Yeah.
Lizzie Logan
And it's just someone who took a picture with like a redheaded guy and was like, I met Ed Sheeran. And it's like, it's not Ed Sheeran.
Dana Schwartz
It. Exactly. Everyone is laughing at the people around her and, like, kind of give her a pass, I think. Mr. Nora, Mr. Worrell's bank collapses, probably because everyone's like, oh, yeah, this guy's terrible judgment.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah. I wouldn't trust him with my money.
Dana Schwartz
No. And again, maybe he's a cruel drunk. According to some sources, Mrs. Worrell, his wife, who was born in America, I think, feels bad because there's a lot of negative publicity around Mary now and arranges for her to travel to Philadelphia, possibly to escape the backlash. Basically, once she comes to America, she starts a show, she becomes like a performer. Very P.T. barnum style.
Lizzie Logan
Okay.
Dana Schwartz
But a little earlier. And so some of the things that she says, I will say are not true because she is saying them on stage.
Lizzie Logan
Right.
Dana Schwartz
But according to lore, allegedly when she was on the ship to America, a storm blew her off course and they came so close to St. Helena, where Napoleon was being held captive, that she took a small boat and rowed it on shore and met him. And he was enchanted by her and possibly became his mistress.
Lizzie Logan
Oh, funny.
Dana Schwartz
Maybe, Maybe not.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah, probably not. Feel like we'd know.
Dana Schwartz
Known liar. Tell story.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah.
Dana Schwartz
But amusing.
Public Ad Host
Support for the show comes from Public, the investing platform for those who take it seriously. On public, you can build a multi asset portfolio of stocks, bonds, options, crypto and now generated assets which allow you to turn any idea into an investable index. With AI, it all starts with your prompt. From renewable energy companies with high free cash flow to semiconductor suppliers growing revenue over 20% year over year. You can literally type anything, prompt and put the AI to work. It screens thousands of stocks, builds a one of a kind index and lets you back test it against the S&P 500. Then you can invest in a few clicks. Generated assets are like ETFs with infinite possibilities, completely customizable and based on your thesis, not someone else's. Go to public.com podcast and earn an uncapped 1% bonus when you transfer your portfolio. That's public.com podcast paid for by Public
Public Legal Disclaimer
Investing Brokerage Services by Open to the public Investing in member FINRA and SIPC Advisory services by Public Advisors llc. SEC Registered Advisor. Generated Assets is an interactive analysis tool. Output is for informational purposes only and is not an investment recommendation or advice.
Public Ad Host
Complete disclosures available@public.com disclosures are you really
Autotrader Ad Host 1
buying a car online on autotrader right now?
Autotrader Ad Host 2
Really?
Autotrader Ad Host 1
At a playground?
Dana Schwartz
Yeah.
Autotrader Ad Host 2
Really? Look at these listings from dealers.
Autotrader Ad Host 1
Wow, your search can really get that specific.
Autotrader Ad Host 2
Really?
Autotrader Ad Host 1
And you just put in your info and boom, car's in your budget.
Autotrader Ad Host 2
Mom needs a second.
Autotrader Ad Host 1
Honey, you can really have it delivered.
Autotrader Ad Host 2
Really? Or I can pick it up at the dealership. One sec, sweetie. Mommy's buying a car.
Autotrader Ad Host 1
Mommy, I think your kid is walking up the slide.
Autotrader Ad Host 2
Kyle.
Dana Schwartz
Again?
Autotrader Ad Host 2
Really? Auto trader. Buy your car online. Really?
Amazon Ad Host
Amazon presents Jeff vs. Taco Truck Salsa. Whether it's verde roja or the orange one, for Jeff, trying any salsa, salsa is like playing Russian roulette with a flamethrower. Luckily, Jeff saved with Amazon and stocked up on antacids, ginger tea and milk. Habanero. More like habanero. Yes. Save the everyday with Amazon.
