Podcast Title: I'll Read What She's Reading
Episode Title: Great Big Beautiful Life | May Book Club
Release Date: June 4, 2025
Introduction
In this episode of I'll Read What She's Reading, hosts Reggie, Mikayla, and Kennedy delve into their May book club selection, "The Great Big Beautiful Life" by Emily Henry. The trio sets the stage for an engaging discussion, emphasizing spoiler alerts and encouraging listeners to read the book beforehand to fully appreciate their insights and reviews.
Movie Rights and Reese Witherspoon Connection
[00:51] Kennedy shares an intriguing fact about the book's potential adaptation:
"Because all her fun facts. Oh, maybe it's not a fun fact. Yeah. Since it's a Reese. If you guys didn't know this, every book that is a Reese Reese Witherspoon book pick, she automatically has the rights to the movie. That's part of the deal."
[01:04] Reggie adds excitement about the possibility of Seeing Reese Witherspoon's involvement:
"Yeah, I can see this being a Reese Witherspoon movie."
The hosts express unanimous enthusiasm for the potential film adaptation, highlighting Reese Witherspoon's knack for bringing beloved books to the screen.
Partnership Announcement and Book Giveaway
[01:52] Mikayla announces a thrilling partnership with Fable, offering listeners a chance to win one of 100 copies of "The Other Side of Now" by Paige Harberson:
"We are so excited to announce that we are partnering with them to give away a hundred copies of the Other side of now by Paige Harberson. This book is a brand new release for F of both Rebecca Searle and Taylor Jenkins Reid."
[02:06] Kennedy provides a brief synopsis of the giveaway book:
"In this book we follow our FMC Meg Bryan, who is a leading actress of a hit TV show and is dating Hollywood's biggest heartthrob. After a small mental breakdown slash realizing her life isn't all she wants it to be, she books a trip to Ireland where her and her best friend Amy always jump to visiting. She finds herself in an alternate reality where she isn't a famous actress. Amy never got into her tragic accident and she's left with an impossible choice."
Listeners are encouraged to participate by clicking the link in the show notes and joining the Fable Kickoff room to enter the giveaway. Winners will be announced on June 10th.
Book Club Discussion
Overall Ratings
The hosts share their initial ratings and feelings about "The Great Big Beautiful Life":
-
Mikayla expresses mixed feelings, rating the book 3 to 3.5 stars, citing it as her least favorite Emily Henry novel due to a slow start and a desire for more cohesive storytelling.
[03:08 - 04:39] -
Kennedy rates the book 3.75 stars, also considering it her least favorite Emily Henry book. She highlights a slow first half but acknowledges emotional moments that resonated with her.
[04:39 - 07:07] -
Reggie aligns with her co-hosts, appreciating Emily Henry's writing but feeling the plot lacked the elements that made her other books captivating. She remains conflicted about her final rating.
[07:07 - 09:35]
Likes and Dislikes
Likes:
-
Family Dynamics: Both Reggie and Kennedy appreciate the mother-daughter relationships portrayed in the book, finding them relatable and emotionally impactful.
[15:15 - 16:51] -
Specific Scenes: Memorable moments like the hurricane scene and heartfelt conversations stand out to the hosts.
Kennedy:"One of my favorite moments was at the end when she finally has this conversation with her mom about, like, you love me, but you don't like me kind of a thing."
[12:58 - 13:41] -
Quotes: Thought-provoking quotes and one-liners resonate deeply with the hosts.
Kennedy:"Love isn't something you can cup in your hands. And I have to believe that means it's something that can't ever be lost."
[13:20 - 13:41]
Dislikes:
-
Pacing and Plot Development: The initial slow pace and abrupt romantic developments left the hosts feeling disconnected from the story's progression.
Reggie:"There was just something about the romance aspect of it that felt like I got a little lost halfway through where I was."
[25:21 - 25:50] -
Character Relationships: Mixed signals between characters caused confusion and diminished emotional investment.
Mikayla:"It was kind of making me angry that he was like, like, almost leading her on."
