Loading summary
Mikayla
Hi guys. And welcome back to I'll read what she's reading. I'm Mikayla.
Reggie
I'm Reggie.
Kennedy
And I'm Kennedy.
Mikayla
And today we're going to be talking about book to movie slash TV adaptations. Before we begin that we're going to update you guys on. Remember a few episodes ago we picked books for each other to read and so we're going to update each other on what we rated them, what we liked them and everything like that.
Kennedy
So that was kind of a long time ago. Two months ago probably.
Mikayla
So when I say a couple episodes, probably like several.
Reggie
10, who knows, 10 episodes ago.
Mikayla
If you are a first time listener, we sometimes do a little segment where we, we pick books for each other to read and then we, you know, report back. Yeah, report back about it. So this is our update on the last time we picked books for each other.
Kennedy
So you should go first, Michaela.
Mikayla
Okay. So Kennedy picked for me and it was Scythe. Did I pronounce it correct? By Neil?
Kennedy
It's like Schusterman or something.
Mikayla
Shot. Yeah, Scythe. It's like with the red cover with the, you know, little. Anyways, it was, it was really, it was really good. I think I rated it 3.53. The world itself was very interesting and different, which I really enjoyed. I just have had a hard time with young adults characters recently. And it's not even like when I read it. It's just like every young adult character I've been reading has just been driving me crazy. So I think it was more a me problem than like a book problem. But it, I really liked how different it was from like some of the other books I was reading. So I think it was a really great pick. I did read the first two in the series and I thought they were really good. I, I liked the ending of the second one a lot. Kennedy advised me to not read the third one and I can, I can understand why and I will eventually look up the synopsis for it. But I. Yeah.
Kennedy
Did you know there's a fourth book coming out? No, I'm pretty sure it's out. I think it's like a 0.5, but it's thick.
Mikayla
Is it?
Kennedy
And I will not be reading that one.
Mikayla
I think it's like 3.5.
Kennedy
I, I agree with you. The world is really cool and the concept is very interest, but after the first and second, it just got a little convoluted and a little wild. So. Yeah. But I did talk to somebody who read the series and loved every single book. So if you're looking for a young adult dystopian unique book. I would recommend that, but go into it with really low expectations. It's not anything that's revolutionary, I thought.
Mikayla
I didn't realize it was going to be like dystopian for some reason. I really had little. Little knowledge about it. I really. I didn't read the back. I don't know why I thought it was going to be like kind of fantasy, but it wasn't at all. Not really.
Kennedy
It's more dystopian than fantasy. Yeah.
Mikayla
Way more dystopian. Because it's like in the future, if that's how our world became. So it was. Yeah, it was a wild ride. So he wants to report next, Reggie.
Reggie
I will report. I was gonna say I can't really see you. Hi. Okay. Michaela picked the Things We Live Unfinished by Rebecca Yaros for me. And I thought I gave it four stars, but I gave it five stars. I thought I gave it four. But a very, very good read. I loved that. It was dual point of view and also dual timeline. If you're familiar with Rebecca Yarros romance Books, not 4th Wing. She writes a lot of like military romance. And so there's like present day and then there's flashbacks. And it was very, very good. I really liked it. I was glad Michaela picked it for me because it's been one of those books that has been on my TBR for a long time, but it's almost been on my TBR for so long that I kind of forgot that it was on my tbr And I was really glad I finally got the push to read it because I really enjoyed it. There wasn't anything I disliked about it got me in my feels. And I would recommend that book to many, many people. So. Yeah. And the. The audiobook. I listened to part of the audiobook. The audiobook's fun too, because there's lots of different voices and characters and stuff. So.
Kennedy
Yeah.
Mikayla
I'm so glad you liked it.
Reggie
Yeah, it was pretty good.
Mikayla
That's good. You also read it.
Kennedy
I did read it and I really liked it.
Mikayla
Yeah, it is.
Kennedy
It's a tear jerker.
Mikayla
It is.
Reggie
It is a tearjerker. I wasn't expecting. I. I don't know what I was expecting when I started the book. I know a lot of people say they cry in it, so I was like, okay. Like, it might be like an emotional book, which it was. But it was also. There were so many other elements to it that I wasn't anticipating, which made it really Fun. So check out the things we leave unfinished. If you're needing a book to make you cry. Yeah, it's good. Just a good.
Kennedy
Yeah. Feel good book Reggie picked for me. She only picked the first book in the War of Lost Hearts trilogy, but I read all of them. The first one is Daughter of Daughter of no Worlds. So the War of Lost Hearts trilogy slash Daughter of no Worlds by Carissa Broadbent. And she didn't pick the third book, but the third book in the trilogy was my favorite. Very good. Um, I. There was one part in the first book where I sobbed on a golf cart in front of my husband and his friends. It was rather embarrassing. But there's just something that happens in the first book that really sends you.
Reggie
Into orbit about this trilogy. And I get to hear every single time.
Kennedy
Um, very fun trilogy. A lot of people compare it to Throne of Glass, which I don't like that comparison at all because I feel like I saw so many tiktoks comparing it to Throne of Glass. So I feel like I went into it expecting Throne of Glass, so I was a little disappointed. So don't go into it expecting Throne of Glass. I saw people compare the third book in the trilogy to Kingdom of Ash.
Reggie
Yeah. I don't know why.
Kennedy
I hate that comparison.
Reggie
I don't understand.
Kennedy
But very, very good trilogy. I do wish that it would have been a duology like the Crowns of Nyxia series. There were certain parts in the first and second book that just felt really repetitive and kind of like, what are we doing here? So I do think it could have been longer a lot. Like two long books. Like two 700 page books, 800 page books. The magic system is really cool and the main male character is just a little sweetie pie. I want to hug him and just love on him. So, yeah. Overall, I gave the series four stars, which is amazing. So I'm very glad she recommended it to me because I don't know when I would have gotten to it had she not recommended it.
Reggie
Yeah. I selfishly just needed someone to talk to about it.
Kennedy
So now we'll just read it. I do think you'll really enjoy it.
