
Cohosted by Nick of Check out the on Spotify. A brand new show covering all things DOGE! Get it on Itunes at For more Rogan exclusives support us on patreon.com/JREReview For all marketing questions and inquiries: Follow me...
Loading summary
Amazon Music Ad
Hey prime members, are you tired of ads interfering with your favorite podcasts? Good news. With Amazon Music you have access to the largest catalog of ad free top podcasts included with your prime membership. To start listening, download the Amazon Music app for free or go to Amazon.com ADFreePodcasts that's Amazon.com ADFreeP Podcasts to catch up on the latest episodes without the.
T Mobile Ad
Ads with T Mobile. No trendspotter has to deal with trendspotty service because T Mobile helps keep you connected from big cities to your hometown on America's largest 5G network. Switch now keep your phone and T Mobile will pay it off up to $800 per line via prepaid card. Visit your local T Mobile location or learn more@t mobile.com keepandswitch up to 4.
Lines of your virtual prepaid card. Allow 15 days qualifying unlock device, credit service port in 90 days device ineligible carrier and timely repetition required. Card has no cash access and expires in six months.
Podcast Host 1
You are listening to the Joe Rogan Experience Review Podcast. We find little nuggets, treasures, valuable pieces of gold in the Joe Rogan Experience Podcast and pass them on to you. Perhaps expand a little bit. We are not associated with Joe Rogan in any way. Think of us as the talking dead to Joe's Walking Dead.
Podcast Host 2
You're listening to the Joe Rogan Experience Review.
Adam Thorne
What a bizarre thing we've created. Now with your hosts, Adam Thorne. This might either be the worst podcast.
Nick
Or the best one. One go.
Podcast Host 1
Enjoy the show.
Nick
Hey guys and welcome to another episode of the JRE Review joined this week by my buddy Nick from the lesser known operators podcast link in bio. Check that out. How you doing Nick?
Adam Thorne
I am doing well. Thanks for having me back.
Nick
All right, good to have you back. This week we are reviewing Daryl Cooper. Now this was an interesting Rogan podcast. Rogan had him on for a good reason. This guy's been taking some heat. It's kind of a self taught historian and host of the Martyr Maid podcast. It's really known for its like deep dive into like historical events like Jonestown Massacre which you talked about World War II. It's got over a quarter million followers on X. And he's a good storyteller too. He's done some podcasts with Jocko and recently he went on Tucker Carlson and in that interview it kind of people have branded him as an anti Semite, a bit of a Nazi sympathizer. That's a rough spot to be in. You know he's even called Winston Churchill a villain and and yeah. What. What was your. Was this the first time you've been introduced to this person, Nick?
Adam Thorne
I had not heard of this guy before you text me and said, what do you think of this? So threw it on. And you're right. The Tucker Carlson interview. Right. And what does Tucker Carlson do? He just riles people up and that works for him to get people to listen to his show. And he said, even at one point, Tucker said he was going to introduce him as the most influential historian of the 21st century or something like that.
Nick
Right.
Adam Thorne
Well, I'm not that, but he does. And Tucker is a very polarizing person. And that probably brought more heat on this guy. Right. Whether justly or unjustly. But yeah, interesting. He's. Go ahead.
Nick
Well, it certainly upsets the academics when somebody throws that out because, you know, just like Graham Hancock, like, he's not archaeologist, he's just a researcher and storyteller. So they come to head, like real quick in if you're not like a professor somewhere or you don't have the PhDs. But does that mean you can't tell a story and maybe tell it in a different way?
Adam Thorne
Yeah, Joe loves that. He loves the person that upsets the status quo. Right. Especially with Graham Hancock. And you know, a lot of these fields are like a. A club. Right. And you're not allowed to have an opinion about our area of study unless you're part of the club, unless you have that degree, unless you're published or in this magazine or this novel. And people will vehemently support or defend these institutions, really. With very little understanding about who they're attacking.
Nick
Yeah. It's almost like they create a narrative which is then has to be agreed upon and then it's taught that way. And that's what, you know, in his case, the history is. It's like, well, I guess it's the same with Graham Hancock. It's like, this is. This is when we develop this, or this is what happened in this war. And it's hard to tell the story a different way.
Adam Thorne
Nobody ever wants to say they're wrong. And the more. And that becomes more evident today, no one ever wants to say they're wrong, but if they did, once in a while, people would respect them more. Have. How many times in your life have you said, you know what, I messed up and I was wrong about the opinions I had before and changed your mind. And people go, I. That's okay. It's when you're continually wrong and you keep hammering away at it and pushing all of those signs that are pointing it right out of your life is when you run into problems and then you get so deep in the discussion that you can't back yourself out of it.
Nick
Yeah. You got to, like, double down, Especially if you kind of get caught in a bit of a lie or contradictory statement, and then you double down because you don't want to be embarrassed yourself. It's. It's like what every. That's like the politician playbook. When was the last time you remember a politician actually apologizing for something?
