Podcast Summary: "How Did This Get Made?" – Highlander II: The Quickening LIVE! w/ Sam Richardson

Release Date: July 1, 2025

Introduction

In this live episode of "How Did This Get Made?" (HDTGM) hosted by Paul Scheer, June Diane Raphael, and Jason Mantzoukas, the trio delves into the notorious sequel, Highlander II: The Quickening. Joined by comedian and actor Sam Richardson, the hosts attempt to unravel the convoluted plot of this widely criticized film, exploring its numerous plot holes, production mishaps, and overall reception.

Overview of Highlander II: The Quickening

Highlander II: The Quickening attempts to expand the original Highlander universe but quickly confuses both fans and newcomers with its intricate and poorly explained mythology. The sequel introduces the concept of the Highlanders being extraterrestrial beings from the planet Zeist, adding layers of time travel and alternate realities that stray far from the original narrative.

In-Depth Analysis and Critique

Plot Confusion and Character Dynamics

From the outset, the hosts express their bewilderment regarding the film's storyline. Paul Scheer reflects on the opening narration:

“I'm Dexter Morgan. I've been through hell, but now I'm back for my curtain call...” ([00:01])

This unconventional introduction sets the tone for the ensuing confusion.

Sam Richardson admits his unfamiliarity with the Highlander franchise:

“I have never seen Highlander. As such, I was like, oh, this must be all Highlander stuff that I'm not aware of because I didn't see Highlander.” ([07:18])

June Diane Raphael echoes the sentiment of frustration and anger toward the film's incoherence:

“I felt very scared that I had missed so much. But here's the thing. I didn't understand any of it, but I also didn't care to understand it. Yeah, that's the other part of that. I didn't care to. And that's what made me angry.” ([05:56])

Production Issues and Multiple Cuts

The discussion reveals significant production turmoil, including multiple endings and cuts that left the narrative disjointed:

“They shot three endings. There are three cuts of this movie. And the director left at a certain point, so there are some giant plot holes in it.” ([29:10])

The Renegade Cut attempts to present a version where Highlanders are from another planet, but this addition only further complicates the already tangled storyline. The hosts criticize the lack of coherence and logical progression, making it difficult for audiences to follow.

Character and Mythology Inconsistencies

The film’s mythology, particularly the introduction of characters like Sean Connery’s Ramirez and the concept of the "Quickening," is a focal point of frustration:

“The only Scottish person in the movie played a Spaniard by. Or an Egyptian, by the way of Spain. So he's a Highlander... What makes Christopher Lambert special?” ([74:02])

Jason Mantzoukas summarizes their collective confusion:

“I spent not understanding anything that was going on.” ([07:18])

Notable Quotes and Moments

Throughout the episode, the hosts share notable quotes from the film that highlight its absurdity and lack of continuity. One standout moment involves a parody of a Hamlet scene:

“Alas, poor Yorick. I knew him, Horatio... What's your fucking game, shithead?” – Sean Connery’s Ramirez ([37:12]–[38:25])

This blend of Shakespearean references with crude humor exemplifies the film’s erratic tone.

Audience Reactions and Reviews

The hosts examine real and fabricated reviews, further cementing the film's reputation:

• Five-Star Reviews: Absurdly positive comments that seem out of place, such as “Just what my child wanted” and “My fantasies get tickles by the dream...” ([88:08]–[89:00])

• One-Star Reviews: Genuine confusion and disappointment, exemplified by statements like “I am just confused by this plot.” ([90:23])

Roger Ebert's scathing critique is also referenced:

“Plot of Highlander 2, the Quickening is one of the most hilariously incomprehensible experiences I've had in a long time.” ([91:00])

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

After an exhaustive and often exasperated discussion, the hosts reach a unanimous conclusion:

“The movie was a piece of shit... It fucked me up.” – Jason Mantzoukas ([92:54]–[93:04])

They lament the film’s inability to present a coherent story, its reliance on nonsensical plot devices, and poor character development. Despite the hosts' efforts to dissect and understand the film, Highlander II: The Quickening ultimately stands as a testament to how a sequel can dramatically falter by deviating too far from its source material without providing a satisfying narrative for audiences.

Closing Remarks

The episode wraps up with plugs for upcoming projects and other shows the hosts enjoy, maintaining their signature blend of humor and camaraderie. They express their appreciation for their live audience and the continued support from listeners.

Key Takeaways:

• Highlander II: The Quickening is widely regarded as a poorly executed sequel with a confusing and convoluted plot.
• Production issues, including multiple cuts and unresolved plot holes, contributed to the film’s negative reception.
• The hosts of HDTGM highlight the importance of coherent storytelling and staying true to the essence of the original material in sequels.

Notable Quotes:

• Paul Scheer: “I spent not understanding anything that was going on.” ([07:18])
• June Diane Raphael: “I felt very scared that I had missed so much... And that's what made me angry.” ([05:56])
• Jason Mantzoukas: “I am still, like. I can't, like, think. This movie broke me.” ([93:04])

Timestamp Highlights:

• 00:01 – 01:02: Introductory advertisements skipped.
• 07:18: Sam Richardson reveals he hasn’t seen the original Highlander.
• 29:10: Discussion on multiple film cuts and their impact on the plot.
• 37:12 – 38:25: Clip and analysis of a chaotic Hamlet-themed scene.
• 90:23 – 91:00: Examination of audience reviews and Roger Ebert’s critique.
• 92:54 – 93:04: Hosts unanimously express their disdain for the film.

Note: This summary excludes advertisements, introductory segments, and non-content sections to focus solely on the discussion and analysis of Highlander II: The Quickening. Readers unfamiliar with the podcast or the film will gain a comprehensive understanding of the hosts' perspectives and critiques.