Mikayla
Okay.
Kennedy
I've also just been a really big hater lately. For some reason, no books I read have been hitting like I want them to. And I just. It's a me problem. It is a me problem. I haven't had a five star read in like three months.
Mikayla
Yeah. I just feel really nervous to pick up a lot of these books.
Kennedy
Have we hit our peak? Have we hit our Peak in reading, everyone.
Reggie
No.
Mikayla
And I. I think it's just because you enjoy those. You guys both enjoy Red Rising and Daughter of no World so much, and I'm, like, nervous that I'm not going to enjoy them.
Reggie
Going with low expectations.
Kennedy
Yeah. But you know what? Here's the thing. Our podcast guest for next week. Surprise. Guys, we have a podcast guest. I'm not going to say who it is. I saw her read Red Rising and she rated it 2 1/2 stars. So you know what? And I wasn't. I didn't have a breakdown. So if you read Red Rising and you don't like it, I'm going to be okay. I will be okay.
Reggie
I think it's just like, you want to enjoy it.
Kennedy
I do.
Reggie
Yeah.
Mikayla
And it's been hyped up quite a bit. Not just from you guys, but from everyone else.
Reggie
Yeah.
Mikayla
So I feel. I feel really nervous when books are hyped up to me. And I've been trying to really hard to not hype books up for other people at all. I just say, like, oh, they're really good. I think you'll enjoy it. And that's as much as I say, because I feel like there's this pressure behind when people hype up books. And if I don't feel the same, I'm like, is something wrong with me? And so I don't know. That's just. I feel really nervous. There's like, quite a few books I have on my full TBR that I just have not touched because I'm, like, so nervous. I don't know why. Anyways, I just read Fable and I had no expectations for it and I absolutely loved them so much. And so I'm like, maybe I just need to, like, just give myself no expectations for some of these books and then hopefully I'll like them.
Kennedy
Hey, it makes you feel any better, the first Red Rising book is the worst one, so.
Reggie
Okay.
Kennedy
Okay.
Reggie
Yeah.
Mikayla
Anyways, I think that was all we needed to update on, Right?
Reggie
Yeah.
Mikayla
Should we get into our episode?
Kennedy
Yeah, yeah.
Mikayla
Talking about movies and TV shows that were first books, so.
Kennedy
And speaking of books that I have probably overhyped for a lot of people, we can start off with the first book to TV adaptation, which is Dark Matter by Blake Crouch. I really, really loved that book. It made me fall in love with sci fi. If you guys haven't listened to me talk about it before, just a really good book that completely surprised me in every way. And the TV show was done actually really well. I was feeling really scared to watch the TV show just because of how much I loved the book and how highly I think of the book. But honestly, I think they did such a great job. Absolutely incredible.
Mikayla
It's really good. I really liked it.
Kennedy
I will say the first if you haven't read the book, watching the show. The first probably like four or five episodes were a little slow. Kind of like, can we move on? Can we get this going? At least for me, I thought they were a little slow. My husband also thought it was a little slow because he hadn't read the books. But he watched the show with me. But the last three episodes, roller coaster, intense.
Reggie
They definitely changed some things. But honestly I was a big fan of most of the changes that they made. So it's one of those. I think I said this on the podcast before, but my husband watched it with me and when we were done watching the show, he was like, why didn't you tell me to read the book first? And I was like, I told you to read the book first. But you're like, oh, just watch the show. So he really wishes he would have read the book because after one of the episodes he like pulled open the book because I had it sitting out. And he probably read like four or five chapters. He just sat there and just kept like reading it. And then I was like, okay, you gotta stop at like this page. Cause that's when like the current episode we had just watched ends and. And he was like, yeah, I really wish I would have read this book. And it was really easy to. It's a not a very long book, so definitely pick up the book first. Yeah, a fun sci fi kind of thrillery, in a sense. Ish.
Kennedy
Kyle thought it was scary, so. But he thinks a lot of things are scary. He was scared the last few episodes.
Mikayla
He was like, they're intense.
Reggie
Yeah. Very intense suspense.
Mikayla
Yeah.
Reggie
Yeah. So yeah, that's probably one of my favorite book to TV adaptations I've seen.
Mikayla
So it's also one that you can watch with anyone. Like all of our husbands really enjoyed it. So like if you're a book girly that has a significant other or is married and they're not book readers, I think they would really enjoy it and it's something you guys can both do together. So it was. Yeah, it was really good. I really liked it.
Kennedy
I squid like a little girl at certain episodes. I was just. There were a few things that were in the books that I was going to be really upset if they were not in the show. And we're winding down to the last few episodes, and those things still hadn't happened, and I was so upset. But they were there.
Mikayla
They were there.
Kennedy
They added all the good that was from the book and added some things to the TV show that I think made it a lot more interesting for tv.
Mikayla
Yeah, it was. Well done.
Kennedy
Congrats. Blake Crouch. You did a great job.
Mikayla
Did a great.
Reggie
Five stars. Five, ten stars. All right, next one I have not seen. So I'll let you guys. I haven't seen it. I haven't read it. Okay, so I'll let you guys discuss. At this point. I don't know. Okay, let me tell you the book real quick. A Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. I don't even know if I'm gonna read the book at this point because I feel like I've seen spoilers on TikTok from, like, fan edits that people.
Kennedy
Have made, so I have not seen the movie. Oh, I know, I know. I know. You haven't seen the movie. No, I haven't seen the movie yet. Okay. Read the book. Even though I haven't seen the movie. Michaela, you can say whether or not this is accurate or not.
Reggie
All right.
Kennedy
I wish I would have just watched the movie, not read the book.
Mikayla
Yeah, yeah. It's okay. The thing is, as far as book to TV adaptations, it's exactly the same. Exact. Everything is the exact same.
Reggie
It's almost like. Did you think she wrote it knowing, like, this is. Because here's the thing, they're gonna be doing the Haymitch one, but that's not gonna be another book, is it? It's just. They just are doing a TV series.