Adam Thorne
I'm not that old, so I don't.
Nick
Yeah, I can't. I can't remember either.
Adam Thorne
They don't do it. Maybe Bill Clinton, I don't know. Because he had to.
Nick
Yeah, my bad. Well, Nixon.
Adam Thorne
Yeah. He said he wasn't a crook, but. Yeah, with. With that. It's just people. People form opinions rather quickly, don't they? I think this individual has fallen victim of that. And partly, people attack you on the Internet and they don't know anything about you. They never met you. They never had a conversation with you, but you'll say something they don't like and will go against you for the rest of their lives. And then part of it also is there's so many fake accounts causing havoc on the Internet, and sometimes you'll click through and somebody makes a comment, and you just go down the rabbit hole and you determine that that profile is fake. Right?
Nick
Yeah.
Adam Thorne
So you've got fake people being propped up by real people that think they're saying the right thing, where they're just trying to stir up discourse. Yeah.
Nick
And I think that's why Joe felt so strongly about having him on. Joe's obviously listened to his podcast, kind of knows his stance on things, and as far as I could tell from this conversation, he was somewhat humanizing the Germans that were Nazis or the German people in World War II in a way that obviously upset a lot of people. I mean, you throw the word Nazi sympathizer out there, it's pretty loaded. You know, it's. It's. It's like what Elon is getting accused of, and everyone's drawing swastikas on Teslas, and, you know, it's like the ultimate you're a bad guy symbol.
Adam Thorne
It is. It stands out the most from the 20th century. Right. Nothing can get more evil than that. And people are going to get upset when you bring up Nazis or the Holocaust because it's still. It's not fresh. But our grandparents lived through that, and they're still our Grandparents are still alive. Right. Or their, their parents were there. Those stories are still fresh. And it is the, the most nasty thing that most people can think of. And they, it does bother me that people will throw that term out and call other people Nazis when that's. That's not even. That's not the case. Like, do you break down how horrible it is to be a Nazi? You're rounding up a population of people and gassing them or burning them to death and they'll throw this word out there because they're losing an argument or they hate somebody and things like that. That's no way to act. All right? Have a discussion, have discourse, and find out why this person thinks like that or from their perspective. Because he kept saying in there, imagine it from their perspective. Well, people attacking him, by the way, they don't want to imagine things from his perspective, which is terrible. And that's what he's trying to get at is we need to understand why things happen so they don't happen again.
Nick
Yeah. And that's all about putting together as accurate a picture as you can, which is really the, like, the point of historians. Right? They got to work through the legend and the mythology and the rest of it to get to, like, what did it actually look like? And for it to go back not even 100 years. And maybe we don't have as clear a picture of something like World War II as we think then, you know, there might be things we're missing and it can repeat itself if we don't understand it. Well, that's what's scary about something like that.
Adam Thorne
History. As in newspapers and history, only the names and dates change, the actions are exactly the same. And I guess to unravel that, everything happens over and over again. If you see the signs. That's why some people are so good with finances. They can recognize patterns. And historians are so important because these things happen over and over again. People rise to power, they fall out of power. Countries come and go. Once you're on top, you can only stay there for so long.
T Mobile Ad
With T Mobile, no trendspotter has to deal with trendspotty service because T Mobile helps keep you connected from big cities to your hometown On America's largest 5G network Switch now keep your phone and T Mobile will pay it off at the $800 per line via prepaid card. Visit your local T Mobile location or learn more@t mobile.com keepandswitch.
Up to four lines via virtual prepaid card. Last 15 days qualifying unlock device credit service port in 90 days, device and eligible carrier and timely redemption required card is no cash access. It expires in six months.
Podcast Host 2
When the Moore family ditched cable Internet and switched to Zigly Fiber, they got so much more. Mr. Moore got more upload speed for next level gaming and live streaming to the masses. With reliable service, Mrs. More is no longer her family's IT guru, leaving her more time to stream games into overtime.
Adam Thorne
Let's go.
Podcast Host 2
And young Mason Moore got more done quickly uploading HD product demos and video conferencing. Without freesight, the numbers look good.
Adam Thorne
Brad, you're on mute.
Podcast Host 2
Switch from cable Internet to Zibli Fiber and get more of what you love for $65 less per month than cable@zibliefiber.com.
Adam Thorne
And that's the job of the historian, to bring everything to the forefront. Hey, this happened before, but, you know, as we go along in the modern age, our attention span gets shorter and shorter and shorter, and we just want the information in 30 seconds. And we don't want to look at the second behind the curtain anymore and get the rest of the facts. And that's where people jump to conclusions, right? They just establish what they believe and that's it. And they don't have time or the. Or the capacity to look deeper into things and see what's really going on.