Ryan Seacrest
Hey, it's Ryan Seacrest for Albertsons and Safeway. You don't want to miss the annual beauty event. For big savings on all your favorite beauty products now through April 28, spend $25 on participating products and save $5. Shop in store or online for items like Billie women's razors, Billie body buffer or body wash, native hand soap, Neutrogena makeup remover towelets, and Q tips. And save $5 when you spend $25. Offer ends April 28th. Restrictions apply. Offers may vary. Visit albertsons or safeway.com for more details.
Dana Schwartz
So in the US she tries to kind of capitalize on her fame and and appear on stage as Caribou. The thinking is that Americans are still smarting from the War of 1812. And so the idea is like, oh, aren't you gonna be entertained by this woman who fooled these dumb British people? And I also kind of think it's interesting how nowadays if someone is like, quote unquote, canceled, they kind of do their, like, villain arc tour.
Lizzie Logan
Yes.
Dana Schwartz
And the way they try to capitalize on that notoriety for money and public with that publicity is happening a hundred years, 200 years ago.
Lizzie Logan
Oh, yeah. You would just, like, write a tell all book.
Dana Schwartz
Yeah.
Lizzie Logan
This is. This is her tell all book.
Dana Schwartz
This is her tell all book.
Lizzie Logan
This is her going on Call her daddy.
Dana Schwartz
She's going on call her daddy. Except she's going on the Philadelphia stage. She writes a letter back to the worlds saying that it's really hard to be a celebrity. Just like her notoriety. Like, it's not like, oh, it's so hard to be famous, but, like, it's very uncomfortable the way everyone knows me, I don't like living here. And in 1824. So a handful of years later, she comes back to Britain, and then her life becomes pretty normal. In 1828, she's living as a widow, which is possibly not true. Maybe she just is living as a widow with the last name of a cousin, Mary Burgess. So it seems like she just sort of took on a fake name to avoid the notoriety from all of this. Okay. She marries a man named Richard Baker, which is why sometimes, if you see stories about her, she's referenced as Mary Baker. She gives birth to a daughter, Marianne. And in 1929, so little over a decade after all of this, she's making a living selling leeches to a Bristol.
Lizzie Logan
This is 1829.
Dana Schwartz
1829. Thank you.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah.
Dana Schwartz
1829, she is making a living selling leeches to the Bristol Infirmary Hospital. Which is a thing that you need to do. Yeah, these hospitals need leeches.
Lizzie Logan
They gotta get them leeches for the
Dana Schwartz
blood and the humors. Someone has to collect those leeches. And apparently she's making a respectable living. But she is still embarrassed about her notoriety. Children would run after her, calling Caribou. It's kind of like when a person who was on a sitcom then works at Trader Joe's.
Lizzie Logan
Yes.
Dana Schwartz
Because she's just the leech lady. She's just trying to have a respectable job with her husband and child. But that kind of embarrassment of this youthful summer is by all accounts, making her very uncomfortable. But she lives until her 70s. She dies around 72 or 73 years old on Christmas Eve, buried in Bristol in an unmarked grave. Cause they were very poor. And then this is like the very sad part about her story is her daughter takes up the family leech business and lives alone with a bunch of cats for the rest of her life until she dies in a fire in 1900. Oh, yeah.
Lizzie Logan
I mean, congrats on having a lot of cats. We love cats.
Dana Schwartz
We love cats.
Lizzie Logan
But that's very sad.
Dana Schwartz
It just is a very strange, sad, anticlimactic ending. Again, because she lives for decades after where it's like she really shined very bright this summer. Where she was in the news and on everyone's lips and then tried to capitalize on it in this show in America that wasn't that successful. Came back and tried to live a normal life, was sort of haunted by her reputation, and then did the best she could.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah, it. A little bit. I mean, I think that taking advantage of stereotypes aside, I find her quote unquote crime, like mostly Harmless. Yeah. And like, kind of fun.
Dana Schwartz
She's also not imitating a specific racial group. She is speaking nonsense. Yeah.
Lizzie Logan
But what it a little bit reminds me of is like, there's a comedian, an actor, like, lied about surviving 911 and like, that is just all he's ever going to be known for. And like, it's just done.
Dana Schwartz
Yeah, you're the 911 guy.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah. Like, that's it. And like, whatever boost he got from that is completely. I hope he enjoyed what like, whatever auditions that anecdote got him.