Mikayla
I think it's a book.
Reggie
So they're gonna. The book's gonna come out and then the movie's gonna come out right after.
Mikayla
Yeah, I think so. Yeah. Yeah.
Reggie
Interesting.
Mikayla
I think that she started writing it knowing exactly that it was going to be a movie. And it's. It's. Which is awesome that it's the exact same. But, I mean, you don't really. The only thing that's different is you just get more inner dialogue.
Reggie
Yeah.
Mikayla
With Snow. Cornelius. Snow. Than you do, like, in the movie, because obviously he's not going to be talking out loud, speaking to himself. So. Yeah, it was pretty much like the exact same. I mean, it has been a little bit since I've read the book, and it's been a little bit since I've watched the movie. You guys can correct me if I'm wrong if there is, like, any differences, but if there is I feel like they're so minor that I just, like, don't even remember so well.
Reggie
I don't know if I love the fact that they're doing the Haymitch story in a book and then a movie, and they've already casted who Haymitch is. Like, I kind of wish I could have.
Kennedy
Who's Haymitch again?
Reggie
Mike Feist, which I'm stoked about. Love him to death. But I almost don't love that I know who. Like, it feels weird to know there's a movie. It's kind of like with Fourth Wing. Like, we know, for example, like, I'm going to be reading Onyx Storm, and I know I don't know who's casted yet, but I'm like, you're telling me I'm going to be reading Onyx Storm knowing, like, this is going to be. There's just something about that that I don't love. It feels a little more exciting to read a book, love it, and then come to find out, oh, they're making a show out of it. It kind of feels weird to do it in a backwards type of order, like, at the same time.
Mikayla
But I guess that happened with Game of Thrones. Oh, like, the books aren't complete.
Kennedy
Yeah. The directors had to. The writers of the show made up an ending to. To the show. So at. At the point where everybody starts to think Game of Thrones goes downhill is when the books end and then the directors and the writers wrote the end of the show. And that's why everybody was so upset, because the books never. The books still aren't over, I don't think.
Mikayla
I. I heard a rumor that he's like, I don't think they'll ever get the endings.
Kennedy
I could see that. Isn't that weird?
Reggie
Is so sad.
Kennedy
But what's funny is so obviously Divergent is another TV adaptation, which we're not going to talk about because it's kind of, you know, old news. I will say, though, when I read the Divergent books, I loved being able to picture the actors as the characters. So maybe it's just because that felt nostalgic to me because Divergent is so old. I'm not sure. But it is weird that she's writing books with the intention of them being movies.
Reggie
But, hey, get your bag, girl.
Kennedy
I'm still gonna go see it.
Reggie
Yeah. I mean, I'm a lot more interested in reading the Haymitch story than I probably was the snow story.
Kennedy
So I don't know. It was pretty. Like, it Was good.
Mikayla
What was the best part to me was this was the very beginning of the Hunger Games.
Reggie
Yeah.
Mikayla
So they did not have, like, all these things, like, all these, like, kinks.
Reggie
Yeah.
Mikayla
In the Hunger Games was like, I can't. What. What Hunger Games game? Is it 10? Yeah.
Kennedy
It's like, really?
Reggie
Yeah.
Mikayla
And so I found that the most interesting was, like, pretty much how it started and, like, where it began versus where it's at. And a lot of the things were his idea.
Reggie
Yeah. I feel like I would have enjoyed it had I picked it up when it first came out.
Kennedy
Yeah.
Reggie
But now that it's been out a while and I still haven't read it and I feel like I've seen spoilery.
Kennedy
Things I think you could see. I wish I would have just watched it and not read it. Because I will say I do feel like I loved the casting.
Mikayla
Yeah.
Reggie
Oh, yeah.
Kennedy
They did a great job doing the casting.
Reggie
And so I'm pretty sure I've seen, like, the very end scene already. That's what. So, yeah.
Kennedy
Going along the same lines of childhood young adult nostalgia books. We have the Uglies, and Michaela is the only one that has watched it. And based on her reaction, I probably will not be watching it. Yeah.
Reggie
You know, one of my biggest regrets in my life is that I told Michaela to read the Uglies book, and she read them. I just forgot how bad they were. I loved them as a middle schooler love them. So in my mind, I was like, she's gonna love them because she loved, you know, like, Maze Runner, Percy Jackson, that kind of stuff. Yeah. I forgot how, like, bad those books are. They're just not great. And I think I had this hope that the movie. And like I said, haven't seen it like anybody said, but I had this hope that this movie was going to somehow bring back more of that dystopian vibe that we've all been missing in our lives. And from the reviews that I've seen, the clips I've seen of it on TikTok, big thumbs down. Unfortunately, I still am intrigued. I might hate watch it. And. Yeah. One day.
Kennedy
One day.
Mikayla
I really just think when you're older, those books just seem really bad. But when you're younger and your world is a little bit smaller.
Reggie
Yes.
Mikayla
It seems like this really fantastic world. And like, I. It's honestly just the lingo and verbiage of the book that really drove me crazy. I love the idea of it. I do. I love, like, you know, like, you're in a society where everyone's ugly until you're made beautiful. But just the lingo of it drove me insane. Drove me insane. But the movie. I just wasn't a big fan of the casting. Except for what's his name? I can't remember.
Kennedy
I'll look it up for you.
Mikayla
He is very cute. He did a really good job. And I feel sad that this is like. I feel like one of the only movies I have seen him in. Keith Powers, he. He did so good. I. He was the best part of the movie. He was so good that he was the only person I liked.
Kennedy
So was it cheesy? It was so cheesy. Okay.
Mikayla
It was pretty dang cheesy.
Kennedy
How was the cgi?
Mikayla
Pretty terrible. Okay, well, if you guys could tell with the. The bold glamour on her, like, did.
Reggie
They just use all their budget on Joey King and Chase Stokes? And what's the other person in it that I saw? There's a lucky blue Smith in it.
Kennedy
Yeah, for like, in like, a party scene.
Reggie
That's so random. I wonder if that was like he was in.