Nick
For sure, yeah. When. When he's telling stories like, what he does is like, you know, recaps these things from like World War I, World War II, all the rest of it. I mean, going into things like trench warfare, for example. How important do you think it is for generations that have no experience with war to understand these stories and for these stories to be told.
Adam Thorne
The stories are hard to be told as it is. I just interviewed a guy, background similar to mine, combat veteran. As a Green Beret, I'm not. I want to clear up. I was not a combat veteran. I got hurt. He was a combat veteran, Green Beret, and he didn't learn certain things about his dad until he got back from Afghanistan. And his dad was a Vietnam vet. And he. Nobody heard these stories. He didn't tell anybody. And he learned a whole new thing about his dad that he never knew before, a new perspective of him, a man he'd known his whole life. Right. And he only told him because they have been in combat, not together, but they had seen actual fighting in different parts of the world in different generations. And the individual, it's very hard for them to tell those stories. And that's where the historian comes in. Right. But they are also telling stories based on their perspective because they have to get people to listen to them. You write a textbook and that just sits on a shelf. It's dead, right? It's. It's sitting there. It's not doing anything. But a story that people want to listen to and possibly learn something about, that's difficult to do. And to put the time in to take the lessons learned of battle, especially World War I, was horrible. Horrible fighting, the worst you can imagine. The technology was far, far beyond the tactics of the time. Just most horrible thing you can encounter. And that was fresh in everybody's mind 10 years, 20 years later, in 37, 38.
Nick
Right. Yeah, yeah. I mean, the, the story that he was telling about how the. That you'd be in the trenches, right? You can't go anywhere. You can't get over the top. You're just laying there. It's probably muddy, it's probably wet. It's really uncomfortable. I'm sure their gear is like nothing like guys have today. So who knows what the state of their boots were like and all the rest of it, their rations. And over in the corner, you know, could be your buddy, been dead for a few days, can't do anything. Can't bury anybody because they're already buried along the trenches. Can, can any human mind, like perceive what the heck is going on there?
Adam Thorne
No. You have. There's no. You can't to go off into battle. It's one thing to join the military, right? It's one thing to train and get ready to do things. It's another to actually do it. But to see the horrors of war and thing, it's something you can't impress on people because. All right, have you ever heard the phrase the worst thing to ever happen to you is the worst thing to ever happen to you?
Nick
Yes.
Adam Thorne
Well, that's true, right. If you're fighting a battle and seeing your friends die, that's the worst thing that's ever happened to you. If you're going to college and you get kicked out of math class and that's the worst thing to ever happen to you, that is also your baseline of the worst thing to ever happen to you. But inconceivable. This the comparison between the two, right. Unless you've experiencing something that traumatic and with that type of an impact, you're not going to know one, how it's going to affect you, or two, what it's like. And that's a deep perspective that even the best storyteller is not going to be able to Convey that message.
Nick
Sure. Yeah. You almost need to be, like, walking in the trenches, you know, they need to make, like, a movie set that you can walk through to even make sense of what is being said.
Adam Thorne
Oh, that's good. That's a good point. You bring that up, right? Saving Private Ryan, the opening.
Nick
Yeah.
Adam Thorne
Several. Several World War II veterans were invited to the. The opening night, and they had to. They walked out.
Nick
Yeah.
Adam Thorne
Because it was so realistic.
Nick
It was so unusually like. I. I don't want to say realistic because I hadn't been there. I had no experience with anything, so I wouldn't know. But it just. It hit in a different way, for sure. Like, it was so vivid. Like, you could. You just sunk into that opening scene and it was terrifying. That was D Day. Right.
Adam Thorne
The perspective. That's a good way to put it. Right. A perspective like that. Or you can see it and you're. You can. Multiple senses are taking it all in. You can see it. You can hear it in surround sound. And you. And you could feel it also, because the bass in the theater, so you got three senses taking it in. That's really the only way. Because like I said, if you're reading something, you're just. That's a. That's a dead story. But if you're feeling it and looking at it and then you can conceptualize, you have the wherewithal to realize what's going on. People are dying. And there's the same age people up on that hill as the ones on. Down in the beach are shooting machine guns at these people. They're all people. Kids being told by slightly older kids to kill those people down there.
Nick
Yeah. The average age, it was young. Right. They were like 18, with very little training. And it's like, go.
Adam Thorne
A different generation, too. A much different generation. How many times have you seen an article where so and so volunteered to join the Navy or the Marines? When he was 15, he lied on his entrance exam.
Nick
Right.
Adam Thorne
And went off to war. And things like that. Was having all the time going off to fight for their country. Completely different generation. The world, what we live in right now, is not that place. It's tough to imagine.
Nick
Yeah, it is. And it does seem. It does seem valuable because, you know, like, anything we forget, we could do multiple decades in even whole generations in America, for one, without most people seeing war. And, you know, I think it's. I think it's important to understand and be somewhat reminded of how horrific it is to, you know, slow down any efforts to get back there. I'm not Saying like, our government is looking to get into a war. But you know, when you get upset with a different side or there's another nine, 11 or whatever it is, it's like, yeah, go get them. Let's get him for this. Instead of realizing, hey, this is 25 years of money and pain and death.
