Just Trish – Episode Summary
Episode: Lily Allen EXPOSES David Harbour For Cheating + Ned Fulmer Starts Dating Show
Host: Trisha Paytas with Oscar Gracey, Moses, Jimmy, Mama Got Back, and special family/friends
Date: October 31, 2025
Overview
This extended Halloween episode of "Just Trish" centers around viral celebrity hot topics, internet drama, and hilarious unfiltered commentary delivered by Trisha Paytas and her rotating cast, including Oscar Gracey, Moses, Jimmy, and family. In classic Just Trish fashion, the tone is both outrageous and candid, overflowing with personal stories, costumes, and pop culture discourse.
Key themes this week include:
- Lily Allen’s explosive revelations about David Harbour’s cheating
- Ned Fulmer launching a bizarre self-hosted dating show post-scandal
- Halloween costumes, pop culture obsessions, and Broadway dreams
- Insightful side conversations on mukbangs, TikTok ragebait, gaming (especially Minecraft/FNAF), and nostalgia
- Highlights from the hosts’ personal lives and family dynamics
The episode is filled with memorable quotes, deep dives into the week's juiciest celebrity gossip, and an underlying thread of “chosen family” energy.
Major Topics & Discussion Points
Halloween: Costumes, Festivities & Minecraft Cosplay
[00:33–04:16, 11:12–13:04, 18:16–23:02]
- The group celebrates Halloween, all in Minecraft-inspired costumes. Trisha is the "garbage man," Moses is "Steve," Oscar appears as "Chicken Jockey," Jimmy is a Minecraft pig.
- Discussion of the joys and woes of wearing wigs and beards for costumes—Trisha hilariously recounts her kids' dramatic reactions to everyone in wigs or beards.
- The group reminisces about their best and worst Halloween costumes, why certain ideas flopped, and hyperfixates on fun group themes.
Ned Fulmer’s Attempted Image Rehab: Hosting a Dating Show
[04:21–09:20]
- Moses: “The hot topic I brought today was Ned Fulmer's dating show. Because I feel like Ned Fulmer is kind of the gift that keeps on giving in this spooky, ooky month.” (04:24)
- Discussion centers on the absurdity of Fulmer, infamous for cheating and being ousted from the Try Guys, attempting to host a dating show—one that inexplicably features an AI bachelor (“Fifty shades of dubious. It does keep getting worse.” – Moses, 06:08).
- Trisha and crew mock both the premise and Fulmer’s continued inability to read the room:
Trisha: "The person I want to go to for love advice is the one that ruined his whole loving marriage." (05:11)
Escape The Night, Joey Graceffa, & YouTube Nostalgia
[13:04–17:57, 63:37–64:07]
- Celebration of Joey Graceffa, his role in YouTube culture, and news of him auditioning for Hunger Games and returning with a new Escape the Night season.
- Discussion about the creative runs of YouTube personalities and niche casting stories.
Minecraft the Movie Sequel and Trisha’s Broadway Manifestation
[10:10–12:14, 58:02–59:41]
- The crew obsesses over the upcoming Minecraft 2 movie; speculation about casting a "female Jack Black" with Trisha hotly vying for the role of Alex.
- Jimmy and Oscar nerd out about the Minecraft game, skins, and possible in-game Trisha Paytas avatars.
Pop Culture Potpourri: FNAF, Halloween Movies, & Music
[18:16–31:29, 54:00–56:10]
- Deep dive into favorite Halloween movies and costumes, from Jennifer’s Body to Scream, Disney, and FNAF.
- Memo on hot new music releases—Demi Lovato (endorsed by Moses), Ariana Grande, and others.
- Nostalgic references to Drag Race UK, Pearl, Maxine, and other pop culture moments.
Lily Allen Exposes David Harbour’s Cheating
(The Core Hot Topic)
[92:29–101:46]
- Jimmy: “Lily Allen and David Harbour, they married in 2020. David Harbour is from Stranger Things... If these allegations are true, I'm very disappointed in you. The cheater or the butt plug? Oh, the cheater. The butt plug is fierce.” (93:00–93:19)
- Recap of Lily Allen’s new album and interviews in which she details Harbour asking for an open marriage within weeks of marriage, infidelity, and finding "a Duane Read bag... filled with sex toys, butt plugs, lube, hundreds of Trojans."
- The hosts roast Harbour:
Trisha: “So that is, is crazy.” (99:42)
Jimmy: “The idea of David Harbour... waiting at the glass case for an employee to open for the butt plugs is crazy.” (99:41) - The symbolism of releasing this information right as Stranger Things launches promotion is not lost on the table:
Jimmy: “…the way she's dropping all this information right before Stranger Things starts the press tour...” (96:06) - Quotes from Allen’s album raise the question of Harbour’s loyalty, emotional impact, and speculation on the “other woman,” Madeline:
Jimmy: “We had an arrangement. Be discreet and don't be blatant. There had to be payment. It had to be strangers. But you're not a stranger. Madeline.” (96:36–96:48)
Mukbangs, TikTok, & Social Trends
[110:48–121:31]
- Mama Got Back’s hot take section, poking fun at TikTok mukbang “rage-baiters,” the ethics of eating content, and the psychology of watching food videos.