Mikayla
He was a part of the beautiful community.
Reggie
Oh, of course he was.
Mikayla
Yeah. You know, because he couldn't be anything.
Reggie
Hey, imagine getting that email.
Mikayla
Hey, get your bag.
Reggie
I just need you.
Mikayla
Because your wife is getting it right now.
Reggie
I mean, Nara's probably making more off of a single Tick Tock video than he probably made being in that movie. Let's be real.
Mikayla
But no, it was. It was. I. Yeah, it's definitely something.
Reggie
All right, so if anyone enjoyed it, I would love to know.
Mikayla
I think there were quite a few people who really did like it.
Kennedy
So maybe it felt. I think I saw one Tick Tock that the girl was like. It just felt really nostalgic for her because she had read those in middle school. Absolutely loved them. And so then.
Reggie
Yeah, I almost wonder because you read that where. I did read it, like, years and years and years ago. I don't know. I don't remember too much about it, but I'm definitely gonna give it a watch. Mark my word.
Mikayla
Mark my word. All right. This was turned into a TV series. A Good Girl's Guide to Murder. I have read the series. We've all read the series. Me and Reggie are the only ones that have watched it. I have some beef with it. Yeah, that's it. I don't know. They didn't make it a freaking podcast. It pisses me off.
Reggie
So. So in the book. Okay, so we've talked about A Good Girl's Guide to Murder. If you're New. It's a. And you haven't heard about the Netflix show or the book. Essentially, it is a book about a girl in high school who has to do this final project, and she chooses to do her, like, paper on this unsolved murder that happened in her community.
Mikayla
Yeah.
Reggie
And so she's trying to solve this murder, and in the process, she makes a podcast and is podcasting the whole updates on everything. And they didn't include anything like that in the movie except for, like, she makes a video or something. And I don't even know if that followed the plot too much. Like, it was different in the book. Here's my thing. I know you didn't love it. I mean, I wish it would have been part of it. I think I can just understand why they maybe didn't. And I think it's because there have been a lot of shows recently that have had podcasting involved in it. Especially, like, only Murders in the Building, for example, got really popular because it's about people who are trying to solve a murder with a podcast. I wonder if, like, maybe that played part into it. Maybe not. But I do think it would have been a lot more fun to have the podcast element to it because I feel like it kind of adds in the series a little more suspense in a sense. Well, you know, like, if you can.
Kennedy
Cut this out, if this is a spoiler. But does she gain. Because in the book, she starts to gain traction on her podcast.
Reggie
Yes. There's none of that in the series.
Kennedy
So how are they going to continue on with the next book? Book.
Reggie
That was my question.
Mikayla
I was curious, how do you do.
Kennedy
That without that element?
Reggie
So I don't know. This fly is.
Kennedy
Okay.
Mikayla
Well, with only MERS in the building, I have watched all three seasons in the podcast. You see them doing the podcast, like, maybe for 10 seconds. That's not even, like, that's not even the part of. Really part of the story. And so I don't know. I think it really. I think it was really a miss when they didn't incorporate that because it's such a big. A big part of the story. But I mean, I understand why, like you said. But I think it was a mess in my. Because I. I don't know how they're gonna further without that backstory. Yes.
Reggie
Yeah, yeah. No, I, I. Yes, I was. I kept waiting. Every episode I was like, wait, when is this gonna happen? And it just. Yeah, so it will be interesting to see because I. Besides that, I thought it was very well done. Like, I don't know if I just had really low expectations, but I really enjoyed watching it. I thought the cast was really great, the overall vibes and just, like, visually I thought it was really cool. But yeah, moving forward, if they're gonna do a season two, which I feel like a lot of people really liked it. It was rated fairly highly on Netflix when I was watching it, at least. I'm just curious to see if maybe they. Maybe she starts a podcast in the second season. But this I don't know. But, yeah, I would love to ask why that didn't happen. So my.
Mikayla
Another complaint is it's just really dark. I couldn't watch it during the day.
Kennedy
I couldn't see anything.
Reggie
Yeah, I remember at one point, like, I was vacuuming or what was I doing? I was doing. I wasn't vacuuming because I wouldn't have been able to hear it. I just remember I was, like, cleaning something up in my living room and I kept, like, pacing in my room to try and see if I could get, like, a better view of my tv. Like, yeah, the last episode was like, I couldn't see anything. No, I had a lot.
Mikayla
I need to watch it.
Reggie
I felt like an audiobook a little bit.
Kennedy
So did you guys feel like it was cheesy, Like a young adult show?
Reggie
Yeah, no, not so much. I mean, like, when I. I guess when you say like, cheesy kind of young adult, I automatically think Riverdale. I don't know why. It didn't give Riverdale vibes to me. Maybe it did to you. I thought it was very. I thought it was. I mean, it definitely seemed like younger. Like a younger audience could still watch it, but, like, I don't think my husband would. Would have enjoyed watching it with me, but. Because, I mean, yeah, they are in high school, but it didn't feel like. It didn't feel cheesy to me, but it did feel young. Okay, so you'll have to let us know what you think when you watch it one day.
Kennedy
This next book I wanted to include because I feel like it doesn't get. The book doesn't get talked about and the TV show doesn't really get talked about. It is the Silo trilogy by Hugh Howey. The first book is called Wool. I can't remember if the TV show on Apple TV is called Wool or Silo. But the second season is actually coming out here shortly, if it isn't already out by the time this episode drops. But if you liked Fallout, you would probably like Silo. Fallout is probably a little bit More of a fun, campy vibe. And Silo is a little bit more of a dark vibe. But basically it's a dystopian society where people live in a silo because outside of the Silo, the earth is uninhabitable. And it just kind of talks about like the people living in the silo, their community, conspiracy theories they have about the outside world. And it follows a woman who is like a detective in her silo.
Reggie
So there's how many books? There's three and then there's the TV show cover. All three books or just the first from?