Adam Thorne
$10 trillion, right? $10 trillion spent in the Middle east on war and global war on terror. And that's the Nexus event, right? We don't live. Our modern equivalent to something like I.e. september 10, 2001 is not the same planet that we were on on September 11, 2001. Two different, two different, completely different worlds. And, but that's a long time ago now. It's gonna be 24 years in September. That's all. There's people alive that weren't born at that time. Many people that are alive at that time, they don't know that feeling. And there's many people that are gone, passed away, that were there, remember it, would have remembered it. So the population, even though it's still huge, is shrinking. That has memory of that. And that's. It's nobody's fault. It's. I wouldn't say it is a fault. It just is a result of life, right? Everyone's opinions and perspectives is going to be shaped by their experiences that they go through in their life. And whenever they happen to be born or things like that, they're going to be affected by those. And that's going to shape the view of the past going forward.
Amazon Music Ad
Hey, prime members, are you tired of ads interfering with your favorite podcasts? Good news. With Amazon Music, you have access to the largest catalog of ad free top podcasts included with your prime membership. To start listening, download the Amazon Music app for free or go to Amazon.com adfreepodcasts that's Amazon.com adfreepodcast to catch up on the latest episodes without the ads.
T Mobile Ad
Unlike what you're listening to, T Mobile's coverage is no joke because T Mobile helps keep you connected from big cities to your hometown On America's largest 5G network Switch now keep your phone and T Mobile will pay it off at the $800 per line via prepaid card. Visit your local T Mobile location or learn more@t mobile.com KeepAndSwitch up to four.
Lines via virtual prepaid card. Last 15 days. Qualified unlock device credit service port in 90 plus days device and eligible carrier and timely redemption required card is no cash access and expires in six months.
Nick
For sure. In Vietnam, how many Americans died In that. Do you know roughly what it was, the number?
Adam Thorne
58,000.
Nick
Okay, yeah, because I was just looking for like, a. One of the stats from World War I. It said the Battle of the Somme saw over 57,000 British casualties in one day. Obviously they didn't all die casualties, but think of how enormous that is.
Adam Thorne
I've just watched Ken Burns Civil War, right? There was battle after battle after battle where they would lose 10, 20, 30, 000 soldiers. Not all dead, but most, you know, killed in battle. And then for every soldier that was killed in battle, two would die of infection. They're hacking limbs off. You get shot through a limb, they're cutting your limb off and things like that. Horrible, horrible conditions. It's unimaginable. More men fell at the first Battle of Shiloh than had fallen in all previous wars up to that point in the history of the United States. And that was as the war went on. That was a small battle of small, small casualties. And that just continued on through the Civil War, where we slaughtered each other wholesale. We're very good at war. We're very good at killing one another. And that. That's not restricted to the boundaries of the United States. It's a. It's a good thing that war is so terrible, or else we will become too fond of it. Well, I think we have become fond of it. It's very ingrained in our world history, fighting and killing each other wholesale.
Nick
And, you know, part of the reason, and this is what I was suspicious of after listening to this podcast, is maybe we're not telling the story as well as we should. Like, with something as terrifying and horrible as what war is from an. An outside perspective, it doesn't seem like it should be too complicated to get most of the people to be very against the idea of it, but it's not always how it's.
Adam Thorne
I don't know if that's. We're not telling it. I don't know if it's. That we're not telling the story. Well, I think we are developing a story based on our predispositions of our culture and the point of view that we're coming from. Right. We're still. He's still telling a good story, but that's based on where he's coming from, his perspective on life, where a few. If you tell the story of the last 20 years in Afghanistan and you go interview some Afghanis and start to put together what the last 20 years was like for them, that's not going to be the same story. It's not going to be the same tale, and they might tell it well, but it's not going to line up with what is being told to us. And ours won't line up with what theirs is. They just won't. They won't mesh. They'll be happening at the same time, but from different sides of the coin.
Nick
Yeah. And you hear that sometimes, too, with different countries. And the way that they. I mean, they always say that, like, history is told by the winners. Right. But in a sense, like, the losers don't get all wiped out anymore. They continue, and then they have their history.
Adam Thorne
Yeah. You want to get the most recent example of perspective in battle or a gunfight? Go on Netflix and watch Surviving Black Hawk Down. They have the Delta Force and Ranger operators that were actually there being interviewed, telling their story. And then they sent out people to interview these people in Somalia that were, in the battle, normal civilians or. Or Somali rebels or fighters that were fighting against these same people that are being interviewed. And that's a perfect example of two different perspectives on fighting and killing one another.
Nick
Wow. And I could imagine it is very different.