[24:08 - 24:25] -
Multiple Storylines: The intertwining of Margaret's and Alice and Hayden's stories felt unfocused, with both narratives not being fully developed.
Kennedy:"I would have been okay with it being. Maybe being a little bit longer to be able to establish a little bit more of that romance as well as seeing a little bit more of Margaret and Cosmo."
[31:24 - 31:41]
Favorite Moments and Quotes
-
Mother-Daughter Conversations: Emotional dialogues that showcase the complexities of familial relationships.
Reggie:"I feel like they were kind of like, they were just living in their own separate worlds and they needed to have that moment to come together."
[14:35 - 15:15] -
Hurricane Scene: A vividly described moment where a character arrives in the rain, symbolizing emotional turmoil and connection.
Kennedy:"It's just pouring rain. And, you know, as a reader, you knew this was coming. Her phone was dead. Yeah. Nobody could get a hold of her."
[12:58 - 13:01] -
Impactful Quotes: Reflective and meaningful lines that encapsulate the book's themes.
Kennedy:"Love isn't something you can cup in your hands. And I have to believe that means it's something that can't ever be lost."
[13:20 - 13:41]
Fan Casts: Imagining the Characters on Screen
The hosts engage in a lively segment imagining which actors could portray the book's characters:
Hayden
-
Kennedy envisions Adam Driver for Hayden, citing his tall stature and unique features.
[34:09 - 34:16] -
Reggie mentions Dev Patel and Charles Melton, noting their suitability based on physical attributes and acting prowess.
[35:03 - 37:21] -
Mikayla considers Christine Froster Frost for Alice, highlighting her innocence and up-and-coming talent.
[38:14 - 40:07]
Alice
-
Mikayla selects Christine Froster Frost from The Buccaneers for Alice, appreciating her unique beauty and acting style.
[38:14 - 38:38] -
Kennedy opts for Ella Purnell from Yellowjackets, valuing her ability to portray bubbly and positive characters.
[39:00 - 40:20]
Margaret
-
Kennedy suggests Meryl Streep for Margaret, praising her versatility and emotional depth.
[42:35 - 43:05] -
Reggie imagines Lily James as a younger Margaret, drawing parallels to her role in Mamma Mia.
[43:05 - 43:22]
Cosmo
-
Reggie considers Austin Butler, inspired by Hayden's Southern twine and Elvis-like charm.
[43:05 - 44:09] -
Kennedy and Mikayla discuss potential actors but leave the final choice open for future episodes.
[44:14 - 44:55]
Announcing the Next Book Club Selection
Transitioning from their review, the hosts reveal the upcoming book club pick with a playful twist:
[45:00 - 46:10]
Reggie announces that the next month's book will be "Silver Elite" by Danny Francis, a pen name that has sparked curiosity and speculation among fans. The trio teases that Danny Francis is actually the hosts themselves, adding an element of mystery and excitement.
[46:24 - 47:38]
The discussion touches on rumors that the book could be a work by Colleen Hoover, especially amidst her recent media controversies. However, the hosts decide to keep the true identity under wraps, planning to incorporate it into future episodes. They invite listeners to join and guess who the real author might be, fostering engagement and anticipation.
Conclusion
In this comprehensive discussion, Reggie, Mikayla, and Kennedy provide a balanced critique of "The Great Big Beautiful Life", highlighting both its strengths and areas for improvement. Their passion for literature and deep engagement with the book's themes make for an insightful episode. Additionally, their creative fan casting and the tantalizing announcement of their next book club selection promise continued excitement for their audience.
Notable Quotes:
-
Kennedy on Love:
"Love isn't something you can cup in your hands. And I have to believe that means it's something that can't ever be lost."
[13:20] -
Reggie on Relationship Progression:
"There was just something about the romance aspect of it that felt like I got a little lost halfway through where I was."
[25:21] -
Mikayla on Familial Bonds:
"I feel like the stories to me weren't cohesive."
[04:23]
Join the Conversation:
Engage with the hosts and fellow listeners by participating in their book club on Fable and following them on social media for updates, giveaways, and more fan casting fun!