Kennedy
I've actually never seen the TV show, but from what I understand based on the trailers where I don't think the episode the TV show ends where book one ends. I think the TV show ends in like the middle of book one from what I've kind of seen. But I think I rated the book like three and a half or four stars. It was really fun. It's like a dystopian adult book. A little slow paced, but not anything you have to move up on your TBR and honestly maybe just go watch the show. But I just never hear it getting talked about. And it actually has some really big actors in the show and I feel like Apple TV always does such a good job with their shows.
Reggie
Yeah.
Kennedy
When you think about like dark matter or shrinking or what's the one with the guy from Parks and Rec?
Reggie
Ted Lasso.
Kennedy
Ted Lasso. But that's not the one I was thinking of. I feel like Apple TV does really well with their shows. So go give that a watch and if you like the show, then read the book.
Reggie
So you would recommend the show then? The book?
Kennedy
I mean, I've never seen the show.
Reggie
The book.
Kennedy
The book is just a little slow moving. I listened to it and read it, which helped a lot, but different.
Reggie
I'm intrigued.
Kennedy
Consequence, you know.
Reggie
Sweet.
Mikayla
That's fun.
Reggie
This next one we're going to talk about is probably one of my favorite TV or book to TV adaptations. Although they did change a few things like they always do. And that is Daisy Jones and the Six. So Kennedy, I think we've all seen the show.
Kennedy
Mm.
Reggie
Mikayla hasn't read the book.
Kennedy
Mikayla will not be reading the book.
Reggie
She will not. I would actually be. So I'm trying to decide if like Mikayla had not read any previous Taylor Jenkins Reid books. If she had read Daisy Jones and the Six, I still don't think she would have really, really liked it. But it's just very diff. It's written very differently than any book I've read because it's kind of like a. It's just dialogue.
Kennedy
It's like an interview style.
Reggie
Yeah. Which is really cool. But I. I loved the. The TV show, so Daisy Jones and the Six Taylor Jenkins Reid. If you've read like Seven Husbands or heard of Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo, it's in that same. Same author. Literally, it's just a book about drug, sex and rock and roll. You know, that's pretty much. You know. And I loved it. I loved it so much. I was a little nervous about the TV show going into it, but I ended up absolutely loving it, even though there are a few things that made me a little angry. I thought Sam Claflin did a very phenomenal job. However, I just do think he was a little too old.
Kennedy
Yeah.
Reggie
And he. I would have loved them to have picked someone younger with some musical background behind them. I think it's awesome that he was like, yeah, I'm going to sing. And he did fairly well for having no experience in that regard. But, like, they learned the instruments and, like, it was very fun to watch. Yeah. His acting, I thought he was great. He just. In my mind, I'm like, he needed to just be younger and have a little more rock star vibe to him. I mean, I think he played the rock star well. But, like, when it came to actually performing and singing, I'm like, the musical person in me was like, please give me someone whose voice I'm like, drooling over. And I wasn't. But I thought the rest of the cast was amazing.
Kennedy
So I will say the soundtrack had me in a chokehold for like a month after watching it. So, you know, I actually went to. Oh, sorry, what's her name?
Reggie
Elvis's granddaughter.
Mikayla
I don't know.
Reggie
Oh, it's bothering me that I can't think of her name.
Kennedy
Anyways, she was fantastic.
Reggie
Yeah, she was great. I went to a photo shoot recently and the photographer was playing music and one of the songs from there came on and I was like, did you watch this TV show? And she was like, yeah, I read the book and I loved it. And so then we were like, talking about it, so. Yeah, that's fun.
Kennedy
I do think the TV show made me like the book more.
Reggie
Yeah.
Kennedy
In a weird way. But what did you think about it? Having not read the book?
Mikayla
I thought it was okay. I don't know. I feel like I was just. Wasn't super invested. But I'm also not a person who normally likes those kind of shows. So it was. Yeah, it was good.
Reggie
Yeah. Music. The music behind it is really cool. And also it's set in, like, the 70s, so that vibe, really fun. I actually really want to re. Watch the show. My husband started watching with me and then we forgot that we had been watching it. So. Yeah, I loved it.
Kennedy
I mean, it makes a lot of sense that you really loved the show and the book because, like, it's just kind of who you are as a person. And. Yeah, you didn't really enjoy it because it's kind of like, not. Yeah. Things you're super interested in, so it makes sense why, you know.
Mikayla
Yeah. I also thought Sam Claflin was a.
Kennedy
Little old, so Camilla, though, that actress, she's so stunning. Oh, my gosh.
Mikayla
So pretty.
Reggie
So good.
Mikayla
Honestly, it's. To me, it's not a super memorable show. Like, I don't remember a ton from it. I just. I know the basis of it, but I don't remember, like, anything. So I don't think I would ever watch it again. But also, I just haven't been watching shows at all.
Reggie
So. Can we take a quick pause? Because this has been talked about a lot on TikTok, and I just feel like we need to say something about. On the podcast. I don't think you guys have started it yet, but nobody wants this.
Kennedy
Oh, so good.
Reggie
And I just have to say I saw a TikTok that was a girl saying the reason why this show is so fun to watch is because she said it feels like you're reading, like, your favorite romance book. Like, it kind of gives you that feeling. Not to, like, over. No, not to, like, over hype it or anything, because, like, there's some things about it that maybe I didn't love, but it was very bingeable, very cute. And it's about these two sisters who started a podcast. Anyways, if you guys are needing something to watch, but you're like, I don't want to read a book before I watch something it's not. There's no book, but you can go watch. Nobody wants this. If you want, just, like, cute little rom com. Because I love it. I think it's. It's a very memorable TV show for me. And I know it seems fresh, but it was very great. So I just feel like I had a insert. Insert that.
Kennedy
What's his name? Adam Brody, Right?
Reggie
Yes. He's so freaking cute.
Kennedy
I loved him in the O.C.
Reggie
Yeah.
Kennedy
And he's married to Blair Leighton Meester.
Reggie
Yeah. Their chemistry, it's so great. And, yeah, it's just like a. It's a fun watch. So. Yeah, I just had to add that in there. So anyways, I'll get to that eventually. Back to books.