- Trisha and her mom banter about which styles of eating on camera are empowering vs. just messy:
Mama Got Back: "I mean, they do look like a pig, I gotta say. Like, in a. Like in a trough." (114:15)
Notable Quotes & Moments
- Moses on Fulmer: “You don't try things very well. You don't do marriage very well. So we can't really host. I don't know. I don't know where we go from here.” (07:06)
- Jimmy (on David Harbour): “Going to Duane Reade for butt plugs, which you'll be very familiar with. Duane Read, it's like CBS Walgreens in New York... you gotta press the button. Assistance needed in aisle. Aisle. Butt plugs. David Harbour waiting at the glass case for an employee to open for the butt plugs is crazy.” (99:20–99:41)
- Mama Got Back on TikTok food trends: “And I just, I love those girls so much. Shout out to those girls. Keep doing it. I used to do those too, back in the day.” (120:51)
- Trisha manifesting Broadway: “Once again, Beetlejuice, November 4th through 23rd, Trishmas, November 30th through December 22nd, will be everywhere. And, yeah, so much fun.” (136:11)
- Oscar on pop culture cycles: “It is interesting how things just, like, come back because people have, like, no, like, original ideas, I guess.” (54:27)
Breakdown by Key Segments
| Topic/Segment | Timestamps (MM:SS) | Summary | |-------------------------------------------|--------------------------|-------------| | Halloween & Costume Stories | 00:33–04:16, 11:12–13:04, 18:16–23:02 | Minecraft costumes, Halloween fatigue, parenting in wigs and beards | | Ned Fulmer Dating Show | 04:21–09:20 | Disbelief at Ned’s self-produced dating show. Mockery of AI twist, poor view counts | | “Escape the Night”, Joey Graceffa & YouTube| 13:04–17:57, 63:37–64:07 | YouTube careers, Hunger Games auditions, nostalgia for old-school creators | | Minecraft 2 & Casting Speculation | 10:10–12:14, 58:02–59:41 | Contenders for “female Jack Black,” Trisha’s acting ambitions | | Music & Halloween Films | 18:16–31:29, 54:00–56:10 | Endorsements for Demi Lovato, Ariana, Beetlejuice musical talk, favorite movies | | Lily Allen & David Harbour Cheating Exposé | 92:29–101:46 | Major story: Open marriage demand, the butt plugs anecdote, analysis of Allen’s lyrics, timeline of cheating | | Family Banter & TikTok Trends | 110:48–121:31 | Mukbang authenticity, rage-bait, “nine to five lunch” TikToks, generational takes on social media | | Manifesting Broadway, Beetlejuice, Trishmas| 136:11–138:00 | Trisha’s performance dates, gratitude section, manifesting good outcomes |
Podcast Tone, Style, and Vibe
- Language: Uncensored, playful, often irreverent. Trisha and the crew speak exactly as they do on YouTube – chatty, quick-witted, and self-aware about their place in internet culture.
- Energy: Chaotic blend of hot takes, deep gossip, and family comfort—punctuated by raucous laughter, interruptions, and heartfelt asides.
- Flow: Topics are riffed with lots of overlap; everyone jumps in with personal anecdotes, pop culture references, and inside jokes.
For New Listeners
This episode is a whirlwind tour through the week’s wildest celebrity stories, internet drama, and deep-dive pop culture obsessions—anchored by Trisha’s distinct blend of no-filter honesty and family warmth.
If you’re here for the hot tea:
- Don’t miss the Lily Allen and David Harbour cheating saga ([92:29–101:46]), as well as the “Ned Fulmer Dating Show” roast ([04:21–09:20]).
- For Halloween fans and Broadway hopefuls: costume chaos and Beetlejuice manifestation are scattered throughout.
If you love Trisha’s family and community vibe:
- Heartfelt/funny segments with Mama Got Back, Jimmy, and Moses are woven throughout—see the mukbang TikTok chat ([110:48–121:31]) and their emotional closing.
Closing Sentiment
Trisha signs off with gratitude for the cast, crew, and audience—previewing her imminent Broadway debut in Beetlejuice and promising the podcast will continue “bigger, better” even as the crew heads to New York.
Trisha: “...I don't know why we called it just Trash. I guess I was trying not to rely on anyone, but I rely on a lot of people, and they're all here and wonderful and thank you, guys. And we'll see you in the next one… Happy Halloween!” ([162:57])