Adam Thorne
Like you're saying, yeah, they. I mean, the US Lost, you know, in the. In the double digits of soldiers. They lost, you know, Somalis 500 to a thousand somewhere in there. And the guy says, we don't. I don't care how many people we lose, as long as we kill one American or we kill Americans or get our shots off and things like that. Completely different way of looking at things willing to sacrifice just to bring down the big bad Americans that are disrupting their way of life. Interesting. You should check it out.
Nick
Yeah. It was a powerful movie just in itself. And yet one of those things where you watch it and you're like, I obviously, movies are not where you should get your history from, but it's.
Adam Thorne
This is a. This is a documentary. This just came out.
Nick
Yeah. No, the only thing I've seen is the. Is the movie of it. I did see the documentary on Netflix, and it was one of those things where I'm like, I need to take. I need to take a good night or evening where I've got some time, because if something grabs me, I have to watch all of them. And then, you know, it just, like, will ruin the next six hours because I just won't be able to stop. It just does one of those. Yeah. Powerful stuff, man. It's just. It's just terrible, terrifying things. And, you know, when somebody like this guy, a storyteller, you know, I almost Called him a historian. He doesn't want that. But it tries to put together an idea of what was happening. I mean, the big controversy for him is when he was talking about, like, Hitler's younger part of his life, just understanding who this man is that rose to power, what was happening in Germany and the pieces that kind of led to it. And yeah, he does kind of humanize parts of Hitler's younger life, but what he was saying he's noticed is there's no room for that in the discourse. Like, he has to be demonized at every point, ultimately leading to being the worst person ever. And. And I. Yeah, I don't necessarily get the value of that. Unless people are just so concerned that there will be, like, admiration that gets built or some sort of following. It doesn't seem possible.
Adam Thorne
Oh, to lead to a second coming, you mean of the. The Third Reich. It's interesting. So he is a face for that story. But the stuff that he is saying, I have heard in just documentary form on like a Netflix or a streaming service. Right. And they'll say, this happened to Hitler and here and in World War I, while he was recovering from his mustard gas inhalation in the hospital. Then he started going to these. And they just lay it out. All the things that led up to him becoming. What was he a chancellor or whatever he was elected. Right.
Nick
Yeah, I think they called that chancellor that.
Adam Thorne
He's just telling those same things that are. That are laid out in documentaries in a different way. So. Yeah, I don't get. Maybe people just don't like his face. So that could be as simple as that. But, yeah, I don't know. Those are hot button subjects. Right. You bring up the Nazis or the Holocaust, people are going to get upset. And they don't. They don't want to hear it. They don't want to. Yeah, I get it. Yeah. Humanize any part of the Nazi war machine because it was so evil, so bad and such a stain on humanity as a whole that any humanization of that evilness is taboo.
Nick
Yeah. And. And so much of what I felt like he was saying is just kind of understanding the time and the people of that time and knowing that, you know, they're still people like we are. But it was a different time. They had, like, different motivations and politics. They, especially in Germany, they just come on off the back of, like, what was that? Super hyperinflation. Like, their whole country was in disarray. They were desperate for something to help kind of hold them together and create some nationalism and yeah, it's a weird one because already I was like thinking to myself not to make excuses for him, but like they, they're trying to just keep their country and their life together.
Adam Thorne
Right? They and rebuild. Right? World War I was terribly taxing on Europe at the time and they want to rise back to where they were. And that was a way forward that some people saw to get there and things got off the rails because obviously to get elected into power, you have to say one thing and then, well, we just slowly descended into hell after that.
T Mobile Ad
Unlike what you're listening to, T Mobile's coverage is no joke because T Mobile helps keep you connected from big cities to your hometown on America's largest 5G network. Switch now keep your phone and T Mobile will pay it off at the $800 per line via prepaid card. Visit your local T Mobile location or learn more@t mobile.com keepandswitch up to 4.
Lines via virtual prepaid card. Laugh. 15 days qualifying unlock device credit service port in 90 plus days device ineligible carrier and timely redemption required Card is no cash access and expires in six months.
Podcast Host 2
When the Moore family ditched cable Internet and switched to Zigly Fiber, they got so much more. Mr. Moore got more upload speed for next level gaming and live streaming to the masses. With reliable service, Mrs. Moore is no longer her fan family's IT guru, leaving her more time to stream games into overtime.
Adam Thorne
Let's go.
Podcast Host 2
And young Mason Moore got more done quickly uploading HD product demos and video conferencing. Without freesight, the numbers look good.
Adam Thorne
Brad, you're on mute.
Podcast Host 2
Switch from cable Internet to Zibli Fiber and get more of what you love for $65 less per month than cable@zibly.