Mikayla
I don't know when I will, but.
Kennedy
I gotta watch A Good Girl's Got to Murder. I gotta watch A Ballad of Songbirds and Stakes. Don't you. I'll get to it. The next book. TV adaptation we're going to talk about is. It's all about Michaela. Well, it's all on Michaela because I've never read or seen the Percy Jackson series. So, Michaela, the floor is yours.
Mikayla
Okay, fiance. Just kidding. I loved the Percy Jackson series growing up, and so I made it a goal to reread them before the TV show came out. And so it was very fresh on my brain and it was good. It followed. I feel like it follows the book pretty closely. It is like a. Like a young. Like, it's geared towards, you know, younger. A younger audience. But it was very nostalgic for me. I'm really excited about season two. I don't know if you guys have seen. His voice has changed so much, and it's so cute. He's just like, growing up and it's so fun because that's kind of how Harry Potter was worth these kids, just getting to watch them grow up in each movie. So I think it's going to be really, really a great, great thing for these kids. And it's fun that we get to see them grow up together. So they actually were in Disney World the day before me and Kennedy were there. No way. Yeah.
Kennedy
How rude.
Mikayla
I know. So I think they were just in a different park than we were in.
Kennedy
Dang it.
Mikayla
Yeah. So, yeah, I think. I think he plays the most perfect Percy Jackson and he. I just think he's a cutie. So I'm really excited to see what this new season brings.
Kennedy
So hopefully it will be as successful as Harry Potter because I know the first time they tried the Percy Jackson, it was not good.
Mikayla
I actually loved those movies, but it did not follow, like, the books at all.
Reggie
I read the very first Percy Jackson. How many books are there?
Mikayla
There's five.
Reggie
I think I only read the first one. Maybe I read the second one. And I remember watching the movies because, like, I was excited about it. And I even remember as a kid being like, huh, a little bit.
Mikayla
So, yeah, it's just the iconic poker face in the. The Lotus Hotel. Yeah, the Lotus. They have the scene of everyone's, like, if they don't put that in the New. I'm like, they're not gonna put that in the new show. But it was very iconic.
Reggie
Yeah.
Kennedy
I just think it's so funny because the girl in the original movies of Percy Jackson is the sister to the guy that everybody cast as Asriel, the daddario.
Reggie
Oh, yeah. Oh, yes.
Kennedy
I just feel like that's. I don't know why I find that funny, but yeah.
Mikayla
And yeah, yeah, it was good. I'm excited for season two. See what it brings to the table. The. The series is very nostalgic. I really want to read the second series. It's Roman gods instead of Greek gods. And I think in this other series, they're a little bit older than Percy Jackson.
Reggie
Same author.
Mikayla
Yeah. Recording. So very, very fun. Love it.
Kennedy
Okay. The last book to movie adaptation we're going to talk about that's already out and it's probably the reason you're here because you want to hear us talk about this. Maybe not. Just kidding. It's. It ends with us. And if you didn't know this, we did have an event where we had a private screening with a whole bunch of listeners where we watched the movie together and had a little portion after where we discuss the movie. And it was so much fun. But we've. We haven't talked about. It ends with us on the podcast.
Reggie
Yeah. And it might be old news because it's been a while since it's been out. But those of you who didn't get to come to the event we had. I did a question box on our Instagram story not too long ago where I was asking, like, what kind of episodes you want to see? Or like something like that. And so many people, like, talk about it ends with us. I'm like, oh, that's right.
Kennedy
Like, we.
Reggie
We've talked about it, but literally we talked about it immediately after we watched the movie. So we can give our brief thoughts. Who wants to go first?
Kennedy
I can go first really quick. I think that. How did I. I almost called him Raphael. What is his name?
Mikayla
Justin Baldoni.
Kennedy
Justin Baldoni did fantastic as Ryle. I think he was a great Ryle. I think he did such a great job. I think that they were still a little old, but it's okay.
Reggie
And.
Kennedy
Overall, I think I gave it like a 4 out of 5. But I would say Justin Baldoni was a shining star for me in the movie, personally. Oh, and the sister.
Reggie
Oh.
Kennedy
Oh, Loved her.
Mikayla
Yeah.
Kennedy
We didn't get enough of her.
Reggie
It's Alyssa.
Mikayla
Yes.
Reggie
And Marshall.
Mikayla
Marshall.
Kennedy
I loved her. I was very Unsure about her casting because she plays one of the most annoying characters in Parks and Recreation on Planet Earth. And I feel like she kind of has that typecast.
Reggie
Yeah, yeah.
Kennedy
So I was a little unsure, but she was one of my favorite characters. And I think, once again, Justin Baldoni as Ryle did a fantastic job.
Reggie
So, yeah, my thoughts.
Kennedy
There you go.
Reggie
Yeah, I thought it was well done. Like, it was a lot better than I thought it was going to be. For sure. I agree with everything you said. I also feel like there were just maybe some changes, which I don't. I don't want to say what changes, because for sake of spoilers, if you haven't read the book, I'm gonna guess most of you maybe have. But there were just some bigger moments in the book that I don't see why it would have been hard to include them in the movie. And I know you have to, like, take away things, and I understand you can't fit everything into one movie, but I just think some things would have hit a little bit deeper and a little bit harder had they included just some smaller details in the movie. And I feel as if we didn't. We. I also just feel like we didn't get enough of even, like, there's backstory of, like, the flashbacks. I wish we would have gotten a little more of that so it had more of an emotional impact, like I was saying, of things that got taken away. And also I just feel like we didn't get a lot with, like, Marshall and Alyssa. I feel like we could have gotten a little more from them. I don't know. And also just like Atlas, overall, I kind of feel like we didn't get as much of him as we should have gotten. So. Yeah, I still thought it was very well done. Very well done. I just, you know, like, most adaptations would have loved to have seen a little bit more. So.
Mikayla
Yeah, yeah, I agree with pretty much everything you guys said. I've seen it twice.
