Podcast Summary: "Our Latest FOUR STAR Reads"

I'll Read What She's Reading hosts Reggie, Mikayla, and Kennedy delve into their latest four-star book recommendations in this engaging episode released on July 16, 2025. The episode not only highlights their favorite mid-tier reads but also includes a beloved segment where they exchange and discuss books they've selected for one another. Below is a comprehensive summary capturing the essence of their discussions, enriched with notable quotes and timestamps for reference.

Introduction to Four-Star Reads

Kennedy opens the episode by highlighting the often-overlooked category of four-star books. She remarks, "honestly, I rate a lot more books 3 and 4 stars than I do 5 stars," (00:28) emphasizing the value and enjoyment found in these middle-tier selections. The trio aims to provide listeners with quality recommendations that might not always make the five-star cut but still offer significant enjoyment.

Segment: Book Recommendations for Each Other

Before diving into their individual four-star picks, the hosts engage in their favorite unnamed segment, where they review books they've previously selected for one another and introduce new recommendations.

Kennedy Discusses Reggie's Pick: "Legend Born"

Mikayla shares her thoughts on "Legend Born," a book Reggie recommended. She praises the unique magic system, stating, "It's never been read a Magic System like that," (02:00). However, Mikayla points out challenges with the protagonist's age, saying, "the main character being 16... I just have a hard time with that," (02:15). Despite these hurdles, she appreciates the book's uniqueness and expresses intent to continue the series.

Reggie Reflects on Mikayla's Pick: "Once Upon a Broken Heart"

Reggie discusses "Once Upon a Broken Heart," chosen by Mikayla. She admits to struggling with the audiobook format and balancing it with other reading commitments. Reggie shares, "I have not really sat down to read a physical book. I am just on the audiobook train," (04:35), expressing a desire to eventually revisit the book to fully appreciate its depth.

Mikayla on Reggie's Pick: "Summer Will Be Different"

Mikayla reviews "Summer Will Be Different" by Carly Fortune, a book Reggie suggested. She rates it 3.5 stars, mentioning, "Probably would have liked this even more if I read it and not listened to it," (09:38). Mikayla appreciates the book's vibes and witty banter but notes a lack of memorable retention, hinting at a potential reread in the future.

Kennedy on Reggie's Additional Pick: "When in Rome"

Kennedy introduces "When in Rome" by Sarah, another recommendation from Reggie. She describes it as a "super simple love... a fun, easy read for the summer," (12:18), appreciating its lightheartedness and small-town charm. This selection aims to provide a relaxing summer read with engaging characters and a pleasant storyline.

Deep Dive: Hosts' Four-Star Reads

1. "Sword of Kaigen" by M.L. Wang

Kennedy presents "Sword of Kaigen," rating it four and a half stars (16:00). She highlights the standout female protagonist, remarking, "Our female main character, main character in this book is a monster," (16:36), praising her unique characterization. However, she notes pacing issues and complexities in the world-building, advising listeners to utilize the provided glossary for better understanding.

2. "Throne of Glass" Series by Sarah J. Maas

Reggie revisits the "Throne of Glass" series, particularly "Queen of Shadows." Initially rating it at three stars, she retrospectively upgrades it to four and a half stars after re-reading. Reggie shares her journey of reassessing the series, stating, "Reading really can play, like, the time and place you read a book can literally change everything for you," (21:30). She emphasizes the importance of context and personal growth in appreciating literary works.

3. "Rebel Witch" by Kristen Cicero

Kennedy discusses "Rebel Witch," the first book in Kristen Cicero's duology. She enjoys the witchy elements and whimsical setting, rating it five stars (23:27). The sequel, "Heartless Hunter," receives high praise for maintaining the magical allure while introducing deeper character development. Kennedy appreciates the originality and fun narrative style, making it a standout in her four-star selection.

4. "All Roads Lead Here" by Mariana Zapata

Mikayla reviews "All Roads Lead Here," a slow-burn romance by Mariana Zapata. Rating it four and a half stars (26:40), she lauds its realistic portrayal of romance and emotional subplots. However, Mikayla mentions the length and audiobook format slightly detracted from her experience, suggesting that a physical read might enhance appreciation.

5. "One Golden Summer" by Carly Fortune

Reggie introduces "One Golden Summer," a continuation of Carly Fortune's universe. She rates it 4.25 stars (30:03), praising its witty banter and heartfelt family dynamics. Reggie describes it as a fun summer read with memorable quotes and a relatable protagonist, though she notes occasional corny moments.

6. "Never" by Jessa Hastings

Mikayla discusses "Never" by Jessa Hastings, rating it four stars (29:07). She admires the whimsical setting and innovative plot elements, such as the concept of "bags" or "baggage," which adds depth to the narrative. Despite loving the setting and imaginative storytelling, Mikayla finds certain character portrayals infuriating but ultimately appreciates the book's unique charm.

7. "Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil" by V.E. Schwab

Kennedy reviews "Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil," a dark fantasy novel by V.E. Schwab. Rating it four stars (36:01), she compares it to "Vicious" and "Addie Raine" for its toxicity and violence intertwined with beautiful prose. Kennedy praises Schwab's vivid writing yet critiques the pacing and frequent timeline jumps, which slightly hinder her full enjoyment of the book.

Concluding Remarks

The hosts wrap up by reaffirming the value of four-star reads, emphasizing that these books offer substantial enjoyment and unique perspectives without the need to attain perfection. Kennedy concludes, "Just because you don't read a book five stars doesn't mean you didn't love it," (49:00), encouraging listeners to explore a variety of reads based on personal preference rather than strict ratings.

They also tease upcoming merchandise collaborations and invite listeners to share their thoughts on the discussed books via their Goodreads account and Instagram.

Notable Quotes

• Kennedy (00:28): "Honestly, I rate a lot more books 3 and 4 stars than I do 5 stars."
• Mikayla (02:15): "The main character being 16... I just have a hard time with that."
• Reggie (21:30): "Reading really can play, like, the time and place you read a book can literally change everything for you."
• Kennedy (16:36): "Our female main character... is a monster."
• Mikayla (26:40): "It's one of the most realistic romance books I've ever read."

Final Thoughts

I'll Read What She's Reading continues to deliver insightful and entertaining book discussions, making it a valuable resource for book enthusiasts seeking thoughtful recommendations beyond the usual five-star bestsellers. This episode's focus on four-star reads underscores the hosts' dedication to celebrating a diverse range of literary works, ensuring that every listener finds something that resonates with their reading tastes.

For more recommendations and to join the conversation, listeners are encouraged to follow the podcast's Goodreads account and Instagram page at @whatshesreadingpod.