Adam Thorne
Fiverr.Com and started pushing things off in a direction that the citizens who voted for that probably never intended to. And you gotta, you gotta think people had a trust in what's being fed to them in the media, right? Because there's nothing else being put out. I mean, you've got a few neighbors that you're getting information from and the people you work from, but there's no, there's no cell phones, there's no power in some places, right? You strip away all of the luxuries of modern life and everything you take for granted now in the 30s, and that's what the time you're sitting in where to find anything out, you had to go to a book and look it up first. You had to know which book that you need to get the information out of find it, then understand it. Oh, you know, had to know how to read too. Yeah. So it's just a completely different way of life and, and purpose and everything. And it's something that people maybe now don't have. Oh. 1 don't have the time or the wherewithal or the mental capacity to process just how different things were and what was being fed to them at the time.
Nick
Right. Yeah. One thing that he brought up that I think that in a way America doesn't get that much credit from is kind of the progressive stance it's always taken on immigration. And I know that's always like one of those top button topics, but he said that back in the 1800s, there was just this message put out there to a lot of the world, all those that could get to America, saying, hey, if you want to be an American, come over here and we'll help you be a citizen.
Adam Thorne
Right.
Nick
In so many words. And, you know, a lot of Irish came over, English, you know, Dutch, like, this is why there's the melting pot that kind of, you know, expanded and built the US but almost no other country has had that kind of opening in that way. And it happened for a long time. I mean, they needed to populate the country, so it was useful in a sense. But it brought these people that maybe felt rejected from where they were. Maybe there's religious persecution, maybe they just wanted a different life. There was something happening that made them get over. And you know, a lot of them are landing in New York, they're looking for work, laborers, whatever. He gave the stat that like on the docks there was like a 14 year life expectancy. I can't imagine that that stat was well known because people wouldn't be doing that job. But maybe they didn't have a choice. You just did what you could do.
Adam Thorne
You did. Yeah. Because once the Industrial revolution happened, Right. You're dependent on work to live and to maintain the life that you have, or the, the meager accommodation that you have and eat and things. Now you live in a city and there's pollution. There's no regulation on, on anything as far as the immigration goes. Right. Imagine that we discovered you could live on the moon. It was just habitable, you know, and all you got to do is take a spaceship ride to the moon and you can have some land and go live over there and have your homestead. You go, you'd be like, yeah, let me go to the moon. That's kind of what it was like when. Because America was really, really only started to get explored in the 1800s.
Nick
Right, right.
Adam Thorne
Yeah. Really starting to get us short. You know, the Native American population was there, but that had been completely decimated by diseases and coming over from England that they weren't used to. If you want a good example of why there's inequities in society and the things that happen, read Guns, Germs and Steel. Won the Pulitz Pulitzer Prize for literature. And some cultures were just at a disadvantage of where geographically they were. And that was the case in north and South America. Right. They came over and they decimated by disease. And then also the technology was far beyond coming over the seas, was far beyond anything that existed in the Americas at that time. So we were just able to steamroll over everything that was there and take it away. Not saying it was right, just that's what happened. Right. And another just terrible, terrible things that we did to our fellow humans. But that was the life, the time that they lived in. And they living in that time, not us in the future. Looking back, they thought they were doing the right thing. And we can sit back and judge them all we want, but it's not going to change anything. We got to learn from what they did and not let it happen again.
Nick
Right. Yeah, it would be, it would be interesting if you could get, you know, how they do like the family tree thing, like 23andMe. You're not just your DNA, but like they tell you like who your great, great granddad was, all the rest of it. And then to go back and like, look at these ancestors that laid the ground for you to exist and then judge them based on what they were doing at that time, it would be easy to do. It's almost like that energy exists today and it doesn't. That definitely doesn't seem like the right approach. It's like, hey, they were dealing with what they had in front of them. And yes, nobody's perfect.
Adam Thorne
Yeah, and then. Yeah, but we both say that now. But that comes back to the Nazi discussion, right? Something so horrible that all we've done is pass that judgment, that that is the most evil thing that we can think of. And we get back to why they don't like this guy. Society has established that that is the worst thing to come out of the 20th century is Nazis. And any thing that hints at defending or humanizing them is going to be attacked.
Nick
Right.
Adam Thorne
So maybe he just cares that because we, you know, that's the one we pass judgment on. That's the one where we say, no, them, because that's. That's as bad as it gets. Even though. Even though equally bad things were happening in other parts of the world at the same time. For sure, those are ignored. The things that happened in ussr Horrible, but didn't get the press that Hitler did.
Nick
Right. What was it like the gulags? Was that the awful prisons over there.
Adam Thorne
If you read the Gulag Archipelago by Alexander Solus Netskin, you will be appraised to the horrors of Soviet Russia from the October revolution through the fall of Communism in the 90s. Yeah. Terrible thing. We're very good at being terrible to one another.
Nick
Right? Yeah. That's what history seems to have done for sure. I mean, they gave the example towards the end of the pod where they were saying even in like the 1700s, there were church sites in England that had the skin of human. Dutch raiders, like, stretched over the doors in England.