Dana Schwartz
But is over and again, it's like, this is a woman who was possibly mentally ill. I mean, suffered from mental issues after her rheumatism when she was a child, who was impoverished for her entire life. I'm not here to like, cancel this poor woman who was a beggar for most of her life. I think the larger issue to examine is that she was like a symptom of this 19th century British obsession with Eastern exoticism. And they were so amused by what was so obviously a fraud because they wanted to believe it. I read a few scholarly articles about this. And this historian, Matthew Isaac Cohen wrote an article about British Performances of Java, 1811-1822. And specifically he wrote about those years because not to get too deep into history, but if you've heard of like, the East Indies. Dutch East Indies, the Dutch colonized those islands and then England colonized those islands and then they went back. So this was like a period right after British colonization of the Indies. And he wrote that her performance offered, quote, a ground for imperial fantasy. I'm just gonna quote what he says, which is a theatricalized front to a British audience that was keen to believe in the possibility of the other coexisting in their midst. A representative of a foreign culture who was both totally unlike them and also not so distinct as to cause offense. It's like the perfect version of an other, which is like, it's not too many people. You're not gonna over. You're still the mighty Immigration. Not immigration. It's just one quirky princess who happens to be like a beautiful young woman doing fun things for our amusement. It sucks.
Lizzie Logan
They couldn't treat Meghan Markle like that. Oh, God, she should have been quirkier.
Dana Schwartz
You know who they. You know who they treat like that is Hilaria Baldwin. Realized this.
Lizzie Logan
Oh, my God. I would love. I mean, Hilaria Baldwin episode when.
Dana Schwartz
I mean, yeah, let's not get too deep into this, but Ellaria is doing a princess caribou. She realizes, you get more attention somewhere
Lizzie Logan
between Hilaria Baldwin and like Rachel Dolezal.
Dana Schwartz
Yeah, yeah.
Lizzie Logan
Because it's like, clearly she's not doing it to fit in with a real group of people. She's just doing it for attention.
Dana Schwartz
And she's fully just. Again, this is. She's not pretending to be a specific culture. She's saying she's from a made up place and speaking a gibberish language. Yeah, she is definitely using exoticized trappings of. Of Romani people and East Asian. East Asian people. But she's not do. She's specifically imitating a group that no one else is a part of.
Lizzie Logan
Really, what this more so reminds me of is like singers who pretend to be really poor growing up or like, you know what I mean? Or like how. I mean, we talk all the time about how artists always have to embellish their backstories and present themselves as like, really unusual and coming from some unexpected place when it's like, no, you just went to Idyllwild.
Dana Schwartz
Yeah, you don't. No one wants to be an artist who grew up in Brentwood.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah, but it's like you could get a bunch of face tattoos and now you're interesting and different and we want to listen to you rap.
Dana Schwartz
I mean, that's the interesting thing is like, she knew as a beggar that she would get more attention by being distinct and different. And she was completely correct. She became so famous in this one summer that we are still talking about her.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah.
Dana Schwartz
And I think that the person who should be in trouble, the bad guy of this episode isn't necessarily her. It's the system that did that. What I kind of find interesting is there's been like a slate of projects where she's sort of just the ingenue. Not even like an unlikable female character. Like, there's a 1994 movie starring Phoebe Cates.
Lizzie Logan
That is such good casting.
Dana Schwartz
Well, here's the also really interesting thing. Kate's is half Chinese. Filipino.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah. Because she's a little bit ethnically ambiguous, but also just like a drop dead hottie.
Dana Schwartz
Drop dead hottie. No one talked about the fact that she was, you know, East Asian when they were making that movie. That was not relevant. She was just red. She was a 90s, I guess I
Lizzie Logan
should say she reads ethnically ambiguous. I'm not saying that Phoebe Cates herself is just like an ambiguous blob in the world.
Dana Schwartz
No, I think what's interesting is like,
Lizzie Logan
obviously she's like a real person.
