Inconceivable Truth: Episode 8 - "Pater Familias"

Host: Matt Katz (audiochuck)
Release Date: May 16, 2024

Introduction: A Decades-Long Search

In this poignant episode of "Inconceivable Truth," investigative reporter Matt Katz delves deep into his lifelong quest to uncover the identity of his biological father. What began in his childhood as a straightforward search evolves into a complex narrative intertwined with deception, familial bonds, and profound self-discovery.

Unraveling the Past: Warren or Vincent?

For forty years, Matt believed Warren was his biological father. However, through meticulous research and emotional encounters, he uncovers unsettling truths that challenge his initial assumptions.

Matt Katz [24:10]: "This practice of deceiving couples into believing they were having their own children... I just became convinced that this is how I came to exist."

Matt's investigation leads him to Dr. Dubrovna, the physician responsible for his conception in 1977. Through their conversation, Matt learns about the possibility of semen mixing—a technique that could have introduced Vincent McNally, an Irish actor, as his true biological father.

Dr. Dubrovna [25:24]: "Psychologically, obviously, it was such that the couple would really never know whether it was the husband... It wasn't going to really be medically effective, but psychologically it was."

Family Dynamics: Navigating Relationships and Identity

Matt reflects on his relationship with Warren, whom he refers to as his "original biological father," and Richard, his adoptive father. The emotional turbulence of reconnecting with Warren is palpable.

Matt Katz [09:25]: "I did not have a positive reaction to talking to Warren again. I felt in my body numb... I just sat there miserable."

Despite the pain, Matt finds solace in his relationship with Richard and his daughter Sadie, who provides unwavering support during his tumultuous journey.

Sadie [12:13]: "It's all right, Daddy, she said. You have a dad who loves you right there in Manhattan."

The Revelation: Vincent McNally as Biological Father

Matt's exploration culminates in the discovery that Vincent McNally, a 41-year-old Irish actor from Greenwich Village, is his biological father. This revelation not only shocks Matt but also redefines his understanding of family and identity.

Matt Katz [08:10]: "It's inconceivable truth. I'm Matt Katz. Episode 8 Paterfamilias."

Through DNA testing and archival research, Matt pieces together Vincent's involvement, leading to a heart-wrenching confrontation with Dr. Dubrovna.

Matt Katz [32:02]: "I'm just trying to figure out if there might have been other means in which you were sourcing the semen."

Meeting Gloria Goldman: Stories from Vincent's Past

A significant portion of the episode is dedicated to Matt's interview with Gloria Goldman, Vincent's former girlfriend from the 1960s. Gloria provides intimate glimpses into Vincent's personality, their relationship, and the impact of his decision to donate sperm.

Gloria Goldman [45:04]: "He was very adventurous... He loved to laugh. His personality was larger than life."

Gloria recounts Vincent's struggle with personal setbacks and his eventual choice to become a sperm donor, actions that would unknowingly shape Matt's existence.

Gloria Goldman [49:54]: "The reason I am so pro abortion is because it was a nightmare I had to go through."

Her stories reveal a man torn between his artistic aspirations and personal turmoil, shedding light on the complexities that led to Matt's conception.

Reflections on Identity and the Meaning of Family

As Matt navigates the intricate web of his lineage, he grapples with profound questions about what truly defines family. The distinction between biological ties and emotional connections becomes a central theme.

Matt Katz [34:30]: "We're putting disparate terms together like this because there really isn't a language to this experience for being one ethnic and religious and cultural identity and then getting a new identity."

Matt emphasizes the importance of the bonds he has with his adoptive family and newly discovered siblings, illustrating that family transcends genetic connections.

Matt Katz [56:54]: "I have had the joy of watching them play with my kids... finding new sibling relationships will help to fill that void."

Closure and New Beginnings

The episode concludes with Matt reflecting on his journey, the unexpected discoveries, and the new relationships forged along the way. Despite the shadows of the past, Matt looks forward to building a more authentic and inclusive family.

Matt Katz [62:24]: "It would be weird if you weren't actually my dad. Can you imagine finding that out 30 years from now?"

Gloria Goldman [57:31]: "You are part of him. The four of us are some sort of extension of him."

Matt expresses gratitude to his adoptive family, his newfound siblings, and his biological relatives, acknowledging that his story is a testament to resilience and the enduring essence of familial love.

Notable Quotes

• Matt Katz [25:41]: "It sounds deceptive. It sounds like deceit was sort of built in the process."

• Gloria Goldman [55:46]: "We were listening to Barbra Streisand's 'People that Need People.' It was a song that she sang... 'people that need people are the luckiest people in the world.' He said, 'people that need people are the most unlucky people in the world.'"

Conclusion: The Power of Storytelling and Truth

"Pater Familias" serves as a compelling exploration of identity, ethics, and the intricate tapestry of family. Through candid interviews and heartfelt narration, Matt Katz invites listeners to witness his transformative journey, challenging preconceived notions of what it means to belong and the lengths one will go to find truth.

For those who haven't listened to the episode, this summary provides a comprehensive overview of Matt's emotional and investigative odyssey, highlighting the profound revelations and the human stories that underpin his search for identity.

Credits:
Written and Hosted by Matt Katz
Story Editor: Erica Lance
Mixing: James Trout
Producer: Emily Foreman
Intern: Natalie White
Executive Producers: Jason Hoch (Waveland), John Peratti and Jessica Alpert (Rococo Punch)

Special Thanks:
Gloria Linterman, Bianca Grimshaw of Roomtone, and Christina Bryan for their invaluable contributions.

Connect with "Inconceivable Truth":
Follow Waveland Media on Instagram, X, or Facebook. For inquiries, email podcast@wavelandmedia.com.

Support the Series:
If you enjoyed this episode, please leave us a review and share it with friends and family.

End of Summary