Summary of "Our Mount Rushmore of Fictional Presidents"
Podcast Information:
- Podcast Title: Matter of Opinion
- Hosts: Michelle Cottle, Ross Douthat, Carlos Lozada
- Episode Title: Our Mount Rushmore of Fictional Presidents
- Release Date: December 20, 2024
Introduction
In this special holiday bonus episode, the hosts of "Matter of Opinion"—Michelle Cottle, Ross Douthat, and Carlos Lozada—delve into a spirited discussion about their favorite fictional presidents. This episode serves as a delightful exploration of presidential archetypes in fiction, examining what makes these characters resonate with audiences.
President Josiah "Jed" Bartlet from The West Wing
Overview: Carlos Lozada initiates the discussion by championing President Josiah "Jed" Bartlet from the acclaimed television series The West Wing. Portrayed by Martin Sheen, Bartlet stands as a quintessential idealistic leader in American fiction.
Appeal and Characteristics:
- Idealism and Economics: Michelle Cottle highlights Bartlet's role as a Nobel laureate economist, noting, "Bartlett was a real economist, right? Only in an Aaron Sorkin fantasy does a Nobel laureate economist become president" (02:10).
- Personal Connection: Michelle shares her personal affinity for Bartlet, relating his Notre Dame affiliation to her own alma mater, enhancing her appreciation for the character’s depth and relatability.
- Cultural Impact: Bartlet's portrayal during the series' run coincided with Michelle's move to Washington D.C., making the show a backdrop to her early experiences in the capital.
Notable Quote:
Michelle Cottle (02:10): "Bartlett was a real economist, right? Only in an Aaron Sorkin fantasy does a Nobel laureate economist become president."
Discussion: Ross and Carlos engage in light-hearted banter about Bartlet’s attributes, with Ross playfully critiquing the character’s idealism. They acknowledge how Bartlet embodies a "center-left fantasy," merging historical elements with aspirational leadership qualities.
President Thomas J. Whitmore from Independence Day
Overview: Ross Douthat selects President Thomas J. Whitmore from the blockbuster film Independence Day as his favorite fictional president. Whitmore is celebrated for his heroic leadership during an alien invasion.
Appeal and Characteristics:
-
Heroic Leadership: Whitmore epitomizes the everyman leader thrust into extraordinary circumstances, delivering iconic speeches that rally the nation.
-
Memorable Speech: Ross recites a rendition of Whitmore's famous rousing speech, showcasing the character's ability to inspire resilience and unity:
Ross Douthat (11:02): "We will not go quietly into the night. We will not vanish without a fight. Today, we celebrate our Independence Day."
Notable Quote:
Ross Douthat (11:02): "It has everything."
Discussion: Michelle commends the film for capturing the spirit of American resilience, while Carlos draws parallels between Whitmore and Harrison Ford's president in Air Force One. The hosts explore how Whitmore's character encapsulates the quintessential defender of freedom, making him a standout figure in fictional presidencies.
President James Marshall from Air Force One
Overview: The conversation transitions to President James Marshall from Air Force One, portrayed by Harrison Ford. This character represents steadfast executive leadership amid crisis.
Appeal and Characteristics:
- Decisive Action: President Marshall is depicted as a former military leader who must confront terrorists hijacking Air Force One, embodying strength and determination.
- Iconic Moments: The president's firm declaration, "Get off my plane," underscores his no-nonsense approach to national security threats.
Notable Quote:
Ross Douthat (15:56): "He has to rise to the occasion in this sort of raggedy, disheveled, everyman kind of way."
Discussion: Carlos and Ross compare Marshall's leadership style to Whitmore's, noting similarities in their ability to inspire and protect the nation. They discuss how both characters reflect 1990s American values of resilience and heroism in the face of adversity.
Prime Minister Francis Urquhart from British House of Cards
Overview: Expanding the scope internationally, Michelle Cottle introduces Francis Urquhart, the Machiavellian Prime Minister from the original BBC version of House of Cards. Unlike the idealistic American presidents, Urquhart embodies cunning and political manipulation.
Appeal and Characteristics:
- Machiavellian Schemes: Urquhart is portrayed as a power-hungry politician whose ambition drives him to manipulate and outmaneuver opponents.
