Jeff Lewis Has Issues – Episode: David Archuleta & Justin Sylvester: Winning Cars & Soaking

Release Date: March 28, 2025

In this candid and engaging episode of Jeff Lewis Has Issues, host Jeff Lewis welcomes former American Idol contestant David Archuleta and musician Justin Sylvester. The trio dives deep into personal stories ranging from the highs of winning a car on a national stage to navigating complex issues of faith, sexuality, and personal growth. Throughout the episode, listeners are treated to a blend of heartfelt revelations and humorous banter, all delivered with Jeff’s trademark no-filter style.

1. Winning a Car on American Idol

The episode kicks off with Jeff and Justin quizzing David about his American Idol experience, particularly the surprising win of a Ford Escape despite being the season’s runner-up.

• David Archuleta (01:43): "I did. I got a Ford Escape. I still drive it."

David explains his emotional attachment to the car, detailing why he chose not to exchange it like other contestants might. The practicality of the Ford Escape, with its ample storage and easy parking, made it the perfect fit for him.

• Jeff Lewis (02:03): "You have been through so much in your life and that is the first question that Jeff Lewis is asking you if you want a car on American Idol."

2. Navigating Mormon Upbringing and Sexuality

A significant portion of the conversation delves into David’s Mormon background and his journey with sexuality. David shares his experiences during his Mormon mission to South America, where he began to explore his sexual identity.

• David Archuleta (07:28): "I didn't know, because also I grew up Mormon."

The discussion introduces the concept of soaking, a Mormon practice aimed at circumventing strict sexual prohibitions. David provides an insider’s perspective on how some individuals navigate these complex rules.

• Jeff Lewis (13:00): "Do you know what soaking is?"

David candidly talks about coming out as queer and the support he received from his mission president, highlighting a pivotal moment in his personal growth.

• David Archuleta (15:44): "The first person I told was my mission president."

3. Car Security Mishaps and Anecdotes

Transitioning to lighter topics, the conversation shifts to David’s Ford Escape and the challenges he faced, including it being broken into and the theft of his backpack containing personal items like his passport.

• David Archuleta (20:37): "And I go to my locker and my locker was broken into."

Justin Sylvester shares a similar experience, emphasizing the importance of securing valuable items and the frustrations that come with such mishaps.

• Jeff Lewis (24:33): "He found himself in that mission."

4. Fitness Routines and Gym Stories

David discusses his fitness regimen, mentioning his memberships at various gyms like Planet Fitness and encountering thefts at the gym. The group humorously debates gym preferences and shares personal anecdotes related to their fitness journeys.

• David Archuleta (19:39): "My gym clothes, unfortunately."

Jeff and Justin add their own twists to the conversation, making the segment both informative and entertaining.

5. Playlist Detective – A Musical Guessing Game

Towards the episode's end, the guests engage in a fun segment called Playlist Detective. Each person selects a favorite song, and the others must guess who chose it based on first impressions. This game showcases the group's camaraderie and reveals unexpected musical preferences.

• David Archuleta (36:26): "I was still blown away by that."

• Jeff Lewis (37:54): "But someone, something put you there in order for..."

The playful nature of this segment adds a lighthearted conclusion to the episode, allowing listeners to connect with the guests on a more personal and relatable level.

Notable Quotes:

• Jeff Lewis (01:02): "When you're Jeff Lewis, the drama never stops."

• David Archuleta (25:13): "And I was so tired of trying to be what I'm supposed to and failing because I was like, I need to be straight."

• Jeff Lewis (31:01): "This is amazing, by the way. The fact that we could sit here and have this conversation."

Insights and Conclusions:

This episode offers a raw and unfiltered look into David Archuleta’s life beyond the spotlight. From the bittersweet triumph of winning a car on a reality TV show to the profound struggles of reconciling faith with personal identity, David’s stories resonate with authenticity and vulnerability. Justin Sylvester complements the conversation with his own experiences, adding depth and humor to the discussion.

Jeff Lewis facilitates the conversation seamlessly, balancing serious topics with moments of levity. The episode underscores themes of resilience, the importance of self-acceptance, and the power of supportive relationships in overcoming personal challenges.

Listeners are left with a profound appreciation for the guests' honesty and the nuanced way Jeff navigates complex issues, making this episode both insightful and deeply engaging for those who tune in.

Conclusion:

Jeff Lewis Has Issues continues to deliver compelling and heartfelt conversations, and this episode featuring David Archuleta and Justin Sylvester is no exception. Whether grappling with personal demons or sharing lighthearted moments, the trio exemplifies the essence of authentic dialogue. Subscribers can look forward to more unfiltered stories and genuine connections in future episodes.

To listen to this episode and others ad-free, consider subscribing to SiriusXM Podcasts+ or start a free trial on Apple Podcasts by visiting siriusxm.com/podcastsplus.