Podcast Summary: "Sharing Your SPOOKY STORIES | Vol II"

Episode Release Date: October 30, 2024

Introduction

In the highly anticipated Halloween special of "I'll Read What She's Reading," hosts Peyton Gray, Evangeline, and Mustang delve into a chilling collection of spooky stories submitted by their listeners. This episode, titled "Sharing Your SPOOKY STORIES | Vol II," promises an evening filled with eerie encounters, ghostly apparitions, and supernatural mysteries that are sure to send shivers down your spine.

Listener-Submitted Spooky Stories

The centerpiece of this episode revolves around the spooky tales shared by the podcast’s audience. Each host reads and reacts to these unsettling narratives, creating an engaging and immersive experience for listeners.

1. Haunted House Encounter ([02:22] - Mustang)

   Mustang begins with a story set in 2016 at her ex-boyfriend’s family home. While watching "Once Upon a Time" with her friend, they hear loud footsteps from upstairs. When the little brother, Jonathan, arrives home peacefully with their mother, Mustang calls her ex, who reveals that the house is haunted—information she was previously unaware of.

   "I saw a ghost. I've seen one." – Mustang ([02:09])

   The hosts discuss the implications of living in a haunted house and the eerie calm that follows attempting to communicate with the supernatural.

2. Creepy Childhood Home in Michigan ([06:20] - Evangeline)

   Evangeline recounts growing up in a rural Michigan house adjacent to train tracks, which contributed to a constantly unsettling atmosphere. The house's odd layout, including closets leading nowhere and a crawl space resembling a "murder basement," set the stage for various ghostly experiences. Notably, her sister suffered from sleep paralysis, seeing shadowy figures, and Evangeline herself felt inexplicable bed movements at night.

   "I climbed about halfway up the ladder and tried to feel for her in the dark. After a moment... I was overcome with this immense feeling of dread and the urge to run." – Evangeline ([07:20])

   The discussion highlights how physical surroundings and unexplained phenomena can contribute to a sense of hauntings.

3. Nanny's Terrifying Encounter with a Stranger ([15:18] - Evangeline)

   A listener named Hannah shares a harrowing experience from her childhood in Ireland. While on a family holiday, she was left alone in a car with her three younger brothers. A sinister figure with "long ratty gray hair" and a "crooked dirty smile" persistently tried to coax her into opening the car door. Demonstrating remarkable composure, Hannah resisted the entity’s demands until her parents returned, ensuring their safety.

   "I started to get scared too. We decided to say a quick prayer that we would be safe." – Hannah ([16:56])

   The hosts commend Hannah's bravery and discuss the fear of encountering malevolent beings versus supernatural ghosts.

4. Father-in-Law's Cursed Pottery ([24:00] - Mustang)

   Mustang narrates a story about inheriting native American pottery from her father-in-law. Shortly after placing it in the garage, unexplained noises and apparitions plagued her household. The relentless banging and the appearance of a large dark figure culminated in Mustang fleeing the house. After apologizing to the pottery, the disturbances ceased, suggesting a supernatural attachment to the object.

   "They recommended apologizing to the pottery because when it was brought into my home, I insulted it." – Mustang ([25:03])

   This story underscores the belief that physical objects can harbor spirits and the importance of respecting cultural artifacts.

5. Ghostly Figure in a College House ([28:00] - Evangeline)

   Evangeline shares her experience of witnessing a ghostly figure, known as Greg, in her childhood home. Initially terrified by a figure in a brown trench coat, she later discovered Greg's tragic history with his wife, Ruby. Their lingering presence provided a bittersweet conclusion to her spooky encounters.

   "Greg and Ruby... If they're both dead, just be together, you know?" – Evangeline ([30:10])

   The hosts reflect on the emotional aspects of ghost stories, blending fear with elements of love and loss.

6. Honeymoon Nightmare in Jackson Hole ([34:00] - Peyton Gray)

   Peyton recounts a terrifying experience during her honeymoon in Wyoming. While suffering from food poisoning, she encountered a naked ghost repeatedly disrupting her peace. Despite attempts to rationalize the events, the persistent disturbances led her to cut their trip short, leaving her haunted by the memory.

   "A naked ghost." – Peyton Gray ([34:00])

   This story highlights the intersection of physical ailment and supernatural fear, amplifying the horror of the experience.

Hosts' Personal Experiences and Discussions

Beyond the listener-submitted stories, the hosts share their own ghostly encounters, deepening the episode's authenticity and relatability.

• Peyton’s Haunted Apartment Experience ([05:45] - Peyton Gray):

  Peyton describes working as a nurse in a hospital with a notoriously haunted room, where strange noises and apparitions deterred staff from entering. Her efforts to cleanse the space with salt present a practical approach to dealing with the supernatural.

  "I took a salt packet and threw salt in the door." – Peyton Gray ([05:25])

• Mustang's Encounter with a Ghost ([20:44] - Mustang):

  Mustang elaborates on her belief in ghosts, fueled by her experiences and her nail technician’s ghost-hunting adventures. Her skepticism shifts as the stories become too personal and frightening to dismiss.

  "I believe in ghosts too. I've been ghost hunting." – Mustang ([20:42])

Belief in the Supernatural

A significant portion of the episode is dedicated to the hosts debating their belief in ghosts and supernatural phenomena. Peyton affirms her belief based on personal sightings, while Evangeline and Mustang share their differing perspectives and experiences, leading to a rich discussion on the nature of ghosts—ranging from benevolent spirits to malevolent entities.

"Yes, I've seen one." – Peyton Gray ([20:44])

"I believe in ghosts too." – Mustang ([20:44])

"Have you ever seen that?" – Evangeline ([22:21])

Scariest Movies and Books

Transitioning from personal experiences, the hosts discuss their favorite horror movies and books. They compare cinematic scares to literary frights, analyzing what makes a story truly terrifying. While Peyton finds real-life inspired films more frightening, Mustang prefers supernatural horror, highlighting the diverse ways fear can be elicited through storytelling.

"Have you guys read Those stupid books from, like, when you're in Goosebumps?" – Evangeline ([37:17])

"The scariest book?" – Peyton Gray ([37:03])

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

As the episode winds down, the hosts reflect on the power of storytelling in connecting and sharing fears. They encourage listeners to continue submitting their spooky experiences and tease forthcoming vlog content and merchandise, maintaining engagement with their audience.

"Wear it. And we hope you have a very spooky or not so spooky and safe Halloween." – Peyton Gray ([44:31])

Notable Quotes

• Peyton Gray on Haunted Experiences:

  "I saw a ghost. I've seen one." ([02:09])

• Mustang on Respecting Spirits:

  "They recommended apologizing to the pottery because when it was brought into my home, I insulted it." ([25:03])

• Evangeline on Childhood Hauntings:

  "Greg and Ruby... If they're both dead, just be together, you know?" ([30:10])

Final Remarks

"Sharing Your SPOOKY STORIES | Vol II" is a spine-tingling episode that masterfully combines listener tales with the hosts' personal encounters, creating an atmosphere of suspense and camaraderie. Whether you're a skeptic or a believer, this Halloween special offers something for everyone craving a taste of the supernatural. Tune in to experience these haunting narratives and join the community in celebrating the mysterious and the unexplained.