Kennedy
Probably the second time you didn't see it where their faces were distorted. Yeah, we sat in the very front row on the left, so their faces were kind of wonky.
Mikayla
It wasn't distorted.
Kennedy
It was good.
Mikayla
Yeah. I just felt like, yeah, they just missed some things. They missed the mark on something, so. Which I feel like happens a lot with book to movie TV adaptations. We want all something and they deny us what they could actually give us. Yeah.
Kennedy
So I think it's hard when not to say every book should be made into a TV show, because I don't think it ends with us needed to be a TV show. But when you sit and think about it, books that are made into TV shows, they have seven hours of content to give us, whereas a movie, they have two. So when you're reading, I don't know how long it ends with us is. Let's just say it's a 350 or 400 page book. Yeah, of course they're gonna have to cut some things out, but also, to your guys's point, some of the things they included, it's kind of like, why did they decide to include that? But they took this out or why did they make this change when it didn't need to be changed?
Mikayla
So very nice. Well, that was really fun. So let's talk about book to movie adaptations that are coming out, like, official. I know there's like, quite a few that are rumored, but these are, like, officially have been picked up in production. Yes. So.
Reggie
All right, fourth wing, let's talk about it. I don't really feel like I have a lot to say other than after seeing some interviews with Rebecca Yarros. I'm feeling a little more. I'm not. I don't want to say my expectations are a little bit higher, but I think they might be. She just seems like one of those people that just. She's not gonna take no for an answer. Like, she is just like, this is the way we're gonna do it. And she seems like she's very involved. So, yeah, I'm. I'm very intrigued to see when it's going to come out.
Kennedy
Well, did you guys see the interview? I was so confused by this interview. Well, number one, she was talking about how. I can't remember what question was asked, but she basically was like, I had. When it got picked up by the production company, she had to tell them the whole synopsis of the series. So she had to know how it was going to end. But then she went on to say, and maybe I misunderstood what she was saying, that some of the deaths in the sh. In the TV show and in the book are going to be different.
Reggie
She's. Yeah, she said, how does that make sense? I feel like she was making it say, like, the only thing that is there's the only changes they're really making or something. I honestly think someone in the comments said this, and this is what I'm hoping. I don't think she means that like, oh, in the book, I'm gonna kill off this certain main character down the line, but that's not gonna happen in the TV show. Or vice versa. I almost took it as, after I saw this comment that maybe there's just going to be. Maybe they're gonna have to, like, cut some characters from the show because, you know, like, that's a lot of money to have cast like, yeah. This huge group of friends. And think about it. Gotta, like, cast all the voices for all the dragons. Like, I feel like they're gonna be like, hey, for sake of budget, we maybe need to like cut the cast down a little bit. That's maybe that's how a lot of people in the comments were kind of taking it. I can't imagine that, like the death of a character is. Because that could change the entire plot of a book in a sense. So that's why I was.
Mikayla
Yes, I could see that. But I also feel like there's these characters that are important.
Reggie
Yeah.
Mikayla
So, like, I feel like my only thoughts on this is I hope it's just done well, like the cgi. That's what I. Freaking top tier or it's gonna be ruined. I don't care how good of a actor you cast or how good the casting is, if the CGI is absolute garbage, it's gonna be a terrible show.
Reggie
Yeah. Because it just gives off like, low budget. It makes it automatically so much more cheesy.
Mikayla
Yes.
Reggie
You know, well, think about how much.
Kennedy
CGI is going to be in that show.
Mikayla
There's so much.
Kennedy
So much cgi. You hope it. I mean, I haven't gone through and watched all Game of Thrones, but from what I understand, Game of Thrones CGI was done very well. So hopefully it's like that.
Reggie
I just. Yeah, yeah. The cgis. I also feel like depending on when it comes out and when they start production of like the next episodes or season or however they're doing it, if it does well, that like how Game of Thrones was, they're gonna have a much bigger budget for the next ones. They do. Yeah.
Mikayla
So the first season dictates if they're going to be getting more.
Kennedy
Maybe they'll cut it. How it's. Maybe the first book isn't the first season. Do you know? You know what I mean? Maybe it's more so just based in the college. Less fighting. I don't know.
Reggie
Maybe they only do it like for like how they're doing a lot of TV shows on like Outer Banks, for example. It's like, watch the first four episodes. I mean, I know they kind of like, you know, maybe they split it up.
Kennedy
Where is it? Where is it streaming? Is it going to be Amazon. Oh, Amazon freaks me out a little. I can't lie. They're very hit or miss. They're very hit or miss. Netflix. Netflix also used to be very good, but they're also very hit or miss.
Reggie
Yeah. Right now I'm like, but Rings, Hulu, were they.
Kennedy
It was that Amazon.
Mikayla
Yes.
Kennedy
You know what? Now that you think when you say it, any streaming service is hit or miss.
Mikayla
Yeah.
Reggie
So, yeah. I don't know.
Kennedy
We have faith. We have faith.
Reggie
I. I'm putting my faith in Rebecca, and I just am hoping. I think my biggest thing is that I'm just hoping. Well, like Michaela said, that it's done well. But also, I just hope this doesn't change how I. The feel of the books, where it's like, it feels like she had to hurry and finish them for the sake of the TV show. I just really hope that, that. I mean, it sounds like she has the whole story complete before she kind of had to talk to him about the TV show. But I just hope it doesn't make the writing process rushed along, which it might be. I don't know how far she is, but, yeah.
Mikayla
I feel like we won't get this show until maybe the fourth or fifth book is out.
Kennedy
Yeah. I'm hoping it takes them years to film it. That's how you know it's going to be good.
Mikayla
Because they haven't even come out with, like, the cast or anything, so obviously they haven't. Unless they're keeping it under wraps.
Reggie
Sometimes I just wish we wouldn't know about these announcements because I'm like, I would be fine to wait a year to find out there. You know what I mean?
Kennedy
Yeah.
Reggie
Like, now I'm going to be sitting and thinking about this however long I'm.
Kennedy
Too focused on the next book.