Adam Thorne
Warn people. Yeah, you got to warn people. Look back. What steps led them to that action? Right.
Nick
Yeah.
Adam Thorne
To. To leave that warning for people. So. Okay. Yes, that is terrible. How did we get to that point?
Nick
Right.
Adam Thorne
Was probably even more horrible. The things that were happening to make that happen and then something more horrible before that.
Nick
Yeah. I mean, it's. It's unlikely without knowing more that it was just some psychopathic preacher that just skinned some Dutch people and stretched it over the door. But it's kind of how we would see it if it happened today. Yet in the context of it being on their doors for a while, there's a whole thing in there. It's like a warning to raiders, like a message that gets sent. And if you have to send a message that strong, then there might be. I don't want to say good reason, but there might be a need for it. Like that's how dangerous these invaders could be. Right?
Adam Thorne
Yep. There's definitely a reason for it. You're definitely sending a message not to. Not to. With this. This location at all or this will happen to you. And that, you know, often it's like, does the punishment fit the crime? The punishment never fits the crime. Right. We put these Nazi leaders on trial, Nuremberg trials, and the. What should the punishment have been? They should have been put in concentration camps and work to death like they subjected people to do. But that. That's not humane to do. Right. So. And a lot of that happens with crime and things. The punishment never fits the crime. So it's terrible that it will happen again because the things that will happen to the people that do it are never. They're never. It's never enough to deter somebody from Making it happen again because then you become evil, just like. Just like they were.
Nick
Yeah. I mean, look, I think that what, what Daryl is doing is valuable. I think that the kind of attacks that he's coming up against, you know, kind of remind me of what people are doing with Teslas out there drawing swastikas on right now, because they're angry, they're mad and they want to demonize a certain thing and speak out against it. And you know, in a lot of ways, I'm kind of a freedom absolutist. Like, you know, I think protests and the ability to do it are important. Speaking out against things you don't like. Sure. I mean, try not to destroy property, but yeah, if you don't like something, you get to speak against it too. But I think what Daryl is doing has value and you know, I think ultimately it helps the narrative. You know, maybe it helps reconstruct future historians to kind of narrate the past in a different way. And there's just something that hits me with this about accuracy, accuracy of the story to be told that I think is useful.
Adam Thorne
People can get upset for whatever reason they're getting upset with, with him over, and that's their business. Right. But he's storytelling history. And what are the other benefits of that? Right. Is in our hyper rush to judgment, quick attention span generation, he's putting out long form history lessons for people to digest, especially younger generation. Will they somehow be weaponized or, or they're, they're towards. Pushed towards Nazis. I don't see it. Apparently some people do. I don't. But you got to get people interested in it, even if you don't, even if you don't like it. History is tough to sell to people. It's like fitness, Fitness is tough to sell to people. But if you make it fun, if you make it fun, people can get into it. Health and fitness, you know, history, you have to learn where you came from before you can know where you're going. Right?
Nick
Yeah.
Adam Thorne
Otherwise you know more cliches or you're risked or you're risking to repeat the inequities past or however. Yeah, doomed to repeat it.
Nick
That's it. Yeah, to repeat it. Yeah, good point. And on that note, thank you for joining me this week, Nick. And yeah, good discussion. And I want to check Dara out some more. I want to get into his podcast, kind of like make my own decision other than just doing it off of Rogan's show. But yeah, it's fascinating. Check it out guys. Let us know what you think and otherwise. We'll speak to you guys next time.
T Mobile Ad
With T Mobile. No trendspotter has to deal with trendspotty service because T Mobile helps keep you connected from big cities to your hometown on America's largest 5G network. Switch now keep your phone and T Mobile will pay it off up to 800 per line via prepaid card. Visit your local T Mobile location or learn more@t mobile.com KeepAndSwitch up to four.
Lines of your virtual prepaid card allowed 15 days qualifying unlocked device credit service support in 90 plus days. The buyest and eligible carrier and timely redemption required card has no cash access and expires in six months.
Podcast Host 2
Geico's motorcycle expertise gives me the coverage I need like 24.
Amazon Music Ad
Seven claims, I'm on cloud nine.
Geico Ad
Clouds are wholly unable to support the weight of an adult human.
Nick
What's happening?
Geico Ad
Furthermore, clouds are not numbered. Even if you procured a jetpack and searched, you'd find no cloud number nine. However, at that altitude, you'd likely befriend a flock of migrating snow geese. Geese who'd encourage you to leave your 24.7geico motorcycle claims insurance behind, as they would take you in and even share their dinner of crickets and clowns clovers with you. GEICO assumes no liability for any indigestion that may occur from a clover cricket dinner. Geico expertise for your motorcycle if you.