- British Subtleties: Michelle praises the British version for its nuanced portrayal, contrasting it with the more overt dramatics of American counterparts.
Notable Quote:
Michelle Cottle (17:01): "Francis Urquhart... he is pure Machiavellian, sinister, low key British, just evil in the best way possible."
Discussion: The hosts delve into the complexities of Urquhart’s character, highlighting his strategic brilliance and ethical ambiguity. They contrast this with the virtuous portrayals of Bartlet and Whitmore, discussing how Urquhart offers a different perspective on leadership and power.
President Dwayne Elizondo Mountain Dew "President" Camacho from Idiocracy
Overview: Carlos Lozada brings a humorous twist to the discussion by introducing President Dwayne Elizondo Mountain Dew Camacho from the satirical film Idiocracy. Portrayed by Terry Crews, Camacho offers a stark contrast to the noble and cunning leaders previously discussed.
Appeal and Characteristics:
- Satirical Representation: Camacho embodies over-the-top populism and cultural decay, serving as a critique of anti-intellectualism and commercialism.
- Memorable Persona: His flamboyant personality and unconventional leadership style make him a memorable figure in fictional presidencies.
Notable Quote:
Carlos Lozada (21:25): "President Camacho is giving a speech... we're fighting for our right to live. To exist."
Discussion: The hosts analyze how Idiocracy uses Camacho’s character to satirize future governance, highlighting societal flaws through exaggerated fictional leadership. They debate the effectiveness of such portrayals in critiquing real-world political and cultural issues.
Comparative Analysis and Cultural Reflections
Idealism vs. Cynicism: The episode juxtaposes the idealistic portrayals of Bartlet and Whitmore with the cynical and satirical depictions of Urquhart and Camacho. This comparison underscores varying narratives about leadership, power, and national identity in fiction.
Cultural Impact: Michelle criticizes The West Wing for potentially fostering unrealistic expectations about politics, while Ross and Carlos discuss the show’s representation of the "art of the possible" and its alignment with 1990s political optimism.
Notable Quote:
Michelle Cottle (09:31): "It taught an entire generation of people that politics is a place for like, idealists who get to go in there and flaunt their virtue."
Discussion: The hosts explore how these fictional presidents reflect and influence societal perceptions of leadership. They consider the balance between aspirational ideals and pragmatic governance, questioning the extent to which fiction mirrors or shapes political realities.
Additional Insights and Future Content
Casting Preferences: The hosts entertain ideas about who could portray their ideal fictional presidents, discussing the qualities and performances that would bring these characters to life on screen.
Biographical Tangents: Ross briefly touches on his interest in biographers, segueing into a discussion about Edmund Morris’s biography of Ronald Reagan, highlighting complexities in portraying historical figures.
Notable Quote:
Ross Douthat (25:13): "I have a very strong interest in the character of Benedict Arnold... where Benedict Arnold is the first president of the United States."
Discussion: While this tangent veers into historical what-ifs, it underscores the hosts' fascination with leadership and its portrayal across different narratives and mediums.
Conclusion
As the episode concludes, the hosts recap their discussions and invite listeners to engage with future content by sharing their own fictional presidential preferences. Michelle Cottle promotes Ross’s fantasy novel, "The Falcon's Children," hinting at more in-depth discussions on related topics. The episode wraps up with lighthearted farewells, leaving listeners with ample food for thought regarding the portrayal of leadership in fiction.
Final Notable Quote:
Ross Douthat (27:01): "It's a slow burn."
Timestamps for Notable Quotes
- Michelle Cottle on Bartlet’s Economics: 02:10
- Ross Douthat on Whitmore’s Speech: 11:02
- Ross Douthat on Air Force One’s Leadership: 15:56
- Michelle Cottle on Francis Urquhart: 17:01
- Carlos Lozada on President Camacho’s Speech: 21:25
- Michelle Cottle on Idealism in Politics: 09:31
- Ross Douthat on Alternate History: 25:13
- Ross Douthat’s Closing Remark: 27:01
Note: The timestamps correspond to the positions in the provided transcript and are intended for reference within the summary.
This comprehensive summary encapsulates the key discussions, insights, and character analyses presented by the hosts, offering a thorough overview for those who haven't listened to the episode.