Reggie
Yeah.
Kennedy
The TV show. Because here's the thing. Yeah. Anyways. Okay. The next one.
Reggie
Yeah, next one.
Kennedy
I'm actually more excited for this one than I am for Fourth Wing, because I feel like this one's going to be hard to mess up. Maybe you guys feel differently.
Reggie
I think it's going to depend on the cast.
Mikayla
Yeah.
Kennedy
Meaning, like, there's not as much CGI that's going into this book, which is Powerless by Lauren Roberts. I just think.
Mikayla
Yeah, there's not.
Kennedy
There's not as much cgi. And so it worries me less than.
Mikayla
Fourth Wing does because it's just people's powers.
Reggie
Yeah.
Mikayla
Which people have done pretty good.
Reggie
Yeah. I also feel like because it's young adult, there's just something about it. That feels like it. And just the, you know, that the one liners that she writes, whoever at the cast, I really trust that they're gonna pick someone who is going to deliver these lines well. But just see that on the screen. I just am very. I feel. I'm already feeling giddy about it and I'm just hoping, not disappointed in any sense of Kai.
Kennedy
But I think no matter who they cast, it's never gonna meet what I.
Reggie
Have in my head. Yeah, of course. But I think that sometimes, even when it's not what's in your brain, you can still kind of be like, okay, like I can. I don't know. I mean, that's gonna. This is also probably gonna take a.
Kennedy
While, but also, guys, think about how cool this is for Lauren Roberts. Yeah. When two years ago or however long ago she was on Tick Tock, you know, doing her thing, she decided to think about, like how much success she has had since publishing Powerless. That, like, almost makes me emotional for her and I don't like personally know her. I just think that is so incredible and so cool. And this is her first book. Her first book.
Reggie
Yeah.
Kennedy
And look at how far it's come.
Mikayla
Yeah.
Reggie
Yeah. I'm excited for her. So I also just hope for her sake that it's everything that she dreams.
Mikayla
Yeah.
Reggie
That it can be so.
Mikayla
Yeah. I just, I just hope this one. I hope that casting is done really well. And I. I have faith. I have faith. There was this guy going around that people were like, this person needs to be Kai. I can't remember his name, but I can't.
Reggie
I've seen one where people are saying he's like auditioning for Rhysand, but then everyone says he should be Zayden. Is it that?
Kennedy
I've seen that guy.
Reggie
Okay.
Kennedy
I don't know. I don't. He wouldn't fit Kai for me.
Mikayla
No, I don't think it was that one.
Reggie
That's just like the only thing I've seen recently on Tick Tock, so I was wondering if they were also talking about him for that. But yeah.
Kennedy
Live laugh. Lauren Roberts.
Reggie
Yeah, Seriously.
Mikayla
Okay, next one. People we meet on vacation, which is already in production. We've seen sneak peeks of some of the filming and they recreated the COVID I'm obsessed. I'm really excited for this one. I don't think they can mess this up at all.
Reggie
Yeah. I mean, it's a rom com. They have a great cast and I am just. I kind of lost my train of thought. But basically I just think it's a really great cast. Very fun vibes for a book to read, but then to see on the screen is going to be really fun. And yeah, I just. Mostly the cast, I'm just very excited and I think it's going to set Emily Henry's movies up for even more budget success. Cast. I just can't wait to see how well it does.
Kennedy
Well, they go to Palm Springs, don't they? Right? It's in Palm Springs.
Mikayla
It's all over.
Kennedy
Yeah, I know, but the main. The wedding is in Palm Springs. Right? That's gonna be fun.
Reggie
Yeah. Yeah, I can't wait.
Mikayla
It's gonna be so fun.
Kennedy
Okay, and the last one we're gonna talk about now, obviously this list is not exhaustive. There's so many other books that are being made into TV shows and movies, but these are the ones we chose. So maybe we do part two. A part two Project Hail Mary by Andy Ware. And the one thing I'm gonna say, love Ryan Gosling. Other thing I'm gonna say, I said this before, but I think this is gonna be a better movie than it is a book.
Reggie
I think so, too.
Mikayla
Yeah, same.
Reggie
Yeah. Ryan Gosling is top tier. Top is the cast pretty much.
Kennedy
And for reasons I cannot say, I just think it's gonna be a better movie than book.
Reggie
Oh, yeah. I think so, too.
Kennedy
Yeah.
Reggie
I'm so excited.
Kennedy
Me too.
Reggie
And if you haven't read Project Hail.
Kennedy
Mary, listen to it on audiobook, Listen.
Reggie
To it on audible because it is a very great experience and we can't say why.
Mikayla
Yes.
Kennedy
And I know I'll cry watching the movie.
Reggie
Oh, yeah. It's so great if you've seen like, read the Martian or seen the movie the Martian. Same author, same kind of vibe. But yeah, I really love that book. I will think about that book for a long time.
Kennedy
So looking forward to the movie 2026, baby.
Reggie
Gosh, is anything coming out in 2025? I feel like everything's 2026, but, you know, that's fine. More books to read.
Mikayla
All right, and that concludes our episode. Obviously. I think there is a lot more books, slash movies, TV shows that we could talk about. So maybe we need to do a part two in a little bit. We hope you enjoyed and we'll see you guys next week. Bye.
Podcast Summary: "I'll Read What She's Reading" – Episode on Book to Movie/TV Adaptations
Podcast Information:
Mikayla opens the episode, introducing the main topic: book-to-movie and TV adaptations. Before diving in, the trio updates listeners on books they've recently read as part of their mutual recommendations segment.
With updates concluded, the trio smoothly transitions into the main discussion on adaptations, setting the stage to explore various book-to-screen projects.
Notable Quotes:
Conclusion: This episode of "I'll Read What She's Reading" offers an insightful exploration of various book-to-movie and TV adaptations, blending personal experiences with critical analysis. The hosts provide valuable perspectives for both fans of the original books and newcomers, making it a comprehensive guide to navigating the often tumultuous landscape of literary adaptations.