Dana Schwartz
90s Phoebe Cates was just white yes. That's just like, you see her, you're like, white lady. Yeah. But what I do find interesting is the fact that she actually is closer to what quote, unquote, Caribou was pretending to be. This is, by all accounts, not a very good movie. You can watch a trailer. I watch a trailer for it on YouTube. Apparently, Laura Benanti, not ethnically ambiguous, to the best of my knowledge, hosted a workshop for a musical version in 2004. And then in 2016, there was an off West End musical about her.
Lizzie Logan
Amazing.
Dana Schwartz
Which I kind of do feel like maybe.
Lizzie Logan
Maybe the Brits need to reckon with this a little bit.
Dana Schwartz
But that's it. I'm like the 1994 version. I read the Wikipedia and I watched the trailer. I did not watch the movie because my time is very limited. But it's very much sort of like a fairy tale version of this story where there's kind of no bad guys. And it's absolutely not reckoning with, like, racial othering. Yeah. That's just not what that movie is about. But I do think there is. If you are going to make a piece of art about Princess Caribou, that does seem to be the thing that you need to touch on, because otherwise there's just not a lot of There there. Yeah. It is just quirky that a random girl put on a turban and started acting insane and an entire town fell in love with her and she became an international news story.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah.
Dana Schwartz
That's so funny because she was a princess. Yeah. I mean, you also wonder, how long did she think she was gonna pull this off?
Lizzie Logan
Also, like, what was the, like, girl, you gotta stash away your money. Like, you gotta have an exit plan.
Dana Schwartz
You know what the exit plan should have been if I were her?
Lizzie Logan
Get married.
Dana Schwartz
You have to. You have to phase out the accent. It's raw. Have you seen that, Ross, on Friends?
Lizzie Logan
Many times.
Dana Schwartz
If you start with an accent, you have to phase it out.
Lizzie Logan
She, quote, unquote, learns English.
Dana Schwartz
She learns English, stops talking in an accent. And then in like a year, you just. People forget that you are the missing princess. And you're like, oh, yes, my ancestry is quite exotic. And then you marry a rich guy.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah, marry a rich guy.
Dana Schwartz
That would have, I guess, been my plan if I had been forced into a caribou situation. But she really. It was. This con did not last long. I mean, it lasted about two months.
Lizzie Logan
One special summer.
Dana Schwartz
One special summer.
Lizzie Logan
One amazing, wild summer.
Dana Schwartz
That is the story of Princess Caribou. A story about how we love sexy Dumb ladies from foreign lands or smart smart, Possibly smart ladies acting very dumb and childlike.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah.
Dana Schwartz
Lizzy Logan, where can the good people find you?
Lizzie Logan
You can talk to us @hooksthepodcast on Instagram. We love chatting.
Dana Schwartz
We love chatting followers.
Lizzie Logan
Yeah, go ahead, do it. Doesn't hurt. And Dana, what about you?
Dana Schwartz
Hoaxthepodcastmail.com I will get to your email sometimes a little slowly, but I do read all the emails. And Dana Schwartz on Instagram and TikTok with reezies. And I will also beg you if you're a listener of the show, please please pre order a copy of the book. The Arcane Arts Pre orders are the most important thing in the book world. They tell a publisher that this book is worth caring about and putting in bookstores. So if you like anything I'm doing, please pre order that book. This podcast is free. So it is.
Lizzie Logan
And if you like it, share it with a friend.
Dana Schwartz
Share it with a friend.
Lizzie Logan
Send it to someone.
Dana Schwartz
Thanks for listening.
Lizzie Logan
Please Hoax responsibly.
Dana Schwartz
Bye.
Lizzie Logan
Hoax is a production of I Heart Podcasts. Our hosts are Dana Schwartz and Lizzie Logan. Our executive producers are Matt Frederick and Trevor Young, with supervising producer Rima El Kayali and producers Noams Griffin and Jesse Funk. Our theme music was composed by Lane Montgomery. For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Thanks for listening.
Autotrader Ad Host 1
Are you really buying a car online on Autotrader right now?
Autotrader Ad Host 2
Really? I can get super specific with dealer listings and see cars based on my budget.