Beautiful Anonymous Host
Want to feel more connected to humanity and a little less alone, listen to Beautiful Anonymous each week, I take a phone call from one random anonymous human being. There's over 400 episodes in our back catalog. You get to feel connected to all these different people all over the world. Recent episodes include one where a lady survived a murder attempt by her own son. But then the week before that, we just talked about Star Trek. It can be anything. It's unpredictable, it's raw, it's real. Get Beautiful Anonymous. Wherever you listen to podcasts.
Joe Rogan Experience Review Podcast
Episode 434: Review of Darryl Cooper
Release Date: March 22, 2025
In Episode 434 of the Joe Rogan Experience Review Podcast, hosts Adam Thorne and Nick delve into their analysis of Darryl Cooper's appearance on Joe Rogan's show. Darryl Cooper, a self-taught historian and host of the "Martyr Maid" podcast, has garnered significant attention for his in-depth explorations of historical events, including the Jonestown Massacre and World War II. With over a quarter-million followers on X (formerly Twitter) and collaborations with notable figures like Jocko Willink and Tucker Carlson, Cooper has positioned himself as a compelling storyteller within the historical podcasting niche.
Nick: "This guy's been taking some heat... he's been branded as an anti-Semite, a bit of a Nazi sympathizer."
[02:15]
The podcast discusses the backlash Darryl Cooper has faced, particularly following his interview with Tucker Carlson. Carlson, known for his polarizing style, introduced Cooper as "the most influential historian of the 21st century," which both amplified Cooper's visibility and intensified the criticism he received.
Adam Thorne: "Tucker is a very polarizing person. And that probably brought more heat on this guy."
[03:31]
Critics argue that Cooper's attempts to humanize historical figures associated with atrocities, such as Winston Churchill and aspects of Nazi Germany, have led to accusations of anti-Semitism and Nazi sympathization. This controversy raises questions about the fine line between historical analysis and perceived sympathies.
Thorne and Nick explore the essential role historians play in society, particularly those who are not formally trained but possess a passion for uncovering and narrating historical truths. They highlight the challenges non-academic historians face in gaining credibility and the resistance they often encounter from established academic institutions.
Nick: "It's like what Graham Hancock, like, he's not archaeologist, he's just a researcher and storyteller."
[03:49]
Adam Thorne: "Nobody ever wants to say they're wrong... it's when you're continually wrong and you keep hammering away at it... you run into problems."
[05:28]
The discussion emphasizes the importance of understanding the context in which historical events occurred. Cooper's approach to examining the motivations and societal pressures that shaped historical figures is intended to provide a more nuanced view of history, though it has been met with resistance.
Adam Thorne: "Have a discussion, have discourse, and find out why this person thinks like that or from their perspective."
[08:30]
The hosts argue that comprehending the multifaceted nature of historical events is crucial to preventing the repetition of past atrocities. They stress that without a deep understanding of history, society risks falling into the same destructive patterns.
Nick: "They got to work through the legend and the mythology and the rest of it to get to, like, what did it actually look like?"
[09:57]
Thorne and Nick discuss how modern media's rapid information dissemination and shorter attention spans impact the way historical narratives are received and understood. They contend that the depth and complexity required to accurately portray historical events are often lost in the haste to present information quickly and engagingly.
Adam Thorne: "Our attention span gets shorter and shorter... they just establish what they believe and that's it."
[12:11]
The podcast underscores the necessity of accurate historical representation to foster a well-informed society. Thorne highlights that understanding history is essential to recognize warning signs that could lead to future conflicts or societal issues.
Adam Thorne: "You have to learn from what they did and not let it happen again."
[37:52]
Nick reinforces this by drawing parallels between historical events and contemporary issues, suggesting that a lack of historical awareness can lead to the repetition of past mistakes.
Nick: "Anything we forget, we could do multiple decades in even whole generations in America without most people seeing war."
[20:45]
In wrapping up their review, Thorne and Nick reflect on the value of Darryl Cooper's contributions to historical discourse despite the controversies. They acknowledge the challenges Cooper faces but commend his efforts to engage audiences with long-form history lessons that encourage deeper understanding.
Nick: "I think what Daryl is doing has value... it helps reconstruct future historians to narrate the past in a different way."
[44:22]
Adam Thorne: "History is tough to sell to people... but you make it fun, people can get into it."
[45:44]
The hosts conclude by encouraging listeners to explore Cooper's work individually to form their own opinions, emphasizing the importance of diverse perspectives in enriching historical understanding.
Nick: "Check it out guys. Let us know what you think and otherwise. We'll speak to you guys next time."
[46:54]
Nick: "The worst thing to ever happen to you is the worst thing to ever happen to you."
[16:00]
Adam Thorne: "Wars repeat themselves. People rise to power, they fall out of power. Countries come and go."
[10:37]
Nick: "What should the punishment have been? They should have been put in concentration camps and work to death."
[42:19]
These insightful discussions provide a comprehensive analysis of Darryl Cooper's role in historical discourse, the controversies surrounding him, and the broader implications for how history is taught and understood in today's fast-paced media environment.