Autotrader Ad Host 1
You can really have it delivered or pick it up. I think kid is walking up the slide.
Autotrader Ad Host 2
Really? Auto trader Buy your car online? Really?
LifeLock Ad Host
It's tax season and by now we're all a bit tired of numbers. But here's an important one you need to hear. 16 billion. That's how much money in refunds the IRS flagged for possible identity fraud. But it's not all grim news. LifeLock monitors millions of data points per second and alerts you to threats you could easily miss on your own. If your identity is stolen, they'll fix it, guaranteed. Save up to 40% your first year. Visit lifelock.com iheart Terms apply.
Ryan Seacrest
Hey, it's Ryan Seacrest for Albertsons and Safeway. Take care of yourself this spring with great savings on all your favorite wellness brands. Now through April 28th. Save five doll when you buy three or more participating wellness items. Shop in store or online for products like centrum, silver, nexium, 24 hour, tums, ultra strength, or smoothies, tablets and flonase spray and save $5 when you buy three or more. Get these deals before they're gone. Offer ends April 28th. Restrictions apply. Offers may vary. Visit albertsons or safeway.com for more details.
Sheba Cat Food Ad Host
Here's the truth. You could literally be adored by everyone and then come home and still get completely ignored by your own cat. It's classic cat behavior, but new Shiba Premium Puree is a lickable treat that changes all that. They're protein rich, made with bone broth, and have the smooth, creamy texture cats go crazy for, especially when it's hand fed. Yeah, it's more than a treat. It's a fast pass to favorite human status. So feed your cat Sheba and go from totally ignored to truly adored in just 12 days, guaranteed or your money back. Learn more@shiba.com this is an iHeart podcast.
Dana Schwartz
Guaranteed human.
Podcast: Hoax!
Hosts: Dana Schwartz & Lizzie Logan
Episode Date: April 13, 2026
In this episode of Hoax!, Dana Schwartz and Lizzie Logan dive deep into the astonishing 19th-century tale of Princess Caribou—a beguiling woman who fooled an entire English town into believing she was foreign royalty. Using her expertise from a prior episode on Noble Blood, Dana unpacks not only the wild events of the hoax itself but also the broader context, motivations, and cultural climate that allowed such a deception to thrive. Along the way, the hosts reflect on historical gullibility, the dynamics of “otherness,” and why stories like these continue to captivate audiences.
Setting the Scene ([04:38])
Early Encounters
Physical Description and Social Reaction ([06:52])
The Power of Attractiveness
Society’s Fascination with the Exotic
The “Translation” and Creation Myth ([10:11])
Enthralling the Locals ([12:44])
Testing the Ruse ([21:00])
Exposure ([22:20])
Public Reaction & Social Commentary
Early Life and Quirks ([23:57])
Evolving the Hoax
Motivations and Context
Post-Unmasking ([29:15])
American Adventure and Celebrity ([31:08], [34:20])
Return to obscurity
Societal Willingness to Believe
Modern Parallels
Ongoing Cultural Fascination
Dana on “pretty privilege”:
“If you see an unhoused person or a felon who is very conventionally attractive, something in you is like, well, that person shouldn’t be there. They should be doing Pilates.” ([08:24])
Lizzie on Princess Caribou “committing to the bit”:
“I’m obsessed with her. I love her so much. This is incredible. I love how much she has committed to the bit.” ([22:26])
Dana on the historical context:
“[Her] performance offered… a theatricalized front to a British audience that was keen to believe in the possibility of the other coexisting in their midst.” ([39:06])
On how to really succeed as a hoaxer:
“You have to phase out the accent… If you start with an accent, you have to phase it out.” ([44:40])
On Princess Caribou’s fleeting fame:
Lizzie: "One special summer."
Dana: "One amazing, wild summer." ([45:16])
The story of Princess Caribou is an embodiment of society’s perennial hunger for novelty, sensation, and the exotic, all filtered through the lens of privilege, gullibility, and the desire to believe in a myth. Dana and Lizzie deftly unravel not just the facts of the hoax itself, but why such stories thrive—then and now—and what they reveal about us today.
For more from the hosts:
Please hoax responsibly!